Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 572 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
MACA 1165/2018

MACA No. 1165 of 2018

This High Court of Kerala, in MACA No. 1165 of 2018, examines whether the second respondent, G. Venugopal, can be held liable for compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act where ownership of the offending vehicle is disputed and the owner’s name continued in official records. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Alappuzha, held that the vehicle was not duly insured and that the second respondent (appellant) along with the driver (first respondent) were liable for the awarded compensation. The appellant contends that the vehicle was sold to Sadasivan Pillai in June 2006 and that the driver had purchased the vehicle from Pillai; Exts. B1–B5 allegedly show a complete sale under the Sale of Goods Act, thereby terminating the appellant’s ownership/possession at the time of the accident on 15.11.2006. He relies on Kerala High Court decisions Sumathy v. Raghavan and Said Mohammed v. Rema and on Surendra Kumar Bhilawe v. New India Assurance Co. The respondents argue that the registered owner remains liable, a proposition reinforced by a line of Supreme Court precedents (Jose v. Chacko; P. P. Mohammed v. Rajappan; Pushpa @ Leela v. Shakuntala). The court ultimately agrees with the Supreme Court line, distinguishes earlier Kerala decisions, and dismisses the appeal, while reserving the appellant’s right to pursue recovery from the driver in an appropriately constituted proceeding. The case also contemplates supplemental respondents added as legal heirs of the deceased respondent 1.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 29255 OF 2021

UCO Bank v. State of Kerala and others

On 21 January 2022, the Kerala High Court heard a writ petition by UCO Bank challenging attachments on a mortgaged property and seeking the registration of a Sale Certificate under the SARFAESI Act. The Bank had obtained an equitable mortgage over the property from respondents 3 and 4 on 10.09.2014, and after the borrowers defaulted, the Bank proceeded to sale under SARFAESI. The sale was confirmed in favour of the auction purchaser, but the Sub Registrar refused to register the Sale Certificate due to encumbrances reflected in the Encumbrance Certificate. The Bank argued that all attachments were created after the mortgage date and, following this Court’s precedents, should not impede the Bank’s right to proceed and register the Sale Certificate. Respondents contended that SARFAESI violations and ongoing proceedings before the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) challenge the sale, and that the Sub Registrar is constrained by orders from a competent Court. The Government Pleader indicated that the Sub Registrar could register the Sale Certificate and, if statutory conditions are satisfied, erase the attachments. The Court held that a bank with a prior equitable mortgage has a primary right to proceed, and that attachments post-dating the mortgage may be effaced to enable registration, leaving rights of challenge to appropriate fora. The writ petition was allowed, directing registration of the Sale Certificate de hors the attachments and eventual effacement of attachments after the mortgage date, while preserving other rights for the parties.

High Court of Kerala
ARB.A NO. 52 OF 2020

Arbitration Appeal No. 52 of 2020, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This is an appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 from an arbitral award in O.P.(Arb.) No.557 of 2015, Thrissur. The appellants, MoonWalk Polymers and Butterfly Micro Polymers, were partners in two firms with the respondent RishaJ alleging they misappropriated funds. The respondent had advanced Rs.1.62 crore for the business, with an understanding that the amount would be repaid and with a dated agreement Ext.A3 (19.11.2010) promising repayment by 01.05.2012. The Arbitral Tribunal awarded recovery of Rs.1.62 crore with interest and costs by realisation from the firms’ assets and personal assets of the appellants, and dissolved the two firms. The appellants challenged the award under Section 34, contending Ext.A3 is forged or not properly proven and that the award violated the arbitration clauses in the partnership deeds. The record reconstruction necessitated by the arbitral death was discussed, and the court and advocates reconstructed the proceedings. The High Court examined whether the arbitral tribunal could award relief based on Ext.A3 and whether such relief violated the amended Section 28(3) of the Act or other contract terms. It held that the tribunal was within its jurisdiction to interpret Ext.A3 but that directing repayment under Ext.A3 amounted to rewriting the contract, constituting patent illegality. Consequently, the Ext.A3-based relief was set aside, while dissolution and other reliefs remained intact. The judgment cites multiple authorities on the limits of arbitral interpretation and the contract-bound nature of awards, emphasizing that tribunals must not rewrite contracts outside their terms.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 7457 OF 2022

NIDHIN RAJ VETTIKKADAN ANCY THANKACHAN v. STATE OF KERALA AND AISWARYA V.S (CRL.MC 7457 of 2022)

This High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, dealt with CRL.MC No.7457 of 2022 filed by five accused persons (Soori M.B, M.K Babu, C.C Shamala, Sidharth M B, and Diya S Lakshmi) seeking to quash the final report in Infopark P.S. Crime No.542 of 2022, which is pending as C.C. No.624 of 2022 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kakkanad. The offences alleged against the petitioners are under IPC sections 498A, 354A(1)(i) and 509 read with 34. During admission, counsel for both sides—petitioners and the de facto complainant—stressed the possibility of settlement because both parties are lawyers. The matter was mediated in Court, resulting in a written compromise where the de facto complainant agreed not to proceed with the criminal proceedings. Relying on the Supreme Court precedents Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, and State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan, the Court noted that a High Court can quash proceedings under S.482 Cr.P.C in relation to non-compoundable offences when parties settle, to serve ends of justice and prevent abuse of process, even if Section 320 Cr.P.C bars compounding. The dispute being purely private and not affecting public interest, the Court held that no purpose is served by continuing the proceedings and quashed the final report. The Crl.M.C. was therefore allowed, and Annexure-A3 Final Report stood quashed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.3709 of 2023

K. V. George alias George Varghese v Sub Regional Transport Officer/Taxation Officer; The District Executive Officer, Kerala Motor Transport Workers Welfare Fund Board; The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, Employees' Provident Fund Organisation

The petitioner, K. V. George alias George Varghese, runs an industrial unit and operates 17 goods-carriage vehicles, evidenced by certificates Exts. P1–P17. He asserts his establishment is governed by the Employees Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (EPF Act), and that he has been regularly remitting EPF contributions, with Ext. P18 serving as proof through the Electronic Challan cum Return. The Kerala Motor Transport Workers Welfare Fund Act, 1985 (KMTWWF Act) requires contributions under Section 4 by employer and employee, but its proviso exempts undertakings to which EPF Act or the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 apply. The petitioner contends the 1st respondent Regional Transport Officer is improperly demanding proof of remittance to the Welfare Fund before accepting motor tax payments, arguing that if EPF coverage applies, Welfare Fund contributions are not due. The issue is whether the exemption in the proviso to Section 4 applies to the petitioner, a question to be determined before the adjudicating officer, not in a writ court, as held in George Antony v. State of Kerala. The court directs the Welfare Fund Board to determine coverage and issue an exemption certificate, and for EPF authorities to provide a verifiable certificate of remittance. The writ petition is disposed with directions to expeditiously process exemption and tax liability as stated.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.13 of 2020

Mohammed Arshid v. P.P.SHAMEEM

This Rent Control Revision under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 challenges an eviction order issued against tenant P.P. Shameem for allegedly demolishing an eastern wall of the petition schedule shop room, thereby diminishing the premises’ value and utility. The Rent Control Court (Principal Munsiff, Kannur) had granted eviction under Section 11(4)(ii) on 19.12.2013. The Rent Control Appellate Authority (Additional District Judge-II, Thalassery) reversed on 15.10.2019, finding no reliable evidence that the wall was removed by the tenant and noting complicating issues of ownership of the eastern shed and prior alterations. The revision petitioner argues that Ext.A1 (the lease deed) describes an independent tenancy and that, supported by PW1’s evidence and Ext.C1 (Commissioner report), the wall was removed by the tenant; he relies on Mohammed Hajee P.V. v. Mundoli Muhammed Hajee to support eviction when removal reduces the landlord’s value. The respondent counters that the wall’s removal could have been by the previous owner or under mutual arrangements, and that the eastern shed belonged to the petitioner’s in-laws. The High Court examines PW1, RW1, Exts.A1–A3, C1 and the Commissioner’s report, and cites Boramma v. Krishna Gowda to emphasize proper evidence appraisal. Ultimately, the Court agrees with the Appellate Authority and dismisses the revision petition, upholding the earlier order banning eviction only if proven by reliable evidence."

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 748 OF 2022

Sathyendran K. v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal revision petition filed by Sathyendran K. challenging a conviction recorded by the Judicial First Class Magistrate-III, Palakkad, in S.T. No.800/2022 arising from Crime No.50/2022 at Hemambika Nagar Police Station. The accused pleaded guilty to offences under IPC sections 279 and 337 and under section 3(1) r/w 181 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and was convicted with fines and default sentences; the fines were later remitted. The petitioner contends that the plea of guilty was not properly recorded: he had suffered severe injuries, was hospitalized for an extended period, and a vakalath executed by a lawyer (for a claim petition) was allegedly used to plead guilty without his explicit authorization. The Public Prosecutor opposes interference, arguing that the plea of guilty was made by counsel on behalf of the accused and that sections 251 and 252 Cr.P.C. were complied with to the extent required, with limited scope for review under sections 397/401 Cr.P.C. The Kerala High Court, relying on precedents such as Raseen Babu K.M. v. State of Kerala and other authorities, holds that accepting a plea of guilty is not an empty formality and requires strict adherence to procedure: charge framing (where applicable), reading and explaining the charge, ensuring voluntariness, and recording the plea in the accused’s own words. Finding inadequacies in the trial court’s handling of the plea, the court allows the revision, sets aside the conviction and sentence, and remits for a fresh trial after proper recording of the plea. The decision underscores the potential prejudice to the accused beyond punishment, including affects on compensation under the MV Act.

High Court of Kerala
RP No. 267 of 2022 in RSA No. 490 of 2021

ELSY v. SARITHA SHAJI

This is a review petition (RP No. 267 of 2022 in RSA No. 490 of 2021) in the Kerala High Court challenging a judgment dated 25 August 2021 in a suit arising from O.S. 346/2013 before the Munsiff, North Paravur, and the subsequent appeal A.S. 79/2017 before the Additional District Court-II, North Paravur. The suit sought the return of Rs. 4,00,000 paid as advance under an agreement to purchase the plaint schedule property for Rs 10,10,000 dated 10.05.2012. The defendant allegedly evaded completion of the sale; the plaintiff contends readiness to perform and balance payment, while the defendant asserts readiness was lacking and that liabilities were cleared, justifying forfeiture of the advance. The Munsiff dismissed the suit for lack of evidence that the plaintiff was ready and willing to perform, while the 1st Appellate Court held that in a suit for return of advance money the determination hinges on whether the seller suffered loss or damage due to non-performance, not on readiness/willingness. The High Court, in a single-judge order dated 23 August 2022, dismissed the appeal as lacking any substantial question of law and directed mediation as a limited exercise. The present review petition argues procedural irregularities and errors of law; the court ultimately dismisses the review, upholding the earlier conclusions. The matter centers on forfeitability of advance money and the requisite proof of loss/damage.

High Court of Kerala
Cont.Case (C) No.124 of 2020

Cont.Case (C) No.124 of 2020

Cont.Case (C) No.124 of 2020 arises from five petitioners (petitioners 8, 9, 10, 17 and 20) who were part of W.P.(C) No.3112 of 2017 in the Kerala High Court, challenging the non‑compliance with directions issued in Annexure II of the judgment dated 25 February 2019 and connected matters following Annexure I judgment in W.P.(C) No.13120 of 2015. The petitioners, employees of Aralam Farming Corporation (Kerala) Ltd., filed this contempt petition under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, alleging willful disobedience by Umesh Kumar, Assistant PF Commissioner, EPFO Kannur, of the directions. The Supreme Court's later decision in Sunil Kumar B. (2022) clarified the legality of Notification No. G.S.R.609(E) (2014) and mandated changes to the pension scheme, including the post‑amendment provisions and extension of certain options. The Kerala High Court noted that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by the EPFO in light of the 2022 Supreme Court judgment and closed the contempt case with liberty to re‑consideration in accordance with law. The case references Annexure II, Annexure I judgments, and related Orders, and invokes Article 142 of the Constitution for the directive to act within the law.

High Court of Kerala
MACA 1303 of 2018

M.A.C.A.1303 of 2018

This is a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal (MACA) arising from OPMV 286/2015 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Waynad. The appellants are the parents and sister of Jinno Kurian (deceased) who died following a February 2014 motor accident. They challenge the Tribunal’s quantum of compensation under several heads, contending that the notional income fixed by the Tribunal (Rs.25,000 per month) is too low in light of Exts.A7 and A10, which show a job offer at AED 4500 per month (about Rs.72,500). Ext.A7 is supported by Ext.A10 (letter from the Consulate General of India, NORKA Roots) confirming the employment offer. The insurers argue that these documents reflect a prospective future employment and not actual present earnings, and that the Tribunal properly computed income at Rs.25,000. The appellants further seek future prospects (40-50%), and for a higher stake in loss of consortium for parents, as well as inclusion of love-and-affection and other heads. The Court reviews precedents on future prospects (Meena Pawariya; Mekala; Pranay Sethi; Santosh Devi) and distinguishes conflicting authorities (Zuhara; Assainar; Kahlon). It holds that notional income should be based on Exts.A7/A10, allows 40% future prospects, and grants higher consortium to the parents, while reducing some heads (e.g., pain and suffering). The appeal is allowed to the extent reflected in the final enhanced schedule, with payment directions and interest provisions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 31313 of 2022

C.S. ABRAHAM v. STATE OF KERALA & ORS

The petitioner, C.S. Abraham, holds an A-class civil contractor’s licence with the Public Works Department and has been engaged in government contracts since 1998. In 2017, the PWD issued Ext.P2 inviting bids for the Pallakkalumkal Bridge project. The petitioner submitted Ext.P3 on 03.08.2022, but was later found by the tendering authority to fail the pre-qualification norms, resulting in Ext.P5 disqualification. The petitioner challenged the decision, arguing that he satisfied the mandatory pre-qualification criteria and that Ext.P5 lacked stated reasons, reflecting non-application of mind after bid acceptance. The respondents contended that the pre-qualification process is system-based: preliminary acceptance allows bidding, followed by post-evaluation using PRICE software, which allocates marks across criteria like structure, finance, resources, and experience. The court underscored the limited scope of judicial review in contractual matters and referred to Silppi Constructions Contractors v Union of India, National High Speed Rail Corporation Ltd v Montecarlo Ltd, and NG Projects Ltd v Vinod Kumar Jain to emphasize restraint, expert reliance, and non-interference unless arbitrariness or mala fides are shown. The court found no mala fides or perverse evaluation and held that the tender authority’s decision was consistent with the established procedure. Consequently, the writ petition was dismissed, upholding the tendering authority’s prerogative and emphasizing deference to technical assessments in public contracts.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.31124 of 2022

Sunilkumar S. v. State Co-operative Election Commission, Director of Industries, India Coffee Board Workers' Co-operative Society Limited, and State of Kerala

This writ petition challenges the election of the Managing Committee of the India Coffee Board Workers’ Co-operative Society Limited (No. 4227) at Thrissur. The last election was held on 19.11.2017, with the committee’s five-year term due to expire on 19.11.2022. The Society’s Managing Committee passed Ext.P1 on 09.10.2022 requesting the State Co-operative Election Commission to conduct the next election on 30.10.2022. The petitioner argues that elections cannot be conducted solely by a Managing Committee resolution unless the General Body declares the date for its general body meeting and the election, as required by Section 29(i)(ce) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act. The petitioner contends that the General Body has ultimate authority over elections and could decide not to hold elections if the majority desires departmental administration. The respondents contend that the Act’s scheme requires timely elections and that Rule 35A(1) requires a date to be fixed after the General Body declares the election date, with primary legislation prevailing over subordinate rules. The court examines Sections 28, 29 and Rules 35A and 39(3), and while acknowledging guidance from several authorities, holds that there is no prescribed consequence for failure to declare a due date, and that the object of the Act is democratic self-government of co‑operative societies. Reading Section 28 with Rule 35A as a purposive framework, the petition is dismissed; elections should be held democratically rather than appointing administrators.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No.1850 of 2022

Krishnakumar v. State of Kerala

This Criminal Misc Case (CRL.MC No.1850 of 2022) before the Kerala High Court challenges the continued prosecution arising from Crime No.489/2006 of Cherpulassery Police Station. The petitioner, Krishna Kumar, accused in a large conspiracy murder case involving multiple accused, seeks to quash the final report and proceedings transferred to LP No.64/2014 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Ottappalam. The prosecution alleged a criminal conspiracy wherein the petitioner allegedly aided or abetted the murder of Ravi, whose parents were purportedly murdered by the deceased. The trial had multiple phases across courts; ultimately, the Sessions Court acquitted the other accused in Annexure-C judgment, while the petitioner’s case remained pending. The petitioner contends that, in the light of acquittals, the substratum of the prosecution is lost and further proceedings are unwarranted; reliance was placed on Moosa v. Sub Inspector of Police (Full Bench) to contend against invoking extraordinary jurisdiction under Section 482 Cr.P.C. The State counters that the petitioner, who was absconding, cannot be permitted to stand in the way of justice, citing stealthy or improper conduct. After thorough scrutiny of Annexure-A final report and Annexure-C judgment, the court concludes that the prosecution’s nexus to the petitioner is not established, and continuing the prosecution would be futile. Differentiating Moosa’s rule, the High Court invokes Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the final report and all further proceedings, thereby allowing the CRL.MC.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.1694 of 2021

Ramakrishnan P.K. v. Kerala State Beverages (M&M) Corporation Ltd.

Ramakrishnan P.K. filed a Writ Appeal challenging a prior order that withheld retirement benefits, notably gratuity (DCRG) and leave encashment, after his retirement in 2013. The learned Single Judge had held that withholding gratuity was illegal and ultra vires since the corporation had no valid rules permitting prolonged post-retirement disciplinary action to fix liability and had directed immediate disbursement of gratuity. The corporation later sanctioned the full gratuity but resisted payment of interest, citing Section 7(3A) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, arguing interest could be payable only if the delay was caused by the employer and under certain conditions. The appellant contends that the withholding and the failure to fix liability promptly violated statutory rights and sought interest from the date gratuity fell due, in addition to other reliefs. The respondents rely on governance rules (Rule 76–78) and Rule 8 of the Kerala State Service Rules (KSR) and Note 2–3 to Rule 3 Part III KSR, explaining that liability fixation should be completed with due process and within statutory time limits, and that criminal proceedings being pending justify delay. The High Court ultimately held withholding illegal, but modified the order to provide 8% simple interest on the full DCRG from 01-01-2014 to 19-07-2021, directing payment within two months, and disposed of the WA with these directions.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev Nos. 84/2018; 75/2018; 78/2018; 77/2018; 79/2018; 80/2018; 82/2018; 81/2018; 86/2018; 91/2018; 92/2018; 94/2018 (and connected cases)

State of Kerala v. Raphel T. Joseph

This batch of OT.Revisions before the Kerala High Court challenges a common order of the Kerala Value Added Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 5 March 2018, in T.A.(VAT) Nos. 564–569/2014 and related cross-objections. The revisions under Section 25 of the Kerala Value Added Tax Act, 2003, are filed by the State (revision petitioner) against Raphel T. Joseph and M/S Renil Auto Garage (respondents). The core issue concerns reassessment powers where turnover escaped assessment, was under-assessed, or taxed at a rate lower than applicable, and the interplay with compounding of tax under Section 8, deemed self‑assessment under Section 21, and other provisions (Sections 6, 8, 21, 22, 24, 25, 56, 66). The Tribunal’s impugned order was based on a line of decisions including Cholayil Pvt. Ltd. that supported the Revenue’s view. After differences of opinion among authorities, the matter was referred to a Full Bench. The Full Bench (31.03.2022) held that reassessment powers under Section 25 are comprehensive and independent of compounding, rejected the narrow proposition of A M Muhammed Ali (holding it not to be the correct proposition of law), and clarified that Sections 25, 56 and 66 operate independently to prevent revenue loss. Consequently, the High Court set aside the Tribunal’s order, allowed the OT revisions, and remitted the matters to the Tribunal for fresh disposal on merits, preferably within four months, to be decided in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 6720 OF 2021

K.R. Vijaya v. State of Kerala and Others

Petitioner K.R. Vijaya, proprietor of Haritha Pharmaceuticals, holds SP VI and SP VII licences under the Kerala Spirituous Preparations Rules, 1969 for wholesale and retail sale of ayurvedic medicines. On 14 December 2021, an Excise Inspector intercepted a vehicle transporting Ayurvedic medicines and directed it to the Excise Office on the premise that the transport violated Rules 9 and 10. Crime No. 51/2021 was registered under Sections 63, 56(b) and 67B of the Abkari Act; the vehicle and consignments were seized and an inventory and mahazar prepared; confiscation proceedings are pending. The petitioner contends the registration of the crime is abuse of process and illegal. He relies on Priyamvada P.G. (Dr.) v. State of Kerala and Others (2015 (5) KHC 63), as confirmed by a Division Bench in WA No.546 of 2016, which held that Arishtams and Asavas are ayurvedic medicines and cannot be treated as liquor under the Abkari Act; at most they may be intoxicating drugs but outside the Act and do not require a licence under the Act for transport. The State’s appeal contends the contrary. The Division Bench found the quantity transported within licence limits and held that licensing conditions under the Rules govern such transport, not the Abkari Act, so Sections 56(b) and 67B do not apply. Annexure VII was quashed; Crl.M.C. allowed with directions to Excise authorities to avoid harassment and educate on the correct legal position.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 30661 OF 2022

T.G. Mohandas v. State of Kerala & Others

Petitioner T.G. Mohandas, a retired engineer, advocate, public worker and media person, approached this court by WP(C) 30661 of 2022 to obtain a mandamus directing the registration of a FIR and investigation into a purported cognizable offence under Section 124 IPC against His Excellency the Governor of Kerala, arising from a 2019 incident at Kannur University during a conference where the Governor was allegedly intimidated, interrupted, and where slogans were shouted from the audience. He claimed that police personnel present did not register any crime and that inaction persisted for over three years; he sought directions for disciplinary action against delinquent police officers and invoked Lalita Kumari v. State of UP to argue a police duty to register. The State respondents argued that a writ petition cannot replace investigation by the police, and that the petition is based on newspaper reports, which alone are not evidence; they cited Circular No.29/2017 and the court's earlier decision in W.P.(C) No. 14316 of 2020, which held that mandamus cannot issue. In the end, the court held that the petition is not maintainable, that remedy under Article 226 is extraordinary, and that it cannot compel an investigation or action by central or state agencies; the petition was dismissed with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P. No.715 of 2021

K.A. Manikantan v. P. Philip and State of Kerala

This criminal revision challenges a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and the appellate modification of sentence by the III Additional District and Sessions Court, Palakkad. The trial court convicted the petitioner for issuing a cheque for Rs. 1,40,000, sentencing three months’ simple imprisonment and directing compensation under Section 357(3) Cr.P.C., with an order of imprisonment in default for non-payment. The appellate court, in Criminal Appeal No. 29/2014, modified the sentence by directing payment of Rs. 1.50 lakh as fine to be realized as compensation under Section 357(1) Cr.P.C., and ordered three months’ imprisonment in case of default. The revision contends improper appraisal of Ext. D1, a disputed document, and relies on Ext. P1 and Ext. D4 forensic findings linking the signature to the author of the specimen; it is argued that the defence was not properly considered and that Basalingappa v. Mudibasappa supports the standard of proof as preponderance of probabilities. The respondents defend the courts’ appreciation of Ext. D1 and the testimony, maintaining no reversible error. They rely on settled principles about presumption under Section 139 NI Act and the credibility of the complainant’s sources of funds. Ultimately, the High Court dismisses the revision, upholding the concurrent verdicts.

High Court of Kerala
W.P. (C) No. 10580 of 2022

Krishnakumar R v. Chief Secretary, Government of Kerala & Others

This writ petition, W.P. (C) No. 10580 of 2022, challenges Ext. P3, the Anganwadi Helpers selection list published by the ICDS Project, Pathanamthitta at Ezhumattoor Grama Panchayat. The petitioner alleges procedural illegality and favoritism in the selection process and seeks quashing of Ext. P3 and reconstitution of the selection committee in line with Ext. P7 Government Order dated 22.12.2012 (renewing the selection committee for Anganwadi Workers/Helpers under ICDS). He also seeks to cancel the purported flawed process since the selection was allegedly conducted contrary to the amended norms in Ext. P7, and he points to a lack of transparency in responding to RTI requests (Ext. P5) and subsequent complaints (Ext. P8). The core issue centers on whether the selection committee was constituted as per the 2012 GO (as amended) and whether the published list was prepared free of favoritism and procedural violations, with proper representation (Grama Panchayat President, Convener, Block Panchayat representative, Panchayat Secretary, Medical Officer, ICDS district unit, and five social activists). The petition further asserts violation of natural justice and the 2012 GO’s directives. The High Court, however, dismissed the petition holding that it does not satisfy the requirements of Public Interest Litigation (PIL) and concluded that the petition lacked bona fides, emphasizing the need for genuine PILs and cautioning against frivolous petitions. The judgment thereby prevents quashing Ext. P3 or mandating reconstitution, and sustains the standing selection process.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 3439 of 2020

Salim K.M. v. The State of Kerala

Salim K.M., an agriculturist with possession of 72.30 acres of land in Survey No.185/1, Vagamon, challenged in a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 Cr.P.C. the proceedings in CC No.10/2018 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thodupuzha, arising from Crime No.603/2017 registered by Vagamon Police for offences under Sections 7(a) and (b) of the Kerala Land Conservancy Amendment Act, 2009 and Section 447 IPC. The petitioner asserted possession since 1960 through his predecessors and an application for land assignment under Kerala Land Assignment Rules, 1964 (Rules 11(8), 12(1)) was filed on 25.05.2015; reports by the Taluk Surveyor (2016) and Village Officer (2017) indicated possession, boundaries and a tea plantation, with a proposed patta in his favour. The State contends that possession was not legally established and therefore the prosecution could proceed; cognizance had been taken on a final report though the patta had not yet been granted. The High Court examined Rule 7 and Rule 2(cc) of the Rules, and Kunhali v. Tahsildar, Kozhikode and Others, concluding that action under the Act can be initiated only where possession is established. Since possession was not proved, the prosecution was unsustainable. On 14.10.2022, the court allowed the Cr.M.C., quashing FIR Annexure VII and Final Report Annexure VIII in CC 10/2018.