Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 573 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.A Nos.1037/2016, 1038/2016, 1039/2016 & 1040/2016

State of Kerala v. Rangaswamy; Sivakami; Senthil; Saravanan (Criminal Appeal Nos. 1037/2016, 1038/2016, 1039/2016 & 1040/2016)

The judgment deals with four consolidated criminal appeals arising from a cross-border murder case, where a Tamil Nadu Municipal Councilor was murdered and the deceased—an eye-witness—was allegedly abducted and killed to silence him. The trial court convicted A1–A9 under various IPC provisions, notably 302 read with 149 and other allied sections (364, 201, 143, 147, 148) based on circumstantial evidence, including last-seen-together testimony, a purported dying declaration (Ext. P3/a) on the back of Ext. P3, handwriting issues, and a lodge-room discovery with a Tata Sumo. The Kerala High Court, however, undertakes a meticulous re-appreciation of the evidence. It notes grave omissions, inconsistencies, and improvements in witnesses’ testimonies (PWs 3, 5, 8), questions the reliability of the dying declaration and the TIP, and finds no independent corroboration of the last-seen theory or the alleged Tamil Nadu connection. The court emphasizes that a dying declaration is weak evidence and handwriting evidence is not conclusive, demanding corroboration. It concludes that there is no cogent chain of circumstantial evidence establishing guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, all accused are acquitted and must be released forthwith, with bail bonds canceled if applicable. The judgment cautions against over-reliance on dying declarations and identification based on digested or uncorroborated handwriting.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4323 OF 2013

Rajan v. State of Kerala

Rajan, the petitioner, challenged OR No.29/2013 initiated by the Forest Range Officer, Kumily, under the Kerala (Prohibition of Felling of Trees Standing on Land Temporarily or Permanently Assigned) Rules, 1995, alleging offences for felling two rosewood trees from Survey No.222, Kumily, Peermade Taluk, Idukki. He contends that the land is his absolute property, the trees were never reserved by grant, and that he had authority and permission to cut and remove the trees as evidenced by Annexure II; he also argues that the Rules, 1995 do not apply to him and that the prosecution ignores the dictum in Augustine Mathew & Another v. State of Kerala. The respondent asserts the land is part of Amaravathy Estate, potentially acquired via kuthakapattam grant, with the government retaining ownership of the rosewood trees and the alleged violation of forest laws. The court notes that the land is non-forest and in a non-notified area, and that the land may not have been reserved, and it recognizes that the Act of 2005 empowers owners to plant and, in certain cases, to cut trees (except sandalwood) but only with proper declarations and authorisations. The court considers Sukumaran and Others v. State of Kerala and holds that, given the absence of reservation and non-notified status, the offence under the Act 2005 is not made out. It further holds that continuing the investigation would be an abuse of process and quashes OR No.29/2013 and allows the CrL.M.C. petition.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 1227 of 2016 & CRA(V) No. 715 of 2017

Kuriachen @ Syriac v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court judgment, delivered by a Division Bench on 8 March 2022, deals with two related criminal appeals arising from SC 74/2016: Crl.A No.1227 of 2016 (appeal by the convicted husband) and CRA(V) No.715 of 2017 (victim’s appeal for conviction against co-accused). The appellant challenges the trial court’s conviction under sections 498A and 304B IPC and the acquittal of A3 (the sister‑in‑law). The State supports the conviction, arguing that dowry harassment and cruelty were established, and that the reinvestigation ordered nearly nine years after the death unearthed crucial facts. The defense contends the trial court’s discussion was missing, the FIS was suppressed, and many statements were unreliable; it further alleges police interference and planted witnesses, noting the delay and changes in testimony across investigations. The court scrutinizes the evidence, including testimonies of PW1–PW4 and medical evidence of a suicide by corrosive poison, while highlighting inconsistencies, suppression of Ext.D5 (initial FIS), and the lack of prompt complaint after the death. Relying on established law, including Kashmir Kaur, Pradeep Kumar and Anil Kumar, the bench holds that absence of cruelty/harassment undermines the inference under 113A/113B, acquits the accused, and allows the victim’s appeal to the extent of invalidating the conviction while upholding A3’s acquittal. It also cautions against inappropriate interference by the Kerala State Women’s Commission in investigations.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos. 271 & 274 of 2022

Writ Appeal Nos. 271 & 274 of 2022

The Kerala High Court, in a common judgment rendered by a Division Bench headed by Justice P.B. Suresh Kumar and Justice C.S. Sudha, disposed of two writ appeals challenging government decisions denying sanction for additional higher secondary batches in Moonniyoor Higher Secondary School (Malappuram). The appeals arose from writ petitions filed by students seeking admission to higher secondary courses and by the school manager challenging the government’s refusal. The government contends that COVID-19 necessitated online classes, financial constraints, and reliance on a State Level Committee’s recommendations, while allowing only a 20% seat increase where possible. The petitioners argue acute shortage of seats in the district and insist on expanding capacity to meet educational needs, citing constitutional obligations and prior court directions (notably in St. Sebastian’s High School, Thrissur) that require a transparent, data-driven determination of need and a policy-guided process for sanctioning batches. The learned Single Judge had allowed the petitions, but the court finds that the data presented by the authorities shows ongoing district-wide need. It sets aside the impugned orders, directing the Government to decide forthwith how to address Malappuram’s higher secondary needs, and to initiate expansion with due regard to resources and the established guidelines. The decision emphasizes fair, transparent, and policy-driven assessment of educational needs within fiscal constraints.

High Court of Kerala
TR.APPEAL(C) NO. 5 OF 2022

Sruthy S. v. Reshmi Chandran

This is a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court dealing with a transfer petition under Section 24 CPC in a matrimonial matter. The appellant-husband (SRUTHY S.) challenged an order of the Single Judge dismissing Tr.P.(C).No.489 of 2020, a transfer petition seeking to move O.P.No.1329 of 2020 from the Family Court, Thiruvananthapuram, to the Family Court at Chavara. The original petition for divorce was filed by the respondent wife under various enactments (Special Marriage Act, Hindu Marriage Act and Family Courts Act). The wife’s current address, for purposes of jurisdiction, is stated to be Kollam, though the permanent home is Kollam; the wife presently resides in Thiruvananthapuram. The appellant contends that the respondent’s claimed residence is a stratagem to fix proceedings at Thiruvananthapuram, whereas a transfer to Chavara would be appropriate, given the residence and convenience of witnesses and parties. The learned Single Judge held that no grounds exist for transfer, noting that the difference in forum would be marginal and that the appellant’s assertions about residence were not sufficient. The High Court, after considering canonical precedents on transfer of cases, upholds the impugned order, holding that no reasonable grounds for transfer were made out. The appeal is therefore dismissed, with no order as to costs.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) No.152 of 2022

Noushad Flourish v. Akhila Noushad

This Original Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenges Exts. P13 and P14, the common order dated 10.02.2022 passed by the Family Court, Thalassery in O.P. No. 941/2019, along with I.A.s 6, 8 and 9 of 2021. The petitioner sought to recall RW1 and RW2 and to receive in evidence a pen-drive containing a telephonic conversation between the petitioner (RW1) and RW2, purportedly relating to a possible settlement of the matrimonial dispute. The applications were opposed by the respondent, who argued the evidence is irrelevant to the restitution petition and that RW2 had turned hostile; after the pronouncement of Khula, the relevance of the proposed evidence was questioned. In the context of the admissibility of the pendrive under Section 65B of the Evidence Act, the court noted that even if the contents are proven, they would constitute prior statements and could be used only to corroborate or contradict RW2’s testimony. The court restated the settled scope of Article 227, citing Shalini Shyam Shetty, Jai Singh, K.V.S. Ram and Sobhana Nair, that supervisory interference is narrow and only in cases of manifest error, gross injustice, or patent illegality. On these lines, Exts. P13 and P14 could not be said to be manifestly wrong, and the petition was dismissed. The court thus upheld the Family Court orders and declined to reopen evidence.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C. No.3354/15

Parle Agro Pvt. Ltd. and others v. State of Kerala and Senior Inspector, Legal Metrology, Thiruvananthapuram

This is a Criminal Misc. Case (Crl.M.C. No. 3354/2015) heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court (Bechu Kurián Thomas, J.). The petition challenges a criminal complaint filed under the Legal Metrology Act, 2009 and the Legal Metrology (Packaged Commodities) Rules, 2011, arising from a 1.5 litre bottle of a fruit-based beverage marketed as FROOTI. The complainant, an Inspector of Legal Metrology, alleged violations of several Rules (4, 6, 7(2), 9(1)(b), 9(3), read with Rule 8(2) and Rule 18) and of sections 18 and 36(1) of the Act, mainly on the grounds that the MRP declaration on the label was not printed or legible and that the font size of MRP and packing date did not conform to the prescribed minimums. The petitioners contended that the product complied with the Act and Rules, and that the prosecution is an abuse of process, including issues around nominee rights under section 49 of the Act and the removal of contents from the seized bottle. The court analyzed definitions of 'label' (section 2(f)) and 'principal display panel' (Rule 2(h)) and the interplay of Rules 8(1) and 8(2). It held that, under the pre-2017 regime, the entire bottle could be treated as the principal display panel; the neck-printed online information does not amount to a violation. Distinguishing PepsiCo’s case and relying on Danone Narang Beverages Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Karnataka and Ors, the court quashed the proceedings as an abuse of process and allowed the petition. The petition is allowed; all proceedings in CC No. 3240/2014 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 7404/2022

Dimple John v. Regional Head, Union Bank of India & Branch Manager, Union Bank of India

The petitioner, a day-scholar student enrolled for an M.Sc. Biotechnology program at MES MK Mackar Pillai College for Advance Studies, Edathala, Ernakulam, challenges the denial of an education loan by the Union Bank of India. She had sought a loan of ₹1,40,100 for the 2020–22 academic year, but Ext.P5 rejected the loan on the ground that she did not secure the requisite 60% in her qualifying examination, having scored 56%. The petitioner asserts RBI Circular Ext.P6 (dated 28.04.2001) provides that for loans up to ₹4 lakhs, minimum qualifying marks need not be insisted upon, and she notes that the same bank had earlier sanctioned a loan. She contends the policy in Ext.P6 is a guideline with statutory force, which must be read as a supplement to the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 (as held in ICICI Bank Ltd. v. Official Liquidator of APS Star Industries Ltd.). The petitioner also relies on two of this Court’s judgments (Exts.P7, P8) suggesting favorable treatment in similar circumstances. The respondents maintain that the petitioner falls under the general category and that the 60% criterion is fixed by Master Circular (RBI/Bank) Annexure-R1(a) and Model Educational Loan Scheme (Annexure-R1(b)). The court ultimately grants relief to the petitioner, holding RBI guidelines have force and directing the bank to reconsider Ext.P3 without insisting on the 60% threshold and to decide within two weeks.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No.2498 of 2007

Criminal Appeal No. 2498 of 2007 (Kerala High Court)

This is a criminal appeal by Jojo and Baby challenging their conviction under Section 8(2) Abkari Act by the IV Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-II), Thodupuzha, in SC No.563/2006. On 6 November 2003, around 1:30 AM, the Excise team found two cans containing 5 litres of illicit arrack each in front of the house of accused No.2, on the Chathamattom-Mullaringadu road. The case was investigated and final report submitted; the accused were tried and convicted, each receiving two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. The High Court examines the defense challenges focused on chain of evidence and whether the contraband substance reached the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory in a tamper-proof condition, the completeness of the forwarding note, and the absence of key witnesses. It cites Kumaran v. State of Kerala, Rajamma v. State of Kerala, and State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram to underline deficiencies in tamper-proof despatch and chain of custody, and Krishnadas v. State of Kerala, Vijay Pandey v. State of U.P, and Sasidharan v. State of Kerala to illustrate delays and the necessity of linking the seized sample to the lab analysis. The Court ultimately holds that the prosecution failed to prove the essential link, acquits the appellants, and allows the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 9362/2022; 9381/2022; 17318/2022; 17322/2022 (connected cases)

WP(C) Nos. 9362/2022, 9381/2022, 17318/2022 and 17322/2022 (connected petitions) – High Court of Kerala

These connected writ petitions challenge refunds of amounts collected as a condition precedent to an order under Section 27A of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. The petitioners contend that payment of such amounts is not a valid condition precedent to an order under Sec. 27A and seek refunds of the funds collected by revenue authorities, arguing illegality in the levy. The court traces a chain of Supreme Court precedents holding that sums collected under unconstitutional levies must be refunded, irrespective of whether the claim is brought in a suit or under Article 226 of the Constitution. Notable authorities cited include Mahabir Kishore v. State of Madhya Pradesh, Hmm Limited v. Administrator, Bangalore City Corporation, Salonah Tea Company Ltd. v. Superintendent of Taxes Nowgong, and U.P. Pollution Control Board v. Kanoria Industrial Ltd. Based on these authorities, the court holds the petitioners are entitled to refunds and directs refund within two months; Ext.P5 in two petitions is set aside. The judgment consolidates four writ petitions, treats the unconstitutional levy as refundable, and clarifies that the constitutional remedy under Article 226 remains available. The decision thus requires the government to reimburse the deposits collected under the challenged regime.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 10536 OF 2022

Kerala Private Medical College Management Association v State of Kerala & Ors

The Kerala Private Medical College Management Association, representing private medical colleges, approached the Kerala High Court seeking directions to the 3rd respondent (Commissioner for Entrance Examinations) and 4th respondent (Admission Supervisory/Fee Regulatory Committee for Professional Colleges, Kerala) to grant time for fresh registration in the NRI quota for eligible students before Mop-up counseling. The petitioner argued that after NEET results and KEAM 2021 state quota rank lists, there were vacant NRI quota seats (about 57), which would revert to the State Merit Quota if not filled, causing financial loss to member colleges. The petition emphasizes that the COVID-19 pandemic restricted many eligible candidates from abroad from applying and seeks (i) time for fresh registration, (ii) a direction to consider Ext. P3 representation within a time limit, (iii) permission to admit NEET-qualified students in NRI quota before a cut-off date, and (iv) permission to collect NRI-quota fees if vacancies are filled. The court, after hearing, noted that KUHS fixed a cut-off date and that despite earlier orders, the number of unfilled NRI seats had diminished; it held that extending time would disrupt the academic calendar and that clause 5.5.4 of the prospectus governs the process. The petition was ultimately dismissed. Appendices include petition exhibits (P1–P6).

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4618 OF 2017

E.M. Vijayakumar v. State of Kerala and Binny Devassia (De facto complainant)

This criminal miscellaneous case concerns a private complaint filed by the de facto complainant against E.M. Vijayakumar, a former Sub Inspector who initially investigated Crime No. 504/2005 at Pavaratty Police Station. The death of Jeesamol P. Devasia, a 21-year-old nursing student, occurred during an exam and was investigated as an unnatural death under Section 174 Cr.P.C. The private complaint contends that the petitioner conducted the investigation in a shabby manner and deliberately caused evidence of the offence to disappear to screen the offender. Annexure A details alleged defects: failure to conduct fiber tests, delayed seizure of material objects, non-disclosure of the shawl used for hanging to the doctor, and a delay in sending vaginal swabs for chemical examination. The CBCID and later the CBI conducted further inquiry, with a closure report finding suicide by hanging as the cause of death; a protest against the acceptance of this report was filed, and a final report was accepted. The High Court, perusing the materials and the final report, found no prima facie case for an offence under Section 201 IPC, noting that the prosecution could not establish intentional suppression to screen a culprit. Relying on Treesa v. State of Kerala, the court observed that where the identity of the offender is unknown, the requisite mens rea cannot be presumed. Consequently, the court quashed all further proceedings in CC No. 2785/2014 and allowed the Crl.M.C.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 2038 OF 2021

Sasi K. and others v. S. Asokan and others

MACA No. 2038 of 2021 pertains to a motor-accident claims appeal in the Kerala High Court. The three appellants—Sasi K., Sandhama, and Smitha—seek to condone an extraordinary delay of 3367 days in filing the appeal against a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal award (O.P.M.V. 192/2003) in Pathanamthitta. They contend poverty, lack of legal awareness, and late discovery of a co-passenger’s related proceedings as grounds for the delay. The respondents oppose condonation, arguing there is no bonafide explanation and that the delay is the result of willful negligence, prejudicing their rights accrued over a decade. The court canvasses Supreme Court precedents on condonation of delay, including University of Delhi v. Union of India and others, Pandlik Talam Patil v. Talgaou Medium Project, Maniben Devraj Shah v. Municipal Corporation of Brihan Mumbai, and Esha Bhattacharjee v. Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy. The principle that delay must be justified by “sufficient cause” and that “delay defeats equity” is emphasized, with distinctions drawn between inordinate delay and short delays. On balance, the court finds prejudice to the respondents and lack of a credible, timely explanation, and declines to condone the delay. Consequently, the appeal is dismissed and the CMA is refused.

High Court of Kerala
CON.CASE(C) NO. 2007 OF 2019

Muhammed Haseeb T.K. v. Darlene Carmalita D Cruz and others

Muhammed Haseeb T.K., the petitioner, filed Contempt Case (Civil) No. 2007 of 2019 alleging non-compliance with Annexure A1 of this Court’s judgment dated 5 August 2019 in WP(C) 38888/2018. The writ petition had disposed of the matter after recording the Government Pleader’s submissions that the District Road Safety Council’s Ext.R2(a), item 12, directing the removal of a bus shelter at Uduma Junction, should be implemented forthwith by the respondents within one month from receipt of a certified copy. The contempt petition traces a protracted sequence: review petition Sivaprasad v. State of Kerala (2020) 6 KHC 373; orders and counter-affidavits; and the court’s concern that the bus shelter protruded into the bus bay, creating safety hazards to passengers and pedestrians. The judgment cites Apex Court directions in Union of India v. State of Gujarat (2013) and Yoosaf K. and others v. State of Kerala (2019) to emphasize limits on unauthorised structures and the role of PBSKL/EIA-EMP standards. By 2020–2021 the respondents submitted affidavits showing demolition of the disputed shelter and the erection of new shelters, amid protests. In December 2021 a further shelter was demolished, and the court, after recording the developments, closed the contempt case on 29 March 2022, while noting safety and public trust considerations and reserving para 15 observations.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 7712 OF 2021

Saramma Cherian v. The Manager, Girideepam Higher Secondary School, Vadavathoor; and The Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act (Deputy Labour Commissioner, Kottayam at Ettumanoor)

Petitioner Saramma Cherian, a 71-year-old workman, approached the Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act seeking gratuity payment from her employer. After the evidence stage, the management produced a bundle of documents including true extracts of acquittance registers and multiple bank statements (South Indian Bank and others) linking to the gratuity claim. The petitioner challenged Ext.P5 (the management’s affidavit-in-evidence), contending that, post-Civil Procedure Code amendments, evidence must be admitted either by originals or accompanied by an undertaking to produce originals during cross-examination; otherwise the documents could not be admitted. She argued that the Controlling Authority, a quasi-judicial body, cannot function as a Civil Court, and that Section 7(5) of the Act and Rule 14 govern the manner of taking evidence. The respondents argued that the Controlling Authority has the power to take evidence by affidavit under Section 7(5) and Rule 14, and that photocopies of documents could be admitted with undertakings. The learned Judge held that the controlling authority’s power to take evidence is governed by Section 7(5) and Rule 14, and that the authority is not a Civil Court but may exercise judicial-like powers within statutory limits. The Court directed production of original acquaintance registers at cross-examination and held that certified copies of bank statements (Nos. 2–19) are admissible under Section 34 of the Indian Evidence Act. The writ petition was disposed of accordingly, with the matter proceeding under the statute.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 4150 of 2023

Sayooj Punnakot v. State of Kerala and others

The petitioner, Sayooj Punnakot, an Office Attendant at AUP School Kaithakkad, challenges Exts. P2, P5, P7 and P10, which rejected his appointment in a retirement vacancy on the ground that the school was newly opened/upgraded and hence a protected teacher would be required, with appointment to be considered only from the date of such protected hands as per Rule 7(5) of Chapter XXI KER. He had been appointed from 01/06/2020 and seeks approval from that date with payment of all consequential benefits, relying on Ext. P3 (consent letter) and Exts. P11–P12 (government orders/clarifications). The petitioner argues that there was no protected non-teaching staff in the district at the time of his appointment and no list of protected hands, and that Ext. P9 directing reconsideration should be honoured, along with Ext. P11 Clause (iv). The respondents contend that the policy requires protection for the post via Rule 7(5) of KER and that consideration must align with Circular No. J2/57/2019 and the reservation of disabled persons; Ext.P10 was issued for lack of consent and pre-2019 vacancies. The Court ultimately sets aside Ext. P10, directing reconsideration in light of the 13.03.2023 Division Bench judgment in W.A.No.1445 of 2022 and connected cases, with opportunity of hearing and application of Ext. P11 Clause (iv).

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No. 837 of 2021

Anjali Nath v. C.B. Krishna Chandran and others

This is an original petition (OP(C) 837 of 2021) filed in the High Court of Kerala challenging an order dated 02.03.2021 passed in IA No. 2/2021 in OP(Election) 2/2021 before the Munsiff Court, Sasthamcotta, Kollam, under Article 227 of the Constitution. The election petition under Sections 87 and 89 of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994, alleged that five candidates cast double votes, a factor potentially altering the outcome by a margin of three votes. While the petition was pending, the petitioner moved IA 2/2021 contending that the election petition was not maintainable because it was not presented by the election petitioner in person; the petition was allegedly filed by an advocate, with docket records showing the presenting party as the advocate, Parippally R. Raveendran. The trial court rejected these objections, noting that the petition contained pleadings on the grounds under Section 102 of the Act and that the election petition may be presented by a candidate or an elector within 30 days of declaration of the result. The High Court examined the requirement under Section 89(1) that petitions be presented by a candidate or elector, observed the docketing issues, and ultimately affirmed the trial court’s view that the order was not perverse or arbitrary. The petition was dismissed (O.P.(C).No.837/2021), though the judge left open the possibility of challenging non‑compliance of Section 89 at the final hearing with evidence.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 8051/2020; WP(C) No. 11483/2020

THE COCHIN COLLEGE, KOCHI & THE COCHIN EDUCATIONAL SOCIETY, COCHIN v. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF COLLEGIATE EDUCATION, GANDHINAGAR; THE DIRECTOR, DIRECTORATE OF COLLEGIATE EDUCATION, VIKAS BHAVAN; THE SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, HIGHER EDUCATION DEPARTMENT; MAHATMA GANDHI UNIVERSITY

Two writ petitions, WP(C) No. 8051/2020 filed by The Cochin College and its Educational Agency and WP(C) No. 11483/2020 filed by four English teachers of The Cochin College, were heard together as they arise from a common factual matrix regarding workload-based staffing. The Adalath workload order, produced as Ext. P5 in 11483/2020, fixed a workload of 191 hours for the English Department based on GO(MS) No. 93/2018/HEDN (2018) and envisaged 12 posts, while only eight posts had government sanction. The Government later contended that GO(MS) No. 155/2020/HEDN (2020) altered the workload calculations, bringing the eligible workload down to 166 hours and thereby affecting post-sanctions. The petitioners argued that managements may appoint teachers where there is no statutory inhibition and that University approval follows, citing Amina v. State of Kerala and related judgments; the Government argued Adalath orders were non-binding and that the revised criteria should govern. The court held that the 191-hour Adalath workload determined in 2017 governs appointments made on that basis, and that the subsequent changes cannot prejudice those appointments. The petitions are allowed in part: Ext. P10 and Exts. P15/P16 are set aside; the Government is to sanction two balance posts, and the University will reconsider 11483/2020’s appointments with time-bound directions; benefits to teachers to be provided promptly.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 2431 of 2021 & 31342 of 2018

Nazeer Ayoth Thazha Kuniyil v. State of Kerala and Others

These two connected writ petitions challenge orders affecting the appointment of Rahmaniyaa High School staff in Kozhikode. The petitioners—Nazeer Ayoth Thazha Kuniyil (WP(C) 2431/2021) and Naseer Ayoth Thazha Kuniyil (WP(C) 31342/2018)—were appointed previously as UPSA/HSA (Social Science) on the basis of vacancies arising from retirements and promotions. Later, the Director of Public Instructions cancelled the approvals and directed non-payment of salary, culminating in Ext.P9 (and Ext.P5) orders against the petitioners. The petitioners contended that the DPI’s revisional/cancellation action violated natural justice, and that vacancies existed for 2018-19 to accommodate the petitioners as HSA (SS). The State argued that the DEO’s 2017 order and subsequent DPI action were legally permissible, under Kerala Education Rules (KER) and Rule 8/8A of Chapter XIV(A). The High Court consolidated the petitions, found Ext.P9 vitiated for a lack of natural justice, and held there was an available HSA post in 2018-19 that could accommodate the petitioners. It directed the manager to submit a fresh proposal to approve the 12.06.2018 appointment and instructed authorities to process the matter expeditiously. WP 31342/2018 was disposed of by setting aside Ext.P5 and treating the interim salary arrangements as final. The decision emphasizes natural justice and lawful adherence to KER while permitting redress via fresh proposals.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 1025 of 2017

Raju s/o Sreedharan v. State of Kerala

Raju s/o Sreedharan, the appellant, is challenging a conviction under Section 376 IPC and Sections 4 read with 3 and 6 read with 5 of the POCSO Act, upheld by the Additional Sessions Judge for Thiruvananthapuram. The minor victim, about 6½ years old, testified that on two occasions (April 2012 and August 2015) she was sexually assaulted by her neighbour inside her home; the hospital examination (Ext. P3) and the medical findings indicated signs of sexual assault, including digital penetration. The trial court found the accused guilty and sentenced him to ten years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹1,00,000 with a six-month default for the POCSO count. The appellant contends the conviction rests on the uncorroborated testimony of a child, alleging contradictions, omissions, and a three-month FIR delay, arguing insufficient proof beyond reasonable doubt. The State opposed the appeal, arguing the victim’s testimony is credible, corroborated by PW5 (teacher) and PW9 (maternal aunt), and supported by medical evidence; delays in reporting in sexual offences can be excused, and there is no doubt about genesis or genuineness. The court, upholding the trial court’s reasoning and relying on established jurisprudence that child-witness testimony in sexual offences can suffice without corroboration, dismissed the appeal and affirmed the conviction and sentence.