Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 571 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1043 OF 2023

Alifkhan Abdul Ahad Safeena v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Alifkhan Abdul Ahad Safeena, the sole accused in crime No. 7/2023 of the Devikulam Excise Range, Idukki, alleging possession of contraband under the NDPS Act. The prosecution claims the accused was found in possession of 7 grams of dry ganja and 0.126 gram of LSD (7 stamps) while transporting them on a motorbike near Velmudy Kara, Munnar, constituting offences under NDPS Act sections 20(b)(ii)(A) and 22(c). The Public Prosecutor argues the recovery amounts to a commercial quantity and that the twin conditions under Section 37(1)(b) of the NDPS Act must be satisfied before granting bail, given the non-bailable, cognizable nature of such offences. The petitioner’s counsel contends innocence, youth, and prolonged custody since 25.01.2023, requesting bail with appropriate safeguards. The court explains that Section 37(1)(a)(i) requires “reasonable grounds” for believing the accused not guilty and a likelihood of non-recurrence during bail, citing Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari to define “reasonable grounds” as more than prima facie. It emphasizes that the court is not to pronounce an acquittal at this stage. The judgment reiterates established precedents (Paulsamy, Nodira, Abdulla, Rajesh, Niyazuddin, etc.) and holds that the conditions are not satisfied, thereby denying bail. The application is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO.1064 OF 2023

Moosa Kunikotta Moideen v. State of Kerala

This is a bail petition (BAIL APPL. NO.1064 OF 2023) decided by a Single Judge of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam. The petitioner is the 3rd accused in Crime No.37/2023 of Keezhvaipur Police Station, Pathanamthitta, charged under Section 420 read with 34 IPC. The prosecution alleges a cheating scheme where the defacto complainant was induced to part with Rs 5 lakh on the promise of securing a job as a store keeper in Hong Kong; Rs 1.5 lakh allegedly reached the 2nd accused through a bank transfer, and Rs 3.5 lakh in US dollars via the 1st accused after the complainant was taken to Hong Kong, with the job ultimately not materializing. The petitioner contends innocence and asserts he bonafidely introduced the 1st and 2nd accused to the complainant on the belief they could arrange the job, claiming he did not personally receive any amount. He has been in custody since 13 January 2023; counsel emphasizes he is a first-time offender and seeks regular bail. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing the offences are serious and investigation is at an early stage. After reviewing the case diary (FIS) and records, the court finds the petitioner’s involvement not on par with the others, and, considering the custody period so far, grants regular bail with specified conditions, including bond, sureties, witness protection, cooperation, periodic appearance, no intimidation, passport surrender, and no new offences during bail.

High Court of Kerala
OP(CAT).133 of 2020

OP(CAT).133 of 2020

The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, heard OP(CAT).133 of 2020 filed by Union of India challenging the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Ernakulam Bench, OA 387/2015, which directed upgrading the pay scales for rail accounts staff with effect from 1 January 1996 on a notional basis and actual payment from 19 February 2003. The background traces to the Fifth Central Pay Commission recommendations, under which account staff received normal replacement scales; the government later revised the scales notionally from 1 September 1996 but granted these benefits only from 19 February 2003. The respondents/applicants contended that similarly situated railway employees were granted these benefits by the CAT and upheld by this Court, the Patna High Court, and the Supreme Court in related matters, and that the petition cannot rely on a negative equality principle. They relied on government decisions and Cabinet approvals to argue that retrospective effect cannot be assumed absent explicit provision. The petitioners argued that there are contradictory orders and that the question of law was left open in some decisions, suggesting the tribunal’s approach was erroneous. The court ultimately affirmed the Tribunal’s approach and dismissed the petition, noting that similarly situated employees cannot be discriminated against and that the same treatment has been consistently granted in earlier decisions. The petition is dismissed, upholding the CAT order.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos. 388/2023 & 383/2023; WP(C) Nos. 2402/2023, 3521/2023 & 3768/2023

Seema Sebastian v State of Kerala & Others

Two writ appeals and connected petitions challenge the admission process to the Post Graduate Ayurveda courses for 2022 under the service quota for Medical Officers in Kerala. The core issue is whether the government could rectify the eligibility criteria after publication of the final service-quota list. For the academic year 2022-23, the National Testing Agency conducted its exam on 15 October 2022 and published results on 9 November 2022; Kerala released the PG Ayurveda prospectus on 29 December 2022 and invited applications on 4 January 2023; the provisional and final service quota lists were published in January 2023. Based on an interim order dated 25 January 2023, the government changed the upper age limit for Medical Officer quota candidates to reflect seven years of service remaining before retirement; this recast the final service-quota list published on 27 January 2023, placing Seema Sebastian and Dr Sivaprasadan V lower than earlier. The petitioners asserted that eligibility criteria fixed by the prospectus could not be altered after the last date for submissions and that such conduct breached Article 14's equality and fairness; they argued laches barred the challenge. The bench, however, held that while ordinarily changes post last date are impermissible, the government acted to rectify discrimination arising from disparate retirement ages and to align similar classes; thus, reviewing the rights of those already included as legitimate expectations, it allowed WP(C)2402/2023 and dismissed others.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.4178 of 2024

Rahees C.K. v. State of Kerala

Rahees C.K. seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC in Crime No. 405/2024 of the Petta Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, where he is charged under IPC sections 354, 354A(1)(i), and 376(3) and under the POCSO Act, including sections 4(2) read with 3(a)(b), 8 read with 7, 10 read with 9(l), and 12 read with 11(iv). Arrested 18 April 2024, he has already spent about three months in custody; the investigation is complete and the final report is laid. The prosecution contends that the accused exploited a 17-year-old victim with whom he allegedly developed a relationship, committing acts of sexual assault and rape in a lodge near Lulu Mall after promising to marry her when she turned 18. The victim’s statements and the facts on record indicate coercion and a conviction of grave offences, though the defense asserts a consensual relationship and a settled dispute. The court notes the victim’s age at the time of the incident and the seriousness of the offences, but reiterates the principle that bail is the general rule and detention is exceptional, especially where the investigation is complete. After evaluating the rival submissions and the need to protect witnesses, the court grants bail on stringent conditions, balance of public interest and individual liberty in mind.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.Nos. 89, 94, 151 & 152 of 2019

Karthu and others v Hindhu Matha Dharma Paripalana Sabha, Moothakunnam; Dayavathi and others v Hindhu Matha Dharma Paripalana Sabha, Moothakunnam; Sudhakar and others v Hindhu Matha Dharma Paripalana Sabha, Moothakunnam (R.C.Rev. Nos. 89, 94, 151 & 152 of 2019)

This is a consolidated set of Rent Control Revision petitions under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, challenging eviction orders passed by the Rent Control Court (Munsiff), North Paravur and affirmed by the Rent Control Appellate Authority (Additional District Judge), North Paravur. The petitioners, tenants in multiple tenanted shop rooms, challenge the eviction on grounds of bonafide need by the landlord Sabha to demolish and construct an old-age home, contending that the second proviso to Section 11(3) is not satisfied and that the landlord has alternative vacant lands. The landlord argues the need is genuine, proximate to a hospital and public road, and backed by envisaged plans and governmental guidelines. The Rent Control Court held a detailed trial, concluding the need was bona fide and that the other two lands did not vitiate the eviction; the Appellate Authority affirmed. The petitioners contend lack of proper representation, non-fulfilment of the second proviso’s limbs, and issues related to fair rent proceedings. The High Court (Division Bench) undertook a consolidated re- examination, considering subsequent events and statutory guidelines, including provisions for elderly care homes and relevant rules and Government guidelines. The court ultimately remitted the cases to the Rent Control Court for a limited retrial to assess the feasibility of establishing an old-age home compliant with statutory requirements, with road widening considerations kept in view, and set aside eviction judgments while keeping the revision petitions allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C Nos.1017/2020; 1023/2020; 2751/2020; 2752/2020; 2753/2020; 2755/2020; 2757/2020; 2760/2020; 2762/2020; 2763/2020; 2796/2020; 2798/2020; 2801/2020; 2802/2020; 2803/2020

Priya Varma v. State of Kerala and S. Balachandraran and Parameel Balachandran and Sreeja V., PP

The Kerala High Court, in a batch of Criminal Miscellaneous Cases (CRL.M.C. Nos. 1017/2020, 1023/2020 and connected), disposed of petitions challenging cognate proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The petitioner Priya Varma, the accused in several small-town prosecutions against a firm, was accused based on cheques allegedly issued by the firm to respondent Balachandran. The core issue is whether the complaint is sustainable when the cheque was drawn on a bank account maintained by a firm that is not a party to the complaint. The court relies on settled law that a complaint under NI Act is not maintainable if the drawer is a firm and the firm is not a party to the complaint, citing Aneeta Hada and Others v. M/s. Godfather Travels & Tours Pvt. Ltd. and Others, Velayudhan Pillai S. v. Chellath Franklin and Another, and Indira Gandhi Memorial General Marketing Society Ltd. (K-900) v. Roys Abraham and Another. The proceedings arose from a settlement mediated within the Kerala High Court Mediation Centre, with cheques issued as part of the settlement; some cheques were honoured, others dishonoured, and an inadvertent omission led to the firm not being impleaded. The court stayed and ultimately quashed the prosecutions on technical grounds, while leaving civil remedies available, and directed exclusion of stay time from limitation in any civil action.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos. 3802/2023 and 3820/2023

W.P.(C) Nos. 3802 & 3820 of 2023

These two connected writ petitions challenge the exclusion of the petitioners from intra-college competitions conducted by St. Albert's College, Ernakulam and Union Christian College, Aluva, respectively, and their consequent disqualification from the Mahatma Gandhi University Youth Festival scheduled in February 2023. The petitioners argued that they performed better than the first prize winners at the college level and that depriving them of first place and participation in the inter-collegiate festival is illegal and arbitrary; past A grades do not entitle them to automatic top rank, and the marks awarded by the judges should reflect merit on the day of the event. The University and colleges countered that intra-college events are internal assessments designed to identify college representatives; judges’ evaluations are inherently subjective, and mere differences in perception cannot be a ground for interference under Article 226 of the Constitution. The court surveyed jurisprudence, notably Rhomy Chandra Mohan, Sweety, and Devna Sumesh, reaffirming that judicial review cannot re-weigh merits absent gross illegality, mala fides, or perversity, and that appellate/disciplinary bodies’ decisions shall be treated as conclusive. Ultimately, the court dismissed the petitions but directed administrative measures to prevent mishaps in Kalolsavams and emphasised healthy competition over winning at all costs.

High Court of Kerala
CRP Nos.48, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56, 64, 66, 68 & 73 of 2021

Maya Venu vs Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd

This batch of Civil Revision Petitions arises from the Power Grid Corporation's construction of 400 kV transmission lines over private properties and the consequent claims for compensation for damages. The revision petitioners challenge the dismissal of their petitions by the District Court on the ground of limitation under Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963, arguing that compensation for both the value of trees cut and diminution in land value was due and that the right to seek such compensation accrues on the occurrence of the last damage or upon inadequate compensation, not simply from the date of tree-cutting. They contend that Government orders and schemes, including ex gratia payments in 2017-2018 and subsequent packages, did not extinguish their statutory rights to full compensation under the Telegraph Act, 1885, particularly Section 16(3). The respondents maintain that the 2017-2018 ex gratia payments were not compensation and that the three-year period began from the initial act of cutting, and thus the petitions were time-barred. The Kerala High Court, relying on decisions under the Indian Telegraph Act and precedent on accrual of rights to sue, holds that the right to apply accrues with the last act causing damage or when compensation proves to be inadequate, and that the petitions were filed within time. The court allows the petitions, sets aside the impugned orders, and remits the matters for merits to the District Court.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos. 2676 of 2023 and 3501 of 2023

W.P.(C) Nos. 2676 of 2023 and 3501 of 2023 - Viswa Hindu Parishad v State of Kerala and others; T.B. Sajeevan v State of Kerala and others

These consolidated writ petitions challenge the leasing of Aluva Sivarathri Manappuram, a Devasom land adjoining the Aluva Mahadeva Temple, for a commercial trade fair during Sivarathri 2023. In W.P.(C) No.2676 of 2023, petitioners Viswa Hindu Parishad and Hindu Aikya Veedi contend that the land is under the control of the Travancore Devaswom Board and the Aluva Municipality has no authority to lease it for a fair; they seek a declaration that the Manappuram belongs to Aluva Mahadeva Temple and an account of income from leasing for the last 30 years. They rely on 1961 State records and a 2018 judgment directing land use, urging that the land beyond 11.70 acres (as per older records) should be treated as Devaswom property. In W.P.(C) No.3501 of 2023, devotees urge compliance with Ext.P1 (common 2018 judgment) and extend religious use, invoking the Public Trust Doctrine and environmental considerations; they challenge the Ext.P3 agreement (18.01.2023) between the Aluva Municipality and the 6th respondent threatening religious activities and adjoining environmental interests. The State and local authorities argue the tender covers land outside Devaswom bounds or requires state-level decision. The Court, after hearing, directs strict compliance with the directions in paragraph 39 of the 2022 DBP No.6 order and disposes of the petitions with directions, while leaving merits open to future challenge.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NOS. 3766 OF 2022; 3834 OF 2022; 2729 OF 2022

Renjith v. State of Kerala; Anoop v. State of Kerala; Sujin G.S alias Sunil G S v. State of Kerala

Three connected bail petitions under Section 439 CrPC were heard together before a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court (Honourable Justice Gopinath P.) on 13 July 2022. The petitioners—Renjith, Anoop, and Sujin G.S alias Sunil G S—were involved in Crime No. 5/2021 of the Kattakkada Excise Range Office, Thiruvananthapuram, and sought regular bail citing prolonged custody (approximately 281 days total), completion of investigation, and absence of criminal antecedents, arguing that there was no justifiable reason to continue detention. The State, through the Public Prosecutor, opposed bail, relying on NDPS Act provisions. It contended that Section 37 of the NDPS Act requires reasonable grounds to believe the accused are not guilty, and that even where contraband is not recovered, the rigour of Section 37 applies; it also noted that Sections 27A and 29 of the NDPS Act may apply to those involved in financing the drug trade. The court observed that there was no change in circumstances since the earlier denials of bail, and ultimately declined to grant bail in all three petitions, aligning with the position that Section 37 requires cautious consideration of bail in NDPS cases. Appendices include annexures and references to prior orders. The final disposition: bail petitions dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No. 425 of 2022

Nadeera P.A. v. State of Kerala and Others

The petitioner, Nadeera P.A., a Senior Grade Scientific Assistant in the Agricultural Development and Farmers Welfare Department, challenged before the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (OA 1279/2020) an order dated 13.04.2022 denying her promotion to Assistant Soil Chemist. The tribunal found that the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) excluded her from the select list for the reason that she did not have 15 years of total service in the Scientific Assistant category across all three grades, after accounting for a long Leave Without Allowance (LWA) taken abroad from 17.07.2006 to 12.04.2013. The Recruitment Rules require 15 years of total service in the category for promotion by promotion to Assistant Soil Chemist, with the 15 years to include all three grades. The petitioner contended that the period of LWA should count as service under KSR provisions, and that the lien purpose allows continuation of service, so the extension of LWA should not bar promotion. The Tribunal held that, once LWA is excluded, the petitioner would not meet the 15 years; Appendix XIIC of Part I KSR states that during leave, service benefits are lost and promotions events tied to seniority are affected, so the leave period cannot be counted. The High Court affirmed the Tribunal’s view, citing Abdul Rasak, M.M. Thomas and Shaji Sanjay Nottitthodi (FB). The OP(KAT) is dismissed, and the tribunal’s order is upheld.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 1218 OF 2023

Nandu, Akshai Kumar, Ananthu A.S. v. State of Kerala

This is an anticipatory bail petition under Section 438 CrPC filed by accused Nos.1–3 in Crime No.101/2023 of Pozhiyoor Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, before the Kerala High Court. The matter was heard on 22 February 2023 by a Single Judge. The prosecution alleges that on 30 January 2023 the accused restrained, abused and caused hurt and grievous hurt to the complainant, with specific allegations that the 2nd accused kicked the lower abdomen, the 3rd accused restrained him, and the 1st accused struck the complainant on the head with an iron rod, resulting in a nasal bone fracture and other injuries. Offences under Sections 341, 323, 324, 326 and 506 read with Section 34 of the IPC are alleged. The petitioners claim the allegations are false and that the defacto complainant, a Branch Secretary of CPI(M), has maliciously implicated them; they contend prior incidents on 29 January 2023 and 2 February 2023 show the complainant’s conduct and that the petitioners are innocent and willing to cooperate with investigation. The Public Prosecutor counters with medical records showing the nasal fracture and other injuries, arguing custodial interrogation and weapon recovery are necessary. The court refused anticipatory bail for the 1st accused, but granted bail to the 2nd and 3rd accused subject to several conditions, including surrender within 10 days, bonds, and ongoing cooperation, with strict undertakings to refrain from intimidation and further offences.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 8216/22

Khaledur Rahman v. State of Kerala (Bail Application)

This Kerala High Court bail application concerns Khaledur Rahman, accused of kidnapping and rape of a minor, who seeks regular bail on the ground that he validly married the victim under Muslim personal law. The victim, a West Bengal girl born 16 December 2006, was about 15 years 8 months at the time of the FIR, and the prosecution alleges abduction and repeated penetrative sexual assaults leading to pregnancy. The petitioner argues that the marriage was valid under Mahomedan law and that such marriages below 18 years are legally permissible, so POCSO offences should not attach; he emphasizes family support during her pregnancy and contends that detention is unnecessary given their marital relation. The Public Prosecutor counters that the victim’s age makes her a child under the POCSO Act; even if a marriage occurred, the POCSO Act, being a special statute, overrides personal law, with Section 42A clarifying that the Act is in addition to, and not derogatory of, other laws. The court discusses the conflict between personal law and the POCSO Act, cites maxims and cases on interpreting conflicting provisions, and ultimately holds that the very marriage alleged cannot shield the accused from POCSO scrutiny. Considering the ongoing investigation and the minor’s age, the court denies bail and dismisses the application.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No.859 of 2023

Jithuraj v. State of Kerala

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No.859 of 2023) before the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam concerns the accused, Jithuraj, in Crime No. 447/2022 registered at Pantheerankavu Police Station, Kozhikode, facing charges under sections 283, 440 and 308 IPC. The petition seeks quashing under Section 482 CrPC on the basis that the parties have amicably settled their disputes and do not wish to pursue prosecution, supported by Annexure-3 affidavit of the third respondent. The Investigating Officer was directed to verify the settlement and assess any impediments to terminating proceedings or the accused’s criminal antecedents. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations, noting that quashing should not be invoked in cases involving heinous offences or special statutes, and should be guided by prior Supreme Court rulings. The High Court engaged in a detailed discussion of the law governing the use of 482 CrPC in private, non-compoundable offences where settlements occur, citing State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, among others, to lay down a framework (paras 15.1–15.5). The court ultimately held that the inherent jurisdiction can be exercised to quash such proceedings where the dispute is settled and public interest is not implicated, while cautioning against quashing in serious crimes. Result: the petition is allowed; the Final Report in Crime No. 447/2022 and all further proceedings in CP No. 52/2022 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
Tr.P (C)No.448/2020 and Tr.P(Crl)No.30/2021

P.K. Sreekumari v. Arul P. Sugathan

The judgment is a common order disposing of two transfer petitions arising from marital discord between P.K. Sreekumari (wife) and Arul P. Sugathan (husband). Tr.P(C) No.448/2020 seeks transfer of OP No.492/2020 from the Family Court, Ettumanoor, to the Family Court, Thrissur, where maintenance proceedings are ongoing (MC 377/2020). Tr.P(Crl) No.30/2021 seeks transfer of MC 377/2020 from Thrissur to Ettumanoor. The Court notes the marriage was solemnised in Thrissur and the petitioner wife resides in Cherpu, Thrissur, while the maintenance case is in Ettumanoor (123 km away). The respondent contends illness (paranoid schizophrenia) and lack of an escort; medical certificates are discussed, but the Court ultimately finds the respondent capable of travel and grants liberty to seek dispensation of personal appearance if needed. Relying on established jurisprudence (Sumitha Sing v. Kumar Sanjay; Mona Aresh Goel; Vaishali Shridhar Jagtap; Santhini Vijaya Venkatesh; N.C.V Aishwarya), the Court emphasizes the convenience of the woman/children and the goal of consolidating proceedings to avoid multiplicity and save judicial time. The result is a selective disposition: TrP(Crl) No.30/2021 is dismissed; Tr.P(C) No.448/2020 is allowed, transferring OP 492/2020 to Thrissur; records are to be transmitted; Thrissur will post MC 377/2020 with OP 492/2020, with discretion to dispensation requests. The decision under Sec.24 CPC reflects the court’s broad supervisory powers to consolidate matrimonial litigations.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) No.581 of 2022

Arafath Aboobacker v. Afreen Arafath

This High Court of Kerala, in exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution, reviews Ext.P5 (16.09.2022) of the Family Court, Kannur in I.A.No.2 of 2022 in O.P.No.25 of 2021, which directed the petitioner-father to hand over the minor Aman Arafath’s original passport, birth certificate, Aadhar card, and marriage certificate to the respondent-mother. The child, aged about seven, is the subject of custody proceedings between the father (petitioner) and the mother (respondent). The Family Court had earlier granted visitation rights to the father; the mother sought documents on account of her intention to go abroad with the child, allegedly for employment. The petitioner contended that the order unjustly facilitates a unilateral relocation and undermines ongoing custody considerations; the mother argued that she would not take the child abroad without proper orders and the documents were needed for travel with safeguards. The Court examined the scope of Article 227, citing Shalini Shyam Shetty, Jai Singh, K.V.S. Ram, and Sobhana Nair K.N., and held that supervisory jurisdiction is limited and not appellate, and that the Family Court’s order was not perverse or illegal. Consequently, the petition is dismissed, with directions for the mother to file an affidavit within a week pledging not to take the child abroad without Family Court permission, upholding the child’s welfare as paramount.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.No.403 of 2022

State of Kerala represented by Secretary, General Education Department, Government Secretariat, Thiruvananthapuram; Director of General Education; Regional Director of Higher Secondary Education, Thiruvananthapuram v. P. Radhamani and Manager, Higher Secondary School, Thiruvampady

This writ appeal arises from a dispute over entitlement to full-time Higher Secondary School Teacher (HSST) pay scales under Ext. P3 by a transferee who began as HS A (Maths) and was posted as HSST (Jr.) (Maths) from 25 July 2001, prior to the Kerala Special Rules coming into force. The appellant (State of Kerala and education authorities) challenges the decision of the learned Single Judge, which quashed Ext. P9 and directed reconsideration of the petitioner’s claim for the benefit of Ext. P3. The petitioner, Radhamani, contends that she, as an approved HSST (Jr.) appointed by transfer between 13 May 1998 and 12 November 2001, is entitled to the full-time HSST benefit under Ext. P3, even though the Special Rules were notified later. The respondents rely on Dolichan v. State of Kerala (2001) 1 SCC 151 to insist that statutory rules govern service conditions and government orders cannot override them once statutory rules exist. The court traces the policy shift under Ext. P12 (25:75 quota) and the Krishnankutty decision upholding that quota, while also recognizing the Moothedath dictum limiting clubbing of posts. Ultimately, the Division Bench disposes of the appeal with directions to reconsider the petitioner’s claim untrammelled by Ext. P8 and the impugned judgment, assess whether Ext. P12 quota applies, and decide in accordance with the Manager, Moothedath ruling, closing interlocutory matters.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5578 OF 2024

Siyad v. State of Kerala

This bail application before the Kerala High Court concerns Siyad, the sole accused in Crime No.681 of 2024 at Karunagapally Police Station, Kollam. The petition seeks bail under Section 483 BNSS 2023 arguing innocence and asserting that the allegations under IPC Sections 326 and 307, in particular, are not substantiated, and that those offences were added to deny bail. The matter has been pending since 04.05.2024 with the accused in judicial custody for 91 days; the investigation is not complete and the final report has not been laid. The prosecution contends the petitioner is a habitual offender with six prior similar crimes and warns that bail could lead to witness intimidation and tampering. The court recalls the 02.05.2024 attack in which the informant suffered grievous injuries, including the loss of his right forefinger, and notes the procedural framework under Section 167(1)-(2) CrPC governing detention beyond 24 hours when investigation cannot be completed, including the indefeasible right to statutory bail after prescribed periods if the investigation remains incomplete. Relying on Uday Mohanlal Acharya v. State of Maharashtra and Sanjay Dutt v. State (supra), the court holds the petitioner is entitled to statutory bail. The bail is granted on Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, and subject to monitoring and conduct conditions, including weekly appearances and non-interference with witnesses; Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) is cited regarding bail conditions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 8853 of 2021

Poruvazhy Service Co-operative Bank Limited v. Kerala Lok Ayukta and Others

This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution concerns a complaint filed by Thankachan G., respondent No.2, before the Kerala Lokayukta (Complaint No.72 of 2019) alleging misappropriation from the Poruvazhy Service Co-operative Bank (the petitioner). The Lokayukta initiated proceedings and, on 02.12.2020, observed that the complainant faced a large outstanding loan liability and that action was being taken under Sections 65 and 68(1) of the Lokayukta Act. On 19.03.2021, the Lokayukta directed the bank’s Secretary not to disburse any payment to others until Rs.1,50,000 was paid to the complainant and noted an inflow of funds to the bank, prompting a lump-sum disbursement. The petitioner bank challenged these interim directions, arguing that the Lokayukta lacks power to issue binding orders and that the directions would prejudice other depositors. The High Court, while considering objections, set aside the impugned interim order, stating that the Lokayukta should dispose of the complaint expeditiously after giving hearing to all parties. It relied on prior decisions that Lokayukta actions are recommendations rather than binding directives. The court directed the Lokayukta to proceed in accordance with law, while closing interim applications. The petition was thus allowed, with directions to finalize the matter promptly within due process.