This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA No.1823 of 2008 (A)) filed by the appellant, T.K. Rahim, challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam’s award in OP(MV) 3598/1999 dated 12 December 2006. The accident occurred on 9 July 1999 on the Aluva-Ernakulam road when Rahim’s motorcycle was struck by a scooter owned by the first respondent, allegedly due to negligence of the driver. The Tribunal partly allowed the petition, awarding a total compensation of Rs. 20,000 but reducing it to Rs. 10,000 after holding the claimant 50% contributory negligent. Rahim challenged this quantum and the contributory negligence finding. During hearing, the High Court examined Exts. A1–A3 and A7–A8 (police reports and scene evidence) and observed that the accident was primarily due to the 1st respondent’s negligence. It rejected the 50% contributory negligence finding, holding the appellant not liable in negligence. The judge recalibrated the compensation formula, adopting a notional monthly income of Rs. 4,000 (in light of Ramachandrappa and Syed Sadiq), and verified disability first via Ext A9 (15%), later accepting Ext C1 (2%) as a later report but retaining 15% disability for calculation. The final order enhances compensation to Rs. 1,70,700 with 6% interest from the petition date and proportionate costs, directing deposit before the Tribunal.
F.A.O. Nos. 215 of 2008 & 236 of 2014 These are two connected appeals filed under Order XLIII Rule 1(d) CPC challenging the common interlocutory orders dated 03.07.2008 in I.A. Nos. 2313 and 2314 of 2005 in O.S. No. 173 of 1997, before the I Additional Sub Court, Thiruvananthapuram. The appellant Nithya, the 1st defendant, seeks to set aside or review the ex parte decree in the suit for specific performance of a contract for sale. The primary contention is that she did not receive proper summons and that the agreement for sale was purportedly backed by a forged power of attorney executed by her father; she maintained that she and her husband lived at different places due to employment changes, which caused delay in filing the applications under Order IX Rule 13 and 28(3) of the Specific Relief Act. The respondents contend that summons were served, and that the delay was neither justified nor excusable. The High Court examines delay-condonation principles under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, citing Katiji and Esha Bhattacharjee for a liberal-but-not-unfettered approach, and relies on Rafeek v. K. Kamarudeen to reiterate the need for reasonableness and fairness. It finds the delay of 3 years 75 days inordinate, notes that the explanation is unsupported, and holds that the statutory bar and the conduct of the parties justify dismissing the appeals. The appeals are thus dismissed.
The appellant, Bimal Bhaskar, filed MACA No.976/2013 challenging the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Ernakulam’s dismissal of his O.P. (MV) No.1281/2003 for compensation following a motor accident on 14.08.2002. The petitioner, an electrical/electronic mechanic aged about 21 with claimed monthly income of Rs 5,000, sustained injuries and disability, and sought compensation for loss of earnings, medical expenses, pain, and loss of amenities. The 2nd respondent insurer admitted the policy but contested negligence and quantum. The Tribunal’s order rested largely on Ext. A4, the final police report, which implicated the appellant as an accused, though Exts. A13–A14 and eyewitness testimony in the criminal case suggested a different sequence of events. The High Court re-examined the evidence and noted contra materials, including the appellant’s cross-examination and the criminal court depositions, which challenged the sole reliance on the police report. It held that some negligence by the appellant could not be ruled out, and 50% contributory negligence should be apportioned to the appellant, with the remaining 50% on the first respondent. The court then recalculated quantum using Rs 3,500 per month as income (instead of Rs 5,000) and a 12% disability, awarding Rs 1,81,199 in total and directing the insurer to deposit Rs 90,660 with 7.5% interest, while excluding interest for the delay period."
The petitioner, Sathyananth.K.R., asserts that he served as a Lab Assistant at the LBS Centre for Science and Technology, Kozhikode, from 1995 on a daily-wage/contract basis, with earlier regular extensions up to 15 December 2007. He kept applying for leave extensions (15.12.2007 to 14.04.2008) and sought reinstatement or regularisation through several representations from 2011 to 2020, citing a Scheme of Regularisation for contract employees and a comparator, Sri Nazeer A., who obtained regularisation. The respondents contended that the petitioner only worked until 15.12.2007, never rejoined after leaving, and there is no record showing that his later representations were received or acted upon; at least one representation was addressed, and the petitioner chose not to pursue legal remedies for over a decade. The court notes the settled legal position that repeated representations do not create new or vested rights, particularly where no statutory remedy exists for a contract employee seeking reinstatement or regularisation. Nonetheless, the court is persuaded to afford a limited, discretionary opportunity: the petitioner may make a comprehensive representation to the Director of the LBS Centre within one month from the judgment, so that the second respondent can consider it under the extant scheme (Exts.P9, P10). The writ petition is allowed to that limited extent, without creating any vested right.
Radhakrishnan, the revision petitioner, was convicted under the Abkari Act for transporting illicit spirit on 21.3.2002, and was sentenced to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 with a default of six months’ imprisonment. The 2nd accused was acquitted. On appeal, the Principal Sessions Court confirmed the conviction but reduced the sentence to one year’s simple imprisonment while maintaining the fine. The revision petition contends that the prosecution failed to prove guilt beyond reasonable doubt due to serious lacunae in the chain of custody and the lack of proper specimen sealing on Ext.P1 seizure mahazar; there is no description of the seal or its affixation on the sample bottle, and the evidence does not establish that the sample analyzed in the laboratory was the same sample seized. It also points to unexplained delays: the occurrence was in 2002 while the final report was filed in 2004 and the analysis report dated 25.4.2002 was not reconciled with the filing. The High Court, while acknowledging its limited revisional scope, emphasized strict compliance with Abkari Act formalities and cited Baburaj v. State of Kerala and Sathi v. State of Kerala to underscore that presumption of regular official acts under Section 114(e) of the Evidence Act cannot cure such defects. After reviewing the evidence and the authorities, the court held that the prosecution failed to establish the link between seizure and analysis beyond reasonable doubt and allowed the revision petition, acquitting the petitioner.
The revision petitioner, Rajesh, was the accused in S.C. No. 144 of 2006 before the Asst. Sessions Judge, Alappuzha, charged under Section 55(i) of the Kerala Abkari Act for allegedly selling Indian Made Foreign Liquor. On 28-10-2004, around 2 PM, authorities allegedly found him in possession of 3.650 litres of aristocratic XXX rum. The trial court convicted him to three months’ simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with an alternate 45-day term in default. The First Appellate Court upheld the conviction and sentence. In the CRL.R.P., Rajesh challenges the conviction on grounds that Ext P3 seizure mahazar lacks a specimen seal, description of the seal, and a forwarding note; no specimen seal is affixed, and the forwarding note is not produced. He argues these deficiencies undermine the chain of custody and tamper-proof handling of the sample, essential for lab analysis. The High Court reviews the matter, recognizing that strict compliance with Abkari Act formalities is necessary given the Act’s harsh penalties. Citing Baburaj, Sathi, Vijayan, Nadarajan, Gopalan, Prakasan, Ramachandran, Moothedath Sivadasan, Sasidharan and other authorities, the court emphasizes the need for seal impressions, forwarding notes, and proper linkage between seized samples and laboratory results. Finding fatal lacunae in the link evidence, the court allows the revision petition, acquitting Rajesh and ordering release; bail, if any, is cancelled and refunds directed where applicable.
CON.CASE(C) NO.724 OF 2021 Cont.Case (C) No.724 of 2021 arises from WP(C) No.30990/2016 and connected matters, filed as a contempt petition under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 by petitioners 14, 45, 50 and 68 against the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO). The petitioners allege willful disobedience of Annexure A1, the High Court of Kerala’s judgment dated 12.10.2018 in WP(C) No.30990/2016 and connected matters. The Supreme Court’s 4.11.2022 decision in Civil Appeals Nos.8143-8144 of 2022, and connected matters, in Employees Provident Fund Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B., held the 2014 G.S.R.609(E) notification to be legal and valid, and read down certain scheme provisions for present members. The Kerala High Court notes this authoritative ruling and directs that EPFO reconsider the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension in light of the Apex Court’s directions, undertaking the exercise in accordance with law. The court closes the contempt proceeding, but preserves EPFO’s right to reconsider entitlement under the 2022 judgment. The judgment cites related precedents, endorses certain views from RC Gupta, and reiterates the exercise of jurisdiction under Article 142 if necessary, with time-bound directives for implementation and adjustment within the pension scheme framework.
RFA No. 429 of 2007 & CO No. 26 of 2008 This is a Kerala High Court Regular First Appeal (RFA 429/2007) and Cross Objection (CO 26/2008) arising from O.S. 342/1997, concerning partition of ancestral family properties of Vasudeva Shenoy and related claims to a share of profits from partnership assets. The sole plaintiff, A.V. Mithra Devi, claims 1/3 share as a Class I heir under the Hindu Succession Act and asserts rights in plaint A, C, D, E and F schedules, including rights in Shenoy Chambers and assets of the D20 partnership firm. The trial court partly decreed and held Ext.B4 Will to be forged, while denying portions of the partition and profits claims. Defendants/appellants contested, challenging the Will’s genuineness, the existence or availability of several properties for partition, and the applicability of Section 37 of the Indian Partnership Act to grant profits to a representative of a deceased partner. The High Court, on 12-01-2021, after hearing, held that Section 37 provides temporary relief in ongoing partnership matters and is not a permanent remedy in partition, allowed the appeal in part, and modified the preliminary decree to grant 1/3 shares in select assets (A schedule items 2 and 4, and D20 assets) and in related revenues (Shenoy Chambers) with fixed interest and profits, while leaving certain questions to final decree proceedings. The cross-objections were dismissed; final decree to determine quantum and availability of assets was directed.
WP(C) Nos. 37635 of 2022 and 4428 of 2023 These two connected writ petitions challenge actions within the General Education Department concerning leadership appointments and disciplinary actions at VPM Higher Secondary School, Vellarada. In WP(C) 37635 of 2022, the petitioner I. Bindu, a retired teacher-in-charge, seeks mandamus to compel the Government to disqualify the manager (5th respondent) and to appoint the petitioner as Headmistress with effect from 01/04/2019 to 31/05/2022. In WP(C) 4428 of 2023, the Manager of VPM Higher Secondary School questions Ext.P28 and Ext.P30 orders and prays for quashing and for consideration of Ext.P31, along with mandamus directing the 1st respondent to decide Ext.P31 promptly. The petitions are connected; the court disposes of them by a common judgment. The judge directs the 1st respondent to consider Ext.P31 in WP(C) 4428 within two months from receipt of a copy of the judgment and to issue appropriate orders, with notice to petitioners. Depending on the Ext.P31 decision, the Manager is to take steps in accordance with law, and petitioners must furnish certified copies of the judgment for compliance. The order embodies a time-bound task to resolve the leadership dispute and ensure due process in school governance.
Aliyamma George, the appellant, challenged a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (Kottayam) order that dismissed her claim for compensation on the ground that the appellant was a spouse riding as a pillion on the motorcycle driven by the first respondent. The accident occurred on 24 April 2006 when the vehicle attempted to overtake an autorickshaw on the Thripunithura–Karimukal road near Ambalamukal; the appellant suffered a crush injury to the left foot, amputation of the fifth toe, injury to the third and fourth toes, and underwent inpatient treatment for ten days. She claimed Rs 1,36,500 against the owner and insurer; the tribunal dismissed the petition, holding the appellant not entitled to compensation since the rider was her husband. On appeal, the High Court held that the husband’s status does not bar recovery; citing National Insurance Ltd. v. Balakrishnan and Sajad Saheer v. Rajeev, it held that a pillion rider is entitled to compensation under a comprehensive policy, and the insurer is liable to indemnify. The High Court re-fixed the appellant’s notional income at Rs 4,500 per month and recalculated heads of compensation, resulting in a total award of Rs 77,110 with interest at 6% from the date of petition to deposit in two months. The appeal was allowed in part.
MACA No. 1359/2018; OP(MV) No. 133/2017 Subin Manjush C.J., the appellant, challenged the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal's award in OP(MV) No.133/2017 arising from a motorcycle accident on 14 June 2016, which left him with a 42% permanent disability and an amputation below the knee at age 19. The tribunal held the insured negligent and directed the insurer to pay ₹41,71,520 with 6% interest. The appellant argued that the tribunal undervalued his future earning capacity and that the income figure used (₹72,000 per annum) was grossly inadequate, failing to reflect his meritorious studies and restricted career options due to disability. He urged application of the Pranay Sethi principle to include loss of future prospects, citing Pappu Deo Yadav v. Naresh Kumar (2020) and National Insurance Co. v. K.K. Assainar (2019) as supportive authorities. The insurer opposed increasing compensation, denying negligence and disputing the quantum. The High Court found the income figure too low and, considering the appellant’s age and 42% disability, fixed a monthly income of ₹12,000 and adopted the 40% future-prospects enhancement under Pranay Sethi, recalculating the permanent disability compensation. It also allowed ₹4,00,000 for maintenance of the artificial limb and ₹2,00,000 for future treatment. Consequently, the appeal was allowed in part and disposed of with enhanced sums and directions for deposit and payment by the insurer.
The appellant, Smt. C. H. Sameera, challenges Ext. P9, an order dated 19.11.2020 of the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO), Kasaragod, which rejected her Form 6 application for change of land use and directed inclusion of portions of her land in the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. She had previously submitted Exhibit P6 on 10.11.2017 under clause 6 of the Kerala Land Utilization Order, 1967, seeking permission to use paddy land for non-agricultural purposes. The writ petition W.P.(C) No. 38853 of 2017 was disposed of by this Court on 05.01.2018 directing the RDO to consider Exhibit P6 and pass orders within six weeks; subsequently, the RDO disposed Exhibit P9 in 2020. The petitioner contends that the RDO’s power to include land in the Data Bank was not available at the time and that pre-amendment law should govern such applications; she preferred certiorari or mandamus to direct reconsideration of Exhibit P6. The learned Single Judge dismissed the petition, noting an available statutory remedy under Section 27B of the 2008 Act. This Division Bench, relying on Tahsildar, Thodupuzha Taluk v. Renjith George, holds that Section 27A’s effect is prospective from 30.12.2017; pre-cutoff applications fall under Clause 6 of the L.U.O. 1967, and thus allows the appeal, quashes Ext. P9, and directs reconsideration within three months.
This Kerala High Court judgment, delivered by a Division Bench (S. V. Bhatti, J. and Basant Balaji, J.) on 17 February 2023, concerns OP (CAT) No.6/2015 (and OA 607/2013 of the CAT Ernakulam Bench). The original petition challenged the CAT order that had allowed the pension claim of the 1st applicant, N. Chandran Asari, who served for long as an Extra-Departmental Agent and later in Group D, asserting that his ED A service should be counted toward the qualifying service for pension and that arrears should be paid. The CAT had directed the respondents to sanction pension by treating the applicant as having completed the minimum qualifying service of 10 years from retirement and to pay arrears within three months. The Kerala High Court, however, set aside the CAT order, applying the Gandiba Behera principle, and held that the CT’s conclusions cannot be sustained. The judgment directs the parties to approach for relaxation under Rule 88 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, with Krishnamma T. given liberty to pursue such relaxation on behalf of the deceased 1st applicant within four weeks, and the exercise to be completed within four months. Annexure A9 is also set aside. The matter is ordered to be reconsidered in light of Gandiba Behera, with full sympathetic consideration for pension, within the specified timeframe.
Subhish B Nair v. State of Kerala is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC filed by the sole accused challenging quashing of proceedings arising from Palakkad Judicial Magistrate First Class-I CC No.471/2021 and Walayar Police Station Crime No.781/2020. The accused faced charges under IPC Sections 341, 323 and 324 for an incident dated 25 December 2020. The petitioner contends that the parties have amicably settled their disputes, supported by an affidavit from the injured/defacto complainant, and undertakes no further grievances; the investigating officer was directed to verify genuineness of the settlement and antecedents, if any. The Public Prosecutor initially raised reservations about quashing solely on settlement, though no other complaints or transgressions against the accused were alleged. The court relied on established jurisprudence (State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and related Supreme Court decisions) to evaluate whether inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC can quash non-compoundable offences where the civil/private nature of the dispute and its settlement mitigate societal impact. After weighing gravity of offences, injuries, antecedents, and relationship, the court found quashing appropriate to promote peace and ends of justice, and thus allowed the petition, quashing Annexure-1 Final Report and all further proceedings in CC 471/2021.
OP (RC) Nos. 74 of 2023 & 83 of 2023 The Kerala High Court, in a combined hearing of OP (RC) Nos. 74 of 2023 and 83 of 2023, addressed petitions seeking directions to dispose of Rent Control Petitions (RCPs) pending in Ernakulam and Chavakkad courts. Presiding judges A.K. Jayasankaran Nambiar and Mohammed Nias C.P. Monday noted massive pendency: thousands of original suits, RCPs, execution petitions, and related matters, with a significant number more than five years old. The Court observed that despite earlier orders and attempts to expedite proceedings, backlogs persist, necessitating judicial oversight. Citing Shiju Joy.A. and Others v. Nisha (2023 (2) KLT 193) and related family-court jurisprudence, the Court underscored that out-of-turn disposal can undermine equal treatment and fairness. It recalled Section 24 of the Rent Control Act, which aims for timely final orders where practicable (four months from appearance). The order directs Rent Control Courts and Appellate Authorities to process applications for early hearing expeditiously (within two weeks) after proper justification, to pass brief speaking orders, and to respect the normal queue unless exceptional reasons justify departure. Accordingly, the petitions are closed, without prejudice to the petitioners’ right to pursue the prescribed applications, and registry directives are issued for compliance by the lower forums."
This is an appeal under Order XLIII, Rule 1(d) CPC challenging an ex parte decree in O.S. No. 6 of 2008 for specific performance of an agreement for sale. The respondents filed a suit seeking specific performance of an agreement for sale valued at Rs 7,50,000, with Rs 4,00,000 paid as advance. The suit was decreed ex parte on 20.09.2010 after the appellant did not attend and did not file a written statement. The appellant contends that she is a woman living in a remote village in Idukki district and was unable to obtain timely legal assistance or respond to service; she learned of the decree only upon receiving a notice for delivery. She moved I.A. Nos. 64 and 65 of 2011 seeking to set aside the ex parte decree and to condone the delay of 93 days. The Sub Court Thodupuzha did not accept her reasons and dismissed the applications. The High Court, applying liberal principles from Katiji and Esha Bhattacharjee, held that a short, 93‑day delay in such circumstances can be condoned with due regard to justice, especially when the subject matter concerns a residential building and the appellant is a woman living in rural conditions. The appeal was allowed, with a cost order, and the matter was directed to be restored for further proceedings.
This Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA 388/20) from Kerala High Court challenges the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Vatakara’s award in OP(MV)482/2017, arising from a road accident on 17.01.2017 that left the deceased, a highly qualified management professional, dead. The appellants, the father and mother and two siblings of the deceased, contend that the Tribunal erred in notional income fixation for the deceased; they sought Rs.20,000 per month (supported by Ext. A5 employment certificate) and claimed the Tribunal erred in reducing it to Rs.12,000, with a further claim for Loss of Consortium (Rs.40,000 per head, citing Pranay Sethi). The Insurance Company opposed Ext. A5 as uncorroborated, arguing lack of supporting witnesses; the Tribunal’s reliance on Exts. A6 and A7 established the deceased’s professional qualifications but not the Ext. A5 income claim. The Allahabad, Delhi, and Kerala precedent Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Insurance Co. Ltd. (2011) 13 SCC 236 is cited to justify a minimum notional income for unascertained earnings; the Court ultimately adopts Rs.15,000 as notional income, adds 40% as future prospects to reach Rs.21,000 per month, and revises Loss of Dependency to Rs.21,42,000, while deleting Loss of Love and Affection and granting Rs.80,000 for Loss of Consortium. The appeal is partly allowed with interest at 8% p.a. and proportional costs to be paid by the Insurance Company, after excluding 221 days for delay in filing the appeal.
This First Appeal from Order arises from O.P. No.2 of 2011 in the Subordinate Judge’s Court, Payyannur, filed under Section 92 CPC seeking leave to institute a suit challenging a deed transferring substantial immovable property held by the Rajeev Memorial Health and Educational Society, a public charitable trust-like body. The petitioners claim a trust existed prior to the society’s registration and that property was held in trust for public educational and welfare purposes; the respondents contend the society is not a trust and thus Section 92 CPC is inapplicable. The suit involved a one-hectare-plus property conveyed to a fourth respondent for a comparatively small sum, with no evident general-body consent for the sale. The Sub Judge’s order dated 23.03.2013 declined leave, citing earlier Kerala decisions (Amrithakumari v. Ramananthan; Abhaya v. Reheem) that mere registration under the Societies Registration Act cannot alter the character of property. The High Court, however, found the order cryptic and noted the pleadings require a thorough determination of whether a trust was created before or after registration. It set aside the order and remanded for fresh consideration of the Section 92 petition within three months, after providing an opportunity to both sides. The judgment emphasizes that leave under Section 92 CPC hinges on proving a trust creation or breach and that pleadings must be carefully evaluated to discern the true character of the property and the entity.”
This is a Kerala High Court revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 challenging the Rent Control Appellate Authority’s reversal of an eviction order against the tenant. The Rent Control Court had in R.C.P. No.129/2013 directed eviction under Section 11(4)(v) on the finding that the tenant ceased to occupy the petition premises for six months without reasonable cause following a license and sale of the building. The RCAA reversed that finding, accepting the tenant’s explanation for non-occupation. The revision petitioner contends that the RCC’s order and the evidence on record, including the advocate-commissioner reports (Exts. C1–C4) and documentary materials, establish cessation of occupation for more than six months without reasonable cause. The High Court, applying Section 20’s limited power, re-appraises the evidence to determine whether the appellate authority acted according to law. It notes that the first Ext. C1 report showed non-occupation; subsequent visits, bank/receipts, and lack of electricity bills could not sustain an ongoing business as claimed. The court emphasizes that “occupation” in rent statutes means actual use by the tenant or agents, not mere legal possession. It concludes that the RCC’s findings were correct and that the RCAA erred in interfering. The revision is allowed; the RCC’s order is restored with six months’ time to vacate, subject to undertaking and rent arrears payments.
This criminal miscellaneous petition, CRL.MC No. 2593 of 2023, arises from Crime No.425/2022 of Infopark Police Station, Ernakulam, where the sole accused, PRADEES MADHAVAN, faces multiple IPC allegations including sections 354, 354A(2)(I) r/w 354A(i)(ii), 509, 506(i), 376, 376(2)(k)(n) and 313. The matter is pending as SC No.10/2023 before the Additional District and Sessions Court (POCSO). The petitioner contends that the defacto complainant’s statement demonstrates the relationship with him was consensual and that Annexure A4, dated 16.10.2023, proves no rape or criminal intimidation occurred. The defacto complainant affirms the affidavit’s contents, stating a consensual relationship since 2019 and cohabitation in Bahrain and later in Kerala. The Public Prosecutor aligns with the complainant’s affidavit, while the counsel for the complainant confirms continued adherence to Annexure A4. The court considers precedents holding rape to be a heinous offence not quashable solely on settlement (Gian Singh; Laxmi Narayan) but also recognizes circumstances where quashing may be warranted—per Pramod Suryabhan Pawar, Shambhu Kharwar and Dhruvaram Sonar—based on the factual affidavits. On these grounds, the court allows the Crl.M.C. and quashes all further proceedings against the petitioner in Crime No.425/2022.