Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 501 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1971 of 2018

Sherin.R. v. Raveendra Varma, Kuruvila K. Thomas, Ajayakumar and The Branch Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd.

In a horrific accident on 12 December 2004, the motor-cycle rider Sherin R. was collided with a vehicle driven rashly and negligently, leaving him in a vegetative state and bed-bound. He pursued OP(MV) No.1221/2005 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Pathanamthitta seeking about Rs 19.51 lakh as compensation, which the Tribunal allowed only Rs 12,03,415. The appellant contends the Tribunal adopted an inappropriately low notional income and ignored Supreme Court guidance on compensating severely disabled claimants (Ramachandrappa; Rajani; Kajal; Jithendran; Abhimanyu Partap Singh) and appropriate heads of compensation. The appellant’s disability is 100% permanent per Exts. A15, yet his income prior to the accident was shown predominantly through Exts. A18–A20 (work as a plumber). The High Court re-evaluates the compensation by adopting a notional income of Rs 5,500 with 40% future prospects, applying a multiplier of 17 (Sarla Verma) due to the appellant’s age (26). It also awards Rs 5,000 per month for Attender charges (per Kajal), Rs 1,500 per month for medical articles, and increases pain/suffering and loss of amenities heads. The Court partly allows the appeal, enhancing disability compensation to Rs 15,70,800, Attender charges to Rs 10,20,000, medical articles to Rs 3,06,000, and pain/suffering and loss of amenities to Rs 1,00,000 and Rs 3,00,000 respectively, while keeping other Tribunal findings intact. The insurer must pay the enhanced sum with 7.5% interest and costs, depositing within two months.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1494 of 2012; MACA No. 774 of 2012

Dr. Ashalatha R. & Ors. v. Mammen Mathew & KSRTC

These MACA Nos arise from an order of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kottayam, in OP(MV) No.231/2008, concerning the death of Giresh B.B. in a motor accident on 06.11.2006, when his motorcycle was struck by KSRTC bus KL 15/5037. The claimants — the wife (Ashalatha R.), two minor children (Namitha A.G. and Nayana A.G.), and the mother (K.K. Santhakumari) — sought compensation for loss of dependency, funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of consortium. The Tribunal found negligence by the KSRTC driver (ex parte) and held the KSRTC liable to pay Rs.22,56,040 with interest at 7.5% p.a. The KSRTC challenged the quantum; the claimants sought enhancement. The High Court held that the deceased was a regular employee with a monthly income of Rs.19,670 (PW2, Ext.A16) and, applying the Pranay Sethi principles (30% addition for future prospects for a person in the 40–50 age bracket and the tax payable, after deductions), recomputed the annual income and dependency loss. The Court concluded an enhanced total dependency figure of Rs.31,27,298 and allowed an additional Rs.9,24,258 on that head. It also increased funeral and estate damages to Rs.15,000 each and enhanced loss of consortium to Rs.40,000 per claimant, adjusting the Rs.15,000 love‑and‑affection amount against this head in light of Satinder Kaur. The result is an additional Rs.10,79,258; the award was modified accordingly, with deposit within three months and offsetting the delay permitted for MACA 1494/2012.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO.2439 OF 2016

SAINUDDIN v. GEORGE THOMAS and THOMASKUTTY and THE UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal arising from an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, under the Motor Vehicles Act. The petitioner, Sainuddin, a fish merchant, sustained injuries on 15.09.2011 when a Tata Sumo (KL-04-AA-7881) collided with his bicycle. The Tribunal held the accident occurred due to the driver’s negligence and exonerated the insurer (The United India Insurance Co. Ltd) on the ground that the vehicle had been converted to a contract carriage and the insurer’s policy had been obtained for a private car, amounting to suppression of material facts, thereby voiding the contract. Consequently, the Tribunal awarded Rs. 4,26,800 with 8% interest and directed joint liability on the owner and driver, with insurer absolved of liability. The High Court, however, examined the policy transfer (Ext.B1), the vehicle’s conversion to contract carriage (02.09.2011) and accident date (15.09.2011), and held that Section 149(2)(b) did not render the policy void because suppression of material facts was not established as to the policy transfer. The court clarified that the insurer could still be liable for the enhanced compensation, applying notional income concepts (Ramachandrappa) and age-based multiplier (Sarla Verma). The appeal was allowed, increasing the compensation to Rs.5,53,600, with the insurer required to pay first and recover any amount from the owner thereafter, and to deposit within two months."

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1139 OF 2017; MACA NO. 2719 OF 2016

MACA No. 1139 of 2017; MACA No. 2719 of 2016, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

The Kerala High Court, exercising appellate jurisdiction in MACA Nos. 1139 of 2017 and 2719 of 2016, heard appeals arising from OP(MV) No.1184/2012 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakuda, concerning the death of Rajan in a road accident on 17.07.2012. The claimants, Radha, Manjusha, Vaisakhhan, and Thanka (widow, children and mother of the deceased), sought enhanced compensation from the insurer, National Insurance Company Ltd., which had admitted coverage but disputed liability and quantum. The Tribunal had awarded Rs.8,41,500 with liability on the insurer, leading to two parallel appeals: MACA 2719/2016 by the claimants challenging quantum, and MACA 1139/2017 by the insurer challenging the quantum and alleging overassessment. The court reviewed the record through the lens of Supreme Court principles governing motor-accident compensation: the Ramachandrappa and Syed Sadiq authorities to compute monthly income, the Pranay Sethi framework for future prospects, and subsequent refinements in Satinder Kaur and Magma cases on loss of consortium and family heads. The court held that future-prospects addition should be 10% for the 50–60 age band (not 30%), and re-based monthly earnings to Rs.8,500 with Rs.500 yearly increments, yielding a higher dependency figure. It reassessed heads of loss of estate, loss of consortium, and funeral expenses, reducing double-counting of love and affection, and determining an enhanced total of Rs.2,87,150. The appeals were allowed, with the insurer directed to deposit the enhanced amount within three months, and with a 119‑day delay in MACA 2719/2016 limiting interest on the additional amount.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No. 13035 of 2022

M.K. Prasanna Kumar v Airports Authority of India & Others

This writ petition is filed by M.K. Prasanna Kumar, then Joint General Manager (Air Traffic Management) in the Airports Authority of India (AAI), challenging Ext.P4, the interview component of a selection process for the post of General Manager (ATM). He contends that although he secured the highest objective-score (68/75), he was awarded a meager 5/25 in the interview, resulting in the denial of his promotion. He asserts malicious or mala fide conduct in the interview scoring by the Selection Committee, which allegedly manipulated marks to override his seniority and deprive him of promotion. He seeks to set aside Ext.P4 and is to be promoted with effect from the date the sixth respondent, his immediate junior, was promoted. The AAI’s Standing Counsel admits the objective score (68/75) but maintains the petitioner’s interview score (5/25) and argues that no personal mala fides against any Selection Committee member are demonstrated; moreover, the petitioner had already been promoted subsequently. The petitioner relies on Deepthy Vijayakumar v. Joint Registrar of Coop.Societies, Thrissur (2008 (4) KLT 321) to invoke res ipsa loquitor to permit a review despite lack of explicit mala fides, but the court ultimately finds insufficient material against the Committee and notes that the doctrine cannot apply here given the absence of corroborating evidence. The court dismisses the petition, observing no material to support victimisation and upholding the selection process as lawful.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 2796 OF 2010

Sundaran v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition filed by Sundaran, the accused in SC No. 326/2002 of the Assistant Sessions Court, Sulthanbathery, challenging his conviction under Section 58 of the Kerala Abkari Act for possession of 4 litres of arrack. The trial court sentenced him to two years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with a default sentence. The Appellate Court (Additional Sessions Court, Ad hoc-II, Kalpetta) confirmed the conviction and modified the sentence to one year of simple imprisonment with the same fine. In the revision, the Petitioner challenges several procedural and evidentiary flaws: absence of a specimen seal on the mahazar Ext.P2, missing description of the seal in the mahazar and forwarding notes, unexplained delays in forwarding the sample to the chemical analysis laboratory (Ext.P7) after it was sent from the court, and the lack of examination of the Thondy Clerk who handled the sample; an unexplained delay in filing the complaint despite the chemical analysis report, and a two-year overall delay in investigation in contravention of Section 50 Abkari Act. The High Court cites a line of precedents emphasizing strict compliance with Abkari Act formalities, tamper-proof chain of custody, and the necessity of linking the seized sample to the analysis. On these grounds, it finds the prosecution’s link evidence defective and, invoking the stated authorities, allows the revision, acquitting the petitioner and setting aside the lower courts’ conviction and sentence. The bail bond is cancelled and the petitioner is ordered to be set at liberty, with refund of any deposited amount as permitted by law. The order, authored by Justice Viju Abraham on 09 October 2023, underscores that a merely laboratory-confirmed result cannot substitute for proper chain-of-custody and procedural compliance."

High Court of Kerala
CON.CASE(C) NO.345 OF 2021

Ondiveeran J. v. Sunil Barthwal and Shri Andrews Prabhu

This Contempt of Court case arises from a writ petition (W.P.(C) No.26968/2016) and related matters, where the 15th petitioner, Ondiveeran J., alleges willful disobedience of the directions in Annexure A1 of the Kerala High Court judgment dated 12.10.2018. The linked matter concerns Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) pension entitlements under the 1995 pension scheme, subsequently amended by notification G.S.R. 609(E) dated 22.08.2014. The Supreme Court delivered a detailed judgment on 04.11.2022 in Civil Appeals Nos.8143-8144 of 2022 and connected matters, holding the 2014 notification legal and valid, directing read downs and extensions of options under paragraphs 11(3) and 11(4) of the pension scheme, and noting Ultra vires elements related to the additional employee contribution. Following that decision, the Kerela High Court observed that the petitioner’s higher pension entitlement requires reconsideration by EPFO in light of the 2022 Supreme Court judgment. On 30.10.2023, after hearing the petitioner and the Standing Counsel for EPFO, the Contempt Case was closed, with a direction that EPFO undertake the reconsideration within the framework of applicable law. The order preserves EPFO’s right to re-evaluate entitlement consistent with the 2022 judgment.

High Court of Kerala
R.F.A. No. 322 of 2004

Chandrasekharan @ Stephen and Gracy v. Thressia @ Salomy and Hema Elizabeth Kurian and others

This Regular First Appeal (RFA No. 322 of 2004) arises from a suit for specific performance (OS 579/1996) filed in Palakkad by Thressia @ Salomy and others against Chandrasekharan @ Stephen (represented by Gracy and his heirs-added appellants) and others. The suit concerned Ext. A1, an agreement dated 22 December 1993 for sale of plaint schedule property at ₹41,000 per acre, with advances of ₹5,00,000 paid by the plaintiff. The trial court decreed specific performance in favour of the plaintiff, while the appellants challenged on several fronts: (i) whether time was the essence of Ext. A1, (ii) the adequacy and correctness of the plaint description and the extent of the property (initially alleged as 27.80 acres, later amended to 12.70 acres after excluding defendants 3 and 4’s properties), (iii) the defendants’ claim of readiness and willingness to perform, and (iv) the plaintiff’s readiness to pay the balance consideration. The High Court engages in a thorough survey of contract-law principles governing specific performance, citing Chand Rani, Gomathinayagam Pillai, and other key authorities, and ultimately holds that time is not ordinarily the essence in sale of immovable property, and that Section 20 of the Specific Reliefs Act governs judicial discretion. The court affirms the decree but directs an enhanced contingency: if excess land is found on measurement, the plaintiff must pay an additional amount at ₹2 lakh per acre for the excess, while the balance for the scheduled 12.70 acres remains payable at ₹41,000 per acre. Interest at 12% per annum from the date of suit applies to the unpaid balance, and the sale deed must be executed within three months after payment. The appeal is disposed of in terms of paragraphs 26 to 26.2, and interlocutory applications are closed.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.24363/2024

Dr. Sasikumar and N. Sasidharan v State of Kerala and Others

The Petitioners challenge the 3rd respondent Sub Registrar’s decision to treat the rectification deed Ext.P2 as a conveyance for stamp duty purposes, arguing that Ext.P2 merely rectifies clerical errors in Ext.P1 and does not create or extinguish any right beyond what was conveyed. Ext.P1 was a sale deed; Ext.P2 aimed to correct boundary descriptions for consistency with the original transaction. The State contends Ext.P2 effects a transfer of rights and, as such, is a conveyance under the Stamp Act, attracting stamp duty. The Court notes that a rectification deed is meant to cure mistakes without creating new rights, and Schedule provisions of the Stamp Act do not prescribe stamp duty for rectification deeds. Relying on decisions like Jihas P.A., Rajesh Kumar K.T., Vannathi Valappil Mahmood, Baburaj P.K., and Madras Refineries Ltd., the Court emphasizes that the real and true meaning of the instrument must govern, and Ext.P2 does not transfer rights beyond Ext.P1. The Court holds Ext.P2 to be a rectification deed for all purposes, including registration, and directs the 3rd respondent to register Ext.P2 without stamp duty, thereby allowing the petition and setting aside Ext.P3.

High Court of Kerala
MACA 974/2012; MACA 1567/2013; O.P.(MV) 910/2010

MACA Nos. 974/2012 & 1567/2013, The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd vs P.M. Suneer (and Suneer P.M. v The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd)

These Motor Accident Claims Appeals arise from O.P.(MV) No.910 of 2010 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode, concerning injuries to a motorcycle rider in a 2009 accident caused by a car. The 3rd respondent insurer admitted coverage but contested negligence and the quantum of compensation. The Tribunal held the insurer liable, awarding Rs. 9,39,910 with interest and costs. The insurer challenged the quantum (MACA 974/2012) and the claimant sought enhancement (MACA 1567/2013). The High Court, through a detailed re-appraisal, scrutinizes income, disability, and future prospects. It rejects the Tribunal’s low monthly income (Rs. 3,300) and, applying the framework from Ramachandrappa v. Manager and Syed Sadiq v. Divisional Manager, adopts Rs. 7,000 per month as the baseline for 2009, even in the absence of conclusive evidence. The medical certificate shows 100% functional and 100% occupational disability, with head injury and neurological sequelae. The court further accepts future prospects, following Pranay Sethi, adding 40% of income. Consequently, disability compensation is recalculated to Rs. 19,99,200, plus Rs. 30,000 for pain and suffering, and Rs. 22,200 for loss of earnings due to higher income impact. The appeals are disposed of by enhancing the award by Rs. 13,38,600, with deposit within three months and a rider on interest for the delayed period.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC Nos.4769/2020 & 5715/2019

CRL.MC Nos.4769/2020 & 5715/2019: Sarfu @ Sharafudheen; Rahim Manikoth; Jaffir; P.B. Inthias; Thasreef v. State of Kerala

The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, before Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A., dealt with two criminal miscellaneous petitions—CRL.MC Nos.4769/2020 and 5715/2019—arising from Crime No.898/2013 of Hosdurg Police Station, Kasaragod. The petitioners include Sarfu @ Sharafudheen (accused No.11) and four other accused (Rahim Manikoth; Jaffir; P.B. Inthias; Thasreef) who sought quashing of further proceedings in CC No.898/2018 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate-II, Hosdurg, and the final report filed in Crime No.898/2013 (Annexure-AII). The prosecution alleged that on 21 July 2013, at the Madiyan junction in Ajanur Village, more than 300 persons formed an unlawful assembly, violated a District Collector–issued prohibitory order under Section 144 Cr.PC, disrupted police duty, and damaged a government vehicle (loss Rs. 9,000). Annexure-AII final report accused 12 persons. The Magistrate’s judgment (Annexure-AIII) acquitted accused Nos.1 and 10; the identity of accused persons and independent witnesses were problematic, and no 144 order was produced. The High Court, noting Moosa v. Sub Inspector of Police (2006) 1 KLT 552, held that the substratum of the prosecution was destroyed and continuing the prosecution would be futile. Consequently, the petitions were allowed, Annexure-AII final report and all further proceedings against the petitioners in CC No.898/2018 were quashed.

High Court of Kerala
Ex.F.A.44/2007

The Federal Bank Ltd. v. Maniyoth Chandran and others

This is an execution-first-appeal (Ex.F.A. 44/2007) before the Kerala High Court, challenging the order in E.A. No.168 of 2004 in E.P. No.97 of 2003 in O.S. No.18 of 2001 of the Sub Court, Thalassery. The claim petitioners (respondents) sought to release attachment under Order 21 Rule 58 CPC, arguing that a mortgage created in 1999 by the 2nd respondent (Maniyoth Chandran’s side) and the subsequent court sale did not bind the petition schedule property, as the deed of sale by Narayani to her son was sham. The 1st respondent bank had advanced funds in 1993, with a mortgage later created; the bank contends no attachment existed in the execution, so Order 21 Rule 58 is inapplicable to mortgage decrees, and the petitioner could not claim attachment rights. The appellant bank argues that the mortgage was created after the agreement and that the petition petition should be dismissed for lack of attachment; it relies on several decisions including Indian Bank v. Nallam Veera Swamy and Doraisami Iyer v. Arunachalam Chettiar. The respondents contend that the mortgage is valid and binding or that the attachment rules should apply given their rights under the decree. The High Court ultimately held that Order 21 Rule 58 requires attachment, which was absent here, and allowed the Ex.F.A., setting aside the trial court’s order and remitting the case.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC 2796 of 2023

SHAJAHAN K. and others v. State of Kerala and Ashraf Ali (Defacto Complainant)

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under section 482 CrPC filed in the Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, by five accused-petitioners (Shajahan K., Asher @ Akku, Sinil Thomas, Babu M.C., Jayachandran M.G.) challenging the proceedings in CC No.396/2022 arising from Crime No.200/2022 of Elamakkara Police Station. The charges are under sections 341, 447, and 323 read with 34 IPC. The prosecution contends that the accused wrongfully confined the victim after trespass and assaulted him. The petitioners, with the support of the victim via affidavit, seek quashing under section 482 on the ground that the dispute between private parties has been settled and there is no further need to prosecute. The Public Prosecutor expresses reservations about quashing solely on settlement but concedes that the matter is settled. The court recalls the three-judge Supreme Court decision in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019), and the related lines from Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, to lay down the governing principles: quashing is possible for private, non-compoundable offences where the dispute is settled; however not for heinous/serious offences or offences under special statutes or involving public servants; and that antecedents and conduct of the accused, evidence available after investigation, and the nature of the offence (e.g., S.307 IPC or Arms Act) must be considered. On balancing these considerations and reviewing the records, the court holds the dispute private, the settlement valid, and allows the Criminal Misc. Case, quashing the further proceedings in CC 396/2022. This is a single-judge decision by Justice P. V.Kunhikrishnan, bench type Single Judge, with the final outcome to quash the proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.R.P No.73 of 2014

Gangadharan S/o Lakshmanan v. State of Kerala

Gangadharan (the 2nd accused) challenges the conviction under section 8(2) of the Abkari Act arising from a search in House No. V/342, Peringottukurissi, Palakkad, where 5 litres of illicit arrack was found. The prosecution relied on PW1, a Circle Inspector of Excise, who conducted the search and seizure and forwarded the matter for investigation. The trial court and the 1st appellate court held the accused guilty, while the 2nd accused was convicted and sentenced to six months' imprisonment and Rs. 1 lakh fine with default imprisonment. On revision, the Kerala High Court examines whether PW1 could lawfully detect the offence as an Abkari Officer given the Arrack Act’s notification framework, and whether procedural defects (delay in investigation, non-examination of the investigating officer, ownership-only linkage of the house to the accused, and lack of direct evidence of possession) taint the conviction. The court distinguishes Sujith v. State of Kerala, noting distinct factual contexts, and explains that PW1 was an Abkari Officer notified under SRO 234/67 and, though redeployed to a Special Squad, retained Abkari Officer status for detection within his scope. The court ultimately finds grave credibility issues and delays in investigation, leading to acquittal of the 2nd accused and setting aside the conviction/sentence. The revision petition is allowed; the respondent’s case collapses with the acquittal and liberty forthwith.

High Court of Kerala
RFA No. 594 of 2012; RFA No. 600 of 2012

P.K. Abdul Salam v Abdul Jabbar (deceased) and others

This is a consolidated decision in RFA Nos. 594 of 2012 and 600 of 2012 before the Kerala High Court, arising from two suits: OS 43/2007 for specific performance and OS 58/2007 for a mandatory injunction to reclaim possession in Kochi. The appellant-plaintiff P.K. Abdul Salam sought specific performance of Ext.A1, an agreement dated 22.03.2006 to convey about 10.258 cents with buildings for Rs 30.5 lakh, with substantial advances having been paid (Rs 20.25 lakh). The defendant Abdul Jabbar (deceased) admitted the agreement but contested readiness and willingness under Section 16(c) of the Specific Relief Act, and raised issues about conveyable title, the extent of property, and the plaintiff’s willingness to proceed. The trial court held that the plaintiff failed to establish readiness and willingness and that misalignment between Ext.A1 and plaint schedule existed; it declined specific performance but decreed return of the advance money. The cross-suit OS 58/2007 sought possession; the trial court granted a mandatory injunction and declined interest on the advance. On appeal, the High Court, by a single Judge, held that the plaintiff could not establish the required readiness/willingness given the insistence on additional land not covered by Ext.A1, and that the vendor’s title issues did not entitle the plaintiff to relief. Ultimately, the appeals were dismissed, confirming the decree for return of Rs 20,00,000 with interest and directing vacatur of the premises within a fixed period (extended later by IA).

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 2861 of 2023

SUNEER v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a regular bail application (BA 2861 of 2023) filed by the 13th accused in Crime No. 1015 of 2022 of Infopark Police Station, Ernakulam. The prosecution alleges that on 23.12.2022 the accused trespassed into the defacto complainant’s office—operating as the ‘Brawny Brute’ Family Studio Health and Boutique Clinic—where he and others beat staff with a hammer and wooden stick, forcibly obtained a cheque signed by the complainant, and robbed files, a laptop, treatment equipment, a car (i20, KL-40-L 3141), ATM card, gold, dress and other items valued at about Rs. 14,80,000. It is further alleged that they poured salt at the office to simulate MDMA, took photographs with the items and warned the complainant of public exposure; the complainant sustained injuries to the face and eyes. Police registered the crime on 25.12.2022 under IPC sections 452, 324, 328, 395, 427 and 506(ii) read with 212 IPC. The petitioner contends that he is a first-time offender, has already spent about 65 days in custody, and that the investigation is practically over; he offers to cooperate. The State argues the offences are serious and investigation is at an early stage, and earlier anticipatory bail applications were dismissed. The court ultimately grants regular bail with conditions: bond Rs 50,000, two solvent sureties, no witness intimidation, cooperation with investigation and trial, regular appearance, no travel without permission, and no further offences.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 505 OF 2023

SATHEESH S/O SASI v. STATE OF KERALA

Satheesh S/o Sasi, the second accused, challenges an order of the Special Judge, Thrissur, dated 20 March 2023, denying anticipatory bail under Section 14A of the SC/ST Act in Crime No.131/2023 of Peechi Police Station. The Kerala High Court examines whether the accused merits pre-arrest bail in light of the SC/ST Act provisions and relevant case law. The prosecution alleges caste-based abuse, assault, and injuries, with the defacto complainant belonging to a Scheduled Caste while the accused are not; the FIR cites offences under IPC Sections 294(b), 323, 324, 341 and 308 read with Section 34 and under Section 3(1)(x) of the SC/ST Act. Counsel for the appellant contends that the FIR does not establish any SC/ST Act offence against the appellant; the soda-bottle assault is attributed to the first accused, leaving the appellant with no prima facie case to answer. The Public Prosecutor asserts misstatement of Section 3(1)(x) and argues that Sections 3(1)(r) and (s) are attracted for caste-based abuse, invoking Sections 18 and 18A of the SC/ST Act, which would bar anticipatory bail. The court relies on settled law that anticipatory bail is not categorically barred where there is no prima facie SC/ST offence; consequently, the appeal is allowed, the impugned order set aside, and anticipatory bail is granted with conditions to ensure cooperation with investigation and protection of witnesses.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 2679/2010

Savithri v. Sasidhara Kurup Panavila Veedu and others

This is a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal (MACA 2679/2010) before the Kerala High Court arising from an award in O.P.(MV) 1299/2003 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Attingal. On 07.06.2003, Babukuttan @ Babu (the deceased), aged 33, riding a motorcycle, was struck by a lorry driven by the 2nd respondent. The lorry owner (1st respondent) and insurer (3rd respondent) were arrayed; the 4th respondent is the deceased’s mother and wife of the appellant. The Tribunal partly allowed the petition, awarding Rs 2,52,000 with 7.5% interest and costs, while the additional fourth respondent’s claim was rejected because she remarried during the proceedings. The appellant contends that the Tribunal erred in quantum, having evidence of the deceased’s UAE income of Rs 25,000 per month, yet fixing a notional Rs 2,500/month and a low overall sum. Ext.A5 shows negligence by the second respondent. The High Court re-evaluates compensation using established Supreme Court doctrines: notional income (Ramachandrappa), multiplier (16) for age 33 (Sarla Verma/Pranay Sethi), future prospects (40%), and deduction for personal living expenses (50%). Conventional heads from Pranay Sethi are applied: funeral, loss of estate, and loss of consortium. The court arrives at a revised total of Rs 6,10,100; it enhances compensation by Rs 3,57,600 with 7.5% interest from the petition date (excluding 89 days delay) and orders deposit before the Tribunal. The appeal is allowed and interlocutory applications are closed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 4004 OF 2008

Muraleedharan v. State of Kerala

Muraleedharan v. State of Kerala is a Kerala High Court criminal revision in which the accused challenged a conviction under Sections 8(1) and 8(2) of the Abkari Act. The trial court had convicted him for transporting three litres of arrack on 17 June 2003 and sentenced him to six months' rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 1 lakh, with default imprisonment. The Additional Sessions Judge (Fast Track Court‑II), Alappuzha, dismissed the appeal, upholding the conviction and sentence. In the revision petition before the High Court, the petitioner contends material irregularities in the prosecution case: notably, the absence of a specimen impression of the seal on the seizure mahazar Ext.P3, and unexplained two‑year delay in investigation. The High Court agreed that the prosecution relied on Ext.P3 and the sample reaching the laboratory but found the lack of a specimen seal and the unexplained delay to be critical defects undermining the chain of custody and the genuineness of the sample. Relying on decisions including Moothedath Sivadasan, Bhaskaran, Rajamma and Kumaran P., the court held that the prosecution did not prove the case beyond reasonable doubt. Consequently, the conviction and sentence were set aside; the accused was acquitted under Section 235(1) Cr.P.C., bail cancelled, and he was ordered to be set at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.13682/2020(I) & WP(C).No.22430/2020(C)

WP(C) Nos.13682/2020(I) & 22430/2020(C) — I. Unnikrishnan v Union of India & Ors; G. Anoop v Union of India & Ors

These two connected writ petitions challenge a SEBI show-cause notice (Ext.P2 dated 13.03.2020) issued to BRD Securities Limited and others for alleged public-issue-style debentures without proper registration and compliance under SEBI Act and Companies Act provisions. The petitioners, fellow members of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India and appointed debenture trustees, contend SEBI lacks jurisdiction over NBFCs (regulated by RBI) and that the show-cause notice is ultravires, both on jurisdictional grounds and on procedural grounds like the replication of RBI/Companies Act domains. They rely on multiple High Court/Apex Court decisions to contend that SEBI cannot encroach upon RBI-regulated NBFC activities, and seek quashing Ext.P2 or stay of the proceedings. The respondent SEBI counters that as long as NBFCs are not expressly excluded from SEBI’s ambit, SEBI has authority to regulate securities transactions and protect investors; debenture trustees must be registered under SEBI Act and the relevant Regulations. The court, while noting the petitioners’ submissions and the cited authorities, ultimately upholds SEBI’s show-cause proceedings at the show-cause stage and dismisses the petitions, holding that the NBFC’s issuance of debentures and non-registration fall within SEBI’s regulatory purview. It emphasizes that the petitioners have an opportunity to reply before SEBI and contest jurisdiction and other issues at the Board level.