Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 503 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C 6247/2021

Sanju @ Sanjunni; Sanjay Babu @ Kaka; Preman @ Paramesh; Gokul; Rahul; Boopalan; Anus v. The State of Kerala and Akshay

This is a criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 CrPC filed by seven petitioners (accused Nos. 1 to 7) seeking to quash CC No. 77/2018 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thrissur, arising from Crime No. 208/2018 of Thrissur West Police Station. The accused were charged with offences under sections 143, 147, 148, 342, 323, 324, 365, and 506 r/w 149 IPC for allegedly forming an unlawful assembly on 8 March 2018 and assaulting the complainant. The petition contends that the dispute has been amicably settled and the parties do not wish to pursue the prosecution, supported by an affidavit from the respondent. The State including the Public Prosecutor expresses reservations about quashing solely on the basis of a settlement, though it concedes there are no other serious offences against the petitioners. The court surveys Supreme Court authority (State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan; Gian Singh; Narinder Singh) to set out the governing principles: quashing under 482 is permissible for non‑compoundable, private disputes with predominantly civil character where settlement is achieved; not for heinous or public-interest crimes (e.g., murder, rape, dacoity) or offences under special statutes or against public servants; and the need to examine whether incurrence of Section 307 IPC is proper, as per the evolving jurisprudence. After weighing gravity, injuries, antecedents, and the settled posture of the parties, the court concludes that quashing would promote peace and ends of justice without adversely impacting society. The petition is allowed, leading to quashing of the Final Report (Crime No. 208/2018) and all further proceedings in CC No. 77/2018.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 7444 of 2022

Mango Meadows Agricultural Pleasure Land (Pvt. Ltd.) v. Union of India & Others

Mango Meadows Agricultural Pleasure Land (Pvt. Ltd.), a company operating an agricultural theme park in Ayamkudi, Kottayam, challenged Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) after the 9th respondent, a financial creditor, invoked the provision following a cascade of loan defaults totaling about Rs. 14 crores (Rs. 4 crore in 2015, Rs. 8 crore in 2016, Rs. 2 crore in 2017). The loan facility had been serviced initially, but COVID-19 disruptions impaired viability, prompting the 9th respondent to initiate SARFAESI proceedings and later approach the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) under Section 7 read with Rule 4 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority) Rules, 2016. The petitioner sought a declaration that Section 7 and the Form prescribed thereunder are unconstitutional, arguing that the adjudicating authority’s role is mechanical and that the provision violates Article 14 by discriminating against corporate debtors in favour of financial creditors. The respondents defended maintainability and relied on drip-down jurisprudence including Shivam Water Treaters, Swiss Ribbons, Innoventive Industries, and Vidarbha Industries Power, contending that Section 7 is a valid, beneficial mechanism for insolvency resolution. The Court, after analysis, held that Section 7 is not unconstitutional, emphasizing the discretionary and context-driven nature of admission and the need to balance creditors’ interests with the corporate debtor’s viability. The writ petition was dismissed with directions to allow objections and proceed in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. 972 of 2023

SABARINADH and MAHALAKSHMI v. STATE OF KERALA

This High Court of Kerala, in Bail Application No. 972 of 2023, considers anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC for accused Nos. 2 and 3 in Crime No.14/2023 of Vadakkencherry Police Station, Palakkad. The private complaint alleges that the 1st accused, along with three others, pledged gold ornaments to secure loans and later misappropriated funds after pledging the same gold to another entity. The petitioners challenge the registration of the crime, noting that the complaint does not name them or set out overt acts against them. They point to a prior bail order in a separate Crime No.1153/2022 based on the absence of allegations against them. The State counters that there are other connected crimes and that the complainant Leela’s statements support involvement of the petitioners in pledging gold and enacting fraudulent schemes, resulting in large sums misappropriated. The court, while recognizing the seriousness of the allegations, confines its consideration to the present Crime No.14/2023 and determines that interrogation of the petitioners is necessary to elicit details. Consequently, the court grants anticipatory bail on conditions: surrender within seven days, two-day interrogation window, bond of Rs.30,000 with two sureties, regular appearance, co-operation with investigation, and prohibition on witness intimidation or further offences. The order emphasizes trial readiness and ongoing supervision through the bail conditions.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 847 OF 2006

CRL.A NO. 847 OF 2006

This Kerala High Court criminal appeal arises from convictions of two appellants (accused Nos. 1 and 2) by the Ad hoc-III Sessions Court for offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 324, 326 and 307 r/w 149. Accused No.1 was convicted under Section 307 IPC and sentenced to three years’ rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 10,000, and accused No.2 was convicted under Section 326 IPC with a similar sentence. The trial court acquitted accused Nos. 3–8. The prosecution’s case rests on PW3’s testimony of injuries (including a 6x1 cm incised wound on the temporal-parietal region) and medical certificates Exts. P1 and P2, with Ext. P4 FIS and Ext. P11 FIR produced on the same day. The defence argued non-identification of accused Nos. 1 and 2, absence of any test identification parade, reliance on the FIS/FIR, and belated FIR. The High Court held that there was no significant delay in FIR lodging and that medical evidence, FIS, and the wound certificate corroborated the victim’s account, while also accepting res-gestae evidence via PW4. It rejected the challenge to identification on the basis that identity was disclosed in the wound certificate/FIR and declined the Vijayan v. State of Kerala proposition. On appeal, the court upheld the convictions but modified the substantive sentences: accused No.1’s sentence was substituted with 45 days’ pre-trial detention plus a fine of Rs.25,000 with a three-month default; accused No.2’s sentence, for a non-vital injury, was similarly adjusted. Accused No.2 having died, the fine is to be recovered from assets of the deceased, with Rs.40,000 to be released to PW3 and the balance adjusted toward costs. The appeal is allowed in part.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No. 34 of 2015 (Z)

KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION v Sini P.V, Sheeba K, Sheena M.P.

This Original Petition (OP) under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India challenges an order of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (KAT) dated 13 August 2014 in O.A. No. 242/2014. The respondents before the Tribunal were three candidates for state-wide teaching posts (Higher Secondary School Teacher - Mathematics and Non-Vocational Teacher - Mathematics) category No.457/2010, whose applications were rejected on the ground that the identification certificates’ water marks did not conform to the prescribed specifications. The PSC had initially notified the selection in 2010 and conducted a written examination in 2013; the short-listed candidates were to be interviewed. On 1 April 2014 the PSC announced a general decision not to insist on the water mark in the identification certificate. The Tribunal, taking the 1 April 2014 decision as applicable to all selections, disposed of the OA by directing verification, interviews, and inclusion in a rank list if otherwise eligible. The PSC contends that the 1 April 2014 decision is prospective and cannot apply to selections initiated under the 31 December 2010 notification and that altering pre-notification conditions would undermine fairness and the rules of the game. The High Court ultimately holds that, for this selection, the 2010 notification conditions remained binding; the Tribunal’s order is set aside and the OA is dismissed, leaving the earlier notification regime intact. The court relies on established principles of reasonableness, fairness, and adherence to clear instructions, as emphasized in Full Bench decisions, including Resmi’s case, to hold that the PSC’s pre-existing conditions govern this case and that a general post-notification decision cannot be applied retroactively to pre-notification selections.

High Court of Kerala
ITA No.3/2017

The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Kottayam v. Vazhapppally Service Co-operative Bank Ltd

On 28 September 2022, the Kerala High Court (Division Bench) heard ITA No.3/2017, challenging ITAT Cochin Bench’s order in ITA No.191/Coch/2016 for AY 2010-11. The core issue is the application of CBDT Circular No. 3/2018 (and No. 3/2019) to tax appeals where the tax effect falls below the statutory ceiling. The Revenue contends that several Supreme Court decisions carve exceptions to the general rule, enabling the circular’s applicability to pending matters with caveats (Surya Herbal Ltd.; Tarun R. Tahiliani; S.C. Naregal). It also relies on the principles laid down in Mavilayi Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. and DIT v. S.R. M. B. Dairy Farming to argue that the circular should extend to pending cases without causing cascading effects. The bank/respondent, while not exhaustively detailed in the excerpt, is represented by multiple advocates and contends against expansive application, emphasizing that the circular should not unduly broaden its reach absent cascading or group-wide implications. After considering the above authorities, the court concludes that the circular can apply to pending matters but subject to the caveats discussed in Surya Herbal and Naregal, and that the appeal’s monetary value falls below the CBDT ceiling. Accordingly, the appeal is disposed of in favor of dismissing the Revenue’s challenge (appeal dismissed). The decision clarifies how CBDT circulars interact with pending assessments and caveats from precedents.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).Nos. 17509/2016 (K) and 17571/2016 (K)

Rajee Rajkumar v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Non-Corporate Circle (1), Ernakulam; Anappadikal Hospitality Private Ltd v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Non-Corporate Circle (1), Ernakulam

These writ petitions, heard together, challenge a reopened assessment for AY 2008-09 under sections 147/148 of the IT Act. The petitioner, Rajee Rajkumar, and, in the allied petition, her husband’s company, Anappadikal Hospitality Private Ltd, contended that the notice under section 148 was issued beyond the statutory period and that service of the notice was not effected within the time prescribed, thereby invalidating the re-assessment. They relied on the distinction between the “issue of notice” and “service of notice,” as discussed in RK Upadhyaya v. Shanabhai Patel, and on the proposition of “reason to believe” under section 147 as laid down in Rajesh Jhaveri Stock Brokers P. Ltd. The petitioners also invoked Travancore Diagnostics Pvt. Ltd. v. ACIT to urge limitations on reopening. The Department argued that the notice was issued within the limitation period (and 149/151 requirements) and that service delays did not defeat jurisdiction since the assessment order requires service, not merely issuance. The High Court ultimately held that the notice was issued within time and that service, though delayed, did not invalidate the proceedings; thus the petitions were dismissed, with liberty to file appeals, and with exclusion of the petition period from the appeal timeline if appeals are filed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 1163 OF 2021

Silpa Projects and Infrastructure (I) Private Limited v. Asten Realtors Private Limited

This matter concerns a construction dispute under a residential project named Rajagiri Campus Court at Kakkanad, Ernakulam. The petitioner, Silpa Projects and Infrastructure (I) Private Limited, after completing the work, raised a bill for Rs. 7,18,86,078 against the respondent, who allegedly failed to pay. Invoking the arbitration clause, the petitioner approached the Commercial Court and obtained an ex-parte conditional attachment over 20 unsold apartments. After the respondent appeared, an interlocutory application sought to lift the attachment by offering alternative security in place of the attached property. By Ext. P3, the Commercial Court accepted the alternative security and withdrew the attachment, subsequently dismissing the petitioner's appeal in Ext. P4. The petitioner challenges Ext. P3/Ext. P4 on the grounds that the alternative security—25 apartments in Kanjirappally owned by a subsidiary of the petitioner—was undervalued and insufficient to cover the sum in dispute. The respondent contends that the courts below correctly exercised discretion under Order 38 Rule 5 CPC and that Article 227 of the Constitution affords limited interference. It is argued that in a separate arbitration proceeding the petitioner had previously accepted a valuation of Rs. 30 lakhs per apartment and that security exceeded the due amount. The High Court, upon review of the record and documents, held the security adequate and the attachments justified, and declined to interfere with concurrent findings. The original petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No.246/2019

State of Kerala & Ors. v. M. Raju

This Division Bench of the Kerala High Court sits on OP(KAT) No.246/2019 challenging the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s 27 November 2018 order in TA 7538 of 2012. The respondent, M. Raju, a part-time/ casual sweeper engaged since 1999, had his enhanced pay and arrears determined under earlier Government orders; the petitioners, State of Kerala and its officers, contend that the Tribunal’s direction to continue the enhanced salary irrespective of subsequent re-measurement of sweeping area is unsustainable and misapplies the governing scheme. The judgment traces a complex history of pay revisions for part-time and casual sweepers, including G.O. (P) 831/80/Fin, G.O. (P) 3000/98/Fin, and G.O. (P) 390/03/Fin, as well as clarifications and corrections issued in 2003 regarding the sweeping area (carpet area, verandas, courtyards, etc.). Mercy v. State of Kerala (2004) and the Division Bench decision in Mercy (W.A.No.1863 of 2004) are cited as pivotal authorities shaping the principle that pay protection is provided to incumbents and that sweeping area measurements should be fixed under supervision, with notice, and typically not exceeding certain limits. GO 361/2005 and GO 501/2005/Fin. are referenced as schemes for regularisation and maintaining arrears. The Tribunal’s order, which effectively preserved the enhanced pay for those already in receipt, was not found illegal by the High Court; rather, the court endorsed the Government’s policy alignment with binding precedents and, noting the lapse of time, granted a further six weeks for compliance and dismissed the petition with costs."

High Court of Kerala
MACA.2051/2010, MACA.2283/2010, MACA.2312/2010

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Fasila, Kadeeja, Safiya, Shyju, Abdul Salam, Rasheed (MACA Nos. 2051/2010, 2283/2010, 2312/2010)

These three motor accident claims were heard together by a single judge of the Kerala High Court. The New India Assurance Company challenged three awards of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Vadakara, concerning a fatal accident (OPMV 1143/2007), a serious injury (OPMV 854/2007) and damage to the motor cycle (OPMV 393/2008) involving a jeep. The Tribunal, having examined evidence including PW1 and Exhibits A1–A16, held the insurer liable and awarded compensation to the claimants: in OPMV 1143/2007, Rs. 9,94,000 inclusive of Rs. 50,000 under Section 140 MV Act at 7.5% interest from petition date with Rs. 5,000 costs; in OPMV 854/2007, Rs. 8,500 with 7.5% interest and Rs. 500 costs; and in OPMV 393/2008, Rs. 10,500 with 7.5% interest and Rs. 500 costs. The insurer contended contributory negligence because the rider of the motorcycle died and argued the award was unjust and not backed by documentary evidence, including income. The respondents supported the Tribunal, relying on evidence and precedent that police chargesheets can constitute prima facie evidence of negligence under Section 166 MV Act and that the income of the deceased should be fixed consistently with guidelines. The High Court dismissed the appeals, upholding the Tribunal’s quantum and holding the award just and reasonable.

High Court of Kerala
MACA.No.2813 OF 2008(A)

Ramesh P.V v. Lakshmanan and The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd.

This appeal arises from a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal award in which the petitioner, Ramesh P.V., sought compensation for injuries sustained on 16 July 2004 while traveling in autorickshaw KL-174828 from Adimali to Kurisuppara. The first respondent, driver of the autorickshaw, was alleged to have driven rashly, causing the accident, and the second respondent, insurer, faced the liability. The tribunal dismissed the petition, finding the claim false and concocted after evaluating conflicting statements and documentary evidence (Exts A1–A11 and B1–B2). The appellant contends the accident occurred due to negligence of the driver, supported by Ext A1 (FIR) and hospitalization records, and that compensation of Rs.1,50,000 was due. The insurer argued the driver lacked a valid license and that the appellant was not involved, suggesting the petition be dismissed. On appeal, the court notes that Division Benches in New India Assurance Co. Ltd v. Pazhaniammal and Kolavan v. Salim held that a charge sheet can be prima facie evidence of negligence, with the onus on the opposing party to rebut it. In this case, the insurer shifted the onus to RW1 and Ext.B1, which the court found improper, leading to dismissal of the appeal and upholding the award.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No.188 of 2016

V.K. Gopinathan v. Director, Local Fund Audit, Thiruvananthapuram and Others

This is a Kerala High Court appeal (FAO No.188 of 2016) arising from an order in I.A.488 of 2015 in O.P. (LFA) No.14 of 2014 before the Addl. District Judge-I, Kalpetta, challenging a surcharge certificate LF 9322/Spl.Cell/CSC/D2/2010 (dated 18.07.2013) issued by the Director, Local Fund Audit. The appellant sought restoration of the original petition which had been dismissed for default when the matter came up for hearing in November 2015. He relied on provisions of Order IX CPC (Rules 8, 9 and 13) and invoked Order XLIII Rule 1(c) CPC to challenge the dismissal. The High Court examines the scope of “sufficient cause” for non-appearance, drawing on G.P. Srivastava v. R.K. Raizada (2000) 3 SCC 54, and subsequent Kerala rulings in M. Shivananda v. M. Susheela and Peeves Enterprises v. Muhammed Ashraf, to emphasize liberal construction and the discretionary power to do justice in such circumstances. It concludes that the appellant’s restoration application was within time and should be considered on merits, notwithstanding the prior default, and allows the appeal, setting aside the 08.04.2016 order, with costs. The matter is to be restored and disposed of within four months before the Addl. District Judge, Kalpetta. The bench comprises Justices Anil K. Narendran and P.G. Ajithkumar.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.18306 of 2021

P. Haridas v. Special Tahsildar (Travancore Devaswom) & Others

The petitioner, a devotee of the Mankombu Bhagavathy Temple, filed a writ petition under Article 226 seeking a mandamus to direct the 1st respondent, the Special Tahsildar, to take action based on Ext.P1 dated 09.07.2021 for eviction of unauthorised occupation of Devaswom land, alleged to be in possession of the 4th respondent. He also sought restoration of temple properties to the Devaswom from encroachers and those who obtained property unlawfully. The petition came up for admission, with appearances by the Senior Government Pleader for the 1st respondent and the Standing Counsel for the Travancore Devaswom Board for respondents 2 and 3; the 4th respondent filed a counter affidavit; the District Judge, Thathampally (Alappuzha) was suo motu impleaded as the 5th respondent. The principal question is whether this Court should intervene in writ proceedings to examine the grievances in Ext.P1 and take action under Article 226, considering guardianship principles over Devaswom properties. The Court anchors its reasoning in precedents such as A.A. Gopalakrishnan v. Cochin Devaswom Board (2007) 7 SCC 482 and Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair (2013), stressing the Devaswom’s protection and the court’s parens patriae jurisdiction to safeguard temple assets. It also cites Achuthan Pillai v. State of Kerala (1970 KLT 838) and Mrinalini Padhi v. Union of India (2018) SCC OnLine SC 667 for supervisory and policy considerations. The Court dispositions the petition by directing the District Judge to conduct a proper enquiry per the Supreme Court’s directions in W.P.(C) No. 649 of 2018 and file a report within four months, while keeping contentions open for later challenge before the appropriate forum. The writ petition is disposed of with these directions.

High Court of Kerala
RSA NO. 1306 OF 2009

P.K. Abdullakunhi (through legal heirs) v. Andunhi and others

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a partition suit (OS 275/2006) concerning plaint A schedule property in Re-survey No.20/2, Kubanoor village, Kasargod. The property originally belonged to Seedi Beary and devolved on his wife Kaijamma and their children, including the plaintiff. After Seedi Beary’s death, defendant No.8—who purchased a share in 1969 by Ext.A1 sale deed—claimed exclusive rights to the plaint A schedule property, while the plaintiff and his sister Asiamma were not joined as signatories to Ext.A1. The Trial Court decreed partition, allocating 14/72 to the plaintiff and 7/72 to the group of defendants 1–7, with the balance to defendant No.8, and granted future mesne profits. The First Appellate Court upheld this decree. The appellant contends Ext.A1 did not bind the plaintiff/Asiamma, who remained co‑owners, and questions whether the sale extinguished their rights. It is argued that adverse possession cannot defeat co‑ownership, and that the suit is not barred by partial partition or non‑joinder of necessary parties. The court reviews the adverse possession claim, relying on established authorities on hostile possession, willful neglect, and animus possidendi, concluding that the appellant’s contentions fail. Substantial questions of law are answered against the appellant; the Regular Second Appeal is dismissed with costs.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 5764 OF 2020

Abida Beevi A v. State of Kerala

Abida Beevi A, wife of late N.S. Nooruddin, was the petitioner in CRL.MC 5764/2020 challenging Annexure A4, an order of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Varkala, dismissing her Section 452 Cr.P.C. application for release of five kilograms of gold seized from her husband and another accused during the registration of Crime No.331/1992 (Varkala Police) later re-numbered as Crime No.32/CR/93 under CBCID. The trial against several accused progressed; ultimately, four accused were acquitted (Annexure A1), the third accused died, while the remaining two accused had their proceedings abated on their death, leaving no active trial. The petitioner, as legal heir of the deceased first accused, argued that with trial concluded and abatement due to death, Section 452 Cr.P.C. empowered the court to release the property or dispose of it, after due notice to all interested parties. The State countered that there were multiple parties with potential claims and that the petition was filed in a pre-referral stage, not in the subsequent proceedings (620/2008). The High Court found that Annexure A4 could not stand as the procedure under Section 452 requires notice and adjudication of rival claims; it remanded to enable impleadment of all affected parties and directed that, if rival claims exist, civil court adjudication should follow, while permitting release of the property if no serious dispute exists. The decision aligns with Section 452 jurisprudence and recognizes the need to secure all interests.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.2115 of 2009

K. J. George v. Shaji, K.R. Shaji and United India Insurance Co. Ltd.

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA) from the Kerala High Court challenging an order of the Additional Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kottayam, in OPMV 684/2003. The appellant, K. J. George, a teacher and agriculturist, sustained injuries in a motor-vehicle accident on 21 May 2000 involving a vehicle owned by the second respondent and insured by the third respondent. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 54,580 with interest and costs, in part of the claim petition seeking Rs. 8,71,500. The insurer opposed the full liability, arguing that the accident occurred due to the appellant’s own negligence and that policy conditions were violated. The High Court examined negligence, liability, and quantum, upholding the finding of negligence and liability of the insurer. On income, the Tribunal fixed the appellant’s notional monthly income at Rs. 7,000, while the appellant claimed Rs. 14,078 based on salary and agricultural earnings; the court considered the evidence and accepted Rs. 7,000 as reasonable. For disability, Ext A6 shows 15% permanent disability. Relying on Puttamma v. K.L Narayana Reddy, the court applied a split multiplier of 11, considering continued service till age 55, and followed the Sarla Verma framework. The Court computed loss due to disability at Rs. 1,38,600 and allowed an enhanced award, with interest and costs, payable by the insurer within sixty days, with the Tribunal to disburse accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 21960 of 2021

M.K. Sajeevan v. Chief Security Commissioner, Railway Protection Force, Southern Railway and others

M.K. Sajeevan, a Railway Protection Force constable who rose to Head Constable, challenged a disciplinary process launched after an incident at Coimbatore Railway Station on 15 August 2012. Sajeevan detained a passenger (Nagendran) carrying finished jewellery; a cover containing Rs. 5,000 was allegedly placed in his pocket by an intermediary, and Sajeevan handed the cover to the IPF the following day. Subsequently, he faced charges under Rule 147 and other provisions, including discreditable conduct and improper use of position, culminating in a department enquiry that resulted in compulsory retirement in 2013. He challenged the penalties through appeals, revisions, and reinstatement in 2014, but a fresh enquiry was directed by the revisional authority in Ext.P10 after prolonged delay. In 2021, the petitioner moved a writ petition challenging the fresh enquiry as mala fide and violative of fair process due to an eight-year gap since the incident. The Railways argued that Ext.P10 was a provisional direction and that the fresh enquiry was not prejudicial. The Kerala High Court, after analyzing delay jurisprudence and relevant Supreme Court and High Court authorities, held that the prolonged delay without satisfactory explanation materially prejudiced the petitioner and warranted interference. The court quashed Exts.P15 and P16 and related proceedings, directing a decision on how to reckon the intervening period within two months.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 12585/2021

Omanakuttan K.G v Union of India and others

This public interest writ petition, WP(C) No. 12585 of 2021, challenges the Information Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021, and seeks a ban on WhatsApp in India on grounds of end-to-end encryption, privacy concerns, potential manipulation of media and evidence, and the platform’s alleged non-cooperation with Indian law enforcement. The petitioner argues that WhatsApp’s data practices—such as storing messages, accessing contacts, and identifying non-users—jeopardize privacy and can be misused to create false evidence or disrupt trials. The petition relies on privacy principles elaborated in Justice K. S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India to urge protection of citizen rights, and contends that the new IT Rules undermine privacy and can undermine the judicial process. The petitioner also seeks to direct investigating agencies not to rely on WhatsApp contents, and to require the Registrar General to ensure WhatsApp contents are not admissible in court proceedings; and, if WhatsApp does not cooperate, to ban its operations. The Government counters that the IT Rules were enacted under Section 87 IT Act, provide due diligence and oversight, and that mandamus to override ongoing regulatory processes is inappropriate. The Court ultimately holds the petition premature, unsubstantiated, and without merit, and dismisses the writ petition.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 25628 OF 2022

CSB Limited (Formerly The Catholic Syrian Bank Ltd.) v. Kerala State Human Rights Commission and Jency Mathew

CSB Limited, a banking company, challenges Ext.P5 interim order of the Kerala State Human Rights Commission dated 3 August 2022, which directed the bank to permit the second respondent to rejoin her earlier post, regularize her absences, and ensure a safe working environment, while informing the Commission about progress of the police investigation. The petition contends the order interferes with the bank’s internal management and transfer decisions protected by Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, and that the Commission exceeded its jurisdiction by addressing service/transfer matters. It argues that the POSH Act regime is being misapplied; Regulation 17(f) of the Kerala Human Rights Commission (Procedure) Regulations, 2001 excludes service and industrial disputes from Commission scrutiny. The petitioner relies on Maiyadas v. RDO to contend that interference with internal employment matters violates constitutional guarantees. The respondents contend that harassment at workplace was being dealt with and that the Commission is empowered under the POSH Act and the Protection of Human Rights Act to inquire and safeguard the petitioner’s employees. The High Court ultimately holds that the interim order constitutes unwarranted interference, sets aside Ext.P5, and allows the writ petition, emphasizing the bank’s prerogatives and the need for ICC due process.

High Court of Kerala
W.A. No. 829 of 2021

Cochin Port Trust v All India Port & Dock Workers Federation and Others

This Kerala High Court Writ Appeal (WA No. 829 of 2021) arises from an interim order passed in WP(C) No. 1020 of 2021. The appellant/Respondent No.4 is the Cochin Port Trust challenging the applicability of the Union government’s office memoranda—particularly Exts. P-1 (19.11.2020) and related communications Exts. P-2, P-4, P-5—to employees of Major Port Trusts and Dock Labour Boards. The writ petition prays quashing Exts. P-2 and P-4 and seeks declarations limiting Ext. P-1 to Executives and Non-Unionised Supervisors of CPSEs, and declaring that Major Ports are not CPSEs hence Ext. P-1 has no applicability. The Single Judge had interimly stayed enforcement to the extent Exts. P-2 and P-4 affected Major Port Trusts’ employees, pending disposal of the petition, while noting Bombay and Karnataka High Court interim orders (Exts. P-9, P-10) and Kerala’s Ext. P-7 (17.12.2020) which confined Ext. P-1 to CPSE Executives/Non-Unionised Supervisors. The Division Bench, while not finding grave perversity in the impugned order, did not disturb it at this interlocutory stage and directed expeditious final disposal of the main petition. The WA is ultimately dismissed, with directions to proceed to final disposal. The proceedings touch on inter-ministerial differences in applying DA and related pay norms across CPSEs and Major Ports, and the role of interim orders in such disputes.