CRL.RC Nos. 611/2018 (and connected cases: 612/2018, 613/2018, 617/2018, 618/2018, 620/2018, 621/2018, 623/2018, 624/2018, 626/2018, 630/2018, 639/2018, 643/2018, 648/2018, 649/2018, 654/2018, 659/2018, 660/2018, 663/2018, 665/2018, 669/2018, 675/2018, 679/2018, 680/2018, 683/2018, 684/2018, 685/2018, 687/2018, 688/2018, 691/2018, 692/2018, 693/2018, 694/2018, 695/2018, 696/2018, 698/2018, 702/2018, 703/2018, 704/2018, 708/2018, 709/2018, 711/2018, 712/2018, 713/2018, 716/2018, 719/2018, 721/2018, 722/2018, 723/2018) The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, presided by Justice P. Somarajan, heard a batch of suo motu criminal revision cases arising from orders of numerous Judicial Magistrates of First Class, Kollam, wherein the Administrative Committee’s resolution dated 18.09.17 was invoked to initiate suo motu proceedings. The proceedings concern various St. Nos and CR numbers (e.g., ST Nos 3804/2014, 3645/2014, etc.) and involve the State of Kerala represented by Sub-Inspector of Police and individual respondents such as Vijayan, Noushad, Mukesh, Abdul Kharim, Saneesh etc. The petitions challenge magistrates’ orders under Section 258 Cr.P.C., which permits stopping proceedings in summons cases where the accused cannot be procured or costs would exceed the maximum fine. The court cites a Division Bench decision in 2023 KHC OnLine 821 (Suo motu v. State of Kerala and Another) for reference regarding the application of Section 258. The judgment clarifies the legal position and assesses whether interference is warranted. Ultimately, the court holds that the cases fall within the ambit of Section 258 Cr.P.C. and that stoppage of proceedings by the magistrate deserves no interference. Consequently, the revisions are dismissed and closed, with the bench noting the binders and procedural posture of the connected matters.
This Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 r/w Order XLII Rule 1 CPC challenges the judgment and decree in OS 224/2009 of the Munsiff Court, Changanacherry, which was thereafter affirmed by the Additional District Court (Special Court) II, Kottayam in AS No.135/2011 on 07.06.2014. The appellants contend that the decree passed against them is erroneous and seeks reversal. The core issue is whether the delay in filing the second appeal should have been condoned. The appellants obtained certified copies of the decree on 15 July 2014 but the appeal was not filed until several years later. In a supporting affidavit, they attribute the delay to misplacement of their counsel’s file during 2014 when the counsel shifted offices to Ernakulam, and later to belated realization only in late 2019. The respondents did not appear. The High Court of Kerala examined the application for condonation under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, citing several decisions, including Majji Sannemma and older precedents, to assess whether there was a “sufficient cause.” The court emphasized that while liberal construction is allowed, it cannot condone neglect or dilatory tactics without bonafides. It ultimately held that no sufficient cause had been shown for such a long delay and that the High Court’s order condoning delay was unsustainable. Consequently, the delay petition was dismissed, and the second appeal was dismissed as barred by limitation.
These Regular Second Appeals arise from a common judgment and decree that dismissed the appeals and confirmed the trial court’s dismissal of O.S.226/2000 and O.S.65/2000, relating to Ext.B2, a sale deed No.1052/83 of SRO Vazhakkad. The plaintiff, Amina Umma, claimed Ext.B2 (assignment in favour of her four daughters) was void, alleging fabrication and undue influence by her sons and their spouses. The trial court and the first appellate court disbelieved PW1’s testimony that Ext.B2 was not executed by her, despite PW2’s handwriting report (Ext.A4) suggesting the disputed signatures did not match her admitted signatures. The High Court re-evaluated the record, holding that in cases involving illiterate or pardanashi executants the burden lies on the beneficiaries to prove proper execution and understanding of the document, and that the trial and first appellate courts failed to consider vital aspects, including Ext.A4 and other surrounding circumstances. On these grounds, the court found Ext.B2 to be a fabrication not binding on PW1 and decreed O.S.226/2000, while dismissing O.S.65/2000. The judgment set aside the concurrent findings, allowed the appeals, and directed relief consistent with the declared nullity of Ext.B2, with no costs due to the close kinship of the parties.
On 3 February 2017 at Beverage junction, Pothanicadu, the deceased Alice was struck by a motorcycle driven by the second respondent, sustaining fatal injuries. Her brothers and sisters filed O.P. MV No. 651/2017 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Muvattupuzha seeking compensation for the death of Alice, originally claiming ₹29.5 lakh, later quantified by the Tribunal as ₹66,001 (rounded to ₹66,100). The insurer admitted the policy but disputed the compensation. The Tribunal held that the appellants cannot be treated as dependents since the deceased was unmarried, and consequently did not award loss of dependency; notional income was fixed at ₹7,000 per month. The appellants argued for enhancement by applying the loss of dependency head and cited Sijo Jose v Rejender Kumar Saini to buttress the principle of loss of estate when dependency is absent. The High Court, applying Sudhakar and Joseph v. Giji Varghese, held that where dependents are not established, the remedy lies in loss of estate and adopted the multiplicand–multiplier method, using one-third of the deceaseds income and a multiplier of 9 (deceased age 60). The Court allowed the appeal in part, awarding an additional ₹2,37,000 for loss of estate, with 8% interest and costs, to be deposited within two months, and directed the claimant to furnish PAN Aadhaar and bank details for disbursement.
BAIL APPL. NO. 815 OF 2024 This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Rajeev Kumar, the sole accused in Crime No.6/2023 of the Directorate of Revenue Intelligence (DRI), Calicut Regional Unit, Kozhikode, in connection with offences under Section 21(c) read with Section 8(c) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. Arrested on 28 August 2023, the accused was intercepted at Calicut International Airport following an intelligence report that he would arrive by Air Arabia Flight G9454 around 3:45 a.m. A seizure of contraband comprising 3,490.49 grams of cocaine and 1,296.2 grams of heroin was made from the accused and several concealments. The Chemical Analysis Report confirmed cocaine and heroin. The petitioner’s counsel contends innocence, false implication, and illegality of the search; argues detention is unnecessary as investigation is complete and recovery has been effected. The State’s counsel disputes bail, highlighting the contraband’s commercial quantity and the accused’s conscious possession, invoking Section 37 of the NDPS Act. The court discusses the NDPS framework, citing Supreme Court precedents (Shiv Shanker Kesari; Nawaz Khan; Sarkar) to articulate the stringent bail standard and the necessity of reasonable grounds. Upon evaluation, the court finds no reasonable grounds to grant bail given the commercial quantity, seriousness, and lack of domestic ties, and accordingly dismisses the application.
BAIL APPL. NO. 2288 OF 2024 This bail petition, under Section 439 CrPC, arises out of Crime No. 08/2024 registered by the Excise Enforcement and Narcotic Special Squad, Malappuram, alleging offences under Sections 20(b)(ii)B and 29 of the NDPS Act. The petitioner, Niyas C., aged 34, was arrested on 06 February 2024 while transporting 6.03 kilograms of ganja in an autorickshaw KL-55B-9780. The petition contends innocence and false implication, noting the ongoing investigation and completion of recovery. It is argued that the contraband quantity is intermediate and thus the stringent rigour of Section 37 NDPS should not apply, and bail should be granted. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, but conceded that the contraband is of intermediate quantity and that the petitioner has no prior antecedents. After hearing, the learned judge considered the circumstances: the petitioner has been in judicial custody since 06 February 2024, recovery has been effected, investigation is practically complete, and there is no criminal record. The court held that continued detention is not necessary, and granted bail on a bond of Rs 1,00,000 with two sureties of equal amount, subject to conditions including appearance before IO on Saturdays for two months, non-interference with witnesses, non-commission of offences while on bail, surrender of passport, and power to cancel bail for violation. The order cites Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and Anr. as an authority that investigations can proceed during bail.
This is a criminal appeal filed by Anil Kumar, the sole accused in Cr. App. No.370 of 2023, challenging a life imprisonment judgment under Section 302 IPC passed by the Additional Sessions Judge, Kollam, in Sessions Case No.186/2018. The prosecution's case is that on 31.10.2017, while the couple resided in a single-bedroom flat in Velicham Nagar, Kollam, the accused, driven by suspicion over his wife Moly’s fidelity, poured kerosene on her, and set her on fire with a match, causing more than 70% burns. She succumbed on 6.11.2017. Three neighboring women (PWs 1–3) witnessed the incident and immediately intervened, attempting to rescue; they later gave consistent testimonies corroborated by 164 CrPC statements (Exts. P1–P3). A dying declaration (Ext. P7) recorded through finger spelling by a deaf-mad interpreter (PW10) and translated by PW26 is key to the prosecution’s case, attaching to the narrative of conjugal suspicion and premeditation. Medical evidence (Exts. P8, P9, P14) corroborates the extent of injuries and cause of death. The defense argued unreliability of witnesses and lack of premeditation, while the prosecution urged strict adherence to dying declaration jurisprudence. The High Court, after evaluating the evidence and following established principles on dying declarations and the intent required for murder, upheld the conviction as sustainable and refused to disturb the trial court’s findings, confirming the life sentence and fine.
WA 811 of 2020 (and connected cases) This is a Kerala High Court Full Bench decision interpreting the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995 in light of amendments and subsequent Supreme Court guidance. The appeals arise from a common judgment of February 25, 2020, in W.P.(C) 2019-2019 series which allowed pension calculations without the ceiling of the maximum pensionable salary by permitting higher- salary contributions to the pension fund. The Division Bench’s reference to Sasikumar P. v. Union of India (ILR 2019 Ker. 614) and RC Gupta v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner (2018) 14 SCC 809 triggered reconsideration of the scheme’s core premises. The Full Bench (Anil K. Narendran, J., with Viju Abraham, J., and G. Girish, J.) held that Sasikumar P. requires reconsideration, especially insofar as it strikes down the 2014 Employees’ Pension Scheme amendments that tie pension to actual salary via regular contributions. It affirmed guidance from the Three-Judge Bench in Sunil Kumar B. and others (AIR 2022 SC 5634) and directed EPFO to reassess higher-pension entitlements consistent with that decision, within eight weeks as directed by Sunil Kumar, and with RC Gupta as supportive authority. The court concluded that the fund’s corpus integrity and the interests of regular contributors must be balanced, overruling the narrower reading of Sasikumar P. in respect of post-2014 amendments.
CON.CASE(C) NO. 2260 OF 2019 This Contempt Case (Civil) arises from W.P.(C) No.32557/2016 and concerns petitioners—K.P. Sasidharan, K. Vijayan, and Chandrika Kumari K.C.—all junior assistants of the Kerala State Civil Supplies Corporation—alleging willful disobedience of Annexure A1, the 12 October 2018 judgment in W.P.(C) No.32557/2016 and connected matters. They filed under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, seeking enforcement of higher pension benefits. Respondents, the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO), represented by Sunil Barthwal and Andrew Prabhu, contend that post-2018 developments and the Supreme Court’s 4 November 2022 decision in Employees Provident Fund Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B. necessitate reconsideration by EPFO in accordance with law. The Supreme Court’s 2022 judgment upheld the validity of G.S.R.609(E) (2014) and directed implementation of amended pension provisions, with read-down directions and time extensions for certain options, along with other consequential directives under the Employees Provident Funds Act and the pension scheme. The Kerala High Court notes this decision while interpreting that the petitioners’ claim to higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO in light of the 2022 ruling. Annexure A1 is the certified copy of the 2018 judgment. The court ultimately closes the contempt petition, without prejudice to EPFO’s right to reconsider entitlement according to law post-2022 judgment.
CRL.M.C Nos. 8368 of 2023 & 2531 of 2024 Two petitions under section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure were heard together seeking to quash the FIR (Annexure-A1) and the final report (Annexure-A3) and all further proceedings in CC No. 300/2021 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Aluva, arising from Crime No. 182/2021 of the Elamakkara Police Station. The petitioners in CRL.M.C. No. 8368/2023 are Abbey Paul and Mercy Joseph (accused Nos. 2 & 3); in CRL.M.C. No. 2531/2024 the petitioner is Dr. Thomas Paul (accused No.1). The offences alleged are under Section 498A IPC, rooted in a marriage between the first accused and the second respondent, Priya Ajith Kunnel. The petitions contend that the matrimonial dispute has been amicably settled, with the second respondent executing Annexure-A2 affidavit stating no subsisting grievance and no objection to quashing. The State public prosecutor and the second respondent’s counsel corroborate the settlement, and the second respondent appeared online to reiterate no objection. The court cites Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) 10 SCC 303 and Aahir @ Parbatbhai Bhimsinhbhai Karmur v. State of Gujarat (2017) 9 SCC 641 to reiterate that amicable settlements, in non-serious offences, may justify quashing to secure ends of justice. After examining the materials, the judge holds that continued proceedings would waste judicial time and not serve public interest, and allows the petitions, quashing the FIR, final report, and all further proceedings.
BAIL APPL. NO. 708 OF 2024 Rajesh R, the fourth accused in Crime No.1710/2023 of Poojappura Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC in a six-accused murder case involving multiple IPC offences (294(b), 341, 323, 324, 302, 506(ii) and 34). Arrested on 12.11.2023, he had previously moved BA No.10711/2023, which was dismissed on 05.01.2024. The prosecution’s case alleges an unlawful assembly in which the accused followed the de facto complainant and deceased to Hill View Hotel, assaulted the deceased and injured the complainant, culminating in the death of the deceased by the first accused. The fourth accused is alleged to have participated in the beating. The petitioner contends innocence and argues there is no identifiable overt act linking him to the predicate offence under 302; he claims 90 days of custody, completed investigation, and final charge report with changed circumstances warranting bail. The Public Prosecutor counters, asserting a specific overt act, corroborated by postmortem findings and the I.O.’s report; the petitioner is a history-sheeter with prior cases; risk of witness intimidation and evidence tampering if released. The court consults Supreme Court bail jurisprudence: Prasanta Kumar Sarkar, Kalyan Chandra Sarkar, Mahipal, and Ash Mohammad, emphasizing that bail involves a balancing of factors, though no straitjacket formula exists. It notes CCTV evidence suggesting presence at the scene, the gravity of the offence, and antecedents, and ultimately denies the bail application, dismissing the petition to allow the case to proceed to trial.
BAIL APPL. NO. 9347 OF 2023 This is a bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed by Manoj and Thankamaniyan, petitioners/accused in Crime No.887/2023 of Nemom Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, for offences under IPC sections 420, 405 and 468 read with section 34. The matter was heard by Justice C.S. Dias. The petitioners, represented by counsel Vishnu Bhuvanendran and others, sought pre-arrest bail. The Respondents included the State of Kerala, and Omanakkuttan (impleaded as Addl R2) along with intervenor/defacto complainant, represented by their counsel. At an initial hearing, the matter was referred to mediation, and later a Memorandum of Settlement dated 05.03.2024 was executed amicably between the petitioners and the defacto complainant/intervenor. On considering the facts, the court found custodial interrogation not necessary and granted pre-arrest bail subject to standard conditions: surrender within ten days; if arrested, production before the jurisdictional court; bond of Rs.50,000 with two solvent sureties; cooperation with investigation; no witness intimidation; no other offences; power to cancel bail on violation; and possibility of modifying bail conditions. The decision cites Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) for editorial guidance on bail conditions. The judgment was delivered on 18 March 2024.
Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd. (the revision petitioner) challenged an order of the VI Addl District Court, Ernakulam, in O.P Ele 586 of 2013, which enhanced compensation payable to the first respondent for diminution in land value caused by the construction of a 400 kV transmission line across his property. The dispute concerns 13.34 Ares in Sy.No.613/B, Mukkannur Village, Aluva Taluk. The court below rejected the claim for enhanced compensation for the value of trees but granted enhancement for diminution in land value after considering Ext.A5, Ext.C10 and Ext.C10(a) (commission report and sketch). The Advocate Commissioner found the petition schedule property near essential facilities, including a bank, hospital and school, and the court fixed land value at Rs.1,80,063 per cent, about 20% lower than Ext.A5, with 40% of the land value for the central corridor and 20% for the outer corridor, totaling Rs.3,27,426. The petitioner argued these figures are exorbitant, that reliance on Ext.A5 was flawed, and that Government-fixation of fair value should bound the court. The respondent contended the lower court properly weighed factors such as land nature, commercial importance and proximity to infrastructure. The High Court, applying the KSEB v Livisha framework and citing V.V. Jayaram, rejected the revision and upheld the lower court’s order, finding no illegality or material irregularity and concluding the revision petition could not succeed.
This writ petition, filed by Abhijith P., Nitheesh P.C., and Anil A., challenges the respondents’ refusal to fill vacant clerical posts at the 5th respondent, the Institute of Integrated Medical Sciences (GMC Palakkad), under direct recruitment in Palakkad district. By Ext.P-4 (20 January 2021), the government declared the 5th respondent a society under the Kerala Public Service Commission (Additional Functions as Respects Certain Societies) Act, 1996, thus bringing its appointments under PSC purview. Draft Special Rules for non-teaching staff were prepared (Ext.P-10) but not finalised, delaying PSC recruitment. The petitioners seek a declaration that vacancies must be filled from Ext.P-2 ranked list and a direction to finalise and publish the Special Rules without further delay. The government counters that Special Rules are not finalised and the process—considering qualifications, age, experience—remains ongoing; hence the petition is premature. The petition relies on Government Circular dated 7 November 2001 based on this court’s O.P. No. 4261 of 2001 and on Biju C.V. v. Jashna K.J. The Division Bench’s 2022 decision in W.A. No. 764/2022 is cited to argue that Palakkad Medical Officers are state servants and that interim appointments may be made from the PSC list. The court ultimately directs that, until the Special Rules are finalised, direct recruitment appointments in Palakkad shall be made only from Ext.P-2, with a six‑month deadline to finalise the rules, and disposes of the petition accordingly.
OP(CAT) Nos. 79/2015 & 72/2016 These petitions concern pay fixation and recovery issues arising from BSNL employees absorbed from the Department of Telecom in 2000 under the Biennial Cadre Review (BCR) regime and subsequently re-fixation under BSNL regulations (2008). The petitioners, retired telecom mechanics who were promoted and fixed under FR-22 options, alleged that their pay was not correctly rectified under the 2006 OM and that recoveries effected from pension papers were improper. The Central Administrative Tribunal had found that the pay fixation followed the 2008 BSNL regulations, and it directed that recoveries from pension papers be interfered with. The Kerala High Court, while declining to disturb the pay fixation on account of the 2008-regulation framework, invoked the recovery guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (AIR 2015 SC 696) to hold that recoveries were unsustainable when effected within one year of retirement. Accordingly, the court ordered the recovery to be refunded to the petitioners within two months, with pension and other benefits to be calculated based on the refixed pay. In short, pay fixation under the 2008 BSNL regulations was upheld; however, the recoveries were ordered to be reversed in light of Rafiq Masih guidelines. The petitions are disposed of accordingly.
This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Anoop, accused No.6 in Crime No.1710/2023 of Poojappura Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, registered for offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 294(b), 341, 323, 324, 325, 326, 302 and 506(ii) r/w Section 149. The High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, presided over by Justice C.S. Dias, on 21 February 2024, dismissed the application. The prosecution case alleges that on 07.11.2023, around 23:30 hours, six accused formed an unlawful assembly and, in pursuance of a common intention, pursued the defacto complainant and the deceased after a previous dispute, stabbing both; the 6th accused participated in brutal beating, causing the death of the deceased. The petitioner contends total innocence, claiming false implication and highlighting Annexure A2 showing injuries from a prior accident. He has been in custody since 08.11.2023 (about 105 days). The prosecution objects, citing CCTV visuals and the accused’s participation in other cases (NDPS and Juvenile Justice Act) indicating criminal antecedents, with a risk of witness tampering and adverse societal impact if released. The court underscored the broad discretion in bail decisions under Section 439 CrPC and relied on Supreme Court bail precedents to assess prima facie involvement, gravity of the offence, risk of tampering, and societal interest. After considering the materials and submissions, the court found grave and severe accusations, evidence of involvement, and reasonable apprehension of witness interference, thus denying bail. The application was dismissed.
Bail Application No. 716 of 2024 Chandran, the second accused in Crime No.50/2024 of the Vellarikundu Police Station, Kasaragod, seeks pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC in connection with offences under IPC Sections 341 and 324 (later upgraded to 326) for an alleged assault on the complainant on the night of 14 January 2024. The prosecution contends that the defacto complainant was forcibly restrained and assaulted with an iron rod and a wooden stick, resulting in grievous injuries including a type 2 compound fracture of the right tibia and fibula, a fracture of the left ulna, and a fibular fracture, as evidenced by the accident register cum wound certificate dated 15 January 2024. The petitioner’s counsel argues innocence, claiming the complainant trespassed into the petitioner’s sister-in-law’s house and instigated trouble, with no complicity by the petitioner and no necessity for custodial interrogation; the petitioner is willing to cooperate and abide by strict conditions. The Public Prosecutor counters that the investigation is in its nascent stage, custodial interrogation is necessary, and early release would hamper the process. The court cites Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra and the Sibbia principles to emphasize that anticipatory bail guidelines are not rigid and discretion under Section 438 CrPC must be exercised with care, and also cites Jai Prakash Singh to underscore that pre-arrest bail is an extraordinary privilege. After careful consideration, the court holds that the petitioner is not entitled to pre-arrest bail, and the bail application is dismissed, while directing surrender within 10 days with further directions for expeditious consideration of any subsequent bail application.
RSA No. 100 of 2017 & RSA No. 104 of 2017 The Regular Second Appeals (RSA Nos. 100 and 104 of 2017) before the Kerala High Court arise from concurrent decrees in two suits before the Munsiff Court, Kayamkulam, and the Additional District Judge, Mavelikkara. In O.S. No. 244/2006, Somarajan and another sought a permanent injunction against Gopalakrishnan and his counterpart, while O.S. No. 313/2006, filed by Gopalakrishnan, claimed tenancy and related rights. The trial court dismissed the first suit and decreed the second in favour of Gopalakrishnan, directing possession to be handed to the plaintiffs, along with arrears and damages. The appellate court affirmed these verdicts. The appellants contend Ext. A3 (sale deed No.114/2005) was executed as security for a loan and that there was an oral agreement for reconveyance; they argue the real relief is for a declaration of Ext. A3 as security and for a specific performance remedy, which is time-barred. The respondents maintain Ext. A3 was an outright sale, with mutation and tax payments supporting occupancy and ownership; no challenge to Ext. A3 at the trial or appeal stage has been sustained. The High Court, reviewing admission in light of Section 100 CPC and Order XLII, finds no substantial question of law and dismisses the appeals without admission, upholding the concurrent verdicts. Interlocutory applications are also dismissed.
Subaida P., the petitioner, is the absolute owner in possession of 2.21 acres in Sy. No. 83/7-7 in Cheriyamundam Village, Malappuram. She challenged Ext. P5, a Revenue Divisional Officer order, which rejected her Form 5 application under Rule 4(d) of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Rules, 2008 for removal of her land from the Data Bank. The petitioner argued that the land is not paddy land or wetland under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, and that its inclusion as nilam was erroneous since the area is surrounded by commercial buildings, a major district road to the east, and has long ceased to be a paddy/wetland; she had moved for data-bank removal in Ext. P2. Reports (Ext. P3 from the Agricultural Officer and Ext. P4 from KSRSEC) describe surrounding structures, mixed vegetation, and partially fallow land, and note that the land may have been converted after 2008. The court observes that wetland/paddy land classification hinges on status as of the date of coming into force of the Act, 2008, and reviews precedents including Mather Nagar Residents Association v. District Collector, Adani Infrastructures v. State of Kerala, and Arthasasthra Ventures v. State of Kerala, which hold fallow land is not wetland and emphasize careful consideration of the 2008 status. The court sets aside Ext. P5 for non‑application of mind and directs reconsideration by the RDO based on Ext. P4 and the court’s observations, within two months.
BAIL APPL. NO. 897 OF 2024 Jerin, a 23-year-old accused, is the second accused in Crime No.32/2024 of Ochira Police Station, Kollam, charged with offences under Sections 341, 323, 324, 308, 143, 145, 147, 148 and 149 IPC. He seeks pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC. The prosecution alleges that on 08.01.2024, the accused, along with five others, restrained the defacto complainant and his friend and assaulted them with a rock and a stem of a plantain bunch, resulting in injuries to both victims. The prosecution relies on the injury certificates showing hematoma and abrasions. The petitioner’s counsel argues the accused is innocent and that the alleged overt act pertains to the 1st accused, hence Section 308 is not made out; custodial interrogation is unnecessary as recovery has been effected. The Public Prosecutor counters, citing injury reports to argue that custodial interrogation is necessary to further investigation and that bail would impede the investigation. The court discusses the Supreme Court principles on anticipatory bail (Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre; Sibbia; Jai Prakash Singh) stressing discretion, case-specific evaluation, and the exceptional nature of bail. After considering the materials and rival submissions, the court holds that the petitioner has not shown exceptional grounds for pre-arrest bail and dismisses the application. It directs surrender within 10 days for potential future bail consideration on merits, if surrendered.