Aggrieved by a 2008 conviction for offences under the Abkari Act, Ponnan challenged his trial court’s verdict in this Kerala High Court criminal appeal. The prosecution case placed him at his Paravur residence on 29 July 2005, where 115 litres of illicit arrack and 50 litres of wash were seized. The trial court convicted under sections 8(2) and 55(g) of the Abkari Act, sentencing two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs.1 lakh after hearing evidence and defense. On appeal, the appellant argued three defects: (i) the seizure mahazar failed to describe the seal affixed on the sample bottles; (ii) the forwarding note lacked the specimen of the seal; and (iii) the prosecution failed to prove conscious possession. The court noted defects in Ext. P3 mahazar and the forwarding note, and invoked Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala to hold that the specimen of the seal must be produced to verify the sample; Rajamma v. State of Kerala was cited to demand production of seal specimens before the Chemical Examiner; and jurisprudence on possession—Ravi C., Gunwantlal and Santhosh—was invoked to explain that possession requires dominion or control, with constructive and conscious possession as essential. The High Court found no link tying the accused to the contraband or the laboratory sample and, on that basis, held the evidence insufficient. Accordingly, the conviction and sentence were set aside, the appellant acquitted and released. The appeal was allowed.
CRL.A Nos.153/2017, 785/2016 The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, presided over by Dr. Justice Kauser Edappagath, delivered a consolidated judgment on 9 December 2022 in two criminal appeals (CRL.A. Nos. 153 of 2017 and 785 of 2016) arising from SC 74/2009. The cases concern NDPS Act offences registered as Crime No. 197/1997 against three accused at Thampanoor, Thiruvananthapuram, for possession of ganja. The trial court convicted accused Nos. 2 and 3 under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) NDPS with four years’ rigorous imprisonment and fines; accused No.1 had died. The High Court analyzed per-accused possession weights: 250 g (accused 1), 1.65 kg (accused 2), and 1 kg (accused 3). The Court accepted the prosecution's seizure and chain of custody but found that the per-person quantity of accused No.3 fell within the “small quantity” limit, and the evidence did not show common possession or shared intent to make a commercial batch. Relying on a precedent in Muthu Kumar v. SH0, it held that Section 20(b)(ii)(C) cannot apply where each person’s possession does not amount to a commercial quantity. Consequently, accused No.3’s conviction was altered to Section 20(b)(ii)(A) with a nine-month sentence already endured; accused No.2’s conviction stood. The appeals: 785/2016 allowed in part; 153/2017 dismissed. The judgment clarifies quantification per individual possession under NDPS and limits the reach of aggregate quantities.
This is a criminal appeal preferred by two accused, Anil Kumar and Ashok Kumar, challenging their conviction under Sections 55(a) and 58 of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc), Fast Track Court No.1, Thrissur, for possession of illicit liquor. The trial court sentenced each to three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh for each section, with the sentences to run concurrently. The prosecution’s case rests on the seizure of contraband spirits from a building in Kanattukara Desom, Thrissur, on 24.07.2002, with lab analysis and chain-of-custody facts disputed. On appeal, the High Court scrutinized delays in production of seized articles, whether the samples were actually subjected to chemical analysis, and whether the detecting officer had valid Abkari powers. It relied on jurisprudence about the necessity of a tamper-proof chain of custody, the requirement to prove that the seized sample corresponds to the lab analysis, and the mandatory arrest memo prescribed by D.K. Basu. The court found numerous infirmities: unexplained delays, lack of seal description and specimen before court, and the absence of proper arrest memos. It ultimately held that the prosecution failed to establish essential links and acquitted the appellants, allowing the appeal.
ITA Nos.45/2019, 47/2019, 50/2019, 51/2019 Avathar Jewellers, a partnership firm engaged in the jewellery business, challenged four cross-appeals before the Kerala High Court arising from assessments under Section 143(3) read with Section 153C of the Income Tax Act for AY 2009-10 and 2010-11, as adjudicated by the ITAT Cochin Bench in ITA Nos. 580/Coch/2017, 582/Coch/2017 and 583/Coch/2017. The ITAT dismissed the delay condonation petitions and the appeals, noting the absence of a satisfactory explanation for the late filing. The appellant contends that the delay—217 days in aggregate—was occasioned by the Managing Partner’s police custody, which prevented him from signing documents required to file the appeals; Annexure-D in the memorandum of appeal explains the circumstance. Relying on Supreme Court jurisprudence starting with Esha Bhattacharjee, the appellant argues a liberal, justice-oriented approach to condonation of delay and asserts that substantial justice should prevail over strict technicalities. The respondents contend the delay was excessive and not adequately explained, and that the Tribunal’s refusal to condone it was correct. The High Court agrees with the appellant that the Tribunals misapplied the law and that the delay should be condoned in view of the bonafide circumstances. Accordingly, it sets aside the ITAT orders, condones the delay, and directs the ITAT to decide the appeals on merits within three months from receipt of a copy of the judgment. The appeals are allowed.
Varun @ Yadhu, the petitioner, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC in Crime No.1661/2023 of Thalassery Police Station, Kannur, for offences under Sections 341, 324 and 308 IPC. Arrested on 26.12.2023, the accusation is that on 25.12.2023, around 6:30 am, while the de facto complainant was returning from church, the petitioner restrained him and attempted to strike him with a beer bottle; the blow grazed the head, causing grievous injuries. The prosecution contends the case involves a history-sheeter with 17 cases; investigation incomplete, risk of re-offending, witness intimidation and tampering with evidence. The petitioner claims false implication, political motivation, and that Section 308 was added to deny bail; he asserts prior cases are mostly pre-2010 and that he has been honorably acquitted in many. He has been in judicial custody since 26.12.2023, around 47 days, and is the sole breadwinner; he offers to comply with stringent conditions. The State opposes bail on grounds of antecedents and ongoing investigation. The High Court cites Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh, and State of Kerala v. Raneef to emphasize the presumption of innocence and that bail is the rule, not imprisonment before conviction. After evaluating the facts, the court concludes continued detention is unnecessary and grants bail with conditions, while keeping the investigation and recovery powers intact as per judicial guidance.
This Writ Petition (C) No. 33431/2014 filed by four family members of Govinda Panicker seeks renewal of a kuthakapattom lease for 75 cents of kayalpuramboke land in Survey No. 236/1, Panavally Village, adjoining the petitioners’ land in Survey No. 197/9. The petitioners contend that they are entitled to a long-term lease under the Kuthakapattom Rules, 1947 (Travancore), and challenge prior Government orders regarding the fixation of land value and assignment. The matter traces back to 1992 when an attempt to assign the land was initially rejected, then reconsidered, with a recommendation to assign at Rs. 150 per cent; the Government later fixed a far higher price, which this Court quashed in Ext.P5 (2006) and directed reconsideration. The Division Bench’s WA No. 1756/2012 observation suggested that, if the petitioners have any interest in land as per the Kuthakapattom lease, they may pursue remedies in accordance with law. The Government’s counter-affidavit indicates the Landslide is a kayalpuramboke and subject to water-body constraints. The learned Judge concluded that the petitioners have no entitlements under Kuthakapattom Rules (both without time limit under Rule 6 and with time limit under Rule 7, which requires public auction) and that the land on river/watercourses cannot be alienated. Citing Susetha, M.C. Mehta, Intellectuals Forum and Sarvepalli Ramaiah, the Court held the land cannot be leased and dismissed the petition, directing restoration of the land to the Government within three months.
Bail Application No. 264 of 2024 (Crime No. 40/2024) This Kerala High Court bail application concerns three accused in Crime No. 40/2024 of Bekal Police Station, Kasaragod. The petitioners—Rasheed K., Rashid, and Burhanudheen B.—approached the High Court under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure for bail after their arrest on 16.01.2024 in connection with offences under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 324, 427, 308, and 149, allegedly committed by an unlawful assembly on 13.01.2024 around 22:30 hours, during which a soda bottle was allegedly thrown at the informant, resulting in injuries. The respondents contended that the investigation was ongoing and that a specific overt act was attributed to the first accused. The petitioners contended their innocence, claiming false implication; they pointed to the wound certificate, noting it did not indicate grave injury, and referred to Annexure-A5, which recorded that accused 5–9 had been granted pre-arrest bail on grounds of no serious injuries. The court observed that the petitioners had been in judicial custody since 16.01.2024, exceeding 21 days, and that the investigation was virtually complete with recoveries effected, and that there were no noted criminal antecedents. It relied on the principle cited in Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and another to justify bail with conditions. The order grants bail on a Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, subject to conditions including periodic IO appearances, no tampering with witnesses, surrender of passports, and potential cancellation upon violation, while allowing the IO to continue investigations and recoveries if necessary.
This writ petition (criminal) under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenges a detention order passed under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAA(P)A). The petition is a second habeas corpus challenge; the earlier W.P.(Crl).No.789/2023 was dismissed by this Court on 13 December 2023. Ramseena S, the wife of the detenu, contends that the detention order was illegal and relies on fresh grounds not canvassed in the previous petition, notably that the detenu was not released on bail as represented and remains in judicial custody due to a bar under Section 37 of the NDPS Act. The petitioner argues there is no bar to successive habeas petitions under Article 226, citing Nisha Salim v. State of Kerala. The respondents maintain that a bar exists on entertaining successive petitions for habeas under Article 226 and that the remedy lies in approaching the Supreme Court under Article 32 or filing a civil appeal, citing Ghulam Sarwar v. Union of India. The Court discusses habeas corpus, administrative-law principles for detention orders, and the doctrine of res judicata in writ jurisdiction, citing Lallubhai Jogibhai Patel and Bandopadhya as authority for limitations on repeated challenges. Ultimately, the Division Bench holds that the successive petition challenging the same detention order is not maintainable and dismisses the writ, emphasizing liberty against preventive detention but respecting finality where grounds are not essentially fresh.
WP(C) No. 28200/2021; WP(C) No. 31265/2023 The petitions concern the management and ownership of a private school at Malappuram. The petitioner in WP(C) No. 28200/21, Sayyid Hashim K.V.K, claims entitlement to be the Manager of the school in view of a 2018 sale (Ext. P3) which, after prior assignments dating to 1988, culminated in a change of management recognized by the AEO and later resisted by the Director of General Education. The mother in the same case and other siblings challenge the transfer, alleging invalid alienation; civil suits were filed (and later some withdrawn) while authorities delayed final orders. WP(C) No. 31265/2023 is filed by the mother of the petitioner challenging orders (Exts. P4 and P5) appointing a temporary Manager and seeking continued management until the civil suits resolve. The court heard rival submissions: the petitioners rely on Rule 5A, Chapter III of the Kerala Education Rules (KER) and on Roopa v. State of Kerala (2014) to contend that Section 6 of the Kerala Education Act does not bar transfer of a running school; respondents contend pendency of suits justifies executive restraint. The Court quashed Exts. P9 and P12 in 28200/21 and directed consideration of Ext. P7 under Rule 5A within six weeks, while noting the Director must honor Ext. P3 transfer and extend interim arrangements until final decision. WP( C) 31265/2023 disposed with ongoing interim arrangement.
This Division Bench of the Kerala High Court (Justices Anil K. Narendran and Harisankar V. Menon) exercises suo motu jurisdiction over a matter concerning alleged financial irregularities by the Temple Advisory Committee of Valliyamkavu Devi Temple, Idukki. Registered as DBP No. 49 of 2022 on 26 August 2022, the matter followed an Ombudsman inquiry leading to Report No. 25 of 2023 and connection with O.S. No. 323 of 2020 filed by the Travancore Devaswom Board against the temple committee, currently before the Munsiff Court, Peermedu. The Munsiff’s report dated 18 March 2024 shows that summons were served on defendants 1–4 and 6–14; defendant 5 was not served and the suit against him was dismissed; the remaining defendants have filed written statements and the suit is posted for issues on 14 June 2024. The Court traced the statutory framework: Sections 15A, 16 and 31 of the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 (as amended by Act 5 of 2007) and the supervisory role of the Board, to manage Devaswoms and conduct temple rites. It cites Ram Mohan Das v. Travancore Devaswom Board and Suo motu v. State of Kerala for fiduciary duties and parens patriae. Observing pendency of the civil suit, the Court disposes of the DBP without addressing merits, directing the Board to prosecute OS 323/2020 diligently, with power to seek expeditious disposal under Article 227 if delays persist.
Power Grid Corporation of India Ltd. challenged an order enhancing compensation for land value diminution due to the construction of a 400 KV line across the party respondents’ property in Karukutty Village, Aluva Taluk. The claimants (respondents 1–3) owned about 26 cents, with land used for cultivation and trees. The corporation had paid only Rs. 1,16,898 toward trees; no compensation was granted for diminution in land value. The trial court rejected the claim for enhanced compensation for trees for lack of independent evidence beyond an Advocate Commissioner’s report, and, for land value diminution, it relied on Ext. A5 along with Exts. C13 and C13(a) commission report and sketch, deducting 20% from Ext. A5 and determining central corridor at 40% and outer corridors at 20%, resulting in Rs. 4,70,720 to the claimants. Counsel for the Corporation argued that this diminution is exorbitant, that reliance on Ext. A5 is flawed, and that drawing lines with agriculture or small structures should not trigger such high compensation; that government valuation guidelines should not bind judicial computation, and that 9% interest on the land value is unwarranted. Counsel for the claimants contended the enhancement was properly granted after weighing all relevant factors. The High Court, applying the factors from KSEB v. Livisha and upholding the approach in V.V. Jayaram, dismissed the revision petition, finding no illegality or material irregularity in the impugned order.
The petitioner, R GOPALAKRISHNAN NAIR, a retired Chief Clerk of Southern Railway, challenges Ext.P7 (02.02.2023) of the Central Administrative Tribunal’s OA No.180/00516/2019. He retired on 31.01.1991 in the pay scale 1600-50-60-2660. The post was redesignated as Office Superintendent Grade II in 1994. After the Fifth Central Pay Commission, the post scale was revised to 5500-9000, with pension revised proportionately until 30.09.2008, after which pension was revised per the VIth CPC. Annex A6 notes a pension of Rs.2,750 (50% of Rs.5,500). The petitioner contends that pension ought to have been calculated on the revised pay scale applicable to the redesigned post (Office Superintendent Grade II), arguing the redesignation, along with subsequent pay revisions, should yield a higher pension (reflecting the pre-revised-to-revised scale transition). The respondents contend that pension is fixed on the corresponding scale of pay from which the pensioner retired; redesignation after retirement cannot trigger a further revision. The High Court relies on the apex court’s decision in K.S. Krishnaswamy (2006) 13 SCC 215 that the relevant base is the pre-revised scale at retirement, not the post from which the retirement was drawn, to determine minimum revised pension. It also references related CAT rulings (e.g., Krishnaswamy’s 2019 matter) for consistency. The court ultimately upholds the tribunal’s reasoning and dismisses the petition, declining relief to the petitioner.
This is a criminal miscellaneous case filed in the High Court of Kerala seeking to quash FIR No.6/2016 of VACB, Ernakulam. The petitioner, Dr. Riji G. Nair, served as Managing Director of the Kerala State Consumer Federation (Consumer Fed) during 2011–2013. The FIR alleges that the petitioner, along with the Chairman and Chief Operating Officer (accused Nos. 2 and 3) and others (A4–A6), abused their official positions and conspired to cause a monetary loss to the Consumer Fed by entering into agreements with event management groups under the guise of promoting Consumer Fed’s growth, resulting in unlawful gain to the private firms and a loss of about Rs. 17 lakhs. The offences cited are under Section 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120B IPC. The petitioner contends the acts were in good faith, Board-approved, aimed at publicizing Consumer Fed’s stores, and supported by annexures showing governance steps and general progress; he also notes that many related FIRs were dropped. The State counters that the FIR contains the ingredients of the offences and relies on Neeharika Infrastructure and other precedents endorsing cautious exercise of 482 Cr.P.C. The court, after hearing, declines to quash, holding that the matter should be subjected to investigation and that the petition lacks merits. The order states no observations on merits, and the petition is dismissed.
CRL.M.C. No. 7537 of 2023 This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC pending before the Kerala High Court, filed by four accused—Rahul @ Muthu, Ashwin @ Achu, Muhammed Rayan @ Rayan, and Shyam—seeking quashal of proceedings in S.C.No.621/2020 (Crime No.1403/2018, Kareekulangara Police Station, Alappuzha). The accused faced offences under sections 294(b), 324, 326, 506(ii) and 308 read with Section 34 IPC. The essence of the petition lies in a settlement between the parties, evidenced by affidavits from the victims, and the respondents’ acknowledgement of the private settlement. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing solely on settlement, but did not oppose the underlying settlement. The court invoked the legal framework laid down by the Supreme Court in State of MP v Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) 5 SCC 688, which in turn relied on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) 10 SCC 303 and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab (2014) 6 SCC 466. The decision clarifies that the power under S.482 CrPC to quash non-compoundable offences can be exercised when the dispute is private and the parties have resolved it, provided it does not involve heinous or public-interest offences or offences under special statutes. Balancing the private settlement against public interest, the court concludes that the dispute in this case is private in nature, the settlement is acceptable, and thus Cr.M.C. 7537/2023 is allowed and the proceedings in SC No.621/2020 are quashed.
Valiyath Melparambil Sreedharan, the appellant, challenges a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act for possession of 570 litres of spirit allegedly seized from a car at Iritty on 22.09.2000. The trial court convicted and sentenced him to two years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh after trial under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act. The High Court scrutinizes critical aspects of the prosecution’s chain of custody and the evidentiary value of the seized sample. Notably, there was inordinate delay before the court received the property list (Ext. P4) and the sample; the prosecution failed to offer a satisfactory explanation for the delay, raising concerns about tampering. The court emphasizes requirements from several authorities that the specimen of a seal, the nature of the seal, and the seal’s description must be recorded, with a specimen produced, so as to establish authenticity. The witnesses who safeguarded the sample (property clerk and the police constable) were not examined to prove tamper-proof despatch or the linkage to the laboratory analysis (Ext. P9). Relying on Ravi v. State of Kerala and subsequent Kerala authorities, the High Court concludes that the prosecution did not satisfactorily prove that the sample analysed in the laboratory was the same sample seized. As a result, the conviction is unsustainable and the appellant is acquitted; the appeal is allowed. The appellant is to be set at liberty.
This Kerala High Court Criminal Appeal challenges a conviction under Section 58 of the Abkari Act for possession of 8 1/2 litres of arrack. The appellant Maniyan was convicted by the trial court and sentenced to three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The appeal raises three core issues: (i) the arrest of the accused is doubtful because there was no arrest memo or arrest intimation placed before the court; (ii) the sampling of the contraband was conducted by a property clerk under a Magistrate’s instruction, a practice the appellant contends is not sanctioned by law; and (iii) there is no proof that the contraband seized at the scene was subjected to chemical analysis in a laboratory. The court examines D.K. Basu’s arrest-memo directive and cites Ramankutty, Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Baburaj, Smithesh, and Baby to stress strict compliance with arrest formalities, sampling/sealing procedures, and chain of custody. It notes delays in producing seized properties, absence of specimen seals, and gaps in linking the sample to the laboratory report Ext. P6. The prosecution’s failure to establish a tamper-proof chain and to prove that the analysed sample was the same as that seized leads to reasonable doubt. Consequently, the conviction cannot stand; the appeal is allowed and the accused is acquitted and set at liberty.
This criminal appeal, filed by the complainant Shibu L.P., arises from an order of acquittal passed by the Judicial First Class Magistrate-V, Thiruvananthapuram in C.C. No.155/2004 under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The trial court had convicted the accused on 31.01.2006, but the Sessions Court, Thiruvananthapuram, set aside that conviction and remanded for fresh disposal on the ground that PW1—the power of attorney holder for the complainant—lacked direct knowledge and his testimony was hearsay. After remand, PW1 testified further and the trial court again heard the matter; on 26.03.2008, PW1 claimed knowledge of the transaction, but the magistrate ultimately acquitted the accused. The appellant contends that the cheque was issued and signature admitted, triggering presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act, and that PW1’s earlier admission of direct knowledge should be sufficient to prove the transaction. He invokes Narayanan A.C. & anr. v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. to support filing a complaint via power of attorney and the necessity for the PoA to have witnessed or possess direct knowledge of the transaction. The High Court, however, relies on Narayanan to emphasize that a PoA cannot rely on hearsay and must demonstrate direct knowledge, failing which conviction cannot rest on such evidence. The court ultimately held that PW1’s evidence did not prove the transaction, and affirmed the acquittal. The appeal is dismissed.
The appellant, Biju s/o Jose, was convicted under Section 55(i) of the Abkari Act by the Adhoc-II (II) Additional Sessions Court, Thodupuzha, in Sessions Case No. 535 of 2006, and sentenced to six months’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. The prosecution alleged sale of Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) on 29 January 2005 at Muttom, Thodupuzha, contrary to the Abkari Act. The case was committed to the Sessions Court, and the trial culminated in conviction after recording the accused’s statement under Section 313 Cr.P.C. The High Court, however, found serious procedural and evidentiary gaps undermining the prosecution’s case: unexplained delays in producing properties and the sample before the Court; lack of evidence that the contraband reached the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory; and a long gap before analysis of the sample. Crucially, the prosecution did not examine officials who handled the sample from the Court to the laboratory; the seizure mahazar (Ext.P1) failed to describe the seal, and Ext.P7’s certificate had no corroboration about tamper-proof dispatch. Relying on Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi and other authorities, the Court held that the chain of custody and tamper-proof handling were not proven, and that the sample tested could not be reliably linked to the seized contraband. Consequently, the conviction could not stand, and the appeal was allowed with acquittal.
This is a Kerala High Court bail application under Section 439 CrPC by Shyam Kumar, the first accused in Crime No. 1583/2023 registered at Sakthikulangara Police Station, Kollam, against the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. The petition seeks release on bail while the investigation is nearing completion. The prosecution alleges involvement in transporting 2.025 kg of ganja in a car on 27 December 2023, with the contraband purchased from the third accused for sale. The petitioner contends innocence and false implication; he cites annexures including the FIR (Annexure A1), remand report (Annexure A2) and a medical certificate (Annexure A3) indicating his wife’s locomotor disability; An earlier bail application before the Court of Session was dismissed (Annexure A4). The Public Prosecutor counters with the petitioner’s alleged criminal antecedents and links to two other similar cases; argues that, despite investigation being complete, there is a likelihood of re-offending. The Court notes the contraband is an “intermediate quantity” and that the investigation is practically complete, thus concluding that further detention is not necessary. Under Section 37 NDPS, the rigour does not apply here, and bail is granted subject to stringent conditions: appearance before the IO on Saturdays, prohibition on tampering with witnesses, surrender of passport, and possible cancellation of bail for violations, as supported by a cited Supreme Court principle from Sushila Aggarwal.
Joy Alukkas India Pvt Ltd, a KVAT registered dealer dealing in gold and diamonds, challenged an assessment for 2009-10 that disallowed input tax credit (ITC) on purchases from dealers who opted for the compounding scheme under Section 8(f) of the KVAT Act. The petitioner argued that Section 11(5)(c) of the KVAT Act, which prohibits ITC for purchases from compounded dealers, coupled with the first proviso to Section 8(f) and Section 30, creates inconsistencies and infringes the right to credit, particularly since compounding enables tax collection by dealers with excess tax to be paid to the government. The respondents contended ITC is a concession and not a vested right; restricting ITC is within the legislature’s competence to regulate a complex, revenue-raising regime, and there is no unconstitutional discrimination since treatment varies across sectors and dealers. The High Court analyzed Sections 11(5)(c), 8(f) proviso, and Section 30, and, following its earlier decision in Amrutheswari Jewellers v. State of Kerala, upheld the constitutional validity of Section 11(5)(c). It held the ITC framework is a concession that must be availed per statute, and differences between compounded and non-compounded dealers are rational. Consequently, the petition was dismissed, though the petitioner retained the right to challenge the Ext.P5 assessment order by law.