Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 676 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 5340 of 2022

WP(C) No. 5340 of 2022, High Court of Kerala

This writ petition challenges the Third Professional MBBS Degree Part-II Supplementary examinations (General Medicine Paper-I held on 22 November 2021 and Paper-II on 24 November 2021) conducted by the Kerala University of Health Sciences (KUHS). The petitioners, a batch of MBBS students, contend that the question papers deviated from the KUHS Examination Manual (Exhibit P9), the syllabus and the model question papers (Exhibits P10–P12), by disproportionately featuring Dermatology and Psychiatry questions and not adhering to prescribed topic distribution. They allege that the discrepancies caused mass failure and unusually low pass percentages; they seek reliefs including granting grace marks, declaring Pass on the basis of grace marks, and directing a proper enquiry into representations (Exhibits P13–P17) and expeditious action on Exhibit P14. KUHS responds that question papers are prepared by a vetted panel of subject experts, scrutinizers verify conformity to the syllabus, and that General Medicine being a vast domain cannot be rigidly demarcated; it asserts there was no violation of statutory provisions and that the declines in pass rate are not attributable to improper paper setting. The learned Judge defers to expert educational bodies, cites established authorities that courts should refrain from interfering in academic policy, and ultimately dismisses the petition with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) No.65 of 2022

Sunitha Ann Varghese and Sevyan v. Nibu Mathew Titus, Lessy Titus and Binu Abraham Titus

This is a constitutional petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging Ext. P8, the order dated 21.06.2018 passed by the Family Court, Thiruvalla in I.A.825 of 2017 in O.P.358 of 2013. The original petition (OP) 358/2013, filed for patrimony, was dismissed for default in 2015; multiple restoration petitions (IA 1279/2015, IA 533/2016, IA 337/2017) followed and were dismissed at various stages for default or non‑appearance. On 29.04.2017, a restoration was allowed, but the Family Court allegedly restored OP 358/2013 rather than the restoration applications, leading to IA 825/2017 being filed for review. The Family Court, on 21.06.2018, allowed IA 825/2017, recalled the 29.04.2017 restoration order, and again dismissed OP 358/2013. The petitioners contend procedural lapses and seek restoration on merits, arguing that defaults occurred due to circumstances such as the first petitioner’s stay in Kuwait and communication gaps with counsel. The Kerala High Court, invoking supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227, and relying on Rohin Thapa v. Rohit Dora and Kozhikkara Veettil Saidalavi, held that merits should guide litigation where possible and set aside Ext. P8, directing restoration of OP 358/2013 on file and proceeding thereon on merits.

High Court of Kerala
WA Nos. 236, 271 and 491 of 2021

WA Nos. 236, 271 and 491 of 2021 (In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam)

These writ appeals arise from a challenge to the selection and appointment for the post of Assistant Professor in Environmental Science at St. John’s College, Anchal. The petitioner in WA 271, Dr. Reshmi R.R., contends that the Selection Committee acted with bias and favoritism, depriving her of a fair chance in the interview process and alleging that the 9th respondent, Dr. T. Alexander, was improperly favored. Exts. P6 and P7 indicate alleged nepotism, while Ext. P9 (Facebook photographs) were cited as supportive but not determinative evidence of close ties between the 8th respondent (HoD) and the 9th respondent. The court reviews the principles governing bias, including the “real likelihood of bias” standard, the doctrine of “no man can be a judge in his own cause,” and the coram non judice concept, drawing on authorities like Kraipak, Ranjit Thakur, and Secretary of Government v. Munuswamy. It emphasizes that while an expert committee conducts viva voce and assigns marks, the court’s role is limited to assessing whether there is a real likelihood of bias or illegality, not re-evaluating merits. The court also considers UGC Regulations, 2018 and Kerala University First Statutes, 1977, noting mandatory composition and the need for recusal when a member is related to an applicant. Ultimately, WA 271 is dismissed, while WA 236 and WA 491 are allowed with the impugned judgment set aside, directing that the process be reconsidered in light of the high court’s observations.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 3713/2022, 3714/2022 and 3554/2022

W.P.(C) Nos. 3713/2022, 3714/2022 and 3554/2022 – Laisamma Sasi, N.I. Benny and Prof. K.I. Antony v. Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies (General) and Others

This batch of writ petitions concerns parallel proceedings in the Thodupuzha Primary Co-Operative Bank: disqualification of two members of the Managing Committee and a no-confidence motion against the President. The petitions arise from a complaint by the President on 27 December 2021 seeking disqualification of two MC members, while a motion for no-confidence was proposed by eight MC members on 7 January 2022. The challenge to the meeting convened for the no-confidence motion rests on Rule 43(A)(ii) of the Co-operative Societies Rules, argued to require 15 days’ notice. The court notes that the grounds for disqualification are being contested on merits before the Registrar, with Ext.P3 (and Ext.P4) notices in play, and that the rule regarding notice is regarded by some authorities as directory rather than mandatory. Relying on K.T. Mattachan v. Joint Registrar and Ors and V.A. Jose v. Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies, the court holds that lack of 15 days’ notice can be non-prejudicial. The court also clarifies that a petitioner against whom a no-confidence motion is moved has no right to vote, and discusses the proper sequencing of proceedings. The court directs disqualification proceedings to proceed first (03.03.2022) and the no-confidence motion to follow (07.03.2022), disposing of the petitions without interfering with the underlying proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.No.131/2022 & W.A.No.202/2022

W.A.No.131/2022 & W.A.No.202/2022, Kerala High Court (Division Bench)

Two writ appeals, W.A.No.131 of 2022 and W.A.No.202 of 2022, were heard together by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court. The appellants are retired KSRTC employees challenging government actions that extended enhanced dearness allowance/relief (DA/DR) to State Government employees but paid KSRTC pensioners a comparatively lower DR. In 2021, KSRTC employees received 112% DA/DR from March 2021, while KSRTC pensioners received 109% DR from March 2021. The appellants argued that once the Government extended the benefits to KSRTC, pensioners could not be discriminated against, and such differential treatment violated Article 14 of the Constitution. The respondents contended that differential rates were necessitated by KSRTC’s financial health and its obligation to pay salaries, with reliance on decisions of the Supreme Court and other authorities that financial considerations may justify classifications. The court Surveyed principles from Ram Krishna Dalmia, Khandige Sham Bhat, Venkateshwara Theatre, State of Gujarat, Shukla, Rathnam, Ambica Mills, Deoman Upadhyaya, Pioneer Urban, and others to test reasonable classification under Article 14. It held that restricting the enhanced DR to KSRTC pensioners while extending it to employees was discriminatory and violative of Article 14. Consequently, the writ appeals are allowed, with consequential reliefs to extend the enhanced DA/DR to KSRTC pensioners as well.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 3517 OF 2022

Mahin K.E. v Kalamassery Service Co-operative Bank and Secretary, Kalamassery Service Co-operative Bank and Joint Registrar (General)

This writ petition challenges Ext.P4, a stay order issued by the Joint Registrar (General) (3rd respondent) staying the recruitment process for the post of Peon in the Kalamassery Service Co-operative Bank. The petitioner, a rank-list candidate, sought to keep Ext.P1 rank list alive and to appoint him to a vacant Peon post. The bank had advertised one post; a rank list of eleven was prepared (Ext.P1) and the first-ranked candidate was appointed. Subsequently, three more posts were dealt with, and complaints of malpractices were raised and later withdrawn (Ext.P2). The petitioner contends there exist at least two vacancies and that his 4th rank qualifies him for appointment, especially as the rank list was due to expire on 10-02-2022. The Government Pleader argued that vacancies cannot exceed the notified number and that the select list ceases to exist once the advertised vacancies are filled; a person in the select list does not acquire an indefeasible right. The learned Judge examined the precedents (State of Orissa v. Rajkishore Nanda; State of Punjab v. Raghbir Chand Sharma; Mukul Saikia v. State of Assam) and found no basis to interfere with Ext.P4, noting the advertisement was for a single post and that filling beyond the advertised vacancies would create future vacancies. The petition was dismissed; Ext.P4 stands.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.Rev.Pet.No.1377 of 2019

Shiju S. v. State of Kerala

Shiju S., aged 34, is the 14th accused in CC 4352/2016 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Kollam, arising from alleged malpractices in the Kerala Public Service Commission recruitment examination held on 30 October 2010 for a post in the Kerala State Beverages Corporation. The prosecution alleges a conspiracy among 21 accused to obtain the examination paper deceitfully, with several accused obtaining hall tickets, forging an identification certificate, and impersonating another candidate to facilitate cheating using mobile phones and the internet to convey correct answers to candidates in the examination hall. The petitioner allegedly supplied the answers via his mobile phone to A13 during the examination. The defense contends that even if the prosecution case is accepted, the petitioner could at most be liable for malpractices rather than the more serious offences such as cheating, forgery, theft, trespass, etc., and urged discharge under Section 239 CrPC. The State counters that the petitioner was an active participant in the conspiracy, supported by evidence including call details, a purchased mobile phone, SIM cards, witnesses, and documents. The High Court discusses discharge versus framing of charges, citing CrPC Ss. 239 and 240 and foundational authorities (including Union of India v. Samal, Kuriachan Chacko, Selvi, and Shyam Sundar) to emphasize that discharge is warranted only if the charge is groundless and that materials may be evaluated at the charge-framing stage. The court held that the materials disclose ingredients of the alleged offences and upheld the trial court’s refusal to discharge; the revision petition was dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 48 of 2020 and connected cases

WA Nos. 48/2020 and connected matters (In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam) - State of Kerala v. various assessees (KVAT amendment batch)

This batch of writ appeals arises from challenges to the amendments made to the Kerala Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (KVAT Act) by the Kerala Finance Acts 2017 and 2018 and related constitutional-legal consequences in light of the introduction of the Goods and Services Tax (GST). The State, represented by the Special Government Pleader (Taxes), contends that amendments substituting the period of reopenings under Section 25(1) of KVAT (from five years to six years) and the extended proviso for assessment renewals are valid and operative, even after the KVAT Act was repealed and replaced by the KGST Act. The petitioners (assessees/ respondents) challenge both the 2017 substitution and the 2018 proviso, arguing lack of legislative competence post-repeal, and asserting that the amendments cannot operate retrospectively to revive time-barred reassessments. The High Court (Division Bench of S. V. Bhatti and B. Balaji JJ.) ultimately held that the 2017 amendment to Section 25(1) is prospective (not retrospective) and that the 2018 proviso to the third proviso to Section 25(1) of KVAT Act is unconstitutional for lack of legislative competence. The appeals were dismissed, sustaining the view that the 2017 amendment is not a retrospective augmentation of rights and that the 2018 amendment cannot validate an extension after repeal and GST implementation.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.R. No. 21 of 2022

Paryantavida Anshad v. Kolayakkarakath Puthiya Purayil Noorjahan

This is a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court’s revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 (R.C.R. No. 21 of 2022) arising from eviction proceedings in R.C.P. No. 65 of 2014 before the Rent Control Court, Talipparamba, and an appeal therefrom. The Rent Control Court had ordered eviction under Sections 11(3) and 11(4)(v) of the Act (with Section 11(4)(iii) rejected), and the Appellate Authority confirmed. The tenant-petitioner challenged these orders by filing the revision petition, which the High Court admitted on 24.01.2022 and stayed eviction for one month. The core issue is whether the landlord’s need for occupation of the petition schedule shop room is bonafide. The respondents contend the need is genuine, supported by the landlord’s family circumstances and lack of other suitable space, while the petitioner argues that the landlord’s need is pretextual given the husband’s absence abroad and the tenant’s established business operations. The court surveys established jurisprudence on bona fide need (Adil Jamshed Frenchman; Shiv Samp Gupta; Deena Nath; Ammu; Gireeshbabu; and others), clarifying that bona fide need must be sincere, actual, and not a mere whim. It affirms the concurrent findings that the need is bonafide and that there is no illegality in the orders. Consequently, the revision petition is dismissed, and the court grants three months to vacate, with conditions including an unconditional undertaking, arrears deposit, and prohibition on third-party occupancy.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 17301/2020 & batch

W.P.(C) No. 17301/2020 & batch

This batch of writ petitions challenges the scope of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 (the Act) and, in particular, who qualifies as the “owner” eligible to seek reclamation of paddy land for constructing a residential building under Section 5(3) read with Section 9. The Court traces a line of authority beginning with Thankachan v. District Collector (2017) and Yousuf Chalil v. State of Kerala (2019), and its subsequent Division Bench decision, which had held that post‑statute purchasers could also invoke the reclamation mechanism. The petitions highlight various districts and local bodies (LLMCs and District Level Authorized Committees) across Kerala, with multiple petitioners who bought fragments of paddy land after 12.08.2008. The Respondents contend that the Act was designed to conserve paddy land and that the protective entitlement should be confined to the original owner as of the date of coming into force (12.08.2008), with strict conditions for exemptions and a preference for the land’s cultivation. The Bench, after a purposive, contextual reading of Sections 3, 5(3), and 9, as well as amendments and objects and reasons, holds that the owner for entitlement must be the person who held the paddy land on 12.08.2008, and that post‑enactment buyers cannot claim Section 5(3) r/w Section 9 relief. The Court, however, allows relief for the petitioner in W.P.(C) No. 18356/2020 (Jinimol P.) to reconsider in light of the clarified law. The decision reaffirms a strict, purposive interpretation to preserve paddy land, while permitting reconsideration where the facts are uniquely situated.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 84 of 2019

Kerala State Co-operative Rubber Marketing Federation Limited v. Mutholy Service Co-operative Bank Limited and Others

The Kerala State Co-operative Rubber Marketing Federation Limited (the Federation) is an apex society registered under the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969 (KCS Act). Primary Agricultural Credit Societies deposited surplus funds with the Federation following Circular No.11/97 (22.3.1997) and a subsequent communication dated 23.4.1998 directing Joint Registers of Co-operative Societies to advise PACS in Kerala to deposit surplus funds with the Federation. Relying on these directions, pursuant to section 57 of the KCS Act, the first respondent and similarly situated societies made fixed deposits with the Federation. After maturity, the Federation failed to disburse the deposits with interest, prompting the first respondent to file WP(C) No. 6520 of 2017, seeking immediate payment of the amounts with interest. The Single Judge disposed directions to repay as per Ext. P8 within 8 months, with a caveat that non-compliance would invite liquidation/other action. The Federation challenged on grounds of maintainability under Section 69 of the KCS Act and the availability of alternative remedies, citing financial constraints and purported government assurances for settlement. The respondents pressed that the liability is undisputed and that the writ was properly entertained. The Division Bench dismissed the appeal, affirming repayment within two months and allowing recourse to the Act’s provisions if delayed, while noting no illegality in the writ court’s order.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 1071 OF 2007

Kunjappan v. State of Kerala

Aggrieved by a judgment of conviction under Sections 55(a) and 8(2) of the Abkari Act, the appellant Kunjappan challenges the trial court’s verdict in Sessions Case No. 811/2002. He was found in possession of 17 polythene packets containing 150 ml arrack each, seized on 02.08.1999 at Kattachal, and the contraband was sent for chemical analysis. The trial court convicted him and sentenced two years’ simple imprisonment and Rs. 1 lakh fine, with no separate sentence under 8(2). In his appeal, the accused contends that crucial seizure documents are defective: Ext. P1 mahazar does not describe the seal; PW1 did not testify about the seal’s nature; the specimen seal was not produced; forwarding note for the sample dispatch was not marked. The prosecution’s case hinges on the link between the seized sample and the laboratory analysis, a connection the defense argues is not established, given the absence of tamper-proof chain documentation. The High Court canvassed leading precedents on sampling, sealing, and chain of custody (Sasidharan; Sathi; Ravi; Bhaskaran; Rajamma; Ramachandran; Vijay Pandey), underscoring that the state must prove that the very same sample tested in the laboratory was seized, and that seals and forwarding notes are verified. Where these steps are missing, the evidentiary value of the laboratory report is compromised, and presumption cannot replace proof. Applying these principles, the court holds that the prosecution failed to prove the chain of custody, and the appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 35 of 2022

Jimson Titus v Bank of Baroda, Thrissur Branch & Reserve Bank of India

This writ appeal arising from WP(C) 21235/2021 before the Kerala High Court concerns an educational loan sanctioned by Bank of Baroda under the IBA/ RBI framework for the petitioner’s MBBS education at Petro Mohyla Black Sea National University, Ukraine. The appellant seeks mandamus to disburse the full sanctioned loan of ₹7,00,000 in accordance with the course cost estimated at ₹29,58,936 for a six-year period, submitting that the first-year costs amount to ₹2.57 lakh as tuition and ₹2.85 lakh for travel, and that the RBI model scheme and Ext P3 provisions allow release of funds to meet yearly needs. The bank opposes this, arguing that loan disbursement must follow a pro-rata basis aligned with the requirements for each year, to avoid over-financing, in line with Ext P3 and RBI guidelines (Ext R1(b)). The writ court and the bank rely on Clause 28 of Ext P3 and the RBI guidelines to justify staged releases, while the petitioner contends the guidelines permit upfront disbursement for essential first-year expenses. The court cites a prior W.A.No.1281 of 2021, which upheld the pro-rata approach, and accordingly dismisses the appeal, holding there is no error in the impugned judgment and that the bank’s pro-rata disbursement aligns with the governing guidelines.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 2863 of 2021

Sudharma P.S. v. State of Kerala and Others

The petitioners in WP(C) No.2863 of 2021, Sudharma P.S., Beena K. Sugathan, and Suneetha K.U., challenge Exts.P1–P3 which deny approval of their appointments from the initial dates, and seek quash of Ext.P9. The petitioners allege that they were appointed as CRCC and UPST in SMSNVHSS Vaikom between 2006 and 2008, but approval was granted only from 1.6.2011 due to an economic ban; despite representations, no relief was given. The 3rd respondent states that approvals were delayed because the manager did not execute the bond as required by G.O(P) 10/10/G.Edn, and that the posts were created in anticipation of vacancies that did not materialize. The 5th respondent-manager is said to be willing to execute a bond for appointing in additional vacancies in line with a 1:1 ratio, though protected teachers can be appointed only for vacancies arising after 29.1.2016; an existing protected teacher was already appointed. The government contends that bond execution is a precondition for approval. In a pivotal ruling, the Division Bench in Suma Devi (supra) held that non-execution of a bond by managers should be deemed as executed, obliging the manager to appoint from the protected list in proportion to approved posts during the ban. The Court accords due weight to this doctrine, quashes Ext.P9, and directs the 1st respondent to reconsider P5–P7 afresh, treating the manager as having executed the bond and ensuring appointments from the protected list, within four months, subject to Apex Court orders.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.Appeal No. 441 of 2008

Kunhu Kunhu @ Joseph v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court judgment concerns Crl.A. No. 441 of 2008 filed by Kunhu Kunhu alias Joseph, challenging a conviction under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) NDPS Act (1985) for allegedly transporting 5.2 kilograms of ganja on 14 August 2003 along the Ayyanthole–Puzhakkal road near Priyadarsini bus stop, Ayyanthole. The trial court (Court of Session, Thrissur) convicted the appellant and sentenced him to four years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of ₹25,000, with an additional four months’ imprisonment in default; set-off under Section 428 Cr.P.C. was allowed. The High Court, per Justice C.S. Sudha, dismissed the appeal, upholding the conviction while reducing the substantive sentence to the period already undergone, and closed any interlocutory applications. The prosecution relied on PW1 (detecting officer), PW6 (investigation officer), and PW2 (gazetted officer) who testified to seizure from a box carried by the accused; PW3 and PW4, independent witnesses, turned hostile but were not fatal to the prosecution’s case. The court scrutinized arguments about the search sequence, timing, and the role of Section 50 NDPS safeguards, noting that the contraband was recovered from a cardboard box carried by the accused rather than from a personal search. Citing State of Punjab v. Baljinder Singh (AIR 2019 SC 5298) and the Constitution Bench decision in Baldev Singh (AIR 1999 SC 2378), the court held that where there is other evidence, non-compliance with S.50 does not invalidate the vehicle-search–based seizure. Ultimately, the appeal failed, and the conviction was maintained with a reduced sentence in view of the accused’s age and health.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos. 7037 of 2014; 9722 of 2014; 27737 of 2014; 3360 of 2021; 12890 of 2021; 16988 of 2021; 18817 of 2021

W.P.(C) Nos.7037 of 2014, 9722 of 2014, 27737 of 2014, 3360 of 2021, 12890 of 2021, 16988 of 2021 and 18817 of 2021 (K.P. Vijayan and Joseph John v. District Collector, Pathanamthitta and others)

The batch of writ petitions, consolidated before the Kerala High Court, arises from long-running disputes over a Convention Centre project and adjacent land at Kavumbhagom, Thiruvalla. Petitioner K.P. Vijayan (and, in several petitions, Joseph John) claimed that required permissions were granted under applicable statutory regimes and that subsequent actions by revenue and local authorities, including cancellation orders and building permits, were either lawfully issued or should be regularised. Opposing him, Joseph John alleged that the project infringed on paddy land/wetland status under the Kerala Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 and caused flooding on his properties. The case turned on the interplay of the Kerala Land Utilisation Order, 1967 (KLU Order), the 2008 Act (and its amendments), data-bank classifications of land as purayidam/nilaiam and the LLMC’s corrective measures. A key component was Ext.P27 (common judgment, 29.09.2020) directing drainage measures and providing a framework for building numbering and potential regularisation. Ultimately, the court disposed of the petitions with a bundle of directions: excluding the petitioner’s lands from the data bank, directing building numbers for compliant constructions, authorising drainage work under an Advocate Commissioner, and leaving open the possibility of regularisation under the Act’s provisions. The decision emphasizes that any enforcement action under the 2008 Act remains subject to due process and post-Ext.P27 directions.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 846 OF 2022

Mujeeb P.T. v. Shoukath and State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. filed by Mujeeb P.T., the accused in S.T. No. 685/2014 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Perinthalmanna, and arising from CC proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The trial court convicted the accused for issuing cheques towards discharge of liability and sentenced him to six months’ simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 2,00,000, with default imprisonment. The appeal in Criminal Appeal No. 208/2017 before the Sessions Court, Manjeri, upheld the conviction but modified the sentence to imprisonment till rising of the court and to pay Rs. 2,00,000 as fine, directing that after realization of the fine the amount be given as compensation under Cr.P.C. The revision petition before this Court contends that the power of revision under Cr.P.C. is limited and not intended to re‑appreciate evidence to reach a contra‑finding; it also notes that the defence raised by the accused includes that gold ornaments were returned and that cheques were given as security, while the complainant alleges misappropriation. The Court discusses the settled law on revisionary powers and the well‑established presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act, including presumption rebuttal by preponderance of probabilities, and refers to landmark judgments. Ultimately, the Court dismisses the revision petition but grants a three‑month window to pay the fine and undergo the sentence, with execution deferred until 17/04/2023 and appearance by 18/04/2023.

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos.732 and 775 of 2024

BA Nos. 732 and 775 of 2024 (Sunil R v. State of Kerala; Linu v. State of Kerala)

This Common Order disposes of two connected bail applications (BA Nos. 732 and 775 of 2024) filed under Section 439 CrPC, by accused in Crime No.75/2023 of the Neyyardam Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, alleging offences under IPC sections 294(b), 341, 324, 326, 506 and 307 read with 34. The petitioners, Sunil R and Linu, were arrested on 20.11.2023. The prosecution asserts that the injured had grievous injuries and that the investigation is not complete, arguing that release on bail could tempt tampering with evidence. The petitioners contend innocence, point to parity with co-accused who have already been granted bail, and emphasize the fundamental presumption of innocence. The court recalls Supreme Court principles from Sanjay Chandra v. CBI (2012), Dataram Singh v. State of U.P. (2018), and State of Kerala v. Raneef (2011) to underscore that bail is generally the rule and pre-trial detention is an exception, and that prolonged detention which infringes Article 21 cannot be countenanced. After considering that the petitioners have been in custody since 20.11.2023 (about 90 days) and that co-accused 2, 3 and 5 have already been bailed, the court allows the bail applications subject to stringent conditions, including bond Rs. 1,00,000 and two sureties, periodic reporting, non-tampering with witnesses, no new offences, and surrender of passport if any.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 30147/2022 and 3611/2024

Asianet Digital Network Private Ltd v Union of India & Others

This is a Kerala High Court writ petition challenge by Asianet Digital Network Private Ltd (formerly Asianet Broadband/Asianet Digital Cable TV Pvt Ltd) against two show cause notices issued under Section 73 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, for periods February 2017 to June 2017 and July 2017 to March 2020. The core dispute concerns whether GST tax on digital cable TV services supplied via a DAS regime should be computed on the gross amount collected from subscribers or on the amount retained by Local Cable Operators (LCOs) remitted to the MSO. The petitions argue that the Department’s action is without jurisdiction: the show cause notices were issued by a DGGI officer under the Finance Act, 1994 and adjudicated by other officers, which, they contend, violates statutory requirements that the same officer (the ‘Central Excise Officer’) issue and adjudicate such notices. The petition also challenges invocation of the extended period of limitation, asserting lack of fraud/suppression as jurisdictional facts. The respondents contend that DGGI officers are empowered to issue notices and adjudicate under CBIC notifications and Circulars, and that the issue involves complex classification and valuation, justifying continuation of proceedings and potential extended period. The judgment ultimately dismisses the petitions, directing the petitioner to file a reply within four weeks and pursue the matter before the competent authority.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 847 OF 2024

Sajad v. State of Kerala (Bail Application No. 847 of 2024)

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by Sajad, the third accused in Crime No.1302/2023 of Thrissur Town West Police Station, involving seven accused charged with offences including murder under IPC. The applicant has been in judicial custody since 08.11.2023. The prosecution case alleges that, on 06.11.2023, the first to sixth accused formed an unlawful assembly at Poothole Railway Colony and murdered Sreerag by stabbing him; others allegedly attacked rescuers. The defence contends Sajad is falsely implicated and that there is no specific overt act attributed to him in the murder; at best he assaulted two witnesses, Ajmal and Jiyas, but not the deceased. The investigation is complete, the final report is laid, and the case is at the committal stage; the petitioner is willing to cooperate and comply with strict conditions. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, highlighting potential witness tampering and Sajad’s criminal antecedents, though he concedes that the investigation is complete and the final report is laid. Relying on Supreme Court principles—presumption of innocence, bail as the general rule, and the right to speedy trial—the Court ultimately allows Sajad’s bail subject to stringent conditions, balancing liberty with the integrity of the ongoing investigation.