The appellant, Salin Kumar Sulaja Mandirathil, was the accused in SC No. 349/2002 before the Addl. Sessions Judge (Abkari Cases), Kottarakkara, for offences under Sections 8(1) and 8(2) of the Abkari Act in connection with seizure of 10 litres of arrack in a jerry can on 1 June 1999 along the Kottarakkara–Oyoor road. The trial court convicted him and sentenced him to five years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with a default term of six months’ imprisonment. On appeal, the appellant challenged the legality of the search, seizure and arrest, alleging that these were conducted by an Assistant Excise Inspector who, per the Abkari Act then in force, was not authorized to perform such acts; he also pointed out that the forwarding note was not marked, which the prosecution uses to prove the chain of custody. The Public Prosecutor contends that oral and documentary evidence establish the offences and the conviction should not be disturbed. The Kerala High Court, after reviewing precedent on the authority of Assistant Excise Inspectors and the critical role of the forwarding note as a link in evidentiary chain, concludes that the lack of proper empowerment vitiates the trial. It relies on Bhaskaran, Subrahmaniyan and Sasidharan to hold that acts by an unempowered officer before 8 May 2009 render the proceedings void, and accordingly allows the appeal, acquitting the appellant and setting him at liberty; bail bonds, if any, are cancelled.
WA Nos. 48/2020; 1562/2019; 2/2020; 314/2020; 323/2020; 324/2020; 328/2020; 332/2020; 333/2020; 339/2020; 342/2020; 343/2020; 361/2020; 365/2020; 379/2020; 383/2020; 385/2020; 394/2020; 398/2020; 399/2020; 400/2020; 402/2020; 412/2020; 431/2020; 437/2020; 447/2020; 448/2020; 449/2020; 451/2020; 459/2020; 463/2020; 467/2020; 475/2020; 477/2020; 480/2020; 481/2020; 487/2020; 490/2020; 497/2020; 512/2020; 514/2020; 516/2020; 518/2020; 520/2020; 539/2020; 540/2020; 541/2020; 542/2020; 551/2020; 562/2020; 567/2020; 568/2020; 569/2020; 571/2020; 574/2020; 580/2020; 587/2020; 589/2020; 591/2020; 596/2020; 606/2020; 607/2020; 611/2020; 615/2020; 617/2020; 621/2020; 628/2020; 629/2020; 630/2020; 643/2020; 652/2020; 662/2020; 669/2020; 703/2020; 722/2020; 742/2020; 785/2020; 877/2020; 892/2020; 912/2020; 986/2020; 1019/2020; 1528/2020; 1558/2020; 3/2021; 7/2021; 8/2021; 10/2021; 48/2020 (and connected WA Nos.) This batch of writ appeals in the Kerala High Court concerns the validity and retroactive/ prospective effect of amendments to the Kerala Value Added Tax Act, 2003 (KVAT) introduced by the Kerala Finance Acts 2017 and 2018 in the wake of the from KVAT’s repeal and the advent of GST. The core issue is whether amendments substituting the five-year period for reopening assessments under Section 25(1) of KVAT (Finance Act 2017) and the subsequent extension up to 31 March 2019 (Finance Act 2018) can be applied to reassessments that had already become time-barred or were time-barred under the pre-amendment regime, in light of the Constitution (One Hundred and First Amendment) Act, 2016 and the introduction of GST. The court analyses vesting/accrued rights, legislative competence post-CAA, and the saving provisions under KGST (Kerala GST) while evaluating the retroactive prospective nature of substitutions. It relies on Baiju A.A. v. State Tax Officer and other key precedents to decide that the 2017 amendment is prospective and that the 2018 amendment, even as a substitution, faces constitutional obstacles in extending the period for reopening beyond the pre-existing limit. The appeals are dismissed, holding that the amendments do not retrospectively validate notices issued for earlier years, and that the State lacked power to amend KVAT post-repeal in 2017-2018 without proper constitutional basis.
WA 48/2020 (and connected cases) This batch judgment of a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court deals with a large spectrum of writ appeals challenging assessments and reassessments under the Kerala Value Added Tax Act (KVAT) and related amendments made by Kerala Finance Acts 2017 and 2018 (the KVAT amendments to Section 25(1) and its third proviso). The core issue is whether amendments effecting the period of limitation for reopening assessments (from five years to six years) and the corresponding extension for assessments, were valid after the 2016 Constitution (One Hundred and First) Amendment and the subsequent repeal of KVAT in favor of the KGST regime, with savings provisions. The court ultimately held that the 2017 substitution of ‘five years’ to ‘six years’ has prospective operation and does not revive rights to reopen closed assessments, while the 2018 proviso extending the period beyond 31 March 2019 was beyond legislative competence given the KVAT Act’s repeal and the savings under KGST. The decision involves extensive statutory interpretation, constitutional scheme, and a survey of authorities on retrospective legislation, vesting rights, and the interplay of state and central tax powers under Article 246A. The appeals were dismissed with costs, confirming the court’s stance that the challenged amendments could not revive time-barred assessments.
This is a Rent Control Revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, filed by four tenants challenging eviction under Section 11(3) of the Act. The Rent Control Court (Munsiff, Taliparamba) had allowed eviction in R.C.P. No.12 of 2015 (dated 11.10.2019) on the landlord’s bonafide need to run a garment business from the petition shop for his wife. The tenants’ appeal before the Rent Control Appellate Authority (District Judge, Thalassery) was dismissed by judgment dated 30.11.2021. The tenants then moved this Revision petition contending that the eviction order was ex parte and meritless, and disputing the landlord’s bonafide need and entitlement under the second proviso to Section 11(3). The High Court, after examining evidence and historical case-law on the applicability of the Limitation Act to rent-control proceedings, concluded that the Rent Control Court’s order was wrong and liable to be set aside. It held that the Rent Control Court is a Court for the purposes of Section 29(2) of the Limitation Act and that Section 5 of the Limitation Act applies, overruling Ratheesh and other precedents to the extent inconsistent. The original petition is allowed; the RCP is restored on file and the matter is to be re-heard with full opportunity to both sides within four months from 28.02.2022.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (Criminal Appeal No. 435 of 2007) by the accused, Sreekumar, challenging a 2007 conviction under Section 58 of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court, Neyyattinkara, in a case arising from the seizure of 60 litres of arrack at Kuttichal Junction in 1999. The trial court sentenced the appellant to five years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000/-. The core issues on appeal concern (i) unexplained delay in producing the seized sample and other property before the court, and (ii) whether the contraband purportedly sent for Chemical Examination was duly analyzed. The judgment scrutinizes the chain of custody, noting that the seizure properties were reported late and that the sample was reportedly produced by a court official rather than drawn by police, with no satisfactory documentary explanation for the delay. It cites several decisions (Ravi v. State of Kerala; Sasidharan v. State of Kerala; Sathi; Bhaskaran; Baburaj; Smithesh; Baby) to stress the necessity of timely production, proper sampling/sealing procedures, and tamper-proof handling from the place of occurrence to the chemical laboratory. Ultimately, the court acquits the appellant, holding that the prosecution failed to establish the link between the contraband and the sample tested, and thus sets aside the conviction, allowing the appeal.
This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Appeal by the accused Rajendran @ Rajamany challenging a Sessions Court conviction under the Abkari Act for possession of illicit arrack and Kingfisher beer. The trial court found the accused guilty under Sections 55(a), 55(h) and 8(2) of the Abkari Act and sentenced him to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. The High Court, on 12 October 2022, allowed the appeal and acquitted the appellant, holding that the prosecution failed to establish crucial compliance with mandatory arrest procedures and the chain of custody relating to the contraband samples. The court emphasized that arrest memo and arrest intimation were not produced and that, based on D.K. Basu and Ramankutty, non-compliance with mandatory arrest formalities fatally undermines the prosecution. It also highlighted that the sample referred to in the Chemical Analysis Certificate (Ext. P8) lacked verifiable linkage to the seized contraband because the sample’s custody and handling (including examination of officials who transported the sample) were not established, and the samples (or their transfer to the laboratory) were not adequately corroborated. Citing Daulat Ram and Vijay Pandey, the court held that mere laboratory reports cannot conclusively prove possession without a proven chain of custody. As a result, the conviction could not stand. The appeal is allowed and the accused is acquitted.
Ramesan, the appellant in CRL.A No. 254 of 2007, challenges a conviction under Sections 55(a) and 55(g) of the Kerala Abkari Act, arising from a 2000–2001 incident in Chirayinke ezhu. The Additional Sessions Court (Fast Track Court), Thiruvananthapuram, convicted him based on seizure at the scene, with the prosecution alleging illicit arrack manufacture for sale. The High Court proceedings followed after the Supreme Court, in a 2020 judgment in Crl.Appeal No.77/2020, remanded the matter for hearing afresh after permitting legal heirs to participate, given the appellant’s death during proceedings and the wife’s challenge. The core issues on appeal concern the veracity of the arrest at the scene, the chain of custody of the contraband sample, and the linkage between the seized material and the Chemical Examiner’s analysis. The court scrutinized Ext.P2 (arrest memo) showing a crime number, noting the doubt as to whether the FIR preceded the seizure or the number was inserted after registration, casting genesis-related doubt. It also scrutinized Ext.P6 (forwarding note) and the absence of specimen seal, non-examination of custody officials, and a significant delay in analysis. Relying on precedents such as Sasidharan, Sathi, Bhaskaran, Rajamma, and Krishnadas, the court held the prosecution failed to establish tamper-proof custody and a proper chain of custody, rendering Ext.P7 inconsequential. The conviction is set aside and the appellant acquitted; any deposited amount is to be disbursed to the wife, Girija A.
Ramanalukkal Shareef v. Mohammed (R.C.Rev.No.42 of 2022) is a Kerala High Court revision petition challenging an eviction order under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. Heard by a Division Bench comprising Justices Anil K. Narendran and P.G. Ajithkumar Monday, the matter traces to an eviction petition under Sections 11(2)(b), 11(3) and 11(4)(ii) filed by the landlord against the tenant in a three-shuttered shop. The Rent Control Court (Munsiff, Tirur) ordered eviction under 11(2)(b) and 11(3) and rejected 11(4)(ii); the Rent Control Appellate Authority confirmed, and the revision petition challenges both the factual finding on the rent and the legal conclusions on bona fide need and the feasibility of eviction. The landlord purchased the premises in 2002 and claims to have increased rent to Rs.9,000, intending to operate a bakery and stationery business; the tenant contends rent has always been Rs.1,800 and disputes the alleged increase for lack of evidence. The High Court undertakes a thorough review of the evidence, including affidavits and witnesses, and clarifies that a court cannot substitute an agreed rent rate absent conclusive proof. While upholding the landlord’s bona fide need to occupy, the Court finds the evidence insufficient to sustain the higher rent claim and affirms eviction under 11(2)(b) and 11(3), but grants a six-month period for the tenant to surrender possession upon conditions, including deposit of arrears and an undertaking not to allow third parties in possession. The revision petition is dismissed.
This is a Kerala High Court original petition (OP(C) No. 90 of 2022) by C. U. Rajan challenging an order dated 08.09.2021 of the Munsiff, Pattambi, in an unnumbered original suit. The petitioner sought to restrain the respondents from removing gates allegedly fixed unauthorisedly on the schedule property. The Munsiff’s order, which returned the plaint at the threshold without numbering the suit, relied on the Supreme Court rulings, notably K.S. Varghese v. Saint Peter’s & Saint Paul’s Syrian Orthodox Church, and the petition contests Ext.P3 as erroneous, improper, and unsustainable. The petitioner argues that Rule 10 of Order 7 CPC governs return of plaints, and that the court should consider maintainability only after the plaint is registered; otherwise, the suit must be decided on merits. The court below’s reliance on KS Varghese to deny numbering is urged to be contrary to the CPC and the binding ratio in KS Varghese and Fr. Isaac Mattammel Cor-Episcopa v. St. Mary’s Orthodox Syrian Church, which emphasized obedience to binding judgments. The High Court, invoking Article 227, sets aside Ext.P3, directs the court below to number the suit, and proceed to decide it on merits, underscoring the binding effect of Supreme Court decisions and the constitutionally overseen discipline required in such matters.
Mohanan, the appellant, was convicted under Section 55(i) of the Abkari Act and sentenced to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh for possessing 3 litres of illicit arrack on 3 April 2001 at Thazhava. The prosecution had represented that an arrest was made by a Sub-Inspector of Police and that the contraband, seizure mahazar, and samples were sent for chemical analysis. On appeal, the Kerala High Court, in a single-judge bench of Justice K. Babu, scrutinized the chain of custody and the linkage between the seized contraband and the sample analysed in the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory. The court found significant deficiencies: the arrest memo bore a crime number, inviting doubt about whether the FIR was registered before or after seizure; there was unexplained delay in producing the seized properties and samples in court; the seizure mahazar lacked seal particulars, the forwarding note for the sample was not produced, and the specimen seal was not demonstrated to tally with the sample. Relying on a series of precedents emphasizing the necessity of a robust link between the seized contraband and the analysed sample, the court held that the prosecution failed to establish this vital link. Consequently, the conviction could not be sustained, and the appellant was acquitted, with the appeal allowed and the appellant set at liberty.
Instant writ appeal challenges the common judgment of the Kerala High Court in WP(C) No.3019/2022, which dismissed the petition challenging the admission framework for MBBS 2021 under the Persons with Disabilities (PwD) quota. The appellant, Shivendu R. Sekhar, a candidate with 40% disability, sought admission under the PwD quota and claimed eligibility and access to an online option portal, which she alleged was not opened. She was certified fit for MBBS by the Medical Boards, with the State Level Committee recorded as 40% disabled (40% being a composite of 20% prehension and 20% strength in the left hand). The Entrance Examinations Commissioner’s data sheets showed her as qualified for the PwD quota, yet the candidate portal failed to enable her option submission by the deadline. The writ petition argued that a 5% PwD quota applies for state seats, with eligibility criteria aligned to MCI regulations and the State Level Committee’s binding role in determining eligibility and suitability. The writ court, however, upheld the restrictions and reliance on expert medical board findings. On appeal, the Division Bench found procedural irregularities, including unilateral insertion of the word “Not” in the suitability column and directed the portal to be opened, admitted the appellant under the PwD quota, and reserved one seat for disabled candidates, effectively allowing the writ appeal.
Bhargavan, the appellant, challenges a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act for possession of 600 ml of arrack seized on 9 December 1998 in front of his residence at Kallelibhagam muri, Karunagappally. The trial court, by judgment dated 29 June 2007 in S.C. No. 575/2001, sentenced him to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 with default terms of imprisonment. On appeal, counsel for the appellant submitted two points: (i) Ext. P9 is the forwarding note, but it bears no seal; (ii) Ext. P9 does not indicate through whom the sample was forwarded, thereby impairing the chain of custody from seizure to the laboratory. The Public Prosecutor contended that oral and documentary evidence suffice to prove the offence. The High Court scrutinized the relevance of the seal in the forwarding note, citing Ravi v. State – SI of Police, Meppadi; Smithesh v. State of Kerala; and Balachandran v. State of Kerala, and Kumaran P. v. State of Kerala. Balachandran emphasizes that absence of a specimen seal jeopardizes the ability to identify the sample, while Kumaran discusses the need to establish the despatch and chain of custody. The court ultimately held that the chain of evidence was not satisfactorily established due to the seal/identification gaps, and thus the appellant must benefit from doubt. The appeal is allowed; the conviction and sentence under the Abkari Act are set aside, and the appellant is acquitted with bail bonds cancelled.
This writ petition challenges Crime No.303/2020 registered at Moozhiyar Police Station, Pathanamthitta, seeking to quash proceedings against the petitioner, PRADEEP M.P. @ MANU, who is accused under IPC sections 342 (wrongful confinement), 366 (kidnapping), 376(2)(n) (rape with enhanced penalty), and 354C (capturing private act) and Section 119(b) of the Kerala Police Act, all arising from events allegedly at a quarantine centre in Nilakkal/Angamoozhy from 18.6.2020 to 1.7.2020. The 3rd respondent, a nursing student, claims a consensual relationship that deteriorated into alleged coercive acts, including taking her photographs and sexual acts during the quarantine, under a promise of marriage. The petitioner contends that, even if the entire FIS is accepted at face value, the allegations do not constitute the charged offences and that initiation of proceedings is malicious. The learned Public Prosecutor submits that prima facie offences are made out and Article 226 jurisdiction should not be exercised. On evaluating the FIS, the judge finds no wrongful confinement or abduction to attract Sections 342 or 366, but holds that Sections 354C, 376(2)(n) and 119(b) may be attracted given the recording of acts and the alleged false promise of marriage. Citing Deepak Gulati and Dhruvaram Sonar, the court emphasizes an enquiry into mala fide intent and whether consent was vitiated by a false promise. Ext.P3’s marriage certificate is not conclusive. Consequently, the FIR is quashed only insofar as it relates to 342 and 366; the writ is allowed in part while the other offences remain.
Priyarenjan, the sole accused in Cr. No. 1373/2023 of Kattakada Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, seeks regular bail under Section 439 Cr.P.C. The prosecution accuses him of murdering a 15-year-old boy, Adisekhar, on 30 August 2023, allegedly in a premeditated, enmity-driven act. The crime, initially registered under sections 279 and 304A IPC and subsequently augmented to include Section 302 IPC, occurred in a temple precinct; the accused allegedly waited near the temple, in KL 19N 6957 car, and, upon the boy’s approach, knocked him down and ran over him, causing fatal head injuries. After the incident, the accused is said to have halted the car to obstruct hospital access. The victim’s mother has been impleaded as a respondent. The court notes that the prosecution claims it was preplanned and cold-blooded, supported by CCTV footage showing the accused waiting at the spot for about half an hour. The defence contends the incident was a road traffic accident, with a disturbed mental state and no enmity, and points to edited video footage as misleading. The court, applying the principles for bail from State of U.P. v. Amarmani Tripathi, emphasizes the gravity and potential for witness tampering, the danger of absconding, and the need to examine material CWs before granting bail. Consequently, bail is denied; the court directs that bail be reconsidered only after material witnesses are examined in SC No.216 of 2024, and leaves open merit-based future applications.
BAIL APPL. NO.11057 OF 2023 This bail petition, Bail Appl. No.11057 of 2023, concerns two accused persons in Crime No.1090/2023 of Aloor Police Station, Thrissur, facing charges under IPC Sections 448, 341, 294(b), 323, 324, 326 and 34. The Kerala High Court, through Justice C.S. Dias, evaluates whether pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC should be granted. The prosecution alleges a violent incident on 11.11.2023 in which the de facto complainant and his wife were assaulted, resulting in injuries including a displaced fracture of the nasal bone (as per the discharge card and wound certificate). The petitioners claim innocence, contend they have been falsely implicated, and express willingness to comply with stringent conditions; they argue custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The respondent State opposes bail, emphasizing the gravity of offences and the need for custodial interrogation to facilitate investigation, which is at nascent stage. The Court cites Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra and Sibbia (Constitution Bench) to reiterate that no rigid guidelines can govern anticipatory/pre-arrest bail and that discretion must be exercised with care, weighing factors like gravity, role, antecedents, flight risk, and witness tampering. Ultimately, the Court holds the petitioners are not entitled to pre-arrest bail, dismisses the application, but offers a conditional surrender pathway allowing the jurisdictional court to consider merits of bail on surrender within 10 days.
This is a Kerala High Court Bail Application (Bail Appl. No. 2365/2024) by accused nos. 4 and 10 in Crime No. 528/2024 of Ernakulam Central Police Station, alleging offences under Sections 419 and 420 IPC. The petitioners were arrested on 03.03.2024. The core prosecution case alleges that on 22.02.2024, a Mumbai Crime Branch call claimed a bank account opened in the name of the complainant using his Aadhaar and involved in money laundering. The accused allegedly received money from other accused (1–3) who misrepresented themselves as police officials to facilitate a crypto-currency business, resulting in a transfer of Rs. 9,75,000 to a sixth account and onward transfers to the petitioners. The petitioners contend innocence and wrongful implication, noting that the investigation is nearly complete with recovery effected and pray for bail. The Public Prosecutor objects, citing ongoing investigation and risk of repetition if released. The court cites foundational bail principles from Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh, and others, emphasizing presumption of innocence, that bail is the rule and jail is the exception, and the rights of undertrials under Article 21. After considering the facts, custody duration (50 days), and the nearly complete investigation, the Judge allows the bail application with conditions. The order directs bond of Rs. 50,000 with two solvent sureties, periodic appearances, no inducement or tampering, passport surrender, and potential cancellation on breach, citing Sushila Aggarwal for guideline on bail conditions.
This judgment deals with a batch of writ petitions challenging the Government of Kerala’s implementation of pension revisions under the University Grants Commission (UGC) scheme, notably through GO(P) No. 38/2021/FIN (dated 25 February 2021) and GO(P) No. 162/2021/FIN (dated 2 December 2021). Petitioners, a large cohort of retired university teachers and college staff, attack the stance that revised pension and arrears would be payable in cash only partly and with arrears from 2016-2019 treated as notional; and that arrears would be disbursed in installments on a schedule. They invoke the principle that pension is a vested right, not a bounty, and rely on precedents such as Union of India v. P. N. Menon and All Manipur Pensioners Association to challenge cut-off dates and deferment of payments on fiscal grounds. The Government contends fiscal constraints necessitate phased payment and potential cut-offs under established law (including UGC guidance). The learned Judge, while acknowledging fiscal constraints and the need to protect public finances, holds that pension rights cannot be arbitrarily denied and orders the Government to re-examine Clause 6.1 of GO(P) No. 38/2021 and GO(P) No. 162/2021 after hearing the petitioners, within three months, to consider modifying the approach consistent with constitutional and jurisprudential precedents. The judgment does not quash the orders outright but directs a reconsideration to reconcile pension rights with financial realities.
WP(C) Nos.2517/2020; 25202/2020; 25209/2020; 25213/2020; 26222/2020; 27386/2020; 22466/2021; 23782/2021; 27795/2021; 29919/2021; 30508/2021; 30564/2021; 30652/2021; 30668/2021; 30679/2021; 7461/2022; 27478/2022; 29383/2022; 35026/2022; 35173/2022; 35231/2022; 35246/2022; 453/2023; 456/2023; 1548/2023; 13827/2023; 16984/2023; 17289/2023; 25635/2023; 25814/2023 The batch writ petitions in WP(C) Nos. 2517/2020 and connected cases challenge amendments and SOPs affecting Unit Run Canteens (URCs) run within Army formations. Petitioners, URC staff including ex-servicemen and dependants, contend that URCs are State instruments or ‘other authorities’ under Article 12 of the Constitution, and that writ jurisdiction under Article 226 is available to challenge their terms of service and related amendments. Respondents, led by Union of India and the Defence establishment, argue URCs are private undertakings funded by regimental non-public funds, governed by SOPs and AO/19/2003/QMG, without deep and pervasive governmental control or statutory creation, hence not subjects of Article 12. The court, applying the Ajay Hasia framework (creation, finance, and control) and following established authorities (Ramana Dayaram Shetty, Sukhdev Singh, Andi Mukta, Zee Telefilms, Chotelal, Mohd. Aslam, Layak Ram, Sarasamma, Karuppaiah, Babian, etc.), finds that URCs do not satisfy the State/other authority tests. Creation is via Army orders, not statute; finance comes from non-governmental regimental funds; control is exercised largely by URC management under station authorities. The court ultimately holds URCs are not “State” or “other authority” under Article 12, upholds the preliminary objection, and dismisses the petitions, while granting liberty to petitioners to pursue appropriate industrial or civil remedies. The judgment is a single-judge decision (Basant Balaji, J.) dated 04-03-2024.
The petitioner, C.K. Mercy, was appointed as a High School Needle Work Teacher in St. Paul’s High School, Kozhinjampara, Palakkad, with effect from 01.06.2010, against a retirement vacancy, supported by Ext.P1. In the 2009-10 academic year the post of Needle Work Teacher was sanctioned in the High School section but was abolished in the Staff Fixation Order of 2010-11 (Exts.P2–P3). The Manager sought to challenge the abolition by moving the Deputy Director of Education (Ext.P4), but no orders were issued. The District Educational Officer (DEO) rejected the petitioner’s approval (Ext.P5), and appeals before the DDE were dismissed (Ext.P6). A statutory Revision Petition before the Director of General Education (Ext.P7) yielded no orders. The petitioner then sought sanction and approval from the Government (Ext.P8), which was rejected (Ext.P9), a decision upheld on review (Ext.P10). The petitioner had earlier approached this Court in W.P. (C) No.14099/2014, withdrawn with liberty to file a fresh petition. Counsel for the petitioner contends Ext.P3, which abolishes the post, is unsustainable since a Sewing Teacher post falls under the Craft Group, whereas the Music Teacher belongs to the Arts Group, and the existence of a Craft/Seamstress post is subject to Rule 6(4)(c), Chapter XXIII, KER, only when at least 200 girls study. She cites Suman Paul (2013 (2) KHC 598) to support admissibility of the Sewing post where conditions are met. The State counters that the two provisos to Rule 6(4)(c) restrict the sanctioning of Specialist posts, and that Ext.P10 is in line with G.O.s. The High Court sets aside Ext.P10, and directs reconsideration of the petitioner’s claim under Rule 6, Chapter XXIII, with an opportunity to be heard, not later than three months, taking into account Suman Paul and the statutory provisions.”
LA.App. Nos. 815 of 2014 and connected cases This is a consolidated, batch judgment disposing of Land Acquisition Appeals (LAA) arising from the Kovoor-Vellimadukunnu road widening under the Kozhikode City Road Improvement Project (KRSDP). The appellants include the State of Kerala represented by the District Collector, Kozhikode; the Special Tahsildar (LA), KOZHIKODE; the Kozhikode City Road Improvement Project; and the Kerala Road Fund Board. The respondents/claimants are persons whose lands were acquired for the road corridor; several related LARs (land acquisition references) were consolidated with LAAs 2014–2016 and numerous cross-objections. The Court addresses (i) classification of the acquired lands (rejecting wetland classification in favor of garden land in a highly developed, urban area), (ii) market-value-based compensation vs. the basis land, (iii) the applicable rate per cent, and (iv) statutory interest under sections 23(1A) and 4(1) of the Land Acquisition Acts, and section 54 of Kerala’s Land Acquisition Act, 1961. After hearing extensive evidence (Advocate Commissioners’ reports, Exts. A1–A3; Ext.X1), the High Court holds that enhanced compensation is warranted in many cases, fixes rates (ultimately up to Rs 4.5 lakh per cent in most cases) and directs payment of 12% additional land value from the 4(1) notification to taking possession. The judgment disposes of dozens of connected appeals, with subsequent modification orders issued in 2023 increasing the cross-objection awards to Rs 5 lakh per cent for specific CO Nos. 17/22 and 148/22.