WP(C) Nos. 2517/2020; 25202/2020; 25209/2020; 25213/2020; 26222/2020; 27386/2020; 22466/2021; 23782/2021; 27795/2021; 29919/2021; 30508/2021; 30564/2021; 30652/2021; 30668/2021; 30679/2021; 7461/2022; 27478/2022; 29383/2022; 35026/2022; 35173/2022; 35231/2022; 35246/2022; 453/2023; 456/2023; 1548/2023; 13827/2023; 16984/2023; 17289/2023; 25635/2023; 25814/2023 This batch of writ petitions before the Kerala High Court challenges the status and treatment of Unit Run Canteens (URCs) under the Army Canteen Services. The petitioners, who include ex-servicemen and dependants working in URCs, contended that amendments to the SOP and other actions threatened their appointments and continued engagement, and they invoked writ jurisdiction under Article 226, asserting State/authority status and violations of constitutional rights. The respondents argued URCs are private undertakings financed and operated on non-public regiments funds, with management and staffing unrelated to the Consolidated Fund or deep government control; they flag that URCs are created by Army orders (AO/19/2003/QMG), funded by non-public funds, and governed by SOPs, thus not State or ‘other authority’ under Article 12. The court, applying Ajay Hasia’s creation/finance/control tests and citing precedents such as Layak Ram, Sombir Singh, Rajesh Tiwari, and Rudani, held that URCs do not constitute the State or an ‘other authority’ for Article 12 purposes. It dismissed the petitions as not maintainable, while granting liberty to pursue industrial remedies if appropriate.
BAIL APPL. NO. 785 OF 2024 This is a Kerala High Court bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 785 of 2024) by a sole accused in Crime No. 1071/2023 of Aroor Police Station, Alappuzha, charged under sections 324 and 307 IPC. The applicant, Sarin Kumar, was arrested on 17 December 2023 following allegations that on the night of 16 December 2023 he attacked his father with a chopper during a quarrel, causing injuries including two lacerated wounds; the defacto complainant reportedly blocked the attack with his hand. The prosecution contends the accused inflicted injuries while the father attempted to ward off the attack, amounting to grievous hurt and attempted murder, though no fatal injury occurred. The defense submits innocence, claims the complainant has mental derangement, and notes the investigation is nearly complete with the final report filed; the applicant has remained in judicial custody for about 50 days. The High Court, considering the wound certificate, lack of prior criminal antecedents, and near-completion of investigation, holds that continued detention is unnecessary and grants bail with stringent conditions. The order emphasizes accountability through conditions such as regular appearance, non-tampering with witnesses, no new offences, passport surrender (if any), updated addresses, and potential misuse restrictions. It also cites a Supreme Court principle permitting recovery actions by police even while on bail.
This is a Rent Control Revision from Kerala, challenging eviction under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The revision petitioner, Binu Varghese, a municipal councillor, was subjected to eviction by the Rent Control Court in RCP No.10 of 2023 on the ground of bona fide need for the landlord, K.S. Mathew, to occupy the premises for his own residential use for his daughter and son‑in‑law. The Rent Control Court’s order, dated 11.04.2023, was affirmed by the Rent Control Appellate Authority in RCA No.10 of 2023 on 21.11.2023. The revision petitioner contended that the landlord’s claimed need was not genuine and that the proceedings were tainted by indefensible contentions and delays; he also challenged the lack of applicability of provisos to Section 11(3). The High Court, while upholding the concurrent findings of fact and law, accepted that the bona fide need must be natural, real, sincere and honest, as per established Supreme Court and Kerala precedents. It noted the onus on the tenant to prove provisos and held that provisos 1 and 2 to Section 11(3) do not apply in this case. Ultimately, the revision petition was dismissed, but two months’ time was granted to the tenant to surrender possession, with conditions including an unconditional affidavit, arrears deposit, and ongoing rent payments.
Sheeba, the appellant, challenges the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakuda's common award dated 26.07.2019 in OP(MV) 1115/2016, seeking higher compensation for injuries suffered as a pillion rider on an Enfield Bullet. The vehicle KL-08-F-3806 collided with the motorcycle she rode as a passenger. The Tribunal held the insured liable for compensation and found no contributory negligence; it awarded Rs 94,690 with 8% interest from 05.10.2016. The appellant contends that the quantum is inadequate under several heads and seeks enhancement by applying the Ramachandrappa principle to fix a higher notional income of Rs 10,500 per month for a coolie, and to revise loss of earnings accordingly from Rs 16,000 to Rs 21,000. She also argues disability compensation should reflect a whole-body disability of 7.82% instead of 3%, and that damages for pain and suffering and loss of amenities are understated. The insurer opposes enhancement, arguing the Tribunal correctly assessed earnings, disability, and other heads, and that there was no contributory negligence. The High Court accepts the higher notional income and recalculates disability and other heads, increasing the total to Rs 1,13,190 and awarding an additional Rs 18,500 in appeal, with 8% interest and costs. The insurer is directed to deposit the enhanced amount within sixty days, with PAN and Aadhaar details furnished by the claimant.
WP(C) No. 25233/2022; WP(C) No. 32096/2022; WP(C) No. 32568/2023 The petitions challenge four Government Orders (dated 13.11.2018, 17.04.2020, 25.09.2020 and 30.04.2021) issued by the Government of Kerala that provided price-difference benefits for bitumen escalation to contractors whose works were ongoing as on 01.11.2018. Petitioners contend these orders created a benefit that extended to others beyond the original category or continued Works, arguing discrimination in denying the benefit to contractors who did not fit the exact cut-off. They rely on evidence in Exts.P8, P13, P15, P16 and related communications to show that benefits flowed to some contractors despite contemporaneous post-01.11.2018 tenders or agreements. They challenge the 26.08.2022 order (Ext.P11) that purportedly withdrew these benefits with prospective effect, arguing it should be interpreted to protect vested rights already crystallized and to grant relief under the earlier orders, following the Malabar Tech v. State of Kerala line of reasoning. Respondents submit that the four Orders restricted benefits to contractors whose works were ongoing as on 01.11.2018, that Ext.P3/Ext.P4 clarified scope, and that subsequent orders do not extend eligibility to post-cutoff contracts. The Court ultimately holds that eligibility was limited to pre-cutoff ongoing works and disposes of the petitions.
RSA No. 101 of 2023; RSA No. 102 of 2023 These regular second appeals Nos. 101/2023 and 102/2023 arise from two suits in the Additional Munsiff's Court, Ernakulam—O.S. 1422/2004 and O.S. 1055/2005. Joseph K.X., the plaintiff in O.S.1422/2004, challenged the trial court's decree rejecting his injunction claim, while in O.S.1055/2005 the defendants sought boundary fixation, possession and an easement right over a pathway. The trial court, after joint trial, dismissed the first suit and decreed the second by fixing the boundary along Ext. C2(a), granting recovery of plaint B to a named plaintiff, recognizing a right of way through plaint D, and restraining the defendant from obstructing that path. The appellate court confirmed these findings. Joseph challenged the common verdicts in the two Regular Second Appeals under Section 100 read with Order XLII Rule 1 CPC, arguing that the pleadings regarding the D schedule pathway were insufficient and that his title; The court, however, found no substantial question of law requiring admission. Relying on Nazir Mohamed v. J. Kamala and Others; Kondiba Dagadu Kadam; Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari; and Government of Kerala v. Joseph, the High Court held that formulation of a substantial question of law is mandatory for second appeals and dismissed the appeals as meritless, with all interlocutory applications also dismissed.
Divya K.N, the petitioner, seeks certiorari to quash Ext.P9, an order of the Agricultural Officer rejecting her Form 5 application for removal of land from the Data Bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy and Wet Land Act, 2008. The petitioner owns 0.0202 hectares in Sy. No.127/4 of Anakkara, Palakkad, and intends to construct a residential house. Her Form 5 application was rejected by Ext.P9, which relied on a report from KSREC and the Local Level Monitoring Committee. The petitioner argues Ext.P9 is not a speaking order and fails to address her submissions; she also contends that the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) did not independently assess the land’s status or call for a KSREC report as of 12.08.2008, which is a critical threshold date under the Act. The court refers to Muraleedharan Nair v. Revenue Divisional Officer and Aparna Sasi Menon v. Revenue Divisional Officer to emphasize the need for a speaking, reasoned order and for an independent assessment, focusing on whether land is suitable for paddy cultivation. The court finds Ext.P9 comically inadequate, sets it aside, and directs the 4th respondent to reconsider the Form 5 application within three months, with KSREC input to be obtained if necessary, and for the petitioner to file KSREC report within two weeks."
This Original Petition challenges an order of the Debt Recovery Tribunal-I, Ernakulam, dated 18.08.2023 in I.A.868/2022 in S.A.224/2021, concerning SARFAESI measures following default on a Rs.1.43 crore loan from Indian Overseas Bank. The petitioners sought stay of coercive steps, citing stay directions previously issued by this Court and non-compliance with statutory provisions such as Section 14(1) and Section 17(5)/Rule 12 of the DRT Rules. The Bank argued the order is appealable under Section 18 and that Article 227 is not available. It contended the Tribunal considered contentions and applied interim-relief principles, citing Varghese A.P. and Sama Rubber to show SARFAESI matters should not be unduly delayed and that High Courts should exercise Article 227 sparingly. The court notes a stay contingent on Rs.50 lakhs had been previously obtained; Ext.P21 directed rehearing and merits within two months. It ultimately held that the petitioners have an adequate statutory remedy and dismissed the petition, while clarifying it had not adjudicated the merits. The decision reinforces SARFAESI’s self-contained remedies and is not a substitute for appellate relief under Section 18.
WA 48/2020 (and connected batch) This batch of writ appeals arises from assessments under the Kerala Value Added Tax Act (KVAT) and the consequential amendments made by the Kerala Finance Acts of 2017 and 2018, set against the backdrop of the post-CAA 2016 constitutional changes. The core legal issue is whether amendments to Section 25(1) of the KVAT Act, substituting ‘five years’ with ‘six years’ and the third proviso extended by Finance Acts 2017 and 2018, can operate retrospectively to reopen completed assessments when the limitation period had expired prior to the amendments, especially after KVAT Act was repealed with the advent of the KGST regime. The court traces the legislative chronology: the 2017 amendment (Finance Act 11/2017) and its transitional commencement from 01.04.2017; the 2018 amendment (Finance Act 5/2018) extending the outer limit to 31.03.2019; the constitutional backdrop of CAA 2016 and Article 246A enabling concurrent state and central taxation; and the saving clause under KGST Act (Section 174). Notable authorities cited include Calcutta Discount Co., Hajee Abdul Shakoor, Baiju A.A., Jyoti Traders, Mohit Minerals, Reliance Industries, Prashar, Gadgil, Jyothi Traders and others. The bench concludes that the 2017 amendment is prospective for KVAT and that the 2018 amendment lacks competence post-repeal; the batch of appeals is dismissed with costs.
Robin, the sixth accused in Crime No.391/2009 of Kaduthuruthy Police Station, challenged the proceedings against him by filing a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 Cr.P.C. The matter arises from offences under the Kerala Abkari Act (Sections 55(a), 55(g), 55(h), 55(i), 55(B), 58(B)(a) and (e)). The prosecution alleged that on 19.09.2009, during a police search, the accused were found indulging in the manufacture of illicit IMFL by adding colour to arrack. The case was initially pursued in the Judicial First Class Magistrate court, Vaikom (C.P. No.27/2010), then committed to the Sessions Court, Adhoc No. I, Kottayam (S.C. No.277/2010). Annexure B records that in the trial, all accused except the petitioner were acquitted; the 1st accused was convicted on some counts, while others including the 1st accused were acquitted on certain charges relating to adding colour to liquor. The petitioner contends that the substratum of the case has been destroyed due to the acquittals of co-accused, relying on Subash v. State of Kerala and Ashok Kumar v. State of Kerala, and Moosa v. Sub Inspector. The State argues trial should continue as issues are factual. The Kerala High Court held that the substratum was destroyed by acquittals, invoked its inherent power under 482 Cr.P.C., and quashed the final report and proceedings against the petitioner.
The appellant, Babu, the 1st accused, challenges a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act, arising from possession of 500 ml of illicit arrack near Nelliyadikkadavu Palam in Viyyur amsom. The Trial Court, after hearing the case (SC 317/2006), convicted him and sentenced him to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. On appeal, the prosecution’s case is scrutinized for a credible genesis of the seizure and a proper chain of custody linking the sample analysed in the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory to the contraband allegedly recovered from the scene. The appellant argues that the arrest itself is not proved, the sample’s path to the laboratory is unproved, and the seizure documents lack seal details, with Ext P1 not describing the seal’s nature. The court examines whether the arrest memo (Ext P2) contains a crime number that undermines the genesis of the case, and whether the sample’s tamper-proof dispatch and sealing were established, citing case law on chain of custody and lab-sample linkage. The court ultimately finds the prosecution failed to prove the essential link between the seized contraband and the analysed sample, and thus acquits the accused. The appeal is allowed; the accused is acquitted and discharged.
This Criminal Appeal arises from a 2008 conviction of the appellant, Janaki, under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Fast Track (Adhoc-II) Court, Kozhikode, for possessing 2 litres of illicit arrack seized at Chathamangalam on 29 March 2004. The trial court convicted Janaki after the prosecution examined witnesses and marked exhibits, including a sample allegedly sent to the Chemical Examiner. The appellant challenged the link between seizure and analysis, the chain of custody of the sample, and the identity of the accused. The Kerala High Court questions the sufficiency of identification, noting there was no test identification parade and the witnesses who identified Janaki did so after four years, rendering in-court identification unsafe in the absence of a prior parade (citing Kanan, Jameel, Raja, Shukla and Hafeez). It also scrutinizes the chain-of-custody for the sample, emphasizing that non-examination of officials who handled the sample undermines tamper-proof assurance (citing Sasidharan and Daulat Ram). Additionally, it questions the detectability powers of the officer under the Abkari Act, since SRO provisions at the material time did not confer Abkari Officer status on the officer who detected the offence. Relying on Suresh v. State and related authorities, the court holds that the prosecution failed, acquits Janaki, and allows the appeal.
Eldhose, the appellant in CRL.A No.2262 of 2007, challenges the judgment of the Additional Sessions Court/Special Court for NDPS Act Cases, Thodupuzha, which convicted him under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act and sentenced him to one year of rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. The prosecution's case is that on 11 January 2003 at 12:50 pm, the appellant and co-accused were found transporting 10 litres of illicit arrack at Avarukutty junction, violating the Abkari Act. After investigation, the case was committed to the Sessions Court, where charge under Sec. 8(2) Abkari Act was framed and the accused were tried. The trial court convicted the appellant after hearing arguments on both sides. On appeal, the appellant contends that the prosecution failed to establish (i) the identity of the person who fled on seeing the excise party, and (ii) that the contraband seized was eventually subjected to chemical analysis in a laboratory. The respondent contends that the prosecution proved the offence. The High Court scrutinizes eyewitness identification given the long time gap, and the chain of custody for the seized sample and its laboratory analysis, citing several decisions (Baburaj, Krishnadas, Vijay Pandey, Bhaskaran, among others) to emphasize test identification parity, link evidence, and tamper-proof handling. The court ultimately holds that essential links are missing and acquits the appellant, allowing the appeal.
Cr. Appeal No. 798 of 2017 Arumughan, the appellant, was convicted by the Special Court for trial of offences under the POCSO Act and the Indian Penal Code for sexually assaulting a minor girl, aged 11 at the time of the incident, in 2014. The prosecution alleged repeated rape at Chandragiri Coffee Estate, Kadachikkunnu, Mattam, Mooppainadu Village, and at the accused’s home, leading to charges under IPC 376(2)(i)(n) and 506(ii) and POCSO Section 5(l)(m) r/w 6. The trial court, while the accused was in judicial custody, framed the charges, and after trial sentenced him to 10 years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000 for the rape offences, with concurrent sentences and no separate sentence for the POCSO count. Aggrieved, the appellant challenged the conviction, contending that it rested on uncorroborated testimony of a child witness and that medical evidence did not support the prosecution version; he argued the absence of independent witnesses. The State contended that the essential ingredients of the offences were proved and that the victim’s testimony, corroborated by PW3 (child line volunteer) and PW4 (hostel warden) along with medical records (Exts P8, P11), sufficed even without independent corroboration. The High Court held that the victim’s credibility was robust, emphasized that corroboration is not a mandatory rule in sexual offences, and relied on established precedents to affirm conviction and sentence. The appeal was dismissed with no interference in the trial court’s findings, and the conviction and sentences were upheld.
Contempt Case(C) No.463 of 2021 This Contempt Case (C) No.463 of 2021 arises from a writ petition disposed of on 15.06.2020 in W.P.(C)No.35605 of 2018, wherein the Kerala High Court directed action to abate noise pollution from loudspeakers used by the 8th respondent Temple Committee in compliance with the Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000 and the Kerala Police Act, 2011, while recognizing the right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution. The judgment relied on Forum, Prevention of Environmental and Sound Pollution v. Union of India (2005) 5 SCC 733 to frame the fundamental-right standard against noise pollution and on Robin Chacko v. State of Kerala and the earlier Church of God v. K.K.R Majestic Colony Welfare Association to emphasize that religious practices involving amplification must stay within environmental and police-law limits. In the contempt petition, the petitioner alleged willful disobedience of Annexure 1’s directions. Respondents filed affidavits; on 06.04.2022 the local SHO appeared with files. A joint meeting resolved to lock the amplifier box, keeping the key with the SHO to ensure that volume remains within permissible limits. The court, noting these steps and the agreement of the parties, held that no further orders were required and disposed of the contempt case by closing it with this factual resolution, thereby endorsing a pragmatic enforcement mechanism consistent with the statutory framework.
Sha ji S/o Saidalavi was convicted under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act by the Fast Track Court Palakkad for transporting spirit in a Maruti Zen car (KL 7BB-31) on 21.12.2006. The trial court sentenced five years’ imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 3,00,000. The appellant challenged the conviction in a criminal appeal before the Kerala High Court (Court (Adhoc)-II, Palakkad). The core issue was whether the seized spirit was subjected to chemical analysis in a laboratory and, critically, whether the chain of custody from seizure to analysis was properly established. The appellant’s contentions included inordinate delay in producing the seized properties, Ext P2 seizure mahazar’s failure to describe the seal, PW4’s lack of detail about the seal, Ext P9 forwarding note’s failure to include a seal specimen, and non-examination of several officials who handled the sample, all casting doubt on tamper-proof handling. The court canvassed authorities such as Sasidharan v. State of Kerala, Sathi, Ravi, Rajamma, Bhaskaran, Vijay Pandey and State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram, emphasizing that chain-of-custody and proper sealing are essential; a laboratory report cannot be linked to the contraband without showing that the exact sample reached the lab safely. Finding the link unsatisfied, the court acquitted the appellant and allowed the appeal, underscoring that the prosecution must prove a tamper-proof chain to sustain a chemical analysis connection.
The appeal arises from a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possession and transportation of illicit arrack, based on a sample allegedly seized near Thachurithazham Angady, Madavoor. The trial court convicted the appellant and imposed 1.5 years’ imprisonment and a Rs. 1 Lakh fine. On critical review, the Kerala High Court examines the prosecution’s chain of custody and the timeliness of the samples’ analysis. The Court observed that Ext. P7 (Chemical Analysis) shows the sample was forwarded on 06.03.2003 and reached the lab on 17.03.2003, but the analysis occurred only on 10.08.2004, with no explanation for the delay or for the custody of the sample between forwarding and analysis. Citing Viswanadhan, Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Krishnadas, and Vijay Pandey, the Court emphasizes that the prosecution must prove that the contraband sample tested in the laboratory is the same sample seized, in tamperproof condition, with a transparent chain of custody and proper handling by officials who were examined. Given the unexplained delays, absence of testimony from officials who handled the sample, and lack of corroborative link evidence, the Court holds that the link to the contraband was not established. Consequently, the conviction is unsustainable and the accused is acquitted; the appeal is allowed.
This is Criminal Appeal No. 2253 of 2007 filed by Imbichutty alias Vichutty challenging a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Adhoc District and Sessions Court (Adhoc-II), Manjeri, in SC No.264/2006. The trial court held the accused guilty for possession of 10 litres of illicit arrack in a plastic can on 22.06.2004 near his residence, sentencing him to one year’s imprisonment and a fine of Rs.1 lakh. On appeal, the High Court undertook a detailed examination of the prosecution’s chain of evidence, focusing on the legality of the detection, the seizure procedures, and the link between the seized contraband and the analysis report. The court scrutinized whether the detecting officer was an Abkari Officer at the relevant time, whether the seizure mahazar (Ext.P1) described the seal, whether a specimen seal was produced, and whether forwarding notes and lab timelines were properly established. It relied on precedents stressing that the seal’s nature must be described, the specimen seal produced, and the sample must be proven to have reached the laboratory in tamper-proof conditions with a clear link to the contraband. Finding serious deficiencies and delays, the court concluded there was reasonable doubt about the chain of custody and the link to the laboratory analysis, and acquitted the accused, allowing the appeal. The order underscores the stringent requirements for sample handling and evidentiary linkage in Abkari cases.
WP(C) Nos. 4244/2022; 6683/2022 This judgment of a single-judge of the Kerala High Court deals with the legality of the suspension of Appolly (Apputtu) C., Secretary of the Kunnameangal KSHEERA Vyavasaaya Sangham, and the challenge by the Sangham to the disciplinary process and the order canceling the suspension. Apputtu C. was suspended on 7.7.2020; extensions were granted, and the one-year limit under Rule 198(6) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969 expired on 6.7.2021. The Society sought a further extension through Ext.P2 and delayed action until the Registrar’s approval; Ext.P4 (8.2.2022) cancelled the suspension and ordered reinstatement, but the matter also involved WP(C) 6683/2022 filed by the Society challenging Ext.P7. The court underscored that indefinite suspension is not permissible absent material showing necessity to continue disciplinary proceedings, citing Leelamma Augustin M v. Kerala State Co-operative Rubber Marketing Federation Ltd. (2008) to emphasize that suspensions must be time-bound and justified by need. It held that there was no prior Registrar approval and no adequate material to sustain continued suspension beyond one year. Result: WP(C) 4244/2022 allowed with a direction to reinstate forthwith; WP(C) 6683/2022 dismissed, upholding the cancellation of the suspension order.”
This High Court of Kerala, in a Criminal Appeal (CRL.A. No. 2956 of 2008) by Bobby s/o Joseph, sets aside a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act and acquits the accused. The appellant was found in possession of 8 litres of arrack for sale on 28 December 2006 in Monippally village, leading to a three-year rigorous sentence and a Rs. 1 lakh fine by the Ad-hoc II – Kottayam Sessions. The prosecution's case rested on the seizure of the contraband at the place of occurrence, the arrest of the accused, and the samples sent for Chemical Analysis. On appeal, the defence argued that the arrest may be doubtful because the arrest memo bore a crime number, implying possible pre-FIR or post-seizure recording, and that the sample's genuineness and chain of custody were not established due to delays, lack of seal description, absence of specimen seals, and unexplained custody. The Trial Court convicted after considering Exts P1-P6 and related materials. The High Court, per Justice K. Babu, found that the prosecution failed to demonstrate a direct link between the seized sample and the Chemical Analysis Report, and that the chain of custody and sampling procedures were not satisfactorily proven. Consequently, it held the accused not guilty, acquitted him, and permitted return of deposit. The appeal was allowed.