This is an original petition under the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (KAT) challenging OA 426/2019. The Central issue is whether a part-time casual sweeper, Abdul Majeed, employed at the Forest Check Post, Illithode and later Kadapppara, could be regularised under Government Order Annex A4 (GO (P) No. 501/2005/FIN) of 25.11.2005. The KAT had held that the applicant was entitled to regularisation with effect from 18.6.2001 after setting aside Annex A12 and directed the 1st respondent to pass orders on Annex A6 within three months. The petitioners submitted that the sweeping area, originally certified as 201 sq.m., later shifted to Kadapppara in 2007 and was reduced to less than 100 sq.m., which would negate eligibility under Annex A4 GO, which prescribes regularisation only where sweeping area exceeds 100 sq.m. The High Court clarified that the applicant’s right accrued on the date of Annex A4 GO and cannot be denied by subsequent changes, affirming that the Tribunal correctly applied the guidelines. Consequently, the O.P. (KAT) is dismissed; the applicant is thereby entitled to regularisation, with the Government to implement the relief in terms of the Tribunal’s order. The decision hinges on protecting accrued rights under theGO despite later alterations in site specifics, citing Mercy v. State of Kerala as supporting precedent.
This Kerala High Court criminal misc. petition arises from a trial for serious offences including Section 302 IPC. A witness had recorded the incident on a mobile phone and handed a CD to the investigating officer. The CD was marked as a material object since the prosecution had not produced a 65B certificate under the Indian Evidence Act. The prosecution sought permission to receive the 65B certificate to make the CD’s contents admissible. The defense opposed, arguing that admitting the CD as a document at a belated stage would enable tampering and prejudice the accused, undermining fair trial since all documents should be supplied with the final report. The Sessions Court allowed the belated 65B certificate and permitted the prosecution to display the CD’s contents in court, with PW9 recalled to prove the contents. The Public Prosecutor pressed that the 65B certificate is a procedural safeguard, not an evidentiary creator. The court invoked Section 311 Cr.P.C., noting its wide discretion to aid truth-seeking while ensuring justice. Relying on precedents (Sabharwal, Soni, Varsha Garg, and Khotkar), the High Court held that belated production of the certificate is permissible if no prejudice arises, and that copying the CD must be provided to the accused. The court disposed the petition with modifications, preserving the certificate’s admissibility while restricting public display of the CD contents and directing transfer of a CD copy to the accused before recalled testimony.
RFA 270/2017; RFA 374/2017 These Regular First Appeals arise from the judgment and decree dated 29-10-2015 in O.S. No. 85/2007 of the III Additional Sub Court, Ernakulam, on a contract for construction of a 350-bed Ayurveda hospital at Thripunithura. The plaintiff, P.K. Ramachandran, sought declaration and realization of money for work executed for the State Public Works Department (PWD); the work spanned from 1999 to 2005 with a late site handover and delayed material supply by the defendant. The trial court partly allowed the plaintiff’s claims under multiple heads: payment based on 1996 and 1999 PWD schedules, additional marble flooring, semi-wire-cut bricks, and open-market procurements, along with interest and cement value, totaling substantial sums. The defendants argued limitations and that supplemental agreements and final bills capped claims at agreed rates, asserting no entitlement to enhanced rates due to extensions. The appellate court overruled the limitation argument, recognized that the delay was not caused by the plaintiff, and relied on established case law (Aries v. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board, Assam State Electricity Board v. Buildworth, and P.M. Paul v. Union of India) to affirm escalation principles. It affirmed most of the trial court’s findings while clarifying interest and costs. On final disposal, RFA 270/2017 was dismissed; RFA 374/2017 was partly allowed, granting pendente lite and future interest at 6% and proportionate costs.
This original petition challenges the Ext.P6 final order dated 17.02.2023 of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram, in OA No. 672/2020, wherein Vijith T.K. Thekke Koodathil, the petitioner, is a third party to the OA proceedings. The High Court reiterates a settled principle that a third party to OA proceedings may not have locus to file an original petition in this Court against a Tribunal decision; the proper remedy is to approach the Tribunal itself by initiating appropriate proceedings, including a review. counsel for the petitioner sought leave to withdraw this petition with liberty to approach the Tribunal. The court cites Rajeev Kumar and Another v. Hemraj Singh Chauhan and Others (2010) and Haris K.M. and Others v. Jahfer K. and Others (2021) as authorities informing the locus principle and available remedies, though without treating them as binding to override the Court’s view. On balance, the court grants leave to withdraw the petition with liberty to approach the Tribunal in appropriate proceedings and disposes of the petition accordingly. Annexures A1–A36 and Exhibits P1–P6 accompany the petition, detailing gazette notifications, degrees, eligibility, experience, and RTI-related documents relevant to the dispute over the post of Head of Section-C Computer Applications & Business Management in Government Polytechnics.
The petitioners, led by Housing Development Finance Corporation Limited (HDFC Ltd.), along with two auction purchasers (petitioners 2 and 3), challenged a Sub Registrar’s refusal to register the sale certificate Ext. P3 on the ground of an attachment created by a court later than the mortgage. The borrowers (respondents 4 and 5) defaulted on a loan secured by an equitable mortgage in favour of the first petitioner under the SARFAESI Act, and the property was sold at a public auction (Ext. P2) in favour of petitioners 2 and 3. The Sub Registrar refused registration of Ext. P3 due to an attachment by the Addl. Munsiff, Kottayam (O.S. 561/2022, I.A. 1/2022, dated 01.10.2022), which is reflected in Ext. P6. The petitioners contend the attachment occurred after the mortgage was created and, under established law, does not affect the sale under SARFAESI; it should be effaced from the encumbrance register (as per Madhan S. v. Sub Registrar and subsequent decisions). The respondents argued that the attachment creates a legitimate impediment to registration. The Court relied on Madhan’s line of authority and its affirmations in Ali Asharaf M.M. and Sajitha Nizar cases, concluding the attachment post-mortgage does not invalidate the sale. Ext. P6 is quashed; registration of Ext. P3 should be effected, and mutation in favour of petitioners 2 and 3 ordered, with other civil rights preserved. The petition is disposed of.
The Kerala High Court, before the single judge P. V. Kunhikrishnan, hears a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC filed by George Bivera, the accused in SC No.301/2014 arising from Narakkal Police Station crime no.791/2012. The case concerns offences under IPC sections 452 and 332 and Section 3(1)(x) of the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989, allegedly committed during a dispute at a service co‑operative bank where the defacto complainant works as a clerk. The prosecution’s case is that the accused, due to prior animosity toward the SC/ST defacto complainant, barged into the bank with the deliberate intention to obstruct the complainant’s lawful duties and physically assaulted him. The petitioner seeks quashing of the ongoing prosecution on the basis that the parties have resolved their dispute via a notarized settlement and the victim has filed an affidavit stating no objection. The learned Public Prosecutor initially expresses reservations about quashing solely on settlement, but concedes that the matter is settled. The court, relying on decisions in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019 (5) SCC 688) and the earlier Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh and Others v. State of Punjab, lays down the framework: quashing non‑compoundable offences may be permissible when the dispute is private, the offence is not heinous or of a public‑interest nature, and the settlement is genuine; the court will assess antecedents and the conduct of the accused where necessary. After reviewing evidence and the settlement affidavits, the court finds the dispute private and settled, and thus allows the Crl.M.C. and quashes all further proceedings against the petitioner.
Vinod D., the petitioner, invokes the inherent powers of the High Court under Section 482 CrPC to quash a pending criminal proceedings, CC 628/2023, arising from Crime No. 314/2023 of Chirayinkil Police Station, currently before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Attingal. The accused are alleged to have committed offences under sections 294(b) (obscene language), 323 (voluntarily causing hurt), 506 IPC (criminal intimidation), and 427 IPC (mischief). The prosecution asserts that the accused used filthy language, assaulted the victims, and intimidated them. The defence contends that the dispute has been amicably settled and the victims have filed affidavits indicating consent to quash the proceedings. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing on the basis of a settlement alone, but conceded that the matter is settled. The court examined the facts, the affidavits, and governing authorities, relying on the Supreme Court decisions in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688, which discusses the conditions under which 482 can quash non‑compoundable offences, and on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab for the governing principles. The court concluded that the dispute is private in nature and that the settlement can be accepted, quashing CC 628/2023. The order reiterates that 482 powers to quash are exercised where the offences are private, non‑heinous, and settled, with appropriate consideration of the accused’s antecedents and conduct.
This writ petition (WP(C) 18492/2013) before the Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, concerns Ananda Kumari @ Anandi, a tenant claiming Kudikidappukaran status under the Kerala Land Reforms Act and seeking inclusion in the Kudikidappukars register to enable purchase rights. The petitioner argues that Section 2(25) defines Kudikidappukaran and that Explanation IIA deems certain long-occupants as Kudikidappukaran; she requests mandamus to (i) prepare and maintain a Kudikidappukars register under Section 80 and Rules 73-76 of the 1970 Tamiln? Kerala Land Reforms (Tenancy) Rules; (ii) consider and dispose of her application dated 24/4/2013 to include her name in the register; and (iii) restrain OA No. 7/1968 from proceeding until disposal of the application. The State counters that a right to purchase cannot accrue unless she is declared a Kudikidappukaran via Section 80 procedures. Landowners’ counsel also supports the prayers. The court relies on the Supreme Court’s decision in Madavi Amma v. S. Prasannakumari (AIR 2013 SC 1384), which held that the government must prepare and maintain a Kudikidappukars register. The judge, after hearing, allows prayers A and B and directs the 2nd respondent to decide the Section 80 application and maintain the register, with hearing afforded to all parties, and to complete the exercise within six months from the date of judgment.
Con. Case (C) No. 2031 of 2023 This Contempt of Court Case (Civil) No. 2031 of 2023 before the Kerala High Court arises from the writ petition W.P.(C) No. 31851 of 2022, which directed the National Highway Authority of India (NHAI), Kannur Project Implementation Unit, to consider Ext.P2 representation dated 03.09.2022 within six weeks and to pass orders in accordance with law. Petitioners Abdul Nasir C.I. and Namshad K.M., seeking mandamus to install traffic signals at the Nainmarmoola Junction on NH-66 and to respond to the representation, allege willful disobedience by the Project Director, who issued Annexure 3 (23.11.2022) and Annexure 5 (07.01.2023) communications in reply to Ext.P2. Annexure 3 states that during construction, traffic diversion plans and signage shall be by the concessionaire per IRC SP 55-2014; post-construction, signage shall follow IRC 67-2012; Annexure 5 mentions an underpass as a change of scope. Counsel for petitioners argued that these responses violate Annexure 2's directions and amount to willful disobedience. The respondent argued that IRC norms and road-safety standards govern, that the project requires expert evaluation, and that the Court’s role is limited in such policy matters. The Court noted Annexure 2’s directive was the sole relief and there is no proven willful disobedience; consequently, the contempt petition is closed, while the directive to consider Ext.P2 within six weeks remains a guiding order.
CRL.M.C. No. 7279 of 2023 This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC filed by accused Nos.1 to 5 in C.C. No.643/2018 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Kasaragod, arising from Crime No.25/2018 of Vidyanagar Police Station. The petition seeks quashing of the proceedings in the non‑compoundable offences under Sections 341, 323, 324, 506(i) and 294(b) read with Section 149 IPC. The prosecution case alleges wrongful confinement and assault with filthy language. The petitioners and the victim state that the dispute is settled and do not wish to pursue the prosecution. The Public Prosecutor expresses reservations but concedes the settlement. The court examines the settled law on quashing non‑compoundable offences via Section 482 CrPC, notably State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) 5 SCC 688, which, following Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, lays down a framework: quashing is permissible for private, civil‑character disputes where parties settle, not for heinous or public‑interest offences or offences under special statutes; and the High Court may consider antecedents and conduct of the accused when accepting settlement. Applying these principles, the court finds the dispute private and the settlement acceptable, and thus quashes the proceedings in C.C.643/2018 against the petitioners. The order reflects a cautious, principle‑based exercise of 482 CrPC to end private disputes that do not affect public safety, subject to the continued validity of the cited precedents.
Chandramathy and three other petitioners, landowners in Nemmini Village, challenged the omission of the 3rd respondent Tahsildar (LR) from entertaining their application for reassessment of the Basic Tax rate on their land and for entries in the Basic Tax Register. They own about 30.30 Ares in Survey Nos. 177/4 and 75/5A in Thachinganadam Desom. Their predecessor had obtained an order under the Kerala Land Utilisation Order, 1967 (Ext. P5) in 1981 permitting non-agricultural use of the land. Despite this enabling order, the land continued to be described as Nilam/Paddy land in revenue records, and the petitioners filed Ext. P9 under Section 6(3) of the Kerala Land Tax Act, 1961 seeking reassessment and entries in the Basic Tax Register. The Tahsildar did not decide the application, prompting the writ petition. The Government Pleader resisted, arguing that Ext. P5 requires verification and current land status must be ascertained before any reassessment. The Court relied on Mary Abraham v. State of Kerala and District Collector, Ernakulam v. Fr. Jose Uppani, which held that after a valid KL U Order, earlier classifications become redundant and a fresh assessment under Section 6A is mandatory; and that post-2008, authorities must consider subsequent Form 5A under the Kerala Land Tax Act. The petition is allowed, with the Tahsildar directed to process Ext. P9 within one month.
This writ appeal challenges the selection process for the post of Assistant Professor in Sanskrit (Nyaya) at Sree Sankaracharya University of Sanskrit, arising from Ext. P1 notification inviting applications for four vacancies (one reserved for Ezhava, one for SC, two open). The appellant, Ashitha R.K., alleges that amendment to Section 32 of the Sree Sankaracharya University Act, 1994 by Act 26 of 2014, and the category-wide reservation system, violate Articles 16(1) and 16(4) of the Constitution by treating all university departments as a single unit. The selection process followed the UGC Regulations, 2018 (Minimum Qualifications, Appendix II, Table 3A; Regulation 4.1.I and its Note), under which short-listing is based on academic scores and the interview is used for final selection. The University fixed index marks (55 for SC/ST, 60 for others) and only candidates meeting the cut-off were invited for interview; the appellant scored 42 and was not shortlisted. The Single Judge dismissed the petition as the appellant did not challenge her exclusion. The Division Bench upheld this approach, holding that the appellant lacks locus standi to challenge the Note or Section 32, and that even if those challenges were entertained, relief would be unfounded. The court ultimately dismisses the writ appeal, endorsing the respondent's selection framework and relying on precedents such as Kiran Gupta to justify interview-based selection.
CRL.R.P Nos. 474 & 475 of 2022 This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition challenging two concurrent judgments arising from two private complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, filed by the accused, Binu Mathew, against the State/complainant and against Joby Joseph. The underlying cases S.T. Nos. 22/2013 and 43/2013, at the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Changanacherry, involved dishonor of cheques for Rs. 1,50,000 and Rs. 3,00,000, respectively. After trial, the court convicted the accused under Section 138 NI Act and imposed sentences (four months’ imprisonment plus Rs. 1,50,000 fine in the first case; six months’ imprisonment plus Rs. 3,00,000 fine in the second) with compensation under Cr.P.C. The appellate court (Additional Sessions Judge-II, Special, Kottayam) partly allowed the appeals by confirming conviction but modifying sentences to imprisonment till rising of the court, with the fine to be paid as compensation to the complainant, and a date for appearance to serve the modified sentence. The revision petitions challenged these concurrent findings and the modified sentences, arguing misappreciation of evidence and improper interference with the trial court’s findings. The High Court, invoking revisional principles and numerous precedents on supervisory, non-appellate nature of revision, ultimately dismissed the petitions, while directing limited payment and surrender terms and releasing a portion of the deposited amount to the complainant. The matter highlights the narrow scope of Cr.P.C. revisional review in NI Act cases and the enduring presumption framework in Section 138 proceedings.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No.6489 of 2023) was filed under Section 482 CrPC before the Kerala High Court by seven accused challenging the continuation of criminal proceedings arising from SC No.1503/2022 in the Principal Sessions Court, Thiruvananthapuram, connected with Crime No. 224/2022 of Malayinkeezhu Police Station. The accused face offences under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 452, 294(b), 323, 324, 427 read with 149, and Section 3(1)(r)(s) and 3(2)(Va) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Amendment Act, 2015, on allegations of forming an unlawful assembly to assault CW1 to CW3 and to humiliate them by caste references. The petition asserts the dispute is private in nature and has been resolved by settlements, with the victims supporting this and opposing continued prosecution. The Public Prosecutor, while acknowledging the settlement, expressed reservations about quashing non-compoundable offences, and argued for careful scrutiny. Relying on the Supreme Court’s decisions in Laxmi Narayan, Gian Singh, and Narinder Singh, the Kerala High Court held that private, settled disputes involving non-heinous offences may warrant quashing under Section 482, after examining antecedents and the circumstances of the case. Finding the case private in nature and acceptable settlement, the court allowed the petition and quashed all further proceedings in SC No.1503/2022. The judgment notes that the court may examine whether the inclusion of S.307 IPC or other serious provisions is merely formal; quashing is permitted where the dispute is private and settled, subject to the described safeguards.
The petitioner, SUT Hospital, Pattom, a company registered under the Companies Act, challenges Ext. P9, the Labour Court, Kollam's preliminary award in ID No. 55/2015. The Labour Court held that the disciplinary enquiry against two employees—Sri R. Jayachandran and Sri Shaji—was conducted without following proper procedure and that the evidence did not support the enquiry officer's findings. The Government referred the dispute to the Labour Court under Section 10(1)(c) ID Act, 1947. The petitioner contends that the Labour Court travelled beyond its powers by concluding the findings were not based on evidence and argues that the decision on a preliminary issue should not determine the rights of the parties at large; at issue is whether the preliminary order can be interfered with before final adjudication. The petition relies on Supreme Court decisions in Cooper Engineering Ltd v. P. P. Mundhe and other cases (S.K. Verma; D.P. Maheshwari) that caution against stalling industrial adjudication by challenging preliminary findings, and on Kerala and Amrita decisions reiterating that High Courts should refrain from interfering with preliminary Labour Court orders and that remedies lie in the final award. The court ultimately dismisses the writ petition, holding it not inclined to entertain the challenge to the preliminary award and leaves open the petitioner's right to challenge the final Labour Court award on aggrieved grounds, emphasizing speedy resolution of disputes.
WP(C) Nos.25515 of 2021, 191 of 2022 and 276 of 2022 These writ petitions challenge a 2021 order of the Cochin Devaswom Board granting leisure boating and a cafeteria in Vadakkechira, the renovated pond at Asokeswaram Devaswom temple. The petitioners, devotees and temple guardians, contend that the pond forms an inseparable part of the temple and its sacred environs; therefore, commercial leisure activities and the adjoined cafeteria should not be permitted, and the pond should not be alienated for any purpose. The petitioners rely on Chandran v. Travancore Devaswom Board (2003) which held temple ponds to be sacred places linked to temple sanctity. The pleadings reveal that the Board's 2021 approval (Ext.P7) authorized a three-year maintenance period ending 2024, for leisure boating and a cafeteria, following renovation orders issued in 2020 and 2021; the arrangement involved a private contractor and signage on pedal boats. The respondents argue that the rehabilitation and ongoing maintenance are essential to preserve the pond and to fulfill devotees’ needs, with expert input from Kerala Agricultural University and Tantri's acceptance of certain rites; they maintain that the Devaswom Board is a trustee obligated to maintain temple properties. The court, after careful scrutiny, holds that the procedure in Ext.P7 was arbitrary and illegal, and disposes the petitions by setting aside the challenged order, directing the Board to reconsider after obtaining Tantri and scientific opinions, within two months, while ensuring protection and maintenance in the interim.
V.J. Wilson, the title holder of 62.32 acres in Ezhupunna, filed this writ petition aggrieved by Ext.P9 and sought directions to prevent interference with his boundary ridge construction essential for paddy cultivation on land covered by Ext.P1 sale deed. The property lies as nilam with backwater on one side and adjacent lands on other sides; the ridge had been damaged, and the petitioner began reconstructing it (chiravarambu) using mud from the land itself. The Fourth Respondent Village Officer issued Ext.P5 stop memo alleging conversion of paddy land. The petitioner contends that he is only maintaining a boundary ridge to enable pokkali cultivation and fish farming, activities permissible under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, and relies on Exts.P1, P2, and policy provisions. He asserts that Ext.P7 directed reconsideration in light of Ext.P6 (Subramonian Namboothiri v. District Collector, Malappuram) and that the Fourth Respondent did not inspect or hear as required, while Ext.P9 purportedly classifies the land as wetland. The court surveys the Act’s provisions, cites several precedents—Subramonian Namboothiri, Wonderla Holidays Ltd., Mariadas, Suraj, Jafarkhan—and highlights that ridge strengthening for paddy and fish farming can be lawful if it does not amount to reclamation. It sets aside Ext.P9 and directs a joint inspection, with a fresh decision within two weeks, and, if merely ridge repair, allows it under supervision.
Supriya S's writ petition challenges Ext.P6, the PSC's 16-01-2016 order denying seniority to petitioner in Draughtsman Grade II cadre of the Kerala Water Authority. She was included in the short list but omitted before final rank publication, allegedly for higher qualifications. She pursued relief through O.P.12048/1997, leading to a 2003 review petition (RP 636/2003). The High Court, via Ext.P1 dated 15-12-2003, directed that she be considered for advice in the next arising vacancy, and an advice memo (Ext.P3) was issued on 14-01-2004 with appointment on 30-01-2004 (Ext.P4). The impugned order treated seniority as arising from the date of advice, ignoring the review directive's turn and the possibility of seniority over lower-ranked persons. Petitioner argued that seniority could be assigned over those ranked below, given the rank-list appointments. The respondents contended that seniority is fixed from the date of advice or re-advice, in accordance with Rule 227(c) KS&SSR 1958 and Rule 3(C) KS&SSR 1958, and that Ext.P1 did not direct modification of seniority. The High Court found Ext.P6 unsustainable, set it aside, and issued a mandamus directing PSC and Water Authority to assign seniority above lower-ranked persons after notifying those likely to be affected, within four months, relying on Jyothi v. PSC.
This High Court of Kerala, in Crl.M.C No. 5050 of 2023, entertained petitions by five accused challenging the continuation of CC No.39/2023 arising from Crime No.406/2022 of Kakkur Police Station, Kozhikode. The accused were charged with offences under sections 143, 147, 341, 323, 324, 326 read with 149 IPC. The core factual backdrop is an alleged unlawful assembly resulting in grievous hurt to the victim. The petitioners sought quashing under Section 482 CrPC on the ground of a settlement between the parties. The victim filed an affidavit stating willingness to settle; the victim-side counsel did not object. The Public Prosecutor raised reservations but conceded that there was a settlement. The court examined the settled private nature of the dispute and referred to Supreme Court jurisprudence (State of MP v Laxmi Narayan; Gian Singh; Narinder Singh) clarifying that Sec 482 quashing is permissible for non-compoundable offences where the dispute is private and the parties have resolved it, provided the offences are not of grave category. The court concluded that the case falls within the private dispute category and that the settlement is acceptable; thus, it allowed the Crl.M.C and quashed all further proceedings. The order underscores exercise of power under Sec 482 to promote private settlement where appropriate.
668 of 2021; 169 of 2022; 721 of 2022 These matrimonial appeals arise from a common judgment of the Family Court, Thiruvananthapuram, in OP Nos. 223 of 2018 and 224 of 2018, wherein the husband sought a decree of divorce and permanent custody of his minor children. The Family Court dissolved the marriage and dismissed the custody petition but granted the father visitation on Sundays from 10 a.m. to 5 p.m. The wife, both doctors, contested the divorce and the custody arrangement, arguing that reconciliation remained possible given their long history and professional commitments that would render frequent weekly visits impractical. The couple were separated for about five years with no meaningful prospect of reunion and allegations of cruelty floated by both sides. The High Court, after considering the evidence and the parties’ submissions, held that the marriage has become irretrievably broken. Relying on Samar Ghosh v Jaya Ghosh and Naveen Kohli v Neelu Kohli, among others, the court approved the view that continuing a doomed marriage is not in the public or familial interest and affirmed the underlying principles guiding dissolution where reconciliation is unlikely. The court disposed of the connected appeals by modifying the custody arrangement (granting the father specified visitation rights) and dismissed the separate appeal challenging the divorce, while ensuring the exchange venue and vacation custody are practicable. An overall balance was sought between parental rights and children's welfare.