Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 617 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
RSA No.1000 of 2012

State of Kerala represented by District Collector, Kottayam; Tahsildar Taluk Office, Kanjiirapppally; Asst. Executive Engineer, National Highway 220, Kanjiirapppally v. Tomy Dominic; Union of India represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Shipping, Road Transport and Highways, New Delhi

This Kerala High Court Regular Second Appeal arises from a suit concerning the plaint schedule property over item No.2 (20 square metres) in which a portion of a four-storeyed building stands. The suit, originally for perpetual injunction and later amended for declaration of title and possession, was decreed by the Munsiff and challenged in RSA No. 1000/2012. The appellants sought to condone a delay of 411 days in filing the appeal under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963. The Deputy Tahsildar supported the delay on grounds of administrative exigencies; the plaintiff-respondent countered that the reasons were not sufficient to condone such a long delay. The High Court applied the jurisprudence on condonation of delay, citing Esha Bhattacharjee and Basawaraj for the standard of “sufficient cause,” and Union of India for a liberal approach tempered by prejudice to the other side. It noted that the delay spanned over 411 days with an inconsistent chain of certified copy reception and drafting, and that only routine administrative explanations were offered. Ultimately, it held that there was no satisfactory explanation for the delay, dismissed the petition to condone the delay, and dismissed the Regular Second Appeal with no order as to costs.

High Court of Kerala
RC(Rev.) No.131 of 2023

M.M. Thomas v. A.K. Rajagopalan

This is a Rent Control revision arising from RCP 26/2022 before the Rent Control Court (Additional Munsiff), Kannur, where the landlord sought eviction under Sections 11(2)(b) and 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965 and the tenant was directed to pay arrears under Section 12. The tenant-contends that no rent is payable for the crusher unit governed by a 2016 licence agreement (07.11.2016) if the unit could not operate for more than 15 days; the licence cancellation and non-operability negated the rent liability. The Rent Control Court, by an order dated 23.02.2023, held admission of landlord–tenant relationship, acknowledged the admitted rent at Rs. 1,75,000 per month, and directed the tenant to pay arrears from 01.01.2021 at Rs. 1,75,000 per month, including a lump-sum arrears payment till January 2023, with further payments due. The Rent Control Appellate Authority (Thalassery) in RCA 443/2023 held that Section 18 appeals against Section 12(1) orders are not maintainable following Siddharthan (supra). The High Court questions this approach, noting that Section 18 allows appeals when rights are decided and that the impugned order touches jurisdiction and arrears without considering the licence deed. The Court refers Siddharthan for larger bench reconsideration and sets aside the 12(1) order, remitting for fresh consideration within three months. Annexure A1 contains the 07.11.2016 licence agreement between parties.

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos.7274 & 7067 of 2023

Harikrishnan v. State of Kerala (Bail Applications No. 7274 of 2023 and 7067 of 2023)

The High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam heard two regular bail applications filed by Harikrishnan, the 7th and 9th accused in two Neyyyardam Police Station crimes (Crime Nos. 1473/2021 and 1474/2021). The petitions, filed under Section 439 CrPC, relate to grave offenses including multiple IPC sections (141, 143, 144, 147, 148, 149, 120B, 294(b), 324, 353, 307, and in certain counts 341, 332, 427, 506(ii) read with 149), along with arms, explosive substances and damage-related statutes (Arms Act Section 27; Explosive Substances Act Sections 3 and 5; PDPP Act Sections 3, 4, 5; and related provisions of the Prevention of Damage to Private Property and Payment of Compensation Act 2019, and the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act 1984). The incidents allegedly occurred on 16.07.2021 at about 01:30 hours, where the accused formed an unlawful assembly near a police jeep, used deadly weapons, hurled a petrol bomb, and pelted stones, resulting in injuries and obstruction to the police in duty. Bail had been granted earlier in Crime No.1474/2021 but was later cancelled; in Crime No.1473/2021 bail had also been subject to CMPs for violation of conditions. Prosecution shows seven antecedents and anti-social conduct, including a rowdy-list designation. The court rejected the petitioners’ reliance on Rajeev v. State of Kerala, distinguishing it on the facts, and held that releasing the petitioners would jeopardize investigations and the trial, with risk of witness intimidation. Consequently, the bail applications were dismissed, balancing liberty with public order and safety.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 5078 OF 2023

Mohammad Rashid, Najimon K.E., Abin V.A., Shijin Shijo v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous petition (CRL.MC No. 5078 of 2023) under Section 482 CrPC challenging the order/judgment in CC No. 274 of 2023 of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Kothamangalam. The petitioners, accused 1 to 4, are charged with offences punishable under Sections 341, 323, and 294(b) read with 34 IPC. The prosecution alleges that on 15.12.2021, in furtherance of their common intention, they restrained the de facto complainant, hurled abuses, and assaulted him, causing injuries. The petitioners seek quashing of the proceedings, asserting an amicable settlement between the parties and the absence of any ongoing grievances, supported by an affidavit from the respondent. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but acknowledged there are no other crimes of serious nature against the petitioners. The High Court relies on Supreme Court precedents (State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan; Gian Singh v. State of Punjab; Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab) to outline the scope of Section 482 CrPC to quash non‑compoundable offences in civil/private disputes once settled, while excluding heinous or highly public offences and offences under special statutes. After considering gravity, injuries, antecedents, and the settled relationship, the court concludes that quashing would promote peace and ends of justice. The petition is allowed, quashing the Final Report in Crime No. 2904/2021 and all further proceedings in CC No. 274/2023.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.30178 OF 2023

State Bank of India v. Sub Registrar, Eravipuram Sub Registrar Office, Eravipuram; Village Officer Mundakkal; Dinesh Kumar. K; Nandu

The petitioner, State Bank of India, challenges Ext.P6, the order of the 1st respondent Sub Registrar refusing to register Ext.P5 Sale Certificate on the ground that the mortgaged property is attached in O.S. No. 36/2020 before the Sub Court, Kottarakkara. The 3rd respondent availed a Cash Credit Loan and created an equitable mortgage over 3 Ares of property by deposit of title deeds in 2014. After default, the loan was classified as a Non-Performing Asset and the bank proceeded under SARFAESI; the secured asset was auctioned and Ext.P5 Sale Certificate issued to the successful bidder. On presenting Ext.P5 for registration, Ext.P6 was refused due to the civil attachment evidenced by Ext.P7. The attachment, created on 27.10.2020, is subsequent to the mortgage’s creation on 17.01.2014, and the petitioner contends that such attachment cannot defeat the bank’s right to register the sale. The bank relies on Rajalekshmi Amma v. E.A. Basheer & Others, Madhan S. v. Sub Registrar Kollam & Others, and Keechery Service Co-operative Bank Ltd v. Sajitha Nizar alias Sajitha P.M. & Others, arguing that post-mortgage attachments do not extinguish or override the mortgage encumbrance, and that a mortgage remains an encumbrance notwithstanding attachments or alternative recovery methods. The court ultimately holds that Ext.P6 is quashed; post-mortgage attachments must be effaced from revenue records and Ext.P5 sale certificate must be registered if otherwise in order, directing the Sub-Registrar and Village Officer to complete the necessary steps within a stipulated period.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.26607 of 2023

A. Ramachandran Nair and Maya Ramachandran Nair v. State of Kerala and Others

The petitioners, A. Ramachandran Nair and Maya Ramachandran Nair, own 60.22 acres of land in Chengamanad Village, Ernakulam District. They challenge the omission of the 4th respondent Tahsildar in entertaining their application under Section 6A of the Kerala Land Tax Act, 1961 for re-assessment of the Basic Tax rate and for updating entries in the Basic Tax Register, despite obtaining Ext. P2, an order under the Kerala Land Utilisation Order, 1967, permitting non-agricultural use. They had sought reassessment after the lands were permitted to be converted, but their records still described the property as Nilam/Paddy Land. Ext. P2 was issued in 2021; Ext. P3 was filed under Section 6A, yet no orders were passed, prompting the writ petition. The State, represented by the Senior Government Pleader, argued verification of Ext. P2’s genuineness and the land’s current status before any reassessment. The court relied on the precedents in Mary Abraham v. State of Kerala and District Collector Ernakulam v. Fr. Jose Uppani to hold that once an enabling order under KLLO 1967 is in place, old entries become redundant and a fresh assessment under Section 6A KLTA is mandatory after verifying the permission. Accordingly, the writ is allowed, Ext. P4 is set aside, and the Tahsildar is directed to pass fresh orders on Ext. P3 within one month, with Form-A to be filed if required.

High Court of Kerala
Cont.Case (C) No.153 of 2021

Cont.Case (C) No.153 of 2021

Cont.Case (C) No.153 of 2021 is a contempt matter before the Kerala High Court arising from W.P.(C) No.11629 of 2015 and related petitions, involving six petitioners (petitioners 51, 64, 72, 89, 101 and 107 in 2015) who challenged the EPFO’s disbursement of higher pension under the Employees Provident Fund scheme. The petitioners filed the contempt petition under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, contending willful disobedience of directions issued by the High Court in the judgment dated 12.10.2018 in W.P.(C) No.11629 of 2015 and connected matters. The respondent EPFO, led by its counsel, opposed the contempt, while the Supreme Court’s later judgments—most notably the 2022 decision in Employees Provident Fund Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B. (AIR 2022 SC 5634) and related Supreme Court orders—played a pivotal role in guiding the proceedings. The judgment cites RC Gupta and others v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner, EPFO, and others (2018) 14 SCC 809 and recognizes the validity of the 2014 amendments (G.S.R.609(E)). It holds that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO under the 2022 apex directives, and directs such reconsideration. Finally, in view of the apex judgment, the Contempt Case is closed, preserving EPFO’s right to reassess entitlement in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MCNO.4423OF2023

Adith Manoj and Mohanan v. The State of Kerala and Manoj

This criminal misc. petition under section 482 CrPC challenges CC 134/2022 of the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Kolenchery, in which accused Nos. 1 and 2 — Adith Manoj and Mohanan — are charged with offences under sections 447, 341, 506, 323 and 324 r/w 34 IPC. The petition contends that the parties have amicably settled their dispute and do not wish to pursue the prosecution, and urges quashing so that the matter ends in peace. The State of Kerala, represented by the Public Prosecutor, resists quashing on the basis that the court should exercise restraint in cases involving non-compoundable offences and potential public interest concerns; however, it concedes no other serious crimes exist against the petitioners. The High Court cites State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, along with Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, to lay down the governing law: quashing is permissible under 482 CrPC for non-compoundable private offences where the dispute is settled, provided the offences are not heinous, serious, or under special statutes. After examining gravity, antecedents, and the settled relationship, the court holds that quashing would not adversely affect society and would serve ends of justice, thereby allowing the petition. The final quashing order terminates the proceedings in CC 134/2022 and related reports.

High Court of Kerala
El.Pet. No. 11 of 2021

Election Petition No.11/2021 (D. Kumar v. A. Raja)

Election Petition No.11/2021 before the Kerala High Court challenged the Devikulam (Reserved for Scheduled Caste among Hindus) seat in the 2021 Kerala Legislative Assembly election. The petitioner, D. Kumar, contended that the seat could be filled only by a person who belongs to the Hindu Parayan caste within Kerala. The respondent, A. Raja, asserted Christian identity by birth and baptism, with paternal grandparents who migrated from Tamil Nadu; he argued Hindu Parayan status in Kerala and relied on evidence and prior records. The petition argued that Section 5 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 requires a person to be a member of the relevant Scheduled Caste or Tribe in that state and to be an elector there, and that the respondent could not claim such status in Kerala given migration originating outside the state. It also challenged the validity of relying on a 1950 Presidential Order in a migrant context and invoked Articles 341 and 342 on state-wise recognition. The Respondent contended limitation and factual disputes; argued that migration occurred before 1950 and thus that Hindu Parayan status could be claimed in Kerala. The court reviewed constitutional provisions, state-specific caste notifications, and relevant precedents (including Marri Chandra Shekhar Rao; Puducherry v. Pondicherry; and Maharashtra v. Union of India) to hold that SC status is state-specific. It ultimately declared the respondent not a Hindu Parayan in Kerala and allowed the petition, voiding the election under Section 98 RP Act, 1951.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C)Nos.29371 and 29762 of 2023

W.P.(C)Nos.29371 and 29762 of 2023

These are two writ petitions challenging the e-tender notification dated 23.08.2023 issued by the Executive Officer, Sabarimala, for the year 1199 ME (2023-24) under which Kuthaka items 84A and 84B (hotels, refreshment stalls, fruit and juice stalls, etc.) were included for Sabarimala, Pamba and Nilakkal Devaswoms during Mandala-Makaravilakku. Petitioners, comprising former bidders and traders who ran hotels and stalls in Sabarimala/Sannidhanam during past seasons, argued that they cannot be forced to procure fruits, soft drinks or other items from Kuthaka holders and that the tender of 84A/84B is void, violative of rights, and enforceable only as per law. Respondents, notably the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB), contended that the inclusion is to curb unauthorised stocking and supply of fruits, vegetables and beverages in High-Security Zones and to preserve pilgrim safety, public health and fair play, relying on statutory powers under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, the Kerala Police Act, 2011 and the Food Safety Act, 2006, along with directives from previous court decisions. The Division Bench examined the legality of the Kuthaka items, the tender clauses (including Clause XV), and the Board’s surveillance measures, directing compliance with safety standards and ongoing monitoring. Ultimately, the court disposed of the petitions, upholding the tender framework while mandating regulatory oversight and reporting obligations to ensure safety and lawful conduct during Mandala-Makaravilakku.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 8280/2013 & 17283/2021

Ayisha v. The New India Assurance Company Limited and Others; Sajitha and Others v. The Manager, United India Insurance Co. Ltd. And Others

The two connected writ petitions challenge the tax treatment of interest earned on motor-vehicle-accident compensation awarded by MACTs. In Ayisha, widow of Ahammed, the MACT awarded Rs.3,01,000 with 8% interest; in Sajitha and others, claimants received Rs.22,77,500 with 8% interest. The insurer initially paid the compensation but later demanded PAN details and threatened TDS at 20% on interest if PAN details were not furnished, arguing the interest would be taxed as income. Petitioners argued that TDS on interest on MACT compensation is illegal since compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act is a restitutionary, beneficial remedy to victims and not a business income; interest is part of compensation and not taxable income. The counsel for the insurer contended TDS liability on interest as per IT Act provisions. The Kerala High Court, after examining judgments from several High Courts (Punjab & Haryana, Bombay, Madras, Gujarat) and the Supreme Court, held that the interest portion arising from MACT awards cannot be subjected to TDS and that the insurer’s demand for PAN details and the requirement to furnish IT returns is illegal. The court noted the SLP against Ext.P3 was dismissed and quashed the insurer’s communication. The petitions were allowed to the extent of preventing TDS on interest beyond the awarded compensation.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) Nos. 233/2023; 269/2023; 369/2023

OP(KAT) Nos. 233/2023, 269/2023 and 369/2023 v. State of Kerala and Others

These three original petitions under OP(KAT) challenge the Kerala Administrative Tribunal's orders concerning retirement age for AYUSH Department medical officers (Ayurveda and Homeopathy) in Kerala. The petitioners seek parity with Health Service doctors, who retire at 60, arguing equal treatment, pensions, and service conditions. The Tribunal had relied on the Supreme Court's decision in North Delhi Municipal Corporation v. Ram Naresh Sharma to hold AYUSH doctors entitled to the benefit of an enhanced retirement age. The State and AYUSH Department challenged, asserting that retirement age is a policy decision and that AYUSH doctors constitute a distinct class with different duties. A Division Bench of this Court in OA 142/2022 had previously held that the NDMC ratio has no application, directing that the matter be considered by the Government via representation. In the present judgment, the High Court affirms that retirement age is a policy matter and that AYUSH doctors form a distinct class with distinct duties; it endorses the Government’s stance not to extend AYUSH retirement age, citing the Gujarat v. Bhatt decision to support separate treatment of AYUSH doctors. Consequently, there is no interference with the Tribunal’s order, and the petitions are dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.14295 of 2021

Najeeya S. v. Regional Cancer Centre, Government of Kerala Health & Family Welfare Department, and Director of Medical Education

This writ petition concerns the entitlements of Najeeya S., a Laboratory Technician who transferred from the Medical Education Department to the Regional Cancer Centre (RCC) in 1990. The core dispute is how service and pay are to be reckoned for retirement benefits after bifurcation of posts between the Medical Education Directorate and RCC, and whether the petitioner’s earlier service from 1983 should be counted for terminal benefits. The petitioner contends that her service and pay should be fixed by reckoning her original date of entry, 16 March 1983, in line with older judgments and the government’s transfer promises, despite her 1990 transfer to RCC. The record traces through time-bound grade promotions, the transition to the Flexible Complementing and Ladder Promotion (FCP & LP) scheme, and the alignment of RCC pay scales with SCTIMST, including subsequent central pay revisions. The respondents argue that the petitioner quit government service on transfer and accepted terminal benefits, thus not entitled to reckon past service for RCC retirement benefits, and rely on Ext.R1(b) and Ext.R1(a) for interpretation of joining, seniority, and service conditions. The High Court ultimately allows the petition, quashing Exts P17, P20 and P23, directing arrears and pension fixation from 16 March 1983, and permitting the petitioner to pursue arrears under 6th and 7th Central Pay Revisions after a one-month representation window.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.25268 of 2021; WP(C) Nos.28793 of 2022

W.P.(C).Nos.25268 of 2021 & 28793 of 2022

The two writ petitions challenge government actions vis-à-vis the Koothuparamba Higher Secondary School (Koothuparamba Educational Society). The lead case, W.P.(C).25268/2021, filed by K. Balan Master, Secretary-cum-Manager of the Koothuparamba HSS, and the connected matter W.P.(C).28793/2022, filed by Sathyan Naravooraged, raise issues about the amendment of the society’s bye-laws, the term of the managing committee, and the government’s power under Section 14 of the Kerala Education Act, 1958 to take over management. The petitions trace a sequence from the 2009 bye-law amendment extending the seven-year tenure, to the 2018 general body amendment reducing it to five years (not conclusively approved). The government, citing lack of an approved bye-law and multiple civil disputes, entrusted management to the District Educational Officer; this was challenged as improper. The court examined whether Ext.P14 (the government order) was legally sound and whether the ongoing civil suits, elections, and bye-law amendments justify government intervention. It ultimately quashed Ext.P14, finding that the government’s action was not justified given an elected committee and pending civil proceedings, and directed that such issues be resolved in civil courts. The court, while quashing Ext.P14, left room for ongoing inquiries under prior judgments, and held no direction to take over should issue at this stage for W.P.(C).28793/2022.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4295 OF 2023

Sarin.S v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC filed by Sarin S., the accused in Crime No. 554/2023 of Pothencode Police Station, seeking quashing of the proceedings arising from a dispute that led to offences under Sections 294(b), 341, 323, 324 and 506 IPC. The prosecution alleges that on 28.03.2020, at about 3:00 pm, the petitioner wrongfully restrained the de facto complainant and caused injuries. The petitioner’s counsel submits that the parties have amicably settled their disputes, supported by Annexure-2 affidavit from the second respondent, and that terminating the proceedings would promote peace and allow both parties to move forward. The court previously directed investigation to verify the authenticity of the settlement and whether the petitioner has any criminal antecedents or impediments to quashing. The Public Prosecutor voiced reservations about quashing proceedings based solely on a settlement, but conceded lack of other transgressions. Citing a line of Supreme Court authorities including Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, Laxmi Narayan and others, the court lays down the doctrine that, for non‑compoundable offences of a private nature, the High Court may quash where the parties have resolved their entire dispute, except in grave cases (e.g., heinous offences) or in cases involving public wrongs. After considering the gravity of the allegations, injuries, antecedents, and the amicable settlement, the court concludes that quashing will not injure societal interests and would serve the ends of justice. The petition is allowed and Annexure-1 FIR and all further proceedings in Crime No. 554/2023 are quashed, with the proceedings terminated.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.3030 of 2019; CO No.198 of 2019; CO No.53 of 2020

Shriram General Insurance Company Limited v. Shyamala and others

This Kerala High Court judgment deals with MACA No.3030 of 2019 and connected cross-appeals challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode's award in OP(MV) No.1664/2017 for the death of Shyamdeesh in a motor accident dated 23.03.2017. The insurer (3rd respondent in MACA) appeals against the quantum of compensation; the claimants file cross-objections seeking enhancement. The Tribunal held the insurer liable and calculated compensation primarily under loss of dependency, based on a monthly income (without documentary proof) of Rs.12,000. The appellants contend this figure is excessive; the claimants contend for a higher monthly income in line with Manusha Sreekumar v. United India Insurance (SC), which fixes driver income using statutory/fair-wage context. The court, applying the Manusha Sreekumar principles, fixes the deceased’s monthly income at Rs.15,600 and recomputes loss of dependency with a 40% future prospects addition, using a 2/3 multiplier for 18 years, yielding Rs.31,44,960. After adjusting for amounts already awarded (Rs.24,19,200), the added compensation becomes Rs.7,25,760. The court also revises the head of loss of love and affection in light of United India Insurance Co. v. Satinder Kaur (SC), deducting Rs.1,00,000 and increasing the loss of consortium to Rs.1,20,000 (Rs.40,000 each for parents and wife) and reducing pain and suffering to Rs.10,000. The final result is an enhanced compensation of Rs.6,30,760 to the claimants, with deposit within three months.

High Court of Kerala
RPFC No.196 of 2022

Khaleel V.K v. Shafnasa T and others

This is a Kerala High Court revision petition (RPFC No. 196 of 2022) challenging a Family Court, Kannur order under Section 125 CrPC directing the petitioner to pay monthly maintenance to his wife and two minor children. The Family Court, after consolidating proceedings (including OP 33/2019 for past maintenance), ordered the revision petitioner to pay Rs. 8,000 to the first respondent, Rs. 7,000 to the second, and Rs. 6,000 to the third, from the date of the petition (totaling Rs. 21,000 per month). The petitioner, Khaleel V.K, who worked abroad (UAE) and claims substantial income, denied earning Rs. 1,25,000 monthly and contended that he was maintaining the respondents to the best of his ability; he also alleged that the first respondent deserted him and demanded Talaq, and that he must also support his aged mother and three sisters. The respondents contended the petitioner earns Rs. 1,25,000 monthly from employment abroad plus Rs. 25,000 from property and cannot sustain themselves without maintenance. The High Court relied on Supreme Court precedents emphasizing maintenance as a social-justice measure (Rajnesh v. Neha; Captain Ramesh Chander Kaushal; Bhuwan Mohan Singh) and held that adverse inference could be drawn from lack of evidence of income. The Court upheld the Family Court’s Rs. 21,000 monthly maintenance and dismissed the revision petition in limine.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 16268 of 2019

KERALA CRIMINAL JUDICIAL STAFF ASSOCIATION, DISTRICT COMMITTEE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM v STATE OF KERALA AND OTHERS

The petitioners, a district committee of the Kerala Criminal Judicial Staff Association and 16 other members of the Kerala Judicial Ministerial Subordinate Service in the Criminal Wing, approached the Kerala High Court challenging denial of a one-advance increment under the Pay Revision Order (Exhibit P2) for incumbents officiating as Head Clerk in the Special Court for Forest Offences. They contend that Bench Clerk Grade II posts, when promoted or transferred to the Head Clerk post in the Forest Offences Court, carry the same pay scale as the feeder category post; Exhibit P2, Paragraph 43, provides that where promotion or transfer to posts carrying the same scale of pay occurs, an advance increment should be granted, subject to exceptions for time-bound promotions or interchangeable posts. They argue that Head Clerk in the Forest Offences Court was created by Government Order (Exhibit P1) and that the non-inclusion of these posts in the Special Rules should not deprive them of the Benefit, relying on prior Kerala Civil Judicial Staff Organisation judgments that promotees on the same scale are entitled to the increment. The respondents contended that the posts are not clearly regulated by the Special Rules and that allowing the increment would contravene the pay structure. The High Court ultimately held that denial of the advance increment cannot be sustained, quashing Exts. P3, P5 and P6 to the extent of denial, and directing that Petitioners 2–17 are entitled to the one advance increment on their Head Clerk appointments in terms of Ext. P1, relying on the principle of seniority-based appointment and subsequent judicial interpretations. The petition is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.15717 OF 2020

Writ Petition (Civil) No. 15717 of 2020

This is a Kerala High Court writ petition filed by retired employees (petitioners) who are subscribers to the Employees’ Provident Fund (EPF). They seek higher pension under the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, claiming entitlement under the option exercised by them to secure a pension larger than the ceiling set by para 11(3) of the Employees’ Pension Scheme, 1995. The petitioners contend pension should be calculated on the average monthly pay drawn during the contributory period in the 12 months preceding exit, inclusive of 8 1/3% of the full contribution by the 7th to 16th respondent establishments, and without artificial wage ceilings. They pray for a mandamus to re-fix pension and pay arrears under the pre-amended scheme. The respondents, represented by the EPFO, contend that the issue is settled by the Supreme Court in EPF Organisation and Another v. Sunil Kumar B and Others (2022) and that the petitioners’ grievance should be addressed in accordance with those directions. The Court disposed of the petition by directing the competent respondents to re-consider the claims in light of the Supreme Court judgment within three months from receipt of a copy of the judgment.

High Court of Kerala
RPFC NO. 385 OF 2016

Musthafa v Zeenath and Safnas

Musthafa, the revision petitioner, challenges the Family Court, Tirur’s 2013 order in MC 471/2013 directing him to pay monthly maintenance to his wife Zeenath and their son from 13.12.2012. The Family Court consolidated the maintenance application under Section 125 CrPC with related relief petitions. The respondents testified that the couple married on 18.02.2007 and their second respondent was born on 24.11.2007; Musthafa, a construction worker earning about Rs.45,000 per month, treated the first respondent with cruelty and refused to maintain them. He contended that Zeenath left the matrimonial home without sufficient cause and that he had no job or income, arguing that the application should be dismissed. The respondents argued for maintenance on the basis of their need and lack of means. The Family Court, after recording evidence (PW1, PW2 for the respondents; RW1-RW3 for the petitioner; Exts P1–P7 and R1–R2), partly allowed the application by directing the petitioner to pay Rs.3,000 per month to each respondent from 13.12.2012. On admission, the High Court stayed execution on conditions: deposit 50% of arrears and continue to pay Rs.2,000 to each respondent. The Court dismissed the revision petition under Section 19(4) of the Family Courts Act, 1964, reiterating the benevolent purpose of Chapter IX CrPC and citing Anju Garg v. Deepak Kumar Garg to underscore the obligation of maintenance by an able-bodied husband toward wife and child.