CRL.M.C. Nos. 1697 of 2022 and 4147 of 2021 Two Criminal Miscellaneous Petitions (CRL.M.C. Nos. 1697 of 2022 and 4147 of 2021) are before the Kerala High Court seeking to quash proceedings in CC 1808/2017 (Judicial First Class Magistrate Court No. I, Ettumanoor) arising from Crime No. 1048/2017 at Gandhi Nagar Police Station. The petitioners, accused Nos. 1–3 in CRL.M.C.1697/2022 and the 4th accused in CRL.M.C.4147/2021, challenge the continuation of criminal proceedings on the ground that a settlement has been reached with the de facto complainant and his wife, who have sworn affidavits (Annexures A3–A4) acknowledging no remaining grievances. The respondents, including the State represented by the Public Prosecutor and the co-accused, support the settlement and confirm its genuineness after verification. The Court notes that the alleged offences (section 451 trespass, section 294(B) obscenity, section 323 hurt, and section 506(1) criminal intimidation, all read with section 34 IPC) concern a private dispute. It holds that when the dispute is private, and there is a genuine settlement, the likelihood of securing a conviction is bleak and continuing the prosecution would serve no fruitful purpose. Relying on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Another, the court exercises its inherent power under section 482 Cr.P.C. and quashes all further proceedings in CC 1808/2017. The petitions are allowed.
The High Court of Kerala, in a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Cr.M.C. No.1898/2013), quashed the private complaint and all subsequent proceedings against 12 petitioners (leaders of the Communist Party of India (Marxist)) arising from a 2 October 2009 ‘human chain’ protest along the National Highway in Kerala. The complainant alleged offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 149 and 283, and under Section 38 read with 52 of the Kerala Police Act, 1960, asserting unlawful assembly and obstructive conduct during protests linked to opposition to the ASEAN-India Free Trade Agreement. After cognizance was taken and the matter renumbered, the petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. argued mala fide proceedings and asserted that the protest constituted a lawful exercise of rights under Article 19 of the Constitution (freedom of speech and assembly). The court found no evidence of a common object to commit offences, no use of criminal force or mischief, and no prolonged or violent disruption; the protest was peaceful and transient, thus protected by fundamental rights. Applying de minimis principles (Section 95 IPC) and supporting precedents (Masalti, Aravindan, Akthar Alam, Veeda Menezes, Narayanan, Attappa, Amit Sahni), the court held the proceedings to be an abuse of process and allowed the petition, quashing the charges against the petitioners.
This is a Miscellaneous First Appeal under the Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923 filed before the Kerala High Court (Single Judge). The appellant is M/s. C.T.S Packers & Movers, challenging a Compensation Commissioner’s order that exonerated the owner of the vehicle and the insurer and fastened the entire liability on the appellant for the death of a worker who was unloading goods from a lorry owned by the fifth respondent. The deceased, employed by the appellant, died during unloading; his dependants sought compensation from the employer. The Commissioner held the appellant liable and absolved the owner and insurer. The appellant contends that liability should not rest solely on it; the substance of the case is whether the vehicle owner (and insurer) can be held vicariously liable, given that the driver—an employee of the owner—stationed the lorry beneath a power line and allowed the victim to stand on the goods, a configuration showing negligence by the owner’s employee. The court recognizes that while documentary proof of the employment relationship was lacking, the facts indicate the driver’s act attributable to the fifth respondent, making the owner liable to indemnify the principal to some extent under Section 12 of the Employees’ Compensation Act, 1923. The appeal culminates in apportioning fifty percent liability to the appellant and fifty percent to the insurer, directing payment of the corresponding shares to the respondents. The appeal is allowed with no costs.
This Criminal Misc Case challenges quashing of Annexure-I complaint and cognizance in CC No. 694/2008 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate-V (Special Court for Mark List Cases), Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioner, the 3rd accused, seeks to set aside sanction findings in Annexure-XI and discharge under Section 482 Cr.P.C. The complaint, dated 05.03.2003, alleges that on 26.02.2003, the accused, along with an accomplice posing as a thief, entered Maheshwari Jewellery at Chalai and, through coercion, extracted gold ornaments totaling 23 sovereigns, with threats that the complainant would be made a co-accused otherwise. The ornaments were allegedly bought from several jewelleries, and the gold was delivered to a Sub-Inspector to secure the complainant’s release on 27.02.2003. The incident involved Sections 420 and 506 read with 34 IPC. The petitioner contends lack of sanction under Section 197 Cr.P.C. and asserts protection under that provision, arguing the acts were performed in discharge of official duties; the investigation was led by another Sub-Inspector. The Respondents oppose, arguing no connection to official duties and that the course of investigation and procurement of gold were not protected. The High Court relies on the Supreme Court’s tests in Riswan Ahmed Javed Shaikh and Sankaran Moitra to determine the test for Section 197(3) protection, and ultimately quashes the proceedings, holding the acts during official duty and sanction not required.
Ranjith P. and Jayakumar K.S., devotees of Sree Pariyanampatta Bhagavathy Temple, filed a writ petition under Article 227 challenging the proposal to appoint a nonhereditary trustee by constituting a Board of Trustees for the temple. They argued the appointment is unauthorized, without jurisdiction, and violative of Section 39(1) of the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951, thereby infringing the petitioners’ fundamental rights under Articles 25 and 26 of the Constitution. They also sought a writ of mandamus to restrain the respondents from constituting a Board of Trustees mainly comprising political activists and in a manner inconsistent with the Constitution and executive orders. During pendency, they sought to amend the petition to challenge Ext.P3 (order of the 3rd respondent Commissioner) and Ext.P4 (the first meeting resolution of the nonhereditary Board). The court examined the scope of revisional jurisdiction under Section 99 of the Act, noted the controversy over locus standi, and referred to Kunhirama Variar v. State of Kerala, which suggested that the Act contemplates hearing hereditary trustees; the court distinguished that decision on the present facts. The petition was disposed of with directions that, if a revision under Section 99 is filed, the revisional authority must consider it with notice to all affected parties, keeping the contentions open for adjudication. Ultimately, the court left the substantive issues unresolved, pending any eventual revision petition.
Ottappalam Granites (P) Ltd., a quarrying company holding 5.7 hectares in Lakkidy Perur-1 Village, Palakkad, seeks to set aside Ext.P8, the Additional District Magistrate’s order dated 16.11.2020 denying a NOC for an Explosives Licence to establish an explosives magazine. The petition traces a sequence starting in 2015 when the applicant applied for NOC under Rule 102 of the Explosives Rules, 2008 for a magazine; it was rejected because initial approval under Rule 101 had not been obtained. The petitioner subsequently obtained Ext.P1 approval from the Deputy Chief Controller of Explosives for possession for use of explosives from a magazine, conditioned on obtaining NOC and an endorsed plan. An application under Rule 113 (Ext.P2) for NOC was submitted, but the 1st respondent referred the matter to the Panchayat for objections. The Panchayat indicated it did not authorize NOC and that a further meeting would consider the issue. Ext.P6 required documents such as LOI and Environmental Clearance, which the petitioner insisted were unnecessary at the NOC stage. The 2nd respondent, relying on objections and reports of police and revenue authorities, rejected Ext.P2 (Ext.P8). The court noted that mere objections cannot justify rejection without proper enquiry, citing Joy Joseph v. District Collector, Kannur. It held that Ext.P8 cannot stand, set it aside, and directed the competent authority to reconsider Ext.P2 in accordance with law, clarifying that environmental clearance and LOI are prerequisites for later regulatory steps but not for the initial NOC stage.
B.A. No. 2691/21; 2692/21; 2693/21; 2694/21; 6371/21; 6372/21; 6378/21; 6379/21; 6746/21; 6748/21; 6750/21; 6754/21; 9750/21; 1676/22 This judgment consolidates multiple bail applications (BA Nos. 2691/21 and connected matters; also references to BA Nos. 2692/21, 2693/21, 2694/21, 6371/21, 6372/21, 6378/21, 6379/21, 6746/21, 6748/21, 6750/21, 6754/21, 9750/21 and 1676/22) arising from crimes registered at Bekal Police Station, Kasargode, alleging rape and related offenses under sections 376(2)(n), 506 read with section 34 IPC. The petitioners, numerous accused in separate but connected cases, sought pre-arrest bail. The court notes the victim’s ongoing trauma, the alleged involvement of close associates of the husband, and the use of videos to threaten and blackmail. It records that initial investigations showed irregularities in the first information statements, allegedly shaped by intervening investigators, prompting a direction in a prior decision (X v. State of Kerala) to have the Special Investigation Team ferret out the truth. The court critically observes the SIT’s slow progress and emphasizes custodial interrogation as essential to uncovering the truth, recovering devices, and advancing the investigation. While some connected petitions had final reports, the court nonetheless dismisses the bail applications, holding that the gravity and circumstances require continued custody and scrutiny, and cautions against potential interference with witnesses or evidence.
This writ petition challenges police action in Crime No. 297/2017 (Nedumbassery Police Station). The petitioner, Sagar Vincent, alleges that the Investigating Officer threatens and harasses him to give statements that contradict his earlier responses under Section 164 CrPC and testimony recorded before the court. He asserts that after having already provided statements in 2017 and again under 164 CrPC before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Ernakulam, the IO has been repeatedly summoning him for further questioning in relation to an ongoing investigation under Section 173(8) CrPC. The petitioner seeks a declaration that the IO has no right to harass him and a mandamus-order that restricts such summons, and he relies on Public Prosecutor v. Moidu Haji to argue for the presence of counsel during police questioning. The respondents counter that the petitioner is not an accused and therefore cannot claim a right to counsel during investigation; they rely on Poolpandi, Raveendran C.M. and Arun Gulab Gavali to contend that such a right is not guaranteed in this context. The High Court ultimately dismisses the petition, holding that due process requires due notice under Section 160 CrPC, that continued interrogation may proceed under 161/173(8) CrPC, and that the petitioner must not be harassed or coerced, while ensuring procedural safeguards.
This Rent Control Revision arises from an eviction order under Sections 11(3) and 11(4) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The revision is filed by the tenant, Prof. M. Usman, challenging eviction sought by the landlords in respect of the tenanted premises on grounds of bona fide need and alleged sub-lease. The Rent Controller had granted eviction under Sections 11(3) and 11(4)(i) and 11(4)(iii), and the Rent Control Appellate Authority (RCAA) partly allowed the appeal, setting aside only the order under Section 11(4)(iii) but confirming the eviction under Sections 11(3) and 11(4)(i). The petition has been argued on the premise that pleaded particulars of the proposed business for the bona fide need were lacking; reliance was placed on Nazar v. K.P. Naseema to emphasize the importance of pleadings in bona fide grounds. The landlord’s case is that the second respondent intends to start an agency business in tea, a detail supported by the second respondent in evidence, and that the sub-tenant was engaged in a bag business. The High Court discusses whether lack of precise pleading defeats eviction and whether the sub-lease finding is perverse in light of Ext. B1 documentary evidence. It ultimately holds that the need is bona fide and that the concurrent findings do not suffer from perversity, while upholding a period for vacating with conditions.
This is a motor vehicle accident compensation appeal and cross-objection arising from a claim for death benefits. On 29.08.2012, T.M. Saithu, aged 51, UD Clerk in CJM Court, Ernakulam, died in a road traffic accident. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam, awarded Rs. 33,46,547 with 8% interest to the legal heirs, but the insurer, National Insurance Co. Ltd., challenged the amount as excessive. The claimants cross-objected, seeking enhancement. The High Court reappraised the evidence, adopting a notional monthly income of Rs. 26,987, with 15% future prospects, leading to a corrected monthly income of Rs. 31,035 and after a 1/4 deduction for personal expenses, Rs. 23,276 as monthly dependency. With a multiplier of 11 (age 51), loss of dependency computed at Rs. 30,72,432, higher than the Tribunal’s Rs. 28,23,047. The Court analyzed heads of compensation: it reduced funeral expenses from Rs. 25,000 to Rs. 16,500 but allowed a 10% uplift for three years per Pranay Sethi; it held Rs. 75,000 for pain and suffering, Rs. 5,000 for damaged clothing (reducing by Rs. 4,000); and Rs. 1,25,000 for loss of estate was reduced to Rs. 16,500 with 10% uplift as per Pranay Sethi. Overall, Rs. 94,615 was found excess. The appeal was allowed in part; cross-objection dismissed. Insurer must deposit Rs. 32,51,932 with 8% interest from the petition date within two months, under Circular No.3 of 2019.
This Kerala High Court revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, arises from eviction orders and a later application by the tenant to reconstruct and adjust construction costs in the rent under the second proviso to Section 11(4)(iv). The Rent Control Court (Munsiff), Kodungallur, had ordered eviction in 2004 with a direction to reconstruct within ten months and allotted space to the tenants. In 2013 the tenant sought permission to reconstruct and set-off costs, which the landlord contested as belated. The Rent Control Court dismissed the interlocutory application in 2017; the Rent Control Appellate Authority upheld the dismissal, prompting this revision before the High Court. The Court, placing reliance on precedents such as Achamma Ittoop, Ratnakara Shenoy, Arunachalam Pillai, and Sudheer, held that the landlord’s statutory obligation to reconstruct and the tenant’s right to re-induction run with the land and survive transfers to successors, and that the second proviso empowers the court to issue directions at any time regarding reconstruction. It set aside the lower orders and allowed the petition to the extent of granting re-induction in the building constructed by the second respondent, with the tenant liable to pay fair rent. The Court directed the second respondent to provide suitable accommodation within one month, with enforcement through the Munsiff Court if necessary.
This petition under CrL.MC 2224 of 2017 challenges the initiation of criminal proceedings in CC 801/2015, which arose from a private complaint alleging offences under Section 323 IPC. The sole accused, M.K. Rajesh, a Sub Inspector of Police, faced allegations of assaulting the complainant after a dispute over a bond on 09.10.2013, with the incident allegedly occurring within the Kareelakulangara Police Station premises where he was on duty. The complainant, Manoharan Nair, had earlier paid a fine for a petty public-offence (smoking in public). The Magistrate took cognizance after an inquiry under Section 202 CrPC, and the accused moved to quash the proceedings on the ground that no sanction under Section 197(1) CrPC had been obtained before cognizance. The Kerala High Court, in a well-reasoned order, surveys leading authorities on the necessity of sanction for prosecuting public servants where conduct is connected with official duties, balancing the protection afforded by Section 197 against possible abuse. It examines judgments such as P. Arulswami, Shambhoo Nath Misra, Rashtriya Rifles, Varghese K.J., and Choudhury Parveen Sultana, distinguishing some and endorsing the core principle that cognizance without sanction can be void ab initio if the act is reasonably connected with official duties. The Court ultimately allows the CrL.MC, quashes CC 801/2015, and clarifies that sanction may still be sought from competent authorities. The order emphasizes that the accused’s duty-bound acts cannot be shielded without proper sanction when a cognizable offence is involved.
W.A. Nos. 445 of 2020; 331 of 2021; W.P.(C).No.22754 of 2020 This batch of writ appeals and a writ petition pertains to disciplinary action against a delinquent accountant of the Ollur Town Co-operative Society Ltd. Ten misconducts were alleged, including reduced interest on accounts, non-notice in gold loans, and resistance to computerization. After an enquiry, the employee was terminated. The Arbitration Court upheld the enquiry’s validity, but the Co-operative Tribunal set it aside on the ground that the employee had insufficient opportunity to defend herself. The Tribunal remitted the matter to verify the enquiry, but the High Court held that such remand is impermissible and, more crucially, that the memo of charges was issued by the Disciplinary Sub-Committee rather than by the appointing authority, citing Kodanchery Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Joshy Varghese (2020) to bind the result. Consequently, the enquiry was deemed invalid. The Court directed the Managing Committee to initiate fresh proceedings within two weeks, allow the delinquent to file objections within two weeks, and decide either to issue a fresh memo of charges or consider objections within two more weeks. If a fresh memo is issued, a new Enquiry Officer or Disciplinary Sub-Committee must complete proceedings within three months. The suspension period is to be treated as spent, with full pay and benefits due within one month. The Arbitration Court is not to continue its inquiry. Writ petitions were allowed and writ appeals disposed of.
This writ petition challenges the denial of approval for the petitioner as a High School Teacher (Arabic) for the period 01.06.2010 to 31.05.2011. Sheeja U was initially appointed as a regular UPST in 1999 and later promoted to High School Teacher (Arabic) in 2010 against an additional division vacancy, with approval ultimately granted from 01.06.2011 under the Kerala Education Rules (Rule 43, Chapter XIVA) as part of the comprehensive Teacher’s Package for deployed/protected teachers after a ban on appointments was lifted. The petitioner contends that, despite being eligible and included in the package, she was not granted approval for the 2010–2011 period and that similarly placed teachers have been treated favorably due to the bonds allegedly executed by managers. The Government and various officers contend that appointments in additional division vacancies must be apportioned 1:1 and that managers should have executed a bond under G.O.(P) No.10/10/ G.Edn (2010), with pending Supreme Court litigation affecting certain matters. The court relies on the Suma Devi doctrine that, in the absence of bond execution, bonds can be deemed executed, obliging managers to make an equal number of appointments. The result is a direction to consider the petitioner’s revision petition (Exhibit P7) and to reckon bond assumptions, subject to Apex Court orders, with disposal of the petition.
The petitioners, who describe themselves as followers of the Bible Faith Mission Mount Zenoy, filed this writ petition seeking a mandamus to the Chairman and officials of the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) and to the Kerala Scheduled Caste Development Department to initiate an inquiry into the functioning, management, and accounts of the Bible Faith Mission English Medium School, Mount Zenoy, ParassuvaiKkal, Thiruvananthapuram, and to examine the activities of Bible Faith Mission and all associated institutions. They allege illicit siphoning of school funds, irregularities in salary payments to teachers, and manipulation of bills—claims such as paying salaries under fictitious or non-audited arrangements and demanding repayment from staff. They seek Exts. P16 and P17 representations to be considered and for CBSE officials to take action, asserting that misfeasance would undermine the faith community’s institutions. The respondents counter, asserting the petitioners lack locus standi and that CBSE merely conducts examinations and affiliates schools via NOC from the state, with no control over internal management or finances. The High Court rejected the petition, noting no statutory provision empowering CBSE to conduct internal inquiries and observing that the dispute appears private, not a public-law issue. Relying on Supreme Court authority that CBSE is not a statutory body and that writs under Article 226 require a public element, the court dismissed the petition.
SSCR No.20 of 2021, a suo motu petition instituted by the Travancore Devaswom Board’s Sabarimala Safe Zone Project, comes up before a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court. The court surveys the statutory framework governing motor vehicles and road safety, focusing on the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and the Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, particularly Chapter V and Rule 92(1), along with the Kerala Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989 and Rule 249. It recalls Avishek Goenka v. Union of India (2012) 5 SCC 321, which held that CMVR details exhaustively regulate construction and maintenance, and that what is not specifically provided for is to be read as excluded. The order traces prior directions in SSCR No.20/2021 directing Enforcement Officers and Police to ensure strict compliance with CMVR, Kerala MV Rules, AIS-008 and AIS-052 (Rev.1) 2008, in response to accidents and occurrences involving contract carriages fitted with unauthorised lights, retro-reflectors, or other alterations. Penalties under Section 182A(4) (Rs.5,000 per alteration) and Section 190(2) (offences, licence disqualification) are highlighted, along with the requirement to ensure uniform application of safety standards irrespective of state registration. The Court directs a fresh report on Safe Zone functioning for Mandala-Makaravilakku 1199 ME (2023-24), and to array the listed respondents, with further directions to ensure safety of pilgrims and road users.
Balakrishnan, a jeweller and KVAT assesse, challenged assessment orders CLS for 2013-2014 to 2016-2017 issued under the compounded tax regime (Section 8(f) of the KVAT Act). The Assessing Authority fixed compounded tax at rates derived from 120% of the previous year's tax whenever turnover exceeded ₹1 crore. The petitioner argued that ‘turnover’ for the purpose of Section 8(f) refers to sales turnover only, and that Rule 9 of the KVAT Rules includes purchase turnover, but Section 8 excludes liability under Section 6(2); thus purchase turnover should not be included for a jewellery dealer paying under the compounded scheme. The petitioner contended that the base figure would fall below ₹1 crore if turnover were calculated on sales alone, making the enhanced rate unwarranted. The 1st respondent asserted that annual turnover under Section 8(f) includes both sales turnover and turnover of goods purchased from unregistered dealers; Rule 9 requires aggregation. The court relied on a prior decision, M/s Josco Fashion Jewels v. State of Kerala, noting that dealers paying tax on a compounded basis under Section 8(f) need not pay tax under Section 6(2) for the relevant goods. Consequently, Exts. P1 to P1(c) were set aside and the matter remanded for fresh orders with notice and hearing within two months.
Dr. Vinu Govind challenged his non-appointment as an Assistant Professor in Economics at Mar Thoma College, Thiruvalla, despite being within the zone of appointment in the rank list (Ext.P1). He contended that the College intends to cancel the recruitment and confer the post on another candidate, which he claimed was illegal. The College and MG University argued that, following Ext.P1 and subsequent judicial guidance in a batch of petitions, two vacancies in Economics could be affected by a reservation under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 (PWD Act). The College proceeded to reserve one of the vacancies for persons with disability (PWD) after a government order dated 18.05.2022 and interview dated 20.05.2022, and suggested that the first rank (Dr. Liji Samuel) would be appointed to the first vacancy while the second vacancy would be reserved for PWD as required by the Act. The petitioner’s counsel contended that Ext.P1 did not contemplate PWD reservations and that the appointment of respondents 5 and 6 (the College) to fill the second post should not bypass the open quota. The court observed that mere inclusion in a rank list does not confer a vested right to appointment, citing Unnikrishnan Nair G.S. and Others v. State of Kerala and Others (ILR 2019 (1) Kerala 775). It permitted re-notification of one vacancy for the PWD category if a vacancy arises and noted the need to comply with the Act, while dismissing the petition without granting the prayed relief. The petition was closed with liberty to approach again if a vacancy arises during the rank list period.
This Kerala High Court judgment deals with custody and visitation rights of Evana, a four-year-old, in a Family Court proceeding (O.P.(FC) No. 976/2022 seeking interim custody, and O.P.(FC) No. 630/2022 filed by the father under Article 227 of the Constitution). The Family Court Palakkad had issued Ext.P7 on 01.11.2022 granting an interim custody framework: the mother would receive custody for disposal of the main petition; the father would have limited interaction rights and weekly/scheduled visitation; the child’s safety and welfare were to be monitored by a CM.O/in-charge; and a modest traveling allowance was provided for interaction days. The petitioner challenged this interim arrangement via a petition under Article 227 before the Kerala High Court. After hearing both sides, examining the child with the help of a family counsellor, and considering statutory welfare principles and the need for the child’s contact with both parents, the court found that Evana is very attached to her elder sister and that maintaining sibling proximity would aid her wellbeing. Citing Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan and Vasudha Sethi v. Kiran V. Bhaskar, the bench held that welfare of the child governs custody decisions and that visitation rights should accompany any custody order unless compelling reasons exist. The court disposed of the petition by modifying Ext.P7: custody handover on 18.11.2022, weekend interim custody to the father, restrictions on moving outside Kerala, schooling near the mother’s residence, and a two‑month window for future modification, with a clerical correction to the address in clause (v).
Tip Top Furniture (P) Ltd., an assessee under the KVAT Act, challenged an Ext.P5 assessment for the year 2014-15 on grounds of admitted suppression of turnover detected during a 2015 stock inspection, subsequent compounding under Section 74, and a request for revision of return under Section 22(10). The Intelligence Wing found discrepancies and led to a compounding order of Rs. 8,00,000; the petitioner paid this amount and sought to revise its self-assessed return for 2014-15. The assessing authorities, however, proceeded to finalize an assessment under Section 25(1) for escaped turnover, arguing that a pattern of suppression existed (parallel billing, stock variation, unaccounted purchases and sales), and that revision is merely an option, not a guarantee. The petitioner maintained that after compounding and payment of admitted tax, revision should be permitted and the return deemed accepted, while the department asserted that best-judgment assessment could and should be adopted where a pattern of suppression is detected. The High Court examined Sections 22(9) and 22(10) of the KVAT Act and relied on authorities such as James Thomas v. State of Kerala, Moosa v. State of Kerala, and State of Kerala v. Shalimar Jewellary to emphasize that the proviso to Section 22(10) is an abundant caution and does not divest the department of the power to undertake best-judgment assessment in the presence of suppression. The petition was disposed of with directions to pursue statutory remedies before the appellate authority, stay of recovery pending appeal, and other ancillary orders, without determining the merits of the alleged suppression.