Shanvika Industries and Bearings Pvt. Ltd. filed W.P.(C).No.36720 of 2022 challenging Ext.P2, a notification for an e-tender for the operation and maintenance of 130 departmental container toilets and 30 container bathrooms at Nilakkal during the Mandala Makaravilakku festival season of 1198 ME (2022-23). Ext.P2 required bidders to have valid, active registration with PWD or Travancore Devaswom Board or its equivalent, plus a prequalification (one year experience in sanitation and provision of vacuum suction tankers). A special condition mandated contractor registration with TDB prior to executing the agreement. The petitioner acknowledged lack of such registration and sought mandamus to complete the proceedings and secure registration, as well as registration as a contractor. The respondents argued the tender process adhered to the rules and GO requirements; the lowest bidder Shanvika lacked TDB/PWD registration, and the award ultimately went to the second lowest bidder, Sri P.M. Sivadas, after negotiations. The court noted alleged cartel-like behaviour and irregularities in the tender, citing Abu K.S. and Suneesh K.S. The petition was disposed of by directing an inquiry by the Chief Vigilance Officer into the award of contracts for Nilakkal, Pamba and Sannidhanam during the festival, with a report due by 31.03.2023, and action to follow based on the report.
This execution second appeal challenges the concurrent orders in E.A. Nos. 31/2009, 267/2009, and 90/2009 in E.P. 192/2008 arising from O.S. 609/1999 before the Principal Munsiff, Kottayam. The appellant, Mary Mathew, claiming title through a 1965 Will executed by her father-in-law Mathen, seeks declaration of title to petition-schedule property (1.35 acres) and permanent injunction against delivery of possession under an E.P. For mutation, the revenue authorities require seizure of life interests by the in-laws, and the Will’s genuineness is disputed by the respondents. The Munsiff and the Additional District Judge (Special Court) concurrently held that Ext. A1 (the Will) was not proved and that the petition schedule property did not fall within the decree’s described property. The court noted contentious issues about whether the petition schedule property aligns with Sy.No. 302/4 as per the Will or the final decree property Sy.No. 305/1 in Panachikkad, and treated the matter as one properly addressed under Order XXI Rule 97/99, not by conflicting with the subject matter of execution. In reaffirming that the remedy for misalignment of properties lies in separate suit, the High Court dismissed the appeal, clarifying that objections to execution cannot extend to other properties. The judgment emphasizes the need for clear title proof and the limited scope of execution proceedings.
This criminal miscellaneous case arises from CRL.MC 8324/2022 filed by Shaju Jacob, the sole accused in CC 1557/2016 (NI Act) challenging an order in CMP 2151/2022. The Magistrate refused to invoke Section 319 CrPC to implead M/s Chiriyankandath Agencies and three partners as additional accused, holding that the required notice under Section 138(b) of the Negotiable Instruments Act had not been served on the partnership or its partners. The petitioner contends that Section 319 CrPC is an enabling provision empowering the court to proceed against persons not being the accused if evidence indicates their guilt and that the power can be exercised after the charge-sheet is filed and once the trial proceeds, to prevent the real perpetrators from escaping punishment. He relies on the Apex Court decision in Manjeet Singh v. State of Haryana (2021 (4) KLT Online 1156 (SC)), which enumerates the guiding principles for Section 319 CrPC: the court’s duty to discover truth, that it can act to bring non-accused to trial, and that it should rely on evidence before the court rather than investigation material. The respondents defend the Magistrate’s reasoning, highlighting strict compliance with NI Act procedure and the absence of proper notice, which purportedly bars summoning under Section 319. The High Court, after considering the arguments, dismisses the petition, upholding the Magistrate’s order and holding that Section 319 is enabling but requires evidence before the court and compliance with NI Act requirements. The petition is therefore dismissed.
This is a public interest writ petition by Sreenivasan E., a resident and River Protection Council member, challenging the absence of a mechanism to dispose of dry leaves and fossils of trees in thickly populated areas and seeking eco-friendly disposal by converting such matter into compost. The petitioner sought a writ of mandamus to direct the State respondents to make provisions for disposal and to issue guidelines, and a direction to consider Ext. P2 representation within a time frame. The High Court declined to issue a writ mandamus directing the Government to legislate, explaining that mandamus cannot compel the Legislature to enact a law under Article 309 and that the court’s role is to exercise judicial review within constitutional limits, not to legislate. The court relies on several Supreme Court authorities to emphasize the doctrine of separation of powers, including that the Parliament and State Legislatures are sovereign to enact laws, and courts cannot direct them to do so. While dismissing relief for mandating legislation, the court did direct the 2nd respondent to consider and pass orders on Ext. P2 within two months from the date of judgment, and disposed of the petition accordingly. The decision reaffirms judicial restraint and the limited ambit of judicial intervention in policy matters, particularly where legislative action is required.
This Kerala High Court criminal appeal challenges a Sessions Court order in CrMC 2988/2021 that denied pre-arrest bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C. in a case arising from Crime No. 1910/2021 of Peroorkada Police Station. The appellant is accused of offences under IPC sections 376 and 376(2)(n) and Section 3(2)(v) of the SC/ST Act, 1989, for alleged sexual acts with the victim during 2019–2021 after a false promise of marriage. The Sessions Court dismissed the pre-arrest bail application on 20.12.2021. The High Court examines whether the bar under Section 18A SC/ST Act applies to bail and whether the 3(2)(v) offence is prima facie made out. Relying on Prathvi Raj Chauhan, Ravinder Singh, Ramdas and Others, and Stephen Joseph, the court holds that there is no prima facie case under Section 3(2)(v) and that caste prejudice is not evident in the FIS; hence the bar does not operate. It notes the victim’s admission that the appellant was married with a child and that the subsequent divorce occurred in 2020, with the sexual acts occurring prior to that date, suggesting consent not vitiated by misconception. Consequently, the appellant is entitled to pre-arrest bail on conditions: bond of Rs. 1 Lakh with two solvent sureties, cooperation with investigation, weekly appearances, non-contact with witnesses, and prohibition on leaving Kerala without leave.
Mat.Appeal No.949/2018 & Crl.R.P No.547/2020 Jessy Sam v. Sam George concerns a dispute over ownership of the petition schedule property and the status of the relationship between the parties. Sam George approached the Family Court, Pala in O.P.482/2015 seeking a declaration of absolute title to the property and an injunction, asserting there was no legal marriage with Jessy Sam, whom he cohabited with since 1997 and with whom two children were born. Jessy Sam counter-claimed that she is the legally wedded wife and that the property was purchased with her assets. The Family Court dismissed Sam George's declaration and held there was no valid marriage, thereby depriving his relief on the property. Jessy Sam then challenged the order in Mat.Appeal 949/2018; separately, Sam George challenged a Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act order obtained by Jessy Sam, leading to Crl.R.P 547/2020. The High Court, in a division bench, held that the Family Court lacked jurisdiction to entertain a property action where there is no legal marriage, but acknowledged that the Family Court could determine marital status under Section 7(1)(b). The court found no proof of a valid marriage, affirmed the non-marital status, but left open the property claim to be resolved in the Civil Court. It also held that DV relief can be obtained even without a pre-existing marriage and invoked Velusamy to define "relationship in the nature of marriage." The appeals were disposed of accordingly: Mat.Appeal allowed in part and Crl.R.P dismissed.
This petition under OP(CAT) 222 of 2020 challenges the CAT OA 180/2014 order dated 14.12.2016 and the broader process of absorbing casual labourers into regular posts in the Southern Railway. The petitioner Union of India contends that the High Court’s Ext.P9 judgment (29.07.2011) binds the parties and that the Tribunal was not authorized to grant regularization with retrospective effect from 2003. The case relates to a worker, Peer Mohammed, who was engaged as a casual labourer prior to 1981 and included in seniority lists prepared under a Supreme Court direction in Inder Pal Yadav v. Union of India for absorbing casuals into regular service, with seniority linked to the length of engagement. Railways first filled Group D posts in 1999 (171 vacancies) and, in 2003, 94 more vacancies, based on the seniority list. Peer Mohammed did not respond to a Railways notification for 1999 appointment; OA 72/2010 later directed fresh consideration. The Tribunal, however, proceeded to grant regularization from 2003, inconsistent with Ext.P9. The Kerala High Court concludes that Ext.P9, a final and binding order, cannot be overridden to grant regularization from 2003. It holds that regularization should be treated from 15.03.2011, with consequential benefits, not from 2003, and distinguishes contrary cases cited by the respondents. The petition is disposed accordingly.
The Kerala High Court, in WP(Crl.) No.1042 of 2022, deals with a habeas corpus/certiorari challenge to a detention under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAAPA). The petitioner, Jasheela T.M, mother of the detenu Bushar Jamhar, contends that Ext. P-2 detention order dated 27.06.2022 and the Government order extending/determining the period of detention under KAAPA (Ext. P-10 dated 21.10.2022) violate Articles 21 and 22 of the Constitution. The District Collector, Kozhikode, ordered detention citing 11 crimes and the detenu’s status as a known rowdy under KAAPA, with the last incident on 07.03.2022. The Advisory Board opined on 26.08.2022 that there is sufficient cause for detention and that the Government may confirm the detention subject to a rider that the detenu appear before the SHO on specified days; clarification was provided later, stating the Government has discretion to fix the period, up to six months. The petition argues (i) the Government disregarded the AB’s rider, fixing a six-month period; (ii) Sec.3(3) requires forthwith communication of the detention order and records to the Government, which did not occur until 01.07.2022. The Court holds that the AB’s rider cannot bind Government beyond its jurisdiction, but accepts the AB’s finding of sufficient cause; more critically, it finds a breach of Sec.3(3) due to a four-day delay. Consequently, Ext. P-2, as confirmed by Ext. P-10, is quashed and the detenu is to be released forthwith. The petition is disposed of accordingly, relying on Anupama’s case and Hetchin Haokip’s interpretation of “forthwith.”
This is an OP (DRT) challenging a secured asset sale under the SARFAESI Act by the South Indian Bank. The petitioners contend the sale of their property was illegal and undervalued, arguing the bank failed to obtain a proper valuation as mandated by Section 13(5A) of the SARFAESI Act, and Rule 8(5) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002, to secure maximum value. They claim the market value is about Rs. 1.5 crore, yet the asset was sold for roughly Rs. 65 lakh, prejudice arising from the bank’s alleged failure to preserve and upkeep the property post-possession (Rules 8(3) and 8(4)). They invoke Pochiraju Industries Ltd (M/S) v. Punjab National Bank and others (2019 KHC 2998) to support their contentions. The bank responds that possession was taken in 2018 after several writ petitions, and the sale process proceeded with multiple valuation reports resulting in a final sale of Rs. 65.05 lakh on 12.10.2022 after attempts with reserves at Rs. 1 crore and later Rs. 80 lakhs, with no bidders at critical junctures. The High Court declines to interfere under Article 227, upholding Tribunal jurisdiction, and dismisses the petition, while allowing a challenge before the Tribunal or another lawful forum.
Uma M., the seventh accused, challenged a third bail application in Crime No.1 of 2021 registered at the Thaliparamba Excise Range, alleging lack of involvement in narcotics transactions. The petitioner, aged 24, claimed she was merely an employee of a spa inside Sneha Bar Inn Hotel and happened to be in Room 103 where drugs were seized, with no participation in the sale or packing of contraband. The prosecution contends that the accused were caught red-handed while dealing with narcotics—1750 grams of LSD, 53 grams of MDMA, and 5.37 grams of hash oil—in a commercial quantity, and were engaged in packing drugs into small packets for sale. The case is already at trial with a charge sheet filed, and the trial date had been postponed. The court noted the petitioner’s prior bail applications (B.A. Nos. 2556 of 2021 and 5763 of 2021) were dismissed, and there is no ground to infer innocence at this stage. Relying on Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari, the court clarified that Section 37’s “reasonable grounds” require more than prima facie grounds, and must reflect a substantial probability of the accused’s innocence. Given the commercial quantity, gravity of the alleged offences, and likelihood of affecting the trial if released, the court dismissed the bail petition, emphasizing the need to expedite the trial.”
WP(C) Nos.34750 & 40680 of 2022 The Kerala High Court, before Justice Gopinath P., heard two writ petitions challenging SARFAESI proceedings initiated by HDFC Ltd. against properties tied to a loan extended to the borrower (3rd respondent) under a tripartite arrangement with the builder (petitioner in 34750/2022). The builder disclosed that payouts for construction were made directly to him, and he was to execute title documents in favor of the borrower and deposit them with the bank. He allegedly failed to execute and deposit the deeds and instead transferred the residential unit and undivided share to the 4th respondent, prompting the 40680/2022 petition by the subsequent purchasers. The petitioners argued that no mortgage was created and that proceedings under the SARFAESI Act could not be initiated against the property. The respondent bank contended that the tripartite agreement and disbursements to the builder, coupled with alleged fraud (sale to a third party), validated the proceedings and that the petitioners should seek relief only through the Debts Recovery Tribunal if they had grievances. After hearing, the court held that the petitioner in 34750/2022 was not entitled to discretionary relief under Article 226 because of suspected fraud and the tripartite scheme. The court dismissed 34750/2022 and closed 40680/2022, reserving liberty for the latter petitioners to approach the Tribunal under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act, and excluding the period of pendency from limitation calculations.
In OP(C) 806 of 2021, the High Court of Kerala exercises its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 to evaluate the orders of the Munsiff Court, Thodupuzha, and the District Court in a dispute over a plaint schedule property. Aby Abraham, the petitioner (defendant in the underlying suit OS 255/2020), challenges an interim injunction restraining entry into and possession of the property, claimed by his father, Abraham, who seeks a permanent prohibitory injunction. The respondent contends that he holds absolute title and possession to the 4 acres 634 sq. links plus a residential building and appurtenances, while the petitioner, a bachelor employed privately and presently working from home due to the pandemic, asserts his occupancy is permissive to protect his mother from alleged cruelty and that the suit’s cause of action is manufactured. The petitioner relies on a Jammu and Kashmir High Court decision (Mohammed Hashim Bunday v. Ghulam Mohiuddin Banday and others) to argue that without a prima facie case the remaining injunction criteria lose weight; the respondent argues all three classic factors—prima facie case, irreparable injury, and balance of convenience—are satisfied. The court, applying the Sadhana Lodh principle, holds that Article 227 relief is not an appellate reweighing of facts, and that lower courts’ findings are prima facie binding in this context. Consequently, the original petition is dismissed, sustaining the interim injunction posture and refusing to interfere with the inferior courts’ orders.
Eight petitioners, retired employees of the Kerala State Handicapped Persons Welfare Corporation Ltd., challenge the denial of full monetary benefits following the 9th Pay Revision. The Government sanctioned the 9th Pay Revision but extended its monetary benefits to State Government employees and to Public Sector Undertakings like the Kerala Water Authority and to autonomous bodies with a retrospective date, while the Corporation's employees were not given full monetary benefits; instead, benefits were notional from 01.07.2009 to 31.03.2012 and actual payments began only from 01.04.2012. The petitioners allege discrimination under Article 14 and contend that the classification is irrational. They also challenge the non-payment of D.C.R.G. at the enhanced Rs.7 lakh and the denial of terminal surrender and other retirement benefits despite superannuation at age 58. They rely on precedents such as State of Jharkhand v. Brahmputra Metallics Ltd. and Kavirajan R. They argue that, as disabled employees, their grievances should be treated with sympathy, invoking National Pension Scheme considerations and potential statutory rules. The Government contends pay revision is a policy decision and not a legal entitlement; classification is within executive domain. The High Court holds that the decision is policy-based, with financial and administrative considerations, and that courts should refrain from encroaching on the executive's timing or cut-off date. Consequently, the petition is dismissed.
This is a Cr.M.C filed for quashing Annexure AII Final Report in Crime No.724/2020 of Chokli Police Station, Kannur, now pending as C.P. No.16/2021 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Thalassery. Petitioners 1-18 (the accused) seek quashing on the ground that the entire dispute with the de facto complainant has been amicably settled, and continuing proceedings would be unwarranted. Respondents 2-12 (injured/de facto complainant) appeared through counsel and filed affidavits. The prosecution, on instruction, confirms that the matter was investigated and a statement by the de facto complainant indicates settlement. The court notes the offences involve IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 324 and 308 r/w 149, but observes that the dispute is purely personal and will not adversely affect public interest. The Supreme Court precedents cited (Gian Singh v. State of Punjab; Narinder Singh and Others v. State of Punjab; State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan) are invoked to support quashing under S.482 Cr.P.C despite the bar under S.320 Cr.P.C when ends of justice require. The court holds that no purpose is served by continuing proceedings and quashes Annexure AII Final Report. The order emphasizes settlement and ends of justice rather than punishment, and finds the offences not within non-compoundable category for this case.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 751 OF 2022 This is a criminal revision under Cr.P.C. challenging the conviction of the accused for an offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. A cheque for Rs. 1,20,000 dated 18-5-2012 was dishonoured on presentation. The trial court convicted the accused; the Sessions Court on appeal remanded the matter and allowed further evidence, including a Scientific Assistant's input. Thereafter, the appellate court confirmed the conviction but reduced the sentence to a single day’s custody until rising. The revision petition before the Kerala High Court, filed under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C., contends that the evidence (PW1, DW1) does not satisfactorily prove a debt and the purported blank signed cheque Ext. D1 allegedly given to the complainant's mother, DW1, undermines the prosecution’s case. The petitioner argues mis-appreciation of evidence and seeks interference. The High Court reiterates the limited purview of revision—supervisory, not appellate—and surveys leading precedents on re‑appreciation, the presumption under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act, and the onus on the accused to rebut with a probable defence. It ultimately refuses to substitute the lower courts’ findings and upholds the conviction. The court grants one month to pay the fine and directs deferral of sentence until 12-01-2023, with appearance on 13-01-2023 for payment or execution of sentence if default occurs.
This is a criminal revision petition by Syed Alavi Sasin Electronics challenging a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The complainant, E. V. Ramadevan, Managing Partner of M/s Sirtron, Palakkad, alleged that the accused issued Ext. P1 cheque for Rs. 35,716 toward a credit purchase under Ext. D1; the cheque bounced with the note “exceeds arrangement.” The trial court convicted the accused and directed imprisonment for one month and payment of Rs. 23,551 to the complainant under Cr.P.C. 357(3); the appellate court affirmed the conviction. The central issue is whether the cheque amount represented the debt at the time of presentation. The defence contends that four blank cheques were given as security and that the actual liability under Ext. D1 was Rs. 23,551; thus the cheque for a larger amount cannot attract Section 138, particularly where part payments had been made. The prosecution relies on presumptions under Ss.139 and 118 NI Act and argues that the reverse onus becomes operative upon proof of signature. The petitioner relies on conflicting Kerala authorities, notably Joseph Sartho v. Gopinathan Nair and Shiju K. v. Nalini, with Supply House v. Ullas and R. Gopikuttan Pillai discussed. The High Court ultimately held that the cheque did not reflect a legally enforceable debt and acquitted the petitioner, allowing the revision petition.
WP(C) Nos. 36976/2022; 37180/2022; 37186/2022 These writ petitions by three educational agencies seek affiliation of law colleges with Mahatma Gandhi University (MGU). The petitioners contend that MGU has refused to decide on their affiliation applications, instead citing lack of views from the Government. They rely on the principle laid down in State of Kerala v. MGM College of Arts and Science (2017) (2017 (3) KLT 779) that the Government cannot withhold its views or adopt a policy to deny affiliation to new colleges, since education is a constitutional right, and that universities must act. The University responds that it has complied with the statutory requirement to obtain the Government’s views under the MGU Act and the First Statutes, and that no such views have been received yet. The Government Pleader contends that the Government has already conveyed its policy not to allow any new Law Colleges for the next academic year (dated 27.07.2022). The court underscores the duty to balance Government policy with statutory duties and constitutional rights. It disposes the petitions by directing that the Government furnish views within two weeks of copy of the judgment; if views have already been sent, the directive continues; the University should evaluate and decide the applications as expeditiously as possible, but no later than 15.12.2022. It also notes the Bar Council of India application deadline of 31.12.2022.
Adithya Shiva Prasad v. State of Kerala is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case (Crl.M.C. No. 8104 of 2022) decided on 20 December 2022. The accused, Adithya Shiva Prasad, involved in Crime No.14/2022 of the Excise Enforcement and Anti Narcotics Special Squad, seeks to quash Annexure 4 (order in Crl.M.P. No. 2505/2022 dated 14 September 2022) and to be released on statutory bail under Section 167(2) CrPC read with Section 36-A(4) of the NDPS Act. The prosecution contends that the 180-day period for investigation under CrPC 167(2) was extended beyond 180 days by the Special Court under Section 36-A(4) of the NDPS Act upon a report filed by the Public Prosecutor; Annexure 3 purports to document progress, but the petitioner argues it omits vital progress details and fails to narrate the reasons for detention beyond 180 days, violating established precedents such as Hitendra Vishnu Thakur and related cases. The court examines Section 36-A(4) and related precedents (Hitendra Vishnu Thakur, Sanjay Kumar Kedia, Appukuttan, Nayantara Gupta, Jigar, Sanjay Dutt) to interpret the Public Prosecutor’s duty in approving extension and the necessity of notice to the accused. Ultimately, while acknowledging the need for proper compliance with the extension mechanism, the court holds that statutory bail is an indefeasible right and remits to set aside the challenged orders, granting statutory bail with conditions.
Crl.M.C.No. 8537 of 2022 & 8548 of 2022 These Criminal Miscellaneous Cases arise from Crime No.1288 of 2022 registered at Palarivattom Police Station, Ernakulam. The petitioners, accused Nos. 2 to 5 in Crl.M.C.8537 and the 1st accused in Crl.M.C.8548, seek to quash the FIR under sections 420 and 384 read with 34 IPC, on the ground that a private settlement has been reached with the de facto complainant, a film producer. The prosecution alleges that the 1st accused, with deceit and threats, sought money by entangling the complainant in a film project; obscene photos were sent; two lawyers allegedly advised the complainant to pursue a complaint, and a demand of Rs 3 crore was made, with Rs 10 lakh paid as advance. The affidavits in Annexure-A2 sworn by the de facto complainant assert settlement and no objection to quashing, which the SHO verified as genuine. Learned counsel for the state and the de facto complainant oppose continuing the prosecution beyond the private settlement. The court, invoking Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, exercises its inherent power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. to quash the FIR and all further proceedings, holding that the dispute is private and settlement eliminates public interest in continuing the case. The order reflects a private-dispute resolution justifying quashing of proceedings.
BAIL APPL. NO.897 OF 2023 This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC by Balodra Bonju Babu, the 4th accused in Crime No.30/2021 of the Parappanangadi Excise Range Office, involving offences under the NDPS Act (Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29). The petition seeks regular bail while the first three accused had earlier obtained statutory bail due to the prosecution’s failure to file final reports in time. The prosecution contends that on 04.08.2021, 1st to 3rd accused were found in possession of 121.594 kg of ganja; the 4th accused is alleged to have arranged the contraband from Andhra Pradesh and transported it in a pickup owned by the 2nd accused. The State points to financial links: transfers totaling Rs. 2,31,000; Rs. 1,75,000; and Rs. 4,06,000 between 18-06-2021 and 23-06-2021; CDR indicates constant calls between the 2nd accused and the petitioner; the petitioner is also connected to another case (Cr. No.1472/2021, Angamaly) involving 225.380 kg of ganja. The court emphasizes the rider under Section 37 of the NDPS Act, requiring two conjunctive conditions: (i) reasonable grounds to believe the accused is not guilty, and (ii) that he is unlikely to commit an offence while on bail; the standard of "reasonable grounds" is more than prima facie evidence (Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari). Relying on several precedents, the court holds that the petitioner’s alleged involvement in commercial quantity offences and the absence of a satisfied Section 37 rider justify refusing regular bail. The court accordingly dismisses the bail application. The prior bail orders for accused Nos.1–3 do not entitle the 4th accused to bail.