Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 564 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WA No.1654/2021 & WA No.899/2022

SAIL STOCKYARD WORKERS UNION (CITU) v. M/S HADIYYA LOGISTICS PRIVATE LIMITED and Others

This intra-court appeal arises from a Kerala High Court writ petition (WP(C) No.20667/2020) challenging an order that the loading/unloading of steel consignments at SAIL’s Irumbanam stockyard be carried out mainly through mechanized means by skilled workers, with headload workers engaged only for manual tasks where necessary. The writ petitioner, a contract-based consignor/handler, argued that headload workers obstructed operations and demanded engagement for manual loading; it sought police protection and preventive action. The respondents, including the private petitioner (SAIL contractor), police authorities, and headload workers’ bodies, countered that the work is predominantly mechanized and requires machinery with skilled personnel, and that headload workers should not be entitled to the work when machines and skilled staff can perform it. The District Labour Officer’s report clarified the blend of mechanized loading with manual tasks (attaching slings, lifting, etc.) performed by headload workers, and noted registration under Rule 26A for some workers. The High Court, upholding the settled position that mechanization governs the allocation of loading/unloading tasks, affirmed that headload workers cannot demand work that is mechanized or skilled; however, if any manual headload work exists, it must be allotted to registered pool workers. The Bench modified and extended the impugned judgment by directing adjudication under Section 21 of the Kerala Headload Workers Act and ensuring police protection where appropriate, with a time-bound 4–5 month horizon for finalisation of the Sec.21 proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 8555 OF 2020

Dr. Reemol Scaria A v. State of Kerala and Others

Dr. Reemol Scaria A, a PhD holder and lecturer at Bharata Mata College (affiliated to Mahatma Gandhi University), challenges Exhibit P4 denying advancement increments under the 6th UGC Scheme. She joined service in 1993 in a permanent vacancy and earned a PhD in 2004. Under the revised UGC Scheme (implemented in Kerala from 1.1.1996 and later the 6th Scheme from 1.1.2006), those acquiring a PhD while in service are eligible for three non-compounded increments. Previously, she received two increments at the time of entering a Selection Grade and was granted increments for her PhD under the older scheme. The 6th Scheme created a discrepancy: juniors who obtained PhDs after 1.9.2008 receive three increments, while seniors like the petitioner do not automatically benefit, leading to higher pay for juniors. The petitioner cites earlier rulings (W.P.(C) No. 32933/2014, 28.10.2016) and Division Bench decisions (WA No. 488/2017) that rule in favor of stepping up to parity when juniors’ pay rises due to the new scheme. She contends Exts. P13–P14 restrict relief to the same management/department and asks for re-examination, step-up to par with juniors, and arrears. The respondents advocate policy-based limitations and departmental caution. The court allows the petition, quashes Ext. P14, and directs salary re-fixation to parity with juniors, with timelines for implementing and paying arrears.”

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 3576 OF 2023

CKK Nair Containers v. Kerala State Electricity Board Ltd & Ors.

CKK Nair Containers, a partnership manufacturing containers and drums, obtained a High Tension electricity connection from the Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB). On 19 October 2022, the Anti-Theft Power Squad conducted a surprise inspection and detected an enhanced connected load, concluding unauthorized energy extraction. A provisional assessment (Ext. P2) was issued based on Ext. P1 mahazar, to which the petitioner submitted detailed objections (Ext. P3); however, the final assessment order (Ext. P8) was issued without considering those objections, prompting a challenge seeking quashment of Exts. P1, P2, P8, and P9 and a direction to permit a statutory appeal under Section 127 after depositing 50% of fixed/demand charges. The respondents’ counsel relied on Supreme Court authority, notably Kerala State Electricity Board v. Thomas Joseph (2022) SCC Online SC 1737, to contend that charges include fixed components and energy charges, and that the assessment must double the tariff for unauthorized use; Regulation 153(15) of the Electricity Supply Code, 2014, was said to be inconsistent with Section 126. The court, after citing Radha Krishan Industries v. State of Himachal Pradesh (AIR 2021 SC 2144) and Executive Engineer, Southco v. Sri Seetaram Rice Mill (2012) 2 SCC 108, emphasized exhaustion of statutory remedies and held that the petitioner must pursue statutory remedies under Section 127. The writ petition was disposed of with directions to file an appeal within four weeks before the Kerala State Electricity Appellate Authority, with coercive proceedings deferred for four weeks.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.31314/2023

W.P.(C) No.31314/2023

Mohammed Sherif, a Junior Farm Officer in the Botany Division of the Rubber Research Institute of India (RRII), challenged Ext.P2, the Office Memorandum transferring him to CES, Chethakkal, and Ext.P15, the order dismissing his representation. He joined RRII in 1995 and has around 28 years of service, with over 14 years in RRII divisions and an excellent APAR. He contends that RRII rules award higher credit points to officers with longer outstation service (he reportedly holds 80 points, higher than most peers), and, in view of Ext.P3’s credit-point framework, he should have been treated favorably for a home posting rather than being transferred out of his home station; he notes that several colleagues with fewer points were retained in their preferred locations while he was moved, and the 5th respondent’s retention at RRII after being promoted is improper. He submits a detailed representation (Ext.P13) which was rejected (Ext.P15). He relies on B. Varadha Rao, Ram Ganesh Tripathi, and Babu v. State of Kerala to contend that mala fides or extraneous motive in a transfer order warrants interference. The respondents counter that Ext.P2 was issued under Ext.P3 Clause 4, transfers are made on exigencies of service, and home postings are not guaranteed. They emphasize expeditious administration and distance considerations (Chethakkal ~40 km). The High Court concludes that transfer is an incident of service, exercised in public interest, and not subject to judicial review absent mala fides, dismissing the petition.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NOs. 552 OF 2015 & 541 OF 2015

N Chellappan Pillai Susee Confectionary Industries v. State of Kerala; N Vasavan Ananda Bhavan v. State of Kerala (Common Order in CRL.REV.PET Nos. 552/2015 & 541/2015)

Two Criminal Revision Petitions (CRL.REV.PET Nos. 552/2015 and 541/2015) arise from a common judgment convicting two accused under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954 for selling orange candy sweets adulterated with synthetic food colour. The Public Analyst’s Form III report (Ext. P15) found adulteration, and the trial court convicted the accused under Section 16(1-A) r/w Section 2(ia)(j) and Rule 30; the Appellate Court affirmed. The petitions challenge the adequacy of the laboratory analysis, arguing that the sample was analyzed in a laboratory not notified by the Central Government under Section 23(1-A)(ee) and (hh), rendering the prosecution unsustainable. The State counters that Pepsico India Holdings Pvt. Ltd. v. Food Inspector and Rasheed v. Food Inspector require reframing the issue and that Kerala Public Analysts have been appointed, so Pepsico’s ratio does not bind these cases. The High Court refers to Rasheed to interpret Pepsico and ultimately holds that the laboratory-analysis requirement under Section 23(1-A)(ee) is mandatory for prosecutions based on laboratory reports, and that a non-notified laboratory invalidates such prosecutions. Applying these principles, the court holds that since the Public Analyst’s report relied on a non-notified laboratory, the prosecutions fail, and the revision petitions are allowed with acquittal and cancellation of bail bonds.

High Court of Kerala
OP (FC) No.14 of 2023

Mumthas M.K v. Palathinvida Faizal

This is an Article 227 petition challenging Ext.P14 (dated 14.12.2022) in I.A.02/2022 of O.P.691/2020 pending before the Family Court, Kannur. The petitioner-husband’s maintenance arrears under MC No. 442/2018, allegedly unpaid, led her to seek striking off the respondent’s pleadings in the original petition for dissolution of marriage. The Family Court dismissed I.A.02/2022, refusing to strike pleadings, noting the enforcement of maintenance is pending and that striking pleadings is an exceptional remedy. The petitioner approached the High Court under Article 227 to challenge Ext.P14, arguing the respondent’s deliberate non-payment shows unscrupulous conduct and warrants striking under Order VI Rule 16 CPC and inherent powers under Section 151 CPC. The petitioner relies on Mahesh v. Roopa (2017 (3) KLT 226), and references Abdul Razak v. Mangesh Rajaram Wagle (2010 (2) SCC 432) for guiding principles. The High Court recalls that Article 227 powers are supervisory, not appellate, and cautions against a broad correction of judgments. It also cites Jai Singh v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi and Sobhana Nair K.N. v. Shaji S.G. Nair to emphasize restrained intervention. Ultimately, the Court dismisses the petition, holding no manifest error in the lower order and acknowledging that the applicant may pursue enforcement of the maintenance order through execution proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
ITA No. 26 of 2017

The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Kottayam v Kadakkarappally Service Co-operative Bank Ltd.

This is an Income Tax Appeal filed by the Principal Commissioner of Income Tax challenging an order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Cochin Bench) in ITA No.106/Coch/2016 for AY 2012-13, relating to deduction under Section 80P of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The dispute centers on whether a Primary Agricultural Credit Society (PACSoc) such as Kadakkarappally Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. is entitled to deduction under 80P(2) and, more specifically, under 80P(2)(a)(i) in respect of income that may include items like unexplained cash credits assessed under Section 68. The court cites and debates various precedents, including decisions in Mavilayi Service Co-operative Bank Ltd and Peroorkada Service Co-operative Bank Ltd, and contrasts them with older decisions such as 384 ITR 490, 363 ITR 268, 379 ITR 330, and a Constitutional Bench reference in 220 CTR (SC) 98. The Tribunal’s reasoning, which the High Court scrutinizes, appears to hinge on whether the deduction should be constrained to income that truly derives from the cooperative activity and within the language of 80P. The High Court remands the matter for fresh assessment, applying the controlling precedents and considering whether the deduction should be confined to the income covered by 80P(2). The appeal is allowed and the matter directed to be re-adized by the AO consistent with law.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 10254 OF 2022

Saidalavi K. T. v. The District Collector, Malappuram, The Tahsildar, Tirur, The Village Officer, Ponmala Chappanangadi, The State of Kerala, Represented by the Secretary to Government, Taxes Department

This writ petition challenges Ext.P3 assessment order under the Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975, issued for the assessment of building tax on the petitioner’s property. The petitioner contends that the buildings in question are factory buildings and therefore exempt from tax under Section 3(1)(d) of the Act. After a notice under Section 9(2) was served, the petitioner sought clarity on the identity of the building slated for taxation. The Assessing Officer did not respond with specific details; instead, he issued Ext.P3, an assessment order dated 16.11.2020, imposing Rs. 17,31,600 as a one-time building tax, apparently on a printed format. Counsel for the petitioner argued that if the building identity had been properly communicated, the factory-exemption contention could have been raised and would require a government reference for determination. They asserted that the order copied the statutory format without applying mind to the facts of the case and failed to consider Exts. P1 and P2, or any reply thereto. The learned Government Pleader insisted that Ext.P9 shows the officer warned about hearing and that the petitioner could not produce a Factory license, thereby disentitling exemption. The Court agreed that Ext.P3 lacked application of mind and relied on Abraham Thomas v. State of Kerala and others to conclude that the order was perverse. It quashed Ext.P3 and directed fresh orders after observing due process, including an opportunity to file objections and hearing, within three months.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 3117 OF 2015

Periyaswamy and others v. A.T. Varghese and New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

This is a Motor Accidents Claims Appeal (MACA) arising from an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Perumbavoor, in OP(MV) No.1592/2011, challenging the death of Raman in a road accident on 23 September 2011. The appellants, legal heirs of Raman, contend that the Tribunal undervalued the deceased’s notional income and erred in denying certain heads of compensation, including loss of consortium. The appellants argue Raman, though 70, was an able-bodied worker; therefore his notional income should be higher than the Tribunal’s Rs.3,500 per month, citing Ramachandrappa to support a higher figure (Rs.8,000 or more). They also press for parental consortium damages of Rs.40,000 per child and inclusion of Loss of Estate; they challenge awards under pain and suffering and love & affection as impermissible. The respondents, represented by the Insurance Company, defend the Tribunal’s award as fair for 2011 standards and contend that some heads (pain and suffering, love and affection) should not be enhanced, citing United India Insurance Co. v. Satinder Kaur for this principle. The learned Judge admits the appeal with consent and reconsiders the evidence, holding that the deceased’s income should be Rs.6,500 per month (no future prospects due to age), applies 50% deduction for personal expenses, and recalibrates heads of compensation. Ultimately, the appeal is allowed with a revised award: increased dependency, added Loss of Estate and Loss of Consortium, reduced Funeral Expenses, and deletion of certain heads, with directions regarding deposit and recovery.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No.832 of 2023

K.V.ANTONY, K.V.JOSE & K.V.THOMAS v STATE OF KERALA & OTHERS

This is a petition under Section 438 CrPC for anticipatory bail by accused Nos.1 to 3 in Crime No.33/2023 of Chengamanad Police Station, Ernakulam district. The petitioners contend that the allegations arise from an arrangement in which a 25-cent land parcel was conveyed and presented as security rather than as an absolute sale in 2012. The defacto complainant alleges that the first accused executed a registered sale deed but that liabilities to Ayroor Co-operative Society would be discharged and the title transferred thereafter. The prosecution contends that, in connivance with Co-operative Bank officials, the petitioners forged documents and availed a loan by creating a mortgage over the same property, thereby cheating the defacto complainant. The defense argues that there was no absolute sale; the document produced was a security instrument, and possession remained with the petitioners; they continued to repay the loan, and receipts from 2012–2017 (including a reference to a “gold loan”) support this view. Annexures include pleadings in a civil suit (O.S.566/2018). The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, claiming that post-sale encumbrances and further loans were obtained, constituting breach of trust and cheating. The court notes custodial interrogation is unnecessary and directs investigation to proceed through surrender; ultimately, anticipatory bail is granted to accused Nos.1–3 with conditions ensuring cooperation and non-interference.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 12324 of 2023

Soman Chellappan and P. M. Basheer v. National Highways Authority of India and Others

This Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed in the Kerala High Court by two Block Panchayat presidents challenges the non‑commencement of the widening and development of NH-85 (Kochi to Munnar). The petitioners seek mandamus directing the completion of tendering and immediate commencement of the works, and a time-bound program, asserting that the delay violates fundamental rights under Articles 19(1)(d) and 21 and adversely affects road users and residents on both sides of the highway. They request monitoring by the Court through continuous mandamus and rely on representations (Exts. P7 and P8). The respondents contend the delay results from litigation in the Delhi High Court regarding the tender process, not any willful sloth, and that steps have been taken to proceed with development. The counter affidavit details developments: the signing of an EPC agreement with EKK Infrastructure (subject to Delhi’s writ petition outcome), initiation of tree enumeration for ROW, Section 3A notifications for land acquisition, and other steps to ensure shoulder-to-shoulder development from Km 0.000 to Km 124.636. The Kerala High Court, after hearing counsel and reviewing the counter, disposes of the petition on the basis of assurances by NHAI that the work will be expedited, without issuing further directions, reflecting a PIL‑driven oversight while leaving the substantive process to proceed.

High Court of Kerala
MFA (RCT) 141/2017

Malarkodi P. and others v Union of India

This is a Civil MFA (RCT) appeal under Section 23 of the Railway Claims Tribunal Act, 1987, challenging an order of the Railway Claims Tribunal Ernakulam in OA No. 22/2016. The four appellants, dependents of Poovan Vinayathan, seek compensation for his death that occurred on 10 November 2015 when he fell while alighting from train 16305 at Shornur. He had boarded the wrong train, realized the mistake, and, as the train moved, attempted to alight, sustaining fatal injuries. The Tribunal dismissed the petition, holding that the death resulted from a self-inflicted injury within the proviso to Section 124A of the Railways Act, 1989, effectively denying compensation under the no-fault regime. The appellants contend that the death constitutes an untoward incident (as defined in Section 123(c)) and that absence of ticket cannot negate bonafide passenger status; they argue improper inquiries by railway authorities and rely on Supreme Court precedents to interpret self-inflicted injuries and entitlement to compensation. The High Court examines whether the RTC’s finding is perverse and whether the decision should be guided by no-fault liability principles, with emphasis on the bonafide passenger concept and the untoward incident framework. It ultimately allows the appeal, awarding compensation and directing deposit, guided by prior Supreme Court rulings on untoward incidents and quantum.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No.1019/2022; and connected cases (798/2022; 1010/2022; 1995/2022; 3048/2022)

CRL.MC No.1019/2022 & con.cases (and connected matters) v. State of Kerala and others

This is a Kerala High Court order dated 25 July 2023 by Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A. disposing of multiple Criminal Miscellaneous Cases (CRL.M.C. Nos. 1019/2022 and connected matters) challenging the cognizance and proceedings arising from a private complaint under the Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, 1994 (TOHO & T Act) and allied IPC sections. The petitions, filed by accused nos. 1–6 and 10 (Aster Medcity and several doctors) along with other accused in connected petitions (including accused nos. 8, 11, 12 and 13), contend that cognizance was improper, and that maintainability under Section 22(1)(b) TOHO & T Act, and the requirement of sanction under Section 197 Cr.P.C for public servants, were not properly satisfied. The private complaint concerns alleged brain-death declarations and liver transplantation from Ajay Johny to Adv. Suresh, with accusations of coercion, non-compliant brain-death certification, and possible malpractices in organ transplantation. The court examined pre-cognizance requirements, the role of the Appropriate Authority, and the conduct of Board of Experts, and evaluated the applicability of Section 197 Cr.P.C to government doctors and KNOS officials. It relied on established medical-legal precedents (Jacob Mathew; Neeharika) to balance prosecutorial caution with the statutory protections for medical professionals. Ultimately, the court quashed the Cr.M.Cs and the proceedings, holding the pre-cognizance and related procedures wanting and finding no justified basis to continue the prosecutions.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.7271/22

NARASIMHA SHENOY v. SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF), ERNAKULAM; CIRCLE INSPECTOR OF POLICE, ERNAKULAM CENTRAL STATION; SUB INSPECTOR OF POLICE, ERNAKULAM CENTRAL STATION; MRS. SEETHA MOHANAN

This writ petition (W.P.(C).No.7271/22) filed by Narasimha Shenoy seeks police protection to evict alleged illegal trespassers from his property and to register crimes against the 4th respondent and her men for unlawful trespass and criminal intimidation. The background is civil: the 4th respondent filed a partition suit which was dismissed; a counter claim led to a partial decree directing the 4th respondent to hand over possession of part of the property. The Regular First Appeal (RFA) upheld eviction, and delivery of possession was effected in 2016. The petitioner suffered illness in 2019 and alleges that the 4th respondent and her son trespassed again, threatening him. Exhibits P2–P4 contend that the 4th respondent has no rights to reside in the property. The petitioner relies on decisions allowing writ relief to protect property rights and to provide police protection even when a civil remedy exists, arguing experiential inefficacy of civil remedies. The 4th respondent counters with the alternate-remedy doctrine and civil-court remedies. The Court ultimately directs the Station House Officer to verify the petitioner’s claim and provide adequate protection to implement the civil court decrees, within one month, and the writ petition is disposed accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO.850/2016; CRL.A NO.887/2016; CRL.A NO.974/2016; CRL.A NO.1012/2016; CRL.A NO.1023/2016 (Connected cases)

Criminal Appeal Nos.850/2016 and Connected cases (CRL.A.850/2016, 887/2016, 974/2016, 1012/2016, 1023/2016)

This is a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court delivering a consolidated judgment on five connected criminal appeals arising from S.C. No. 408/2009 (Alappuzha) and C.P. 36/2009, involving seven accused charged with murder and related offences under IPC and Arms Act. The prosecution alleged a brutal, coordinated attack on two friends at Thoppuveli, leading to one death and serious injuries to the other, with a claimed motive of prior enmity and a gang war. The trial court convicted all seven under multiple sections including Section 302 IPC for murder and sections 307, 324, 326, 341, 143, 144, 147, 148, 120B r/w 149 IPC, and Sections 20 r/w 27 Arms Act; sentences included life imprisonment for murder and varying terms for other offences. On appeal, the High Court carefully examines the reliability of eyewitness testimony (PW2 and PW3 as principal witnesses) against contentions of planted weapons, delays in recoveries, and alleged misdirection by investigators. While spotting several inconsistencies and arguing that the investigation and recoveries were flawed, the court ultimately upholds the prosecution’s direct ocular and medical evidence, rejects the defense’s allegations of fabricated testimony, and reaffirms the conviction and sentences. The judgment emphasizes that motive is not essential where direct evidence exists and affirms the accuseds’ guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.66 of 2021

A.M. Antony v. Valiyakath Kunji Muhammed and others

This is a Rent Control Revision petition under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, filed by the tenant A.M. Antony against an order of eviction granted by the Rent Control Court (Addl. Munsiff), Thrissur in R.C.P. No. 99 of 2020 and confirmed by the Rent Control Appellate Authority (Addl. District Judge), Thrissur in R.C.A. No. 146 of 2016. The petition schedule premises comprises four rooms in a single building, non-contiguous, leased to the tenant for his readymade garments business. The landlords sought eviction on bona fide need for their own occupation to start a garment business, arguing the space is necessary and that other buildings exist in possession but are either unsuitable or not readily available. The Rent Control Court found the need bona fide and denied relief under the provisos to Section 11(3). The Appellate Authority upheld the eviction. The petitioner contends the need is not bona fide, that the landlord delayed occupying vacant rooms, and that alternative accommodation is available; the landlords maintain the need is genuine and sincere, supported by evidence including PW1’s testimony and commission reports. The High Court, after surveying statutory provisions and a line of precedents on bona fide need, additional provisos, and revisional scope, agrees that the need is genuine and legal, and declines to interfere with the concurrent findings, while granting six months for surrender with conditions. The revision petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(Crl.) Nos. 727/2022, 56/2023, 59/2023, 728/2022, 729/2022, 730/2022, 731/2022, 732/2022 & 733/2022

George Jacob v. State of Kerala & Others (OP(Crl.) Nos. 727/2022, 56/2023, 59/2023, 728/2022, 729/2022, 730/2022, 731/2022, 732/2022 & 733/2022), High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These are a batch of original petitions under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam arising from NI Act complaints against the petitioner George Jacob. The petitions seek to keep the complaints in abeyance pending the Sub Court’s IP No.3/2022, and to address bail on surrender to the jurisdictional court. The petitioner contends that surrender before the trial court should be permitted and that coercive steps should not be prematurely invoked; they propose that bail applications, with advance copies to the prosecutor, be considered on the surrender date. The Public Prosecutor counters that no directional relief to release is warranted; bail decisions should be left to the trial court and based on facts, not on petitions for stay. The court cites Vineeth Somarajan @ Ambadi and Biju S. Praveen to emphasize cautious handling of bail and safeguarding personal liberty, insisting that bail decisions be timely and reasoned. Ultimately, the judge disposes of the petitions by directing surrender within two weeks, with bail considerations on surrender if filed, keeping coercive proceedings in abeyance for two weeks, and leaving contentions open. The order balances due process, personal liberty, and practical trial-life considerations for NI Act cases.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) Nos.2985/2023, 2989/2023, 11867/2023 & 13263/2023

W.P.(C) Nos. 2985/2023, 2989/2023, 11867/2023 and 13263/2023, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This batch of connected writ petitions challenges the insistence on a Government NOC and university/affiliation consent as pre-requisites for starting a new B.Pharm college. The petitioners, Sirajul Huda Educational Complex and Ma'dinusssaquafathil Islamiya (appearing in multiple petitions through their secretary), seek to quash Exts.P12, P7 and P8, which respectively demand a State Government NOC and university/affiliation approvals as a condition for provisional/essential approvals. The central issue is whether such NOC and consent are mandatory prerequisites for consideration of applications to operate a B.Pharm course. The Court tracks the statutory framework under the Pharmacy Act and the B.Pharm Course Regulations, specifically Regulation 9.2 and the requirement of NOC and consent of affiliation, while recognising that PCI approval is a prerequisite. The Court references prior Kerala High Court decisions, notably W.P.(C) No.15525 of 2018, which held that NOC cannot be a prerequisite, and acknowledges a Supreme Court ruling in Pharmacy Council of India v. Rajeev College of Pharmacy (2022 AIR SC 4321) that government NOC can be mandatory in certain contexts. In light of these authorities and the court’s own previous finding, the High Court ultimately quashes the impugned Exts. and holds that NOC from the State Government is not a pre-requisite for approval of a B.Pharm course. Writ petitions are allowed accordingly, with a declaration that NOC is not mandatory.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1717 OF 2015

Legal heirs of Hareesh v. The Managing Director, Malayala Manorama; R. Thankachan; Reliance General Insurance Company Limited

Facts: Hareesh died on 22.08.2011 in a road accident when his motorcycle was struck by a vehicle driven rashly. The legal heirs approached the High Court challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Punalur’s award in OP(MV)No.767 of 2011, seeking compensation of Rs. 10 lakhs, which the Tribunal awarded as Rs. 10,23,000/-. The appellants contended that the award is inadequate, as the deceased was 28 years old, educated (MBA holder), and hospitalized for about 39 days before death; thus, the notional income adopted by the Tribunal (Rs. 6,000/month) was too low. The counsel urged substantial enhancement, noting Exts. A15–A18 (MBA credentials) and Exts. A10–A11 (coaching/remuneration documents) to justify higher income. The Insurance Company defended the Tribunal’s computations. The Court revised the notional income to Rs. 10,000/month (with 40% future prospects, total Rs. 14,000/month), resulting in elevated dependency losses. It increased Loss of Estate to Rs. 15,000 and granted Rs. 1,20,000 for Loss of Consortium, while deleting Loss of Love and Affection. A daily award of Rs. 600 for pain, agony, and attendant expenses for 39 days was granted, despite Satinder Kaur’s stricter limits, which the Court distinguished due to prolonged hospitalization. The order clarifies that enhanced compensation with 8.5% interest will be payable by the insurer, with two months’ time to deposit. The judgment partly allows the appeal and retains other heads as awarded.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 9986 OF 2019

Binulal V.S. and Others v. Cochin University of Science and Technology and Others

This writ petition challenges the selection process for the post of Sweeper-cum-Cleaner in the Cochin University of Science and Technology (CUSAT). Ext.P1 is a 2008 notification that did not specify the selection components. A written test was held in 2010 and Ext.P2 (short list) dated 11.02.2011 stated the listed candidates were to be called for interviews, leading to final selection. Later, petitioners challenged a “skill test” component; this Court’s Ext.R1(a) judgment (17.12.2015) held that the skill test was impermissible, directing the process to be completed through written test and interview, with an 80:20 ratio of marks from written test and interview. CUSAT conducted interviews between 16.04.2018 and 09.07.2018, published Ext.P3, and petitioners were included in the list; petitioners contended nepotism and irregularities. The court examined whether Ext.P2 became impermissible for lacking an interview component, noting Ext.P1 did not specify the selection method. The petitioners voluntarily participated in the interview and were ranked lower in the final list; the court held that challenging a completed process after participation is inappropriate. The judgment also records that police investigations could lead to reparative orders if corruption or nepotism is found. The petition is dismissed; however, if investigations reveal impropriety, CUSAT may issue necessary reparative orders subject to law.