Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 563 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
Bail Appl. No. 5130 of 2024

Ayyappan v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by the sole accused, Ayyappan, in Crime No. 515/2024 of Kalamassery Police Station, Ernakulam, against alleged offences under Sections 324 and 302 IPC. The prosecution narrates that on 29.04.2024, while the accused and his friend were drinking, the son of the accused’s family confronted the accused’s son and allegedly invited trouble; the deceased then attacked the accused’s son with a pickaxe, resulting in injuries. In the ensuing sequence, the accused struck the deceased with the same weapon, causing fatal head injuries. The prosecution contends the accused committed murder; the defense contends that the accused acted to save his son and that the counter-case against the deceased’s son under Section 326 IPC undermines the prosecution narrative. The petitioner has been in judicial custody for about 80 days; there are no criminal antecedents; investigation is practically complete and recovery has been effected. The petition relies on the presumption of innocence and the principle that bail is the rule and imprisonment prior to conviction is an exception, citing Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, Dataram Singh, and State of Kerala v. Raneef, among others, and also references Sushila Aggarwal. The court notes counter-case dynamics and injuries to the petitioner’s son, and ultimately grants bail but subject to stringent conditions, including bonds, multiple sureties, regular IO appearance, travel restrictions, and anti-tampering provisions.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5750 OF 2024

DASAN v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a bail application under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS) filed by the first accused in Crime No.338/2024, Upputhara Police Station, Idukki, challenging a range of offences including 294(b), 341, 323, 324, 307 and 506(ii) r/w 34 IPC. Arrested on 11.06.2024 and in judicial custody for 49 days, the petitioner contends innocence and false implication, arguing that the Investigating Officer added section 307 to ensure detention. The prosecution alleges participation in a common-intention assault on the de facto complainant on 01.06.2024, with obscene abuse, a stone-pelt, a knife injury, grievous harm including injury to the left hand vein, and emasculation of the complainant by the second accused; the third accused allegedly restrained him. An Accident Register-cum-Wound Certificate from Taluk Hospital Kattappana is cited to corroborate injuries. The petitioner’s counsel submits lack of prior antecedents and near-completion of investigation with recoveries; seeks bail. The Public Prosecutor counters that ongoing investigation, overt acts against the complainant, and risk of witness intimidation warrant denial of bail. The court, citing presumption of innocence and Article 21, and underlining that bail is the norm and detention is exceptional, concludes that further detention is unnecessary and grants bail with stringent conditions, subject to bond and sureties.

High Court of Kerala
Cus.Appeal Nos.9/2022, 10/2022, 11/2022, 12/2022, 13/2022, 14/2022, 15/2022; WP(C) Nos.9058/2022 & 27835/2021

Ashwin Gold Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) Cochin & Ors. (Cus.Appeal Nos. 9/2022 to 15/2022; WP(C) Nos. 9058/2022 & 27835/2021)

This judgment pertains to a batch of Customs Appeal Nos. 9/2022 to 15/2022 and W.P.(C) Nos. 9058/2022 and 27835/2021, all heard together by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court. The core dispute is whether actions taken under the SEZ Act 2005 (Sections 21/22 and related provisions) or under the Customs Act 1962 (and allied provisions) govern the movement and treatment of gold moved from a Cochin SEZ unit to the Domestic Tariff Area (DTA), including gold found in various entities and at the Airport. CE­STAT’s Final Order (dated 17.02.2022) had allowed the importers’ appeals and set aside several show-cause findings, with several confiscations and penalties upheld or modified. The Revenue challenged the CE­STAT order on jurisdictional grounds — contending SEZ authorities have exclusive jurisdiction for acts arising in SEZ and that actions in DTA fall under Customs Act. The High Court held that Sections 21/22 of the SEZ Act deal with notified offences and jurisdiction, but the overall interpretation in the CE­STAT order was flawed; it restored a broader view of enforcement, set aside most appellate orders, and remitted the matters to CE­STAT for fresh consideration on merits, while preserving certain findings regarding the 4 kg of gold and related issues. The decision frames a nuanced balance between SEZ and Customs Actjurisdiction and directs remand for fresh adjudication.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl.) No. 143 of 2022

W.P.(Crl.) No. 143 of 2022 — John Rafi K J v. State of Kerala & Others

This is a criminal writ petition (W.P.(Crl.) 143/2022) filed in the Kerala High Court by John Rafi K J, the first accused in O.R. No. 2/2021, Pattikkad Forest Range. The court, with Justice V.G. Arun, deals with alleged clandestine felling and removal of 84 teak trees from land in Sy. No. 1002/02, Killannoor, Thrissur, which the prosecution claims belonged to Government. The petitioner contends that Ext. P3 patta (1972) under Rule 9(2) of the Kerala Government Land Assignment Rules, 1964, covers 28 ares and did not mention any trees in its schedule, implying no trees were reserved to the Government at the time of assignment; thus, he could not be charged under the Kerala Forest Rules (1995) or Kerala Forest Act provisions. He further argues that the Kerala Promotion of Tree Growth in Non-forest Areas Act, 2005 (Act, 2005) grants similar rights to cut trees on non-forest land, except for reserved trees; the contention is supported by Jose v. State of Kerala and Ors. and a Division Bench decision in Crl.M.C. No. 7347 of 2017, as well as reference to Varkey Chacko (supra). The respondents counter that Ext. P3 lists teak in the schedule, invoking Rule 3 of the 1995 Rules and Sections 2(e) and 2(a) of the Kerala Forest and Government Land Assignment Acts, asserting that trees of scheduled species vest in Government irrespective of standing time, and that 2005 Act does not supersede the earlier regime. The court ultimately held that the trees in question fall under Government rights pursuant to the schedule and patta conditions, rejected the petition, and dismissed it, while noting the possibility of auctioning the seized trees with the realized amount subject to final outcome. The decision underscores that the 1995 Rules and related statutes continue to govern, and that reliance on 2005 Act cannot wipe out established rights over scheduled species.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5442 OF 2024

Vishnu Raj v. State of Kerala

Vishnu Raj, aged 28, applicant in Bail Application No. 5442 of 2024, seeks pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC in Crime No. 634/2024 of Aranmula Police Station, Pathanamthitta, for alleged offences under Section 498A IPC. The prosecution alleges that the petitioner, who married the defacto complainant on 02.05.2024, subjected her to mental and physical harassment during cohabitation, questioned her chastity, and misappropriated her gold ornaments and Rs. 1,50,000. The petitioner contends that his consent for the marriage was obtained by fraud and has filed O.P. 369/2024 before the Family Court, Vadakara, to declare the marriage null and void; he also notes prior orders indicating lack of territorial jurisdiction for similar pre-arrest bail requests. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing that arrest would impede the investigation and that recovery is possible during custodial interrogation. The High Court, after considering rival submissions and the matrimonial dispute context, acknowledges some indication of frivolity in the case but notes that the matter must be decided at trial. Relying on principles in a Supreme Court decision cited (and the need to balance expediency with legitimate investigation), the court grants pre-arrest bail under conditions. The order emphasizes it does not determine merits and may be revisited if conditions are breached.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.5480 of 2024

Sindhu Dasan v. State of Kerala

This Bail Application under Section 438 CrPC concerns Sindhu Dasan, second accused in Crime No.338/2024 of Upputhara Police Station, Idukki. The petitioner seeks pre-arrest bail on grounds of innocence and lack of overt acts attributed to her; the FIR was lodged 11 days after the incident, casting doubt on the robustness of the case. The prosecution alleges that on 01.06.2024, in furtherance of a common intention and from prior animosity toward the de facto complainant, the first accused, joined by two others, abused the complainant in obscene language and pelted a stone at his left leg; the second accused exhorted murder; the first accused inflicted a knife wound; the complainant was left grievously injured. The third accused allegedly restrained him and emasculated his testicles. The prosecution relies on the Accident Register-cum-Wound Certificate from Taluk Hospital Kattappana to establish injuries and to show a link to the overt acts. The petitioner argued she lacked any overt act, that custodial interrogation is unnecessary, and that no recovery is to be effected. The Public Prosecutor argued the opposite, noting the explicit overt act and the need for custodial interrogation. The High Court, citing Srikant Upadhyay v. State of Bihar and other Supreme Court authorities, held that anticipatory bail is an extraordinary remedy and should be granted only in exceptional circumstances; therefore, the application is dismissed. It directs surrender within a week if the petitioner wishes to renew the bail application on merits.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. 7646/2023

Prince @ Sanu v State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Sec. 482 CrPC concerns Prince @ Sanu (Accused No. 6) in SC No. 638/2021 arising from Crime No. 560/2019 of Sasthamcotta Police Station, Kollam. The prosecution alleges offences under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 324, 308, 326 read with Section 149 IPC, arising from an incident on 23.03.2019 near a temple during a festival, where several accused assaulted the complainant and others. The 1st accused had his case already quashed by Anx.3; the petitioner contends that the parties have settled their dispute and seek quashing of proceedings on that basis. The Public Prosecutor initially expresses reservations about quashing merely on settlement but concedes the matter is settled, while noting criminal antecedents for the petitioner. The court relies on Supreme Court jurisprudence, particularly Laxmi Narayan (2019), Gian Singh (2012), and Narinder Singh (2014), to reiterate that the power under Sec. 482 CrPC to quash non-compoundable offences may be exercised in matters having civil/private character and where the dispute is settled, with exceptions for heinous offences or offences under special statutes and certain public-interest considerations. After evaluating facts, the court finds the dispute private and accepts the settlement, concluding that the proceedings can be quashed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 8072 OF 2021

Dr. Abdul Jabbar S. v. State of Kerala and Others

The challenge in WP(C) 8072/2021 is to an order (Exhibit P6) denying parity of pay to the petitioner, Dr. Abdul Jabbar S., who contends that despite equal qualifications and duties, he was kept at a lower pay scale than his juniors after the 6th UGC Scheme. The petitioner joined as Lecturer in Chemistry at MSM College Kayamkulam in 1982 and obtained a PhD in 2005. With the 5th UGC scheme, he received two advance increments for PhD holders; thereafter, the 6th UGC scheme introduced further increments and a condition excluding those who already availed benefits. Juniors who earned PhD later were placed at a higher stage in the revised pay scale, resulting in an anomaly the petitioner seeks to rectify. He relies on earlier High Court judgments, notably the decision in W.P. (C) No. 5682/2015 (and connected cases) and on the Apex Court’s ruling in Gurcharan Singh Grewal v. Punjab State Electricity Board that seniority cannot be paid less when juniors are advantaged. He also points to Government orders (Exhibit P1) and judgments (Exhibit P8) encouraging parity in similar circumstances. The respondents argue that parity is department-specific and cannot be generalized. After considering the authorities, the court concludes that the anomaly must be corrected and allows the writ petition, quashing Exhibit P6 and directing the University/State authorities to step up the petitioner’s pay to parity with juniors within two months, with further steps to implement and pay the arrears.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.8058 OF 2022

Crl.M.C.No.8058 of 2022 – Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. v. State of Kerala and Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd.

This Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 CrPC concerns a challenge to Annexure-A1 complaint in CC 1246/2016, pending before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-XII, Thiruvananthapuram. Petitioners are accused nos. 1 and 3: M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. and its authorised signatory Sheeja Sunny. Respondents are the State of Kerala and Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. The complaint alleges that the first accused operated a satellite TV channel through Jeevan; under a carriage/placement agreement dated 20.07.2015, the complainant performed its part while the first accused was to make payments; the second and third accused, as authorised signatories, issued a cheque for Rs. 3,42,000 which was dishonoured. The petition contends that the 2nd petitioner is only an employee with no day‑to‑day control; even if the debt exists, the loss was subsequently discharged by payments reflected in Annexure A-2; thus the substratum of the case no longer exists and continuation would amount to abuse of process. The respondents contend that the 1st accused engaged in business with the complainant, and the 2nd/3rd accused, as signatories, bore liability; remittance records do not conclusively prove discharge of the specific cheque; payments were under an agreement and may not cover the liability. The court applied Nagawwa’s principles, examined the entire complaint, and held that the petition to quash is meritless; the petition is dismissed and the criminal proceedings will continue.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 19159/2022; 26523/2022; 2738/2023

Geetha Rastogi; Sanjay Kumar Rastogi; K.A. Kurian; Anooja K. v. State of Kerala and Others (W.P.C Nos. 19159/2022, 26523/2022, 2738/2023)

These consolidated writ petitions challenge the refusal to grant building permits and lay-out approvals for residential construction on land in Wayanad district, raising the issue whether land exempted under the Kerala Land Reforms Act can be used for a different purpose without triggering ceiling provisions. The petitioners, Geetha Rastogi and Sanjay Kumar Rastogi (WP 19159/2022), K.A. Kurian (WP 26523/2022), and Anooja K. (WP 2738/2023), submitted building plans and obtained village-level certifications that the land is dry and not Paddy Land or Wetland; Exts P3–P5. The authorities rejected permits citing exemption under Section 81(e) of the Kerala Land Reforms Act, arguing that this exemption preserves large plantations and may warrant ceiling actions. The petitioners invoked Kinallur Rock Sand (2021(2) KLT 351) and other judgments suggesting no bar on using exempted land for another purpose and urged the court to direct issue of permits. The respondents stressed public policy against fragmentation and conservation of plantation holdings, citing various precedents (including Harrisons Malayalam, One Earth One Life, Mathew K. Jacob). The court, however, relied on Kinallur Rock Sand and held the impugned orders unsustainable, directing the Local Authority to process building permits and lay-out approvals if statutory requirements are met, while leaving open any ceiling action under law.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) NO. 38 OF 2023

KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION v. VIJAYALAKSHMI CG, SUDEV KRISHNA SHARMAN G, VRINDA P.M, LAKSHMY V, DR.NIKITHA M, STATE OF KERALA, DIRECTOR OF COLLEGIATE EDUCATION, UNIVERSITY GRANTS COMMISSION (UGC)

OP(KAT) No. 38 of 2023 before the Kerala High Court arises from the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s 25.10.2022 order in OA 1378/2022, by which the Tribunal allowed a challenge to Annexure A5, the 21.04.2022 Erratum altering the eligibility qualifications for the post of Assistant Professor in Sanskrit (Sahitya). The original Annexure A1 notification (11.12.2019) prescribed a Master’s degree in the concerned subject with at least 55% marks (or its equivalent), plus a good academic record, and the National Eligibility Test (NET) or an equivalent test. Annexure A5 amended this by requiring MA (Special) in the subject for Sanskrit posts and excluded those with MA in Sanskrit and Literature not designated as “Special.” The petition contends the Erratum is illegal and inconsistent with the UGC Regulations, 2018 (and 2010 adoption by the State) mandating 55% in the subject and NET. The PSC argued the Erratum aligned with central norms and the State’s Special Rules; the High Court ultimately dismissed the petition, upholding that UGC Regulations prevail and that the state should comply, while noting that the Tribunal’s direction to include the applicant in the selection process was correct in substance. The decision also cites Radhakrishnan Pillai and overrules aspects of Raveendran’s case to the extent inconsistent with Kerala’s adoption of UGC Regulations. The overall outcome is that the Original Petition is dismissed and the Tribunal’s order is sustained.

High Court of Kerala
RPFC No. 451 of 2023

Bijesh v. Ampily and Ors

Bijesh, the revision petitioner, challenges the Family Court, Mavelikkara, order in MC 100/2021 awarding interim maintenance of Rs 10,000 per month to his wife and child and, crucially, striking off his defence for non-payment. The Court treated Section 125 CrPC as enabling interim maintenance with an enforcement mechanism, and while it acknowledged the drastic nature of striking off a defence, it examined jurisprudence from Sakeer Hussain T.P., Hari B., Mahesh v. Roopa, Muraleedharan v. Jincy, Kaushalya v. Mukesh Jain and Rajnesh v. Neha to determine the correct approach. The petitioner contends there is no enabling provision to strike off a defence in maintenance proceedings and that remedy lies in Section 128 execution rather than in striking off the defence. The court notes that the law has evolved: Sakeer Hussain T.P. is no longer good law; Hari B. is per incuriam; Kaushalya and Rajnesh establish striking off as a last resort for wilful non-payment of interim maintenance. Ultimately, the High Court holds that the Family Court erred by not giving Bijesh an opportunity to pay arrears and sets aside the impugned order on condition of deposit of arrears within sixty days. If deposited, the matter is revived and the court shall proceed with evidence, disclosures, and disposal of the application; non-compliance would sustain the impugned order.

High Court of Kerala
W.A. No. 1249 of 2019

Union of India v. N.K. Gopalan and Others

This writ appeal (W.A. No. 1249 of 2019) challenges a Kerala High Court decision (WP(C) No. 13863 of 2013) that directed the Union Government to grant central Swatantrata Sainik Samman (SSS) Pension to the petitioner for his participation in the Punnapra-Vayalar movement and to pay arrears. The appellant Union of India contends that the denials were based on Ext. P13 and that the pension entitlement should be adjudicated under the SSS Pension Scheme, 1980 with proper evidentiary standards. The writ petition relied on the petitioner’s underground period (1946-1947) during the freedom struggle, Thamrapathra, and Kerala Freedom Fighters’ Pension recognition; the State Government recommended the claim with a Non-availability of Records Certificate, yet the rejection persisted. The single judge’s judgment in 2018-2013 favored the petitioners, prompting the present appeal. The Division Bench cites liberal-probability standards in freedom fighter pension cases, notably Gurdial Singh v. Union of India and Kamalbai Sinkar v. State of Maharashtra, embracing a non-technical approach and a presumption in favour of the claimant when evidence suggests confinement. The Court ultimately dismisses the appeal, upholding pension entitlement and directing arrears to be paid within three months, with the pension deemed payable from the date of the rejection orders.”

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.50 of 2022; R.C.Rev.No.55 of 2022; R.C.Rev.No.56 of 2022

R.C.Rev.No.50 of 2022; R.C.Rev.No.55 of 2022; R.C.Rev.No.56 of 2022, High Court of Kerala

These Rent Control Revisions arise from a common order of eviction under Sections 11(2)(b) and 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, in respect of petition schedule shop rooms at Hosdurg. The landlord sought eviction claiming bona fide need to shift his business from Nileshwar to the petition premises, which he had purchased in 2014 with that intent. The tenants opposed eviction, arguing that the landlord’s claimed need is not genuine, that the landlord has other suitable premises, and that the protections under Section 11(3) — including the first and second provises — were not appropriately applied for eviction. The Rent Control Court granted eviction in all three petitions, and the Rent Control Appellate Authority upheld the orders. The High Court, in a common judgment by a Division Bench, held that the concurrent findings of fact were not perverse or illegal and that the landlord’s need was bona fide. It relied on established precedents recognizing genuine need, landlord’s prerogative to determine the nature of his business, and the limitations on tenants’ defenses. While upholding the eviction, the Court granted six months to the tenants to vacate, subject to conditions including depositing arrears and continuing rent, in light of the COVID-19 situation.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 1399 OF 2017

Lagesh @ Kannan v. State of Kerala

This High Court of Kerala, sitting in a criminal revision petition, examines whether framing of a charge under Section 306 IPC was warranted against Lagesh alias Kannan for alleged abetment of suicide of a young woman, 'Ragi'. The prosecution contends that the accused maintained a love affair with the deceased while secretly marrying another woman, and that his deception caused her mental distress which culminated in suicide on 13 November 2011. The Sessions Court had dismissed the discharge application under Section 227 Cr.P.C and framed the charge in SC No.141/2014. The petitioner contends there is no evidence of instigation, conspiracy or intentional aiding; at best there is a relationship and alleged heartbreak, which is not sufficient to attract Section 306. The High Court reviews the record, including the First Information Report, the 161 statements of CWs 2 to 6, and the scene mahazar, noting that the deceased was in love with the petitioner and that she was distressed, but the diary and testimony do not establish a link between the petitioner's actions and the suicide. It reiterates the settled view that for abetment under 306 IPC there must be an active role by the accused, either instigating, conspiring, or aiding the act. On these grounds, the court finds no sufficient materials to proceed under Section 306, sets aside the charge, and quashes further proceedings, allowing the revision.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 6778 OF 2022

Rithul Dev M. v. Ministry of Education, Government of India and Navodaya Vidyalaya Samiti and others

Rithul Dev M., a 12-year-old resident of rural Payyoli in Kozhikode district, petitioned the Kerala High Court (WP(C) No. 6778 of 2022) seeking admission to Class VI in a Jawahar Navodaya Vidyalaya (JNV) under the rural quota. The court had previously, on 9 February 2022, disposed of a related petition with directions to the Navodaya authorities to consider Ext.P5 representation for correcting an alleged error in the online admission form and to do so after due opportunity. The petitioner argued there is no bar for rural students to study in urban-area schools and that the 75% rural quota should apply to him if he meets the norms. He studied from Class III to V at Vidyanikethan Public School, Payyoli, which is located in an urban area, while his domicile is rural, and the Tahsildar did not issue a rural status certificate. The Navodaya scheme provides that at least 75% of seats in a district are reserved for rural candidates, with eligibility requiring studies in rural areas for Classes III–V; candidates who studied even a single day in an urban area are treated as urban candidates. The court concluded that the petitioner’s rejection under the rural category was consistent with the scheme’s definitions and refused to entertain a challenge to the scheme, dismissing the writ petition. The order Ext.P7 was upheld as complied with.

High Court of Kerala
W.A. No.355 of 2022

EKK Infrastructure Ltd. & Raji Mathew & Co. v. Theruvath Builders, State of Kerala, and The Project Director, Kerala Road Fund Board

This is a WA (Writ Appeal) by the appellants, EKK Infrastructure Ltd. and Raji Mathew & Co., challenging the judgment of the Kerala High Court’s single judge in W.P.(C) No.3716 of 2022 dated 10 March 2022. The writ petitioner was Theruvath Builders, with the State of Kerala and the Project Director, Kerala Road Fund Board, as respondents. The core dispute concerns tenders for the “improvement of hill highways,” with bids to be submitted online through the e-Government Procurement portal. The tender policy mandated online submission of documents, including the EMD, while hard copies were to be submitted only after online submission. The writ petitioner claimed a Bank-system failure impeded online EMD remittance and sought a mandamus directing the Project Director to accept offline tenders against Exhibits P1 and P2 and to provide a slot for online submission on 4 February 2022. The single judge found evidence of technical glitches and allowed offline submissions provisionally, treating offline materials as online for the purposes of the tender. The appellants argue that strict adherence to tender terms is essential and that accepting offline submissions undermines the policy and fair play. The court analyzed bank certificates and case-law, ultimately dismissing the appeal and upholding the single judge’s order.

High Court of Kerala
ITA Nos. 37/2012, 38/2012, 39/2012, 40/2012, 42/2012

Kerala Cricket Association v. Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, Range 2, Thiruvananthapuram

Kerala Cricket Association (KCA), Thiruvananthapuram, arises in a batch of five ITA appeals (ITAs 37/12, 38/12, 39/12, 40/12, 42/12) against orders of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Cochin Bench, denying exemptions under sections 11 and 12 read with section 12A/12AA for the assessment years 2001-02 to 2005-06. The Kerala High Court, before Judges S.V. Bhatti and Bechu Kurian Thomas, examines whether KCA’s cricket-related activities qualify as charitable under section 2(15) and are eligible for exemption despite changed statutory definitions and provisos in 12A, 12AA and related sections. A core theme is whether registration under 12AA and the broader “charitable purpose” test must be applied strictly or can be re-examined in light of amendments effective from 1 April 2009. The court notes the Gujarat/Ahmedabad line (Ahmedabad Urban Development Authority) and authorities (Sahney Steel & Press Works; Ponni Sugars) on how receipts are classified (revenue vs capital) and emphasizes that the source of funds is not determinative of tax treatment; rather, the use and object of the activity matter. Ultimately, the High Court remits all issues to the Assessing Officer for fresh adjudication in conformity with the law, effectively allowing the appeals and guiding a new test-series.”

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.3651 of 2023

Saji Chacko v. Registrar of Births and Deaths, Mariyapuram Grama Panchayath, IDUKKI District; Mariyapuram Grama Panchayath represented by its Secretary, IDUKKI District

This writ petition (WP(C) 3651 of 2023) before Justice Viju Abraham arises from a clerical error in the petitioner’s birth certificate. The petitioner, Saji Chacko, contends that Ext.P1 records his name as Chacko instead of Saji Chacko, prompting correction through Ext.P2. He produced Ext.P3 receipt and Ext.P4 reply insisting the production of a school certificate or admission register before processing. Ext.P5 shows the admission register naming the petitioner erroneously as Jees James with the father’s name James, while Ext.P6 confirms the “one and the same certificate” linking Saji Chacko to other identity documents. The petitioner argued that lack of correction affects essential benefits for his child, who is described as 70% mentally retarded, complicating access to benefits. Respondents relied on circular Ext.R1(a) (dated 10.05.2017), particularly clauses 9.6 and 9.7, which conditioned correction on school records and pre-admission entries, implying the Registrar’s discretion depends on such documents. The court held that a circular cannot override the Births and Deaths Act, the Kerala Rules 1999, or their procedural framework. It directed the Registrar to process Ext.P2 under the Act and Rules, without insisting on school records, and to effect the correction within two weeks. The petition was allowed, with consideration of several precedents cementing this principle.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 154 of 2020

P. Vinod v. Somasundharan K. and The State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court Criminal Appeal arises from a trial court judgment acquitting the accused under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. The appellant, P. Vinod, representing Janakeeya Cooperative Urban Society ( Kotakkal ), challenged the Judicial First Class Magistrate Malappuram’s 2019 acquittal of the accused who was charged with dishonour of a cheque for Rs. 50,000 issued towards discharge of a debt. The trial court found the prosecution failed to prove execution of the cheque beyond reasonable doubt and acquitted. On appeal, counsel for the appellant contended that the ingredients of Section 138 were substantially proved: issue of the cheque, its presentation for encashment, its dishonour for insufficient funds, and the issuance of a lawyer’s notice with no reply within the statutory period. The defence argued that the cheque was drawn from the accused’s account but obtained by the complainant through Mr. Gopikrishnan, and that there was no legally enforceable debt; reliance was placed on earlier decisions (Joseph M.J. v. Gladis Sasi, Padmanabhan v. Vasudevan Namboodiri, Santhi v. Mery Sherly) to require proof of execution. The High Court, following Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar, held that a signed blank cheque, voluntarily issued, attracts Section 139 NI Act presumption and that the accused failed to rebut it. The appellate court reversed the trial court, convicted the accused under Section 138 NI Act, and imposed a sentence and fine with compensation to the complainant.