WPC 16372/2023; WPC 17085/2023; WPC 17807/2023; WPC 18324/2023; WPC 20070/2023 These five writ petitions, heard together, challenge the Labour Court’s preliminary conclusion that a charge memo issued by a Disciplinary Sub Committee under Rule 198 of the Kerala Co‑operative Societies Rules is not issued by a competent authority. The Labour Court framed the issue as one of jurisdiction and held in the impugned award that the charge memo lacks competence, citing Kodanchery Service Co‑operative Bank Ltd. v. Joshy Varghese. The petitions refer to a Full Bench decision in Mattannur Cooperative Bank Ltd. v. The Co-operative Arbitration Court (and another) ILR 2023 (3) Kerala 863, which held that the Disciplinary Sub‑Committee, under Rule 198(2A)–(2B), and the Managing Committee have jurisdiction to issue charges; the President’s role for the second category is left open for future decision. The court also addresses whether the doctrine of prospective overruling can be invoked by High Courts, noting that only the Supreme Court wields such power. It overrules the earlier Kochurani Jose’s case to the extent inconsistent with the Full Bench’s view and overrules Kodanchery’s judgment. Consequently, the Awards are set aside and remitted to the Labour Court for fresh consideration in light of Mattannur’s dictum. Circulars are suggested to implement the new regime, and past final adjudications remain binding where res judicata applies.
This is an OP(C) 531 of 2018 case in the Kerala High Court concerning execution of a rent/possession decree arising from a suit for recovery of possession of a room and arrears of rent. The petitioner, P.T. Thomas, was the judgment debtor in E.P. No. 1 of 2016 before the Munsiff, Payyannur, based on O.S. No. 103 of 2008 filed by the respondent for eviction and arrears. The trial court decreed eviction and ordered payment of Rs. 7,200 with 9% interest from the date of suit plus costs, and damages of Rs. 600 per month from 01.05.2008 to delivery. The First Appellate Court confirmed the possession order and Rs. 7,200 with interest but set aside the damages award. The Second Appeal filed by the petitioner was dismissed at admission stage (in limine). The petitioner was granted six months to vacate, subject to filing an undertaking in the execution court; he did not file the undertaking and continued in possession until eviction on 04.01.2016. The execution petition seeks rent for 01.05.2008 to 01.12.2015 under the second appeal decree. The court held that dismissal of the second appeal in limine does not amount to an adjudication or a decree; the executable decree remains that of the first appellate court. The petition is allowed; Ext.P7 is set aside; further EP proceedings are confined to execution of the first appellate decree, and rent for occupancy must be recovered by a separate suit.
BAIL APPL. NO. 4241 OF 2024 This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC by the accused in Crime No. 170/2024, Udumbanchola Police Station, Idukki, pending trial for offences under IPC 354A(1)(i), POCSO Act sections 7, 8, 9(n), 10 & 18, and Section 75 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000. The victim is a 12-year-old girl; the accused is her step-grandfather; the alleged offenses occurred on 09-03-2024 and 10-03-2024. The petitioner contends innocence and false implication, highlighting 80 days in judicial custody and completion of investigation; he is the sole breadwinner and is willing to comply with any stringent conditions if released. The Public Prosecutor submits there are incriminating materials and there is a risk of intimidation or tampering if released. The court notes that the final report was laid on 30.04.2024 and forensic examination is complete. Referring to Dataram Singh v. State of U.P., the judge notes bail is the rule and jail the exception, and emphasizes Article 21. After careful consideration, the bail application is allowed, subject to stringent conditions: bond Rs 1,00,000 with two sureties; appearances before the IO every alternate Saturday; no intimidation or tampering; no offense while on bail; surrender of passport; no leaving territorial jurisdiction without permission; and the court below may cancel or modify conditions on breach.
This Kerala High Court judgment (MSA No. 3 of 2022) concerns whether a housing project falls within the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 (the 2016 Act) as an “ongoing project” on the appointed day and whether the appellants are entitled to a promised covered car park. The appellants, Siji Jacob and AISLE Isac alias AISLE Jacob, had contracted to purchase unit 12G from Ultima Builders and Developers Pvt. Ltd. with a promise of a covered car park; multiple letters between 2011 and 2018 failed to secure the parking space, and the sale deed did not record the parking. The core issue is whether the project qualifies as ongoing under the 2016 Act, which came into force in 2017. The respondents contend the project was completed prior to the sale and the occupancy certificate was issued in 2010, with the sale deed executed in 2011, and therefore the Act does not apply. The appellants rely on decisions including M/s Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. v. State of UP (2021 KHC 6692) and Alfa Ventures (P) Ltd. v. State of Kerala (2022 (5) KHC 157) to argue for a broad interpretation. The court examines the distinction between completion and occupancy certificates, as addressed in Alfa Ventures, and notes that occupancy certificates issued before 2017 do not render a project an ongoing one under the 2016 Act. Ultimately, the court upholds the appellate authority’s finding that the project is not ongoing and dismisses the second appeal.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC filed by the petitioners-accused (Omanakuttan, Suresh Kumar, and Santhoshkumar) challenging the order in SC No.553/2020 of the Special Court for Offences under the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989, Kottarakkara, arising from Crime No.919/2018 of Anchalummoodu Police Station (Kollam). The offences alleged include Sections 3(1)(r), 3(1)(s), and 3(1)(u) of the SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989 and Section 27 of the Arms Act; the area relevance under Arms Act is disputed. The petition asserts that (a) the Arms Act charge is not attracted, (b) the crime and alleged injuries involve a private dispute, and (c) the parties have settled their disputes and do not wish to pursue the prosecution, supported by affidavits from victims. The Public Prosecutor initially voiced reservations about quashing solely on settlement but conceded the matter is settled. The High Court relies on State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688, which discusses when non-compoundable offences may be quashed under S.482 CrPC in private disputes where the parties have resolved their differences, and notes the precedents Gian Singh and Narinder Singh. After considering the facts, the court holds the dispute private in nature and that the settlement justifies quashing, and accordingly allows the Crl.M.C. and quashes proceedings in SC No.553/2020 and related cases.
This is a Kerala High Court writ petition under Article 226 challenging the denial of compassionate appointment to the petitioner in CISF following the death of his father, Sreedharan Nair, who served as a constable. The petition traces multiple administrative decisions beginning with Ext.P2 (1993) rejecting the widow’s initial compassionate appointment claim, followed by Ext.P3, Ext.P5 (2004), and Ext.P9 (2018) reflecting attempts to secure relief under revised schemes. The petitioner, now an adult, argues that the compassionate appointment scheme is designed to provide immediate relief to the family of a deceased employee and that the earlier rejections were arbitrary and not reasoned. Respondents contend that Ext.P9 was belated (filed in 2018 for a death in 1992) and that Ext.R4(d) rightly rejects it on the ground of extreme delay. They also rely on judgments of the Supreme Court (Ashish Awasthi; Gouri Devi) to emphasize that relief must be considered under the scheme prevailing at the time of death and that delays defeat the scheme’s objective. The learned Judge acknowledges the illegality of the initial rejection but declines to interfere with Ext.P2 and Ext.P5 since those orders were not challenged, and upholds Ext.R4(d) as well-founded given the 26-year gap since death. The petition is ultimately dismissed.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case (CrL.M.C. No. 922/2023) arising from an airport screening where a live 0.32 caliber cartridge was found in the baggage of the petitioner at Kannur airport. The petitioner, a Maharashtra-based businessman, held a valid arms license in his home state but claimed no knowledge of the cartridge’s presence. He argued that possession of a single cartridge without a firearm is a minor form of ammunition under section 45 of the Arms Act, and, even if recovered, there was no conscious possession or animus possidendi; the cartridge could have remained inadvertently in his bag. The State, represented by a Public Prosecutor, contended that possession or carriage of ammunition in contravention of section 3 constitutes an offence under section 25(1B)(a) of the Arms Act, with a potential penalty of imprisonment and fine, and that the absence of a weapon does not necessarily negate an offence. The court examined the historical doctrine of conscious possession (animus possidendi) from Gunwantlal v. State of Madhya Pradesh (Constitution Bench) and subsequent Delhi High Court authorities (Golap Saikia; Narendra Kumar Gupta) to determine whether conscious possession or power/ control over the weapon is established. It concluded that there was no conscious possession, and proceeded to quash the prosecution as abuse of process under Bhajanlal v. State. The petition was allowed; the criminal proceedings were quashed.
The Kerala High Court, in CRL.MC No. 6128 of 2017, heard a challenge to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thrissur’s cognizance in CC No. 347/2013, arising from a complaint by the Drugs Inspector under Section 18(a)(i) of the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 read with Section 27(d) of the Act. The petitioners, M/s Zest Pharma and three individuals, contended that cognizance was taken without a required inquiry under Section 202(1) Cr.P.C., even though the petitioners’ place of business and residence lay beyond the court’s territorial jurisdiction. The case notes that the cognizance was initially recorded as CC No. 234/2008 before being renumbered as CC No. 347/2013. The court examined Birla Corporation Ltd. v Adventz Investments and Holdings Ltd. (and related Supreme Court law) which held that a Section 202 inquiry is mandatory and failure to conduct it vitiates cognizance. A report from the learned Magistrate indicated that no such inquiry had been conducted. In light of this, the High Court invoked its inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. and allowed the Crl.M.C., quashing the cognizance and all further proceedings in CC 347/2013, remitting the matter back to the CJM Thrissur for appropriate orders, while reserving the petitioners’ rights. The order thus emphasizes the mandatory nature of Section 202 inquiry to uphold fair jurisdiction.
This High Court of Kerala case, disposed as Crl.M.C. No. 8045 of 2022, concerns a petition under Section 482 CrPC to quash an Annexure-A2 complaint in C.C. No. 1243/2016 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners are accused nos. 1 and 3: (1) M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd., represented by an authorised agent, and (2) Sheeja Sunny, an employee and authorised signatory. The respondents are the State of Kerala and Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd. The petition argues that the second accused was only an employee with no control over day-to-day affairs, that the alleged debt (cheque for Rs. 3,42,000 dated 15.01.2016) was discharged by subsequent payments evidenced by Annexure A3, and that the substrate of the offence no longer exists, making continuation an abuse of process. The court examines the petition through the Nagawwa framework for quashing and cites a series of Supreme Court decisions to delineate when quashing is appropriate. It notes bank remittance, without bank manager evidence, does not conclusively prove discharge toward the specific cheque. Ultimately, the court holds that the petition is meritless, dismisses it, and leaves the complaint to proceed to trial. The result preserves the ongoing criminal proceedings while emphasizing cautious use of drastic relief in quashing.]
This High Court of Kerala, sitting in a single-judge bench, considers nine petitioners/accused in Crime No.643/2021 of Thaliparamba Police Station, Kannur, who are charged with offences under Sections 341 and 323 read with 34 IPC, and an offence under Section 4 of the Kerala Prohibition of Ragging Act, 1998. The petition under Section 482 CrPC seeks quashing of the prosecution on the basis that the parties have amicably settled the dispute and the victim has supported the quashing with an affidavit, with no objection to such relief. The Public Prosecutor has expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of a compromise but concedes that a settlement exists. The court places the matter within the framework laid down by the Supreme Court in Laxmi Narayan v. State of Madhya Pradesh and subsequent decisions (Gian Singh and Narinder Singh), which permit quashing of non‑compoundable offences in private, settled disputes where continuing prosecution would be contrary to social interest, while excluding serious or public interest offences. After reviewing the facts—private nature of the offence, the victim’s consent and no objection, and the absence of aggravating elements—the court holds that the dispute is private, the settlement credible, and accordingly allows the Criminal Miscellaneous Case, quashing all further proceedings against the petitioners in Crime No.643/2021.
This is a first appeal from orders (FAO No. 13 of 2021) in a suit for realisation (O.S. No. 776 of 2008) where the defendant-appellant Rajesh Narayanan @ Pavanan challenges an ex parte decree dated 27 October 2011. The appellant contends the decree was obtained due to inadvertent errors by his counsel, an accident to the counsel, and lack of timely communication, and that he should be afforded an opportunity to contest the suit. He seeks condonation of delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, arguing that COVID-19 restrictions and difficulties in obtaining a certified copy caused the delay. The respondent counters that the delay is excessive and not adequately explained, and that multiple earlier petitions to set aside the decree were dismissed for default, making a fresh application untenable. The High Court invokes Supreme Court rulings to frame the approach to condonation of delay, notably excluding COVID-19 lockdown days from limitation (In Re Cognizance for Extension of Limitation, 2022) and endorsing a liberal, reasoned, justice-oriented test while guarding against abuse (Katiji, Esha Bhattacharjee; Rafeek). The court ultimately condones 745 days of delay for the relevant period but holds that I.A. No.1666 of 2016 was not maintainable, and dismisses the FAO 13 of 2021. The CM application (No. 2 of 2021) is allowed.
This is an original petition under Article 227 challenging Ext.P3, an order of conditional attachment issued by the Commercial Court, Ottappalam, in I.A. No.1/2022 in CS No.10/2022. The petitioner, defendant in the suit for recovery of money filed by the plaintiff, contests the applicability of Order 38 Rule 5 CPC to the original side and labels the garnishee’s attachment as erroneous and unsustainable. The impugned order directs the garnishees not to release any sums payable to the petitioner until further orders, and the suit involves security for Rs.47,28,114/-. The petitioner argues that only the defendant’s property can be attached under Order 38 Rule 5 and not third‑party funds; reliance is placed on Bulkeesu Beegum v Gonzago to emphasize territorial constraints. The respondents counter that there is no embargo on attaching third‑party property before judgment and that such measures may be finalised only after decree; they cite Greater Cochin Development Authority v Harrisons Malayalam Ltd and Surender Singh Bajaj v Kitty Steels Ltd to justify pre‑decree attachment. The High Court, while not deciding the merits, directs the Commercial Court to decide I.A.1/2022 after hearing the rival pleadings within one month, exercising supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 to ensure lawful and expeditious disposal.
This writ petition before the Kerala High Court concerns the award of compensation for land acquired for National Highway development under the National Highways Act, 1956. The petitioners, Anil P.V. and Abdul Kareem, contend that the CALA awards (Exts. P2 and P2(a)) were computed by misclassifying the properties as wetland, whereas they have remained dry for decades. They rely on Exts. P4 and P4(a) (data bank entries) and Ext. P5 (certificate from an Agricultural Officer, dated 10/04/2019) to argue that the actual land nature warrants higher compensation under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. They seek modification of the awards to reflect the correct land type and valuation within a specified timeframe. The respondents concede that CALA has issued awards under Section 3G(1) but assert that the remedy for any challenge lies in Section 3G(5) before the Statutory Arbitrator, and not in re-computation of the original award. The court notes a well-established position that once a 3G(1) award is issued, CALA is functus officio except for supplementary awards (citing Usman Arif v. Project Director, NHAI). It further clarifies that altering the original awards is not permissible and directs the petitioners to pursue 3G(5) arbitration, while keeping contentions open for consideration by the Arbitrator and with a view to judicial review if necessary within eight months. The court also cites Aboobacker v. UOI for guidance on valuation methodology.
This is a criminal appeal by the appellant Thankappan Thittamel Muri challenging a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court-I, Mavelikara, in Sessions Case No. 344 of 2000. The prosecution alleged possession of two litres of arrack in the appellant's residence at Chengannur on 6 June 1998, in violation of the Abkari Act, with offences under sections 8(2), 55(a), and 55(i). After trial, the court convicted the appellant and sentenced him to two years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1 lakh. The defense argued that the contraband analysis was not established because the Chemical Examiner's Laboratory analysis was not proven and that the seizure mahazar lacked the seal description, and there was unexplained delay in producing the samples and their properties before the court; none of the officials who handled the sample during transit were examined. The court below relied on judgments such as Ravi v. State of Kerala, Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala and State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram to emphasize prompt production and chain of custody; however, the High Court found unsatisfactory explanations for delay, lack of seal description, and non-examination of transit officials, and therefore quashed the conviction. The appeal was allowed, the conviction and sentence set aside, the accused acquitted, and liberty granted; depositions, if any, were to be disbursed per law.
The Kerala High Court, in a criminal appeal by two accused, challenges their conviction under sections 489C r/w 34 IPC for counterfeit currency. The case arises from Crime No.42/2002 at Kuravilangadu Police Station and S.C. No.85/2005 before the Additional Sessions Court, Kottayam, convicting Appellants Nos.1 and 2 to two years' rigorous imprisonment and a Rs.2000 fine each, while acquitting the 3rd accused under the same offences. The prosecution's case was that on 6 February 2002 the circle inspector and sub-inspector found the two accused at Zodiac Bar with counterfeit currency; a plastic bag contained counterfeit notes after the bag was handed from one to the other. The investigation extended to a 3rd accused and later to the 2nd wife of the 3rd accused. The trial relied on the evidence of PW1 (Circle Inspector) and PW2 (Sub-Inspector) with corroboration from PW3 (bar manager) and contemporaneous documents P1-P3. The Sessions Judge convicted the appellants; the High Court, through a single judge, upheld the conviction, rejecting claims of material inconsistencies and denial of knowledge. The court emphasized that the evidence, including circumstances like concealment and transfer of the bag, and contemporaneous documents, suffices to establish possession with knowledge of fakeness. The appeal is dismissed; convictions and sentences are confirmed.
MACA No. 159 of 2020; MACA No. 1161 of 2020 These MACA appeals arise from the common award dated 22.10.2019 in OP(MV) No.1655/2015 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Pathanamthitta, regarding the death of Prasannakumar in a 05.07.2015 accident involving a scooter and a car insured by United India Insurance Co. The Tribunal held the driver negligent and the insurer liable, awarding Rs.43,79,000 with 9% interest. The claimants (wife, daughter, mother, sister) sought enhancement; the insurer contended that the deceased’s income had been inflated and that the quantum, particularly under loss of dependency, was excessive. The insurer invoked a Supreme Court decision in United India Insurance Co Ltd v. Satinder Kaur to justify a 50% deduction towards personal expenses from the income base. The High Court examined Exts A9–A32 and the bank/account records, concluding the monthly income could be Rs.50,000 but applying the 50% deduction, the dependency calculation uses Rs.25,000 per month with 25% future prospects, yielding an enhanced figure of Rs.52,50,000. After deducting Rs.42,00,000 already awarded under the same head, the additional amount becomes Rs.10,50,000, payable with interest within three months. The appeals are disposed of by modifying the award accordingly, with the insurer directed to deposit the enhanced amount. The judgment is rendered by a Single Judge, Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A., on 18 September 2023.
Viswanathan P., the 4th appellant in A.S. No.59/2021 and the 4th petitioner in E.A. No.70/2021, challenged two concurrent orders: the execution order of 2.09.2021 passed by the Subordinate Judge, Kozhikode, in E.A. No.70/2021 in O.S. No.95/2012, and the appellate judgment of the Additional District Judge, Kozhikode, in A.S. No.59/2021 dated 24.07.2023. The core dispute concerns a sale transaction and a statutory charge under Section 55(6)(b) of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 on the 1/7th share of the judgment debtor as a result of a sale agreement and subsequent events (death of the original owner and a gift during pendency). The decree holder sought realization of money under an ex parte decree dated 14.01.2016. The trial court and the appellate court held that the statutory charge under Section 55(6)(b) is a charge on the property, enforceable against the seller and all persons claiming under him, and thus the charge remains with the property. The High Court framed the issue under Section 100 CPC and found no substantial question of law; it dismissed the second appeal on the merits, holding that the appeal was meritless. The judgment emphasizes strict adherence to formulating a substantial question of law in second appeals and rules against admission where no such question exists.
MACA No. 158 of 2020; MACA No. 3683 of 2022 This is a common judgment of a Division in the Kerala High Court addressing two Motor Accident Claims Appeals (MACA Nos. 158/2020 and 3683/2022) arising from the same accident-related claims and the consequential awards. The core legal issue is whether an aggrieved party may file a claim petition after a “reasonable time” post deletion of sub-section 3 of Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and whether retrospective application of the amendment could be invoked. The Court canvassed the principle from the Apex Court’s Constitution Bench in Purohit and Company (M/s) v. Khatoonbee and Another (2017) and considered Padma’s case (New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Padma, 2003–2004) to determine the applicable test for timeliness. It held that while the deletion removed strict delay, the claim must still be within a reasonable time and be “genuine, live and surviving.” The judgment distinguishes Padma to some extent, acknowledging the post-deletion scenario requires a reasonableness test rather than a hard deadline. In MACA No.158/2020, delay approached nine years with evidence including FIR and postmortem; the challenge was whether the claim could be treated as genuine. The Court allowed the appeals in part, modifying awards: reducing love-and-affection/loss of consortium awards; correcting disability calculations; capping pain-and-suffering and other heads; and tabulating a total of Rs.3,17,540 with 9% interest. MACA No.3683/2022 involved similar reassessments, including the driver’s disability and related heads, yielding a consolidated end-result. The bench: Single Judge. Final disposition: Appeals allowed in part; tribunal awards modified accordingly.
State of Kerala, represented by the Public Prosecutor, challenges a 13 October 2022 order of the Sessions Court, Alappuzha, that granted regular bail to the 2nd accused in a Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (NDPS) case (FIR No. 110/2022, Poochakkal Police Station). The prosecution alleges that on 11 February 2022, 138.750 grams of MDMA were found in the possession of the first accused while travelling by private bus; the first accused allegedly disclosed the respondent’s involvement as a close associate and involvement in the procurement of the contraband with monetary gains. The Sessions Court noted the contraband as a commercial quantity and extended detention under NDPS Act Section 36A(4) till 14 November 2022, while permitting bail under Section 439 Cr.P.C. The State contends that, in NDPS cases involving commercial quantities, bail must satisfy Section 37(1)(b)(ii), require the Public Prosecutor to be heard, and be grounded in reasonable belief of the accused’s innocence and non-commission of offenses on bail; the court below allegedly failed to apply Section 37, misused the extension, and effectively released the respondent contrary to the law. The High Court emphasizes that absence of contraband on the respondent’s person does not absolve involvement and that Section 37 must guide bail decisions, reversing the order and directing surrender with leave to file a fresh application under law.
Vijay, aged 23, is the sole accused in Crime No. 551/2024 of Kuzhalmannam Police Station, Palakkad, charged with offences under IPC Sections 341, 294(b), 326 and 308. He was arrested and remanded to judicial custody on 01.07.2024. Bail application B.A.No.5660 of 2024 was heard on 01.08.2024 under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Surksha Sanhita, 2023. The prosecution alleges that on 30.06.2024, around 16:00 hours, the accused attacked the de facto complainant with a wooden stick in front of his house following a quarrel about rainwater logging, resulting in grievous injuries. The petitioner contends innocence, false implication, and no criminal antecedents; his counsel argues investigation is practically complete and there is no need for continuing detention. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, citing ongoing investigation and the likelihood of tampering with evidence and intimidating witnesses. The court recalls that Sanjay Chandra and Dataram Singh establish that presumption of innocence exists, and bail is the general rule, with detention being the exception, while Article 21 anchors the right to bail. On balancing, given 30 days in custody, completed investigation, and recovery, the judge allows bail subject to stringent conditions: bond of Rs. 50,000 with two solvent sureties for Rs. 50,000 each; appearance before IO every Saturday; no inducement or tampering; surrender of passport; and power to cancel or modify bail. The court also notes that investigation and recoveries may proceed during bail per Sushila Aggarwal.