The original petition in OP(C) No. 1319 of 2024, before the Kerala High Court, Challenges Ext.P3, an arrest-warrant order dated 23.05.2024 in EP No.53 of 2022 (ARC No.758 of 2019) on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Payyannur. The petitioning party—Abdurahman M.—is the judgment debtor in the EP, while Payyannur Urban Co-Operative Society Ltd. is the decree holder. The petitioner contends that Ext.P3 was issued without following due procedure under Order XXI CPC, Rule 40(1), and without an enquiry, and that the court ignored the contrary counter-statement and the possibility of satisfying the decree by sale of property, given the mortgaged land’s value and location. The petitioner relies on Anilkumar v. Divya (2023) to argue that arrest must follow exhaustion of the sale remedy (Clause (b)) and that arrest (Clause (c)) should not bypass it. The respondent society counters that the decree may be enforced against either person or property, and cites precedents permitting simultaneous execution (e.g., Shyam Singh, Leelakumari, Anjengo Coir Mattings) to justify arrest where warranted. The High Court ultimately holds Ext.P3 to be cryptic and not supported by reasons, setting it aside, and directs the execution court to reconsider in light of the observations, strictly under Section 51 and Order XXI CPC with due process, thereby disposing of the petition.
This writ petition by Vijayakumar K.G., a retired clerk, challenges Ext.P8, a 13.04.2021 order directing recovery of excess pay fixation from pension, and seeks pension fixation in the 4000-6090 scale with time-bound higher grades and related benefits. Retired on 31.05.2020, the petitioner had been granted Time Bound Higher Grade in 2002 in the pay scale of 4000-6090 with subsequent revisions, and pension was sanctioned by Ext.P6. The Department later issued Ext.P8, asserting irregular fixation and directing recovery from the petitioner’s pension from 28.07.2002 onward. The petitioner argues the fixation and benefits were properly granted, objections were never raised for nearly two decades, and the retirement pension was approved and processed; Ext.P8 is therefore untenable. The Government Pleader relies on Govt orders (e.g., GO(MS) and GO(P)/Rti clarifications) suggesting re-fixation and the possibility of recovery for wrong fixation, supported by the Administrator Guruvayoor Devaswom v. Aravindan P.C line of authority. The court notes the long delay in raising the issue, the lack of hearing before Ext.P8, and the need to protect pensionary rights. Ultimately, Ext.P8 is set aside and the respondents are directed to grant the pension as approved (Ext.P6) and disburse all benefits without deduction within three months, preserving vested rights while acknowledging correcting misfixations in future if required.
These consolidated land acquisition petitions concern the Coast Guard Air Enclave project at Kochi. The petitions arise from references under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, challenging compensation awards and alleging fraud in the underlying transactions used to claim enhanced values. The court traces a chain of related transactions (L1–L4) around 2007–2009 involving Sreeni Parameswaran, Satish Menon and M.G. Parameswaran Nair, which it finds were manufactured to induce the reference court to grant inflated compensation. While Jasmine and other claimants had challenged earlier awards, the proceedings reveal a pattern of fraudulent documents such as L3 and L4, created to misrepresent market values. The court distinguishes fraud on the court from fraud on a party and holds that fraud against court can warrant recalling a judgment, even in a review-type context, particularly in the inquisitorial framework of land acquisition references. The judgment recalls the outcome in LA.App.No.762/2011, remands to the Reference Court for fresh assessment of market value, and refixes land values (notably at Rs.2,59,746 per Are) where appropriate. It directs open remand and appearance of parties on 3/4/2023, and allows refunds of court fees where indicated. The decision emphasizes that fraud on the court undermines the integrity of proceedings and justifies remedial recall and remand.”
This writ petition challenges Ext.P3, the shortlist of candidates prepared pursuant to Ext.P1 notification dated 24.08.2023 for Balitharas at Pamba Manappuram to perform Pithru Tharpanam on the banks of Pamba during the Mandala-Makaravilakku festival season (1199 ME). The petitioners, who participated in the tender process, allege favouritism, lack of transparency, and cartel-like conduct by bidders, and contend that the recruitment process for purohits is tainted and arbitrary. They seek a certiorari to quash Ext.P3, a declaration that the tender process is illegitimate, and a mandamus directing respondents to adopt proper protocols. The Court previously restrained Ext.P3 proceedings for a week and ordered notices to various respondents to address the urgency of the Mandala-Makaravilakku festival season. The Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 (Part I-III) vests administration of Sabarimala Devaswom in the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB) and imposes duties on the Board under Sections 3, 4, 15, 15A and 31 to manage and supervise temple rites and properties. The Court cites Rajani P. Kuttan (2021) for organizational finances and the limited self-sufficiency of temples, and relies on a 2022 judgment (W.P.(C) No.41546 of 2017) outlining the interview-board and auction-based selection procedure for purohits. The bench ultimately disposes of the petition by directing a revised shortlist of 26 candidates with 34 marks (40%) or more, to participate in an open tender for 19 Balitharas, to be held on 06.11.2023, and directs further DBA proceedings and arraying of purohits as respondents. Overall, the court emphasizes fair procedures, transparency, and a competitive auction to maximize revenue while ensuring tribal representation through a reserved balithara for Scheduled Tribes where applicable.
Limna Shaiju, the fourth accused in Crime No. 621/2024 of Ollur Police Station, Thrissur, seeks pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The prosecution alleges that on 25.06.2024, in furtherance of their common intention, the accused invited the defacto complainant to the residence of the first accused. The fourth accused allegedly asked the complainant to sit in a room, where the other accused assaulted the complainant, robbed money, compelled him to sign blank papers, and took away his mobile phone and ATM cards; offences charged include 342, 323, 324, 294(b), 506, and 394 r/w 34 IPC. The petitioner contends innocence, asserts false implication, and argues that Annexure A1 FIR shows none of the offences apply to her; she asserts no custodial interrogation is necessary and that she has no criminal antecedents. The Public Prosecutor contends that the accused acted in concert, induced the complainant to the residence, with the petitioner seating him in the room; she had a specific overt act and there is common intent to commit the offences. She argues custodial interrogation and recovery are necessary, that co-accused have already been arrested and enlarged on bail, and that granting anticipatory bail would impede the investigation. The court, citing Supreme Court decisions, holds that anticipatory bail is an extraordinary remedy to be granted in exceptional circumstances, and after evaluating the facts, denies pre-arrest bail, directing surrender within a week and allowing a later bail application on merits.
This COVID-era, Kerala High Court matter under Sec. 482 CrPC concerns quashing of Criminal Case CC 141/2023 pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate Kalpetta. The petitioners, led by RMP Infotec Pvt. Ltd. and several associated individuals, face charges under Sections 420 and 120B read with 34 IPC and Sections 3 and 4 of the Prize Chits and Money Circulation Scheme (Banking) Act, 1978. The petition seeks to exercise the High Court’s inherent powers to quash on grounds of settlement between the parties and lack of desire to continue the prosecution. The respondents include the State represented by the Public Prosecutor and the CBCID EOW-III, with a number of alleged victims or associates named in the case. The petitioners argue that the dispute is private, all parties have settled, affidavits support quashing, and the victims do not object to quashing. The Public Prosecutor concedes settlement but objects to quashing in isolation. The court, after examining the records and affidavits, invokes the Supreme Court’s Laxmi Narayan framework (State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan) and related decisions (Gian Singh; Narinder Singh), to hold that non-compoundable offences with a predominantly civil/private character may be quashed if the dispute is settled, provided the offences do not involve serious/public-interest concerns. The court concludes the dispute is private, settlement valid, and hence quashes the proceedings, allowing the CrMC. The order ends with the quashing of CC 141/2023 proceedings.
This is a criminal miscellaneous petition (CRL.M.C. 798 of 2023) filed by accused Nos.16–32 seeking deferral of proceedings in SC No.461/2022, arising from Crime No.897/2021 (Alappuzha South Police Station). The accused, alleged activists of SDPI/PI, are said to have conspired with others to avenge a BJP/RSS activist’s murder by attacking a residence and causing grievous injuries, culminating in a death on 19.12.2021. The investigation led to a final report against accused Nos.1–15 for principal offences, with a “split-charge” plan to file charges later against the remaining accused. The petition contends that such a “split-charge” is alien to the CrPC and prejudices the petitioners, arguing for joinder of charges under Section 223 CrPC and for trial of all conspirators together, since the acts arose from one conspiracy and same transaction. The respondents counter that the CrPC permits a final report against some accused with reserve to file supplementary chargesheet after further investigation, and that cognizance can be taken on the materials before the court regardless of labels. The bench analyzes the law on joint versus separate trials, the concept of “same transaction” and conspiracy, and the permissibility of split-chargesheets. It ultimately holds that there is no illegality in the lower courts’ approach; the petition is dismissed.
This is a criminal miscellaneous petition (Crl.M.C. No. 7682 of 2019) heard by a single judge of the Kerala High Court, challenging an order of 9 July 2019 in CMP 2887(A)/C.No.246/2008 of the Judicial Magistrate, Mannarkad. The Magistrate issued an order recalling PW4 and permitting the marking of a certified copy of a Bail Application in Crime No.3/2007 of the Chittur Excise Range. The petitioner, Sunil Kumar, was accused in Crime No.3/2007; his bail application was rejected, and he fled, allegedly with the connivance of two others who stood as sureties. The prosecution sought recall and admission to bolster the case by presenting the Bail Application dated 13.04.2007. The Sessions Court dismissed the revision. The State, supported by the Public Prosecutor, relied on Varsha Garg v State of Madhya Pradesh (2022 SCC Online SC 986), arguing that a criminal court has ample power under Section 311 CrPC to summon or recall a witness even after evidence is closed if necessary for the just decision of the case. The High Court upheld the trial court’s exercise of discretion, deeming it proper within the broad ambit of Section 311, and dismissed the petition. The petition seeks to avert possibly prejudicial proceedings, but the Court found no merit to interfere with the trial court’s order.
OT.Rev Nos. 29/2022 to 44/2022 These matters arise from a batch of revision petitions under the Kerala VAT/CST regime, heard together by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court on 12 October 2022. The petitions, labeled OT.Rev Nos. 29/2022 through 44/2022, challenge orders of the Additional Bench, Kottayam, disposing of applications for exemption under Section 8 of the CST Act, 1956 and corresponding reliefs under the Kerala KVAT Act, 2003. The core issue concerns whether government notifications issued under Section 8—and later amended—correctly regulate exemptions for inter-State sales of natural rubber and tread rubber, and whether a dealer can secure exemptions under more than one notification. The first notification exempted CST on inter-State movement where VAT had already been paid; the second restricted the exemption to sub-section (1) of Section 8; the third introduced an option for payment of tax. The Deputy Commissioner (Appeals) remanded the matter for fresh disposal and the Tribunal upheld the remand. The State contends the second notification supersedes the first and eliminates double exemptions, while the dealer and its counsel argue the dealer retains a choice and that the remand is tenable. The court, citing Hi-Tek Traders v. Commercial Tax Officer, holds that the second notification governs the exemption regime and that the dealer’s option must be given effect to. The result is that the revisions are dismissed and the remand order is affirmed, with no costs.
This is a Kerala High Court judgment in a cross-appeal arising from an MACT (Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Manjeri) award in OP(MV) No. 1536/2003 for the death of a 12-year-old boy in a road accident involving a car owned by the appellants. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 1,65,500 to the claimants (the parents, who filed a cross-objection) and exonerated the insurer on the ground that the vehicle was not insured under the policy. The appellants challenged the exoneration, arguing that the relevant trade certificates and police records indicate the vehicle was covered under Ext. B1 policy via Ext. A6, while Ext. A4 suggests a Hyundai Santro registration; thus the insurer should be liable. The cross objectors contended that compensation under heads like Funeral Expenses, Loss of Estate, and Loss of Dependency was too low and sought higher sums, citing Pranay Sethi (and subsequent judgments) to support enhanced compensation, including Loss of Consortium for the parents. After hearing counsel for the appellants, cross objectors, and the insurer, the learned Judge found merit in the cross objections, enhanced the compensation to Rs. 3,08,500, and remanded the matter to the Tribunal to reconsider insurance liability, conditioned on depositing the enhanced amount within one month. The court also adopted higher notional income guidelines for a child and applied Pranay Sethi’s framework for head of Funeral Expenses and Loss of Estate, with the possibility of indemnity by the insurer if liable.
This petition challenges the SARFAESI Act proceedings initiated by the Federal Bank Ltd., Sultan Bathery branch, for recovery of a debt owed by M/s. Thara Coffee Pvt. Ltd., in which the petitioner Thara Philip stood as guarantor. The bank classified the loan as NPA on 14.06.2022, served a notice under Section 13(2) on 13.07.2022, and obtained symbolic possession on 11.11.2022. Following this, the bank moved to take physical possession and to sell the secured assets, and enforcement actions proceeded through the Debts Recovery Tribunal framework. The borrower-challenger contends that the properties sought to be auctioned are agricultural lands, protected under Section 31(i) of the SARFAESI Act, and thus immune from enforcement. The bank disputes maintainability and contends that a writ petition under Article 226 is not maintainable against a private scheduled bank. The Court emphasizes that SARFAESI is a self-contained code designed to speed up recovery and provides Section 17 as a remedy with a requirement for expeditious disposal, while also highlighting the principle of exhausting statutory remedies before invoking writ jurisdiction. The decision discusses the need for factual adjudication by the Debts Recovery Tribunal on whether the lands are agricultural, and notes that DRAT is the proper appellate forum for such fact-finding. In the end, the High Court dismisses the writ petition in limine, holding that the remedy under SARFAESI is efficacious and that the petition is not maintainable against a private bank.
Sunil Kumar and Abhilash P.J., transferees of portions of land owned by Goldview Vyapar Private Limited, challenged a registration obstacle created by Ext.P6, a general order invoked under Section 120A of the Kerala Land Reforms Act (KLR Act) to restrain sale of plantation land of shorter extents. On 04-01-2022 they submitted sale deeds (Exts.P2 and P4) for registration along with stamp duty and registration fees; the Sub Registrar refused, citing Ext.P6 restraining transfer. The petition sought quashing Ext.P6 to the extent it affected registration and a direction to register the originals of Exts.P2 and P4. The Court canvassed authorities including Mathew K. Jacob & Anr. v. District Environmental Impact Assessment (Full Bench, 2018) and Nazar v. Mathew K. Jacob (SC, 2019), One Earth One Life v. State of Kerala (2019), and State of Kerala v. M.C. George (Division Bench, 2023 WA102/2022). It held that Section 81(4) enables limited non-plantation uses by exempted land (e.g., hotels, resorts) up to 10 acres without negating the exemption, and that fragmentation to defeat exemption cannot be presumed but must be examined in light of the act’s object. The division bench’s approach, and prior judgments cited, confirm that the objective is to prevent evasion while preserving plantation status. The petition was allowed; Ext.P6 was quashed to the extent it affected registration; the Registrar was directed to register Exts.P2 and P4 if otherwise in order, treating stamp papers as valid, and the petitioners were to present within two weeks of a certified copy of the judgment.
The petitioner, Dr. Chandramohan K., seeks to challenge two RCC notifications (Exts.P7 and P8) for the post of Professor (Surgical Oncology), arguing they prescribe qualifications contrary to MCI Regulations (now NMC) and that the 2020 amendments via Exts.P9 and P10, along with a two-year transitional period, do not apply to the academic qualifications but only to teaching/experience. The matter traces back to a 2017-2018 sequence where the MCI was directed to assess the compatibility of Ext.P1 qualifications with its Regulations (Ext.P5/P6). RCC issued Exts.P7/P8 nearly two and a half years later, claiming conformity with the amended Regulations 1998 (as per Ext.P9) and acknowledging subsequent amendments Ext.P10 (2020). With Regulations 2022 coming into force on 14.02.2022 and repealing Regulations 1998, the petitioner argued that post-14.02.2022 appointments must be under Regulations 2022, and that Exts.P7/P8 cannot operate; respondents argued for a one-time operation of Exts.P7/P8 or that actions pre-date repeal could be saved. The learned Judge held that Regulations 2022 prevail and that no further action under Exts.P7/P8 can proceed; however RCC may issue fresh Notifications under Regulations 2022. The petition is disposed with liberty to apply under the new regime. The court also noted that mere applications or rank lists do not vest a right to appointment.
The writ petition by Sabu Johny, Managing Director of E.V.M. Passengers Cars India Pvt. Ltd., concerns the confiscation of a Nissan Terrano Diesel (KL-07-CP-7386) rented to a customer for a short period in April 2021. The vehicle, licensed for rent-a-car business under Ext. P1, was seized by Vadakara Excise Officials after a crime (O.R. 78/2021) was registered under Sections 58 and 67B of the Abkari Act for alleged illicit liquor transport. The petitioner contends that the rental company was merely the owner and operator of the vehicle, and that the customer, Jinil Mathew, was the one who used the car; the rental agreement (Ext. P3) shows the customer returning the vehicle, and the company’s liability is restricted to providing a licensed service. Ext. P9 (order of confiscation) is challenged, and the petitioner argues the 2nd respondent did not properly evaluate the documents and that the owner took reasonable precautions by enforcing contract terms. The court’s reasoning emphasizes that ownership alone cannot imply culpability; the rental agreement assigned responsibility to the customer, and Section 67C requires proper show-cause plus hearing. The judgment sets aside Ext. P9, quashes the confiscation, and orders permanent custody in favor of the petitioner, directing release of the vehicle.
WP(C) No. 26205 of 2012; WP(C) No. 26863 of 2012 These consolidated writ petitions challenge EPFO actions arising from nonpayment of Provident Fund contributions by Rajgopal Textile Mills and seek relief from attachment/damages and the grant of a No Objection Certificate (NOC) for release of property. In WP(C) No. 26205/2012, Dipesh S. Ved seeks a mandamus to issue an NOC to release attached property of M/s Rajgopal Textiles after EPFO’s Appellate Tribunal reduced damages to 10% and after the EPFO offered an instalment option. In WP(C) No. 26863/2012, EPFO seeks recovery of damages under Sections 14B and 7Q for the default period (2003–2008) against M/s Rajgopal Textiles, challenging the Tribunal’s reduction and arguing that penalties must be enforced. The district court record shows that damages were initially assessed at Rs. 84,91,179 and later reduced to 10% by the Tribunal. The court notes EPFO’s position that Paragraph 32A of the EPF Scheme, 1952, became effective in 2008, making it inapplicable to earlier defaults, and cites a Supreme Court decision (Horticulture Experiment Station Gonikoppal v. RPFO) to support the position that defaults lead to penal provisions that cannot be wholly waived. The Honourable Judge Amit Rawal ultimately disposes of the petitions: WP(C)26863/2012 is dismissed with NOC already issued (subject to a bank guarantee) and WP(C)26205/2012 is disposed of, effectively concluding the matter with the NOC conditions and closing the related bank guarantee."
This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition filed by Krishnan, challenging an order/dismissal related to a private complaint filed under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989 (SC/ST POA Act) and sections of the IPC. The petitioner, a member of the Scheduled Caste, claims that the respondents coerced a police action and misused legal processes to cause financial and personal loss. The underlying facts trace a loan transaction in 2015 where respondent No.2 borrowed Rs.50 lakh from the petitioner and issued post-dated cheques; another loan of Rs.60 lakh to Sandeesh with six blank cheques, which were entrusted to the petitioner. When repayment failed, the petitioner attempted to recover, and the respondents allegedly caused the petitioner to be implicated for theft of the respondents’ car by making false allegations to the police. The case progressed from an initial 156(3) forwarding order to a Section 200 Cr.P.C. inquiry after a prior appellate direction, culminating in dismissal of the complaint under Section 203 Cr.P.C. The core legal issue concerns whether the complaint satisfies the SC/ST POA Act’s knowledge requirement—that the offender knew the victim belonged to SC/ST—and thus whether Section 8 presumption can arise. The court reiterates that knowledge of the victim’s caste is a necessary predicate and, since the complaint lacks this foundational fact, interference is unwarranted. The petition is dismissed.
Jamsheer @ Jimshar, the 2nd accused, approached the Kerala High Court under Section 482 CrPC seeking quashment of SC No. 1061/2021 from the Assistant Sessions Court, Tirur, arising out of Crime No. 985/2020 of Parappanangadi Police Station. The charges include offences under Sections 143, 147, 148, 286, 324 and 308 read with 149 IPC. The prosecution contends that an unlawful assembly assaulted the victim, who is reportedly willing to settle the matter with the petitioner. Citing Sajeev and anr. v. State of Kerala and anr. (2022 (2) KLT 861), the counsel for the petitioner contends that the dispute has been resolved and the prosecution should be quashed in view of private settlement. The Public Prosecutor acknowledges the settlement but expresses reservations about quashing solely on that basis. The High Court examined the public-interest aspects and relied on State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019 (5) SCC 688), and the accompanying principles from Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh and others v. State of Punjab, to delineate the scope of Section 482 in quashing non-compoundable offences when the dispute is private and settled. Finding the dispute private and the settlement genuine, the court allowed the Crl.M.C. and quashed the proceedings against the petitioner in SC No. 1061/2021.
This High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, hears BA 2152 of 2022, a regular bail application by Farhan A.K., the second accused in Crime No. 8/2021 (Feroke Excise Range Office, Kozhikode). The prosecution alleges offences under sections 22(c), 20(b)(ii)(B) read with sections 8(c) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, on account of seizure of 310 grams of methamphetamine (initially believed to be MDMA) and 1.8 kg of ganja on 19.03.2021 from a scooter. The petitioner contends that the search violated Section 50 NDPS Act because the search was conducted by an officer who was not independent and because the accused was not informed of his right to be searched in the presence of a gazetted officer or a Magistrate; he relies on several Kerala High Court judgments and Rajasthan v. Parmanand to urge that the search was defective and bail should be granted. The State, represented by the Public Prosecutor and aided by the Senior Public Prosecutor, counters that the search complied with Section 50; that written notice was given; and that jurisprudence (Sekhar Suman Verma, Sarwan Ram, Sipahi Kumar, Arun, etc.) supports compliance with 50 and applicability of Section 37 given the quantity, justifying refusal of bail. After considering the case diary and submissions, the Court finds the alleged breach of Section 50 not substantiated. Consequently, bail is denied. The observations are limited to bail and not a finding on merits.
Vettukallel Thomas, the appellant, challenges a conviction under Section 8(1) r/w 8(2) of the Kerala Abkari Act for possessing 3 litres of illicit arrack found near his residence on 9 June 2010. The Sessions Court at Thalassery tried the case after committal from the Judicial First Class Magistrate, recording evidence of PW1–PW4 and marking Exts. P1–P9. The appellant was convicted and sentenced under Section 8(1) r/w 8(2) of the Abkari Act to three months’ RI and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with SI for three months in default, and the period of any custody was to be set off under Section 428 CrPC. On appeal, the appellant contends that key witness PW2, who signed Ext. P2 mahazar, turned hostile; PW1’s Ext. P3 occurrence/report contained inconsistencies; and there are serious flaws in the chain of custody and tamper-proof handling of the contraband, as evidenced by Exts. P5–P7 (dates and forwarding notes). The court cites Vijayan @ Puthoor Vijayan v. State of Kerala (2021) for the stringent procedural mandates on collection, sealing, forwarding to the laboratory, and examination of custody witnesses, and scrutinizes the evidence against those standards. It concludes that the prosecution evidence is not free from doubt, benefits the accused, and invites acquittal. Consequently, the appeal is allowed, conviction and sentence set aside, and the accused released forthwith, with bail bonds cancelled and any paid fines potentially refundable.
BAIL APPL. NO. 8253 OF 2023 Shiyas P A, the petitioner, seeks anticipatory bail in Crime No.925/2023 of Chandera Police Station, Kasargod District, alleging offences under Sections 376 and 420 IPC. The prosecution accuses him of entering into a relationship with the victim on a false promise of marriage and of obtaining money with a promise to repay after marriage, thereby committing rape and cheating. The petitioner asserts his innocence, highlighting that he runs a fitness centre, is a model/actor, and that the victim is also a model who allegedly joined him for work; the relationship is claimed to have been consensual, with a genuine intent to marry, though the victim is said to be a divorcee with a 15-year-old child. The petitioner relies on this Court’s Bail Application No. 8772 of 2022 to argue that consensual relationships between mature individuals ought not to be treated as rape merely on the basis of a failed promise to marry. The Public Prosecutor and the victim’s side contend that the allegations are serious and supported by the FIR, including the victim’s statements about a close relationship and a withdrawal from the promised marriage. The Court, while noting the seriousness, found materials suggesting a consensual relationship over 2021–2023 and invoked the distinction between consensual sex and rape. It granted bail, making the interim order absolute with specific conditions: appearance before the IO on 18–19 Oct 2023, passport surrender and no travel outside India, no harassment of the victim, and modification to ensure limited custody under Sushila Aggarwal.