This is a Division Bench judgment of the Kerala High Court in a challenge under Article 227 to an order of the Rent Control Court (Principal Munsiff), Kollam, in an eviction petition under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The petitioner Remani P., along with respondent Nos.4 and 5, had sought to implead themselves as additional respondents in RC(OP) No.18 of 2018 on the ground that they are co-owners and that the tenancy dispute implicates title to the tenanted premises. The Rent Control Court dismissed the impleadment application (I.A.5114 of 2019) by its order dated 02.02.2022. The High Court held that, in eviction proceedings under Section 11, disputes about ownership or title between rival claimants are not within the scope of the enquiry, which is limited to eviction on grounds listed in Section 11. Citing Thankachan v. V. Gireesh Kumar, the court reiterated that if a tenant denies the landlord’s title, the Rent Control Court must decide that question and may direct civil litigation, or proceed on merits. The petition was dismissed, holding that the petitioner and co-owners were not necessary parties to RC(OP) No.18 of 2018. The order emphasizes that co-owners’ rights to profits do not alter the core eviction inquiry.
This is a Kerala High Court (OP(C) No. 304 of 2023) arising from Ext. P7 order dated 02.02.2023 in O.P.(Insolvency) No. 2/2011 before the Ist Additional Sub Court, Thiruvananthapuram. The two petitioners–petitioners/Additional Counter Petitioners are M/S Karimala Granites and Aggregates Pvt. Ltd. and M/S Kannamthananam and Company; they challenge the order on grounds of limited locus standi and denial of opportunity to lead evidence in Ext. P1 insolvency proceedings that included their properties in the schedule. The respondents/Counter Petitioners (1–10 and 13–91) include various creditors and associated entities who initiated or were involved in the insolvency process. The High Court, exercising its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227, found that Ext. P7 denied the petitioners their right to lead evidence in Ext. P1 and set aside Ext. P7 to the limited extent, permitting the petitioners to present oral and documentary evidence on the next hearing. The judgment directs expeditious disposal of OP No. 2/2011 by 31 March 2023 and cites the principles laid down in PRS Hospital v. P. Anil Kumar for admissibility of documents. The court emphasizes fair adjudication in insolvency matters and safeguards the petitioners’ claims while allowing the lower court to proceed with the proceedings expeditiously.
Ex.S.A.No.9/2010 is a Kerala High Court execution second appeal arising from an eviction order in Rent Control proceedings (RCP 86/1994 and related matters) concerning the petition schedule shop. The three petitioners—Kalyani Amma, Ramachandran, and Premarajan—alleged tenancy rights over the shop and claimed that an oral entrustment arrangement, and a mediation in 2006, resulted in their re-entrustment of the premises, with the landlord allegedly colluding to evict the second respondent who purportedly did not have a tenancy. They asserted that the consent letter and related acts evidenced an ongoing tenancy, and that the second respondent was an interloper. The first respondent/decree holder contended that the shop belonged to his father, that tenancy rights devolved to the petitioners, and that a valid rental arrangement existed between the first and second respondents, evidenced by Ext.B8 (the rent deed) dated 01.01.2006, under which the second respondent occupied the premises for Rs.3,750 per month. The petitioners also argued a discrepancy in building numbers (VII/396 vs VII/390) to challenge the eviction identity. The courts below rejected the oral-arrangement theory; the High Court accepted Ext.B8 as proof of tenancy, rejected additional-document requests under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC, and ultimately dismissed the Execution Second Appeal, upholding eviction and possession claims.
RFA 199/2019; RFA 179/2021 The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, before Justice P. Somarajan, hears Regular First Appeals (RFA Nos. 199/2019 and 179/2021) arising from two original suits in Palakkad: O.S. 169/2012 and O.S. 17/2017. The appellants are K. K. Ashok Kumar and Nalini; the respondent is M. Gopinathan. The matter was listed for hearing on 14 February 2022 along with connected matters. The mediation conducted at the Palakkad District Mediation Centre culminated in a settlement between the parties, with a mediation report filed and accepted by the court. Consequently, the appeals are disposed of in terms of the mediated settlement. The terms include: (i) the appellants will surrender possession of the plaint schedule property in O.S. 17/2017; (ii) the respondent will forgo the decree for arrears of rent and occupational charges and relinquish the decretal amounts including costs; (iii) the respondent will pay Rs. 2,00,000 to the appellants under the mediation terms; (iv) the entire court fee paid by the appellants will be refunded in light of the settled position. The settlement is to be recorded in the judgment and decree. The court cites a Kerala High Court/Madras High Court authority (M.C. Subramaniam) to support refunds. The order is a disposition of the appeals without further contest, with no costs. The matter thus ends by consent, avoiding further litigation.
W.P.(C). No. 21291 of 2021 Mahilamony Gireesh, a fireworks licensee under the Explosives Rules since 2014, challenged the cancellation of his licence following a renewal application. The petitioner held licences renewals up to 2020 and sought renewal for three more years; Ext. P7 notice alleged hygienic deficiencies, improper fencing, and that the unit’s platform was not in proper condition. The renewal application appears not to have been considered properly, culminating in Ext. P11, an order canceling the licence on the ground that a residential building existed within 35 meters, whereas the prohibited distance is 45 meters. The petitioner contends that cancellation was done without following the rules and without notice or hearing, especially since defects cited were cured as evidenced by Ext. P10 and the interim order directed consideration of renewal. The 6th respondent, Dhanya Suresh, who purchased the adjacent property in 2018, filed an affidavit stating she has no objection to continuing the unit and that she knew of the unit at purchase; she is prepared to face consequences. The Government Pleader relied on Dasan v. State of Kerala (2018 KHC 3958) to argue that post-licence residential encroachment does not permit operation, emphasizing safety. The Court, while noting the 6th respondent’s affidavit, found Ext. P11 untenable and directed the first respondent to reconsider the renewal after hearing within one month, with an affidavit from the 6th respondent if renewal is granted, and clarified that these observations are not a binding precedent. The decision emphasizes balancing regulatory caution with neighbours’ interests while ensuring due process.
WP(C) Nos. 15579/2023 & 25005/2023 This consolidated writ petition concerns the reservation of sports quota marks for MBBS admissions in Kerala, challenging Annexure XVIII(ii) of Ext.P7, which excludes players representing the Sports Authority of India (SAI) from the sports-quota criteria. The petitioner in WP(C) No.15579/2023, Brijit Joseph, a Kerala student who represented SAI in national volleyball, claimed eligibility for grace marks under Annexure XVIII(ii) priority for those who have represented the State in National Championships, contending equal treatment with State players. The court had earlier directed scrutiny of certificates and provisional inclusion based on merit, with interim orders in force. WP(C) No.25005/2023 was filed by Addl.R5 to Addl.R8 (Amarnath, Gautham Kisor, Niranjana, Abhinandial) challenging the final category lists and seeking re-computation strictly in line with Ext.P1 norms and Ext.P8 judgments. The State and Kerala State Sports Council defended the system under Section 31(1A)(ix) of the Kerala Sports Act, 2000 and insisted that only Kerala-recognized bodies’ certificates should be considered for grace marks, and that SAI participation did not align with the statutory framework. The Court found the challenged classification under Annexure XVIII(ii) to be irrational and not reasonably connected to the objective, while ultimately holding the petitioner in WP15579 entitled to MBBS admission under sports quota (subject to interim orders) and dismissing WP25005. The decision hinges on Article 14 and rational classification tests, balancing public policy with individual merit.
WA 859/2015; WA 1126/2015 This is a batch of two writ appeals before the Kerala High Court (Division Bench) arising from a common judgment in W.P.(C) No.17767/2010 and O.P. No.8538/2003, concerning the prize money won in an online lottery conducted by the Government of Sikkim. The petitioner M. Bensraj (WA 859/2015) and M. D. Santosh Madathiparambil (WA 1126/2015) challenge the withholding of prize money by the Director of Lotteries, Government of Sikkim, and the corresponding tax treatment under the Income Tax Act, 1961 (the Act). The dispute centers on whether the sum of Rs.51,99,088 (and in the second case Rs.34,89,088) withheld as tax could be treated as tax deducted at source under the Act, given that the Act was extended to Sikkim only from 01.04.1989 and that Sikkim had its own Manual (1948) governing income tax prior to that extension. The petitioners argued that the amounts withheld represented unrealised/untaxed prize money and that taxing such sums under the Act would amount to double taxation. The respondents contended that the Manual 1948 continued to govern tax matters until the IT Act was extended, and the withholding was valid. The court eventually held that the retention of the amounts was illegal, unconstitutional, and unauthorized, and laid out a framework for complying with the IT Act, issuing Form 16A certificates, revising assessments, and refunds with interest where appropriate, while preserving the assessment process. The judgment culminates in declaring the reliefs and directing steps to align with the IT Act.
BAIL APPL. NOS. 10344/22, 10343/22, 122/23 These bail applications under section 438 Cr.P.C. are connected and disposed of by a common judgment. The petitioners AjI @ Ajith Kumar V; Jeejo Yohannan; Athulraj K; Vishnu V.V.; Vyshak.K are accused in Crime No. 926/2022 of Cherpu Police Station, alleging offences under sections 323, 324, 326 read with 34 IPC. The prosecution case is that the petitioners and other accused attacked the defacto complainant in a public place, causing a nasal bone injury; it is argued that the weapon was not recovered and the injuries were serious. The petitioners' counsel urged bail on grounds of pendency since 2022 and to ensure fair trial; the Public Prosecutor contended that the injuries were serious and the case is still under investigation. The court observed that although the allegations are grave, the bail applications have been pending for long, and it would be unjust to dismiss them at this juncture; an interim order not to arrest remains in force. Relying on Chidambaram P. v Directorate of Enforcement, the court reaffirmed the general principle that bail is the rule and jail is the exception, and proceeded to grant bail with safeguards: the petitioners must appear before the IO within ten days for interrogation; if arrest is proposed they may be released on bond of Rs.50,000 with two solvent sureties; they must co-operate, not leave the jurisdiction, not commit similar offences, and appear for interrogation on Mondays and Fridays at 11.00 a.m. until final report is filed; violation can lead to cancellation of bail.
The petitioner, Jollyamma Joseph @ Jolly (accused no.1 in SC 496/2020), seeks exercise of powers under Section 482 CrPC to challenge an order of 8 May 2023 passed by the Sessions Judge, Kozhikode, which rejected her discharge application in relation to CW156 — a Will attestation witness later sought to be treated as an additional witness. The core dispute arose after CW156, originally included in the final report as an advocate and notary who allegedly attested a photocopy of a will (bequeathing property to the petitioner and her husband), was later arrayed as accused No.5 in a supplementary charge sheet. The Notary was previously quashed from proceedings by this Court in CRL.M.C. 3927/2022, but the prosecution subsequently sought to examine CW156 as a witness. The petitioner argued that allowing examination would prejudice the accused since the Notary had already been detached, that there was no proper closure for his potential re-accusation (Notaries Act Section 13(1) procedure), and that the matter should follow due process under CrPC Sections 306-307. The respondents urged that CW156, having ceased to be an accused, remains competent to testify under Section 118 of the Indian Evidence Act, and that no embargo prevents summoning or examining him. The High Court, distinguishing Abdul Razak, upheld the trial court’s discretion and dismissed the petition, holding no legal bar to examination and noting cross-examination could be liberal if recalled. The decision preserves fair trial safeguards while allowing necessary evidentiary examination in the ongoing trial.
MACA 2551/2016 & MACA 3285/2016 These consolidated Motor Accident Claims Appeals arise from an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode in OP(MV) No.1851/2014, regarding the death of Mubashira in a road accident on 17.07.2014. The appellants, heirs of the deceased, challenge the Tribunal's award seeking enhanced compensation for dependency, funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of love and affection; the insurer disputes the award noting excesses and seeks re-computation. The court, presided by Justice Devan Ramachandran, examines evidence on notional income, future prospects, and heads of compensation including Loss of Dependency, Funeral Expenses, Loss of Estate, and Loss of Love and Affection, as well as Loss of Consortium for parents versus siblings. It holds that the Tribunal's notional income figure was acceptable in light of Ramchandrappa, but that the future prospects should be reduced to 40% rather than 50%. The tribunal's awards for Funeral Expenses and Loss of Estate were reduced to Rs 15,000 each; the award under Loss of Love and Affection was deleted; Loss of Consortium to parents was confirmed at Rs 40,000 each; siblings could not be granted Loss of Consortium in the absence of dependency evidence. The court finds that the tribunal's ultimate award is adjusted: (i) Loss of Dependency reduced to Rs.15,12,000; (ii) Funeral Expenses and Loss of Estate each Rs.15,000; (iii) Loss of Love and Affection deleted; (iv) Loss of Consortium to parents Rs.40,000 each; (v) other heads unchanged. The insurer’s appeal succeeds in MACA 3285/2016 to the extent stated, while MACA 2551/2016 is dismissed subject to these modifications. The court directs 9% interest on enhanced amounts and costs on the enhanced amount.
BA Nos.7913, 7981, 8006, 8059, 8203, 8239, 8606, 8754 & 8763 of 2022 This judgment from the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam concerns multiple bail applications (BA Nos. 7913, 7981, 8006, 8059, 8203, 8239, 8606, 8754 and 8763 of 2022) filed by Sri Lankan refugees/foreign nationals and others in two connected cases (Crime Nos. 529/2022 at Pallithottam and 868/2022 at East Kollam) arising from alleged human trafficking and related offences under IPC, Foreigners Act, Emigration Act and Passport Act. The petitioners challenged interim bail orders directing stay in Open Prison and Correctional Home, Nettukaltheri, or placement in transit centers, arguing that continued detention was unnecessary and that they should be permitted to remain in refugee camps or receive protection. The Respondents urged ongoing investigation and the gravity of offences, pointing to the need for supervising foreign nationals and ensuring travel/document compliance. After hearing contentions, the Court, noting health concerns (including for a pregnant woman and a child) and the lack of immediate detention facilities, issued interim bail with conditions, ordered relocation to a transit home at Mayyanad (Kollam) and permitted continued stay at Gandhi Bhavan International Trust, Pathanapuram, with educational facilities for children and medical arrangements. The Court requested concrete instructions from authorities and retained jurisdiction to oversee future compliance, disposing of the bail applications on that day (Nov 22, 2022).
WA Nos. 1543/2022 & 1548/2022 Two writ appeals arise from a common judgment dated 24 May 2022 that disposed of two writ petitions: one against the Kattappana Municipality and the other by it. The petitioner in W.P.(C).No.14429/2022 alleged that the Kattappana Municipality intends to enclose a 50-cent land area surrendered in 1968 for a bus stand and convert it into a pay-and-park facility after the relocation of the bus stand in 2018. The petition challenged the alleged breach of the deed of surrender which required keeping the northern, southern and western sides open to enable construction of buildings for business, contending that enclosing the land would deprive access to the petitioner’s shop rooms. The Municipality contended that the petitioner had no title or locus to challenge, and that the land has been in municipal possession for decades; it sought to regulate parking under Rule 344 of the Kerala Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989, though the High Court found Rule 344 inapplicable to the facts here. The court held that the petitioner lacked locus to challenge the surrender’s conditions, that title need not be decided in this proceeding, and that Rule 344 does not apply to a municipal property used for commercial pay-and-park purposes. The appeals were dismissed with observations, and the review’s ownership question left to appropriate proceedings.
W.P.(C) Nos. 5449 of 2019 and 26888, 26901, 27836, 28181 & 29995 of 2021 Common issue across these writ petitions is the validity of the Circular fixing a cutoff date for applications seeking permission to use unnotified paddy land for other purposes under the Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008 as amended by Section 27A. The Government introduced Section 27A to permit user of unnotified land for other purposes on payment of a fee, and on 25 July 2021 issued a Circular fixing a cutoff date for applications. The Circular was challenged, and a Division Bench of this Court held it unconstitutional in Baby v. District Collector. Petitioners across six writ petitions had paid the demanded sums based on the Circular and interim orders. The State argued that payment was voluntary and valid when made; refunds should not be ordered. The Supreme Court has repeatedly held that where a levy or fee is declared unconstitutional, the person from whom it was collected is entitled to refunds, whether in suit or under Article 226. Based on this jurisprudence, the Kerala High Court holds that the petitioners are entitled to refunds. The Court accordingly directs refunds of amounts remitted by the petitioners within two months from the date of this judgment and, in the case of W.P.5449, 20% of the fair value was directed to be paid earlier; no costs. The decision clarifies that relief is grounded in constitutional droit to refund, not merely the circular’s invalidity.
This writ petition challenges the Returning Officer’s rejection of the petitioner’s nomination for election to the Senate constituency of the Cochin University of Science & Technology (CUSAT), sought to be elected as the President of all registered Trade Unions in the State. Ext. P1 notification dated 27.12.2022 invited nominations for the Senate & Academic Council. The petitioner, in the final electoral roll of 357, was the only candidate for the constituency “Presidents of all the registered Trade Unions in the State” and had his nomination form submitted within the allotted time. After scrutiny, the 4th respondent rejected the nomination on the ground of overwriting in the address column. The petitioner’s agent objected, arguing that the remainder of the details—the name, address, membership number, proposer, seconder, consent, and signatures—were clearly legible and that the overwriting was a minor clerical error that did not affect identity. The counter affidavit contends the nomination form is defective and the rejection was legal, based on the wrapping of overwriting. The High Court concludes that the defect is not substantial; drawing on precedents that nominations should not be rejected on technicalities and that substantial compliance suffices, the court allows the petition and directs the Returning Officer to accept the nomination and proceed with the election. The decision emphasizes protecting the right to contest and ensuring a fair electoral process.
This writ petition challenges Ext.P3, a 19.12.2021 communication by the Travancore Devaswom Board that granted permission for videography inside the Iringole Sree Bhagavathy Temple, purportedly in keeping with temple customs. The petitioners, devotees and members of temple associations, seek to quash Ext.P3 and obtain mandamus to prevent unauthorized access and to survey and protect temple land; to erect a boundary wall on all four sides and to appoint security staff. The court recounts Iringole Kavu as a 56-acre forest enclave with four gate entries; encroachments and the absence of a formal Temple Advisory Committee; and the unique rituals and rites, including the goddess's daily transformation and the restriction on certain activities like marriages within the temple. It notes the Board's reliance on Ext.R1 reports and the 19.12.2021 Ext.P3 permission, contrasting with the temple’s customs, and the environmental risks of unregulated videography. The judgment places heavy emphasis on the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act provisions (Sections 3, 15A, 31, 31A and the Rules for TACs) and the Board’s statutory duty to arrange daily worship and protect temple properties. It ultimately allows the petition, setting aside Ext.P3, and directs fencing of the unfenced boundary with barbed wire, along with returning the petition papers to the Board.
Anil Kumar V., the accused in Crime No. 1437/2017 of Nooranadu Police Station, approaches the Kerala High Court in CRL.M.C. 1184 of 2018 seeking quashing of proceedings. The case arises from an incident on 09.11.2017 in which, while serving as a Hindi language teacher, the petitioner allegedly assaulted a Class-X student during the National Anthem, dragging him by the shirt and forcing him into a corner. The offences charged include IPC sections 323 (voluntarily causing hurt) and 341 (wrongful restraint), and section 75 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015. The defacto complainant’s father is arrayed as the additional 2nd respondent. The petitioner’s counsel submits there is no injury as per Annexure A3, and the material does not establish ‘hurt’ under Section 319 and ‘voluntarily causing hurt’ under Section 321, nor does it support wrongful restraint under Section 339/341. He also relies on Rajan @ Raju v. Sub Inspector of Police, Feroke, to argue that actions taken purely for enforcing discipline with a reasonable degree of force fall outside the penal provisions. The State and 2nd respondent contend the merits are questions of evidence and cannot be decided in a Section 482 Cr.P.C. petition. The High Court, guided by the cited precedent and the lack of substantiating material, allows the petition and quashes the continued proceedings in Crime No.1437/2017 (CC 710/2017).
BAIL APPL. NO. 5642 OF 2024 JAMALUDHEEN P B, the petitioner-accused, seeks pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC in Crime No. 246/2024 of Beypore Police Station, Kozhikode, for alleged offences under IPC 354A(1)(i) and 354A(1)(iv) and POCSO Act, sections 9(m) read with 10 and 11(i) read with 12. The prosecution alleges that on 12 May 2024, around 20:45 hours, the accused trespassed into the victim’s apartment and, with one accused wearing black glasses, groped the victim’s breasts, while the defacto complainant (the victim’s mother) was present, amounting to outraging modesty and related offences. The petitioner contends the case is false and shows falsity in the FIR; he highlights that on the same date, another crime (No. 201/2024) was registered on closely related facts against the same set of accused, and that the Sessions Court had already granted pre-arrest bail to some co-accused in that case, suggesting malafide or frivolity. The defense argues that the two complaints contain contradictory statements, implying frivolity and a possible vendetta; custodial interrogation is unnecessary; the petitioner should receive parity with others who obtained bail. Relying on established bail principles (including the possibility of ignominy if arrested and the need to scrutinize frivolity), the court grants pre-arrest bail subject to conditions. The order emphasizes careful judicial evaluation and cooperation with investigation.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case (CRL.MC No. 1874 of 2022) arising from a private dispute that culminated in a criminal investigation. Accused Thushar and Prasanth challenge the order/judgment in SC 524/2021 of the District Court & Sessions Court, Thodupuzha, seeking quashing of further proceedings in Crime No. 105/2020 of Peerumade Police Station, Idukki District. The offences alleged include sections 307, 324, 323, 294(b), and 34 IPC. The prosecution alleges that on 02.03.2020 at around 2 p.m., the petitioners assaulted the de facto complainant with a helmet, causing injuries and allegedly intending to murder him. The FIR (Annexure 1) and chargesheet (Annexure 2) are part of the record. The petition relies on a settlement between the parties, supported by Annexure A3 sworn by the injured party, asserting no subsisting grievance and no objection to quashing. SHO verification and the Public Prosecutor’s confirmation reinforce the settlement’s veracity. The High Court notes the dispute is private in nature and that continued proceedings would serve little purpose, especially since the injuries appear minor, no weapon was used, and there is no clear premeditation for murder. Relying on the guidelines in Gian Singh and Laxmi Narayan, the court holds that the 482 Cr.P.C. power may be exercised to quash; the final report and SC 524/2021 proceedings are therefore quashed.
OP(KAT) NO. 188 OF 2018 & OP(KAT) NO. 189 OF 2018 These are two Original Petitions (OP(KAT) Nos. 188/2018 and 189/2018) challenging Kerala Administrative Tribunal orders in OA Nos. 2122/2015 and 2226/2015. The core grievance is that pensioners who retired as Additional Director of Health Services (ADHS) before 1 July 2009 were not extended the pay-revision benefits accorded to in-service employees, allegedly resulting in two classes of pensioners. The Government had, after the 9th Pay Revision, issued orders in 2011 revising pay and allowances and, in adherence to OROP principles, directed that pension fixation would ensure that, for pensioners with 30+ years of service, the consolidated pension would not be lower than 50% of the revised minimum pay. The Tribunal found merit in the petitioners’ contention that the special allowances merged with basic pay effectively altered the minimum of the pay scale, raising the entry pay for ADHS to ₹50,840 and extending corresponding pension benefits. The State contends that merging allowances was a one-time relief for serving officers and did not alter the pay scales; no benefit accrues to those already retired. The High Court, however, sets aside the Tribunal’s orders, holding that pay scale fixation is an executive function and distinguishing the Akkara precedent, while endorsing the principle that pension fixation cannot be mechanically equated with pay-scale revisions. Ultimately, the petitions are allowed and the Tribunal’s orders are overturned.
ITA Nos. 247/2019, 255/2019, 259/2019, 256/2019, 260/2019, 258/2019, 10/2020, 3/2020, 13/2020, 4/2020, 8/2020, 11/2020, 12/2020, 16/2020 This batch judgment from the High Court of Kerala (Division Bench) consolidates ITA Nos. 247/2019, 255/2019, 259/2019, 256/2019, 260/2019, 258/2019, 10/2020, 3/2020, 13/2020, 4/2020, 8/2020, 11/2020, 12/2020, 16/2020, all arising from Hillwood group entities challenging block assessments under the Income‑tax Act in the wake of searches conducted on 04 December 2013 and a subsequent 133A survey on 14 July 2014 at Riyaz’s residence. Documents seized, including three pen drives, and a Hash Value Report generated in July 2014, were relied upon by the Revenue to determine suppressed turnover and income. The Tribunal dismissed the appeals, and the assessees sought relief by contending (i) the Section 133A survey at a residence was impermissible, (ii) the admissibility and scope of raising additional grounds and evidence under Sections 65A/65B and Rule 29, and (iii) the authenticity and admissibility of data from pen drives and the Hash Value Report. The Kerala High Court, after analyzing the circumstances, held that the Tribunal did not err in admitting the additional grounds and that the survey at Riyaz’s residence fell within the statutory Explanation to 133A. It answered the substantial questions against the assessees and dismissed the batch appeals with no costs.