Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 435 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.MCNO.4427OF2023

Kiran v. State of Kerala and Others

The petitioner, Kiran, is the sole accused in CC 1779 of 2017 pending before the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Iringalakkuda. He faces offences under sections 341, 323, 324, 294 and 506 IPC arising from a 19 July 2017 incident in which he allegedly restrained the complainants, assaulted them with a key, and caused injuries. The petitioner seeks invocation of the inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC to quash the proceedings on the basis that the parties have amicably settled their disputes, supported by affidavits from respondents 2 and 3. The investigating officer was directed to verify the genuineness of the settlement and to ascertain whether the petitioner has any criminal antecedents or other impediments to termination of proceedings. The Public Prosecutor initially voiced reservations about quashing solely on settlement, but acknowledged that there are no other transgressions against the petitioner and that the respondents have expressed no enduring grievances. Relying on Supreme Court jurisprudence summarized by State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and other authorities, the High Court held that the inherent power under Section 482 CrPC can quash non‑compoundable offences in private disputes where the parties have settled and the offence is not heinous or of a public‑order nature. Having considered the gravity of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and the settlement, the court allowed the petition and quashed Annexure-2 Final Report and all further proceedings in CC 1779/2017.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 660 of 2014

W.P.(C) 660/2014

The petition challenges communications/orders (P14, P16, P19, P20) seeking recovery of salary amounts paid to the petitioner as Higher Grade during her tenure as Confidential Assistant (Senior Grade) in the Judicial First Class Magistrate’s Court, Kochi. The petitioner, who retired on 31.10.2013, had risen from Grade-II to Grade-I and Senior Grade through various orders, with a transfer from Cheranallur/Chenganur to Ernakulam in 2000. Audit objections later found the grade promotion to be erroneous, and the District Judge, Ernakulam, and the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate (Economic Offences), Ernakulam, concluded that inter-district transfers caused the petitioner to lose seniority and pay fixation benefits. The petitioner contends there can be no loss of seniority on a state-wide basis due to inter-district transfer and that she is entitled to retain her seniority if not misrepresented, arguing that recovery of amounts already paid is unjust, especially after retirement. She relies on judgments including Thomas Daniel v. State of Kerala and Others (2022 KHC 6489), Vinod Kumar C.R. (2020 KHC 468), and others that recovery where there is no misrepresentation is often disallowed. The High Court’s subsequent reasoning emphasizes equity, hardship, and the absence of fraud, ultimately allowing the writ petition, quashing the impugned orders, and directing payment of remaining retirement benefits within two months, while gratuity already released remains unaffected.

High Court of Kerala
MACA 1568-2012

Saidalavi and Arifa v. Mohammedali, Shamsudheen and The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

This High Court of Kerala heard MACA 1568 of 2012 filed by Saidalavi and Arifa against Mohammedali, Shamsudheen and The New India Assurance Co. Ltd. challenging the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Manjeri’s award in OP (MV) No. 334/2009 following the death of eight-year-old Ashiq Suhail on 16.10.2008 after an auto-rickshaw collision in Tirurangadi. The Tribunal granted Rs. 1,13,156 as compensation with liability primarily on the insurer as indemnifier. The appellants argued that the amount was inadequate and that the notional income of a minor should be fixed higher, referencing Kurvan Ansari and Kishan Gopal to fix the notional income at Rs.30,000 and multiplier 15. They also invoked conventional heads of compensation, following Pranay Sethi and subsequent Supreme Court decisions, for escalation, funeral expenses, loss of estate and loss of consortium. The respondents did not contest liability of the driver; however, the insurer defended the deficiency of compensation. The High Court, after considering the cited precedents, augmented the dependency loss to Rs.4,50,000 and held Rs.1,21,000 under conventional heads (funeral expenses, loss of estate, and loss of consortium), totaling Rs.5,71,000. It directed the insurer to deposit Rs.4,57,844 with interest within 60 days, to be disbursed to the appellants in equal shares, thereby allowing the appeal and refining the application of Kurvan Ansari/Kishan Gopal doctrine and Pranay Sethi-based escalation.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.343 of 2022

WA No.343 of 2022: T.A. Jayakumar and Others v. Kerala State Centre for Advanced Printing and Training Centre (C-APT) and State of Kerala

This writ appeal arises from a 2018 writ petition challenging the termination/retrenchment of a large cadre of employees at the Kerala State Centre for Advanced Printing and Training (C-APT), formerly the Kerala State Audio Visual and Reprographic Centre. The petitioners, 18 in number, were initially appointed in 2001 as helpers and were subsequently terminated in 2002 by Ext.P3, part of a larger retrenchment of around 433 employees. The High Court, in Ext.P4 (2002) Extinguishments, held that Ext.P3 and related termination orders were null and void, deeming the petitioners to be in service with consequential benefits, while permitting the Centre to retrench excess staff following due process. Following Ext.P4, retrenchment affected about 430 employees, but petitioners were not absorbed despite vacancies arising between 2002 and 2018. In 2017-2018, the petitioners sought re-employment, alleging promises of preferential re-employment in order of seniority; they relied on Ext.P8 (and the line of Shaji Michael) to contend that retrenchment must be reversed and re-engagement must occur in vacancies. The 1st respondent cited financial losses and a three-member committee’s report recommending staff reduction. The learned Single Judge dismissed the petition; this appeal contends that the termination and non-re-engagement violate the prior Court’s direction and seniority-based promises. The appeal seeks mandamus-like relief to re-employ in existing vacancies and to ensure compliance with the Industrial Disputes Act provisions.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4675 OF 2023

Manaf.K, Thahir.C.C, Saifudheen Hamsa.M.K v. Ahammed Rasheek.K.M and State of Kerala

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 4675/2023) is heard by the Kerala High Court as an application under Section 482 CrPC to quash CC No.1547/2022 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Payyannur, arising from Pazhayangadi Police Station Crime No.589/2022. The three petitioners—Manaf.K, Thahir.C.C, and Saifudheen Hamsa.M.K—are charged with offences under IPC 341, 323, and 324 read with Section 34. The prosecution alleges wrongful confinement and assault. The petitioners contend that the parties have amicably settled their dispute and request quashing of the proceedings, supported by the victim’s affidavit indicating consent to quash. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but conceded that a settlement exists. The court, after examining submissions and records, relies on Supreme Court precedent beginning with State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan (2019) 5 SCC 688, and on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab (2014) to delineate the scope of Section 482 powers. The learned judges hold that quashing is permissible in non‑compoundable, private‑nature offences where the dispute has been resolved and public interest is not adversely affected, with exceptions for heinous or public‑interest offences (e.g., murder, rape, dacoity, IPC 307, Arms Act, or offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act). The court also notes the need to consider the accused’s antecedents and conduct. Finding the dispute private and settled, the court allows the petition and quashes CC No.1547/2022 and related proceedings. The order is by Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 1109 of 2012

Gopalakrishnan v. Sandosh, Rajesh N and The New India Assurance Company Limited

This High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam heard MACA No. 1109 of 2012 challenging the award dated 25.10.2011 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode in O.P(M.V.) No.1724/2010. The appellant, Gopalakrishnan V, sustained serious injuries in a motor accident on 13.07.2009 when a motorcycle bearing KL-11-U-9922 knocked him down at Ramanattukara as he walked on a public road. He was treated at PVS Hospital, Kozhikode, and later at Baby Memorial Hospital, Kozhikode. The Tribunal held the rider liable for rash and negligent driving and directed the insurer (The New India Assurance Company Limited) to indemnify the first respondent. It awarded Rs.1,53,452/- as compensation with 7% interest and costs. The petitioner argued that the Tribunal erred in fixing a monthly income of Rs.3,000 and in considering only a three‑month loss of earnings, in addition to seeking recognition of disability. Medical evidence later assessed 45% permanent disability. The respondents contended negligence by the claimant and that the compensation sought was excessive, and that evidence did not establish the claimed income. The High Court reassessed using Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance, (2011) 13 SCC 236 to fix Rs.7,000 monthly income and extended loss of earnings to six months, recalculating various heads of compensation. The Court held total compensation at Rs.6,33,602, including Rs.4,80,150 as additional compensation with 7.5% interest, directing deposit by the insurer and noting excess court fee implications. MACA stands allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 2027 OF 2014; CRL.REV.PET NO. 2035 OF 2014

Ansar Abdul Azeez v. State of Kerala and Others

Ansar Abdul Azeez, the third accused in C.C. No. 107/2012 of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram, challenged orders framing charges under IPC sections 354, 506, 384 read with 34, and IT Act section 66E. The revision petitions (CRL.R.P. Nos. 2027/2014 and 2035/2014) were heard together. The prosecution alleges that on 22 May 2010 the accused, with others, outraged the modesty of the de facto complainant inside her house and later in a toilet, threatened to publish nude photographs and extort money. The petitioner previously sought discharge and relied on his passport showing he had left India from 22.4.2010 to 29.5.2012, arguing non-presence on the date. The trial court refused to go into the merits at discharge, citing State of Orissa v. Debendra Nath Padhi (2005(1) KLT 80) that materials produced by the accused cannot be examined at discharge; it then framed charges. The petitioner invoked 482 CrPC to quash. He relied on Rajiv Thapar v. Madan Lal Kapoor (2013 KHC 4066), stating that where material produced by the accused could persuade a reasonable person to discard the prosecution's case, the High Court may quash. The Kerala High Court agreed that such material could justify quashing, and held that the passport evidence would negate the prosecution’s case. Accordingly, it quashed the proceedings; the petitions were disposed of.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1050 OF 2012

Chenthama ra S/O Vel ayudhan v United India Insurance Co Ltd and others

Chenthama ra S/O Vel ayudhan v United India Insurance Co Ltd (MACA No. 1050 of 2012) is a Kerala High Court appeal under Section 173 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, against a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Palakkad award dated 25 November 2011 in OPMV 376/2008. The appellant sustained multiple injuries in a motorcycle accident on 12 December 2007 (bike TN 41J/223) and claimed Rs 6,00,000 from respondents 1–3. The Tribunal, which held respondents 1 and 2 ex parte, awarded Rs 3,48,100 with interest at 7.5% per annum. The third respondent insurer contested the outcome. The appellant’s counsel urged reassessment of compensation, particularly the monthly income; the court invoked Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. to justify fixing monthly income at Rs 3,500 for loss of earnings and disability calculation (20% disability). The High Court re-calculated: loss of earnings for six months at Rs 3,500 per month (Rs 21,000), i.e., Rs 12,000 more than the Tribunal’s figure of Rs 9,000; disability income revised to Rs 1,26,000 (3,500 x 12 x 15 x 20/100), Rs 18,000 more than the Tribunal’s Rs 1,08,000. Pain and suffering increased by Rs 15,000 and loss of amenities by Rs 15,000; extra nourishment by Rs 5,000. The appeal is allowed in part, awarding Rs 4,13,100 in total (Rs 3,48,100 already awarded plus Rs 65,000 enhanced). The Insurance Company is directed to deposit the enhanced amount within two months, with the Tribunal’s rate of interest, excluding 80 days’ delay, as per the order allowing the delay petition.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 29471 OF 2022

Muhammed Haroon P.P v. Kerala State Electricity Board Limited & Ors.

Petitioner Muhammed Haroon P.P., proprietor of M/s Prestige Polymers in Kozhikode, challenges the Kerala State Electricity Board’s demand raised on account of an incorrect multiplication factor used to compute energy charges. The establishment’s meter CT ratio was 200/5, implying a multiplication factor (MF) of 40, but the billing used MF 20. On 8 October 2020, a site inspection found the meter functioning properly with no tampering; however, the MF had been wrongly recorded. The petitioner protested the demand; RTI responses revealed that the CT ratio should have been 100/5 rather than 200/5, indicating an anomaly attributable to the licensee. The Consumer Grievance Redressal Forum (CGRF) Northern Region upheld the demand; the Electricity Ombudsman dismissed the appeal. The petitioner submits that Regulation 113 places the responsibility for meter accuracy on the licensee; Regulation 152 empowers the licensee to cure anomalies detected at the consumer’s premises but does not change the purpose of use; Regulation 109 imposes the licensee’s duty to install proper meters; and Section 56 of the Electricity Act, 2003 imposes a two-year limitation on recovery. The respondent argues that changing CT ratio would not alter actual consumption and relies on Regulation 152 and Section 56A to realize the shortfall, citing Prem Cottex v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. (Civil Appeal No. 7235 of 2009) to distinguish Ajmer. The High Court partially allows the petition, modifying the Ombudsman order to cap the demand at 12 months under Regulation 152’s proviso, while upholding the rest of the order, directing a revised bill within 15 days and deposit within 15 days.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 13447 OF 2022

New India Assurance Company Limited v. Rajesh R., Shini S.R., and Hon'ble Permanent Lok Adalat

This writ petition challenges the order of the Permanent Lok Adalat, Thiruvananthapuram, in O.P. No. 42 of 2020 under Section 22C of the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987. The petitioner, New India Assurance Company Limited, insurer of motorcycle KL 74 A 2259, contends that the extra premium of Rs.320 paid for personal accident (PA) cover for the owner-driver must bind liability; in the accident on 04.02.2020, Adarsh, son of respondents, allegedly driven the vehicle but was not the owner-driver, making him a third party under the policy. The insurer argues the 22C petition cannot be maintained against the owner and driver and relies on judgments like National Insurance Company Ltd. v. Ranjana (2020 ACJ 1185) and United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Master Arun P. Nair; they contend the premium was paid for PA of owner-driver and cannot be extended to cover a borrower. The respondents’ counsel contends that Section 163A claims are against the owner/driver of the offending vehicle and that the PA cover should include the borrower; they invoke Ramkhiladi v. United India Insurance Co. (2020 ACJ 627). The High Court ultimately relies on Ningamma (2009 ACJ 2020 SC) to hold that a 163A claim cannot be maintained against the owner/insurer of a borrowed vehicle; Dhanraj (SC) is cited to emphasize policy coverage limits. The petition is dismissed; the Lok Adalat award of Rs. 15,00,000 remains intact as per the contract terms.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No.251 of 2021

RSA No.251 of 2021

This Regular Second Appeal arises before the Kerala High Court challenging a Subordinate Judge’s decree in a suit for declaration of title, recovery of possession and permanent injunction in respect of plaint A schedule (a building) and plaint B schedule (the building described within the A schedule) in Neyyattinkara. The plaintiffs traced title to plaint A schedule through sale deed No.943/1978 to the mother of the first plaintiff, with the B schedule building forming part of A schedule. The defendants (1 & 2) claimed uninterrupted possession since 1983 and invoked adverse possession, asserting the suit was barred by res judicata in light of O.S.859/1983 and a later counter claim decree, while contending a long possession and open enjoyment of 4 cents of property. The trial court held that the counter claim in O.S.859/1983 was dismissed on technical grounds and did not operate as res judicata, and that the suit was not time-barred; it decreed title and possession in favor of the plaintiffs. The first appellate court initially held res judicata to bar the suit, but on remand (RSA346/2008) allowed amendments to describe B schedule as building within A schedule, leading to further proceedings. The High Court examines (i) whether IA 1/2020 amended the B schedule beyond remand scope or prejudiced the appellants; (ii) whether the suit is barred by res judicata; (iii) whether exclusion of time during pendency of prior suit affects limitation; and (iv) the adverse possession claim. It ultimately confirms the trial court’s findings and dismisses the appeal for lack of merit.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A. No. 2455 of 2008

Lohithakshan @ Gopi v. State of Kerala

Aggrieved by the judgment dated 25.09.2008 convicting the appellant under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act, the accused challenges an order of conviction and sentence by the Fast Track (Adhoc-I) Court, Kozhikode. The prosecution alleged possession of 35 litres of illicit arrack recovered on 05.04.2005 from the kitchen slab of the accused’s residence at Thamarassery, Kozhikode. The trial court convicted after analyzing the seizure and evidence; this High Court appeal tests whether the prosecution proved possession and a proper chain of custody linking the seized contraband to the accused and the sample tested in the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory. The appellant argues lack of proof of actual possession, noting the residence housed multiple occupants and Ext P3 shows a different building number; he contends absence of evidence that the contraband was subjected to reliable analysis. The State contends that possession may be shown by dominion or control and that the materials placed before the court—including seizure (Exts P1–P2) and chemical analysis—sustain conviction. The High Court canvasses the legal meaning of possession under the Abkari Act, citing authorities on dominion, constructive possession, chain of custody, and the tamper-proof requirement. Finding a missing link between the accused and the contraband and flaws in the sampling chain, the court acquits and allows the appeal, setting aside the conviction and sentence.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C). Nos. 20081 of 2021 & 20807 of 2021

W.P.(C). Nos. 20081 of 2021 & 20807 of 2021, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This is a consolidated two‑petition challenge before the Kerala High Court arising from the renewal/non‑renewal of a trade/quarry license under the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act. The petitioners, including landowners and the quarry operator, challenged the Manakkad Grama Panchayat’s 2021 decisions denying renewal of a trade licence for quarry operations and sought a deemed licence under Section 236(3) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994. The petitions threaded through a web of licenses and clearances (environmental clearance Ext. P2, Integrated Consent to Operate Ext. P4, Explosive Licence Ext. P3, lease agreements Ext. P7, and renewal letters Ext. P11/P15), and questioned the Panchayat’s insistence on additional documents (possession certificates, owner IDs) as a precondition for renewal. The court appointed an Advocate Commissioner to inspect benching and other quarrying aspects. It ultimately held that the 20807 petition is entitled to a deemed licence for 2021‑22 under Section 236(3) and directed issue of a paper licence, while Exts. P17/P18 were set aside. The 20081 petition was disposed, with permission for the petitioners to approach the Geologist for redressal of lease‑condition violations, clarifying that the Court would not adjudicate lease violations itself. The judgment navigates the interplay of statutory timelines, documentary requirements, and regulatory approvals in the context of local self‑government licensing authority.

High Court of Kerala
DBP No.53 of 2022

Guruvayoor Devaswom - Guruvayur Sree Krishna Temple - Suo Motu Petition (DBP No. 53 of 2022)

This High Court of Kerala, sitting in a suo motu Devaswom Board petition (DBP No. 53 of 2022), initiated on the basis of a news report in Mathrubhumi dated 31 August 2022 about a motorcycle entering the Nadapanthal area of the Guruvayur Sree Krishna Temple, considers security protocols in the temple precincts. On 1 September 2022, the court suo motu impleaded the Assistant Commissioner of Police as additional 7th respondent and directed reports from the temple administration and security authorities in sealed covers, emphasizing adherence to directions in a prior case (Suo Motu v. Guruvayur Devaswom Managing Committee and others). The court noted that the accused rode into the temple premises late in the evening in a rash and negligent manner, based on police and security reports, and that Nadapanthal entry by vehicles adversely affects worshippers, especially vulnerable groups. The court reaffirmed a earlier principle from the cited SCC OnLine Ker. 336 decision that worshippers must worship in an accustomed manner and Nadapanthal is not for vehicle movement; it permitted restricted vehicle entries only for disabled persons, essential supplies, and emergencies. It directed periodic joint security reviews and emphasized vigilance by Guruvayur Devaswom staff, while recording recommended disciplinary action for security lapses. The petition is disposed of with the stated directions and sealed reports to be kept in judge’s papers.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.Appeal No.937/2022

Abbas R.V. v. State of Kerala & MallI (Defacto Complainant)

This appeal challenges the order of the Special Court for SC/ST (POA) Act, 1989, Mannarkkad, in which anticipatory bail was refused to the first accused (Abbas R.V.) under sections of the SC/ST Act and IPC. The accused allegedly trespassed into the defacto complainant’s house and threatened her in relation to the ongoing Madhu murder trial before the Special Court, purportedly because the complainant belongs to the Scheduled Tribe. The High Court of Kerala/Special Court relied on Sections 18 and 18-A SC/ST Act to deny anticipatory bail, holding that prima facie offences under SC/ST Act were made out (including Section 3(2)(va)) and that knowledge of caste could be inferred from the materials. The appellant contends that anticipatory bail should be available unless a prima facie case is made out, and argues the allegations are false. The respondents counter that the SC/ST Act explicitly bars anticipatory bail and that Section 18 and 18-A apply; they emphasize the protection granted to SC/ST persons, the severity of the offences, and the need for custodial investigation given witness intimidation. The court reviews jurisprudence, including Vilas Pandurang Pawar, Shakuntla Devi, Subhash Mahajan, and Prathvi Raj Chauhan, to reaffirm the bar on anticipatory bail where offences under the SC/ST Act are implicated and concludes that the present case falls within that bar, thereby upholding the dismissal of the bail plea and dismissing the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.17236 OF 2023

Union Bank of India v. Sub Registrar Office Alangad Sub Registry; Tahsildar Paravur Taluk Office; Village Officer Kadungallur; Deputy Commissioner (WCT & LT), Commercial Taxes Department; Regional Transport Officer, Ernakulam; and Others

This writ petition by Union Bank of India (Asset Recovery Branch) arises from the bank's attempt to register sale certificates issued under the SARFAESI Act in respect of a property mortgaged in 2007. After the borrower defaulted, the bank sold the mortgaged assets to Respondents 6 and 7 through extant sale certificates. When the purchasers sought registration, the Sub Registrar refused, citing attachments from civil courts and revenue recovery proceedings over the mortgaged properties. The bank contends that these attachments/post-mortgage entries arose after the equitable mortgage and thus cannot bar registration; it relies on Exts. P5–P8 and Ext. P6 (OS 663/2017) to show that the attachments were subsequent to the mortgage and should be effaced from the encumbrance register, or otherwise would render the title unmarketable. The petitioner invokes Madhan S. v. Sub Registrar, Kollam, and Keechery Service Co‑operative Bank Ltd. v. Sajitha Nizar to argue that post‑mortgage attachments do not affect the sale under SARFAESI and must be erased; this view was affirmed by Ali Asharaf M.M. and others. The court agrees, holding that post‑mortgage attachments under Civil Courts and statutory charges under KVAT/MVAT Acts are to be effaced for registration and mutation, directing the 1st respondent to efface such entries and to register Exts. P2 and P3 in favour of Respondents 6 and 7. The petition is disposed with a two‑month window for the needful actions from receipt of the judgment copy.

High Court of Kerala
W.P. (C) No.17521 of 2023

SABU M JACOB v Union of India and Others

A Public Interest Litigation under Article 226 of the Constitution challenges Ext.P1 issued by the Tamil Nadu Chief Wildlife Warden to tranquilize, capture, and translocate the wild tusker Arikomban. Petitioner Sabu M. Jacob, claiming to represent the Twenty-20 Association and a political party, contends that the process must comply with the Wildlife (Protection) Act, 1972 and its rules, ensuring minimum trauma to the animal, and that alternatives should be explored that separate the animal from human settlements. The petition follows prior PILs in which the Kerala High Court had, in 2021–2023, directed an Expert Committee and considered translocation options, including shifting Arikomban to Parambikulam Tiger Reserve and subsequently to Periyar Tiger Reserve, Kerala, with subsequent events after the elephant’s entry into Tamil Nadu. The Court scrutinizes whether prayers I–III are maintainable, and whether Ext.P1 is within the statutory framework. It notes that Ext.P1 directs capture and translocation within Tamil Nadu rather than Kerala, and emphasizes Sec.11 and related provisions, including Sec.40(2) and Sec.48A, and Tamil Nadu Captive Elephant Rules 2011. The Bench ultimately holds that Ext.P1 is intravires, that prayer I–III lack a prima facie case, and dismisses the petition with no costs, while leaving open scope for redress in the Madras High Court if warranted.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.1177 of 2021; WA No.1068 of 2021

WA Nos. 1177 of 2021 & 1068 of 2021 (Employees' State Insurance Corporation v. Smitha Rajendran & Kit English High School Kareelakulangara)

This common judgment of a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court disposes of two writ appeals arising from claims under the Employees' State Insurance Act (ESI Act) for super specialty medical benefits (SST) in the context of renal transplantation and related treatment. The ESIC challenged an earlier Single Judge order which held that the petitioner (the employee) and her husband were entitled to SST despite the employer’s non-payment of ESI contributions during the relevant periods, emphasizing that the ESI Act provides medical benefits to insured persons and their dependants, and that the ESIC has powers to recover contributions from employers (via Sections 45B–H and 45G, including garnishee proceedings, and Section 68). The appellant argued that eligibility criteria for SST for dependents — including the 156-days contribution requirement and the need for insurable employment — were derived from an Office Memorandum dated 29.10.2018, subsequently enacted in Regulation 96C, and that non-payment by the employer should not automatically deprive the insured of SST; the respondents urged immediate disbursement given urgent medical needs. The court observed that despite reliance on the Delhi High Court’s Baby Devananda decision and the 2018 OM, the authorities subsequently issued a regulatory amendment (Regulation 96C) and a voluntary directive (Ext.P7). It modified the impugned judgment and disposed of the appeals, noting that the ESIC had already paid sums to the hospital, and left certain issues (notably Regulation 96C) to be decided in pending proceedings (WP(C) No.14506/2021). The two appeals are thus disposed of with directions that the main issues shall be resolved in due course under the pending matter.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 9112 OF 2023

Criminal Misc. Case No. 9112 of 2023 (Crl.M.C. 9112/2023)

This Kerala High Court judgment under Section 482 CrPC concerns seven accused petitioners challenging proceedings in SC No. 620/2018 arising from Crime No. 1543/2014 of Kattakada Police Station. The accused were charged with offences including 143, 147, 148, 323, 324, 308 and 427 read with 149 IPC. The petition contends that the dispute between the accused and informant is private and has been resolved through affidavits, with the victims expressing no objection to quashing the prosecution. The Public Prosecutor, while acknowledging the settlement, raised concerns about quashing solely on the basis of compromise. The court examined the matter in light of binding authority, notably State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) and the earlier decisions Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, which hold that the powers under S.482 CrPC can quash non-compoundable offences where the dispute is private, the parties have resolved it, and the offences are not heinous. After a careful review, the court found the dispute private and settled, and held that quashing would serve both private justice and public interest. Consequently, the criminal misc. case is allowed and all further proceedings in SC 620/2018 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
ITA No. 37 of 2020

The Plantation Corporation of Kerala Ltd v Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax Circle 1; Commissioner of Income Tax

This ITA relates to Assessment Year 2014-15 and concerns the deduction claimed by The Plantation Corporation of Kerala Ltd under Rule 7A(2) of the Income Tax Rules, 1962 for replantation expenses and the upkeep/maintenance expenses of rubber saplings till maturity. The Assessing Officer disallowed both claims; the appellant assailed this before the first appellate authority and the Tribunal, which followed a Division Bench decision in Rehabilitation Plantations Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax. A Full Bench of this Court referred extensive questions on whether replantation allowances under Rule 7A(2) are admissible in the computation of business income, and whether upkeep and maintenance expenses till maturity fall under revenue deductions (Section 37) as opposed to capital expenditure. The Full Bench answered that, subject to conditions, the assessee is entitled to deduction for the replacement of dead/unproductive rubber trees in a non-abandoned area under Rule 7A(2), with due regard to Section 10(31) of the Act, 1961; and that upkeep/maintenance expenses until maturity are revenue expenditures deductible under Section 37 of the Act, 1961. The Court remitted the matter to the Assessing Officer for fresh assessment, holding i, ii, and iv in favor of the assessee; iii also favored the assessee, while vii and viii favored the Revenue. The appeal is allowed for statistical purposes and remitted to the AO for disposal in accordance with law.