The petitioner, P.R. Vijayakumar, holder of a Letter of Intent for extraction of 0.9907 hectares in Re-Survey No.53/2 of Venganellur Village, Thalappilly Taluk, Thrissur District, challenges Environmental Clearance condition 3(3). The condition stipulates that since the quarry lies within 10 km of the Peechi-Vazhani Wildlife Sanctuary, clearance from the Standing Committee of the National Board for Wildlife (SCNBWL) is mandatory before starting any activity. Ext.P2 (the Environmental Clearance) imposes this condition; Ext.P3 and Ext.P4 are MoEF&CC OM and a draft ESZ notification. The petitioner argues that Ext.P4 draft notification prescribing Eco Sensitive Areas and Ext.P3 OM dated 08.08.2019 limit SCNBWL clearance to specific circumstances (notably mining within ESZ or within 1 km of sanctuaries) and that the 2019 OM allows development outside the ESZ to proceed without SCNBWL clearance, especially since Peechi-Vazhani is 4.8 km away and the ESZ buffer is 4.5 km. The respondents contend that the EIA Notification, OM 2019, and ESZ guidelines require wildlife clearance for mining within 10 km of sanctuaries. The High Court, applying the Supreme Court's Godavarman line of directions and Goa Foundation rulings, holds that where ESZ or wider buffers are proposed, the ESZ order prevails and that mining activities beyond 1 km may proceed with regulatory oversight. Accordingly, the petition is allowed to the extent of quashing Ext.P2’s General Condition 3(3) and directing the authorities to process the mining lease without mandatory SCNBWL clearance, on the facts here.
This appeal arises from a partition suit (O.S. No. 710 of 2011) filed in the Kollam Munsiff Court, which was dismissed on the ground that Ext. A2 (a settlement deed) beneficiary was not made a party, and no challenge to Ext. B1 (Will) was raised by way of replication or amendment. In appeal, the First Appellate Court set aside the trial court’s decree, admitted an amendment to plead challenge to the due execution of Ext. B1 Will, and remanded to the trial court for consideration of the Will’s genuineness, including examination of attesting witnesses. The defendant/appellant criticizes the remand as improper, arguing that a replication is only required in response to a counter-claim or set-off under Order VIII CPC and that no separate replication was necessary since the plaint adequately pleads and controverts the Will. The judgment analyzes the distinction between set-off and counter-claim (Rules 6, 6A–6G of Order VIII CPC), the role of Rule 1A, 5 and Rule 23, 23A, 24 of Order XL1 CPC, and the mischief rule under Order VIII Rule 10. It concludes that the remand Order is unsustainable, relying on Gopalakrishnan v. Ponnappan (2021) (5) KHC 548) and Bhairab Chandra Nandan v. Ranadhir (1988 KHC 883), and sets aside the remand. The appeal is allowed; no costs. The first appellate court will decide the appeal on the merits, addressing all issues. Parties are to appear on 05/12/2022.
This is a second appeal arising from a dispute over a common pathway (plaint C schedule nadavaramba) between plaint A schedule properties and plaint B schedule property of the Nangolath Tarwad in Kozhikode. The appellant-defendant, P.E. Bhaskara Kurup, challenges a decree that, after remand, found difficulty in establishing a 7-foot wide C schedule way and resulted in directions for demolition of a portion of the boundary wall based on Ext.C6. The original suit sought both a mandatory injunction to restore the C schedule way and a prohibitory injunction to prevent obstruction. The trial court’s decree was set aside by the first appellate court, which remanded for fresh disposal with directions to identify A and B schedules as per Exts.A1 and A2 (title deeds) and survey. On remand, the Commissioner and Surveyor produced Exts.C5 (report) and C6 (plan), but the trial court held that the C schedule way’s width and user rights were not proved; the appellate court, depending on Ext.C6, directed partial demolition of a boundary wall. The High Court ultimately held that the C schedule way is not owned outright by either party but is a shared pathway with mutual user, and that the crucial question is the width of the C schedule way. Exts.C5 and C6 do not identify the width as per the remand order, necessitating a fresh identification. The matter is remanded to the trial court for disposal de novo with a nine-month deadline focused solely on the width of the C schedule way, based on Ext.A1.
OP(WAKF) No. 19 of 2024 before the Kerala High Court challenges a Wakf Tribunal order dated 04.07.2024 appointing an interim Muthavally in the dispute concerning Thevalakkara Shareeful Islam Jama-ath. The matter stems from an AGM held on 11.05.2024 electing a 70-member Jama-ath Council and contemplated the election of a Chairman and Secretary, with contention over quorum requirements for those elections. The Tribunal found the quorum insufficient for the meetings convened and, as an interim measure, appointed a Muthavally to oversee day-to-day administration. The petitioners sought to restrain the new officers from acting and to enable the pre-11.05.2024 council to conduct affairs until resolution of the suit; they argued there was no mandatory quorum for the initial appointment of office bearers and that interim governance should be avoided. The respondents contended that bye-laws do not require a quorum for the initial appointment and urged that the matter be resolved through the Wakf Act’s revised remedy under Section 83(9) and the revisional powers of the High Court, while also citing Article 227 of the Constitution as a fallback. The High Court, applying principles from Surya Dev Rai, Radhey Shyam and Shalini Shyam Shetty, held that there is an alternative statutory remedy and limited supervisory interference; the interim order was a miscarriage of justice under the bye-laws, and the petition was allowed, setting aside the Tribunal’s order with scope for revision under law.
This motor accident claims appeal concerns the compensation awarded by the Addl. Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Ernakulam in OP(MV) No.1344/2018 for the death of Remani in a 21.4.2018 road traffic accident involving KSRTC bus KL-15/7317. The tribunal treated the deceased as a skilled worker and fixed her notional income at Rs.13,500 per month, with one-third deduction for personal and living expenses, and awarded various heads (loss of estate, transport to hospital, love and affection to the claimants 2 and 3, funeral expenses, and loss of dependency amounting to Rs.2,000,000). The total compensation was Rs.23,35,000, with Rs.15,46,800 paid. The insurer challenged the quantum, arguing that the notional income was unjustified and that compensation under the head of love and affection was granted in addition to loss of consortium, constituting dual benefits. The Kerala High Court partly allows the appeal: it refixes the deceased’s income at Rs.18,000 per month with 10% future prospects (Rs.19,800), recalculates loss of dependency to Rs.4,35,600, and deletes the Rs.80,000 awarded for love and affection, directing deposit of Rs.3,55,600 with 8% interest and awarding proportionate costs. The judgment cites Ramachandrappa, Birender, Shalumol, Angad Tiwari, Sanjay Kumar and Reliance General Insurance as guiding authorities, and emphasizes avoiding under-mining due process in fixing notional income under Order-XLI Rule-33 CPC and considering minimum wages and ground realities.
B.A. Nos.5656/2024; 5663/2024; 5666/2024; 5667/2024; 5670/2024; 5675/2024; 5679/2024; 5682/2024 This is a consolidated bail matter before the Kerala High Court, involving eight bail applications (B.A. Nos. 5656/2024, 5663/2024, 5666/2024, 5667/2024, 5670/2024, 5675/2024, 5679/2024, 5682/2024) filed by N.M. Raju and co-accused in several crimes registered at Thiruvalla Police Station under sections 406, 409 and 420 IPC, read with section 34 IPC, and section 4 of the BUDS Act, 2019. The petitioners contend innocence and false implication; they have been in judicial custody since May 7, 2024, and seek statutory bail under BNSS/CrPC provisions. The State argues serious economic offences and risk of witness tampering if released, noting multiple prior cases. The common order, delivered by Justice C.S. Dias, relies on CrPC Section 167(2) (as extended by 90/60-day provisions) and the BNSS framework to grant bail due to the indefeasible right to bail where investigation remains incomplete after extended custody. Citing Uday Mohanlal Acharya and Sanjay Dutt, the court holds the petitioners are entitled to compulsory bail. The order imposes standard conditions: bond of Rs. 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, appearance before the IO on alternate Saturdays, prohibition on tampering with witnesses or leaving the territorial jurisdiction, passport surrender where applicable, and the IO’s authority to pursue recoveries under Supreme Court guidance. The decision ultimately disposes of all eight petitions with bail granted subject to conditions.
Dr. Nakulan K.V., an Associate Professor (retired) of Urdu, challenges Exts. P6 and P13 which deny pensionary benefits for service rendered with Kendriya Vidyalaya Sangathan (KVS) from 03.01.1990 to 26.08.1997. The petitioner’s service record spans multiple institutions: starting as a Junior Lecturer at Government Brennen College (Thalassery) in 1989-1990, then as Primary Teacher with KVS Madras (1990-1997), followed by a Lecturer stint at Government College, Malappuram (1997-1998), and finally joining the University of Kerala as Lecturer in 1998 until superannuation on 31.05.2020. He argues that his continuous service across KVS and subsequent State/Autonomous appointments should be counted as qualifying service for pension. He previously moved W.P. No. 28836/2021, which the Court disposed of by Ext. P11 with liberty to approach competent authorities to determine scope vis‑à‑vis Central Autonomous Bodies/CPSUs. The respondents contend that Kerala rules, amended by GO(P) 53/2018/Fin and Rule 11 Part III KSR (amended 22.11.2010), restrict pensionary benefits to Central Government service and do not count prior CPSU/Autonomous‑body service with State service. The Court ultimately holds that the petitioner has no vested right to insist on counting KVS service and dismisses the writ petition, upholding the government’s position and Exts. P10 and P13.
BAIL APPL. NO. 6254 OF 2024 Nikhil Prakash, the first accused in Crime No.1424/2023 of North Paravur Police Station, Ernakulam, moves bail under Section 439 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The case relates to offences under Sections 8, 22(c), and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, for allegedly transporting 1.824 kg of MDMA (later indicated as methamphetamine per chemical analysis) and storing it in a rented house of the 4th accused. The prosecution alleges a hatched conspiracy to transport contraband to Kerala for sale, with the petitioner as a participant though he contends he was only a passenger in the car from which the drugs were seized. Annexure A4 shows that the 4th accused was enlarged on bail after a prima facie finding of infraction of Section 52A and NDPS Rules 2022, with the petitioner seeking parity with the 4th accused. The learned Public Prosecutor opposed bail, citing commercial quantity and the rigour under Section 37. The court scrutinized the 52A procedure and found the Investigating Officer had mixed contents from multiple packets and produced a single packet before the Magistrate, contrary to law. Relying on jurisprudence emphasizing fair trial and strict adherence to sampling/inventory procedures, the court concluded the petitioner, having no criminal antecedents, has reasonable grounds to believe he is not guilty and not likely to commit an offence while on bail, and allowed the application with conditions.
This criminal miscellaneous case concerns a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. filed by Anish Aravind, Usha B, and Aravindakshan K challenging the continuation of proceedings in Crime No.720/2023 of Sreekandapuram Police Station, Kannur (C.C. No.2882/2023, JFMC Taliparamba) for alleged offences under Section 498A IPC. The defacto complainant Namitha K. opposes the quashment; however, she submits that a settlement has been reached through mediation, she has received monetary settlement and ornaments, and she has filed for divorce; she now has no continuing grievance and does not wish to prosecute. The court recorded the defacto complainant’s statement and considered Annexure-A5 (affidavit) showing a genuine, bonafide settlement. Relying on the principles laid down in B.S. Joshi v. State of Haryana and Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, as well as the earlier State of Karnataka v. L. Muniswamy, the High Court held that where the offences are non‑compoundable but a settlement exists and there is no reasonable likelihood of conviction, quashing the proceedings serves the ends of justice and does not amount to abuse of process. Accordingly, the criminal miscellaneous case is allowed and Annexure-A1 to Annexure-A5 are quashed, bringing the proceedings to an end.
TR.P.(C) 447/2021; Tr.P.(Crl.) 67/2021; Tr.P.(Crl.) 68/2021 This common order of the Kerala High Court, dated 19 July 2022, disposes three transfer petitions arising from matrimonial disputes between Divya L. and Naveen Srigunan and his parents. Tr.P.(C)447/2021, filed by the wife, seeks transfer of O.P.(G&W) 414/2021 from the Family Court, Kasaragod, to the Family Court, Kollam, to consolidate proceedings with M.C.13/2021 (DV Act) and M.C.40/2021 (maintenance) in Kollam. Tr.P.(Crl.)67/2021 and Tr.P.(Crl.)68/2021 are filed by Naveen Srigunan and his parents seeking transfer of M.C.13/2021 from Kollam to Kasaragod and related proceedings. The court relies on Supreme Court precedents including Sumitha Sing v. Kumar Sanjay and others, Mona Aresh Goel v. Aresh Satya Goel, Vaishali Shridhar Jagtap v. Shridhar Vishwanath Jagtap, Santhini V. Vijaya Venkatesh, and Valsal Nisha v. Rajesh Soman Nair, to emphasize that the convenience of the wife and child is central in deciding transfer of matrimonial proceedings. After considering pleadings and the relative hardships, the judge concludes that Divya L. and the child are settled in Kollam, with the child’s congenital cardiac condition and schooling in Kollam, tipping the balance in favor of transferring O.P.(G&W) 414/2021 to Kollam. Consequently, Tr.P.(C)447/2021 is allowed and the Kasaragod case is transferred; the other two transfer petitions are dismissed, with liberty to consolidate and joint trial. The order also directs transmission of records to Kollam and allows dispensation of personal appearance where appropriate.
WP(C) No. 18896 of 2023; WP(C) No. 18893 of 2023 The judgment concerns two writ petitions (WP(C) Nos. 18896 of 2023 and 18893 of 2023) filed in the Kerala High Court by Subhash M.P. and Smt. Aswathy R seeking relief from SARFAESI proceedings initiated by Indian Bank to recover loan amounts. The petitioners availed financial assistance from the bank by creating an equitable mortgage by deposit of title deeds for multiple loans. They contend that due to circumstances beyond their control they could not pay installments on time and that the bank should permit repayment in installments and allow them to close the loan accounts, instead of enforcing the secured asset under the SARFAESI Act. The bank has a substantial exposure (about Rs. 14.843 crore outstanding, with Rs. 1.5 crore overdue) across five loans and is not willing to extend further installment facilities, suggesting the petitioners exhaust statutory remedies. The High Court referenced the Supreme Court’s decision in South Indian Bank Ltd v. Naveen Mathew Philip (2023) LiveLaw (SC) 320, which holds that High Courts should not ordinarily interfere in SARFAESI proceedings under Article 226 unless extraordinary circumstances exist. On that basis, the court found no extraordinary circumstances and dismissed the petitions, while noting that the petitioners may pursue an One Time Settlement or other legal remedies under law. The order was issued with a direction to pursue remedies within the statutory framework.
The petitions challenge the age restriction for admission to the integrated five-year LLB course in Kerala, specifically Clause 28(a) of the Legal Education Rules, 2008, which prescribes a maximum upper age limit of 20 years. The petitioners, who had applied under the notification dated 28.7.2016 and were provisionally admitted in the rank list, contend that there was no upper age limit in the original notification and prospectus; they allege that amendments post-examination, and the action by Bar Council of India to enforce Clause 28, are arbitrary and violative of rights. The Bar Council of India had earlier withdrawn Clause 28 in 2013, and the Government of Kerala amended the prospectus (GO/MS 213/2016/H. Edn.) in 2016, creating a retrospective constraint on admittees. The petitioners rely on various judicial dicta from Madras, Punjab & Haryana, Allahabad and other High Courts, and the Supreme Court’s engagement with Clause 28, including interim orders and committee recommendations, to challenge the rule. The Kerala High Court, after considering the conflicting authorities, stayed the 2016 notification and interim measures, allowing participation in the selection process. The court ultimately holds that it would not subserve justice to dislocate the experience of the petitioners and decides to make the interim order absolute, closing the writ petitions, with certificates to be issued upon completion of the course.
This Original Petition (OP(C) 1696/2020) challenges an order of attachment before judgment in a money suit pending in the Sub Court, Neyyattinkara. The plaintiff, K. Sadasivan, claims Rs 69,87,500 with interest from the defendant, alleging that the respondent borrowed Rs 65 lakh and issued two cheques towards discharge. The cheques bounced for insufficient funds, and despite repeated notices, the borrower failed to repay, prompting the suit. The respondent denies borrowing and contends the claim is false, supported by two cheques allegedly removed by a third party, engaged by the respondent to assist in his business. An interlocutory application for attachment of the respondent’s immovable property was moved; the trial court dismissed the application, and an appeal challenged that order, which a Full Bench held not maintainable under Order 43 Rule 1(q) CPC. The High Court examines the scope of Order 38 Rule 5 CPC, noting attachment before judgment is an extraordinary remedy to secure a possible decree and must be exercised sparingly on two concrete grounds: (i) the defendant is about to dispose of the whole or part of his property, and (ii) such disposal is with the intention to obstruct or delay execution of a decree. The court cautions against deciding merits in such interlocutory proceedings and directs the trial court to decide the suit on evidence, uninfluenced by observations in the impugned order. Since the respondent deposited Rs 70 lakhs and demonstrated capacity to satisfy any decree, the petition is dismissed.
This Kerala High Court review petition concerns a maintenance order under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, arising from proceedings initiated before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Thiruvalla (MC 173/2015) and the subsequent challenge in OP(Crl) 149/2021. Petitioner Alex John seeks to review the 2021 judgment and related orders that directed maintenance for the children (Rs.26,500 per month) and required accommodation or a Rs.10,000 monthly payment, with a stay conditioned on a deposit of Rs.26,500. The Sessions Court later stayed the order on condition of depositing Rs.26,500. The High Court, considering the petitioner’s willingness to deposit Rs.30,000 and his lack of objection to withdrawing the deposited amount, modified the stay to require Rs.30,000 per month from 22.02.2020 onward, subject to the appeal’s final outcome. The petitioner contends that the impugned order did not address his challenges and that the court misapplied the law; the respondents maintain the necessity of timely payment and the continuation of the appeal. The judgment extensively surveys the scope and grounds of review under CPC Order XLVII Rule 1 and Section 114, citing precedents that review is not a second appeal and is limited to patent errors or other substantial grounds. It ultimately disposes of the petition, directing arrears payments and advising prompt disposal of connected appeals.
This writ petition challenges a Kerala Building Tax Act assessment and a communication rejecting a tax appeal on technicalities. The petitioner, the Chairman and Managing Trustee of Nehru College of Educational and Charitable Trust, built a teaching hospital and later a separate teaching facility for a medical college. The assessment, raised in 2020-2021, imposed building tax after an earlier assessment in 2011; the petitioner contends that the additional building is used for educational purposes and is exempt under the Act, and that the Appellate Authority rejected the appeal solely on defects such as insufficient stamp and deposit, without considering the exemption claim or the merits. The petitioner argues that the assessment order is not a speaking order; it fails to apply mind or record the details of the construction or exemption, and appears to be a mechanical filling of a form, violating natural justice. The petitioner argues that the defects were curable and that the government has a duty to consider exemptions for educational institutions under Section 3(1)(b) and 3(2). The government pleads that the Appellate Authority had only one option to reject the appeal due to mandatory deposit under Section 11, and that the remedy lies in statutory revision under Section 13. The court, while acknowledging that there is an alternate remedy, uses its Article 226 jurisdiction to review the perverse, non-speaking assessment, sets aside Ext.P8 and Ext.P12, and directs a fresh assessment in accordance with law, while keeping open the exemption claim.
This High Court of Kerala, in CRL.MC No. 4294 of 2023, heard Sunil Khan’s petition under Section 482 CrPC seeking to quash Crime No. 575/2023 of Pothencode Police Station, which charged the petitioner with offences under IPC sections 294(b) (obscene words), 323 (hurt), and 324 (voluntarily causing hurt by dangerous weapon). The prosecution alleged that on 28.03.2020, the accused abused and assaulted the de facto complainant with a stick due to prior enmity, resulting in injuries. The petitioner contended that the parties have amicably settled their disputes, supported by Annexure-A2 affidavit; if the criminal proceedings are terminated and the settlement recorded, both parties could pursue their future lives peacefully. The State raised reservations about quashing proceedings purely on the basis of settlement, noting concerns about potential impediments and whether the entire dispute is truly resolved. The court initially directed the investigating officer to confirm the veracity of the settlement and any criminal antecedents. Relying on State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and a line of Supreme Court precedents (Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, Shambhu Kewat, Deepak, Manish, Ramesh Kamath, Rajveer Singh, Parbatbhai Aahir, Kalyan Singh, and Dhruv Gurjar), the court upheld a principle that quashing is permissible under 482 CrPC for non-compoundable offences with a predominantly civil/private character when a complete settlement exists, provided public interest is not harmed. After weighing factors such as gravity of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and the amicable settlement, the court quashed the FIR and all further proceedings. The petition was allowed.
This regular bail application is by Sujithran, the ninth accused in Kasaba Police Station, Palakkad, Crime No. 203/2022. The petitioner seeks bail contending there is no serious allegation against him beyond CW80 and that he has been in custody since 06.05.2022, with the investigation over and final report filed. The prosecution alleges involvement in a conspiracy to murder a rival political leader, with accused Nos. 1–4 forming an unlawful assembly and, armed with deadly weapons, ramming the car into the deceased’s bike and assaulting the deceased, causing death; the 9th accused is said to have an active role in the conspiracy, supported by CD R details and CW80. The defense relies on CW80’s limited material and cites Supreme Court precedents (e.g., Mohanlal Gangaram Gehani and others) arguing that admissibility and weight of CW80 must be determined at trial and that long detention alone does not entitle bail. The prosecution argues that this case involves political violence, a brutal murder (74 ante-mortem injuries), and a real danger of witness tampering and social unrest if released. The court, after considering these factors and noting earlier orders, dismisses the bail application and directs expeditious trial (SC No. 903 of 2022) to be completed within six months from charge framing.
The petitioner, G. Nagendran Bharat Wheat Product (P) Ltd., a private company, purchased assets of M/s A.M.A Food Products (P) Ltd. in liquidation pursuant to High Court proceedings. After being the successful bidder for Lot No.5, sale was confirmed for Rs.1.62 crore and the assets (land, factory building and machinery) were handed over to the petitioner. A challenge arose against Exhibit P3, a demand notice issued by the Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB) for arrears alleged to be owed by the previous owner, which purportedly barred a new connection. The petitioner claimed the Board’s action was illegal, without jurisdiction, arbitrary, and violative of natural justice. Regulation 12 of the Kerala Electricity Supply Code, 2005 and Regulation 7 of the KSEB Terms and Conditions of Supply allegedly provide that arrears should be realized from the previous owner and not the purchaser, especially where the property is bought free of encumbrances. The Board argued that Section 56 of the Electricity Act, 2003 creates a first charge on the consumer’s assets, allowing recovery against the property; Regulations later reaffirmed this in various forms." The High Court examined the issue against statutory provisions (Section 56, Electricity Act, 2003; Regulation 12, Code 2005; Regulation 19(4), Terms & Conditions) and several precedents. The court held that while a charge can run with the property, the purchaser was aware of liabilities and the Board's remedy runs with the asset; ultimately the writ petition was dismissed with directions to pay arrears within two months to avoid coercive action, otherwise the Board may proceed by law. The decision emphasizes that electricity dues are statutory in nature and may attach to the property sold in liquidation, even when the purchaser is not personally liable under every circumstance.
Harshappan v. Shyamala is an appeal under Order XLIII Rule 1(j) CPC challenging the order of the Sub Court, Ernakulam, in E.A.No.1005/2019 in E.P.No.224/2018 in O.S.No.87/2017. The execution petition was filed by Harshappan to set aside a public sale conducted in 2019 pursuant to a decree passed on a compromise relating to an agreement for sale of property. The underlying decree arose from a 2014 agreement valued at Rs.28 lakhs, with a decree for realisation of Rs.13 lakhs plus interest, and a default clause. The respondent-Shyamala bid Rs.13 lakhs at the sale. Harshappan contends that the sale was void for procedural irregularities under Order XXI, especially improper proclamation under Rules 64-68, improper publication in a newspaper with insufficient local circulation (Pradeepam), and an inadequate base price, given the decree-holder’s 2014 value of Rs.28 lakhs. He asserts the proclamation’s terms and the valuation were not properly stated as required by Rule 66(2)(e), and that the court did not apply its mind to the property’s true value, resulting in a grossly inadequate sale price and substantial injury to the judgment debtor. The respondent argues the proclamation was settled after hearing both sides, the upset price was fixed appropriately, and the sale occurred with no lawful irregularity. The judgment, delivered by a two-judge bench, ultimately allows the appeal, holds the sale void for irregularities, and directs restoration of the case to proceed under law. The decision underscores strict compliance with Order XXI provisions to protect a judgment debtor’s rights and curtail miscarriages of justice.
Abraham @ Babu and others v. State of Kerala is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition arising from a 1995 incident in which the accused allegedly formed an unlawful assembly and assaulted the prosecution witnesses, resulting in convictions under IPC Sections 143, 147, 149, 323, 324 and 447, with a consequential sentence under 324 r/w 149. The trial court convicted all accused; the Additional District & Sessions Court (Ad-hoc) Fast Track Court I, Pathanamthitta, confirmed conviction and imposed sentences; the appellate court, in appeal, affirmed the conviction but modified some sentences. The present revision petition, heard by Justice Kauser Edappagath on 27 July 2022, challenges both conviction and sentence. Arguments by the applicants’ counsel (Sri V. Philip Mathews) urged leniency in light of the long pendency, the death of several accused and the defacto complainant, and sought to confine the substantive sentence for the 324 r/w 149 offence to imprisonment till rising of the court, along with compensation to the legal heirs under Sec. 357 Cr.P.C. The Public Prosecutor (Sri G Sudheer) urged upholding the convictions. The judge reaffirms the evidence and conviction on all counts but allows a limited modification of sentence, directing imprisonment till rising of the court for accused 2 and 3 and ordering compensation of ₹50,000 to the defacto complainant’s legal heirs, with two months to deposit. The revision petition is allowed in part, invoking Sec. 357 Cr.P.C to meet ends of justice, citing Hari Kishan.