Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 436 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.68 of 2023

Richie Roy v. State of Kerala

Richie Roy, the sole accused in Crime No.677/2022 of the Eloor Police Station, Ernakulam, seeks regular bail under Section 439 CrPC. On 14 October 2022, around 21:15 hours, he was found in possession of 12 LSD stamps weighing 0.140 grams at the ground of FACT, Udyogamandal, Eloor village, without lawful authority, leading to a charge under Section 22(c) of the NDPS Act. The petitioner contends his innocence and argues non‑compliance with Sections 41 and 42 of the NDPS Act, asserting that body search was not conducted in the presence of a gazetted officer; he further argues that the recovery was not body‑search‑based but a routine, chance recovery. The Public Prosecutor counters that no body search occurred and nothing was recovered on a body search; the contraband was seized as a chance recovery during law‑and‑order duties, with the accused found in a frightened mood, so Sections 41, 42 and 50 are not mandatory. Given the commercial quantity, Section 37 NDPS Act demands stringent conditions before bail. The Court analyzes Section 37, citing Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari to define "reasonable grounds" as more than prima facie grounds and requiring existence of facts sufficient to justify a belief of the accused’s innocence and absence of likelihood to commit an offence on bail. It also references several precedents. The recovery is described as routine, seized from a plastic cover, not from the body. The court concludes there are no reasonable grounds to grant bail and denies regular bail, dismissing the petition. Interim bail extensions were rejected.

High Court of Kerala
RPFC No. 73 of 2017

Abdul Razaq v. Sunitha P.C. and Others

This is a revision petition under Section 125 CrPC challenging a Family Court order in MC No.80/2016, Vadakara, which directed Abdul Razaq to pay maintenance of Rs 2,500 per month to his wife Sunitha P.C. and Rs 2,500 per month for each of the two minor children (Sruthi and Sreya) from the date of application (22.04.2016). The respondents, represented by Sunitha P.C. and the children, alleged domestic cruelty and that the revision petitioner, a driver with real estate income, could afford maintenance, despite claims of financial strain. Abdul Razaq contended that the first respondent left the marriage without sufficient cause and converted to Hinduism, making him not liable under Sec.125 CrPC; he claimed only auto-driver income with limited means and argued the amount was excessive. The Family Court, after evaluating pleadings and evidence (PW1, RW1, Exts B1/B2), partly allowed the application by ordering maintenance to be paid. The High Court acknowledged the social justice aim of maintenance under Section 125 CrPC and cited precedents (Rajnesh v. Neha; Captain Ramesh Chander Kaushal v. Veena Kaushal; Bhuwan Mohan Singh) while dismissing the revision petition for lack of merit, noting the petitioner’s income and his obligation to support his wife and children. The court also allowed adjusting any interim deposits against arrears as per the impugned order.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 778 OF 2021

Meena Raju (through legal heirs, substituted for deceased RAJU PHILIPOSE) v. Velmurugan, Manu George & Reliance General Insurance Co. Ltd.

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court arising from an award under OP(MV) 615/2018 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Muvattupuzha. The original claimant, RAJU PHILIPOSE, sustained grievous injuries in a 2018 accident and sought compensation of Rs.18,62,000, with a cap of Rs.10,00,000, but the Tribunal awarded only Rs.5,69,567. During the proceedings, the claimant died and his wife Meena Raju was substituted as appellant. The appellant contends that Ext.A10, a series of Income Tax Returns, proves his income was not Rs.10,000 per month as fixed by the Tribunal; rather, the 2017-18 return shows gross income of Rs.3,11,050, with Rs.18,000 from agriculture, indicating a far higher earning capacity. Counsel for the appellant argues that the Tribunal misread Ext.A10, failed to consider 2017-18 figures, and that Ramachandrappa v. Manager (2011) 13 SCC 236 requires a notional income higher than the Tribunal’s figure. The insurer argues the Tribunal’s findings and computations are correct and income has not been proved. The Court is urged to enhance compensation for loss of earnings, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities in light of the medical evidence and disability certificate showing 18% permanent disability.

High Court of Kerala
Writ Appeal No.1411 of 2022

State Institute of Medical Education and Technology (SI-MET) & Director, SI-MET v. Dr. Janet; State of Kerala; SMT. Prasanna B.

This writ appeal challenges a 2022 High Court decision upholding the challenge to a 2018 recruitment process for the post of Principal of SI-MET's nursing colleges. The petitioner, Dr. Janet, had been terminated in 2013 on grounds of fraudulently claiming five years of teaching experience (08.07.1998–11.06.2003) from MV Shetty Institute while actually serving as a Government Staff Nurse (10.07.1998–13.07.2003). Earlier writ petitions had upheld that the certificate could be genuine and that the petitioner could, in future, compete for appointments, directing that Ext.P2 termination could not bar future employment. In 2018 SI-MET issued a fresh notification (Ext.P15) requiring 15 years’ total experience, with at least 12 years of teaching, 5 years in a collegiate programme, and the petitioner again relied on the MV Shetty certificate (Ext.R4(f)). SI-MET later rejected her eligibility (Ext.P20), prompting this writ appeal. The High Court (Single Judge) set aside Ext.P20 and directed reconsideration, but the Division Bench ultimately allowed the appeal, set aside the writ petition, and remanded with directions to reconsider, clarifying that no immunity extends beyond due process and that a future forged certificate could invite lawful action. The bench emphasized that Ext.P3/P4 judgments cannot forcibly bind SI-MET to accept Ext.R4(f) as valid without due process.”

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 1206 OF 2023

Allen Tony Joseph v. State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court Crrl.M.C. No.1206 of 2023, decided by Justice V.G. Arun, concerns a challenge to an extension of time for completing an investigation under Section 36A(4) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS). The fifth accused, Allen Tony Joseph, contends that the Sessions Court’s order extending the investigation period up to 10.03.2023 is unsustainable because Annexure A7 does not clearly state the progress of the investigation or the reasons required by Section 36A(4), relying on the requirement laid down in Sanjay Kumar Kedia v. Intelligence Officer, NCB (2009) to insist on satisfaction of those conditions. The Public Prosecutor submits that Annexure A7 adequately discloses progress and the reasons for seeking extension, emphasizing the need to trace international links given the Nigerian and Ghanaian co-accused. While the court initially notes that Annexure A7 contains satisfactory reasons for extension, it also focuses on another crucial aspect: the production of the accused at the time the extension was considered. The court applies Explanation II to Section 167(2) CrPC, and the broader principle that production is mandatory for further detention extensions. Relying on Sanjay Kumar Kedia and Jigar @ Jimmy Pravinchandra Adatiya v. State of Gujarat (2022, KHC 7011), the court holds that non-production constitutes a gross illegality violating Article 21. Consequently, Annexure A9 is quashed, and the petitioner is held entitled to default bail under Section 167(2) CrPC, with standard bail conditions including bond, surrender of passport, and regular appearance to the Investigating Officer.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 8986 of 2022

Abdulla Koya T.V. and Faizal Pallikandy v. The Chief Secretary, Government of Kerala and others

The petitioners, Abdulla Koya T.V. and Faizal Pallikandy, residents of Azheekal-Pallikandi on the Kothi river bank, moved a writ petition challenging the Kozhikode Corporation’s plan to establish a Decentralised Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) adjacent to the Kothi river. The first petitioner heads the Sangamam Residents Association, representing about 138 families; the second is the general secretary of Kallaipuzha Samrakshana Samithi, formed to protect the Kallai river. The petition asserts that siting the STP in a dense residential area would pose serious health hazards due to noxious emissions, liquid effluents, dust and bioaerosols. It further alleges violation of the Coastal Regulation Zone (CRZ) notifications, Kerala Municipality Building Rules, and that the river puramboke is revenue land requiring government sanction. The petition relies on the National Green Tribunal (NGT) order of 2020 prohibiting river-bank construction until river plains are demarcated, and invokes the polluter pays and precautionary principles, alongside the public trust doctrine to urge restraint on ecological damage. The Kozhikode Corporation defends the project as part of AMRUT-driven development, supported by detailed project reports (DPR), administrative sanction, and KCZMA approvals, including mangrove compensatory planting. The court ultimately held that the project balanced development with ecological concerns and dismissed the petition, emphasizing the need to satisfy statutory requirements while recognizing the value of sustainable development.”,

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO.5282/2022; BAIL APPL. NO.5292/2022

BAIL APPL. NOs. 5282 & 5292 OF 2022

These bail petitions arise from Crime No. 909/2022 of Thodupuzha Police Station, Idukki, concerning a violent procession conducted under the United Democratic Front (UDF) banner on 14.06.2022. The first accused in BA 5282/2022, Bilal Samad, seeks anticipatory bail, while seven other named accused and Jojo Joseph seek relief under BA 5292/2022. The petitioners contend their innocence and submit they were not engaged in the violence; they point to injuries sustained during the incident and the absence of a prior registration against the first accused, asserting willingness to cooperate and comply with reasonable conditions. The Public Prosecutor counters that accused Nos.1 to 3 used a reaper to assault police on duty and obstructed their functions; as a result, custodial interrogation and weapon recovery are essential. The prosecution lists offences under IPC Sections 143, 144, 145, 147, 148, 332, 353, 151, 152, 294(b), 283 and 188 read with 149, and Kerala Police Act Sections 117(e) and 120B. The court notes the genesis of the case was a political procession during a heated period and, balancing liberty with public order, grants anticipatory bail to the petitioners (except the 8th petitioner in BA 5292/2022, whose plea was infructuous) subject to strict conditions: surrender within ten days, cooperation, appearance for interrogation, bonds of Rs.30,000 with two sureties, and regular attendance on Wednesdays for six weeks. The order emphasizes non-interference with investigations and possible cancellation of bail upon violation.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.7410 OF 2022

Mohammed Bilal v. Station House Officer & Circle Inspector of Police, Sooranad Police Station, Kollam District; District Police Chief, Kollam; Assistant Labour Officer, Samstamkotta, Kollam; State of Kerala; Kerala Head Load Workers Welfare Board; Secretary, Chummattu Thozhilali Union (CITU)

This writ petition concerns the rights of a partner-entrepreneur (Mohammed Bilal) who runs an establishment dealing in cement, steel and construction materials, with branches in Alappuzha and Kollam. In February 2022, a new branch at Chakkuvalli (Sooranad North) was opened and a total of seven employees, including five registered head load workers, were approved by the Assistant Labour Officer for that premises (Ext. P16). The petitioner transferred five workers from the Chettikulangara godown to the Chakkuvalli premises with effect from 1 March 2022, but alleged obstruction by the 6th respondent (a union representative) preventing loading/unloading at the new site. The petitioner seeks a Writ of Mandamus directing the first two respondents to remove obstructions and to provide police protection for the petitioner’s loading/unloading activities using the registered workers. The 5th respondent’s counsel contends that as long as workers are properly registered, they may work at the new site. The court relies on precedents from Eastern Condiments and K.K. Issac to hold that registered workers may be deployed across branches, and that obstructing the establishment’s operations would be contrary to the applicable headload statutes and welfare scheme. The petition is allowed with directions for police protection.

High Court of Kerala
RPFC NO. 439 OF 2017

Shinu Kumar S Pillai v. Bindu Sukumara Pillai

This is a revision petition under Section 125 CrPC challenging a Family Court of Muvattupuzha order directing maintenance to the respondent. The respondent, Bindu Sukumara Pillai, had approached the Family Court under Section 125 CrPC alleging she was married to the petitioner, Shinu Kumar S Pillai, on 24.06.2010 and that she resided with him until his alleged desertion on 16.10.2012, after which she sought maintenance of Rs 10,000 per month. The Family Court in MC 38/2014 partly allowed the petition, ordering the revision petitioner to pay Rs 5,000 per month from the date of application. The revision petitioner’s counsel contends there is no valid marriage; he also asserts a dispute over funds involving Rs 8 lakh allegedly borrowed by the respondent and a co-accused, which forms a facet of the personal relationship but not a binding justification to deny maintenance if a wife is found to be legally married. The respondent supported maintenance, arguing the social justice aim of maintenance laws and the obligation of a husband to support his wife and children, with the respondent’s testimony as PW1. The High Court, relying on established Supreme Court precedents, held that Section 125 cannot adjudicate marriage validity, noted the petitioner offered no evidence to rebut PW1, and dismissed the revision petition, while leaving open the question of marriage validity if pursued separately.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.1279 of 2012

Ali A.A. S/O Avarasokutty v. Sudhakaran S/O Kesavan, Suresh @ Kuttan S/O Narayanan and National Insurance Company Limited

Ali A.A., the appellant, sustained multiple injuries in a January 4, 2004 accident when he was a pillion rider on a motorcycle on the Chavakkad–Puthuponnani road, struck by a lorry driven by the second respondent. He filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking Rs. 2,97,000 in compensation. The Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal consolidated two petitions; both respondents 1 and 2 were ex parte; the insurer defended the claim, disputing the accident’s causation by the rider, the insured’s liability, and the claimant’s income and occupation. The Tribunal awarded compensation of Rs. 1,32,030 in favour of the appellant. Dissatisfied, the appellant challenged the quantum, while respondents argued the Tribunal’s determination was correct and liability was established. The High Court enlarged the notional income on the authority of Ramachandrappa to Rs. 4,500 per month for 2004 and applied the multiplier from Sarla Verma (17) for a 26‑year‑old. It re-assessed the disability at 8% (Ext A17) and recalculated heads of compensation: loss of earnings Rs. 18,000; extra nourishment Rs. 4,950; pain and sufferings Rs. 30,000; loss of amenities Rs. 20,000; loss due to disability Rs. 73,440. The overall award became Rs. 2,23,920 with interest at 7% p.a. on the enhanced amount from the petition date and costs of Rs. 10,000. The appeal is allowed, with directions to deposit the enhanced sum within 60 days and disburse thereafter as per law.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C)No.13066 of 2018

Rajesh A. Nair v. State of Kerala and Guruvayur Devaswom Managing Committee and Guruvayur Devasom

The petitioner, a devotee of Guruvayur Sree Krishna Temple, challenged the Guruvayur Devaswom Managing Committee’s 2018 introduction of a Neyvilakku vazhipadu “special darshan” scheme: Rs. 1,000 for single entry and Rs. 4,500 for five devotees. Implemented from 07.04.2018, the scheme purportedly provides direct entry to the main shrine for vazhipadu holders, accompanied by prasadam kits, while others queue as usual. The petitioner argued the scheme creates two classes of devotees, undermines sentiments, and could foster abuse by intermediaries; he sought quashing and a stay on the scheme. The court admitted the petition on 13.04.2018 and the matter traversed through affidavits, counter-affidavits, and notes from temple authorities (including Ext. R2(a) resolution and Ext. R2(b) Tantri’s written opinion). The Respondents contended Neyvilakku vazhipadu is a long-standing vazhipadu item included in the Vazhipadu List (Serial Nos. 77–80) and that the Tantri’s opinion supports continuing the practice; the scheme purportedly curtails a cartel and increases temple revenue. The judgment discusses Guruvayur Devaswom Act, 1978 (Sections 2, 3, 4, 9, 10, 35), Guruvayur Devaswom Rules 1980 (Rules 3, 4, 6, 20), and the Madras Hindu Endowments Act references, emphasizing the secular nature of management and the Tantri’s final authority in religious matters. Ultimately, the High Court held no interference was warranted and dismissed the petition, upholding the special darshan scheme as permissible under law and custom.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO.2163 OF 2012

Biju Mathew S/o Mathew v. The National Insurance Company Ltd.

This appeal arises from the award passed by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (Kalpetta) under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The claimant sustained injuries in a motor accident on 06.11.2007 while traveling in a Maruthi car. The Tribunal held the 1st and 2nd respondents liable for the accident and the 3rd respondent insurer liable to indemnify the owner, awarding Rs. 63,080 as total compensation. The appellant/claimant, who was 32 at the time and claimed to be an electrician earning about Rs. 6,000 per month, challenged the quantum, submitting that the Tribunal notionally fixed income at Rs. 3,000 and that the injuries were serious. The insurer contended that the Tribunal’s award was just and that there was no reliable evidence of actual income; it opposed enhancement on all heads. The High Court relied on established precedents to determine notional income and the appropriate compensation framework. It noted the claimant’s injuries: a closed comminuted fracture of the distal left humerus with a 3% whole body disability, five days of inpatient treatment, and resulting functional impairment. Citing Ramachandrapa, Syed Sadiq, Raj Kumar, and the Sarla Verma–Reshma Kumari–Pranay Sethi line of authority, the court recalculated a new enhanced sum of Rs. 38,450 with interest, directing payment within two months and fixing no costs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.18840 OF 2023

M/S AA NUTS v State of Kerala & Others

The writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India was filed by M/S AA NUTS, a partnership firm, challenging Ext.P1 order passed by the Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, in a gratuity claim filed by the 4th respondent employee. The 4th respondent claimed continuous service from 16.04.2001 to 31.12.2018 with a last drawn salary of Rs. 15,000 and sought gratuity, contending that although she requested the employer to determine and pay gratuity, the same was not paid. The Controlling Authority issued notices, but the notice was returned with the postal endorsement “intimation 13.04.2022,” leading to a finding that the employer had willfully refused service; the employer was declared ex parte on 21.12.2022. Ext.P1 awarded gratuity of Rs. 1,55,769 with 10% interest from 01.01.2019. The petitioner contends they did not receive any notice in connection with the proceedings before the controlling authority and prays to set aside the ex parte order and rehear the matter by filing Ext.P2. The respondents submit that the employer flouted statutory provisions and that more than 60 gratuity cases are pending; they assert Ext.P1 was served and the amount remained unpaid; the petitioner’s appeal was dismissed for non-deposit under the second proviso to Section 7(7) of the Act, rendering Ext.P2 proceedings not maintainable. The court discusses Rule 11(5) of the Payment of Gratuity Rules, 1972, deemed service by endorsement, and the bar on entertaining petitions under Order 9 Rule 13 CPC after disposal, noting the doctrine of merger. Ultimately, it holds that the writ petition cannot be entertained and dismisses the petition, upholding Ext.P1.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 12523 OF 2022

M.K. Yousaf v. Union of India and Others

This writ petition challenges the non-issuance of the Final Award under Section 3G(1) of the National Highways Act after land acquisition, despite compensation deposits. The petitioner alleges that various benefits under the NH Act have not been granted or have been unfairly deducted, including salvage, electrification, plumbing, and the value of the building, and he contends that the eligible II Schedule benefits under the 2013 Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act have been refused. He seeks a direction to CALA to issue the Final Order under Section 3G(1) within a timeframe so that he may exercise remedies under Section 3G(5) before the statutory arbitrator. Respondents’ counsel indicated CALA can furnish a copy of the Final Order if approached, and that the NHAI official concerned should be heard when the 3G(5) application is filed. The court, after hearing, disposes of the petition with directions: the petitioner may approach CALA within a week for a copy of the Final Order, which should be provided within ten days; once the Final Order is received, the petitioner may file a 3G(5) application before the District Collector, who will hear and proceed with appropriate orders; the court may, if necessary, fix a time frame for the order within eight months; the petitioner is free to raise objections regarding salvage, electrification, plumbing,/building value, and II Schedule benefits under the Fair Compensation Act. The judgment also references related prior cases and valuation reports for context.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 8331 OF 2017

Ummar v. State of Kerala and S. R. Saneesh (Sub Inspector of Police, Anthikkad Police Station)

Ummar, the petitioner before the Kerala High Court, seeks to quash FIR 1785/2017 under Section 482 Cr.P.C. The Thrissur East Police Station registered a crime for an alleged assault on a de facto complainant, who is a Sub Inspector of Police, on 21 October 2017 while the petitioner was being served a notice under Section 41A Cr.P.C in connection with Crime No. 561/2017 (Anthikkad Police Station) for offences of 279 and 338 IPC. The case raises a concern that the basis of Annexure-1 FIR is an abuse of process, reportedly registered as retaliation for a prior complaint (Annexure-3) submitted by the petitioner’s wife against police officers including the 2nd respondent. Annexure-2 shows that the referenced Crime No. 561/2017 involves a different offence and different participants, with the petitioner having no connection to that case. The petitioner points to medical records (Annexures 5–6) suggesting injuries pre-dating the alleged incident and argues that the police action is a retaliatory measure against him, aided by delays in information and a alleged malafide motive. The Respondents contend the incident occurred during service of process and that the 2nd respondent faced a separate complaint. The High Court, citing Bhajan Lal, finds malafide and ulterior motive, concluding the registration and proceedings amount to abuse of process and quashes FIR 1785/2017 under 482 Cr.P.C.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 14176 OF 2022; WP(C) NO. 13879 OF 2022

M/s Biverah Hotel and Suites v. The Additional District Magistrate and Ors. / Ali Huq Najeeth v. Commissioner of Police and Ors.

This judgment disposes two related writ petitions challenging electricity-supply arrangements and police protection in Thiruvananthapuram. In WP(C) No.14176 of 2022, M/s Biverah Hotel and Suites challenged an order dated 06.04.2022 of the Additional District Magistrate rejecting the petitioner’s objection to providing a high-tension (HT) connection to the 7th respondent through an Add-on Ring Main Unit (RMU) installed on the petitioner’s premises. The petitioner had previously incurred substantial cost for an RMU intended for HT distribution and argued that the RMU area had been surrendered free of cost; it contended that Regulation 24(2) of the Kerala Electricity Supply Code, 2014 permits the licensee to use the consumer’s service line if the supply to the consumer is not affected adversely, and that an alternative 11kV feeder could be extended without disturbing the RMU. The ADM relied on the regulatory framework and concluded that the licensee could tap via the RMU and that the petitioner’s objections were unfounded, sustaining the ADM order and dismissing WP 14176. In WP(C) No.13879 of 2022, Ali Huq Najeeth challenged the implementation of the ADM’s order and sought police protection; the court allowed the petition and directed police assistance to facilitate KSEB’s tapping of the existing RMU to supply the 7th respondent forthwith.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 2810 of 2014 & MACA No. 248 of 2015

Muhammed Shereef v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.

Two MACA appeals arise from the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode’s award in OPMV 687/2011. The claimant, Muhammed Shereef, a 19-year-old mechanical engineering student, sustained serious injuries when his motorcycle collided with a lorry on 08.05.2010, resulting in a brachial plexus injury and paralysis of the right hand. The Tribunal quantified compensation under multiple heads and awarded damages that the Insurance Company challenged. The insurer contended that there was no charge sheet, hence negligence could not be established; it also questioned the disability assessment, notional income, future prospects, and certain heads like loss of amenities and pain and suffering. The claimant contended that the charge sheet (Ext. A11) naming the driver and alleging rash and negligent driving constitutes prima facie evidence of negligence under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act and should be relied upon, citing New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. Pazhani Ammal. The High Court admitted the charge sheet as evidence and upheld the Tribunal’s findings on disability (87% limb disability but 60% functional disability), income (Rs. 1 lakh per year), and the 40% future prospects. It rejected arguments that 60% is excessive and that loss of amenities was overreaching. The court enhanced certain heads—transport to hospital, pain and suffering—and directed payment of the enhanced compensation with interest (5% from the petition date) and via NEFT/RTGS after the claimant provides bank details within two months. The appeals are allowed to the above extent, with a tabulated total of Rs. 15,39,656 and an enhanced amount of Rs. 4,67,000.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.10955/2020

P. M. Senan and S. Seetha v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition is filed by distressed parents seeking scrutiny into the death of their daughter, Dr. Aswathy, who was found dead by hanging at her husband’s residence in Thrissur in the early hours of 7 August 2013. The petitioners allege that the initial investigation by the Town East Police and the subsequent CBCID probe were marred by lacunae and manipulation, and they contend that the death was not suicide but a homicide in which the husband Naveen, his parents, and an employee were involved. A complaint (Ext. P2) was filed in 2015 alleging laches and irregularities in the investigation, prompting the State to order a reinvestigation by CBCID, and later to transfer the matter to CBCID for renewed inquiry. The petition argues for CBI intervention, arguing that only a high-powered, independent probe can uncover the truth after years of perceived inaction. The respondents defend the investigations as thorough, with medical and scientific evidence and even a polygraph test supporting suicide. The court acknowledges the petitioners’ grievances and the possibility of fault in the investigation but declines to order reinvestigation as a blanket remedy, citing the Vinay Tyagi principle that reinvestigation should be sparingly used. Ultimately, the court disposes of the petition with a direction to an ADGP to meticulously verify the final reports and determine whether further investigation is warranted, in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
MAT.APPEAL NO.444 OF 2017; MAT.APPEAL NO.445 OF 2017; MAT.APPEAL NO.446 OF 2017; MAT.APPEAL NO.1424 OF 2017

Vidya v. Pradeep

This is a matrimonial appeal from the High Court of Kerala (Ernakulam) involving four connected Mat.Appeal Nos. 444/2017, 445/2017, 446/2017 and 1424/2017 arising out of family court orders in Mavelikkara. The appellant Vidya (wife) sought dissolution of her marriage with Pradeep (husband) under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act; in separate original petitions, reliefs included restitution of conjugal rights and custody issues. The family court’s judgment dated 18.03.2017 dismissed the petitions, prompting the wife to approach the High Court under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984. The matter progressed to mediation in 2022, culminating in a settlement recorded on 07.11.2022. The parties filed I.A.1/2022 (Mat.Appeal 444/2017) under Section 13B for divorce by mutual consent and I.A.2/2022 to waive the six-month waiting period under Section 13B(2). The court, guided by Amardeep Singh v. Harveen Kaur (2017) holding the 13B(2) waiting period discretionary, found the facts compelling: the parties have lived separately since 2012, disputes resolved, and settlement terms fully agreed. The bench disposed of all connected appeals by granting a decree of divorce by mutual consent under Section 13B, waiving the waiting period, and lifting attachments in Mat.Appeal 1424/2017, with directions to communicate the order to the relevant authorities. The overall outcome is a final disposal of the appeals on mutual consent terms.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev Nos. 29/2022 to 44/2022

State of Kerala v. K A Jose, Kollamkulam Agencies Pvt Ltd

This batch judgment from the Kerala High Court consolidates OT.Rev Nos. 29/2022 to 44/2022, each challenging orders of the Additional Bench, Kottayam, under the Kerala VAT/CST regime. The core issue is the interplay of exemptions granted under Section 8 of the CST Act, 1956 and the KVAT Act 2003, in the context of inter-State sales of natural rubber and related products. The State contends that the first notification (and its exemptions under Sections 8(1)/(2)) must be applied literally and that subsequent notifications did not supersede the original, seeking to avoid a double exemption and preserve the 24.03.2010 assessment order. Respondents/dealers argue that subsequent Government notifications restricted exemptions to sub-section (1) of Section 8, introduced an optional payment regime, and thus allowed the dealer to choose exemptions or payment, with the Tribunal remanding for disposal. The court analyzes the statutory scheme (CST Act, KVAT Act, and the relevant notifications), cites Hi-Tek Traders v. Commercial Tax Officer as persuasive authority, and ultimately upholds the Tribunal’s remand, holding that the Assessing Officer should decide relief with due regard to the notifications. The result across the batch is dismissal of the revision petitions with no costs, while preserving the law’s interpretive approach to exemptions.