Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 614 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C)No.31159 of 2022

Lalu G.R. v. State of Kerala and Others

The petitioner, a Hindu devotee, seeks a writ of certiorari to quash Ext.P4 (dated 10 August 2020) issued by the Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB), which dropped further investigation into alleged misappropriation in the collection of funds by the 7th respondent, Thiruvithamcore Devaswom Employees Confederation, from Board employees and contractors, including use of a portion of such funds to acquire land and construct a building at Nanthancode, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioner also seeks a mandamus to compel the relevant authorities to consider Exts.P5–P7 representations and to direct the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (Vigilance) to take over the investigation, ensuring a fair and proper inquiry. The Court sets out the statutory framework governing Devaswoms under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, including duties of the Board (Section 15A), constitutional supervision (Sections 16 and 31), and audit obligations (Section 32). It cites precedents on fiduciary duties of trustees (MV Ramasubbiar; Ram Mohan Das), the protective role of courts over temple properties (A.A. Gopalakrishnan; Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair), and the doctrine of parens patriae. Relying on Suo Motu v. State of Kerala (2022) and the subsequent 2023 decision (KER:41764), the Court holds that Ext.P4 cannot sustain the case and directs a fresh, reasoned evaluation by the Board within three months, with notice to involved parties.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C Nos.6415/2022 & 6421/2022; S.T.No.792/2018; S.T.No.783/2018

Sasikala Menon v State of Kerala and Jacob R V Jose

The petitions (Crl.M.C Nos.6415/2022 and 6421/2022) are filed by Sasikala Menon, the accused, under Section 482 CrPC to quash Annexure-A12 complaints pending as S.T.No.792/2018 and S.T.No.783/2018 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Pala. The core contention is that the complainant, Jacob R V Jose, is mentally incapacitated due to bipolar affective disorder as evidenced by Annexure-A1 (medical certificate) and related material, and that if proven, his ability to prefer and contest the complaints would be vitiated. The petitioner pleads that, though CrPC does not provide for a mental-state inquiry, civil procedure principles under Order 32 CPC should guide such inquiries, citing Mariam & Ors. v. Varghese and other authorities; she also relies on case law about the civil-criminal interface and the propriety of compounding. The respondent State and complainant contest these arguments, noting that the apex Court has allowed trial to proceed and highlighting prior orders in Crl.M.C Nos.6475/2018 and 6564/2018, and SLPs ultimately dismissed, preserving trial. The court undertakes a thorough analysis of res judicata and constructive res judicata in criminal proceedings, reaffirming that the principle applies and there is no basis to quash. The judge eventually holds that the pleas are barred by res judicata, and the petitions are dismissed, allowing the underlying cheque-bouncing complaints to proceed to trial.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No. 7447 of 2023

Solomon Stephan @ Aji and Romi Stephan @ Binu v. State of Kerala and John Castro @ Kaneesh

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CrL.M.C. No. 7447 of 2023) filed under Section 482 CrPC seeking to quash the proceedings in Crime No. 809/2023 of Valiathura Police Station. The petitioners, accused in offences including 294(b) (obscene words), 341 (wrongful restraint), 323 (voluntary hurt), 324 (voluntary hurt with a weapon) and 308 r/w 34 IPC, submit that the parties have amicably settled their dispute. The victim has filed an affidavit indicating consent to quashing and no objection to the prosecution being terminated. The Public Prosecutor, while expressing certain reservations about quashing purely on the basis of settlement, concedes that the matter has been settled. The Court relies on the Supreme Court’s judgments, notably State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019 (5) SCC 688), and the precedents in Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, to hold that CrPC Section 482 powers can be exercised to quash non‑compoundable offences where the dispute is private and settled, provided the offences do not fall into intractable categories like heinous crimes. After considering the facts and the settlement, the court concludes the dispute is private in nature and accepts the settlement, quashing all further proceedings in the case.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 14382 OF 2021

Jibeesh George v. State of Kerala & Others

The petitioner, Jibeesh George, challenged the appointment of Dr. S. Pradeep Kumar as Member Secretary of the Kerala State Council for Science, Technology and Environment (KSCSTE). The High Court of Kerala (Division Bench) delivered the judgment on 12 April 2023. The core grievance is that Exhibit-P13 (24.06.2021) and related post-appointment actions permitted the 4th respondent to continue as Member Secretary on re-employment, despite him allegedly lacking the prescribed qualifications (the MOA envisages a Scientist with research and administrative experience) and having exceeded the outer age limit, especially after amendments to university acts and service rules. The petitioner contends that the 4th respondent’s appointment and continuance violated the MOA/Rules of KSCSTE and Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution, and therefore warrants quo warranto, certiorari to oust the usurper, and mandamus to recover financial benefits and reform appointment procedures in future. The respondents dispute these claims, arguing that the 4th respondent possessed substantial academic, research and administrative experience, that the MOA/Bye-Laws do not prescribe post-appointment qualifications, and that age-relaxation and re-employment practices were valid and in the Government’s domain. They further urge that quo warranto is a limited, discretionary remedy and that the petition lacks locus standi in parts. The court ultimately upholds the Government’s actions and dismisses the writ petition, holding there is no valid usurpation or contravention of statutory rules to oust the 4th respondent.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 29228 OF 2023

M/S Punarnava Ayurveda Hospital Pvt Ltd v. The Arbitrator for NH 66 & District Collector; The Special Deputy Collector (LA) NH 66; Project Director, National Highways Authority of India

This writ petition challenges Ext. P6 order rejecting Ext. P4 appointment of an Advocate Commissioner with a Surveyor and technical personnel to inspect land acquired for widening National Highway 66. The petitioner’s land was compensated under the NH Act, 1956 (Sec. 3G). The Special Deputy Collector (LA), as the competent authority, determined compensation (Ext. P1) and later the matter was to be arbitrated under Sec. 3G(5). While Ext. P2 arbitration proceedings were pending, the petitioner sought Ext. P4 for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner with a Surveyor to inspect the property and file a report with a plan describing lie, nature, appurtenance to the highway, etc. The Arbitrator rejected Ext. P4 (Ext. P6), citing that valuation and related issues had already been addressed and timeframes fixed. The petitioner contends that, where the NH Act arbitration is applicable, the Arbitrator has jurisdiction to appoint an expert under Sec. 26 and 27 of the Arbitration Act, and that refusal amounts to jurisdictional error, warranting a writ. The respondents insist Ext. P4 is not within Sec. 26/27 and that the remedy is under Sec. 34 after final award; reliance on SBP and Co v. Patel Engg and other authorities is urged. The Court discusses Secs. 3A, 3G, and the interplay with the Arbitration Act, cites Harbanslal Sahnia, Unnikrishnan, and Thrissur decisions, and ultimately holds that Ext. P4 cannot be entertained by the Arbitrator under Secs. 26/27. It reiterates the limited scope of judicial intervention under Sec. 5 and dismisses the petition, while leaving open other statutory remedies.

High Court of Kerala
Cont.Case (C) No.1781 of 2019

Cont.Case (C) No.1781 of 2019

Cont.Case (C) No.1781 of 2019 is a contempt petition filed by several petitioners who were interveners in WP(C) No.21614/2016, alleging willful disobedience of directions contained in Annexure I of the Kerala High Court's judgment dated 12.10.2018 in WP(C) No.21614/2016 and connected matters. The petition asserts that the Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) and Hindustan Newsprint Ltd. have not complied with the pension reforms instituted by the 2014 amendment to the Employees’ Pension Scheme (G.S.R. 609(E)) and with the options framework under paragraphs 11(3) and 11(4) of the 1995 pension scheme, including extension of time to exercise options. The apex Court’s judgment dated 04.11.2022 in Civil Appeal Nos.8143-44 of 2022 (Sunil Kumar B.) upheld the legal validity of the 2014 amendment and laid down directions to apply the amended provisions to exempted establishments and to extend option rights, among other aspects. The Kerala High Court noted that petitioners’ entitlement for higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO consistent with the 2022 decision. The court ultimately closed the contempt case, directing EPFO to undertake reconsideration of the petitioners’ entitlement for higher pension in light of the 2022 judgment, under Article 142, and in accordance with law, without granting immediate relief but preserving the petitioners’ rights.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.29279 of 2023

N. K. E. Chandarshekhharan Nampooodiripad v. Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board and Others

Anil K. Narendran, J. and VIJU ABRAHAM, J., of the Kerala High Court, hear WP(C) No.29279 of 2023, a writ petition by hereditary trustee N. K. E. Chandarshekhharan Nampooodiripad challenging Ext.P1 dated 10.07.2023 inviting applications for non-hereditary trustees in TTK Devaswom, a temple complex under the Malabar Devaswom Board. The petitioner contends that appointments must be governed by the scheme framed under Section 58 of the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951, and that hereditary trustees must be consulted and their objections considered. Ext.P1 seeks to appoint non-hereditary trustees without equitable notice to hereditary trustees and without placing a proposed list before them. The court traces jurisprudence, including Sreedharan Nambeesan P. v. Commissioner Malabar Devaswom Board (2018 (2) KLT 115), which emphasized notice/participation; and the later clarifications in Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board and others v. Sreedharan Nambeesan (2018:KER:17236) and Chathu Achan K. v. State of Kerala (2022 (6) KLT 388) that a scheme under Section 58 governs appointments and that sub-section (2) of Section 39 may be inapplicable where such a scheme exists. The court ultimately holds Ext.P1 cannot override the scheme and directs the 1st respondent to ensure compliance with Ext.P1’s disqualification and eligibility clauses, consider hereditary trustees’ views as a non-binding aid, modify the application format if necessary, and act promptly. The petition is disposed of with directions, while preserving the petitioner’s right to challenge the proceedings if Ext.P1 is not strictly in terms of the disqualification and eligibility clauses.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C.No.7433 of 2023

Kishore Kumar, Jithin J. Nair and Nandu Prakash v. State of Kerala and Others

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC filed in the Kerala High Court by three accused challenging the order in CC No. 204/2019 arising from Crime No. 305/2017 of Chirayinkeezhu Police Station. The petitioners are charged with offences under Sections 341, 323, 324 and 326 read with Section 34 IPC for allegedly wrongfully confining the victim and causing grievous hurt. The prosecution case is that the accused wrongfully confined the victim and assaulted him, resulting in grievous hurt. The petitioners contend that the dispute has been settled with the victim and the victim has filed an affidavit supporting the settlement, expressing no objection to quashing the proceedings. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of a settlement, but conceded that a settlement exists. The court examined the entire record and relied on the Supreme Court’s framework for exercising CrPC s.482 in private, non‑compoundable offences when the dispute is private and settled, with limitations for serious or public interest offences. The court cited State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (and the linked Gian Singh and Narinder Singh decisions) to justify quashing. After considering the facts and private nature of the dispute, the court allowed the CrMC and quashed all further proceedings in CC 204/2019, thereby ending the criminal matter between the parties.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 7349 of 2023

CRL. M.C. No. 7349 of 2023, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Cr. M.C. No. 7349 of 2023) under Sec. 482 CrPC challenges the order in CC 1116/2020 of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Malappuram, arising from Crime No. 530/2020 of Malappuram Police Station. The petitioners, Faizal Babu, Ajith and Anees, are accused in the connected challan for offences punishable under Secs. 457 and 380 read with Sec. 34 IPC. The petition contends that the dispute with the victim has been settled and the victims have no objection to quashing the prosecution; affidavits filed by the victims support the settlement. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of a settlement but conceded that the matter is settled. The Court examined the legal position and relied on the Supreme Court’s decisions in State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019 (5) SCC 688), which lays down when non-compoundable offences can be quashed under S.482 CrPC, and the earlier precedents Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh and others v. State of Punjab and another, cited within Laxmi Narayan. The Court held that the dispute is private in nature, settlements can be accepted, and thus quashed the proceedings. The case culminates in allowing the Cr. M.C. and quashing all further proceedings in CC 1116/2020.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 7430 OF 2023; CRL.MC NO. 7441 OF 2023

CRL.MC Nos. 7430 and 7441 of 2023, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This is a consolidated criminal miscellaneous petition before the Kerala High Court (Single Judge) involving two accused-petitioners: Ann Sara Rajesh and Rajesh Mathew (Crl.M.C. No. 7430 of 2023) and Lissy Iypu (Crl.M.C. No. 7441 of 2023). The petitions arise from two criminal cases pending in the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Muvattupuzha: Crime No. 1193 of 2022 (C.C. No. 766 of 2022) and Crime No. 1201 of 2022 (C.C. No. 881 of 2022), under IPC sections 324, 341, 448 and 34 for the first case, and sections 341, 294(b) and 323 for the second. The petitioners contend that the disputes between the parties have been settled and that they no longer wish to prosecute; affidavits of the de facto complainants are placed on record. The State and the de facto complainants support withdrawal of prosecution. Relying on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab (2012) 10 SCC 303 and State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan (2019) 5 SCC 688, the court holds that where a genuine settlement exists and no public interest is served by continuation, the proceedings may be quashed. Accordingly, both petitions are allowed and all further proceedings in CC 766/2022 and CC 881/2022 are quashed against the petitioners.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 20816/2014

Regional Deputy Director of Higher Secondary Education, Regional Office, Kozhikode & Principal, Government Higher Secondary School, Sivapuram, Kozhikode District v. Aboobacker K.C., Retd Principal, GHSS Sivapuram, Naminda Po, Kozhikode District

This Kerala High Court writ petition challenges a Lok Ayukta order directing payment of belated DCRG (₹59,536) with 8% interest to the respondent, a retired principal of a government secondary school. The respondent retired on 31.03.2008; 80% of the DCRG was released in 2008, and the balance was released based on a non-liability certificate dated 19.09.2012 after audit objections. The Lok Ayukta’s order (18.11.2013) held that the delay in finalizing liability breached the statutory obligation to pay retirement benefits promptly and directed payment of interest at 8% from 26.11.2008 to the date of actual payment, with a three-month deadline for action. The petitioners contend that the Lok Ayukta acted beyond its jurisdiction, as Article 226 powers should not compel payment of interest and that Lok Ayukta can only recommend action to the government. They also argue the 4+ year delay in issuing the NLC was not condonable. The court, after surveying relevant jurisprudence on pensionary benefits and interest on belated payments (including University of Kerala v. Sobha and multiple Supreme Court decisions), concludes there is no valid basis to disturb the Lok Ayukta order on jurisdictional grounds, but dismisses the petition on the merits. The writ petition is dismissed; the Lok Ayukta’s directive remains binding, and the petitioners are to pay the amount within two months.

High Court of Kerala
WA No. 1933 of 2018

Malabar Cements Limited v. P. Sooria Narayanan Adithya

This writ appeal, WA No. 1933 of 2018, concerns the termination of P. Sooria Narayanan Adithya (respondent), Personal Secretary to the Company Secretary of Malabar Cements Limited (applicant), following a disciplinary inquiry for wilful negligence of duty, conduct prejudicial to the company’s interests, and wilful damage to the company. The Enquiry Officer’s findings led to dismissal, but the learned Single Judge set aside those findings as perverse and unreasonable, holding that the department had no legally acceptable evidence to sustain the charges and directing the company to reinstate the respondent notionally and pay back wages with terminal benefits within a specified period. The company challenged this order by filing WA 1933/2018, arguing that the Enquiry Officer’s inquiry was thorough, fair, and properly grounded in the evidence, and that Article 226 does not permit appellate re‑weighing of factual findings. The respondent contends that the Single Judge’s approach was justified in light of perversity and Wednesbury unreasonableness, and questions the sufficiency of evidence, including critical witnesses and the role of letters and reports that formed the basis of the charges. Ultimately, the Division Bench dismissed the writ appeal, upholding the Single Judge’s view and leaving the relief granted to the respondent intact, including back wages and terminal benefits after superannuation.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No. 7423 of 2023

Unnikrishnan @ Babu and others v. State of Kerala

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC filed by five accused (Unnikrishnan @ Babu, Suresh Babu, Prasanth, Ranjith, and Vinu) seeking quashing of proceedings in C.C. No.1007/2023 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Palakkad, arising from Crime No.595/2023 of Palakkad Kasaba Police Station. The offences charged are under Sections 447, 427, and 153 read with 149 IPC, involving alleged trespass and mischief. The parties reportedly settled their dispute and the victim filed an affidavit supporting the settlement. The Public Prosecutor initially voiced reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but conceded that the matter is settled. The judge relied on Supreme Court jurisprudence—State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688, which outlines when Section 482 powers can quash non-compoundable offences where the dispute is private and settled, provided serious offences are not involved; Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab and Others (both criminal quashing precedents) are cited to place the decision in a broader context. The court found the dispute private, the settlement due, and proceeded to quash all further proceedings against the petitioners. The order closes the case.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 2979 of 2022

Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. v Abdulla N.M

This Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA No. 2979 of 2022) arises from a challenge to a Tribunal award under OP(MV) 905/2019 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kasaragod, for injuries in the 14 August 2019 accident. The Tribunal awarded Rs. 7,57,101 in total compensation, including Rs. 4,91,832 for permanent disability. The appellant insurer contends that the assessment of permanent locomotor disability (Ext. X1) at 69% is based on the 2016 guidelines, and that the 2018 guidelines—arguably applicable to a 2019 accident—were not produced or marked in evidence; therefore, Ext. X1 cannot be read in the light of those guidelines. The insurer seeks remand to the Tribunal to consider whether the 2018 guidelines ought to have been adopted, or liberty to adduce additional evidence, and asks for 80% of the Award to be deposited before remand. The respondent/claimant argues that RW1’s credibility and the yardsticks used in fixing disability were not questioned, and notes a recorded whole-body disability of 41.4% (Ext. X1) with supportive medical reasoning. The High Court frames the sole issue as whether the 2016 guidelines should be replaced by 2018 guidelines and remands for limited factual reproof, while keeping the remainder of the Award intact. The court also contemplates notional income considerations on remand.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl) No. 394 of 2021

Radhamma v. Director General of Police, CBCID & Central Bureau of Investigation

Radhamma, mother of Aneesh Venugopal, a dental doctor who died by hanging in his clinic, challenges the investigation into her son's death, seeking transfer to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI). The petition, WP(Crl).394/2021, contends that the local investigation by the Crime Branch has been inadequate and that the death could be a homicide, given suspicious circumstances surrounding the scene: the clinic room found with the body, food scattered on the table, a partially open shutter, the body found naked, wet clothes, and blood-like fluid on the floor. The investigation history shows the case began as a police inquiry under Section 174 Cr.P.C., then was transferred to the Crime Branch following a related writ petition, with the Crime Branch taking over on 5.3.2020 after lockdown effects. The petitioner highlighted anomalies and potential homicide indicators, including the manner in which the body was found and certain forensic concerns, supported by mobile call data indicating prolonged interactions. The respondents argued that the Crime Branch is conducting a proper, thorough investigation; lockdown impediments were addressed and the investigation has progressed with more than 70 witnesses examined and samples sent for forensic analysis. The court conducted a detailed review of the materials, concluded the death is most consistent with suicide (per postmortem and forensic findings), and refused to transfer to CBI, directing continued investigation by the Crime Branch with emphasis on call data and the motive behind suicide. The petition is disposed of with these directions.

High Court of Kerala
RCRev.128/23

RCRev.128/23

RCRev.128/23 is a rent-control revision petition before the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam challenging an eviction under sections 11(3) and 11(4)(i) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The landlords sought eviction of the tenants from the petition schedule room on grounds of bonafide need to start an Akshaya centre and a computer facility, and alleged subletting in violation of the lease terms. The Rent Control Court found that the first respondent had sublet the room to the second respondent and held the need bonafide, directing eviction. The appellate authority affirmed, noting that the tenants failed to establish the jural relationship and that the landlord’s need persisted even after the landlord’s death, and upheld eviction under 11(3) and 11(4)(i). In the revision petition, the tenants contended that the jural relationship was not properly established, that the alleged sub-letting was mischaracterized, and that post-death, the original bonafide need could not survive. The High Court concluded that the lower courts’ findings on bonafide need were supported by evidence, rejected the argument that the landlord’s need ended with death, and held that the second proviso to Section 11(3) had not been proven by the tenants. Consequently, the revision petition was dismissed, with six months’ time to vacate subject to conditions: unconditional affidavit of surrender within six months, payment of arrears and damages, and continuous rent payments with licensing compliance.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No. 6431 of 2022 and CRL.M.C No. 6463 of 2022

PRADEEP KUMAR K. v. STATE OF KERALA through Public Prosecutor, and BIJU R.S.

The Kerala High Court, in two CRL.M.Cs (6431 of 2022 and 6463 of 2022) arising from two complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, examined the prayer for joint trial before the Judicial Magistrate of First Class Kalamassery (Temporary). The petitioner-prisoner, Pradeep Kumar K., faced two prosecutions (ST Nos. 1901/2018 and 50/2020) and urged consolidation under Cr.P.C. Sections 218-220, arguing that though the cheques were issued on different dates and for distinct liabilities, the underlying transaction linking the parties was the same and should permit a single trial to avoid multiplicity. The second respondent resisted, contending that the two transactions were separate—one relating to a hand-loan default and the other to a liquidated amount tied to a building deal—and that different notices were issued; thus joint trial would protract proceedings. The court canvassed authorities including Rajendra B. Choudhari v. State of Maharashtra, Rajasthan Trading Co. v. Chemos International Ltd., Essar Teleholdings Ltd. v. CBI, and Ranchhod Lal v. State of Madhya Pradesh. It held that joint trial is not obligatory; Section 219-220 Cr.P.C. are enabling provisions and discretionary. Since the cheques were issued for distinct liabilities with separate notices, the magistrate’s discretion to deny joint trial was affirmed, and the petitions were dismissed, leaving separate trials to proceed.

High Court of Kerala
OT.REV NO. 82 OF 2019

State of Kerala v Oppo Mobiles India Private Limited

This is a revision under the Kerala KVAT Act (OT.REV NO. 82 OF 2019) by the State of Kerala challenging the Kerala Value Added Tax Appellate Tribunal’s order in TA (VAT) No. 477/2018 dated 08-04-2019, which upheld the appellate authority’s reduction of a penalty under Section 47(6) to Rs. 10,000 (from an earlier security deposit converted into a penalty). The respondent-assessee is Oppo Mobiles India Private Limited, a dealer in mobile phones, whose stock transfer transaction from Oppo Mobiles India Pvt Ltd was intercepted on 09-01-2017. The Intelligence Officer found defects in Form 8FA declarations: non-declaration of consignee and transporter identities, pre-dating of 8FA, and absence of a TIN declaration to evade tax, leading to a demand for security of Rs. 45,39,097 and its subsequent conversion to penalty. While the appellate authority held that the 8FA defects were technical and set aside the larger penalty, reducing it to Rs. 10,000 under Section 67(1), the Tribunal confirmed the appellate order. The State’s revision framed five questions of law, contesting the Tribunal’s view that the non‑mention of TIN in 8FA constitutes only a technical defect and seeking to establish that subsequent accounting does not absolve liability. The High Court ultimately dismissed the revision petition, agreeing that the defects were technical and that the Tribunal’s and appellate authorities’ findings did not warrant interference, thereby upholding the Rs. 10,000 penalty and the concurrent orders.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) Nos.304, 390, 396 and 457 of 2023

OP(KAT) Nos.304, 390, 396 and 457 of 2023

These four petitions (OP(KAT) Nos. 304/2023, 390/2023, 396/2023 and 457/2023) before the Kerala High Court challenge the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s order concerning reservation for differently abled candidates in the recruitment for Medical Officer (Ayurveda) and Assistant Insurance Medical Officer (Ayurveda). The core issue is whether the government’s 2020 erratum, identifying the low-vision category as eligible for 3% disability reservation and the Expert Committee’s recommendations under the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, can be applied to a recruitment process for which ranked lists had already been published. Petitioners contend that post-notification alterations to eligibility or to the reserved categories undermine the integrity of the selection process and violate the notion that a ranked list once published should govern appointments, citing decisions such as K. Manjusree and Bank of India v. Aarya K. Babu to argue that eligibility criteria cannot be altered retroactively. Respondents contend that Act 2016 empowers identification and reservation of differently abled categories and that government action, grounded in statutory provisions and expert recommendations, is a valid exercise of policy to ensure equal opportunity. The High Court, in a Division Bench, ultimately holds that the cited judgments are not applicable here, upholds the statutory framework, and dismisses all petitions as without merit, allowing the inclusion of the low-vision category for current notifications.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No. 119 of 2022

F.A.O. No. 119 of 2022

F.A.O. No.119/2022 arises from an appeal filed by Faisal (defendant) challenging an ex parte decree in O.S. No.49 of 2014 of the Sub Court, Tirur, and the order dated 05.08.2022 dismissing I.A. No.1 of 2022 to set aside that decree. The suit was decreed ex parte on 04.12.2015. The appeal was admitted on 11.10.2022 and interim stay orders were granted for two months and extended thereafter; mediation was attempted but failed. The appellant contends that the Sub Court erred in dismissing I.A.1/2022 by overlooking the possibility of condonation of delay even without a formal Section 5 Limitation Act application, relying on Unniraman v. Padmanabhan to suggest that sufficient cause can be considered from the pleadings and facts in the delay-related application. The appellant asserts he learned of the decree only on receipt of service in E.A. No.1 of 2021 in E.P. No.16 of 2016 and that the delay should be counted from the date of knowledge. The respondents’ counsel argued that the decree was valid, knowledge of pendency was established by substituted service and publication, and the long lapse (about six years) cannot be excused by liberal notions of sufficient cause. The court, applying Katiji, Esha Bhattacharjee, and Sabarmati Gas, held that the delay was not sufficiently explained, rejected condonation, and dismissed the appeal as unsustainable.