WP(C) No. 24666/2021 and WP(C) No. 2144/2020 This is a consolidated challenge in two writ petitions arising from an industrial dispute and related revenue recovery proceedings concerning retrenchment compensation and notice wages. The petitioner in W.P.(C) No. 24666/2021, Unnitheri, a toddy tapper employed in the rubber estate of late Smt. Mary Joseph, alleges denial of employment after 2011 and seeks enforcement of an award under the Industrial Disputes Act (ID Act). The Labour Court at Kozhikode held in ID No.18/2014 that there was no denial of employment, but the worker was entitled to notice wages and retrenchment compensation under ID Act sections 25F(a) and (b). When the employer did not pay, the Labour Court quantified the amount under Section 33C(2) of the ID Act (Rs.1,37,000 plus Rs.5,000 costs). A revenue recovery notice under the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act (RR Act) was issued against the legal heirs; this prompted W.P.(C) 24666/2021 to seek recovery actions. W.P.(C) No. 2144/2020 challenges the award and the RR notice. The two petitions were heard together. The Court ultimately dismissed WP(C) 2144/2020 and allowed WP(C) 24666/2021, directing the District Collector and District Labour Officer to complete revenue recovery proceedings against the legal heirs within six months. The judgment clarifies the scope of ID Act relief and RR Act recoveries and addresses belated challenges to awards in the wake of a party’s death.
W.P.(C) Nos.29277 & 29370 of 2023 The two writ petitions, heard together, pertain to the management and protection of temple properties under Devaswom governance in Kerala. The petitioner in W.P.(C) No.29277 of 2023, N.V. Ganapathi Namboothiri, and in W.P.(C) No.29370 of 2023, Pariyarthappan Kshethra Chaithanyarjjjava Paripalana Sabha, challenge alleged mismanagement by the SNDP Sakha (4th respondent in the earlier case) and seek protective intervention under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 as well as Article 226 of the Constitution. They urge the Court to direct a de jure enquiry under Section 38 and, under Section 37, to restore proper temple administration, citing the Supreme Court’s Mrinalini Padhi v. Union of India (2018 SCC OnLine SC 667) to justify public-interest scrutiny of shrine assets. The petitions trace alleged malpractices: removal of deities, unauthorised activities on temple property, and encroachments, supported by Ext.P1 agreements and prior suits. A central tenet is protection of temple assets as trust properties for worshippers and the duty of courts to safeguard such assets (parens patriae). The respondents argue lack of maintainability, lack of pending applications under Sections 37/38, and that the PIL-style directives cannot be commandeered to supersede statutory processes. The Court ultimately dismisses both petitions for lack of maintainable relief within the framed constitutional and statutory framework.
Crl.Appeal No.978 of 2018 Ajikumar, the appellant-accused, stands convicted by the Sessions Court for offences under Sections 324 and 302 IPC in SC No.801/2016 arising from the brutal assault on his mother, Sarojam, on 18 July 2015, and the injury to PW1, his brother, during the same episode. The prosecution alleged that the accused, influenced by enmity, armed himself with an iron pipe (MO.1) and a kitchen knife (MO.2) after his mother rebuked him, and assaulted multiple family members, culminating in the mother’s death. PW1 intervened, sustaining injuries, and the eight-month-old grandchild carried by the mother escaped the fatal blows. The trial court sentenced the accused to life imprisonment and fines. On appeal, the High Court examined, among other things, the admissibility of Ext.P7 post-mortem certificate and whether the prosecution proved the required mens rea. The court critiqued the trial judge’s procedure in tendering Ext.P7 and relied on foundational jurisprudence to discuss Section 84 IPC (the insanity defense) and the distinction between medical and legal insanity, relying on numerous precedents. The court concluded that the accused had a history of mental illness, and there was reasonable doubt about his ability to form the necessary mens rea at the time of the offence. Consequently, the appeal was allowed. The conviction and sentence under 302 IPC were set aside; the accused was acquitted under Section 334 CrPC on the ground of unsoundness of mind and ordered to be detained in a mental health establishment under the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017, with safekeeping under S.335 Cr.P.C. The State’s interlocutory applications, if any, were to be closed.
The petitioner, Elvis Sajan Mathew, challenges Ext.P4, an order cancelling his GST registration following a show-cause Ext.P2 for non-filing of GSTR-3B returns from March 2022 to August 2022. The TSP argues that the show-cause notice Ext.P2 (dated 7.10.2022) and the subsequent Ext.P4 cancellation order were issued in haste, without specific reference to the months of default, and without affording a fair opportunity to defend. The petitioner submits a March 2022 return on 3.11.2022, before Ext.P4, and contends the authority was obliged to issue notice under the proviso to Section 29(2) of the GST Acts. The court finds Ext.P2 vague, the procedure lacking, and the right to defence denied, violating natural justice. It reiterates that quasi-judicial bodies must act with fairness, openness and reasonableness. Exts.P2 and P4 are quashed, and the respondents are permitted to issue a fresh show-cause notice specifying the period of non-filing and ensure fair hearing before any final action. The judgment cites Phoenix Rubbers and relies on natural justice principles, with Justice C.S. Dias delivering the order on 5 July 2023.
This High Court of Kerala criminal miscellaneous case under section 482 CrPC challenges the order in CC No.100 of 2013 arising from Crime No.219/2012 of Meppayur Police Station. Petitioners, accused Nos.1 and 2, are charged with offences including sections 114, 485, and 379 read with section 34 IPC, alleged to constitute theft and related acts. The petition asserts that the parties have amicably settled their dispute and do not wish to continue prosecution; the victim has sworn an affidavit in support of the settlement and has expressed no objection to quashing. The Public Prosecutor initially reservations about quashing only on the basis of a settlement but ultimately concedes that the matter is settled. The court examines the issue in light of State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) 5 SCC 688, and the earlier Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab decisions, outlining when the power under S.482 CrPC can be invoked to quash non-compoundable offences where the dispute is private and resolved. The court concludes that the dispute is private, and the settlement is acceptable; hence the proceedings are quashed. The order reflects that the criminal miscellaneous case is allowed and all further proceedings in CC 100/2013 are quashed.
Subeesh B., the petitioner/applicant, challenged Ext.P2, the Kerala Administrative Tribunal order dated 07.04.2022 in OA(Ekm) No.583/2022, which reserved a single post of Painter in the Health Services Department, Kozhikode district, for a differently abled candidate (as per Annex A1). The ranked list No.310/2020/SS III (Annex A2) placed the petitioner first for the same post, and he contended that setting apart a single post for a differently abled person would equate to 100% reservation in a single cadre post, rendering the ranking exercise meaningless and contrary to public interest. He relied on PGIMER, Chandigarh v. Faculty Association & Others (1998) 4 SCC 1 and Indira Sawhney v. Union of India (AIR 1993 SC 477) to argue that single cadre posts cannot be reserved beyond the published ranking and that the 50% ceiling for reservations (vertical) cannot be stretched to these horizontal reservations. The respondents argued that disability reservations are horizontal, under Article 16(1), and must be implemented even in single cadre posts; citing National Federation of the Blind (2013) 10 SCC 772, which requires the 3% reservation for differently abled to be implemented and to override existing vacancy arrangements. The High Court, upholding the tribunal’s reasoning and relying on the RPWD Act frameworks, dismissed the petition and affirmed that differently abled reservations can apply to single cadre posts. The decision was delivered by a Division Bench comprising Justices A. Muhammed Mustaque and Shoba Annamma Eapen.
The petitioner challenges Ext.P1 detention order issued under the Kerala Anti-social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAA(P)A) on grounds including inordinate delays between the last prejudicial activity and the detention order, delay in the Advisory Board process, and alleged non-application of mind by the detaining authority. The detenu, who was in judicial custody when the last crime occurred, was enlarged on bail on 31.3.2023; the sponsoring authority forwarded a report on 20.3.2023 and the detention order was issued on 16.5.2023. The Government confirmed Ext.P1 on 14.7.2023 (Ext.P4). The petitioner contends that a 51-day gap between the sponsoring authority’s recommendation and the detention order breaks the live link between the last prejudicial activity and detention; that there was an unexplained 18-day delay in the 10(4) confirmation; and that the detinue’s bail conditions were not adequately considered. The respondents contend that the delay was explained by the detenu’s bail status and the voluminous records needed for subjective satisfaction, and that the order and its confirmation complied with legal standards. The court, after detailed discussion of delays, live nexus, and the sufficiency of considerations, holds that the delays are not inordinate and that the detaining authority exercised due mind. The petition is dismissed and Ext.P1 detention, as extended by Ext.P4, is upheld for six months from detention date.
Mat.Appeal Nos.530 and 531 of 2021 This is a consolidated matrimonial appeal under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, challenging the common Family Court, Tirur order dated 18.06.2021 in O.P. Nos.85/2016 and 756/2018. The appellants (Shareefa K.M. and her children) allege that the petition schedule property, purchased in the name of the first respondent as trustee, was funded by sale proceeds of gold ornaments entrusted to him at marriage, and that a 2013 sale deed (Ext.B1) in favour of the second respondent was sham and collusive to defeat their rights. The second respondent and the first respondent contend the property was bought with their own funds and that Ext.B1 was executed for valid consideration by a bona fide purchaser. The Family Court dismissed O.P.85/2016 (dealing with declaration/possession) and allowed O.P.756/2018 (recovery of possession). The High Court, after hearing both sides, held that despite lack of direct proof, circumstantial evidence and the sequence of events establish that Ext.B1 was a sham document created to defeat the petitioners’ rights. Relying on the Supreme Court’s V.M. Salim v. Fathima Muhammed, the Court held the transaction to be sham/collusive. Consequently, Mat.Appeal Nos.530 and 531 of 2021 are allowed; the common order in OP 85/2016 is set aside, Ext.B1 is declared null and void, and the order in OP 756/2018 is also set aside, with the petitioners succeeding. Interlocutory applications are closed.
BA Nos.8033 of 2023 and connected cases This is a consolidated bail order passed by a single-judge of the Kerala High Court (Mohammed Nias C.P.) on 25 October 2023 involving multiple Bail Applications (BA Nos.8033/2023 and connected cases) filed by VIMAL @ ROSHAN, the second accused in a string of cases registered by the Palarivattom Police Station, Ernakulam. The petitioner is alleged to be involved in offences punishable under Sections 406, 420, 468, 471 and 120B read with 34 IPC across several crime numbers (e.g., 1834/2023, 1795/2023, 1808/2023, 1788/2023, 1766/2023, 1751/2023, 1787/2023, 1880/2023, 1739/2023, 1809/2023, 1796/2023, 1873/2023, 1884/2023, 1937/2023, 1930/2023, 1935/2023, 1957/2023, 1654/2023, 1522/2023). The prosecution argues that the petitioner is a habitual offender with numerous antecedents, including forgery in some cases, while the defense submits that he is only an employee attached to AB Cars and not a proprietor, with no direct involvement in the alleged activities. After considering detention already undergone, absence of flight risk, and the role of the petitioner as staff rather than principal offender, the court grants regular bail under Section 439 CrPC subject to standard conditions. The order requires bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, weekly appearance for three months, non-interference with witnesses, no tampering with evidence, prohibition on leaving Kerala or India without court permission (passport to be deposited if required), disclosure of current address and mobile number, and compliance with police investigations. The court cites Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and another (2021) 1 KHC 663 to acknowledge the police’s continuing investigatory power even on bail. The decision constitutes a favorable disposition for the petitioner across all listed bail applications.
CRL.REV.PET NO.866 OF 2022 This is a criminal revision petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. filed by Suresh Kumar (the accused) challenging a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, for dishonour of a cheque of Rs 4,00,000 issued in discharge of a debt. The trial court (S.T.1244/2017, Kakkanad) convicted him and sentenced him to three months’ simple imprisonment with a fine of Rs 4,00,000, directing the fine to compensate the complainant under Section 357(1)(b) Cr.P.C. The Additional Sessions Court-VI, Ernakulam, on appeal, reduced the sentence to one month’s simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs 2,00,000, with a further one month’ imprisonment in default. The revision petition contends that the matter had been settled earlier and that there should be no further contest, noting partial payment; the revision seeks to reassess the case, but this Court reiterates that revisional jurisdiction is supervisory and not appellate, and should not re-appreciate evidence to reach a contra finding unless there is gross miscarriage of justice. Relying on several Supreme Court precedents, the High Court upholds the conviction and narrows the scope of revision, while granting two months for payment of the fine and deferring execution until 07.03.2023 with directions to appear on 08.03.2023 for payment/commitment. The petition is ultimately dismissed, subject to the two-month payment window and deferment of sentence. An amendment later corrected the fine amount from Rs 4 lakh to Rs 2 lakh.
Subair, the 1st accused in SC No. 90/2023 of the Special Court for SC/ST (POA) & NDPS Act Cases, Manjeri, files CRL.MC 6742/2023 challenging the proceedings on grounds of abuse of process and violation of fair trial, and seeks to quash the order in Crl.M.P. 1799/2023 denying certain documents, as well as a stay of further proceedings until his representations (Annexures VIII, X and XI) are decided. The petition arises from the 21 September 2022 incident when a bag—initially reported to contain cash—was found to contain a powder, later identified as methamphetamine, following the accused’s presence near Padaparambu-Perinthalmanna Road. Prosecutors allege a conspiracy to sell narcotics, with MDMA/space procured from Virajpetta and transported for sale at Padaparambu. Subair argues innocence, alleges manipulation by a key witness/employee Amal Kumar, and contends the investigation was not exhaustive or properly disclosed; he also raises issues about call data records and the credibility of forensic reports (RFSL Thrissur) and its accreditation. He relies on Apex Court guidelines on inadequacies in criminal trials and argues for production of material under Sections 173, 207 and 208 CrPC, including witnesses’ statements and objects. The State counters that no confession under NDPS Section 67 was recorded or relied upon, and that the prosecution has complied with disclosure norms. The Court, after considering submissions, concludes that the reliefs cannot be granted and dismisses the petition, while leaving open the petitioner’s rights to pursue grievances through representations.
Rohit Suresh, the petitioner-accused in CC 818/2020 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kalamassery, seeks relief under Section 482 Cr.P.C. The case arises from a road traffic incident on 16.04.2020 (Kalamassery-Cheranallur container road) in which the petitioner, driving vehicle KL 11 BL 6776, allegedly acted with rash and negligent conduct, causing injury to the defacto complainant. Annexure A1 is the FIR and Annexure A2 the final report; the defacto complainant has an ongoing O.P. (M.V.) No. 394/2020 before the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal. The petitioner initially did not appear, resulting in a non-bailable warrant on 03.11.2022, and later surrendered on 04.01.2023 when the plea was recorded as not guilty. The petitioner, a doctor by profession, is employed abroad with NHS in the UK and has a contract in London; he contends he intends to plead guilty and seeks to plead through counsel, citing difficulty in personal appearance. He prays to quash Annexure A4 and to dispense with translation of vernacular documents. He relies on Shyni Moolayil v. State of Kerala, Suo Motu v. State of Kerala, and Santhosh v. State of Kerala, contending that a guilty plea can be entered on a subsequent occasion if voluntary. The High Court quashes Annexure A4 and directs the lower court to entertain a plea of guilty through counsel if filed and pass appropriate orders in accordance with law.
Shamsudeen, the fourth accused in Crime No.1172/2016 of Kollam West Police Station, challenges a Sessions Court order dated 16.07.2022 denying him regular bail under Sec.21(4) of the National Investigation Agency (NIA) Act, 2008. He is arrayed as A-4 along with three other accused in offences punishable under IPC Secs.120B, 307, 427, 324, 121 and 122; PDPP Act Sec.3(a)(iii); and UAPA Secs.15, 16(b), 18 and 20. The final report was filed on 08.09.2017, with a supplementary report under Sec.173(8) Cr.P.C. The Sessions Court refused bail on the ground that the proviso to Sec.43-D(5) of the UAPA must be strictly adhered to and that the case diary and the Sec.164 Cr.P.C. statement of an approver indicate a prima facie case under Chapter IV of the UAPA. The appellant contends that the 164 statement is hearsay and inadmissible at this stage and that there is no direct link tying him to the Kollam blast; he had previously obtained bail in other cases. The State contends that the materials, including the approver’s 164 Cr.P.C statement, reveal a strong prima facie case under Chapter IV, justifying refusal of bail. The High Court, following Watali’s framework, holds that there are reasonable grounds to believe the accusation is prima facie true and denies relief, upholding the Sessions Court’s order. Consequently, the Crl.Appeal is dismissed.
This Kerala High Court first appeal from orders (FAO 101/2023) concerns ESAF Small Finance Bank Limited’s challenge to a District Court injunction refusal in a trademark infringement and passing-off action against SAAF CAPIT FEDERATION. The plaintiff-bank, RBI-licensed and using the registered marks ESAF Small Finance Bank in Class 36 (registration Nos. 3459568 and 4392824; 4392825 with device), sought a temporary prohibitory injunction restraining the first defendant from using the trade name SAAF or SAAF with a design implying an “E” before it and from passing off its services as those of the plaintiff. The District Court dismissed I.A.3/2023 stating no prima facie case. The High Court interviewed the plaintiff’s trademark registrations, the defendant’s “SAAF CAPIT FEDERATION” mark and logo, and the available Commission report, to evaluate the likelihood of confusion for an unwary reader. It emphasized that injunctions are discretionary, requiring prima facie case, irreparable injury, and balance of convenience, and relied on Dalpat Kumar v. Prahlad Singh and Cadila Health Care for framework. The court found the trial court’s reasons inadequate and set aside the order, remanding for reconsideration in light of evidence and apex court dicta. It allowed the FAO, directing a fresh assessment by the District Judge.
Ottasekharamangalam Grama Panchayat filed the writ petition challenging the Kerala State Human Rights Commission’s order in HRMP No. 10557 of 2015 dated 04.07.2016. The Panchayat contends the complaint relates to a civil dispute over private immovable property and not a human rights violation, hence outside KHRC’s jurisdiction. It argues Regulation 17 of the KHRC Procedure Regulation, 2001 excludes civil disputes and matters not involving human rights, and that the Commission’s directions to restore land and pay compensation were illegal, ultra vires, and lacked evidence of trespass. The road widening around the complainant’s property was carried out years earlier by public action, reportedly with the involvement and knowledge of the first respondent, who allegedly passed over portions of his land in 2008 for about 5 meters’ width along 500 meters. The Commission relied on a report and a sketch, ignoring the Panchayat’s stand. The petitioner also highlighted malafides and delay (seven years) in filing the complaint. The High Court distinguished earlier authority (Kallara Grama Panchayat) as having different facts, and relied on decisions that limit KHRC’s jurisdiction over civil disputes. It held that the KHRC order warranted interference and set it aside, allowing the writ petition.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC challenging the order in CC 881/2022 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, Perinthalmanna, arising from Crime No.939/2022 of Perinthalmanna Police Station. The petitioners, four accused in the trial, are charged with offences under Sections 341, 325 read with 34 IPC. The prosecution alleges that the accused wrongfully restrained the defacto complainant and inflicted grievous hurt. The petitioners’ counsel submit that the parties have settled their dispute and do not wish to pursue the prosecution, supported by an affidavit from the victim. The Public Prosecutor, while acknowledging the settlement, expresses reservations about quashing solely on that basis. The High Court, after considering submissions and records, cites Supreme Court decisions in Laxmi Narayan (State of MP) and related cases (Gian Singh, Narinder Singh) to outline the scope of Section 482 CrPC. The court holds that where a dispute is private and non-compoundable offences are involved, quashing can be entertained if the parties have resolved the entire dispute, subject to scrutiny of the nature of the offence and evidence. Observing that the dispute is private and the settlement is genuine, the court allows the Crl.M.C. and quashes CC 881/2022 proceedings.
DR. REDDYS LABORATORIES LTD filed OT Appeal 3/2015 challenging the KVAT authority’s clarification order under Section 94 of the Kerala Value Added Tax Act, 2003. The order, dated 09.01.2015, held Clohex and Clohex Plus to be medicaments attracting 5% tax under HSN 3004.9099, while Senquel-AD Mouthwash was not classified as a medicament and taxed at 14.5% under Entry 92(6) of SRO 82/2006. The appellant, a manufacturer and trader of Clohex, Clohex Plus and Senquel-AD, argued that all three products have therapeutic and prophylactic uses, are marketed with medicinal orientations, and are often licensed as drugs; thus, Senquel-AD should be treated as a medicament rather than merely a mouthwash. The respondents contended Senquel-AD is marketed as a desensitising mouthwash; the Note to Chapter 30 excludes such preparations from Chapter 30, and classification should follow HSN entries. The Court, relying on principles from CIENS Laboratories and Heinz, emphasized that classification requires a multi-factor assessment, including therapeutic attributes, user understanding, and the dominant function of the product; prevention and treatment considerations must be weighed, not mere packaging or licensing. The Court remitted the matter to the clarificatory authority for fresh consideration within three months, with interim stay continuing. The OT Appeal is allowed in part as directed, with notice to parties."
This writ petition challenges Exts.P12 and P14 orders issued by the respondents concerning 23.40 Acres of land at Ezhamkulam village, Pathanamthitta. The first petitioner, ANCYMOL N., holds absolute ownership over 18.30 Ares in Sy.No.6/11 and 5.10 Ares in Sy.No.6/10, with a residential building once standing but now collapsed. Documented as Nilam in title deeds and revenue records, the property has remained dry for more than 30 years, with no paddy cultivation in the subject or neighboring lands during that period. Photographs (Ext.P2) and a data-bank entry (Ext.P3) reflect its dry land status, and Ext.P4 shows a family ration card evidencing a dwelling on the property. Petitioners sought exclusion from the Paddy Land and Wetland Data Bank under PMEGP-related arrangements (Exts.P5-P6, P7-P11) and contend Ext.P12 notice to reclaim lands is unjustified. Respondents contend the land is waterlogged and a paddy field, with reports (Ext.P8) indicating a portion removal from the data bank, and with earlier admissions (Ext.R3(a)) by the petitioner. The court set aside Ext.P14, directed reconsideration by the 3rd respondent, required verification of paddy-land status as of 2008, local inspection, and a KSRSEC report if not already obtained, with a three-month deadline and stay on further Exts.P12 proceedings, noting dicta from Joy v. RDO and Arthasasthra Ventures.
This criminal appeal, Cr.A. No. 948 of 2020, is filed by P. Vinod, Secretary in charge of Janakeeya Co-operative Urban Society, Kottakkal, challenging a judgment of acquittal recorded by the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Malappuram, in ST No. 916 of 2016. The trial court had acquitted the accused on 28 January 2020 in a case instituted under Section 142 read with Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, upon a complaint lodged by the appellant on behalf of the society, alleging that the accused and his son availed two loans of Rs 25,000 each in 2005 and, to discharge the liability, the accused issued a cheque dated 6 December 2013 for Rs 1,28,000 which was dishonored for account closure. Notice under NI Act was issued, but the accused did not respond or settle the amount. The appellant contends that the verdict contradicts settled law; reliance was placed on Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar to argue that presumption under Section 139 NI Act should apply, given a signed cheque issued to discharge indebtedness. The High Court, after examining the evidence, concluded that the defence rebutted the presumption, citing Ext.D1 showing a principal amount of Rs 21,900 and inconsistencies in ledgers, and thus affirmed the trial court’s acquittal. The court discussed standard of proof and distinguished certain authorities, ultimately dismissing the appeal and upholding the acquittal.
The Kerala High Court, in Crl.M.C. No.6666 of 2022, considered an application under Section 482 CrPC to quash criminal proceedings arising from Crime No.1465/2014 of Thoppumpady Police Station and CC 2123/2019 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kochi. The petitioners, Hazeena Abdul Ameer, Rahim, and Shamsudheen Abdul Ameer, faced charges under IPC sections 341, 506(1), 406, and 420 read with 34, as well as related sections, in a case filed by the defacto complainant (the legal heir of the deceased 2nd respondent). The petition contended that the dispute has been settled between the parties and that there is no object or continuation of prosecution, with the victim supporting quashing via an affidavit; the victim’s counsel also stated the matter is settled and has no objection. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing strictly on the basis of settlement but conceded the parties’ settlement. The court examined the evidence and the controlling law, citing State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others, 2019 (5) SCC 688, along with Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, to articulate the framework for quashing non-compoundable offences in private disputes. The court concluded the dispute is private, the settlement acceptable, and proceeded to quash all further proceedings in CC 2123/2019 against the petitioners, allowing the Crl.M.C. petition.