Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 611 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.136 of 2020

Shibu v. Chandrasekharan Nair

This is a Rent Control Revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, R.C.Rev.No.136 of 2020, heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam on 26 May 2022. The revision challenges eviction under Section 11(3) of the Act granted to the landlord in R.C.P.No.105 of 2016 by the Rent Control Court (Additional Munsiff), Thiruvananthapuram, and affirmed by the Rent Control Appellate Authority in R.C.A.No.14 of 2019. The landlord sought eviction to expand his ready-made garment business, aided by his daughter-in-law who designs garments. The Rent Control Court found the need bona fide, holding the provisos to Section 11(3) inapplicable and the tenant did not deserve protection under the second proviso. The tenant contended that the ground really falls under Section 11(8) (additional accommodation) and urged that the authorities had conflated grounds, arguing for dismissal of the petition on that basis and challenging the bona fides, while acknowledging the concurrent findings. The High Court, after surveying the jurisprudence on bona fide requirement, Section 11(3) vs. Section 11(8), and the revisional scope under Section 20, upheld the eviction order but stayed its operation by granting six months to vacate due to the Covid-19 situation, subject to conditions including arrears deposit and an affidavit. The revision is therefore dismissed with a conditioned six-month stay.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No. 1893 of 2016 & CRL.M.C No. 7916 of 2017

CRL.M.C Nos. 1893 of 2016 & 7916 of 2017 (Sakkeeer & Chatholi Shereef v State of Kerala; Kunjahammed v State of Kerala)

This batch of two criminal miscellaneous cases (CRL.M.C. Nos. 1893 of 2016 and 7916 of 2017) arises out of CC 4/2012, in which an earlier final report and proceedings were initiated against multiple accused in connection with a 1 November 2004 incident at Karipur Airport during a reception programme for a political leader. The trial court had framed a charge against several accused under multiple IPC sections (143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 294B and 427 read with 149 IPC), and the case record reveals that the prosecution relied on a cluster of eyewitnesses who could not identify the accused; witnesses testified that they could not name the assailants and no proper test identification parade was conducted. The appellate court later acquitted many accused and held the prosecution evidence unreliable. The petitioners contend that the substratum of the prosecution has collapsed and continued trial would amount to abuse of process; they invoke the High Court’s inherent power under Section 482 Cr.P.C. and rely on Sahadevan v. State of Tamil Nadu, Moosa v. Sub Inspector of Police, and Ajith v. State of Kerala to extend relief to all accused, including those who did not appeal. The court, noting the unreliability of the evidence and the lack of proper identification procedures, ultimately exercises its inherent power to quash the proceedings against the petitioners in CC 4/2012.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 9605 OF 2022

Abdul Latheef v. Union of India and Others

Abdul Latheef, a resident of Thrissur, filed WP(C) 9605 of 2022 challenging Ext. P2 series Awards issued by the Competent Authority for Land Acquisition (CALA) under the National Highways Act for land acquisition related to highway development. The petition challenges three grounds: (A) a 6% salvage deduction from the award amount is illegal in light of the Court’s declarations in Exts. P5 and P5(a); (B) the properties are not agricultural, as evidenced by Ext. P3 certificate issued by the Local Self Government Institutions, yet the awards were valued; (C) interest has been awarded only up to 28.08.2021 though the awards are dated 18.02.2022. The Court recalls the settled principle from Usman Arif v. National Highway Authority of India (2022 (1) KLT 35) that once CALA issues awards, the authority is functus officio except for issuing additional or supplementary awards under the NH Act. The petitioners are not seeking supplemental awards but are challenging the awards themselves, and thus the remedy lies under Section 3G(5) of the NH Act, not in a writ petition. The court directs liberty to file applications under Section 3G(5) within two weeks, with an eight-month window for disposition; arguments on salvage, tenure of the property, and interest shall be considered by the statutory Arbitrator. The order emphasizes that the Arbitrator will assess the three objections with respect to Exts.P5 judgments and Usman Arif, and reflect approved interest in the resultant order, expeditiously.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 8057 OF 2022

Gobins (India) Engineering (P) Ltd. v. The Presiding Officer, Central Government Industrial Tribunal cum Labour Court, Ernakulam; and The Assistant Provident Fund Commissioner, Employees Provident Fund Organization

This writ petition challenges the orders of the Provident Fund Enforcement Commissioner (Ext. P1) and the Employees Provident Fund Appellate Tribunal (Ext. P7) concerning contributions under the Employees Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (the Act). The petitioner-employer, engaged in construction, was found to have omitted wages and to have contributed only on basic wages and select allowances, excluding other components such as House Rent Allowance (HRA), Medical, Transport, and Site allowances. The PF authorities held that these allowances formed part of basic wages for the purpose of provident fund contributions, leading to a demand of Rs. 3,99,802 with potential penalties and prosecutions. The Appellate Tribunal relied on the Supreme Court’s Regional Provident Fund Commissioner (II), West Bengal v. Vivekananda Vidyamandir and Others (2020) 17 SCC 643 and on a decision of this Court in M.S Raven Beck Solutions (India) Ltd. to treat most allowances as basic wages. The petitioner contends the Supreme Court decision is fact-specific and not in rem, and that site allowances were paid only to site workers while admin staff did not receive such allowances. The High Court reaffirms that basic wages may include allowances but must be determined with regard to the nature of duties and job roles, referring to Para 21 of the Supreme Court judgment. It directs a factual exercise by the Enforcement Officer and disposes of the petition.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C.No.1708/2019

Anil Kumar K.S. v. The State of Kerala

The petitioner, Anil Kumar K.S., is the 12th accused in Crime No.123/2011 of Pandalam Police Station, now pending as CC No.2036/2018 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Adoor. The case arises from a 12 March 2011 incident in which, following the death of Ajayakumar in a road accident caused by a tipper lorry, the accused allegedly formed an unlawful assembly with deadly weapons and set ablaze the vehicle, causing substantial losses (Rs.15,00,000) and damage to a stage carriage (Rs.5,000). Annexure-A1 is the FIR; Annexure-A2 is the charge sheet and Annexure-A3 is the judgment in CC 756/2011, in which several accused were acquitted. The prosecution’s case, once consolidated, led to charges under Sections 143, 147, 148, 435, 427 read with 149 IPC. The petitioner seeks to quash further proceedings, arguing that the substratum of the case has collapsed after acquittals, invoking the Moosa v. Sub Inspector of Police principle (2006(1) KLT 552). The State contends that involvement is a factual question for trial and cannot be foreclosed solely due to others’ acquittals. The court reviewed Annexure-A3, noting inconsistent identification by PW1 and PW3, lack of specific overt acts, delays in FIR registration, and hostile witnesses. It held that the prosecution’s case lacked convincing evidence to sustain a conviction. Relying on Moosa’s principle, the court allowed the Crl.M.C., quashing Annexure-A2 and all further proceedings in CC No.2036/2018 against the petitioner.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No.492/2020

Boyce Rubber Estates Private Limited v. Kodikuthy Sree Subramanya Swamy Temple and others

This petition under OP(C) No.492/2020 challenges the Munsiff Court, Peerumade's Ext.P9 order dated 27.01.2020 dismissing the applicant's I.A. No.1/2020 and its recasting of issues in O.S. No.231/2014, a suit for permanent prohibitory injunction over plaint schedule property A and counter-claim property B. Boyce Rubber Estates Private Limited, the plaintiff, seeks to restrain the defendants from entering the property and requests appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to identify the plaint and counter-claim properties with reference to title deeds and to locate their boundaries. The trial court, after initial issues and an suo motu recast, refused to permit the Advocate Commissioner to proceed, holding that the recasted issues did not relate to identification of the properties. The court below and the petitioner exchanged objections, but ultimately the court exercised its supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution to review Ext.P9 and to permit the work (Ext.P7). The Kerala High Court held that identification of property is mandatory in suits for injunction, relying on Pattathari Kuttiraman v. Puthukkudi Narayanan, and found the issues to be related to property identification, justifying interference to avoid multiplicity of proceedings. The High Court accordingly set aside Ext.P9, allowed Ext.P7, and directed the trial court to dispose of the suit in six months. It directed the Advocate Commissioner to identify and report, with the parties submitting work memos, and to proceed in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
OP (C) No. 752 of 2019

OP (C) No. 752 of 2019: C.P. Ragini v. M/S Kotak Securities Ltd & M/S Kotak Securities Kannur Branch

This High Court of Kerala judgment concerns an original petition under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, challenging an arbitral award passed by a Sole Arbitrator appointed by the National Stock Exchange of Chennai. The petitioner, C.P. Ragini, entered into a contract with the second respondent; disputes arose, culminating in an arbitral award. The District Judge, Thalassery, dismissed OP(Arb) No. 259/2009 on the ground that Thalassery had no territorial jurisdiction since the seat of arbitration was Chennai, directing the petition to be pursued at Chennai. The petitioner contends that Ext P3 is erroneous and contrary to law; the petition under Sec.34 cannot be entertained by a court lacking jurisdiction over the arbitration proceedings. The respondents counter that the seat at Chennai consitutes exclusive jurisdiction for the arbitration, thereby depriving Thalassery of jurisdiction. The court cites evolving jurisprudence on the concept of the juridical seat, exclusive jurisdiction, and non-obstante provisions under the Arbitration Act. It relies on BBR (India) Private Ltd v. S.P. Singla Constructions Private Ltd, Inox Renewables Ltd v. Jayesh Electricals Ltd, BALCO, Indus Mobile Distribution, and BGS SGS Soma to crystallize the seat-based framework. Ultimately, the petition is allowed in part: Ext P3 is set aside; OP(Arb) No.259/2009 is to be returned to the petitioner and re-presented in Chennai within 14 days; a one-month stay is granted on related proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
W. P. (C) No. 7193 of 2019

W. P. (C) No. 7193 of 2019

The petitioner, B.S. Syamkumar, an environmentalist and public-spirited citizen, seeks a writ of mandamus to compel the respondents to implement a ban on the manufacture, storage, transportation, import, use and sale of PVC Flex in Kerala and to ensure that only eco-friendly materials are used in election campaigns in the state. He argues PVC Flex is highly environmentally hazardous: its production emits toxic gases, it is non-biodegradable and non-recyclable, and its disposal (burning) releases carcinogenic chlorine, dioxins and furans, while burial risks water contamination through leaching. After submitting a detailed representation to the Chief Secretary, with no substantive response, he invoked Article 226 of the Constitution. The court recalls a 2021 Kerala High Court judgment in W.P. (C) No. 5218 of 2012 and connected petitions that directed removal of unauthorised arches, hoardings and banners and mandated state agencies to enforce road-safety and environmental norms, while requiring related authorities to act against nuisances and promote safer, pollution-free advertising. It also notes a similar issue before the Supreme Court in W. Edwin Willson v. Union of India (Civil Appeal No. 9677 of 2019) with a pending SLP. The bench holds that the 2021 directions are squarely applicable and disposes of the petition accordingly, directing authorities to remove unauthorised outdoor advertisements and to pursue eco-friendly advertising and road-safety measures.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 2195 of 2008

Sundaresan v. State of Kerala

The accused Sundaresan was convicted under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possessing 6 litres of arrack, based on seizure and chemical analysis, in Sessions Case No.1142/2006, and sentenced to two years' rigorous imprisonment with a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The Kerala High Court, while hearing Crl.A. No. 2195 of 2008 on 6 June 2022, re-examined the validity of the chain of custody and the link between the seized contraband and the sample analysed at the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory. The defense argued that no evidence showed the contraband was produced in court, the sample tested was not necessarily the same substance seized, and there was inordinate delay in producing properties, with the seizure mahazar lacking seal particulars, the forwarding note silent about the recipient, and transit officials not examined. The court relied on established authorities (Ravi v. State of Kerala; Sasidharan; Sathi; Kumaran) that tampering risk arises if the chain of custody is not properly proven. It held that the prosecution failed to prove that the sample tested was the exact sample seized, and that delay and missing witness/examined officials undermined integrity. Result: the conviction is set aside; the accused is acquitted and the appeal is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 2023 of 2008

Ratheesh v. State of Kerala

Ratheesh v. State of Kerala is a criminal appeal under the Abkari Act heard by a Kerala High Court bench led by Justice K. Babu. The appellant was convicted under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possession of 3 litres of arrack in a 5-litre can in Kathampotta, Melarcode, Palakkad district, on 01.11.2006. He was sentenced to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh by the Additional Sessions Court (Ad-hoc I), Palakkad. On appeal, the defense attacked the prosecution’s evidence, focusing on the chain of custody and tamper-proof despatch of the sample to the laboratory. The trial- and appellate-court documents revealed deficiencies: the forwarding note (Ext. P4) lacked the name of the forwarding officer, the date of despatch, and a property list; key custodians (the property clerk and Excise Guard) were not examined to prove tamper-proof despatch; Ext. P5 (Certificate of Chemical Analysis) received no link to the exact sample seized. Relying on Kumaran v. State of Kerala, Sasidharan v. State of Kerala, Sathi v. State of Kerala, Ravi v. State of Kerala, and Vijay Pandey v. State of U.P., the court held that the chain of custody could not be established and the laboratory report could not conclusively prove the guilt. The appeal is allowed; the conviction and sentence are set aside, and the accused is acquitted and set at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos. 2203/2022, 2205/2022, 2206/2022

Majeesh C.T v State of Kerala

These bail applications arise from three distinct FIRs registered in Kottarakkara, Vaikom and Punalur police stations against Majeesh C.T. for allegedly obtaining vehicles from defacto complainants through Facebook, under a written agreement to return the vehicles on a specified date, but not returning them. The petitioner seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC, contending that even if the allegations are accepted, the offences under Section 420 IPC are not made out, as the acts may reflect a breach of contract rather than a dishonest intention to cheat. He submits that he is ready to abide by conditions imposed by the court and to cooperate with the investigation. The Public Prosecutor counters that the offences are serious, that the applicant has been arrested in multiple cases and there are several cases pending, and that bail should not be granted given the risk of flight and interference with investigation. The court notes the principle that bail is the rule and jail the exception, citing the Supreme Court in Chidambaram P. v. Directorate of Enforcement, and proceeds to consider the circumstances. It ultimately grants bail in all three petitions, with a bond of Rs.50,000 and two solvent sureties, and imposes standard conditions including appearance before the investigating officer, cooperation with police, not leaving the country, and refraining from committing similar offences. The Court also indicates that failure to comply can lead to cancellation of bail, and the prosecution or victim may move the court to cancel bail if violations occur.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.A No.2230 of 2008

Sreedharan v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal by Sreedharan challenging his conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possessing 45 litres of arrack at a toddy shop in Kumarapuram. The Trial Court convicted him and sentenced two years' simple imprisonment with a Rs 1 lakh fine, while co-accused were acquitted. On appeal, the High Court undertook a detailed appraisal of the chain of evidence, focusing on the integrity of the sample tested in the Chemical Examiner's laboratory. The court scrutinized delays in forwarding the seized properties, the absence of the specimen seal, and the failure to examine officials who handled the sample from seizure to lab, suggesting possible tampering and undermining the integrity of the evidence. Citing Ravi v. State of Kerala and Sasidharan v. State of Kerala, the court held that production of the property should be promptly reported to the court and that the chain of custody must be demonstrated; the absence of a tamper-proof chain renders the chemical analysis unreliable. It emphasized that the contraband sample tested in the lab must be the same sample drawn from the seized contraband. Due to these deficiencies, the court acquitted the appellant, set aside the conviction, and allowed the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
ITA No. 1 of 2022

Sahyadri Agencies Limited v. Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Thrissur

The appeal under Section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 arises from ITA 439/Coch/2019 (Tribunal) and concerns AY 2014-15. Sahyadri Agencies Limited, the assessee, challenged the ITAT Cochin Bench’s 2019 order on ITA No.439/Coch/2019 in ITA No.1/2022 before the Kerala High Court. The assessee’s return for 2014-15 was filed on 29.09.2014 and initially processed with a refund of Rs. 6,92,550. The case was selected for limited scrutiny under Computer Aided Scrutiny Selection (CASS) on two points: significant interest expenses related to exempt income under section 14A and substantial interest paid not commensurate with loans raised and turnover. On 16.12.2016, assessment under section 143(3) determined total income of Rs. 14,97,304. The Commissioner of Income Tax issued a notice under section 263 alleging omissions in the assessment, notably relating to the issue of 30,00,000 optionally convertible cumulative preference shares to a director and the corresponding treatment of securities premium under sections 56(2)(viib) and 68, with Rule 11UA for valuation. The Commissioner directed the AO to verify these aspects and re-do the assessment, after hearing the assessee. The Tribunal dismissed the assessee’s appeal, and the present challenge argues that limited scrutiny cannot be expanded beyond the two points without proper permission, and that the Tribunal erred by supplementing grounds not relied upon by the Commissioner. The High Court ultimately remitted questions 4 and 5 to the Tribunal for fresh consideration and allowed the appeal, with questions 1–3 decided in favor of the Revenue. The final disposition is an allowed ITA with remand for aforestated issues.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev Nos.33/2021, 50/2021, 52/2021, 51/2021, 48/2021, 49/2021

State of Kerala v Malanad Gold Balussery, Kozhikode

This batch of OT Rev (VAT) petitions before the Kerala High Court arises from challenges to a common order of the Appellate Tribunal (VAT) dated 19.08.2020, in a set of cases under the KVAT Act dealing with compounding tax under Section 8(f). The Revenue, i.e., the State of Kerala, contends that the Tribunal erred in setting aside assessment orders for multiple years and in remitting the matter for fresh disposal, and that the re-fixation of compounded tax for 2012–13 to 2016–17 based on the 2011–12 order is unsustainable where the 2011–12 assessment was barred by limitation. The Dealer (Malanad Gold Balussery) relies on decisions and interpretations that the 8(f) provisions determine the compounded rate on the highest tax payable in the preceding three years, considering returns, accounts, or tax paid, and on the interpretive guidance from a Full Bench Reference (S.T. Rev. 21/2014) regarding the words “paid” and “payable.” The court also cites Baiju A A v. State Tax Officer and W.A. No. 48/2020 to support the interpretive framework. The judgment holds that the Tribunal’s approach extending the limitation bar to subsequent years is not sustainable and that the compounded tax for later years can be determined from the dealer’s books/returns, with the matters remitted for fresh adjudication. The bench, being a Division Bench, disposes of the batch by setting aside the Tribunal’s findings and remitting for fresh disposal, with no costs.”

High Court of Kerala
Criminal Appeal No. 2280 of 2007

Jayaram v. State of Kerala

The appellant, Jayaram, challenged a conviction under section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possession of 1 ¼ litres of illicit arrack found at Keerithodu, Idukki on 26 July 2004. The trial court sentenced him to three months’ simple imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. On appeal, the Kerala High Court scrutinized the prosecution’s handling of seized contraband and the chain of custody, highlighting delays in producing properties to the court and questioning whether the sample eventually reached the chemical examiner in tamper-proof condition. Relying on Ravi v. State of Kerala, the court held that production of seized material should occur without unnecessary delay and require explanation for any delay, and noted that unexplained delays open room for tampering. The court also invoked State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram and Sasidharan v. State of Kerala to emphasize the necessity of a tamper-proof chain when the sample changes hands and to safeguard the integrity of the evidence. Santhosh v. State of Kerala and Rafeeque v. Sub Inspector of Police were cited to illustrate anomalies such as the presence of crime numbers in arrest memos, which cast doubt on the genesis of the seizure. Ultimately, the court found the prosecution failed to prove that the seized contraband reached the chemical examiner in its original, untampered form, acquitting the appellant and allowing the appeal.

High Court of Kerala
CUS.APPEAL NO. 25 OF 2018

Commissioner of Customs, Cochin v. M/s Kerala Horticultural Development Programme

This Kerala High Court judgment, delivered by Hon’ble Justices S. V. Bhatti and Basant Balaji Monday on 29 August 2022, concerns a Customs Appeal filed by the Commissioner of Customs, Cochin, challenging a CESTAT order of 07.12.2017 that allowed exemption under Notification No. 148/1994-Customs for imported fruit processing plants by M/s Kerala Horticultural Development Programme. The plants were imported between 12.11.1996 and 09.01.1998 from Italy, with the importer seeking duty exemption on the basis that the goods were gifted free of cost under a bilateral agreement with a foreign government (European Union). The department assessed and demanded duty of Rs. 4,54,10,258/-, while the respondent claimed exemption, which had been previously rejected and then allowed by CESTAT. The main legal issues: whether the EU grant constitutes a “gift” under the exemption notification and whether the CESTAT’s liberal interpretation complied with the principle that exemption notifications must be interpreted strictly. The appellant contends that the goods were not gifted free of cost and that primary documents establishing such a gift are unavailable; hence the exemption claim is untenable. The respondents argue that the grant from the EU satisfies the notification’s gift criterion. The High Court upholds the maintainability of the appeal under Section 130C, sets aside the CESTAT’s findings as per law, and remands the matter to CESTAT for fresh disposal within four months, with directions to decide the exemption issue strictly on the available documents. The appeal is allowed, and no costs are awarded.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2525 OF 2007

Rajesh s/o SASI v. State of Kerala

Rajesh, the sole accused in SC No.29/2005 of the IV Additional Sessions Court, Ernakulam, was convicted under Section 20(b)(ii)B of the NDPS Act for possessing 5 kg of ganja concealed in a large shopper. The Kerala High Court delivered its judgment on 16 August 2022, hearing the criminal appeal under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C. The trial court had convicted him and sentenced him to three years of rigorous imprisonment with a fine of Rs. 50,000; in default, one year more. The prosecution relied on witnesses PWs 1–6 and Exts P1–P11; Ext D1 (the crime index) was marked. The defense challenged the conviction on grounds of non-compliance with Section 50 of the NDPS Act, arguing that Exts P4 and P4(a) were not produced with the final report and that Section 50 compliance was not established. They also contended that the Tahsildar’s presence at the time of search was not proven and that independent witness testimony cast doubt on the search. The court discussed Section 50, noting it applies to personal searches rather than searches of baggage, and relied on statements of PW5 (the Tahsildar) to assess the search. Ultimately, the court allowed the appeal in part, upheld the conviction, and reduced the sentence to two years’ imprisonment and Rs. 30,000 fine, with default imprisonment of six months, canceling suspended sentence and bail bonds and directing surrender within 14 days for the modified sentence.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. NO. 384 OF 2015 & 5684 OF 2021

CRL.M.C. NO. 384 OF 2015 & 5684 OF 2021

These connected criminal miscellaneous petitions under Section 482 CrPC challenge the proceedings in CC 115/2015 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court – I, Perinthalmanna, arising from FIR 1847/2013 of Perinthalmanna Police Station. Petitioners-accused 4, 5 and 7 in CC 115/2015 (Kunhimoideen, Haseena, Naseema) and the 3rd accused Khadeeja in CRL.M.C. No. 5684/2021 seek quashing on several grounds. They contend that the allegations of prostitution are incorrect or not proved, and that the charge sheet was laid by the Inspector of Police, Pandikkad, who is not an authorised officer for the Perinthalmanna area under Section 13 of the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956; there was no proper authorisation to transfer the investigation; evidence is insufficient to establish “carrying on prostitution” under Sections 2(f) and 7; and reliance on prior related orders (e.g., Joseph v State of Kerala). The State counters that quashing would undermine enforcement and that the record, including 17 witnesses, justifies the prosecution. The learned Judge examines the territorial competence under Section 13(1) and the Government notification designating Perinthalmanna for an authorised officer, concluding that Pandikkad’s inspector is incompetent for Perinthalmanna jurisdiction and the investigation cannot satisfy legal requirements. Citing Delhi Administration v Ram Singh and Radhakrishnan v State of Kerala, the Court holds that the evidence does not establish prostitution and that the offences under the IT Act cannot stand. The petitions are allowed; the entire proceedings are quashed and the petitioners exonerated.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 8681 of 2022

P.S. Koshy (Petitioner) v. The Principal Secretary, Directorate of Industries and Commerce; The Managing Director, Silk Industries Kerala Ltd.; The Manager, Silk Steel Fabrication Unit, Silk Industries Kerala Ltd.

This writ petition (W.P.(C) No.8681 of 2022) filed in the Kerala High Court by P.S. Koshy, proprietor of Straight Line Engineering Works, challenges the unilateral termination of a contract for installing a 1600-ton sulfuric acid storage tank at Travancore Titanium Products Ltd. The contract, awarded by SILK on 02 May 2019, involved unloading, leading, erection, welding, painting and testing. Koshy alleges prompt performance by his team but blames respondents 2 and 3 for delaying materials and support, resulting in the contract’s termination on 24 January 2020 and partial payment with substantial outstanding sums. He seeks mandamus to re-calculate payments based on the work order (Exhibit P1) and extra work (Exhibit P12) and to disburse the due amounts. Respondents contend the dispute is contractual in nature, not suitable for a writ under Article 226, citing precedents on maintainability (including Kalathil, Bihar/Jain Plastics, and Jose). On merits, the respondents claim the work should have completed by 02.08.2019, delays were caused by the petitioner, and the SILK extended the timeline before terminating. The court ultimately dismisses the petition, holding no public-law element and relying on Jain Plastics’ view that contract disputes belong in civil courts despite the petitioner's arguments. Exhibits P1–P12 are referenced in the appendix.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 92 OF 2014

Achu @ Achuthan v. State of Kerala

This criminal appeal challenges the conviction of Achu @ Achuthan under Section 8(2) of the Kerala Abkari Act for possession of five litres of arrack on 19 April 2011. PW1, an Excise Inspector, and PW2, a Preventive Officer, testified that they intercepted the appellant along the Muthuthala–Pattambi road, found a plastic container containing arrack, and prepared arrest and seizure documents (Exts. P1–P4). The matter was sent to the Judicial Magistrate under Section 50 of the Abkari Act and ultimately tried by the Additional Sessions Court, Palakkad. PW3 and PW5 appeared as attestors to Ext. P3 seizure mahazar, but their evidence was contested because they allegedly signed Ext. P3 at a different place, and some witnesses turned hostile. The trial court ruled that independent corroboration was not required where the evidence of the witnesses inspires confidence; it relied on PW1 and PW2 and the documentary materials, including Ext. P9 (chemical examination). Abdul Rasheed v. State of Kerala (2008) and Karamjit Singh v. State (Delhi Administration) were cited to support the treatment of police testimony and the credibility of single-source evidence. The Sessions Judge convicted the accused, and the High Court dismissed the appeal in a preliminary order. The present judgment confirms the conviction and sentence, and directs surrender by 18 July 2022.