Cus.Appeal Nos.11/2018, 28/2018, 30/2018, 32/2018, 33/2018, 34/2018, 41/2018 This batch of Kerala High Court Customs Appeals concerns the entitlement of an importer to exemptions under the Served from India Scheme (SFIS) for an MRI scanner imported in 2006 valued at about Rs 3.59 crore. The Revenue (Commissioner of Customs, Cochin) challenging an order of the Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal, which allowed the importer’s appeal and granted exemption from payment of certain duties under Notification Nos. 92/2004 and 20/2006. The central issue is whether SAD (Special Additional Duty) and Education Cess could be exempted under the SFIS regime when the goods were otherwise exempt from basic Customs Duty (BCD) and CVD, and whether the SFIS credit balance was sufficient to cover the duty payable. The Tribunal concluded that the importer was entitled to the exemption by excluding Education Cess and SAD from the duty, applying the notification framework and relying on Gujarat Ambuja Exports Ltd. and Pasupati Acrylon Ltd principles. The Revenue contends that exemptions are not unconditional and that the Tribunal erred in excluding CVD, Education Cess and SAD from the calculation. The Court examined Notifications 92/2004, 20/2006 and related Circular No. 18/2006 and held that Notification 20/2006 provides SAD exemption where goods are exempt from basic duty and CVD; on this basis the appeals were dismissed, upholding the Tribunal’s view and determining the correct computation of SFIS credits.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case challenging Annexure-D, an order of the III Additional District & Sessions Judge, Kozhikode, in which the Public Prosecutor’s application under Section 321 Cr.P.C to withdraw the prosecution in SC No. 731 of 2016 was dismissed. The accused persons faced offences under sections 143, 147, 148, 323, 324, 283, 332 and 308 read with 149 IPC, arising from an incident on 24 December 2015 in which police personnel were assaulted by eight men and others during routine investigation; three police officers were injured. The Public Prosecutor moved to withdraw the prosecution, arguing that the materials on record were insufficient to ensure conviction, that the accused are youngsters, that withdrawal would preserve public harmony, that injuries to the police were not serious, and that the record did not establish that police officers were on duty. The Sessions Court dismissed the application, after considering objections of injured witnesses. The applicants relied on Sheo Nandan Paswan and Rajendar Jain line of precedents establishing that withdrawal is an executive action requiring Court consent and should be allowed only if in the interest of justice; The State argued that the court must evaluate grounds and ensure that withdrawal does not stifle justice and should not be allowed based on extraneous grounds. The High Court concluded that the Public Prosecutor did not apply his mind to the materials and upheld the Sessions Court’s denial of withdrawal; the petition was dismissed and the order remained in force.
The petitioner, T. Krishnakumar, occupies shop XIII/431 in the Devaswom Building at Kodungallur near the Kodungallur Bhagavathi Temple, running the Annapoorna hotel. The shop belongs to the Cochin Devaswom Board (CDB). Ext.P1 (dated 28.09.2007) fixed monthly rent at Rs. 3,370 for a 64.57 sq.m. shop, for a three-year term from 01.02.2007, and Ext.P3 shows the petitioner remitted rent at Rs. 6,989 for November 2021 and offered to continue at that level if renewed under a lower rate. Due to Covid-19, pilgrim inflow plummeted, and the petitioner requested a three-year rent revision at a lower rate in Ext.P3. Ext.P4 (22.01.2022) refused the request, citing bye-law mandating an 11% increase every 11 months and noting the Board’s claim that income from Devaswom buildings is modest. The petitioner argues that the Board cannot behave as an ordinary landlord; he relies on the Division Bench ruling in Dr. N.M. Vijayan v. Cochin Devaswom Board (Ext.P2) that rent fixation must be tempered and that 15–20% increases over three years were acceptable. He also contends that Ext.P4 violates natural justice and that the building’s enlarged occupancy (alleged encroachment) requires scrutiny. The Board counters that the area is commercially vital, that audit reports justify rent revisions, and that the Board, as trustee, must generate income while safeguarding Devaswom interests. The court ultimately dismisses the petition but directs further enquiry by the Chief Vigilance Officer and reporting within a set period, underscoring the Devaswom Board’s trustee duties and the need to balance income generation with protection of temple properties.
WP(C) Nos. 7284 of 2022 and 13482 of 2022 The Kerala High Court, N. Nagareesh, adjudicates two concurrent writ petitions challenging the extension of licences to operate a slaughter house and meat stall by the Kattappana Municipality for 2022-23. The petitioners, Shareef K.K. (WP(C) 7284/2022) and Roy Mathew (WP(C) 13482/2022), contend that the Municipal Council, in its 18 February 2022 meeting, went beyond the agenda by extending licences to the existing licencees without inviting a public tender, despite higher offers from others. They argue that public auctions should ordinarily govern State largesse and that extensions require enabling provisions under the Municipalities Act or its Rules; they cite higher offers (up to 16%) and a comparatively lower extension rate (10-11%) as evidence of arbitrariness. The respondents counter that the 2020-21 disruptions and Covid-19 payments, ongoing threat of litigation, timely fee payments by current licencees, and overall public interest justified a one-year extension at a 10% increase, a position supported by consideration of offers and prior conduct. The Court recalls Manojkumar K.M. and others, and Marykutty George, to frame the scope of tender vs. renewal, ultimately holding that the renewal without auction can be permissible in the best interests of the Panchayat, and declines to interfere, dismissing the petitions.
W.P. (C) No. 6501 of 2022 Leena A., an LPSA in an Aided Lower Primary School at Kottopadam East, was appointed to an additional division vacancy on 15 July 2008. She challenges the non-approval of her appointment from the date of appointment, arguing that successive Government orders shaped the legal regime for protected teachers. The Government imposed a ban on appointments to additional division vacancies by GO (P) 317/2005/G.Edn and, later, the ban was lifted by GO (P) 10/10/G.Edn (12 January 2010) subject to conditions. One condition required managers to execute a bond, while a comprehensive package for deployed/protected teachers was approved by GO (P) 199/2011/G.Edn (01 June 2011). The petitioner was included in the package and her appointment was regularised from 01 June 2011. She contends that in several cases this Court has directed appointment from the date of appointment and deemed the bond to be executed despite the absence of a formal bond. The Government Pleader contends that appointments in such vacancies must be apportioned 1:1 and, where bonds are not executed, the manager should have executed one. The court notes the Suma Devi doctrine that non‑execution of a bond by managers can be treated as executed, permits proceeding, and directs the 1st respondent to decide Exhibit P5 in light of that doctrine, subject to Apex Court orders. The writ petition is disposed of with directions, including expeditious action within four months.
This Kerala High Court writ petition concerns the occupancy of shop rooms in the Puthiyakavu Devaswom Shopping Complex, owned by the Travancore Devaswom Board. The petitioners challenge several notices (Exts. P4, P4(a), P4(b)) that purportedly impose a near-100% rent hike and a large additional deposit, alleging these are styled as licence fees and breaches of the court-ordered 10% annual rent increase. They also challenge Exts. P5, P5(a), P5(b) notices and pray for certiorari to quash them, a mandamus to receive rent at the existing rate with a 10% yearly hike, and renewal of leases, while opposing unilateral conversion of leases into licences. The respondents defend rent redetermination as part of the Board’s fiduciary duty to protect Devaswoms and generate revenue, citing the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 and a Board policy based on the Delhi Schedule of Rates (DSR). They rely on precedents including Travancore Devaswom Board v. Thanath International, V. Haridasan Pillai, and other Kerala and Supreme Court decisions on fiduciary duties and protection of temple properties. The Court ultimately directs refixation of market rent by the Devaswom Commissioner within two months, with hearing, and obtain Board approval within one more month, ensuring rents are not below market rates; the petition is disposed without costs.
The appellant, Pulikun nel Sasidharan, was convicted under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act and sentenced to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh for transporting 20 litres of illicit arrack in an auto rickshaw on 01.01.2000 at Kolayad, Kannur District. The Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-III), Thalassery, tried the accused in Sessions Case No.472 of 2003 and convicted him. The High Court of Kerala, in this criminal appeal (Crl.A No.2177 of 2008) heard on 01.06.2022, analyzed two core challenges raised by the defence: (i) unexplained delay in producing the seized properties and the sample to the court, and (ii) failure to establish that the contraband sample tested at the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory was the same sample seized at the place of occurrence. The Court reviewed a body of precedents—Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Bhaskaran, Rajamma, Ramachandran, Vijay Pandey, and Daulat Ram—emphasizing the necessity of a tamper-proof chain of custody and immediate, well-documented forwarding of samples, including production of the specimen seal. It held that the prosecution failed to establish a reliable link between the seized contraband and the laboratory analysis, and that essential custodial and documentary evidence were missing. Consequently, the conviction could not be sustained and the accused was acquitted; the appeal was allowed.
This criminal appeal challenges a 2008 conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possession of 3 litres of arrack found on 07.12.2004. The trial court convicted the appellant after a trial and sentenced him to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. On appeal, the appellant contends that the arrest of the accused is doubtful because the arrest memo and arrest intimation were not produced, and that the prosecution failed to prove that the contraband was subjected to Chemical Examiner’s analysis. The court evaluates the prosecution’s theory in light of established procedures and precedents—D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal mandating an arrest memo with attestation and countersignature; Ramankutty v. Excise Inspector, Chelannur Range, holding that non-compliance with mandatory arrest requirements undermines the prosecution; Krishnadas v. State of Kerala emphasizing suspicious delays in laboratory analysis. It is noted that the arrest memo and related documents were not produced, and key officials involved in handling the seized sample were not examined, raising concerns about tampering and chain of custody. The sample’s analysis was delayed by about 18 months without explanation. Consequently, the court finds the link between the accused and the contraband unsustained, and Ext. P10 has no evidentiary value. The conviction is set aside; the appellant is acquitted and set at liberty, with deposited sums to be disbursed to him.
The State Bank of India (SBI), a nationalised bank, filed this writ petition to compel the Sub Registrar at Kundara to register Ext. P3 Sale Certificate issued in favour of the auction purchaser, under the SARFAESI Act, despite a Civil Court attachment over the property. SBI contended that the attachment post-dates the bank’s equitable mortgage (15.07.2013) and that subsequent attachments cannot impede its right to sell, as recognized in established precedents, notably Keechery Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Sajitha Nizar alias Sajitha P.M. The attached certificate (Ext. P6) shows an attachment dated 20.12.2014, after the mortgage; SBI urged that Ext. P3 be registered de hors the attachment and the attachment entries erased. Respondents argued the petition is not maintainable since an attachment exists through a valid civil process and the bank may recover remedies; the 3rd respondent claimed only a portion of the assets were mortgaged. The court, aligning with prior jurisprudence, held that if an equitable mortgage predates an attachment, the latter cannot override the former. It directed a hearing to resolve the extents of the mortgage and to decide on Ext. P3 after evaluation of documents, and to register Ext. P3 de hors the attachment if the property is covered by the mortgage, all within a month, with liberty for the 3rd respondent to pursue remedies. The order ultimately favours SBI with a measured directive to balance rights of all parties.
This Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case concerns the quashing of proceedings initiated against the second accused, J. KuriaKose, in CC No. 906/2009 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-I, North Paravur. The first accused, then Circle Inspector, is alleged to have assaulted the complainant during detention on 13.02.2008; the second accused allegedly witnessed without intervening and was arrested earlier. Cognizance was taken on the Annexure-A private complaint for offences under sections 323, 330, 506, and 294(b) read with section 34 IPC. The petitioner argues lack of sanction under Section 197 Cr.P.C. for prosecuting a public servant, and contends that the averments do not clearly implicate him in the alleged assault, as he was only a spectator and at the relevant time was in custody. The State and the 1st respondent counter that sanction is not required if the act is not connected to the official duties, and further contend that the Annexure-A allegations suffice to implicate the petitioner. The High Court relies on the Supreme Court’s decision in D. Devaraja v. Owais Sabeer Hussain (2020) 7 SCC 695, which holds that sanction is required when alleged acts are connected with the discharge of official duty, or performed under colour of duty. On this basis, the court concludes that cognizance without sanction is vitiated and quashes the proceedings against the petitioner, while allowing the complainant to pursue sanction for prosecution against him."
This High Court of Kerala decision concerns Crl.A.307/2022 challenging an order dated 17 January 2022 by the Special Court for Trial of NIA cases, Ernakulam. The appellant, Suresh Raj, sixth accused in RC 01/2021/NIA/KOC, contends that custodial torture to extract a confession constitutes an offence under Section 195-A IPC read with Section 195(1)(b) Cr.P.C and that the Special Court should have proceeded under Section 340 Cr.P.C. instead of forwarding the complaint to the Chief Judicial Magistrate for inquiry under Section 200 Cr.P.C. The National Investigation Agency (NIA) counters that Section 195-A targets giving false evidence by a witness and is not attracted here; the alleged torture would fall under IPC sections 330/331 depending on injury and thus not within 195(1)(b); further, Section 340 is inapplicable because the alleged offence is not committed in or in relation to proceedings in that court. The bench notes that Annexure-5’s allegations do not show threats to make the appellant an approver; thus Section 195-A is not triggered. It also observes that the appellant withdrew his complaint, albeit leaving open the option to pursue other remedies. It ultimately holds that the 340 Cr.P.C path is not applicable, approves forwarding to 200 Cr.P.C, and dismisses the appeal.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No.1814 of 2022) decided by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court, examining a challenge to Annexure-2 (CRL.M.P. No.1043/2022) filed in the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Chavakkad. The petitioner, C. Premanandakrishnan, the Station House Officer (SHO) of Guruvayoor Temple Police Station, seeks to quash the private complaint lodged by the 2nd respondent, Vijaya Kumar, against him, alleging offences under IPC sections 383, 506, 190, 200, 211, 217, 341 and 352, read with Kerala Police Act sections 115 and 116(c). The Magistrate had referred Annexure-2 for investigation under Section 156(3) CrPC to the SHO, with a directive to register an FIR and, if a crime already existed on similar facts, to append the complaint to that file. The petitioner argues this is improper because the accused is the SHO of the very station, and directing an investigation by an officer who is himself the subject of the complaint corrupts the process; relying on CrPC Section 2(o), it is argued that an alternate officer should handle such a reference. The State counters that there is no impropriety; the officer next in rank may perform duties when the SHO is unavailable. The High Court, applying Supreme Court jurisprudence on the necessity of application of mind, affidavits with private complaints, and careful handling of 156(3) referrals, finds the order lacking due consideration and set-aside the Magistrate’s order. The Court directs a fresh, law-compliant order after due scrutiny of the Annexure-A2 contents. The matter is disposed of accordingly with directions to re-assess under the guiding principles from Ramdev Food, Maksud Sayed, Anil Kumar, and Priyanka Srivastava.
This is a criminal appeal by the accused challenging a conviction under section 8(2) of the Abkari Act. The appellant was found in possession of 3 litres of arrack near a culvert on 5 April 2004 and was convicted by the Trial Court; the Additional Sessions (Adhoc) Court-I, Palakkad, sentenced him to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a Rs 1 lakh fine. The prosecution examined five witnesses and produced exhibits including the seizure mahazar, sample and chemical report. On 25 May 2022, the Kerala High Court, sitting as a single judge, allowed the appeal and acquitted the accused, holding that the prosecution failed to establish an unbroken chain of custody and the link between the seized sample and the laboratory analysis. The court found unexplained delay in forwarding the seized properties to the court; the arrest memo contained the crime number, casting doubt on the genesis of the case; and there was no satisfactory explanation for delays in forwarding the contraband. It relied on Ravi v. State of Kerala and Sasidharan, Sathi and Bhaskaran K. to underscore the legal obligations and the need for proper seals and tamper-proof handling. Ultimately, the court held that the circumstantial evidence did not connect the accused to the contraband, and the conviction could not stand; the appellant is acquitted and set at liberty.
WA No. 288 of 2022 arises from a challenge by the State of Kerala against a single-judge order in W.P.C. 15415 of 2020 directing the University to promote the writ petitioner, Dr. John Panicker, to Senior Lecturer in Hindi with effect from 19-08-2000 and to grant all other consequential promotions and benefits. The petitioner, initially appointed as Junior Lecturer (Pre-degree) and later redeployed to St. Gregorios College before re-entry into collegiate service, argued that the UGC Career Advancement Scheme (CAS) entitled him to placement as a Senior Scale Lecturer from 2000 and further as a Selection Grade Lecturer thereafter, counting six years of service including pre-degree work. The State and its officers contended that the post of Junior Lecturer (Pre-degree) is not an equivalent cadre to Lecturer, that the V and VI UGC Schemes did not provide for counting pre-degree service, and that the petitioner joined collegiate service only in 2011; Ext. P14 and Ext. P24 (2017/2020) were relied upon to challenge the claim. The learned Single Judge held in the petitioner’s favour, recognizing CAS eligibility and discrimination against similarly placed teachers. The Division Bench reversed, holding that pre-degree service cannot be counted for CAS, and that Ext. P14 must be construed strictly; it also noted that Ext. P24 was applied retroactively in error and directed uniform implementation. The WA is allowed and the writ petition dismissed, with directions to implement Ext. P24 in all such cases.
Challenge in this Original Petition, filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, is to the district court's order dated 05.03.2022 in I.A.No.3/2022 in A.S.No.10/2022 before the Additional District Court – IV, Kottayam, granting interim relief regarding the plaint schedule 'B' pathway. The sequence of suits began with Sumesh and Shibu Sainudeen filing O.S. No. 218/2004 for permanent prohibitory injunction to declare the 'B' schedule property a public road; in O.S. No. 90/2015, respondents sought declaration and permanent injunction against the petitioners and Respondent No.5. The Trial Court decreed O.S.218/2004 in the petitioners' favour, declaring the 'B' schedule path a public road and granted injunction, while dismissing the other suit. After the decree, steps on the property were removed and partially demolished. On appeal, the district court considered two interlocutory applications and, on 05.03.2022, restrained the petitioners from destroying or altering the property and allowed respondents to restore it to its original position under supervision. The petitioners contended that the district court did not carefully apply Dorab Cawasji Warden guidelines on interim mandatory injunction and overlooked comparative hardship and the right of enjoyment. The High Court concurs that the district court's order requires fresh evaluation under the cited principles and accordingly sets aside the order with direction to decide afresh, disposing of the petition thereafter.
This Original Petition (Article 227) challenges the 2021 CMA 28/2020 judgment of the Additional District Court, North Paravur, which in turn upheld a trial court order granting a temporary injunction in O.S. 322/2020 before the Munsiff Court, Aluva. The plaintiffs, Sunny (Plaintiff No.1), Paul Joseph (Plaintiff No.2), and Mariyamkutty (Plaintiff No.3, represented by her son Sunny), sought partition of two properties designated as A and B schedule, and a permanent injunction against waste and interference with their possession. The trial court granted the injunction restraining Defendant No.1 (Kunjumon) and his men from committing waste. The District Court reversed, holding Plaintiff No.1 lacked locus standi to represent his mother and casting the partition claim as unactionable, also concluding that the suit’s framing was improper since the property description was disputed. The High Court, upon admission, set aside the District Court’s order in parts, citing Wander Limited v. Antox India and directing that the injunction order be modified to preserve the status quo and still restrain waste. It clarified that maintainability and representation can be agitated later and ordered evidence on I.A.1/2022 with the trial to be completed within three months, relegating the next stage to the trial court. The court expressly reserved its view on the merits and disposed of the petition as above.
Rajendran, the appellant, was convicted under Section 55(i) of the Abkari Act for possession of 11 litres of Indian Made Foreign Liquor for sale at Aryad. The judgment of the Additional Sessions Court (Fast Track-II), Alappuzha, dated 20 November 2008, was challenged before the Kerala High Court. The prosecution case rested on seizure of contraband liquor on 21 September 2004 and subsequent chemical analysis. The appellant contends that the prosecution failed to establish that the sample subjected to chemical analysis in the Chemical Examiner's Laboratory was the same sample seized at the place of occurrence, a requirement emphasized by Sasidharan v. State of Kerala and reflected in Daulat Ram, Sathi and Ravi decisions. The appellant argues several procedural gaps: the seizure mahazar Ext.P2 did not describe the seal affixed to the bottle; the seals' specimen was not produced; the officials who handled the sample during transit were not examined; the chain of custody was not established, so the possibility of tampering could not be ruled out; As a result, the certificate Ext.P12 of Chemical Analysis has no evidentiary value. The court relied on Bhaskaran K. v. State of Kerala and Vijay Pandey to insist that mere laboratory confirmation does not prove guilt without a proven link to the seized sample. The High Court acquitted, holding that the prosecution failed to prove the link, and thus the conviction could not stand; the appeal is allowed, and Rajendran is set at liberty.
WP(C) Nos.8727/2022; 8840/2022; 8844/2022 The three writ petitions challenge Ext.P2, communications directing the petitioners to produce land development certificates where construction is sought on plots subdivided from larger tracts. The petitioners contend that demanding a development permit is unnecessary for small extents purchased from larger holdings, and that Ext.P2 imposes an unwarranted hurdle to grant of building permits. The Kerala High Court recalls its own ruling in WA No.1288/2019, which held that buyers acquiring small extents from larger lands should not be forced to produce a development permit for building permissions; this doctrine was corroborated by a Division Bench in Nafeesa v. Chavakkad Municipality (2018(3) KLT 1). The court applies this precedent to these petitions, finding Ext.P2 untenable in the present context. Consequently, the writ petitions are allowed, Ext.P2 is set aside, and respondents are directed to consider the applicants’ building permit applications without insisting on a development permit. Necessary orders are to be issued within six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. The decision reiterates judicial safeguards for small plot purchasers against procedural impediments in development approvals.
The appellant, Unnikrishnan, was convicted under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possession of 2.5 litres of arrack seized on 01.02.2006 at Cheruppatta. The trial court sentenced him to one year of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 Lakh. The High Court allowed the criminal appeal, acquitting the accused on the ground that the prosecution failed to prove that the contraband seized was subjected to chemical analysis in the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory in a tamper‑proof manner. The prosecution relied on Ext. P2 seizure mahazar and Ext. P7 chemical analysis, but the defense highlighted deficiencies: (i) Ext. P2 did not describe the seal affixed on the sample bottle, (ii) the seal’s nature was not proved, (iii) several officials who handled the sample during transit were not examined, and (iv) there was no evidence of custody or return of the sample to secure custody. The court surveyed jurisprudence on sampling/sealing and chain of custody, citing Sasidharan v. State of Kerala, Sathi v. State of Kerala, Ravi v. State of Kerala, State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram, Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala, and Vijay Pandey v. State of U.P, among others. It held that the prosecution must link the seized sample to the tested sample; mere production of a laboratory report is insufficient. Finding no such link, the accused was entitled to benefit of doubt and was acquitted; the appeal was allowed.
The appellant, Gangadharan, challenges a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc), Fast Track Court No. I, Thrissur, in SC No.660/2007. The prosecution case rests on the appellant’s arrest on 11.11.2004 with a contraband substance and a seizure in the Thalappilly taluk. The defense argues that the arrest was not properly documented, citing the mandatory arrest memo directive in D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal, and contends that non-production of arrest memo/arrest intimation renders the arrest doubtful and undermines the chain of custody. The trial court’s conviction hinges on compliance with procedural safeguards around arrest, sampling, and the link between the seized contraband and the sample analyzed at the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory. The appellant also argued defects in the seizure mahazar, the seal description, and forwarding notes, suggesting taint in the chain of custody. The judgment analyzes whether the contraband was subjected to laboratory analysis and whether the sample tested corresponded to the sample seized. Relying on Bhaskaran K. v. State of Kerala, Rajamma v. State of Kerala, and Vijay Pandey v. State of U.P, the court emphasizes that failure to establish a tamper-proof chain of custody neutralizes the evidentiary value of the chemical analysis. Consequently, the court acquits the appellant and allows the appeal, reversing the conviction and sentence.