R.F.A. 199/2019; R.F.A. 179/2021 This Regular First Appeal group comprises R.F.A. Nos. 199/2019 and 179/2021 arising from original suits O.S. 169/2012 and O.S. 17/2017 before the Additional Sub Court, Palakkad. The matter concerns dispute over a plaint schedule property and associated arrears, rents and costs. The High Court, presided by Hon'ble Justice P. Somarajan, referred the disputes to mediation at the District Mediation Centre, Palakkad, as part of dispute resolution proceedings. Mediation spanned multiple sessions (01.12.2021, 15.12.2021, 05.01.2022, 07.01.2022, 19.01.2022) and culminated in a report that the matter was settled. The memorandum of agreement recorded terms: the appellants would accept the lower court judgments (O.S. 169/2012 and O.S. 17/2017) and surrender possession of the property to the respondent; the respondent would forgo the decree for arrears and costs; the respondent would pay Rs. 2,00,000 to the appellants as consideration, payable by the time of possession surrender (on or before 05/04/2022); the appellants would surrender possession by 05/04/2022; in default, execution could proceed; the entire court fee would be refunded to both sides. The settlement is to form part of the judgment and decree. The order disposes of the appeals in terms of settlement, with no further litigation costs. The judgment cites a Kerala High Court direction that supports refunds in settled matters, referencing M.C. Subramaniam and others (2021 (2) KHC 62).
This High Court of Kerala judgment concerns CRL.MC No.70 of 2017 filed by M.J. Vijayapadman, the printer and publisher of Mathrubhumi, seeking to quash a private criminal complaint (C.C. No.81/2016) pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pathanamthitta. The complainant, K.R. Ajithkumar, a former municipal councillor, alleged that a Mathrubhumi news item published on 01 May 2014 defamed him and other councillors by suggesting they had amassed wealth through corrupt practices. The article reportedly presented a comparative analysis of asset declarations from 2010 and 2013, based on declarations before the Returning Officer and Lok Ayukta, with a caption claiming a rise in assets. The petitioner argued that the publication merely reported declarations to promote transparency and public accountability, and did not allege illegality; consequently, it could not attract offences under Sections 499 and 500 IPC. The learned magistrate had taken cognizance, and the matter progressed to C.C.81/2016. The court scrutinized Annexures A–D and found that Annexure-B detailed asset declarations and did not contain statements imputing illegality; there was no materials showing malice or intent to defame. Relying on Mammen Mathew v. Radhakrishnan (2007) that mere publication of an imputation does not necessarily constitute defamation without intent to harm, the court held that Section 499 IPC was not attracted. It allowed the Criminal Misc. case, quashing Annexure-A’s complaint and all further proceedings, and invoked Section 482 Cr.PC as an abuse of the court’s process.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal by the sole accused Thankappan challenging a conviction under Section 58 of the Abkari Act by a Fast Track court. The evidence trail centers on seizure of 3 litres of illicit arrack on 20.12.1999 from the accused’s possession at Pannimala, Kunninpara, and the subsequent submission of a final report under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act. The trial court convicted the appellant after recording evidence from PWs 1-5 and accepting Exts P1-P9 and MO 1-2, with the defense of innocence. On appeal, the appellant’s grounds attacked the arrest as doubtful and the prosecution’s failure to prove that the contraband subjected to chemical analysis was indeed the substance seized. The court relied on prior rulings, notably Santhosh v. State of Kerala, to underscore doubts created by the arrest memo’s inclusion of a crime number, casting doubt on the genesis of the seizure and arrest. It observed serious procedural gaps: no sample was drawn at the scene, no chain-of-custody for the sample, and the Magistrate’s role in sampling violating established practice as per Baburaj, Smithesh, Baby, Bhaskaran, and related cases. Consequently, it acquitted the accused and allowed the appeal, holding that Ext. P8 (Certificate of Chemical Analysis) lacked evidentiary value and that the link between seized material and the analysed sample was not established.
ITA Nos.34 of 2018; 35 of 2018; 25 of 2019; 27 of 2019 This is a consolidated Kerala High Court judgment disposing of four ITA appeals (Nos. 34 & 35 of 2018 and Nos. 25 & 27 of 2019) arising from assessments of cooperative banks seeking deduction under Section 80P(4) of the Income Tax Act. The pivotal issue is whether a ‘primary co‑operative agricultural and rural development bank’ (PCARDB) with area of operation extending beyond a single taluk can claim deduction, in light of Finance Act 2006 amendments introducing sub‑section 80P(4) and its Explanation (b). The appellants (Kottayam and Meenachil Banks) contended that the term ‘a taluk’ should be read in the light of General Clauses Act 13(2) to include multiple taluks, thereby permitting eligibility for banks operating in more than one taluk. The respondents argued for strict, literal interpretation of Explanation (b) to 80P(4), which defines PCARDB as a society whose area of operation is confined to a taluk, and asserted that expanding the meaning would render the text otiose and create absurd results. The court, applying the golden rule of interpretation and literal meaning, held that ‘a taluk’ means a single taluk for purposes of 80P(4); expansion to multiple taluks would defeat the express language and object of the provision. Consequently, the appeals were dismissed, upholding the Revenue’s position and sustaining the ITAT/ACIT decisions. The judgment relies on various case laws to illuminate statutory interpretation but ultimately anchors on tight construing of the statute’s words.
CRL.M.C. 465/2013; CRL.M.C. 845/2014 These two criminal miscellaneous petitions arise from Crime No.1011/2011 of Mattancherry Police Station, now registered as C.C.1912/2011 in the Judicial First Class Magistrate’s Court-II, Kochi. The petitioners, accused Nos.1 to 3, challenge the final report under Section 482 Cr.P.C. alleging offences under Section 498A read with Section 34 IPC. The defacto complainant is the wife of Nasar, the petitioner in Crl.M.C. No.845/2014. The two petitions concern different combinations of co-accused: in Crl.M.C.465/2013 the mother-in-law and sister-in-law; in Crl.M.C.845/2014 the husband of the defacto complainant. The prosecution originally charged offences under Section 498A read with Section 34 IPC; Sections 406 and 420 IPC were not included after investigation. At the hearing, counsel for the petitioners argued that even if the allegations are admitted, no offence is made out and the proceedings amount to abuse of the process; the 3rd accused had no specific overt act; and the 1st accused had died, causing abatement. Counsel for the defacto complainant contended that the allegations are specific and amount to offences, and that the court cannot weigh truth at this stage. The learned Judge held that there are prima facie allegations against the 1st and 2nd accused, the 3rd accused has vague allegations, and the 2nd accused having died abates. He quashed the proceedings against the 3rd accused, held abatement for the 1st accused in 465/2013, and dismissed the 845/2014 petition, while allowing 465/2013 in part.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (CRL.A No. 2183 of 2008) arising from a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act for possession of illicit liquor. The accused, Santhosh @ Unnikrishnan, was convicted by the Additional Sessions Court (Fast Track II Adhoc), Thrissur, for possessing 1000 ml of illicit liquor on 26.02.2004 and sentenced to one year’s simple imprisonment plus a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. The prosecution relied on the seizure, the samples and their analysis, and the chain of custody. On appeal, the defense argued that the sample’s tamper-proof dispatch to the laboratory was not established, and the detecting officer did not have competent authority to make the arrest/seizure under the Abkari Act (relying on SROs and the case law on chain-of-custody). The High Court examined whether the sample’s transit and custody could be relied upon without adequate examination of transit officials, and whether the detection authority was valid. After considering State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram and Suresh v. State of Kerala, the Court found fatal flaws in the prosecution’s chain of custody and officer competence, and allowed the appeal, acquitting the accused and directing his release; deposits, if any, were to be disbursed per law.
This writ petition challenges Ext. P9, an order of supersession issued under Section 32 of the Cooperative Societies Act, in respect of the Managing Committee of City Vanitha Co-operative Society Ltd No. D.3012. The petitioners, eight remaining members of the Committee after four resigned, argue the supersession is mala fide and violative of statutory requirements—specifically lack of notice under Section 32(1) and lack of proper consultation under Section 32(2). The sequence begins with the supersession order dated 31.08.2021, followed by withdrawal of the order during the pendency of W.P.(C) No.22509/2021, with a fresh hearing contemplated. Ext. P3 issued for 03.11.2021; extensive adjournments ensued. Ext. P6, dated 25.01.2022, fixed hearing for 04.02.2022, but in the absence of timely service on all members, the third petitioner complained that notices were not properly served, triggering a finding of violation of Section 104 (service by registered post). The court further held there was no effective consultation with the Circle Co-operative Union and the financing bank, as required under Section 32(2). Consequently, Ext. P9 is quashed, and the Managing Committee is to be restored, with liberty to proceed afresh after complying with the statutory requirements.
The Kerala High Court entertained a Rent Control Revision arising from eviction proceedings under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The Rent Control Court, Ettumanoor, had ordered eviction of the petition schedule shop rooms for arrears of rent and directed deposit of arrears with interest and costs to secure eviction under Section 11(2)(c). The tenants challenged the eviction by seeking relief in RCA No.17 of 2018 before the Additional Rent Control Appellate Authority-IV, Kottayam. The Appellate Authority, by order dated 17.07.2019, dismissed I.A.933 of 2018 (condonation of delay) on the ground that Section 5 of the Limitation Act does not apply to rent-control proceedings. The tenants approached this Court in Rent Control Revision under Section 20 of the Act on 23.03.2021. The matter was admitted on 31.03.2021. The petitioners’ counsel argued that the Appellate Authority’s reasoning in dismissing I.A.933 of 2018 cannot be sustained in light of Gopakumar G. and others v. Ancy Thankachan Philip and others (2019 (3) KLT 346) and related Division Bench authority, which hold that Limitation Act principles apply to appellate proceedings under Section 18 and that Section 29(2) of the Limitation Act should be considered. The respondent-landlord relied on Constitution Bench and Kerala decisions supporting the doctrine of prospective overruling. The High Court set aside the 17.07.2019 order, allowed the revision, and directed the Appellate Authority to reconsider I.A.933 of 2018 on merits within one month of receipt of a certified copy of the judgment.
This writ petition challenges the Sub Registrar’s refusal to register the sale deed in the wake of an e-auction conducted under the SARFAESI framework. The State Bank of India (the petitioner) claims the sale certificate (Ext. P3) in favour of the auction purchaser should be registered despite attachments placed on the mortgaged property by civil courts. The loan to S. Prasanth, predecessor-in-interest to respondents 2–4, was secured by a mortgage over approximately 8.42 acres of land via deposits of title deeds (Exts. P1 and P1(a)), and the property was sold after classification as a Non-Performing Asset. The Sub Registrar refused registration on the ground that the property was under attachment by a Principal Munsiff Court in OS No.470 of 2018, with the court’s decree creating a charge over the scheduled property (Ext. P7). The petitioner contends that attachment does not create a right or encumbrance against the property, citing established precedents (Francis @ Porinju v. Navodaya Kuries & Loans; Rajalekshmi Amma v. E.A. Basheer; Keechery Service Co-operative Bank Ltd v. Sajitha Nizar) and a recent W.P.(C) No.9571 of 2022 ruling. The court agrees with the petitioner, following these precedents, and disposes of the petition by directing registration of Ext. P3 after hearing, de hors the attachments, expeditiously and within one month of the judgment.
Cr.Appeal No.1034 of 2016 Baiju @ Kattadi, the sole accused in SC 664/2013 of the Addl. Sessions Court, Moovattupuzha, challenges his conviction under Section 302 IPC for the murder of the deceased following a financial dispute. The trial court sentenced him to life imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, with Rs. 50,000 to be paid to the deceased’s father under Section 357(1) Cr.P.C. The High Court of Kerala, in a judgment delivered on 10 January 2022, upheld the prosecution’s case based largely on the testimony of three eyewitnesses (PW1 Tibin, PW2 Jolly, PW3 Jomon), who described the sequence at a tea shop where the accused allegedly assaulted the deceased after a confrontation over borrowed money. The prosecution linked the stabbing to MO1 knife and relied on postmortem findings showing a fatal chest injury (injury No.6) and the presence of B+ blood on the garments. The defense attacked the reliability of the witnesses, pointing to contradictions, omissions in Ext.P1 F.I.S., and the recovery of the knife from an open canal. The court rejected these arguments, emphasizing that minor inconsistencies do not undermine credibility and that the evidence collectively establishes the guilt beyond reasonable doubt. Rejecting the defense’s plea for Section 300 Exception 4 and finding no mutual fight, the court concluded the act was premeditated with intent to cause the fatal injury. The appeal was dismissed; the conviction and life sentence were affirmed.
OT.Rev Nos. 29/2022 to 44/2022 These petitions arise in a batch of Other Tax Revision (VAT) matters before a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court on 12 October 2022, challenging orders passed under the CST Act and KVAT Act in respect of exemptions on inter-State sale of natural rubber (HSN 4006.10.00). The revision petitions—led by State of Kerala and opposed by K A Jose, Kollamkulan Agencies Pvt Ltd—deal with the interpretation and interaction of three notifications issued under Section 8 of the CST Act, 1956, and the related provisions of the KVAT Act, 2003. The core dispute concerns whether the exemption granted by the first notification (2008/2011) should stand as controlling or whether the second notification (which limited exemptions to sub-section (1) of Section 8) and the third notification (introducing an option to pay tax) modify or supersede it. The Deputy Commissioner (Appeals) remanded the matter for disposal afresh, and the Tribunal upheld the remand, noting the dealer’s choice to opt for exemption or tax payment. The State contends that allowing dual exemptions yields a double advantage and that the second notification invalidates the first. The respondents argue that the second notification correctly restricts exemptions and that the third notification enables optional payment; the court ultimately confirms the remand and dismisses the revisions, upholding that the Assessing Officer should decide relief in light of the entire notification framework. The decision relies on Hi-Tek Traders and sustains the view that the statutory scheme governs the exemption regime.
This appeal by Tharayil Appunni challenges a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Ad hoc I), Manjeri, arising from Crime No. 52 of 2005 (Thenhipalam Police Station). On 25 February 2005, around 7:30 pm, the appellant was found in possession of 600 ml of arrack in a bottle on a public road at Pallikkal Bazaar. The trial court convicted him after evaluating evidence of seven prosecution witnesses (PWs 1–7) and documentary Exts P1–P10 and MO1. The appellant's defence raised chain-of-custody defects, arguing that the contraband allegedly seized did not reach the Chemical Examiner in a tamper‑proof condition, and that the seal description and specimen were not properly proved. The court considered the seizure mahazar, the seal, and the laboratory link, and relied on precedents emphasizing strict compliance with sampling and sealing of contraband. The High Court examined Sasidharan v. State of Kerala, Sathi v. State of Kerala, Ravi v. State of Kerala and Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala to require that the sample presented in court be the same sample tested in the laboratory, with proper seals and chain-of-custody. It found the prosecution failed to establish the chain of custody and the link to the laboratory, creating reasonable doubt. Consequently, the conviction was set aside and the accused acquitted; the appeal is allowed.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal by the accused, Kannan alias Haridas, challenging a conviction under Section 8(2) Abkari Act for possession of 5 litres of arrack allegedly seized from Nedumpura Village, Thrissur. The Trial Court convicted him and the Fast Track Court II upheld the conviction, sentencing him to three years’ imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. On 19 May 2022, Justice K. Babu allowed the appeal and acquitted the accused. The prosecution case proceeds that on 8 March 2006, Excise preventive officers intercepted the accused near Sankaran’s house, who abandoned a can containing 5 litres of arrack; PW2 seized the can under Ext. P2. PW3 corroborated; PW4-5, independent witnesses, did not support the prosecution version; PW6 conducted the investigation. The defence argued two core issues: (i) identity of the person found with the contraband could not be established, as PW2 and PW3 identified the accused in court after a long interval with no prior identification parade; (ii) the chain of custody and tamper-proof handling of the sample was not established, with gaps in seal description and delays in forwarding the sample to the Chemical Examiner. Relying on established jurisprudence requiring a test identification parade for unknown assailants and rigorous chain-of-custody for chemical analysis, the court held that the link between the accused, the seized contraband, and the lab report was not proved beyond reasonable doubt, and acquitted the appellant. The appeal was allowed accordingly.
This writ petition challenges Ext. P4 (03.03.2021) by Kendriya Vidyalaya-3, EME Centre, Bairagarh, Bhopal, rejecting the petitioner Theertha A.’s request to correct her date of birth from 02.07.2002 back to 02.07.2001 as recorded in the birth certificate. The petitioner relies on Ext. P1 (birth certificate showing 02.07.2001) and explains the inadvertent entry of 02.07.2002 in the CBSE Class X certificate. The Supreme Court’s June 2021 Jigya Yadav v. CBSE decision held that corrections in CBSE certificates to align with public documents could be entertained, subject to conditions (affidavit and undertaking to indemnify the Board, payment of fees, possible public notice, surrender of the original certificate, and a disclaimer in the new certificate). Kerala High Court later followed this approach in Ananthu Ashok v. RO, CBSE (8.4.2022), directing the Board to entertain such requests if conditions are satisfied. In this petition, the court found delay acceptable, overruled the objection that jurisdiction lay elsewhere, and set aside Ext. P4. It directed the school to entertain a fresh application in light of Jigya Yadav and Ananthu Ashok, with the petitioner providing the required undertaking; CBSE to issue a corrected date of birth within 30 days after receipt of the judgment copy. Writ petition disposed.
The petitioner, Farseena P.K., daughter of the late Abdul Majeed, who died while employed as a Pharmacist, seeks a Dependency Certificate to enable compassionate appointment under a Government scheme. She resided with her father despite being married, and her husband is abroad with no regular employment. The second respondent, Tahsildar, rejected her application for a fresh Dependency Certificate, concluding that because she is married and her husband is abroad, she cannot be considered a dependent of the deceased. The petitioner challenges this Ext.P4 order, arguing that dependency must be determined on actual financial reliance on the deceased rather than solely on marital status. The Government Pleader counters that the petitioner’s marriage and her husband’s overseas employment demonstrate she was not financially dependent, and that more than seven years have elapsed since her father’s death (2015), making the compassionate appointment unlikely under the scheme. The court cites Ashkarali K. v. State of Kerala and others, noting that mere marriage cannot be the deciding factor in dependency. It directs the Tahsildar to reconsider the application, after assessing whether the petitioner was financially dependent on her father until his demise, and to receive evidence accordingly. A decision is to be made within six weeks, with the ultimate appointment authority deciding eligibility.
MACA 884/2018; MACA 1903/2021 These are two Motor Accidents Claims Appeals arising from OP(MV) 208/2012 decided by the Addl. Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-II, Alappuzha. The deceased Xavier P.L., a 32-year-old fisherman, died after a road traffic collision on 17 August 2011; his legal heirs—Jessy Xavier and her four children—claimed Rs 22,61,000 in compensation. The Tribunal awarded Rs 16,85,600. The insurer challenged the amount as excessive (MACA 884/2018), while the claimants sought enhanced compensation (MACA 1903/2021). The High Court reexamines headwise components, applying the notional income approach and future prospects: fixed income Rs 8,000/month; with a 40% addition for future prospects and a multiplier of 16, one arrives at loss of dependency of Rs 16,12,800 before deductions. With four dependents, personal expenses of 1/4 are deducted. Medical expenses are corrected to Rs 94,200; pain and suffering is reduced because the death occurred on the second day; damages for loss of consortium, love and affection and mental agony are refined under Pranay Sethi. The court also notes Magma/Nanu Ram and Ramchandrappa principles. Ultimately, MACA 1903/2021 is allowed with enhanced compensation of Rs 2,33,400, and MACA 884/2018 is dismissed. The insurer must deposit the enhanced amount in the claimants’ bank accounts in equal shares with 8% interest within two months, no costs.
Veegaland Developers Pvt. Ltd. (the petitioner) claimed to be the builder of a residential complex named Veegaland Kings Fort, in which 108 apartments exist and 58 flats had been sold by 2022. The Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975 requires tax on buildings; the petitioner filed returns under Section 7, valuing the completed building at 17,934.9 sq.m. In December 2021, after notices, the petitioner provided details of apartment owners, sale deeds, and door numbers. Nevertheless, on 15 February 2022, the assessing officer, treating the entire building as a single unit owned by the petitioner, imposed a substantial building tax of Rs 28,07,495. The petitioner contends the order is perverse, non-speaking and reflects non-application of mind, and should be quashed under Article 226. The respondent argues that the tax is based on occupancy certificate and completion date, and that sale agreements prior to completion are not admissible under the Act, with a remedy of appeal available. The court clarifies that, under Section 2(e) and its Explanation 2, a building may be treated as multiple units if different persons financed construction; separate assessment may apply. It cites Hi-Lite Realtors and Balu to support the explanatory framework, finds Ext. P8 lacking reasoned consideration, and sets it aside. The petition is allowed, with liberty to the third respondent to reassess after hearing within three months.
WP(C) Nos.8727/2022, 8840/2022, 8844/2022 These three writ petitions challenge communications Ext.P2 issued by the 1st respondent directing petitioners to produce land development certificates for proposed constructions, arguing that the area has been subdivided into plots. The Kerala High Court acknowledges a consistent line of decisions— WA No.1288/2019 and the earlier Nafeesa v. Chavakkad Municipality (2018(3) KLT 1)—that where purchasers acquire small extents from larger land parcels, a development permit may not be a prerequisite for grant of a building permit. The petitions, though separate, share a common principle that regulatory formalities should not unduly impede reasonable construction on already subdivided plots. The Court notes that the development permit requirement can constrain development and that local self-government agencies cannot demand unwarranted preconditions for building activities when it would thwart bona fide construction. On this basis, the petitions are allowed, Ext.P2 is set aside, and the respondents are directed to consider the building permit applications without insisting on a development permit. Necessary orders shall be issued within six weeks from the date of the judgment, ensuring swift relief for the petitioners.
The appellant SantHAMMA challenged a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act, arising from possession of 3.5 litres of illicit arrack in 1998 and a trial court finding her guilty and sentencing two years’ simple imprisonment with a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The Kerala High Court, on 31 May 2022, allowed the Criminal Appeal and acquitted the accused, holding that the prosecution failed to establish a tamper-proof chain of custody for the contraband sample from the place of seizure to the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory. Key defects included: the sample bottle not being produced at the time of seizure, delays in production to Court (Ext. P4 and testimony of PW7 showing arrival only on 14.05.1998), absence of seal description on the seizure mahazar (Ext. P1), lack of a forwarding note for sending the sample to the laboratory, and the fact that Baby John, who delivered the sample to the lab, was not examined. The court emphasized that the crux of Abkari cases lies in establishing that the same sample tested was the sample seized, with strict compliance of sealing and chain-of-custody requirements. Relying on Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi and later authorities, the court concluded link evidence was absent, voiding the chemical analysis Ext. P5 and leading to acquittal and setting aside of the conviction.
This is a Kerala High Court original petition under Article 227 challenging an order passed by the Rent Control Court (Munsiff), Thrissur in I.A. No. 2 of 2021 in R.C.P. No. 97 of 2020. The Rent Control Court, while pending eviction proceedings under Section 11 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, directed the tenant to deposit admitted arrears of rent and continue to pay future rent under Section 12(1) of the Act. The order was issued when the tenant was not represented and, despite recalls, the Court later proceeded to extend a Section 12(1) directive. The tenant, who was set ex parte in the eviction petition, challenged Ext. P4 as a manifest error in exercise of the Court’s supervisory powers. The court discusses the object of Section 12 and emphasizes that arrears deposit is a prerequisite to contest eviction, but notes that the remedy under Article 227 is supervisory, not appellate, and requires a showing of manifest error or grave injustice. Relying on K.V.S. Ram v. Bangalore Metropolitan Transport Corporation and Sobhana Nair K.N. v. Shaji S.G. Nair, the court finds that the Rent Control Court committed manifest error by passing Ext. P4 in the tenant’s absence. Consequently, the petition is allowed and Ext. P4 is set aside, with the matter to proceed according to law.