Vincent Y., a retired employee of Thekkumbhagom Service Co-operative Bank Ltd., filed WP(C)6786/2022 alleging that gratuity payable under a Group Gratuity Cash Accumulation Scheme with LIC should be paid in full. LIC paid Rs.22,58,025 toward gratuity; the bank paid only Rs.20,00,000, citing the Payment of Gratuity Act maximum. A balance of Rs.2,58,025 remained in a Suspense Account (Ext.P4), and LIC subsequently credited Rs.4,23,251 towards the balance (Ext.P5). The petitioner approached the bank to release the full amount (Ext.P6) but was told payments would be made only per court orders. Ext.P8 shows Rs.6,81,276 received from LIC and retained in suspense. The petitioner relies on Chandrasekharan Nair v. Kerala State Co-operative Agricultural and Rural Development Bank (Full Bench) to contend that where gratuity is linked to LIC policies, the employee is entitled to the entire amount under the Special Terms of Gratuity, notwithstanding any quantum restrictions. The Full Bench held that Section 4(5) of the Payment of Gratuity Act permits a better term, and that the employee is entitled to the full policy amount, superseding provisos in Kerala Co-operative Rules. A Division Bench later clarified that for societies to which the Act applies, the 4(5) provision prevails over limitations, and the petitioner is entitled to the higher amount. The court allowed the petition and directed the bank to disburse Rs.6,81,276 with 6% interest within two months, expediting relief for the employee.
WP(C) Nos.2067 & 6097 of 2019 Two writ petitions challenge the disciplinary actions taken at an aided school in Palakkad after a joint inspection flagged misappropriation of rice and stock worth about Rs. 19,266.50. An investigation by the Joint Director (Academics) culminated in Ext.P2, an enquiry report that prima facie found the petitioners liable for misappropriation and recommended that disciplinary proceedings be initiated by the Corporate Manager. Based on Ext.P2, the Manager issued a show-cause and ultimately imposed the punishment of barring one increment with effect from January 2019, without a full-fledged inquiry under Rule 75 of Chapter XIVA. The petitioners argued that, since the alleged misconduct concerns misappropriation, the matter should be referred to a proper Rule 75 inquiry before deciding on any penalty; they relied on K.J. Sulatha to contend that the disciplinary authority cannot prejudge the penalty. The Manager contended that barring one increment is a minor penalty under Rule 76, and thus no charge memo or Rule 75 inquiry was necessary; reliance was placed on Kulwant Singh Gill to differentiate minor versus major penalties. The court found that the Manager had bypassed the Rule 75 process, and that the order cannot be sustained. It quashed Ext.P2 and Ext.P5 (6097) and Ext.P7 (2067) and directed reinitiation of disciplinary proceedings after conducting an enquiry under Rule 75 of the Kerala Education Rules.
The appellant Sahadevan was convicted under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc) Fast Track Court No. I, Thrissur, in Sessions Case No. 987 of 2007, for possessing 1.5 litres of arrack on 05.05.2005 near Kunhuvareed, Manalayi Desom. On appeal, the High Court examines critical gaps in the prosecution case, notably the absence of an arrest memo and arrest intimation for the alleged arrest by PW1, the Excise Preventive Officer, and the failure to conclusively connect the seizure with the accused. The defense relied on D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal to challenge mandatory arrest-formalities, arguing that non-compliance undermines the entire case. The court also scrutinizes the chain of custody and the genuineness of the seized contraband, highlighting that the seal description in Ext. P1 and the absence of a described seal specimen violate evidentiary requirements; Ext. P6 forwarding note lacks the name of the officer who forwarded the sample, and Ext. P9’s forwarding note and initial dates are ambiguous. The court cites Ramankutty, Kumaran, Bhaskaran, and Daulat Ram to underscore that improper arrest procedures, uncertain sample forwarding, and tamper-prone custody erode evidentiary value, ultimately rendering Ext. P9 chemical analysis untrustworthy. Consequently, the court holds that the prosecution failed to establish the charge, acquits Sahadevan, and allows the appeal.
CRL.A Nos. 2985 & 2987 of 2008 Two NDPS Act appeals were heard together in the Kerala High Court arising from a 23 May 2008 seizure on Anihall Road, Kozhikode. The Special Court tried two accused: Vijay an @ Dasan (1050 grams of ganja) and Sasidharan (10 grams). They were charged under Section 20(b)II(B) for possession for sale and Section 20(b)II(A) for possession for sale of ganja for the other accused, with common intention. The trial court convicted both; the High Court upheld the convictions but found no evidence of a joint, mutual understanding to possess the entire contraband, thus rejecting a single joint liability. The appellants contended that mandatory NDPS provisions, especially Sections 42, 50 and 57, were not properly complied with and that contraband custody and search procedures were defective, including the search of the accused without Gazetted Officer/Magistrate presence. The Public Prosecutor argued full compliance, supported by PW1–PW3 testimony, seizure mahazar (Exts. P4–P8), and chemical analysis (Exts. P14–P16). The court noted the independent consent waivers (Exts. P2, P3) and held Section 50 was complied with; it relied on procedures to satisfy Section 57 and Section 42(2) per Boota Singh. It affirmed conviction but modified sentences: one year with Rs.10,000 fine for the first accused and six months with Rs.5,000 for the second, counting time already served. The appeals were dismissed with these sentence adjustments.
This writ petition, filed by M/S AA NUTS, challenges Ext. P1, an order passed by the Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972, which held the 4th respondent employee entitled to gratuity. The 4th respondent worked from 01.09.1996 to 31.12.2015, with last drawn salary Rs. 17,000, and claimed gratuity. The Controlling Authority issued notice to the employer, but the notice was returned with the postal endorsement “intimation 02.04.2022,” and the employer was declared ex parte on 20.01.2023. Ext. P1 awarded the 4th respondent gratuity of Rs. 1,86,346 with 10% interest from 01.01.2016. The petitioner contends they did not receive any notice in the proceedings and only learned of the award upon revenue recovery. They filed Ext. P2 seeking to set aside the ex parte order and to rehear, but no response from the authority followed, and the appeal against Ext. P1 was dismissed for non-deposit under the second proviso to Section 7(7) of the Act. The petitioner invokes extensions under Rule 11(5) and contends for maintainability of Order 9 Rule 13 CPC proceedings. The respondents argue the petitioner willfully evaded notice and that the matter is time-barred. The High Court, applying the Explanation to Order 9 Rule 13 and the doctrine of deemed service, dismissed the petition, holding that the remedy under Order 9 Rule 13 is unavailable and there is no interference with Ext. P1.
Shanavas S., the petitioner in WP(C) No. 8458 of 2022, challenges police obstruction and seeks protection and directions to facilitate mechanized felling and loading of rubber wood logs on lands covered by Ext. P1–P2. He contends that he and his trained workforce can undertake felling and loading by using mechanized devices, with human intervention limited to tying logs to cranes. Respondents include the District Police Chief (Kollam Rural), the Station House Officer (Yeroor), the Headload Workers Welfare Board (Kollam District), and several individuals, along with an Additional Labour Officer added as a party. The respondents argue the area is a scheme-covered zone and that manual loading must be performed by registered pool workers under the Act; others concede some activities require human involvement, but claim they are willing to proceed without hindering mechanized operations. The petitioner relies on prior Kerala judgments (Timber Merchant Association, Pala and Others v. SP, Ktym; Maratt Plantations (P) Ltd v. DPC, Malappuram) to justify mechanization. The court, noting ongoing disputes about the necessity of headload workers, directs a site inspection by the 15th respondent (Additional Labour Officer) to determine whether registered pool workers are required. If mechanization suffices, police protection will be provided; otherwise, engagement of pool workers will be mandated, with steps to be completed within ten days.
This Regular Second Appeal (RSA No. 88 of 2023) before the Kerala High Court challenges concurrent decrees in AS 62/2016 of the Sub Court, Neyyattinkara, and OS 981/2013 of the Principal Munsiff, Neyyattinkara. The appellant, Helindas, defendant in OS 981/2013, seeks reversal of a decree awarding recovery of Rs. 1,50,000 together with 18% interest on the assertion of an agreement for sale of his property in favor of the plaintiff, Biju. The plaintiff pleaded that a sale agreement Ext. A1 was executed and Rs. 1.5 lakh was paid as advance; The defendant denied execution, contending Ext. A1 was forged by using a blank signed stamp paper and forged signatures, and that he had borrowed Rs. 1,00,000 from Maniyan. The trial court examined the evidence, with PW1 (plaintiff) and PW2 (attesting witness to Ext. A1) supporting execution of Ext. A1 and the receipt of the advance; DWs 1 and 2 (defendant and associate) denying execution. The trial court decreed the suit, which the appellate court upheld. In the High Court, the defendant’s counsel argued Ext. A1 was not proven and questioned the credibility of witnesses, including the wife-attesting witness; however, the court found the plaintiff’s evidence credible and confirmed the earlier decrees. The court then examined the scope of second appeals under Section 100 CPC, citing Nazir Mohamed, Kondiba Kadam, Biswanath Ghosh, Santosh Hazari, and Government of Kerala v. Joseph, reiterating that a second appeal must be admitted only if it raises a substantial question of law. The appeal is dismissed without admission, with directions to inform the trial and appellate courts.
WP(C) 31506/2022; connected WP(C) 32313/2022, WP(C) 38110/2022 The High Court of Kerala, in a common judgment by Chief Justice S. Manikumar and Justice Murali Purushothaman, adjudicated three writ petitions challenging the appointment of the Vice-Chancellor of the Central University of Kerala and related selection processes. The petitions allege contravention of the Central Universities Act, 2009, the Central University Statutes (Kerala), and UGC Regulations, 2018, arguing that the Visitor (President of India) did not properly approve a panel prepared by the Search-cum-Selection Committee and that the extended panel and subsequent appointment were vitiated by procedural flaws and extraneous inputs from the Ministry of Education. The court traces the appointment process from Ext. P1 (notification) through Ext. P12 (appointment order) and Ext. P11 (interaction/minutes), noting the Government’s role as a secretariat to facilitate the process, and the Visitor’s ultimate independent discretion in appointing the VC. It holds that the extended panel procedure was within statutory interpretation and that the Visitor’s decision was in accordance with law. Emphasizing the autonomy of the Visitor/Chancellor under the Act and Statutes, the court disposes of all petitions by dismissing them, with no costs. The decision also discusses locus standi for quo warranto petitions and the belated nature of some challenges in light of public interest.
The petitioner, M.S. Sunish, stated to be the President of the Kamba Parambu Mojana Committee, filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking mandamus to protect the assets of Mele Thrikovil Sreeramaswamy Temple and Sree Vayilyam Kunnu Bhagavathy Temple, both Devaswom-controlled properties. The grounds allege encroachment by the 6th respondent for a Kalyanamandapam, a road cut through temple land, and use of temple ground for vehicle parking by a nearby workshop. The petitioner also accuses sale of banned substances and late-night liquor parties on temple premises. Ext.P2 (29-05-2015) and Ext.P3 (12-12-2014) representations are urged for timely consideration. Throughout 2015–2023, the Court issued directions to the Malabar Devaswom Board and related authorities to verify boundaries, restore protections, and report actions, citing judicial principles that temples and Devaswom properties deserve guardian-like protection. The judgment surveys doctrinal authorities such as Gopalakrishnan (2007) SCC, Travancore Devaswom Board, Achuthan Pillai, and parens patriae doctrine, emphasizing temple property protection. Ultimately, the Court disposes of the petition by directing a fresh boundary survey by the Ottapalam Taluk Surveyor within three months and authorizes police assistance if encroachment or unauthorised activities persist; the 4th respondent is to protect Devaswom land accordingly.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC heard by a single judge of the Kerala High Court, challenging CC 833/2022 pending before the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Mannarkad. Accused Nos. 1–3 (Mohammed Safwan P., Sayyid Hashirthangal P., and Muhammed Arshad M.) are charged with offences under Sections 341, 323, and 324 read with Section 34 IPC arising from an incident on 12.10.2022, where they allegedly restrained and assaulted the de facto complainant, causing injuries. The petition seeks quashing of the criminal proceedings in light of an amicable settlement between the parties and their non-desire to pursue further prosecution. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations but acknowledged absence of other serious crimes by the petitioners. The court directed the Investigating Officer to verify the truth of the settlement and whether any impediment to quashing exists, including the antecedents of the petitioners. Relying on a line of Supreme Court decisions led by State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and elaborated through Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, and others, the court summarised that Section 482 power to quash can be exercised in non-compoundable, private-offence scenarios where the disputes are settled and public interest is not offended. However, the court emphasised limits in cases involving heinous offences or special statutes. Weighing gravity of the allegations, injuries, and the settled amicable relationship, the court ultimately held that quashing would not adversely impact society and would serve the ends of justice, thus allowing the petition and quashing the Final Report and proceedings.
This criminal appeal (CRL.A No.2012 of 2008) challenges the conviction of accused No.1 under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional District and Sessions Court (Adhoc-II), Kollam, in SC No.1363/2005. On 22.12.2002, around 5:30 pm, authorities found the appellant and another accused in possession of 30 litres of spirit and seven packets of arrack at the eastern side of Ambedkar Cooperative Spinning Mill, Anchalummodu junction, violating the Abkari Act. The prosecution charged them under Abkari Act Sections 55(a) and 8(2). Evidence consisted of PW1–PW5, Exts.P1–P7, and MOs1–3, with the trial court convicting the appellant while acquitting another accused. The core issue on appeal is the chain of custody: whether the contraband allegedly seized reached the Chemical Examiner in tamper-proof condition. The appellant contends that critical lapses exist: absence of seal description in Ext.P1, lack of testimony about seal type, no specimen seal, no witnesses to custody transfer, and unexplained delays in sending samples to the Chemical Laboratory (Ext.P7 shows analysis dates long after seizure). Relying on Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Bhaskaran, and Rajamma, the High Court evaluates whether the link between seizure and laboratory analysis was proven. Ultimately, the court acquits the appellant and allows the appeal, disbursing any deposited fine to him.
This is a Kerala High Court judgment in O.P.(CAT) No.12 of 2016 arising from an order of the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench (OA 958/2013). The applicant, a Central Excise official, challenges the CAT's directions relating to notional promotions and arrears of pay flowing from a long-drawn sequence starting with a denied promotion in 1985. The Tribunal, by its order dated 10.10.2011 in OA 408/2011, directed a review DPC for promotion to the post of Superintendent and held that if found eligible the promotion and consequential benefits would be worked out notionally. In 2011-12 the department issued orders granting notional promotions and pay fixation; in 2015 the CAT granted consequential relief including arrears. The Union of India and others approached the High Court contending that directing payment of arrears upon notional promotion, and up to notional re-fixation, is untenable, and that the prayer for arrears exceeds the scope of OA 408/2011. The High Court ultimately sets aside the CAT order, holds that the tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction by granting arrears beyond the scope of the earlier directive, and allowed the petition. It clarifies that none of the issues regarding recovery will be reopened, and that no costs are awarded. The decision engages a spectrum of case law on retrospective/notional promotions, back wages, and the “no work, no pay” principle, and ultimately restricts relief to notional benefits where appropriate.
This Kerala High Court revision petition under Section 125 CrPC challenges a Family Court order directing the revision petitioner to pay an additional maintenance of Rs. 5,000 per month to the respondent, over and above Rs. 3,000 already awarded by the Judicial First Class Magistrate under the Domestic Violence Act. The respondent had claimed Rs. 10,000 per month, arguing incapacity to maintain herself and her mentally challenged son, while the petitioner contended his net salary is only Rs. 5,729 per month (even though salary records suggest higher earnings). The Family Court examined the pleadings and available records, including Ext. R2 showing a higher net salary of Rs. 34,395, and held that, taking into account the parties’ status and change of circumstances, an additional Rs. 5,000 per month was warranted in light of Rajnesh v. Neha and another. The Supreme Court of India’s guidance on cross-proceeding maintenance under different statutes was applied to adjust the quantum in the ongoing proceedings. The court ultimately dismissed the revision petition, upholding the Family Court’s order. It directed adjustments against any interim deposits and noted that if circumstances change, Section 127 CrPC could be invoked. The decision is rendered by a Single Judge, Justice C.S. Dias.
The appellant, P. Surendran, challenged the acquittal of respondents 1 to 3 in CC 167/2004 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court III, Palakkad, in a case arising from a partnership dispute relating to the firm HaiKai Rubbers (formed 26.04.1997). The firm obtained loans from Catholic Syrian Bank and NSIC, with properties pledged and 50 post-dated cheques signed by the appellant and the 3rd accused. By 2000 the appellant retired and claims that the retirement deed (Ext.P2, executed 14.12.2000) was contingent on the creditors’ consent to relieve him of liabilities; the continuing partners indemnified him under Ext.P2, but Ext.P2 does not mention any creditor consent. The prosecution alleged offences under Sections 418 and 420 IPC and Section 138 NI Act. The trial court acquitted respondents 1 to 3. On appeal, the appellant argued deceitful assurances about creditor consent induced retirement and that the post-retirement liabilities and transactions show dishonest intent to defraud the creditors; he relied on Exts.P1–P13 and argued that the evidence supports Section 420. The State contends the trial court’s acquittal was proper and should not be disturbed absent strong reasons, citing Chandrappa and Pradeep Kumar S. v. State of Kerala. The High Court ultimately deemed no material establishing 420 and dismissed the appeal, upholding the trial court’s acquittal.
This Writ Petition (Civil) arises from a challenge to Ext. P15, which denied approval from the initial date of appointment of five LPSAs at S.M.S.N. Lower Primary School, Vaikom. The petitioners assert that, though appointed during a government ban on appointments, they were later regularised under GO schemes that protected/ deployed teachers, and that other similarly placed teachers were directed by this Court to have their appointments approved from the date of appointment by deeming that the Managers had executed the necessary bonds. The petitioners rely on G.O.(P) No.317/2005/G.Edn (ban on appointments), G.O.(P) No.10/10/G.Edn (lifting of the ban with conditions requiring managers to execute consent/bond), and G.O.(P) No.199/2011/G.Edn (comprehensive package for deployed/protected teachers); they contend that in several judgments the Court has directed approval from the appointment date by deeming bonds executed, so Ext.P15 cannot stand against them. The State counters that all appointments in additional division vacancies must be apportioned 1:1, and if a protected teacher’s appointment is not made as per the GO, the manager must execute a bond, with some challenges already pending in higher courts. The Court relies on the Suma Devi principle (2017) that non-execution of bonds should be deemed executed, directing reconsideration of Exts.P10–P14 in light of that law, quashing Ext.P15 to the extent it affects petitioners, and ordering expeditious action within three months with due notice, while keeping Apex Court decisions in view.
This writ petition challenges a Labour Court award in ID No. 65/1997 against the management of the Aluva State Transport Staff Co-operative Society Ltd. The workman (LD Clerk) was suspended in 1994 for misconduct, including abusive language and alleged assault on the President, following a charge sheet issued on 01.10.1994. An Enquiry Officer held that two charges were proved, but the disciplinary authority dismissed the employee without supplying a copy of the report. The Labour Court, noting the absence of the enquiry report on record, allowed fresh evidence and ultimately found that the two charges were not proved beyond direct and cogent evidence due to inconsistencies and disparities in witness testimony, and ordered reinstatement with continuity of service and back wages. The management contends that the Labour Court treated the matter as a criminal case and failed to prove the two charges; it argues for setting aside or modifying the relief. The workman counters that the charges were not satisfactorily disproved, emphasizing the President’s corrections in loan files and witness coherence issues. The High Court ultimately sustains the Labour Court’s findings but, considering the employee’s age, modifies the remedy: instead of reinstatement with back wages, it awards a monetary compensation of Rs. 6 lakhs, with payment within two months and 6% interest if delayed, citing BSNL v Bhurumal.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal by Janamma challenging a conviction under the Abkari Act. The Trial Court (S.C. No. 595/2006) convicted the accused under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act, sentencing one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh for possessing 1½ litres of arrack in two bottles on 13.12.2002. The prosecution case relied on the seizure at the scene and subsequent handling of the contraband through various custody stages. On appeal, the appellant contends that the identity of the person at the scene was not reliably established, there was an unexplained delay in producing the seized sample and related articles before the court, and there is no satisfactory link showing that the contraband reached the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory in a tamper-proof condition. The court surveys jurisprudence on identification evidence, chain of custody, and the evidentiary value of laboratory reports, citing a series of precedents emphasizing the necessity of test identification, tamper-proof handling, and proper documentation (seals, forwarding notes, and specimen seals). The Division emphasizes that the prosecution failed to establish a direct link between the seized contraband, the sample analyzed, and the accused. Consequently, the conviction cannot stand, and the accused is acquitted; the appeal is allowed.
Tr.P (C) Nos.183 and 184 of 2022 These transfer petitions, heard together as common components of two matrimonial proceedings, seek to shift OP (Div) Nos.1669/2021 and 1672/2021 from the Family Court, Mavelikkara, to the Family Court, Pathanamthitta. The petitioner-wife, Bini Johnson, asserts that she and her three daughters (aged 19, 15, and 6) reside with her parents in Pathanamthitta, and she has been compelled to leave the matrimonial home due to alleged cruelty. She has already filed MC No.239/2021 in Pathanamthitta for maintenance. The respondent, Johnson T, has not appeared. The Court acknowledges that transfer of matrimonial disputes is governed by settled law, notably that the primary consideration is the convenience of the wife and children, a principle underscored by several Supreme Court decisions cited in the judgment (Sumitha Sing v. Kumar Sanjay; Mona Aresh Goel v. Aresh Satya Goel; Vaishali Shridhar Jagtap v. Shridhar Vishwanath Jagtap; Santhini v. Vijaya Venkatesh; N.C.V Aishwarya v. A.S Saravana Karthik Sha). On analyzing pleadings, the court finds that the wife and children are within Pathanamthitta’s jurisdiction and that Annexure A3 (maintenance) is before Pathanamthitta Court; consolidating A1 and A2 with A3 avoids conflicting decisions and saves judicial time. Under Section 24 CPC, the court transfers Annexures A1 and A2 to Pathanamthitta, with liberty to consolidate and try jointly."
Crl.Appeal (V) No. 704/2017 The appeal, labelled as Crl.Appeal (V) No. 704 of 2017, is heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court (Justices K. Vinod Chandran and C. Jayachandran). The appellant Sindhu was charged with the murder of her sister, alleging a sequence of family disputes culminating in a fatal attack by the accused with a chopper on 26 December 2010. The trial court, after analysing 15 witnesses and 25 documents (and 10 exhibits), acquitted the accused on grounds of inconsistencies in the Prosecution’s key witness PW1. The prosecution contended that minor contradictions should not derail a core prosecution case, relied on various authorities, and argued that PW3’s testimony suggesting PW1’s possible involvement was a mere rumor; the recovery of the weapon under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act was not credible given timing and circumstances. The respondents' advocate supported maintaining the acquittal. The High Court, after re-appreciating the evidence, cited Chandrappa and others v. State of Karnataka to explain the appellate scope in acquittal cases and enumerated broad principles: appellate courts may re-appreciate evidence; no strict limits exist; yet double presumption in favour of the accused applies. Ultimately, the court concluded there was no ground to overturn the acquittal, and the appeal was dismissed, upholding the trial court’s order. The judgment emphasizes the cautious use of prior authorities and reaffirms the power to re-evaluate evidence in acquittal appeals.
OT.Rev Nos. 33/2021, 50/2021, 52/2021, 51/2021, 48/2021, 49/2021 The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench comprising Justices S. V. Bhatti and Bechu Kurian Thomas, heard a batch of Other Tax Revision (VAT) petitions under the KVAT Act challenging a common Tribunal order dated 19 August 2020. The petitions (OT Rev Nos. 33/2021, 50/2021, 52/2021, 51/2021, 48/2021, 49/2021) concern compounded tax under Section 8(f) for the periods 2011-12 to 2016-17 and the Tribunal’s approach of extending the benefit of a set-aside of the 2011-12 assessment to later years. The Revenue argued that the Tribunal’s approach was legally misplaced, especially where the 2011-12 assessment was time-barred, and sought a consistent basis for determining compounded tax for subsequent years. The Dealer contends for interpretation aligned with Baiju A A v. State Tax Officer and a Full Bench Reference Order in S.T. Rev. 21/2014, asserting that the highest tax payable, whether conceded in the return/accounts or paid in prior years, should govern the computation under Section 8(f). The Court relies on Baiju A A and the Full Bench decision to interpret the terms ‘paid’ and ‘payable’ in Section 8(f)(i), holding that limitation on 2011-12 does not erase the basis for calculating compounded tax for the following years. The batch is disposed of with a remand to the Tribunal for fresh disposal, and costs are not awarded.