Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 601 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 2793 of 2015; MACA No. 1322 of 2018

M.A.C.A. Nos.2793 of 2015 & 1322 of 2018

These are consolidated Motor Accident Claims Appeals arising from an Award dated 30.01.2015 of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Thrissur, in OP(MV) 404/2005. The claimant-respondent in MACA 1322/2018 seeks enhancement of compensation; the appeal is supported by the reasoning that the Tribunal erred in fixing the notional monthly income of the injured farmer at Rs 3,500 in 2005. Relying on the Supreme Court authorities Ramachandrappa v. Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. (2011) AIR (SC) 2951 and Syed Sadiq v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (2014) (2) SCC 735, the Court holds that notional income should be Rs 5,000 per month, necessitating a re-calculation of heads of loss (earned earnings, disability, etc.) and resulting in a larger overall award (an additional Rs 12,639 with 9% interest from the petition date, excluding a 302-day delay). In MACA 2793/2015, the insurer challenges liability, contending issues including whether the rider possessed a valid driving license at the time of the accident. The Court, while condoning delay in filing, remands to the MACT to determine whether the second respondent had a valid license and the resulting liability. Overall, the Court allows both appeals to the extent described and directs payment and remand for license verification.

High Court of Kerala
WA No.1527 of 2021

Dr. Anupama K.P. v. University of Calicut & Ors.

This writ appeal challenges the University of Calicut’s method of implementing horizontal reservations for persons with disabilities (PWD) in filling Assistant Professor posts, specifically regarding a Journalisms & Mass Communication vacancy. The petitioner, Dr. Anupama K.P., ranked second in Ext.P4 for the two JMC vacancies, but the University appointed the rank-1 candidate, and the petitioner contends the vacancy reserved for PWD was earmarked vertically (roster points 1, 26, 54 with added slots 1A, 26A, 51A), thereby altering the original 100-point roster and messing with caste/ETB allocations. The petitioner argues that KS & SSR Rules (Rule 15 and related rotation provisions) and Section 34 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 mandate horizontal, interlocking reservations that do not disturb the vertical quotas of SC/ST/OBC. The University counters that horizontal reservation for PWD must be implemented as per government orders (G.O.s) and subject to 4% reservation, with the roster modified to accommodate PWD by adding slots. The High Court finds the University’s vertical earmarking and rotation changes illegal and faulted, distinguishing contrary precedents (including Muhazin P. v. Government of Kerala) and upholding the Indra Sawhney framework for horizontal reservations. It directs the University to appoint the petitioner to roster point 54, rework the rotation for already-appointed candidates, and retain others in supernumerary posts, ensuring PWD quotas are satisfied without compromising the vertical quotas.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) Nos.304, 390, 396 and 457 of 2023

OP(KAT) Nos.304, 390, 396 and 457 of 2023

This batch of four petitions (OP(KAT) Nos.304, 390, 396 and 457 of 2023) challenges the Kerala Public Service Commission’s reliance on a late addition of a new category—low-vision differently-abled persons—for reservation in recruitment for Ayurvedic posts (Medical Officer Ayurveda/Assistant Insurance Medical Officer Ayurveda). The notification (14-12-2017) already reserved 3% for differently-abled persons, with lists published in 2019 and an erratum on 6-8-2020 to include the low-vision category after Government proceedings (10-8-2018, 26-11-2018). An Expert Committee under Section 33 of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 (RPDA Act) had identified this category, and the Government argued that the statutory framework empowers such categorization to realize constitutional guarantees of equality. The petitioners argued that eligibility criteria fixed in the notification could not be altered after publication, that retrospective inclusion runs counter to the selection process, and that government orders supporting such changes should apply only to future notifications. The Kerala High Court, while noting the Government’s policy objectives and the RPDA Act’s aims, held that the relevant judgments cited by petitioners were not controlling here and that the category’s inclusion is consistent with statutory provisions; the petitions were dismissed, allowing the Tribunal’s orders and the 2020 erratum/identification to stand for the current notification.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 6753 OF 2016

M.P. Veerandrakumar and P.V. Chandran v. Satheeja Kumari T.S and State of Kerala

This High Court of Kerala, in CRL.MC No. 6753 of 2016, deals with a petition to quash criminal proceedings arising from a private complaint in S.T. No.1618/2016 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Ettumanoor. The petitioners, accused Nos. 2 and 3, challenge the continuation of proceedings under Sections 500 and 509 read with Section 34 IPC. The 1st respondent, Satheeja Kumari T.S., the de facto complainant, has stated through an affidavit that the dispute with accused Nos. 2 and 3 has been amicably settled. It is noted that the 1st petitioner/2nd accused is now deceased, and the respondents’ counsel confirm that the matter was inquired into and a statement by the complainant recorded, indicating settlement. The learned Public Prosecutor submits that the dispute is personal and the 1st respondent has no objection to quashing the final report against accused Nos. 2 and 3. The court invokes established Supreme Court precedent—Gian Singh v. State of Punjab; Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab; State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan—along with Lovely Salhotra and Sajeev & Another v. State of Kerala—to hold that under Section 482 Cr.P.C, the High Court may quash non‑compoundable offences where the parties have settled, if warranted by the facts to serve ends of justice and prevent abuse of process. On these facts, the Court allows the Crl.M.C and quashes the proceedings against accused Nos. 2 and 3 in S.T. No.1618/2016, leaving the rest of the case undisturbed.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.A No. 2974 of 2008

MANOJ, S/O RAGHAVAN v. STATE OF KERALA

The appeal challenges a conviction under sections 8(2) and 55(g) of the Abkari Act for alleged possession of 35 litres of illicit arrack and 1000 litres of wash in a forest area near Akamanam on 29.08.2006. The trial court convicted the accused, which was affirmed by the Sessions Court in Sessions Case No.507/2007. On appeal, the appellant contends that the prosecution failed to prove the identity of the person found with the contraband, that there was an unexplained delay in producing the sample and other properties before court, and that the wash and arrack allegedly seized did not reach the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory. The court notes that PW3, the Excise Inspector, had only a fleeting view of the suspect and identified him in court after two years, and that there was no pre-trial test identification parade. The judgment emphasizes established doctrines on identification and the chain of custody of contraband, citing Kanan, Jameel, Raja, Shukla, Hafeez, Sasidharan, Sathi and Ravi, which require a test parade when the witness does not know the accused, and rigorous proof that the seized sample reached the lab tamper-proof. The court also discusses delays in production of the seized items, Ext. P5–P7, and the need to show proper handling of samples; ultimately, the prosecution’s failure on these fronts leads to acquittal. The appeal is allowed; the accused is acquitted and set at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 3841 OF 2023

SHAJI @ BOMBAY THALAYAN SHAJI v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 3841 OF 2023) filed by the first accused, Sha ji (also referred to as Sha ji @ Bombay Thalayan Shaji), in Crime No. 1126/2022 of Koratty Police Station, Thrissur, under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act (NDPS). The prosecution alleges that at about 12:15 hours on 31.12.2022, the accused was found in possession of 33.430 grams of MDMA for sale, leading to a charge under NDPS Section 22(c). The petitioner argues for regular bail on the ground of long custody since 31.12.2022. The Public Prosecutor counters that the recovered quantity constitutes a commercial quantity under the NDPS Act and that the accused has an extensive criminal history, including 11–12 prior crimes, several of which are NDPS-related, and that he is a habitual offender, making release on bail inappropriate. The court explains that when an accused is alleged to have committed an offence involving a commercial quantity, bail is permissible only if two conditions are satisfied under Section 37(1)(a)(i)/37(1)(b): (i) there are reasonable grounds for believing the accused is not guilty, and (ii) he is not likely to commit any offence while on bail. The court cites Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari to define “reasonable grounds” as more than prima facie grounds. It reiterates that the decision on bail is not a judgment of acquittal. Applying the settled law from several precedents, the court finds that the conditions are not satisfied in this case, given the gravity of the offence and the accused’s extensive criminal antecedents. Consequently, the bail application is dismissed. The judge, SINGLE, A. BADHARUDEEN, emphasizes adherence to the NDPS bail framework and the need to avoid release on bail in a case involving commercial quantity contraband.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2471 OF 2008

Sukumaran v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal by Sukumaran challenging a conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act for possessing 8 litres of spirit on 9 August 2003. The Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc) Fast Track-I, Pathanamthitta, convicted him and imposed two years’ rigorous imprisonment with a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The prosecution relied on seized contraband and a chemical analysis report (Ext. P6) to prove the offence, while the defense contended that the contraband had not been properly subjected to analysis and that crucial link evidence—such as the chain of custody, the seal and its specimen, and forwarding notes—was lacking. The trial court accepted the prosecution’s case after hearing PW1–PW4 and DW1, and on 31.10.2008 delivered the conviction. On appeal, counsel for the appellant argued that unexplained delays in producing the seized properties before court, absence of the seal specimen, and unexamined officials handling the sample undermined the reliability of the Chemical Analysis Report. The High Court examined precedents (Ravi v. State of Kerala; Bhaskaran v. State of Kerala; Rajamma v. State of Kerala; Ramachandran v. State of Kerala) and found no satisfactory explanation for the delay, a missing seal specimen, and gaps in custody. Consequently, the court held there was no proven link to the contraband and allowed the appeal, setting aside the conviction and acquitting the appellant.

High Court of Kerala
OP(CAT) No.20 of 2022

OP(CAT) No.20 of 2022

This Original Petition (Cat) No.20 of 2022 before the Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, arises from a Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) order (OA No.189 of 2019) dated 28.10.2019, in which the Tribunal directed that 50% of the casual labour service rendered by the applicant should be counted with regular service for pension calculation, increasing the total qualifying service to 11 years and directing arrears accordingly. The petitioners/ respondents in OA (Union of India and the Sr. Divisional Personnel Officer, Southern Railway) challenge Exhibit P9, contending that pensionary benefits are governed by rules requiring a minimum of 10 years qualifying service and that counting 50% of casual service must be subject to verification of genuineness of the Casual Labour Service Card; they rely on Supreme Court precedents such as Inder Pal Yadav (1985) 2 SCC 648 and Union of India v. Rakesh Kumar (2017) AIR 1691 to justify their stance, while emphasizing that the applicant’s eligibility hinges on the production and verification of original documents. The respondent in OA is S. Paul Raj, a retired Trackman who contends that 983 days of casual service were properly counted. After hearing, the court noted developments (Exh. R1(a) and R1(b)) showing the respondents implementing the Tribunal’s directions, and disposed of the petition without detailing merits, ruling that P9’s ratio need not bind as a precedent and directing prompt implementation by the Railways.

High Court of Kerala
CRP No. 128 of 2020

Venugopalan vs Jai Prakash

This is a Kerala High Court revision under CRP No.128 of 2020 by Venugopalan challenging an ex-parte decree in O.S. No.22/2014 (Palakkad) and the appellate judgment in CMA No.24/2019. The trial court ex-parte decreed the suit for specific performance or refund of advance, after the defendant failed to appear on the trial date. Venugopalan contends that his non-appearance on the relevant date was due to flood-related disruption in the state, constituting sufficient cause under Order IX Rule 13 CPC to set aside the ex-parte decree, and that there was no willful default. The trial court dismissed the application; the first appellate court affirmed dismissal, finding habitual absenteeism and deliberate non-cooperation. The High Court, while not endorsing the act of absence, adopts a liberal approach consistent with substantial justice, citing Supreme Court authorities that merits-based adjudication should ordinarily prevail and that sufficient cause should be liberally construed. It allows the revision with conditions: cost of Rs.10,000 to be deposited; restoration of O.S.22/2014; appearance on 04.07.2022; and expeditious disposal by 31.10.2022, with a warning that default could lead to ex-parte proceedings again. The Court thereby prioritizes justice on merits while safeguarding the respondent’s hardship.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 25545 of 2020 & 6151 of 2021

Usha Rajan v. Tripunithura Municipality; S. Umesh Shenoy v. Tripunithura Municipality & M/s Nila Homes Private Limited

This joint High Court of Kerala judgment disposes of two writ petitions challenging the denial of Occupancy Certificates for a multi-storeyed residential project named Padmaraga in Thripunithura. The project, developed by the petitioner in WP(C)25545/2020 and purchased by the petitioner in WP(C)6151/2021, received a Building Permit on 03.11.2011 and was valid until 28.10.2020, with completion work reportedly completed in 2018. The core grievance is that despite completion, the Tripunithura Municipality refused to issue Occupancy Certificates on the ground that the land is wetland/paddy land, invoking Section 14 of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, and post-2017 amendments. The petitioners rely on earlier Kerala High Court decisions (Leela Santu; Cheranalloor Grama Panchayat) to argue that permits issued before 30.12.2017 should not be thwarted by the wetland status and that estoppel applies to allow Occupancy Certificates or further construction consistent with the valid Building Permit. The Standing Counsel counters that no estoppel can override a statutory provision and relies on Sneh Gupta to argue against estoppel. The Court, after examining Section 14 and related circulars, holds that pre-2017 permits render the petitioners eligible for Occupancy Certificates and directs issuance within one month, with ensuing steps for unit numbering and property tax assessment. The judgment thus aligns with established pre-2017 estoppel principles while reaffirming statutory restrictions on post-permit wetland development.

High Court of Kerala
R.S.A Nos.835/2020 & 895/2020

R.S.A Nos.835/2020 & 895/2020

This common judgment deals with two regular second appeals filed by C.D. Varghese challenging concurrent decrees in two suits arising from an alleged tenancy/occupation of plaint schedule rooms by Olympus Tours and Travels in Kottayam. The trial court in O.S.520/2014 decreed the plaintiff’s prayer only in part: a permanent prohibitory injunction restraining eviction and obstruction, while declaring that the declaration and mandatory injunction were disallowed. In O.S.565/2014 the relief of mandatory injunction directing the defendants to vacate and remove belongings within three months was decreed, with damages for occupation from 23.07.2014 onwards and future daily damages until vacating. The District Court, Kottayam, in A.S. Nos.153 & 154/2016, affirmed these judgments. The core dispute is whether the arrangement between Varghese and Mani for occupancy of the rooms constitutes a lease (transfer of interest with exclusive possession under Section 105 TP Act) or a licence (permission to use, under Section 52 Easement Act). The High Court, applying the six-parameter test from Delta International Ltd. v. Shyam Sundar Ganeriwalla and Associated Hotels, concludes that the instruments Exts.B1–B5 are licenses without transfer of exclusive possession or a heritable interest. Nomenclature as ‘licence’ does not bar the court from examining real intention and surrounding circumstances. Consequently, the appeals are dismissed; the concurrent verdicts stand, interim orders vacated, and costs awarded to the prevailing party.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) NO. 84 OF 2022

OP(KAT) No. 84 of 2022

This is an Article 227 challenge to Ext.P2 (08.03.2022) interim order of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal, Thiruvananthapuram in OA 331/2022. The petitioners, nine SC Promoters from several districts (Sindhu R, Rupesh Kumar S, Renuka Manoj, Preetha P, Sheebakumary V.S, Suma P.S, Saira K. Soman, Jayasree R, Rethi C.S.), sought to quash or modify an age-barred notification (Annexure A5) issued by the Director of SC Development, which prescribed an 18-30 year age cap for the post of SC Promoter, contrary to government norms (18-40 years) and the more lenient category for those from the feeder source of social workers (up to 50 years) under Annexure A17. The Tribunal, while hearing OA 331/2022, permitted the applicants to submit applications despite age-bar, effectively staying the exclusion, which the petitioners claim protected their rights interimly. The respondents contend maintainability issues under the Administrative Tribunal Act, 1985, reliance on the Supreme Court dictum in State of Karnataka v. Ameerbi (2007) 11 SCC 681, and emphasize that Ext.P2 is an interim order. Annexure A3 (2017) and Annexure A4 (2021) judgments are cited to explain the policy framework. The High Court, after hearing, held that Ext.P2 is interim and there is no necessity to interfere, disposed of the O.P., and left the Tribunal to proceed with OA proceedings. The judgment affirms the interim protection but preserves the Tribunal’s proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
OP (CAT) No.103/2016

N. Narayanan v. Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd.

N. Narayanan, an employee of BSNL, challenges the Central Administrative Tribunal, Ernakulam Bench, order in OA 402/2012 quashing disciplinary penalties imposed for alleged misconduct. The facts trace to a memo of charges in 1997 alleging misbehavior by the applicant with a superior officer, followed by a departmental inquiry in 2010 which held Charge I is partially proved and Charge II not established. The disciplinary authority imposed a penalty of reduction to a minimum pay scale for two years in 2000 without giving notice of disagreement with the Inquiry Officer’s report. In TA 74/2008 the CAT quashed Ext.P-2, Ext.P-3 and Ext.P-5 orders and granted liberty to the Disciplinary Authority to initiate fresh action under Rule 15(2) CCS (CCA) Rules, with opportunity to represent against the Inquiry Officer’s report. Subsequently, the punishment was revised: on reconsideration in 2011, pay was reduced by two stages for two years, then by one stage for one year on appeal, followed by a revision leading to dismissal. The petitioner sought promotion from 2000 to 2011 and challenged the non-consideration post-penalty. The Kerala High Court upholds the Tribunal’s approach to evidence and the limited scope of judicial review, finds no perversity in the disciplinary findings, and disposes the petition by directing promotion as of 01.06.2011, with promotion to be considered within two months from the judgment copy under the rules.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 5136 of 2021

Dr. Z.A. Azif v. The Chairman Governing Body, Mannaniya College of Arts and Science, Pangode; The Manager, Mannaniya College of Arts and Science, Pangode; The University of Kerala; The Deputy Director of Collegiate Education; State of Kerala

Dr. Z.A. Azif, who served as Principal of Mannaniya College of Arts and Science, faced a disciplinary inquiry after suspension in August 2016. An Enquiry Officer held that several charges were proved and, following a show-cause, the Manager imposed a permanent reversion to the post of Associate Professor on 31 May 2018. In a prior Writ Petition (WP) decided on 12 December 2019, the High Court held that charges 1, 6, 8 and 9 were vague and improperly conducted, though Charge No. 7 required reconsideration in light of a refer report from police. The Division Bench later directed completion of disciplinary action after hearing the petitioner and, if guilty, notification of punishment. The petitioner contends that Ext. P8 show-cause and Ext. P10 orders are illegal, that the Manager lacked authority to impose punishment, and that the refer report should inform de novo inquiry, not reconsideration by the Manager. The State and college authorities argue the disciplinary process complied with directions, and punishment was just and fair. The present judgment finds fault with the manner in which the proceedings were conducted, quashes Exts. P8 and P10, and directs Charge No. 7 to be referred back to the Enquiry Officer for fresh inquiry, with a 45‑day deadline to conclude the action, reaffirming natural justice and the independence of quasi‑judicial inquiry.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4062 OF 2023

Buhari and others v. State of Kerala

This High Court of Kerala, in a criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC, examines whether the criminal proceedings against eight accused in C.C. No.2065/2017 (Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Adoor) can be quashed in light of an amicable settlement with the de facto complainant. The petition, supported by Annexure A2 (an affidavit from the 2nd respondent), contends that all disputes between the parties have been resolved and that continuing the prosecution would derail the peace and hinder the parties’ ability to move forward. The prosecution alleges offences under Sections 143, 147, 283, 427, and 447 read with Section 149 IPC arising from a 29 May 2017 incident where the accused allegedly formed an unlawful assembly and pelted stones at a private bus, causing damage of Rs.25,000. The Court recorded the Public Prosecutor’s reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement but proceeded to consider whether the settled private dispute justifies invoking its inherent power. Relying on State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and a line of Supreme Court cases including Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, and Parbatbhai Aahir, the Court held that quashing is permissible for non‑compoundable offences arising from private disputes where the civil character predominates and the settlement is genuine, while not undermining public interest in gravest crimes. The Court ultimately quashed the final report and all further proceedings against the petitioners.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 981 OF 2014

PODIYAN v. STATE OF KERALA

This criminal appeal challenges the conviction of the appellant under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act, 1077 for possessing 550 ml of arrack. On 18 October 2000, excise officials intercepted the appellant near Puthenchira Bridge, Thamarakulam, and found a bottle containing arrack. PW1 (Excise Inspector) and PW2 testified to the arrest and seizure, with a sample drawn from the bottle and the contraband forwarded to court. The case originally resulted in conviction and a sentence of three months’ rigorous imprisonment with a Rs. 1,00,000 fine and a default sentence of one month’s imprisonment. Upon remand for fresh trial, the II Additional Sessions Judge again convicted the appellant. PW4 and PW5, though called to prove the arrest and seizure, did not support the prosecution, yet they admitted signing the mahazar and arrest documents and their signatures appeared on the contraband. The chemical examination (Ext. P3) reported ethyl alcohol in the sample. The High Court assessed the credibility of PW1 and PW2, noting no material inconsistency, and found the evidence sufficient to prove possession of the contraband. Relying on established police-evidence principles, the court dismissed the appeal and upheld the conviction under Abkari Act, with the sentence previously imposed.

High Court of Kerala
DBA No. 3 of 2023

Travancore Devaswom Board – Seeking approval for the transfer and posting of officers at Sabarimala, Pamba, Nilakkal and Erumeli for the year 2023-24

This Division Bench of the High Court of Kerala heard DBA No. 3 of 2023, a Travancore Devaswom Board (TDB) application seeking approval to transfer and post officers across Sabarimala, Pamba, Nilakkal and Erumeli for 2023-24. The Board explains that several officers in key posts have retired or completed their tenure, prompting proposed replacements. Annexure A4 contains the general transfer proposal for the year 2023-24 detailing the officers to be posted, including the posts at Sabarimala, Pamba, Nilakkal, and Erumeli, and their successors. An affidavit sworn by the Board’s Secretary lists retirees and designated incumbents and references an order of this Court from 01.08.2012 (DBAR No.16 of 2010) directing posting after credentials are checked. Annexures A1–A4 accompany the DBA, with A1 being the general transfer order, A2 the 28.05.2023 Vigilance report, A3 the 12.06.2023 Devaswom Commissioner report, and A4 the transfer proposal. During hearings on 19–26 June 2023, the Board stated it did not seek modifications to Annexure A4. The Court underscored the Board’s statutory duty under the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act to supervise temple administration and protect temple properties, citing Suo Motu v. State of Kerala and the trustee-analogy from Ram Mohan Das. It ultimately permitted the Board to proceed with Annexure A4, disposed of the DBA, and directed advance filing of transfer proposals in future to avoid delay.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 5367 & 6278 of 2021

Asha Anilkumar v. Cherthala Municipality and Others

This is a pair of connected writ petitions filed by Asha Anilkumar, a tenant who had constructed a restaurant in building No.639C, Cherthala, on land leased from the landlord (the 4th respondent, Benny S). The petitioner sought a licence under Section 447 of the Kerala Municipality Act to run the restaurant, but the municipality (second respondent) rejected the licence application, citing lack of landlord consent and treating Ext.P2 (a so-called consent letter dated 20.11.2020) as inadequate. The petitioner argued that Ext.R4(a) dated 18.01.2020 established a tenancy and that the landlord’s consent could be implied as part of a tenancy; she relied on Sudhakaran v. Corporation of Trivandrum (2016) which held that a tenant cannot be deprived of a lawful business merely because a landlord withholds consent and that a valid tenancy may carry implied authority for the tenant’s use. The petition sought to set aside Ext.P9 (licence rejection) and have the 2nd respondent reconsider the licence in light of Sudhakaran, without requiring consent from the landlord. In WP(C) 6278/2021, she also sought police protection for occupying the premises. The Court held that the tenant is entitled to consideration of a licence notwithstanding landlord consent issues, and directed police protection for occupancy, disposing of the petitions with the stated directions.

High Court of Kerala
WA 1674 of 2020

WA 1674 of 2020

This writ appeal, filed by the Employees’ Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO), challenges a learned Single Judge’s order in WP(C) 4667/2020 directing re-determination of pension payable to the writ petitioners (respondents 1 to 31 in this appeal). The Division Bench of this Court in P. Sasikumar and others v. Union of India and others (ILR 2019 (1) Ker. 614) had previously laid down directions that inform the scope of pension determinations under the Employees’ Provident Fund scheme. The respondents’ case further contends that the matter now stands governed by the Supreme Court’s decision in Employees Provident Fund Organization and Another v. Sunil Kumar B. and Others (2022 (6) KLT 234 (SC)), particularly Paragraph 44, which upheld the 22 August 2014 notification as legal and valid and provided directions regarding employees’ option submissions. The appellants contend that the issue should be resolved strictly in accordance with the Apex Court’s directions, taking into account any options submitted by employees, and that the earlier Division Bench framework remains the relevant backdrop. The High Court ultimately allows the appeal, setting aside the Single Judge’s order and directing computation in line with Apex Court directions, while leaving open the questions concerning higher pension petitions and the applicability of the circular dated 25 January 2023.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 17412 of 2023

Anitha G Nair and Others v. State of Kerala and Others

This is a Kerala High Court writ petition (WP(C) No. 17412 of 2023) filed by 28 petitioners challenging recovery of earned leave surrender for census duty in 2010 and seeking refund of benefits withheld and entitlement to full service and retiral benefits. The petitioners contend that Ext.P4 directed recovery of 16 days earned leave for census duty; enumeration reportedly spanned 49 days, resulting in an alleged miscalculation and challenging the legality of the recovery since the objected benefits were granted under valid orders. They seek issuance of a writ of certiorari to set aside Ext.P4 and Ext.P11 to the extent of excluding petitioners from recovery, and to obtain a refund of recovered amounts with interest at 12% p.a., as well as other reliefs including waiver of translations. The respondents’ arguments are not elaborated in detail, but the petition notes (through learned counsel) that Exts.P10 and P13 judgments cover the point raised; it also cites OA No.1706 of 2021 before the Kerala Administrative Tribunal and Government orders affecting recovery. The court references Ext.P10 judgment, which criticized earlier government actions and held that petitioners were entitled to refunds. The judgment ultimately allows the petitions, directing the respondents to refund the recovered amounts within four months and to ensure service and retiral benefits are granted de hors the impugned orders, with the question of interest left open. Exhibits include government orders and prior judgments as record evidence.