Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 596 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2037 OF 2008

Prakasan S/o Rarichankutty, Parambath, Chelavoor AMSOM Desom, Kozhikode Taluk v. State of Kerala

The Kerala High Court, in CRL.A No. 2037 of 2008, scrutinizes an appeal against a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act. The appellant was convicted by the Fast Track Adhoc-II Sessions Court, Kozhikode, based on possession of 5 litres of arrack on 21.12.2002. The appellate court focuses on the prosecution’s failure to establish a tamper-proof chain of custody linking the seized contraband to the sample analyzed in the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory. Key issues include the delay in forwarding the sample to the lab (final analysis conducted 26.02.2004 though forwarded 27.12.2002 and reached 20.01.2003), absence of examination of custody officials, and lack of a clear property list; the absence of evidence about custody breaks the chain of custody. The court cites Viswanadhan, Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Daulat Ram, Suresh, Krishnadas, and Vijay Pandey to underscore the necessity that the sample tested be the same sample drawn from the bulk, and that tampering or improper handling undermines proof beyond reasonable doubt. It also rejects reliance on guidelines that presuppose proper official acts without proof. Consequently, due to the absence of link evidence and delays without explanation, the conviction is set aside and the accused is acquitted, with liberty and disposal of deposited amounts as per law.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(RC) No.68 of 2022

Jolly Abhilash alias Jolly Sebastian v. M.C.George

This original petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenges the order of the Rent Control Revisional Authority (Additional District Judge IV), Kottayam, dated 24 February 2022 in RCRP No.4 of 2021. The Revisional Authority had upheld the dismissal of E.A. No.4 of 2021, filed in EP No.166 of 2019 in RP No.13 of 2018, which sought to challenge a delivery/eviction order under Section 11(2)(b) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act. The petitioner, a domestic aide to the respondent, claims through fraud and misrepresentation she is the rightful owner of the petition schedule building, alleging the sale deed was obtained in the respondent’s name with her and her mother’s assistance. She sought relief under Rules 97 and 98 of Order XXI CPC read with Section 47 CPC, challenging the execution petition. The Execution Court had held that Section 47 CPC did not apply to rent-control eviction execution, and E.A.4 was not maintainable. The High Court held that Rule 97 of Order XXI is, in fact, maintainable in execution proceedings under Section 14 of the Act and remitted the matter to the Execution Court to decide E.A.4 on merits, with opportunity for both sides to adduce evidence, without expressing any opinion on merits. The judgment emphasizes that the substantive questions of ownership and title will be determined on evidence in subsequent proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
AR No.32 of 2021

CEEVEES IMAGING AND HEALTHCARE RESEARCH PRIVATE LIMITED v SIEMENS LTD.

This petition, AR No.32 of 2021, filed in the Kerala High Court, concerns an arbitration request under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The petitioners, a private limited company, entered into a purchase order on 13.02.2016 with Siemens for a Biograph 6 True Point eco system, with a quoted value of ₹5.40 crore, for delivery to the Cochin centre. The installation allegedly failed due to inadequate power, and after heavy rains in 2018 the equipment located at the petitioners’ premises was flooded and rendered unusable. The petitioners issued an arbitration notice in October 2020 arguing for arbitration as per the contract, alleging substantial injury and seeking appointment of an arbitrator. The respondents challenged the petition on territorial jurisdiction and seat of arbitration, arguing, through Annexure-R1(e) proforma invoice, that Mumbai is the seat and that Bombay High Court should entertain any Section 11 application. The court, however, examined the arbitration clauses and related documents (Annexure-A purchase order and Annexure-R1(e) proforma invoice) and held that Ernakulam is the intended seat, since Annexure-A mandates arbitration and permits interim relief from Ernakulam courts; its terms supersede those in the proforma invoice if inconsistent. Consequently, the court held the AR 32/2021 maintainable in Kerala and appointed Mr. Justice P. R. Ramachandra Menon as the sole arbitrator, with directions for disclosure and further steps, leaving substantive contentions to be raised before the arbitrator.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) Nos. 653/2021 and 1236/2021

OP(C) Nos. 653 of 2021 and 1236 of 2021, High Court of Kerala (Original Petitions)

These original petitions challenge an order in I.A.1515/2019 in O.S.292/2011 (Munsiff’s Court, Thodupuzha) that partly allowed an amendment application. The suit concerns fixation of the boundary of plaint A schedule (about 1 acre 59 cents) and B schedule (approximately 2.5 acres) with C schedule claimed as encroached. Plaintiffs allege exclusive possession of A schedule; defendants claim possession over 58.87 Ares and contend B schedule extent is mis-stated due to a resurvey. During trial, the plaintiffs sought to amend under Order VI Rule 17 after closure of evidence, citing the commission report and need for reconciling survey details and sale deed references. The Munsiff’s Court allowed one item (sale deed No. 123/1993 added to plaint) since not objected to during hearing and documents were already produced, but rejected other amendments due to lack of stated reasons and to the timing post-closure. The High Court, per Justice V.G. Arun, found merit in the challenge to the impugned order, noting that the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 requires due diligence and proper justification for late amendments, and that Sasikala TV v. C.P. Joseph (2021) no longer renders the position res integra. The Court set aside the impugned order, allowed the petitions, and directed the trial court to reconsider the amendment afresh after hearing, with due regard to the proviso and Sasikala, within strict time limits, and to dispose of the suit thereafter.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No.2397/2007

Anil Kumar v. State of Kerala

Anil Kumar, the appellant, challenges a 304B IPC conviction recorded by the II Additional Sessions Court, Kozhikode in SC No. 635 of 2005 arising from Crime No. 422 of 2004 at Vatakara Police Station. The prosecution alleged that after a Hindu marriage on 23 October 1998, the deceased Bindu, wife of Anil Kumar, suffered ongoing dowry-related cruelty and ill-treatment, culminating in her suicide by self-immolation along with her young son on 7 July 2004. The trial court found him guilty and sentenced seven years’ rigorous imprisonment. The High Court of Kerala, in a Criminal Appeal (Crl. A. No. 2397 of 2007) led by Justice Ziyad Rahman A.A., re-examines the evidence, focusing on the reliability and consistency of principal witnesses (PW2 and PW3), the authenticity of Ext.P4 (marriage certificate) and the date it asserts, and the absence of a thorough investigation into the cause of death (whether suicide, fire accident, or other). The court notes contradictions in the versions of the parents of the deceased, the lack of scene mahazar or a site plan, and the absence of direct evidence of a dowry demand tied to the death. Relying on established principles from related jurisprudence, the court finds that essential ingredients of 304B are not proven and that the prosecution’s case lacks coherence, leading to an acquittal and setting aside the Sessions Court’s judgment.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2802 OF 2012

Panacea Biotec Ltd. and Ravinder Jain v. State of Kerala and Drugs Inspector (Intelligence Branch), Thrissur

Bechu Kurian Thomas, J., delivered the judgment on 14 July 2022 in CRL.MC 2802 of 2012, challenging an order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Thrissur, in CC No. 20/2009. The petitioners, accused 1 to 3, sought relief under Section 482 Cr.P.C. against an order dated 10 July 2012 that condoned a delay in filing the complaint and directed them to stand trial in a private action under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1942. Accused 2 had already died, abating his proceedings. The private complaint, under Section 32 of the Act, alleged misbranding under Section 18(a)(i) read with Section 17(b) and 17(c) read with Rule 96 of the Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945. The High Court had earlier held cognizance tainted by delay and directed the Magistrate to reassess condonation grounds. The learned Magistrate, however, condoned the delay in the interest of justice under Section 473 Cr.P.C. The State contended there was sufficient pleading against the 2nd accused and that Section 202 Cr.P.C. is not mandatory in all circumstances. The judge held that while Section 473 allows condonation, the crucial issue was Section 202’s mandatory character where accused resides beyond the court’s jurisdiction, and cognizance had been taken without a Section 202 inquiry. On this ground, the petition was allowed and the proceedings against accused 1 and 3 were quashed as an abuse of process.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 2858 of 2008

LajeeB v. State of Kerala

A Kerala High Court single-judge (K. Babu, J.) heard Crl.A. No. 2858 of 2008, an appeal by LajeeB challenging his conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act and sentence of one year imprisonment plus fine. The trial court’s conviction arose from possession of 60 plastic covers, each containing 100 ml of arrack, found near Peroor temple in Kottamkara village on 21.03.2003, leading to charges under Section 55(a) and 55(i) of the Abkari Act. The prosecution relied on PWs 1-3, Exts. P1–P8 and MOs I-II, and a 313 Cr.P.C. statement by the accused, who pleaded innocence. The appellant’s grounds of appeal challenged the sufficiency of proof of conscious possession and the link between the seized arrack and its analysis in the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory. He also urged doubts about the arrest since the arrest memo (Ext. P2) bore a crime number. The court traced jurisprudence on chain of custody, delays in producing property and in laboratory analysis, and the necessity of linking seized samples to laboratory results, citing Santhosh v. State of Kerala; Ravi v. State of Kerala; Sasidharan v. State of Kerala; Sathi v. State of Kerala; Krishnadas v. State of Kerala; Vijay Pandey v. State of U.P; and State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram. It concluded that the prosecution failed to prove possession and the tamper-proof chain of custody, with unexplained delays; the conviction was thus unsustainable and the accused was acquitted. The appeal was allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2941 OF 2008

Devi, W/o Late Cheriyeekkan v. State of Kerala

Aggrieved by the judgment dated 24.11.2008 of the Additional District and Sessions Court, Fast Track (Adhoc-I), Kozhikode in SC No.803/2006, the appellant Devi challenges her conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possession of 1.5 litres of illicit arrack. The trial court found the evidence establishing the contraband and the Chemical Analysis, but the High Court scrutinizes key proof: Exhibit P6 shows a bottle was forwarded to the Chemical Examiner on 07.08.2002, while the seizure occurred on 16.08.2002; there is no evidence of the date of forwarding or of tamper‑proof dispatch by officials; none of the custody personnel were examined. The legal framework requires the chain of custody to be established so that the sample tested in the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory is the same sample seized at the place of occurrence. The Court relies on Sasidharan v. State of Kerala and Sathi v. State of Kerala, and State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram to stress that a sample changing hands before analysis must be supported by witnesses and proper sealing. It also notes unexplained delays in analysis, citing Krishnadas v. State and Vijay Pandey. On these grounds, the court acquits the appellant; the appeal is allowed, and she is set at liberty. The court emphasizes that the prosecution failed to prove that the contraband substance tested in the laboratory was the same sample seized, and with the lack of reliable link evidence, the conviction cannot stand.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.6322 of 2021

Sub (PA) C. Suresh Babu and Sub Maj/PA M.E. Biju v. Colonel (PERS), Directorate General of Supply and Transport (ST 12), Officer Commanding, HQ 91 Infantry Brigade, Pangode Military Camp, Pangode, Trivandrum, and Lieutenant Colonel, Establishment Officer, HQ 10 Corps (Establishment)

This writ petition, filed by two Junior Commissioned Officers (JCOs) of the Indian Army, challenges a posting/transfer order issued by the respondents. The petitioners contend that their daughter—a special child diagnosed with Down syndrome with PDA and severe retardation, who is speech-impaired and fluent only in Malayalam—needs continuous Malayalam-language speech therapy and family-based attention. After being posted to Thiruvananthapuram to facilitate such care, the petitioners claim that their daughter has benefited from therapy at the National Institute of Speech and Hearing (NISH) and related treatments; they argue that a transfer to Punjab would disrupt this therapy and adversely affect the child’s development. Exhibit materials establish medical and disability-related details. While the 2nd respondent’s recommendation favored retention, the first respondent issued a transfer on the grounds of public interest and administrative exigencies. The respondents contend that, under public law, a servant has no guaranteed right to remain at a fixed posting and that, absent mala fides or statutory violation, courts should not interfere with transfers. Citing State of Madhya Pradesh v. S.S. Kourav and National Hydroelectric Power Corp. Ltd. v. Bhagwan, the court emphasizes deference to administrative decisions. Ultimately, the court declines to interfere, noting that if the petitioners encounter difficulties post-transfer they may make a representation to the appropriate authority.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 490 OF 2011

Nalini, W/o Unnikrishnan v. State of Kerala

Nalini, wife of Unnikrishnan, the accused in an Abkari Act case, appeals against her conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act by the Additional Sessions Court (Fast Track II), Palakkad, for possessing 5 litres of illicit arrack on 04.09.2007 at Perumudiyar Desom, Muthuthala Village, Ottapalam Taluk. The trial court framed the charge, examined witnesses, and relied on Exts. P1–P9 and MO1 to convict, sentencing her to one year’s rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. On appeal, the Kerala High Court, in a judgment delivered on 24 August 2022 by Justice K. Babu, allowed the appeal and acquitted. The court found that the prosecution failed to establish the identity of the person carrying the contraband at the scene, noting that PW1 and PW2 had only a fleeting view and that Ext. P1/mahazar contained additions (including signatures) not consistently reflected in MO1. There were no independent witnesses corroborating the prosecution, and the accused’s signature on MO1 could not be relied upon to prove identity. Further, there was no verifiable chain of custody for the sample, no tamper-proof dispatch proof, and an unexplained delay in chemical analysis (sample admitted late and analyzed after a long gap). Relying on well‑established authorities on eyewitness identification and forensic chain of custody (including Krishnadas v. State of Kerala), the court held the link to the contraband was not proved and acquitted the appellant. The appeal is allowed as above.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2977 OF 2008

Thankappan v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal appeal (CRL.A No. 2977 of 2008) by Thankappan challenging the conviction under Section 55(g) of the Abkari Act by the Additional District Court (Adhoc)-I, Kollam, in Sessions Case No. 1724 of 2004. The appellant was convicted and sentenced to one year rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. The prosecution case: on 29-01-2003, 5:30 PM, 30 litres of wash were found in a cannas on the roadside at Manappally, Karunagappally Taluk, within the jurisdiction of the excise department. The case proceeded from a magistrate to the Sessions Court, where the accused faced trial, defense evidence was recorded, and the trial court convicted. The core challenge on appeal centered on the chain of custody and the tamper-proof handling of the contraband sample: Ext.P3 seizure mahazar did not describe the seal; the detecting officer (PW1) did not testify about the seal’s nature; specimen seal was not produced; forwarding note for laboratory analysis was not produced; key custody witnesses (Property Clerk and Excise Guard) were not examined. The court examined a string of authorities emphasizing strict compliance with sampling/sealing and chain-of-custody requirements. The appellate court ultimately acquitted the accused, holding the prosecution failed to establish that the sample tested in the lab was the same sample drawn from the contraband, and thus the conviction could not be sustained. The appeal is allowed, and the accused is acquitted and set at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 1800 OF 2021

Crl.M.C. No. 1800 of 2021

Criminal Misc. Case No. 1800 of 2021, before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, Justice Kauser Edappagath, concerns a petition to quash Annexure-AII final report in Crime No. 565/2016, Hosdurg Police Station. The petitioners are accused Nos. 2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 12, 14 to 16 (including an Addl. 10th petitioner later impleaded). The 2nd respondent is the de facto complainant and respondents 3 to 15 are the injured. The offences alleged against the accused are punishable under Sections 143, 147, 148, 447, 323, 324, 326, 308, 354 r/w 149 IPC. The respondents submitted affidavits and appeared through counsel; the matter was amicably settled between the petitioners and the de facto complainant. The Public Prosecutor stated the inquiry corroborated the settlement. The court relied on Supreme Court precedents (Gian Singh; Narinder Singh; Laxmi Narayan) and later Kerala decisions (Lovely Salhotra; Sajeev & Another) to permit quashing under S.482 Cr.P.C in settlements, including quashing FIR against some accused where appropriate. The court found that the dispute is personal, not impacting public interest, and the offences do not categorically prohibit compounding. Consequently, the petition is allowed; Annexure AII final report against petitioners 2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 12, 14–16 is quashed. The order notes addition of the 10th accused and cites ongoing procedural developments.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 7203/2021; 8566/2021; 13904/2021; 15689/2021; 19915/2021; 21493/2021; 22624/2021; 24451/2021; 24545/2021

W.P.(C) Nos. 7203/2021, 8566/2021, 13904/2021, 15689/2021, 19915/2021, 21493/2021, 22624/2021, 24451/2021 and 24545/2021, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

The petitions, filed by retired employees of the Kerala State Financial Enterprises Limited (KSFE), challenge the non-disbursal of terminal benefits such as gratuity, earned leave surrender, arrears of Dearness Allowance, salary revision arrears, festival incentives and flood-relief payments. The Company justifies withholding by pointing to alleged liabilities arising from sticky loans/chits granted by branches where the petitioners had worked, claiming that such liabilities must be recovered from retirement dues. The petitioners argue that no disciplinary proceedings were initiated during service, and benefits are rewards for service that must be released promptly after retirement; withholding them contradicts the mutual trust in employer–employee relationships and violates constitutional rights. The court notes the absence of a statutory provision authorizing post-retirement recovery without due process and relies on a body of jurisprudence recognizing retiral benefits as property and protected rights. Citing cases like Khem Chand, Deoki Nandan Prasad, Haresh Banerjee, Jharkhand v. Srivastava, and Nakara, the court concludes that the company is bound to disburse terminal and related benefits forthwith, directs payment within three months, and imposes interest provisions if delayed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No.68 of 2022

Vinod Kumar M K v. State of Kerala and Others

Vinod Kumar M K, a candidate included in the Kerala Public Service Commission's ranked list for the post of Lower Division Typist in Alappuzha, challenges Ext.P4 order (OA 1275/2021) of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal that dismissed his grievance. He argues that clerical staff and data entry operators are temporarily performing the duties of Lower Division Typists in 71 Grama Panchayats, and that several Panchayats have proposed regularizing these posts (Annexures A2 and A3). He seeks a direction to sanction and create posts in the district based on those proposals, asserting that retention of temporary staff undermines his opportunity for regular appointment despite being listed in Annexure A1 (dated 10-11-2020). The Director of Panchayats contends that the temporary appointments are under a government order (Annexure R3A 2012) creating Technical Assistants on a contract basis with different qualifications, and that the Government rejected the proposal to create Lower Division Typist posts (Annexure R3B). The Tribunal rejected the challenge, holding that inclusion in a rank list grants only a right to consideration for vacancies during its life, not a vested right to appointment, and that post-creation is a policy decision. The High Court, upholding that view, relies on Supreme Court authority that policy decisions are for the Government’s domain and courts should refrain from directing creation of posts. The petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
DBP No.92 of 2023

Advisory Ad-Hoc Committee, Major Cheruvalli Sree Devi Temple v Travancore Devaswom Board

This Kerala High Court DBP (DBP No.92 of 2023) concerns allegations of misappropriation of funds by the office-bearers of the Temple Advisory Committee of Cheruvalli Devaswom, under the Travancore Devaswom Board. The petitioner, Muraleedharan Nair, filed a complaint invoking Ombudsman scrutiny (Complaint No.83 of 2022) and sought investigation into misappropriation during 2017–2022. The Ombudsman’s Report No.42 of 2023 recounts the proceedings, annexures, and recommendations, including Vigilance enquiry and audit of the Temple Advisory Committee and Ad-hoc Committee accounts, and potential disqualification of defaulting members. The matter was placed before the Travancore Devaswom Board; Vigilance recommended auditing the accounts and taking action based on audit findings; the Board’s report and communications were placed on record. The court refers to the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, notably Section 15A (Board duties) and Section 31 (Board management of properties), and to decisions emphasizing protection of temple properties by trustees and courts, including A.A. Gopalakrishnan, Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair, and Suo motu v. State of Kerala. The High Court disposes the petition with directions to the Board to decide based on the Vigilance report dated 26.07.2023, after hearing, and, if the State Audit Department audit is accepted, to file a DBA seeking further directions.

High Court of Kerala
DBP No.83 of 2023

Sri Narayanan Kutty K. v. The Secretary, Cochin Devaswom Board, The Special Devaswom Commissioner, Cochin Devaswom Board, Thrissur (and Addl. R3 Cochin Devaswom Board)

This Division Bench of the High Court of Kerala (Justices Anil K. Narendran and G. Girish) considers DBP No.83 of 2023, arising from Ombudsman Report No.32/2023 in Complaint No.105/2023, concerning alleged untoward incidents on Pooram day at Sree Vadakkumnathan Temple under Cochin Devaswom Board. The petitioner, Sri Narayanan Kutty K., alleges violations of temple rituals and practices; the Ombudsman’s report collates photographs and complaints suggesting improper conduct by Devaswom officials, temple advisory committee members, and municipal authorities. The case situates itself in the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950, noting Section 62 vesting administration in the Board, with certain ritual control retained for specific temples, and a framework under Sections 62, 62A, 62B, 68, 73A, and 74, along with the Kerala Land Conservancy Act, 1957. The Court recalls prior orders and DBP Nos.32/2023 and 35/2023, and emphasizes the Board’s fiduciary duty to manage temples in accordance with trust objects and established usage. It also reiterates that Vadakkumnatha Maidan is Devaswom land; activities there must align with the trust’s purposes and court directions. The judgment prescribes plastic-free Maidan, bans hoardings and political displays, restricts footwear entry, ensures security, and requires strict adherence to earlier court directions during Pooram. Ultimately, the petition is disposed with directions to comply with prior orders during Pooram days.

High Court of Kerala
Tr.P.C. No.762 of 2021

Niju J @ Neju Joseph (Johnson) v. Sosamma and Smt. Swapna Vijayan

This is a Transfer Petition (Civil) under Section 24 CPC filed in the Kerala High Court by Niju J @ Neju Joseph (the husband) seeking transfer of OP No. 607/2021 (money decree filed by Sosamma in the Family Court, Kollam) to the Family Court, Chavara. The petitioner (represented by his power of attorney holder, a senior citizen) argues that defending Annexure-A1 from Kollam would be impracticable due to the POA holder’s health and travel burdens, and that the related divorce proceedings OP 91/2021 filed by him in Chavara should be consolidated with the Kollam matter. The respondent Sosamma and her counsel contend that the governing principle in matrimonial transfers is the convenience of the wife and children, a view reinforced by binding Supreme Court and Kerala cases cited in the judgment. While the petitioner later sought transfer of Annexure-A2 (OP 91/2021) to Kollam to consolidate, the court ultimately held that Annexure-A1 transfer could not be ordered, but allowed Annexure-A2’s transfer to Kollam. The order directs transmission of records, consolidation procedures, and leaves open the possibility of joint trial, emphasizing avoidance of multiplicity of proceedings. The bench, presided by Justice C. S. Dias, clarifies the evolving law on transfer of matrimonial disputes and upholds weight to the respondent’s convenience.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4612 OF 2023

Rahana v. State of Kerala and others

Rahana v. State of Kerala and others concerns a criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC filed in the Kerala High Court challenging the order/judgment in CC 581/2022 from the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Devikulam. The petitioner, Rahana, is the accused in a case under IPC Section 380 (theft) arising on 16.07.2022, when gold ornaments worth Rs 2,20,000 were allegedly stolen from the shop run by the de facto complainant. The petition argues that the dispute between the parties has been amicably settled and that they do not wish to pursue prosecution, with affidavits from respondents supporting the settlement. The State Prosecutor, while noting the absence of other crimes against Rahana, expresses reservations about quashing merely on settlement and stresses the need to justify exercise of the court’s inherent power under 482 CrPC. The High Court reviews jurisprudence from State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and the Gian Singh and Narinder Singh line of authorities, clarifying governing principles: quashing is possible for non-compoundable, private offences with settlement when it would promote ends of justice and not harm public interest; however, it should not apply to heinous/offences of serious nature or offences under special statutes (e.g., 307 IPC, Arms Act). After considering offence gravity, antecedents, and settlement, the court concludes quashing would not adversely affect society. The petition is allowed and the Final Report in Crime No. 502/2022 and all proceedings in CC 581/2022 are quashed, bringing the matter to an end.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 5131/2021 & 22849/2021

All India BSNL-DOT Pensioners Association v Union of India and Others

Two writ petitions in WP(C) Nos. 5131/2021 and 22849/2021 were filed by the All India BSNL-DOT Pensioners Association. The petitions sought relief for pensioners linked to BSNL/DoT and apparently related to service-related schemes such as medical reimbursement and centralised allotment, as evidenced by the exhibits referencing BSNL medical reimbursement schemes and various Office Orders. The core procedural issue tackled by the Kerala High Court was maintainability and locus standi. The respondents raised objections that BSNL employees are central government employees and their grievances fall within the jurisdiction of the Central Administrative Tribunal under the Administrative Tribunals Act, and pointed to a Division Bench decision in Self Financing Arts and Science College Management Welfare Association v. M.G. University (2016 (4) KHC 293) to contend that the petitioning association lacks locus standi to file a writ under Article 226. The court invoked State of Orissa v. Ram Chandra Dev (AIR 1964 SC 685) to reiterate that Article 226 writs require a rights-based foundation, and concluded that the petitioners have no locus standi and no right inviolably threatened. Consequently, the petitions were dismissed for want of maintainability, with the court noting the practitioner’s reliance on the cited precedents. Exhibits include medical reimbursement scheme documents, Office Orders, and representations.

High Court of Kerala
CRL. M.C. No. 7435 of 2023

CRL.M.C. No. 7435 of 2023, Kerala High Court

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC, arising from CC 208/2021 (Crime No. 977/2020, Neeleswaram), where four petitioners are accused of offences under Sections 341, 323, 324 read with 34 IPC. The petitioners seek to quash the prosecution on the basis that the parties have settled their dispute and the victims have no objection. The Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing merely on the basis of settlement but conceded that the matter is settled. The court, after examining the records and the victims’ affidavits, relied on State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) and the related precedents Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh and Others v. State of Punjab, to delineate the scope of the power under Section 482 CrPC to quash non-compoundable offences in private, civil-like disputes. The Laxmi Narayan decision holds that quashing is permissible when the dispute is private, civil in character, and the entire dispute is resolved, with exceptions for heinous offences, offences under special statutes, or acts by public servants. The court found the present dispute private and acceptable for settlement, and allowed the Criminal Miscellaneous Case, quashing all further proceedings in CC 208/2021 against the petitioners. The order emphasizes careful consideration of antecedents and the nature of the offence in exercising the inherent jurisdiction.