Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 597 of 4659
High Court
CRL.MC NO.4299 OF 2023

null

The petition under Section 482 CrPC is filed by accused Nos. 1 to 6 in CP No.47 of 2023 pending before the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Mannarkkad, seeking quashment of proceedings concerning offences under Sections 341, 323, and 324 r/w Section 34 IPC. The prosecution alleges that on 12.10.2022, the petitioners, in furtherance of their common intention, restrained and assaulted the de facto complainant, causing injuries. The petitioners argue that the dispute has been amicably settled and that they do not wish to pursue the prosecution; an affidavit from the de facto complainant supports the settlement. The Public Prosecutor submits reservations about invoking the court’s inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC solely on the basis of a settlement, though notes that there are no other serious crimes against the accused. The High Court cites established law from State of Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan, Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab to delineate the scope of 482 CrPC: quashing is permissible for non-compoundable offences with predominantly civil character where the dispute is settled, while not applicable to heinous crimes or offences under special statutes. After weighing gravity, antecedents, and the settlement, the judge concludes that quashing would promote peace and end justice, and would not adversely impact society. The petition is allowed, quashing the Final Report in Crime No.674/2022 and all further proceedings in CP 47/2023.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC 6087 of 2023

Nitheesh M and others v State of Kerala and others

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC, heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court. The petitioners (accused Nos. 1 to 8) challenge Crime No. 419/2017 registered at Museum Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, for offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 323, 324, 341 and 308 r/w 149. The accused contend that the dispute has been amicably settled with the de facto complainants, with affidavits supporting the settlement, and urge the High Court to quash the prosecution in the interests of peace and ends of justice. The Public Prosecutor initially voiced reservations but acknowledged that no other serious crimes have been registered against the petitioners. The Court analyzes established principles from State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan, Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, to determine the scope of its extraordinary power under Section 482 CrPC in cases involving non-compoundable offences with a predominantly civil character where the dispute has been resolved. It notes exceptions for heinous offences (e.g., murder, rape, dacoity) and for offences under special statutes, while permitting quashing if the ends of justice are served by the settlement and there is no public intrusiveness. On balancing the gravity of the offence, injuries, and the amicable settlement, the High Court concludes that continuing the prosecution would be counterproductive and would not advance public interest. Accordingly, the petition is allowed; Annexure-A2 Final Report and related proceedings in respect of accused Nos. 1–8 are quashed, and the proceedings are terminated. The decision reflects the Court’s view that quashing private settlements in non-compoundable offences can serve peace and the ends of justice when public interest is not implicated.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No. 5691 of 2021; CRL.MC No. 5697 of 2021

Leelamma John and John M. George v. T. George Varghese and State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High CourtCriminal Miscellaneous case involving two petitions (CRL.MC No. 5691 of 2021 and CRL.MC No. 5697 of 2021) challenging orders in two NI Act cases (C.C. Nos. 2658/2017 and 2929/2017) arising from complaints under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The accused, Leelamma John and John M. George (proprietors of Aleph Enterprises), had executed agreements related to import of raw cashew from UAE supplier Delta Star General Trading LLC. Four cheques were issued in discharge of the purported liability, but bounced, leading to criminal proceedings and cognizance by the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners argued that, as per FEMA, payment to a foreign entity must be made only through an authorized person, and the first respondent (the complainant) was not authorized to receive funds on behalf of Delta Star LLC, so there was no legally enforceable debt. They further contended suppression of material facts in support of these petitions. The respondents opposed on grounds of suppression and, in substance, reliance on a mediation settlement dated 14.11.2019, under which installments were to be paid, with interim Bank credits contested. The High Court found suppression of material facts and refused to consider merits, invoking the clean-hands principle and related jurisprudence. Consequently, the Crl.M.Cs were dismissed. The decision emphasizes that writ jurisdiction is equitable and requires full disclosure; any concealment constitutes abuse of process.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P.Nos.798 & 799 of 2023

Abdul Azeez v. Sulaiman & State of Kerala

These two criminal revision petitions arise from two NI Act cases instituted by Abdul Azeez against Sulaiman and the State of Kerala. The complainant alleged that the accused issued two cheques, Ext. P2 for Rs. 10,00,000 and Ext. P3 for Rs. 7,61,900, both dated 14-10-2014, in conjunction with a sale agreement dated 14-03-2013; the cheques were dishonoured for funds insufficient. Notices were issued but payment was not made, prompting prosecutions under Section 138 NI Act in S.T. Nos. 9/2017 and 33/2017. The trial court convicted Abdul Azeez under Section 138, applying the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act, and sentenced him to pay compensation under CrPC 357(3) and to imprisonment in default. The Additional Sessions Judge, Manjeri, as well as the Sessions Court, confirmed these convictions and sentences. The revision petitions argue that Exts. P2 and P3 were part of a sale consideration and, though a sale deed was not executed, there is no reliable evidence that the sale was completed in the accused’s favour or his nominees; the defence did not rebut the presumptions effectively. The High Court held that the trial and appellate courts properly evaluated the evidence, that the complainant discharged initial burden, and that the presumptions were appropriately applied and unrebutted. On these grounds the petitions were dismissed, and the trial court was directed to execute the sentence without delay.

High Court of Kerala
WA 743 OF 2019

Union of India v. K. Gomathy

This is a writ appeal filed by the Union of India challenging a Kerala High Court judgment dated 25 May 2018 in WP(C) No.2692 of 2013, which directed the Union Government to grant Swatantrata Sainik Samman Pension (SSS Pension) to the petitioner, the widow of late C. K. Madhavan. The petitioner asserted that Madhavan was a freedom fighter who actively participated in the Punnapra-Vayalar movement, and that he possessed a Thamrapathra and served a convict sentence under the Travancore Emergency Powers Act, 1122 (Act 1 of 1122 ME). The State Government verified the jail certificate (Ext. P1) and recommended the pension, while the Union Government rejected the claim on the ground that there were no primary records clarifying Madhavan’s participation in the movement and the Act’s applicability, noting that Act 1 of 1122 had not been placed before them. The writ court allowed the petition, holding that the scheme’s object is to honour freedom fighters and that the standard of proof is liberal, based on probable evidence rather than beyond reasonable doubt. The Division Bench, comprising Chief Justice S. Manikumar and Justice Shaji P. C. Chaly, relied on precedents such as Gurdial Singh v. Union of India and Kamalbai Sinkar v. State of Maharashtra to uphold a broad, probabilistic approach. The appellate court ultimately dismissed the writ appeal, thereby sustaining the writ court’s direction that the Union Government grant the pension within three months.

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos. 3813/2023; 5992/2023; 6819/2023 (connected to Crime No. 326/2022, Kollengode PS, Palakkad)

Bail Applications in Crime No. 326/2022, Kollengode Police Station, Palakkad: Hamsa; Musthafa; Asiya; Saidalavi; Jameela v. State of Kerala

These bail petitions arise from Crime No. 326/2022 of Kollengode Police Station (Palakkad), registered for offences including sections 406, 417, 418, 419, 420, 423, 424, 463, 464, 465, 468, 470, 471, 474, 484 and 120B read with section 34 IPC. The petitioners — Hamsa (BA 3813/2023), Musthafa (BA 5992/2023), and Asiya, Saidalavi and Jameela (BA 6819/2023) — seek anticipatory bail in the wake of allegations that they conspired to alienate the defacto complainant’s property through a forged power of attorney and sale deed. The civil suit OS No. 121/2021 before the Sub Court, Palakkad, concerns the same property; the alleged power of attorney was executed on 08.10.2006, coinciding with the complainant’s passport renewal at the Jeddah Consulate, and the sale deed was executed in 2012. Petitioners argue that the sale proceeds were paid to the complainant and reflected in tax returns, and that the civil dispute has been pending for years; they contend custodial interrogation is unnecessary given the long gap and ongoing civil litigation. Prosecution counters that forgery is involved and that custodial interrogation is required for a thorough investigation. The court, after considering rival submissions, grants anticipatory bail to all petitioners subject to conditions (surrender within a week, bonds and sureties, cooperation, no witness intimidation, no leaving India, etc.) and clarifies police power to investigate even on bail per a cited Apex Court principle. The decision balances investigation need with liberty, and orders compliance with bail conditions.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 7419 OF 2023

Mohammed Shahid; Muhammed Favas; Ravin Rajeesh A; Anujith v. State of Kerala and Station House Officer, Ernakulam Town South Police Station, Ernakulam and Sulfikar Ali

CRL.MC 7419 of 2023 arises from Crime No. 1868/2023 at Ernakulam Town South Police Station, where four accused—Mohammed Shahid, Muhammed Favas, Ravin Rajeesh A and Anujith—are charged with offences under Sections 341, 323, 324, 294(b), and 308 r/w Section 34 IPC. The petitioners move under Section 482 CrPC to quash the proceedings, asserting that the dispute between the parties is private, has been settled amicably, and the victim has no objection to quashing. The victim (3rd respondent) supports settlement via affidavit, while the Public Prosecutor acknowledges the settlement but expresses reservations about quashing solely on its basis. The court, citing the Supreme Court precedents in State of Madhya Pradesh v Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) (5) SCC 688, Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab (2014) SCC 466), lays down the framework for invoking 482 CrPC to quash non-compoundable offences in private disputes where settlement exists. It emphasizes that such power is predominantly civil in character and cannot be used for heinous offences or for offences under special statutes or acts against public interest, such as the POC Act or Arms/307 IPC scenarios; the High Court may examine whether the charge was properly framed and the severity of injury only after evidence is collected. In the present case, the dispute is private, settlement is genuine, and quashing is warranted; hence the petition is allowed and all further proceedings are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 2662 of 2008

Thilakarajan S/o Nanu v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal by Thilakarajan S/o Nanu challenging a trial court conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act and Rule 9 of the Foreign Liquor Rules for possession of 20 bottles of Indian Made Foreign Liquor near the cloak room at the New Bus Stand, Thalassery, on 18.11.2006. The Addl. Sessions Court (Adhoc-II), Thalassery, convicted the appellant and sentenced him to three years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000. The prosecution's case rests on seizure details (Exts. P1–P9) and the laboratory analysis of the seized liquor. On appeal, the appellant contends two grave deficiencies: (i) unexplained delay in producing the seized properties before the court, and (ii) failure to prove that the liquor seized at the scene reached the Chemical Examiner’s Laboratory in a tamper‑proof condition. The judgment analyzes the chain of custody, the seals, and the link between the seized sample and the lab report, citing Ravi v. State of Kerala, Sasidharan, and Sathi to underscore the necessity of strict sampling/sealing formalities and prompt production of material. The High Court ultimately finds the link evidence lacking, gives the benefit of doubt, and acquits the appellant, allowing the appeal and setting him at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.7182/2023

Shuaib A.S. v. State of Kerala and Narcotic Control Bureau

This is a second regular bail application (B.A. No. 7182/2023) by Shuaib A.S., accused No.2 in Crime No.1/2022 of the Narcotic Control Bureau, Kochi. The NDPS matter concerns the seizure of 80 grams of MDMA on 09.11.2021 from the possession of accused 1, Sajith S., and alleges involvement of accused 2 in arranging a lodge, paying rent, and funding other accused in the contraband transaction. The prosecution relies largely on the statements of co-accused and the financial transactions traced to accused 2, including payments to facilitate procurement and delivery of the contraband. The petitioner contends these materials are insufficient to connect him to the crime; he asserts that confession statements of other accused are inadmissible and that he is a first-time offender who has been in custody since 29.01.2022, with the Section 37 NDPS rider not applicable. The Special Public Prosecutor argues prima facie complicity and that, given the involvement of commercial quantity, bail should be refused, and directs to expedite trial in line with prior orders. The Court, while acknowledging the law on the NDPS 37 rider (requiring “reasonable grounds” and likely non-commission of offences on bail) and citing Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari, notes that ‘reasonable grounds’ means more than prima facie grounds. On a careful review of materials and the need to expedite, the bail plea is dismissed with a direction to dispose of OR No.1/2022 within six months, and a liberty to apply again if the trial is not completed within that period.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 5398 OF 2020

Ronny v. State of Kerala

Ronny, the sole accused in CC 99/2020 before the Judicial Magistrate of First Class-I, Kollam, faced charges under Sections 323 and 341 IPC for allegedly assaulting and restraining Meridasan near Elampalloor temple on 20.04.2018. The informant, an Overseer at KSEB, reported the incident to police on 21.04.2018, but no crime was registered immediately; a later statement led to Crime No.1964/2019 registered on 06.09.2019, and a final report followed. The petitioner’s counsel argued that the potential penalties under Section 323 (up to one year) and Section 341 (up to one month) reflect the modest severity of the alleged acts, and that the statement registration delay undermines the prosecution. They contended that the delay in lodging the information and absence of corroborating materials to substantiate immediate reporting warrant consideration of limitation. The Public Prosecutor countered that the prosecution records demonstrate substantiated allegations notwithstanding the delay. The High Court examined Section 468 CrPC (bar to cognizance after lapse of the limitation period) and relied on Amritlal v. Shantilal Soni and Others and Sarah Mathew to state that the relevant date for computation is the date of filing the complaint or institution of prosecution, not the date of cognizance. Finding that the complaint was filed after one year and five months, the court held the case barred by limitation and allowed the petition, quashing proceedings in CC 99/2020.

High Court of Kerala
O.P. (CAT) No.185 of 2016

V.J. Xavier v Union of India and others

V.J. Xavier, a retired skipper from the Central Institute of Fisheries Nautical and Engineering Training, challenges adverse entries in his Confidential Report for the period 01.04.2009 to 31.03.2010. He filed OA 817/2012 before the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Ernakulam, seeking expunction of the adverse remarks and related reliefs. The CAT dismissed OA 817/2012 on 14.08.2015 and its Review Application No.180/00019/2015 on 13.11.2015. Xavier contends that the adverse remarks were unjust, arbitrary and the process violated the principles of fair notice and opportunity to rectify. He argues that he submitted a detailed representation on 06.10.2010, but the competent authority retained the adverse entries by a terse order dated 17.02.2011, without adequate opportunity to explain or improve. The respondents claim that the applicant repeatedly took leave, was not regular in duty, and operated under warnings; memos and notes from 22.07.2009 to 23.03.2010 allegedly informed him of deficiencies, enabling improvement. They maintain that the 2nd respondent disposed of the appeal and that the Tribunal correctly retained the ACR entries. The High Court, however, found fault with the Tribunal’s approach, noting lack of due opportunity to rectify and absence of prior adverse remarks for a long period, and ultimately allowed the petition, setting aside the CAT orders and directing relief in favour of the applicant.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 25447/2023 & 25450/2023

Vishnu K. Vijayan and Others v. The Assistant Registrar (General), Office, Kanjirappally; The Special Sale Officer, Co-operative Bank Group; Chirakkadu Service Co-operative Bank Ltd.

These writ petitions challenge Ext.P3 communications by the Assistant Registrar (General), Kanjirappally, informing the petitioners that their applications for setting aside ex parte awards obtained against the 3rd respondent bank cannot be considered. The petitioners rely on this court's decision in Rema Devi and Others v. Joint Registrar (General) of Co-operative Societies, Ekm and Others, 2016 (3) KHC 645, arguing that the arbitrator's powers under Section 70 include setting aside ex parte awards and restoring cases dismissed for default. The court notes that quasi-judicial authorities must possess inherent powers to do justice, to avoid docket congestion, and to avoid resort to endless litigation over technicalities; it cites the need to eliminate technicalities and to ensure access to justice. The court discusses functus officio, concluding that passing an ex parte award does not automatically end the authority's jurisdiction; an authority remains empowered to exercise its power to restore or set aside ex parte orders under law. On consideration, Exts.P3 and P4 are quashed, and the 1st respondent is directed to consider the applications for setting aside ex parte awards on merits and in accordance with law after giving opportunity to both sides. Recovery proceedings are stayed until fresh orders are passed. The court clarifies no opinion on merits.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C. No.2389 of 2013

Giji Daniel v. State of Kerala and Pradeep

The petitioner, Giji Daniel, was the accused in C.C. No.127/2012 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pathanamthitta, under an alleged offence punishable under Section 420 IPC. A complaint led to FIR No.710/2012. The alleged transaction involved an agreement for sale dated 07.11.2010 for 39 cents of land with a total consideration of Rs. 49,00,000, on which an advance of Rs. 4,00,000 was paid. The defacto complainant asserts that the petitioner, with intent to make unlawful gain at the expense of the complainant, entered into the agreement but did not refund the advance or sell the property, and later sold to a third party. The petitioner contends that the case amounts to a civil dispute mischaracterized as a criminal offence, and hence the proceedings should be quashed. He relies on Bhajan Lal’s principle that quashing is warranted where there is no possibility of conviction, and on RK vijayasarathy’s view that civil disputes cloaked as criminal cases may constitute abuse of process. The court analyzes the evidence, noting lack of demand for balance consideration, absence of civil suit for recovery, and absence of proof of criminal intent at the time of agreement. It concludes that there is no criminal liability, and the continuation of proceedings would amount to abuse of process. Consequently, Annexure II final report in CC 127/12 is quashed and the Cr.M.C. is allowed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2191 OF 2008

Lince v. State of Kerala

This criminal appeal, filed by Lince, challenges a 2008 conviction under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act by the Thalassery Sessions Court, which sentenced him to three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh for possessing 12 bottles (1.5 litres each) of Indian Made Foreign Liquor seized on 23 September 2005 near the Thalassery bus stand. The prosecution case rested on seizure mahazar and testimony of PW1–PW3, with Exts. P1–P9, leading to conviction after trial, and the defense calling a DW. The appellant argued two fatal defects: (i) the arrest at the place of occurrence is doubtful because Ext. P2, the arrest memo, contains a crime number, casting doubt on the genesis of the arrest; and (ii) there is no satisfactory proof of tamper-proof despatch of the sample to the laboratory, breaking the chain of custody. The High Court examines these issues in light of authorities including Sasidharan, Sathi, Ravi, Bhaskaran, Santhosh and Vijay Pandey. It concludes the prosecution failed to prove that the laboratory-tested sample corresponded to the sample seized, and that the chain of custody and seal evidence were not properly established, resulting in the reversal of the conviction and acquittal of the accused.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 1305 of 2018

Murali v. State of Kerala

Murali, the sole accused, was convicted by the Additional Sessions Court in S.C. No. 1358 of 2014 for offences under Sections 450 and 376 IPC in a case arising from Crime No. 130/2014 of Kazhakuttom Police Station. The High Court of Kerala, hearing the criminal appeal (CRL.A No. 1305 of 2018), reconsiders the guilt and sentence. The prosecution alleged that on 27.01.2014, Murali trespassed into the victim’s home and raped a 20-year-old mentally and physically challenged young woman, PW-1 (the mother). The victim, who is profoundly disabled (80-95% in various assessments), could not testify, but PW-1, PW-2 (grandmother), PW-3 and PW-4 (neighbours) gave detailed evidence about Murali’s intrusion into the house between 11:30 AM and 12:30 PM, corroborated by MO-1 to MO-3, Exts. P-2 to P-17 and Ext. P-5 (medical certificate). The medical evidence, including Ext.P-5, described rupture of the hymen and other signs; the FSL report Ext.P-17 detected blood on MO-1/ MO-2, though no blood group was determined. The defence challenged the reliability of circumstantial evidence, the conduct of relatives as witnesses, and the lack of direct medical confirmation of rape, invoking Sharad Birdhichand Sarda and related principles. The Court balanced circumstantial evidence with medical uncertainty, reaffirmed the crucial role of independent evidence, and ultimately modified the sentence while affirming conviction, emphasizing restorative justice considerations in light of the victim’s disability.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 24767/2021

Sebin Thomas v. Union of India and Others

Sebin Thomas filed WP(C) No. 24767/2021 seeking a mandamus to stop the release of the motion picture Kurup and to protect the privacy of Sukumara Kurup, a proclaimed offender in Crime No. 22/84. He argued that publication of a film based on Kurup’s life would infringe the right to privacy under Article 21 of the Constitution and that the State has a duty to protect proclaimed offenders’ privacy, which is vested in the government while they remain proclaimed offenders. The petition premised privacy concerns on media reports and public disclosures surrounding the case, and sought directions to prevent release and to safeguard privacy rights during proceedings. Respondents contended that Kurup is the subject of a fictionalized, dramatized work rather than a strict biography, drawing on public-domain information and court records; a disclaimer precedes the film, and the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC) certified it after considering privacy concerns and providing modifications. The court examined Section 82 CrPC and the Cinematograph Act, 1952 and its Rules, including the guidelines under Section 5B(2), noting that the film had already been released (12.11.2021) and that the petition for interim relief was infructuous. Citing K.P. Puttaswamy, R. Rajagopal, Ponnappan, Ramgopal Varma, Abhishek and Suresh A.P., the bench ultimately dismissed the writ petition, distinguishing privacy rights from public-domain information and film fiction.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 7310 OF 2023

Arun Babu v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Misc Case (482) quashing petition filed by Arun Babu, the accused in Crime No.655/2020 of Elamakkara Police Station, Ernakulam, prosecuted for offences under IPC 376(2)(n) and 450 and relevant POCSO Act provisions (Section 4 r/w 3(a), 6(1) read with 5(j)(ii) and 5(l)). The matter is pending as S.C. No.182 of 2021 in the Additional District & Sessions Court (for Trial of Cases Relating to Atrocities and Sexual Violence against Women and Children), Ernakulam. The petitioner contends that after the victim attained majority, the accused and the victim solemnised marriage and are living together as husband and wife; Annexure-5 affidavit and Annexure-4 marriage certificate under the Special Marriage Act corroborate this. He argues that continuation of the prosecution would not serve public interest; relying on Vishnu v. State of Kerala (2023 (4) KHC 1) and a line of Supreme Court decisions (Saju P.R.; Anand D.V.; Jatin Agarwal; Kapil Gupta; K. Dhandapani; etc.), that the inherent power under Cr.P.C. Section 482 can quash proceedings in cases where settlement or marriage between accused and victim promotes ends of justice. The Public Prosecutor and the victim’s counsel acknowledge the current marital status. On these facts, the High Court holds that continuing the proceedings would prejudice the victim and would not advance justice, and consequently allows the petition, quashing all further proceedings in SC No.182/2021 against the petitioner.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C Nos.3603/2021, 3497/2021, 3541/2021, 3565/2021, 3592/2021, 3595/2021, 3602/2021, 3817/2021

Criminal Miscellaneous Cases before the High Court of Kerala (Ernakulam) in CRL.M.C Nos. 3603/2021, 3497/2021, 3541/2021, 3565/2021, 3592/2021, 3595/2021, 3602/2021, 3817/2021

These connected Criminal Miscellaneous Cases arise from a cluster of Crime Branch Pathanamthitta offences involving two petitioners, K.G. Biju and Karippakuzhiyil Sukumaran, who sought quashing of prosecutions under Section 482 CrPC on the ground that the dispute has been settled with the victims and there is no grievance left. The State and the de facto complainants oppose only to the extent of ensuring that quashing does not undermine public interest, especially in offences that are serious or under special statutes. The High Court relies on the Supreme Court doctrine laid down in Laxmi Narayan (State of MP) and the accompanying decisions Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, which hold that quashing of non-compoundable offences can be permitted in private disputes where the parties have resolved their entire dispute, provided the offences are private in nature and do not involve grave public interest. After examining affidavits and records, the court finds the dispute private, the victims consent to quashing, and the offences fall within the permissible category. Accordingly, the court allows the eight connected Crl.MCs, quashing proceedings against the petitioners in specific Crime Nos. related to Crime Branch Pathanamthitta.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 32408/2023; 23185/2022; 30377/2022; 30383/2022; 32074/2022; 33099/2022

Batch of writ petitions in WP(C) Nos. 32408/2023; 23185/2022; 30377/2022; 30383/2022; 32074/2022; 33099/2022, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This batch of writ petitions challenges the liability to pay turnover tax (ToT) on parcel sales of Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL) by FL3/FL11 licensees during the COVID-19 lockdown period (2020-21 and 2021-22). The petitioners, hotel and licensee units, had claimed that no rate for parcel sales was fixed during the limited-period authorisation granted by Government Order Ext.P1, which permitted parcel sales but did not specify the applicable rate; as a result, returns could not be filed or ToT remitted at an undefined rate. The Government eventually issued SRO No.297/2022 dated 26.03.2022 fixing a 5% ToT rate on parcel sales for the restricted periods, while a separate Amnesty/Cabinet framework sought to extend filing and payment deadlines. The State contends Ext.P2 validly fixed the rate at 5% for the concerned periods, and that ToT is a statutory liability; interest for delayed payment is ordinarily due unless explicitly waived. The court, however, adopts a purposive interpretation, notes the lack of a pre-26.03.2022 rate, and holds that the demand of interest for parcel sales during the specified Covid periods is unjustified if returns were filed and ToT paid within the extended window. The judgment relies on Govind Saran Ganga Saran’s four-component tax levy doctrine and distinguishes Voltas Ltd. but treats other cited authorities as mentioned. The petitions are allowed, impugned orders quashed, and cases remitted for fresh assessments with directions on timing and interest.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 29622/2023

Manoj Thomas and Others v State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition concerns the proposed acquisition of about 1039.8 hectares of land from Erumeli South and Manimala Villages in Kottayam District for a Greenfield Sabarimala Airport project. The petitioners claim to be “affected families” under Section 3 of the Right to Fair Compensation And Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (Act 30 of 2013) and challenge the Social Impact Assessment (SIA) Report (Ext. P1) prepared for the project. They allege serious procedural illegality in the SIA process, including lack of transparency, failure to secure consents from project-affected families, and a lack of analysis of whether the land proposed for acquisition is the bare minimum or whether alternatives exist. They also contend that the SIA does not address resettlement and the overall cost-benefit; they seek a declaration that Ext. P1 is illegal and void and for incidental reliefs. The State and its officers deny these allegations, arguing that the petition is premature at this stage of the land-assembly process. They emphasize that the 2013 Act prescribes a stepwise procedure: notification under Section 4(1), publication of the SIA under Section 6, appointment of an independent Expert Group under Section 7 to appraise the SIA, examination by the appropriate Government under Section 8, and hearing of objections under Section 15. The court notes the petition challenges a work-in-progress product at a preliminary stage and that interference at this stage is premature. Citing Sunil J Arackalam v State of Kerala and Others, the court holds that interference at this stage is premature. Consequently, the petition is disposed of with directions to proceed strictly under the Act and to allow petitioners to exercise their rights at the appropriate stage, reserving their rights if prejudice arises.