Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 592 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5330 OF 2024

Rojimon M.V. @ Roji Mathew v. State of Kerala and Station House Officer, Kalamassery Police Station, Ernakulam

Rojimon M.V. @ Roji Mathew, the second accused in Crime No.317/2024 of Kalamassery Police Station, Ernakulam, moves bail under Section 439 CrPC. He is charged with offences under Sections 143, 147, 341, 328, 365 and 419 read with Section 149 IPC. The informant was allegedly assaulted by an unlawful assembly disguised as Narcotics Cell officers; he was injected and taken to Nair’s Psychiatric Hospital where he was treated as a psychiatric patient. The petitioner, an employee of Sacred Heart Hospital, contends he acted bona fide under hospital instruction and was unaware of the other accused’s criminal intent. He has been in judicial custody for 33 days; recovery in the case has been effected; other accused have already been enlarged on bail; he has no criminal antecedents. The learned Public Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing ongoing investigation and risk of witness intimidation or tampering if released. The court cites Sanjay Chandra v. CBI to emphasize presumption of innocence and cautions against denying bail solely on prior conduct, and Dataram Singh v. State of U.P. to reiterate that bail is the rule and imprisonment is an exception. After careful consideration, the court finds detention unnecessary and grants bail subject to stringent conditions, including appearance, non-interference with witnesses, prospective non-commission of offences, passport surrender, and potential cancellation on breach, with leave for further modifications under applicable law.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 2141 OF 2022

I.D.A. Malappuram Branch (Through Its Executive Committee) v. Indian Dental Association Kerala State Branch and others

This Kerala High Court decision arises from OP(C) No. 2141 of 2022 challenging Ext.P6, an order vacating Ext.P3 (an ad-interim injunction) in I.A. No. 2/2022 in O.P.(Arbitration) No. 582/2022 before the Additional District Court-III, Manjeri. The petitioner, I.D.A. Malappuram Branch, sought interim measures under Section 9 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, to restrain the inauguration or installation ceremony of the Indian Dental Association Tirur branch until 15.10.2022. Ext.P3 granted the injunction; after a counter affidavit (Ext.P4) and argument notes (Ext.P5) were filed, the court below vacated the injunction by Ext.P6. The High Court, through Justice C.S. Dias, holds that this course is improper and contrary to the Act’s scheme, which envisages interim relief before or during arbitral proceedings and final disposition of the petition under Section 37. The judge invokes Article 227 of the Constitution to supervise the lower court’s proceedings, notes that the remedy lies in deciding the main petition, and sets aside Ext.P3 and Ext.P6. He directs the parties to maintain status quo as of 29.09.2022, to appear on 14.11.2022, and for the lower court to decide O.P.(Arbitration) No.582/2022 expeditiously, preferably by 23.11.2022. The decision draws on the doctrine of “exceptional rarity” under Bhavan Constructions v. Sardar Sarovar Narmada Nigam Ltd and Deep Industries Ltd. v. ONGC to justify court intervention under Article 227.

High Court of Kerala
W.A. No. 1685/2020 & 1579/2021

W.A. No. 1685/2020 & 1579/2021

This judgment in W.A. Nos. 1685 of 2020 and 1579 of 2021, heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court, concerns the cancellation of a waste-to-energy project concession at Brahmapuram, and the related land handover and contractual issues between M/S G.J. Eco Power Pvt. Ltd. and the Kochi Municipal Corporation, along with State authorities. The State Government, acting on Ext. P28 (30.04.2020) and subsequent orders, cancelled approval and directed termination of the concession agreement; Ext. P29 issued by the Corporation terminated the concession; Ext. P34 reaffirms the government’s stance. The appellant contends that the orders are illegal, arbitrary and violative of natural justice, arguing incomplete land handover (8 hectares, with significant wetland/paddy land), exemptions under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, and the necessity of a lease arrangement and financial close to secure financing. The respondent authorities contend that the concession agreement contains independent, mandatory conditions precedent (including financing and possession) and that failure to achieve financial close justifies termination under Article 3 and related provisions, with orderly termination under Article 16. The Court assesses contractual terms, statutory exemptions, and the 30-day deadline for financial close, ultimately upholding the government’s withdrawal of approval and termination, and dismissing the appeals. It emphasizes that adherence to strict conditions precedent and timely execution are essential to the contract’s viability.

High Court of Kerala
Cont.Case (Civil) No.4 of 2022

Cont.Case (Civil) No.4 of 2022, Sajan T. Sunny v. Biswanath Sinha (Deleted and Substituted) and Rajesh Kumar Singh IAS

The petitioner, Sajan T. Sunny, a retired Commercial Tax Officer, filed Contempt of Court proceedings alleging non-compliance with a 2016 judgment in OP(KAT) No.65 of 2016 which directed the disciplinary enquiry to be finalized and for the petitioner’s eligibility for promotion to be assessed and for consequent promotion and related benefits to be disbursed without delay. The High Court had disposed of the OP(KAT) with directions to proceed and finalize the disciplinary inquiry within four months, so that eligibility for promotion and related benefits could be determined. The contemnor respondents argued that the direction was complied with and that the Contempt case is time-barred under Section 20 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, since the alleged disobedience dates back to 2018 when the DP.C. decided to defer promotion in view of a pending vigilance case. The petitioner contends that the denial of promotion based on a pending vigilance case is unlawful, and that Annexure H (10.08.2021) indicating denial constitutes contempt. During hearing, the court considered precedents such as Pallav Sheth, Maheswar Peri, Dinesh Kumar G.P., and Mohd. Amin Waza, to assess whether there was willful disobedience and whether the limitation provision applies to contempt under Article 215. Ultimately, the court found no willful disobedience and held that the Department had considered his claim and taken a decision; hence the Contempt Case is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
30423/2021; 30524/2021; 30554/2021

WP(C) Nos. 30423/2021, 30524/2021 and 30554/2021

These three writ petitions, heard together before Justice Devan Ramachandran, challenge and seek relief against entries of encumbrances created on a property after an equitable mortgage. The petitioners argue that Ext.P2, which culminated in a judgment directing the Sub Registrar to register Sale Certificates in favour of the petitioners de hors the attachments if they were created after the mortgage, effectively contemplates erasure of post-mortgage encumbrances from the Encumbrance Certificate and Revenue Records. After Ext.P2, Sale Certificates were registered, but the Sub Registrar and Revenue Authorities refused to erase the attachments, contending that the judgment did not expressly order erasure. The Court notes that it is well settled that competent authorities must erase encumbrances registered post the date of the equitable mortgage, citing a catena of judgments including Secretary, Keechery Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. v. Sajitha Nizar Alias Sajitha P.M. The Judge directs the authorities to give effect to this principle and to erase entries of attachments from both Encumbrance Certificates and Revenue Records within two weeks of receiving a copy of this judgment, thereby ensuring consistency with the relief already granted in Ext.P2 and addressing the practical impediments faced by the petitioners. The decision reflects a coherent approach to align registry actions with encumbrance records in light of mortgage-based priorities.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 26904/2021

Naziya B., Dhanya M.S., and Jincy P. Francis v. State of Kerala and Kerala University of Health Sciences

This writ petition challenges the denial of maternity benefits to three contract-based IT programmers at the Kerala University of Health Sciences (KUHS). The petitioners—Naziya B., Dhanya M.S., and Jincy P. Francis—were engaged on 179-day contracts renewed periodically with two-day artificial breaks between successive postings. Although maternity leave was granted, benefits (full pay) were denied. The first petitioner’s contract ran from 23.6.2021 for 179 days; the second from 24.6.2020 to 18.6.2021; the third from 18.8.2021. The respondents relied on Rule 100 and 101 of Part I KSR to argue that contract employees are eligible for maternity leave only if the tenure is beyond one year and that the 80-day actual service condition applies. After Rakhi P.V. (2018) the Government issued GO (P) No. 2/2021 (Ext.P4) extending maternity leave on full pay up to 180 days or until contract expiry, with a caveat that the employee must have “actually” worked not less than 80 days preceding delivery or miscarriage. The petitioners argued that artificial breaks cannot defeat benefits, citing continuous service and earlier judgments; the respondents contended that each contract is a separate engagement. The Court held in their favor, finding that the Ext.P4 extension applies and that artificial breaks cannot bar maternity benefits. It quashed the denial orders and directed immediate computation and payment of benefits within two months, reinforcing welfare protections under the Maternity Benefit Act and Article 42 of the Constitution.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.34841 of 2022

Ajishbhanu v. Travancore Devaswom Board

Ajishbhanu, a registered B-class contractor, challenged Travancore Devaswom Board’s non-payment of bills for works at Sabarimala and Pamba Devaswoms and sought to adjust amounts due to him against the auction deposit for Hotel No.8 at Pilgrim Centre No.3. He contended that Ext.P2 information dated 06.09.2022 lists payments due to him totaling Rs.1,79,29,148, and that Ext.P4 item No.14 relates to the auctioned Hotel No.8. Ext.P5 seeks adjustment of Rs.1,26,40,572 as the first installment (50% of the bid amount) due by 03.11.2022. The respondents argued that, under tender conditions, the highest bidder must remit 50% immediately after confirmation and the balance within the time limit; a writ to compel adjustment would bypass contractual terms. The court anchors its analysis in Supreme Court jurisprudence: where the contract is non-statutory and purely contractual, a writ under Article 226 cannot compel remedy for a contractual breach; however, where documentary evidence clearly establishes contract terms, writ relief may be possible (as discussed in M.K. Jose, ABL International, Jain Plastics, Ganga Enterprises). Applying these principles to the present case, the court finds no entitlement to the relief sought and dismisses the petition. The petition is accordingly dismissed, with no order as to costs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).Nos 16743 & 25585 of 2021

Moonniyur Higher Secondary School, Parakkadavu, Moonniyur v. State of Kerala & Others (WP(C).Nos 16743/2021 & 25585/2021)

Moonniyur Higher Secondary School, Parakkadavu, Malappuram, sought to quash Ext.P7 government order denying sanction for three additional Plus One batches and to compel the Government to sanction additional higher secondary streams in Commerce, Humanities and Science. The petitions, filed under WP(C) Nos. 16743/2021 (by the Manager) and 25585/2021 (by students represented by guardians), were heard together given common issues. The school is an aided institution under the Kerala Education Act and Rules; it already runs 2 Science, 1 Humanities and 1 Commerce batch with around 200 seats per year. In Malappuram district there is an acute shortage of Plus One seats; the district reported 7,1554 SSLC passers with far fewer Plus One seats (about 34,0 seats in State syllabus). The State Government issued GOs and policy measures (GO(MS) No. 75/2016; GO(RT) No. 3446/2021; and other policy decisions) but Ext.P7 declined additional batches on grounds of financial constraints and lack of a formal policy. The petition relied on St. Sebastian’s High School v. State of Kerala (2015 KHC 725) and related dicta that educational need in backward areas must be determined and acted upon; the State Level Committee’s Ext.P6 report identified Munniyur as an area of acute shortage. The court held there was material to show acute need, quashed Ext.P7 and directed sanction of three additional Higher Secondary batches within two months.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT)335 of 2021

OP(KAT)335 of 2021

Satheesh Kumar R., the petitioner, challenges a Kerala Administrative Tribunal order in OA 75/2018 that affected an exemption under Rule 13A(1)(a) of Part II KS & SSR and the subsequent reassignment of a senior clerk's date of appointment. The tribunal held that, for a Scheduled Caste/Scheduled Tribe employee who had been granted temporary promotion under Rule 13A(1)(a) but who failed the requisite test, the three-year period for promotion eligibility should be reckoned from the date on which the exemption was granted and from the date of appointment; this would normally protect the employee's seniority. Satheesh Kumar, who was not a party to OA 75 of 2018, filed this petition for review claiming the tribunal erred and relied on a dictum from Jayakumar v. State of Kerala (2014) that the three-year period must be reckoned from the date of vacancy. The Kerala High Court observed that Satheesh Kumar had no locus to challenge the order at issue, and after examining facts and finding the vacancy arose on 1.4.2010, concluded that the Tribunal's order was in line with relevant rules. The petition was dismissed as not maintainable, with liberty to challenge any adverse orders in future.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 6646 of 2021

Antony V.F. v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal miscellaneous petition (CRL.M.C. No. 6646 of 2021) filed by Antony V.F. challenging the final report in Crime No.21/2021 of the Excise, Enforcement and Anti-Narcotics Special Squad, Ernakulam, under the NDPS Act, 1985 (sections 20(b)(ii)(C), 25 and 29). The petitioner contends that he was falsely implicated, that he resided in a flat where contraband was recovered, and that he was not involved in NDPS offences. A further challenge is raised to the non-fulfilment of mandatory requirements under Section 42(1) NDPS Act (and related provisions under Sections 41/41(2) and 50). The investigation report and seizure mahazar suggest that information about prohibited substances came from a reliable source, and a raid occurred at Flat No.4B in Petro Palace. The court notes that a search of a building requires prior compliance with Section 41(2) (and warrant authority) and that information leading to a search should be documented in writing under Section 42(1). Despite noting the legal safeguards and the Balbir Singh principle that warrants and documented grounds are critical, the court ultimately finds that the seizure and search were not demonstrated to comply fully with the NDPS provisions at this stage. Consequently, the petition is dismissed. The Court emphasizes the objective of NDPS to curb illicit drug activities while upholding procedural safeguards for the accused.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.23605/16

Anukutttan S. v. Deputy General Manager (Personnel & Human Resources), State Bank of Travancore, Chief Manager, State Bank of Travancore, Ambalapuzha Branch, Alappuzha-688 561, and Union of India

This writ petition (W.P.(C).No.23605/2016) concerns compassionate appointment after the death of the petitioner’s father, who served as an Armed Guard with the State Bank of Travancore and died on 30.10.2014. The petitioner contends that a uniform Government of India scheme for compassionate appointments applicable to all Public Sector Banks should govern his case, and that the bank could not rely on its own earlier scheme that limited eligibility to exceptional circumstances, while providing ex-gratia in other cases. The case traces the evolution of schemes in the banking sector: a 1998 SBT scheme, a 2006 ex-gratia scheme replacing compassionate appointments, later modifications in 2011 (for exceptional cases), and a 2015 circular continuing a set of eligibility conditions. Exhibit P8 represents a purported uniform scheme from the IBA, while Exhibit P11 and other communications allegedly authorize following the earlier scheme. The respondents argue that after SBT’s amalgamation into SBI (relevant from 2017 onward) the SBI policy governs; there is no vested right to compassionate appointment; and it is a concession to deserving cases under the extant scheme. The court ultimately holds that compassionate appointment is not an inherent right and that Ext.P8 was a model scheme; the bank’s current policy prevails. The petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.28054/2021

Canara Bank Mullakkal, Alappuzha Branch v. Sachin Shyam Proprieter, M/S. Skilderz Developers, Arjunam; Shyam Raju; Sajikumar T.M.; Rajeev R.

The Canara Bank Mullakkal, Alappuzha Branch filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging an order of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Alappuzha, which refused its application under Section 14 of the SARFAESI Act for possession of the secured asset. The secured asset is mortgaged in relation to a loan extended to the first respondent; the third respondent claimed tenancy rights in the asset. The fourth respondent purchased the asset. The Magistrate held that the tenancy rights predated the mortgage and could not be displaced by SARFAESI proceedings, thereby concluding that the 3rd respondent’s tenancy could not be evicted under Section 14. The petitioner argued that Section 14 powers are ministerial and do not adjudicate disputes between the borrower, third party and the secured creditor; it asserted that there were no documents establishing a bonafide tenancy and that there was collusion between the borrower and tenant obstructing possession. It relied on several Supreme Court judgments (Harshad Govardhan Sondagar; Bajarang Shyamsundar Agarwal; Hemraj Salian) and Kerala decisions (Kottakkal Co-Operative Urban Bank) as to tenancy rights and registration. The High Court held Balkrishna Rama Tarle’s framework (SC) to be controlling, quashed the Ext.P7 order, and remanded for fresh proceedings consistent with the ministerial nature of Section 14 and ITC Limited v. Blue Coast Hotels. Extending two months for fresh orders, the court restored MC proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.22501/2012

K. Kunhiraman v. Government of Kerala & Others

This writ petition by an ex-serviceman (K. Kunhiraman) seeks assignment of 50 cents of river-bank land in Meenathukara village and patta to him, originally leased in 1967. He contends that Ext. P2 shows a Panchayat resolution in 1990 to assign river puramboke and related lands to ex-servicemen, and Ext. P1 confirms the lease; thus there is no legal bar to grant assignment. The respondents counter that concurrence under the Panchayat Raj Act is required and rely on a prior W.P.(C).No. 30774 of 2012 and related rules. The court reviews the relevant statutory framework: Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994; the 1996 Panchayat Raj Rules prohibiting unauthorised occupation and enabling eviction; the 2005 Rules on Acquisition and Disposal of Property; and provisions including Section 254, sections related to lease and disposal, and water-body protections under Section 218 and the Kerala Land Conservancy Act, 1957. It cites M.A. Johny to emphasize that properties vested in local bodies cannot be assigned or alienated except as permitted by law, and Sarvepalli Ramaiah to underline that water bodies are inalienable. The court ultimately rejects the petition, holding that the 50 cents of river puramboke land cannot be assigned, following the earlier W.P.(C).No.30774 of 2012, and dismisses the petition with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 34961 OF 2022

Lakshmy C. Senan v Central Board of Secondary Education and Others

Lakshmy C. Senan, a candidate who completed the All India Secondary Examination in 2004, seeks correction of the date of birth recorded in her CBSE certificate. Ext.P1 shows the DOB as 19.05.1989, while Ext.P2 (birth certificate), Ext.P3 (Aadhaar), Ext.P3(a) Election Card, Ext.P3(b) Driving Licence, Ext.P3(c) Passport and Ext.P3(d) PAN Card reflect a DOB of 14.01.1988. The petitioner had submitted Ext.P5 seeking correction, which the respondents did not process. The counsel for the petitioner submits that the Supreme Court in Jigya Yadav v. CBSE (2021 (3) KLT 711(SC)) has settled the controversy regarding correction of CBSE birth certificates, though it left the question of limitation open and advised amendments to the Byelaws. The respondents rely on Regulation 69.3 of the CBSE Byelaws, prescribing a five-year limitation for entertaining such applications, and point out that the Byelaws have not yet been amended, though several orders have followed Jigya Yadav’s directions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 28354 of 2021

Hussain Bava and Parayangadan Haseena v The District Collector, Malappuram; The Sub Collector, Perinthalmanna; The Tahsildar (Land Records), Perinthalmanna; The Village Officer, Perinthalmanna

Petitioners Hussain Bava and Parayangadan Haseena claim absolute ownership of 26.92 acres of land in Sy. No. 114/1A of Perinthalmanna village, Malappuram, supported by Exts P1–P2 sale deeds. They assert the land was converted for non-agricultural use as early as 1981 by their predecessors under the Kerala Land Utilisation Order, 1967 (KLU Order), and that a cinema theatre has been constructed thereon over decades. They sought reassessment of the land based on Ext P3, an order dated 16.12.1981 passed by the 2nd respondent under the KLU order. On 25.11.2021 they filed Ext P8 before the 3rd respondent Tahsildar (Land Records) seeking reassessment of the land based on Ext P3, but the Tahsildar refused to act on Ext P8, insisting that the petitioners first obtain an order under Section 27A of the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. The petitioners challenge this insistence as illegal and contrary to this Court’s declarations in Tahsildar, Todupuzha and Another v Renjith George (2020 (1) KHC 865) and in Renjith George (Supra). The learned counsel for petitioners argued that Ext P8 has not been decided and should be considered without undue delay; the respondents contended Ext P8 is speculative. The Court observed Ext P8 remains unaddressed and directed the Tahsildar to take up Ext P8, hear the petitioners, and decide after considering Ext P3 and the law declared in Renjith George (Supra), expeditiously and no later than one month from the date of judgment.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No. 7498 of 2022

Muhammed Ajmal G.K. v. State of Kerala

Muhammed Ajmal G.K., aged 24, accused in Crime No.19/2021, was detained in connection with transporting 114 kilograms of ganja in a Maruti Swift car at Kunjathur, Manjeshwar Taluk on 25-11-2021. The Special Judge under the NDPS Act Kasaragod extended the detention period beyond 180 days by passing Annexure A2 on Crl.M.P. No. 1859/2022, and dismissed the applicant’s default bail application by Annexure A3. The petitioner approached the High Court under Section 482 CrPC, challenging these orders, contending that Section 36-A(4) of the NDPS Act requires the Public Prosecutor’s report to indicate both progress of the investigation and the specific reasons for continued detention beyond 180 days; Annexure A1 allegedly failed to disclose such progress. He further argued that the Public Prosecutor is an independent statutory authority and not a mere conduit; thus, failure to show progress would invalidate the extension, and that the accused must be provided notice when extensions are considered. The State contended Annexure A1 complied with the proviso, showing progress, and that the orders were lawful. The High Court examined the statutory language and precedents, including Hitendra Vishnu Thakur, Sanjay Kumar Kedia, Appukuttan, Nayantara Gupta, and others, and held that the proviso requires clear demonstration of progress and justification. It also held that notice to the accused is mandatory. Accordingly, Annexure A2 was set aside, Annexure A3 allowed, and the petitioner was ordered released on statutory bail with conditions.

High Court of Kerala
TR.P(C) NO. 676 OF 2022

TR.P(C) No. 676 of 2022 (Juliet v. Joseph Varghese)

This is a transfer petition under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure filed in the Kerala High Court by Juliet, the wife of respondent Joseph Varghese, seeking to transfer O.P.(R.M.) No.548/2019 from the Family Court at Kattappana to the Family Court at Thrissur. The matrimonial dispute arose from a 2008 marriage after the respondent’s first wife had died in 2007; the petitioner claims cruelty and financial disputes, including coercion to borrow 20 lakh from her brother, for the respondent's business. The respondent had already filed O.P. Nos. 44/2018 and 56/2018 for custody and divorce, and the petitioner has a separate M.C. No.41/2017 under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act in Gram Nyayalaya Peerumade. The petitioner now alleges health issues that make travel to Kattappana difficult and asserts residence in Thrissur. The respondent counters that the marriage deteriorated due to the petitioner’s alleged extramarital relationship, misappropriation of funds, and involvement in other proceedings; he contends travel by him from Idukki to Thrissur would be inconvenient for trial of Annexure 1. The Court cites Vidya Mundekkat to caution against automatic transfers under Section 24 and finds the petitioner’s health claim unsupported by the medical certificate, noting the respondent’s children are in his custody. Ultimately, the Court dismisses the transfer petition, holding no compelling reason to transfer.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C). No.22883 of 2012

Edamana Kesavan Vadyan Namboodiri and O.K. Parameswaran Namboodiri, hereditary trustees of Arathil Sree Bhadrapuram Temple v State of Kerala and others

The petitioners, Edamana Kesavan Vadyan Namboodiri and O.K. Parameswaran Namboodiri, are hereditary trustees of Arathil Sree Bhadrapuram Temple, Kannur district. They filed a writ petition under Article 226 challenging interference by the State and the Malabar Devaswom Board in the temple’s administration and seeking a declaration that the petitioners and respondents 6–19 (hereditary trustees) or their nominees alone should administer the temple. The temple is governed by the Hindu-Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951, and is listed under Section 38 notifications by the Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board. The petition recounts issues surrounding the temple’s management, including the appointment of a Manager (Sankaran Namboodiri) who was removed for grave misconduct, the 3rd respondent’s Ext.P3 order appointing the 5th respondent as Executive Officer (EO) under Section 66, and Exts.P5 and P6 directing trustees to hand over Thiruvabharanam to the EO. Interim orders and prior court actions are noted. The petition argues that the temple is privately administered by hereditary trustees and that the 2–5 respondents have no right to interfere. The respondents contend the temple is under HRCE Act, and the EO exercises statutory powers. The court held that writs cannot compel compliance against statutory provisions and cannot resolve the private-vs-public worship status in a writ proceeding, ultimately dismissing the petition as lacking merit and declining to grant the declaratory relief sought. The decision emphasizes deference to statutory regimes governing temple administration.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.393 of 2019

R.C.Rev.No.393 of 2019 (P.M. Muhammed Shameem & A.H. Abdul Jamal vs. M.Y. Ameera Ali & Smt. Shaheera)

R.C.Rev.No.393 of 2019 is a Division Bench challenge to eviction orders under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The revision petitioners, P.M. Muhammed Shameem and A.H. Abdul Jamal, contend that the Rent Control Court’s order of eviction under Sections 11(2)(b) and 11(4)(v) of the Act rests on disputed rent figures and a mischaracterization of cessation of occupation. They allege that rent was either paid or informally adjusted from an advance deposit of Rs. 8,00,000, and that the petition schedule shop was managed by their power-of-attorney holder (their father) who fell ill, causing temporary cessation of operation. The respondents-landlords claim default in rent from May 2014 and cessation of occupation since April 2014, with the shop being kept closed for over two years prior to the petition. The Rent Control Court found default and cessation, evicting the tenant, and the Appellate Authority affirmed. The High Court scrutinized the evidence, including testimony of PWs and CW1 and the Commissioner’s report, and concluded that eviction cannot be avoided by invoking RW1’s health-related non-occupation. It invoked established precedents on tenant possession and reasonable cause, ultimately dismissing the revision, but granting six months for surrender with conditions, including affidavit, arrears deposit, and non-induction of third parties. The order reflects a strict view that cessation must be by the tenant himself and not by a party acting under a power of attorney.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.No.1639/2021 & W.A.No.1640/2021

Mathew Z Pulikunnel v. Chief Justice of India, Union of India, and others (W.A. Nos. 1639 & 1640 of 2021)

These writ appeals challenge a common judgment dated 01.11.2021 by a learned Single Judge that disposed two writ petitions (WP(C).Nos.17654 & 17657 of 2021) concerning the maintainability of petitions seeking initiation of the Supreme Court Full Court’s in-house procedure against judges of the Kerala High Court. The petitioner contends that a disgruntled party who believes a judgment was influenced by judicial misconduct can invoke Article 226 to compel initiation of the in-house inquiry and enforcement of the procedure, arguing that the in-house mechanism is not merely moral exhortation but a legal process. The respondents contend that the in-house procedure is a confidential peer inquiry and not a law or statutory remedy; it rests in the discretion of the Chief Justice and cannot be reviewed by a writ court. The bench notes that removal of judges occurs only under Articles 124 or 217 and via the Judges (Inquiry) Act, 1968, and that no statutory provision creates a writ remedy to compel the in-house process. Relying on Indira Jaising and related independence-of-judiciary principles (as well as SP Gupta and Mohd Aslam), the court holds that the in-house inquiry does not have the force of public-law ‘law’ and cannot be enforced by writ. Consequently, the appeals are dismissed with no costs to either side, preserving institutional integrity and confidentiality.