OP (RC) No. 217 of 2022; EP 145/2021 in RCP 1/2018 This High Court of Kerala judgment concerns OP (RC) No. 217 of 2022, an original petition under Article 227 challenging Ext. P3, a mediation-based compromise order in an eviction petition filed under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease & Rent Control) Act, 1965. The petitioner-tenant (Jisha C.K.) approached the court after the Rent Control Court, North Paravur, passed Ext. P3 (29-01-2021) on the basis of a mediated settlement in EP 145/2021 in RCP 1/2018, which had directed the tenant to surrender possession after 11 months from 07-01-2020, with the landlord paying Rs. 15,000 as an advance. The tenant contends that the compromise was recorded without reference to the statutory grounds for eviction, and that the landlord’s later steps—to rent the premises to a travel agency at a higher rent—reveal bad faith and non-bona fide need. The court appointed Amicus Curiae to examine the legality of settling eviction on a basis other than the grounds in the Act and cited a cadre of decisions including Star Fish Exports v. Mahamood, Thomas v. Easo, Balakrishna Reddiar v. Madhavan Pillai, and Central Bank of India v. Beena Thiruvenkitam, among others. The bench concluded that Ext. P3 was not in accordance with the Act as it failed to record satisfaction of a statutory ground, and therefore allowed the petition, setting Ext. P3 aside and remanding RCP 1/2018 for merits in accordance with law. The Rent Control Court is to proceed accordingly with a date fixed for appearance.
W.P.(C) No. 30336 of 2019 Petitioner M/s Top Hill Furniture Palace, a private limited company engaged in the manufacture and sale of furniture, challenged Ext.P5, an assessment order under the KVAT Act for the year 2014-15, on the ground that it had already compounded the offence after an Intelligence Wing inspection on 24 February 2015 and paid the prescribed compounding fee. The petitioner had also sought revision of the self-assessment return under Section 22(10), arguing that once the offence is admitted and compounding is effected, the statutory scheme permits a revision that would be deemed accepted on completion of proceedings, subject to Sections 24 and 25. The respondents, however, relied on a consistent pattern of suppression (parallel billing, stock variation, unaccounted purchases and sales) detected across a single shop, and contended that best judgment assessment under Section 25 was warranted rather than allowing revision. The court examines Sections 22(9) and (10), the proviso to 22(10), and the interplay with Sections 24, 25 and 74; it cites James Thomas v State of Kerala, Moosa v State of Kerala, and State of Kerala v M/s Shalimar Jewellary to hold that, when a pattern of suppression is detected, best judgment assessment is legally permissible despite a revision request. The court ultimately directs the petitioner to file an appeal with stay within a month, and keeps recovery in abeyance pending appellate consideration, while signaling a lenient approach to delay.
This writ petition (WP(C) No. 21060/2017) in the Kerala High Court challenges the Kerala Lok Ayukta’s order dated 17 February 2017, which dismissed a complaint filed by the petitioner and rejected his claim that the period of training attached to a prospective appointment should be reckoned as qualifying service for pensionary benefits. The petitioner, a retired Chief Engineer in the Public Works Department, was part of a special drive recruitment in 1980 under Rule 9(a)(1) KS & SSR to the post of Assistant Executive Engineer (Training). Exhibit P1 shows a one-year training with stipend, followed by probation for two years, with the training not counted for increments and qualifying service to commence from probation. Government orders (Exhibits P3 and P5) confirmed that the training period could not be counted for pension calculation. Lok Ayukta’s order upheld this view. The petitioner relied on Lakshmanan v. State of Kerala (1995 KHC 24) to urge reckoning of training as qualifying service, but the court distinguished that case as applicable to police department appointments and not to special drive appointments under Rule 9(a)(1). The court held no arbitrariness in Lok Ayukta’s order, and dismissed the writ petition, noting that the petitioner was aware of Exhibit P1 terms and that the one-year training period could not be counted for pension.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 785 OF 2022 This is a criminal revision petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. by Sankaranarayanan, the second accused in ST No.164/2017, challenging two concurrent convictions: the judgment of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-VII, Thrissur dated 04.10.2021 in ST No.164/2017, and the subsequent Cr.App.No.168/2021 of the I Additional Sessions Court, Thrissur dated 08.07.2022, which partially modified the sentence. The core charge concerns a cheque for Rs.5,00,000/- issued by the second and third accused on behalf of the first accused company (Winplast Polymer Products (P) Ltd.) in discharge of a debt allegedly owed to the complainant, with the cheque bouncing for lack of funds. The trial court accepted PW1’s evidence and Exts.P1–P7, and invoked the presumptions under Sections 118 and 139 NI Act in favor of the complainant. The defence argued, among other matters, that the complaint did not plead that accused No.2 was the Managing Director, and that liability under Section 141(2) NI Act should not automatically attach; it relied on decisions concerning the scope of presumption and the company’s management responsibility. The appellate court concurred, while reducing the substantive sentence. The High Court, citing Rangappa, Bir Singh, Kalamani Tex., and other precedents, reaffirmed the primacy of the statutory presumptions, the non-obliteration of those presumptions absent cogent evidence, and the improper re-appreciation of evidence in revisional jurisdiction. The revision petition is dismissed, with two months’ time to pay the compensation and to undergo sentence; execution deferred till 13.02.2023.
This is a Criminal Revision Petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. by the accused in CC 1922/2017, challenging the judgments of conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, as well as the concurrent appellate order. The complainant, M/S Manayathumariyil Hardwares, Paingottoor Kara, alleged that a cheque for Rs. 5,34,650 issued by the accused on behalf of M/S Sreelakshmi Traders was dishonoured for want of funds, following non-payment after demand notice. The trial court convicted the accused for an offence punishable under Section 138 NI Act and sentenced him; the Additional District and Sessions Judge, Muvattupuzha, dismissed the appeal. The revision contends that the prosecution was defective since only M/s Sreelakshmi Traders was arrayed and the proprietor was not named as an accused, although the cause-title description later shows the proprietor Lakshmi M. as representing the firm. The High Court, while declining to substitute its own view under revisional power, emphasizes the established presumptions under the NI Act (S.139) in favor of the complainant, subject to rebuttal. Relying on Rangappa v. Mohan and Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar, it clarifies the evidentiary burden and the limited scope of revision (not a second appeal). The revisional petition is dismissed, but two months’ time is granted to pay the fine, with surrender to occur on 20.01.2023 and sentence execution deferred to 19.01.2023.
This writ appeal arises from interim orders in WP(C) No. 22864 of 2016 concerning a visually challenged candidate, Anjitha C.P., and the role of the Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC) in arranging a scribe for a 2016 written examination for Assistant posts in Kerala universities. The petitioner contended that the scribe provided by the PSC was incompetent, and she sought inclusion in the shortlist for interview. The Single Judge issued a series of interim directions from July to November 2022, including production of the scribe’s details and invigilator reports, and directions to assess the scribe’s English competence. The PSC complied by filing counter-affidavits and sealed materials; later, the court directed the PSC to arrange for an invigilator's response and for an independent assessment of the scribe’s competence. Questions arose about bias in the PSC’s internal assessment, since an Under Secretary of the PSC prepared a report. Ultimately, the court directed that the scribe be assessed by an independent authority outside the PSC. The PSC argued that its functions related to examinations cannot be outsourced, relying on decisions including Buddhi Nath Chaudhary v. Abahi Kumar and Kerala Public Service Commission v. Ashokan. The Larger Bench rulings in KS Das v. State of Kerala were invoked to determine the maintainability of an appeal under Section 5. The High Court dismissed the writ appeal as not maintainable, holding the interim orders were procedural and complied with.
The petitioner, Mohammed M.A., then Station House Officer (SHO) of Puthercruz Police Station, challenged Exts.P4 (order under Section 18 of the RTI Act) and P7 (penalty order under RTI) issued by the State Information Commission, Kerala. The RTI application was dated 18.09.2014 seeking information about crime registration and hospital information, with a draft reply prepared on 29.09.2014 (Ext.P2) and an initial communication about an appeal (Ext.P1). The petitioner contends Ext.P4 was issued without prior notice, and that he was not served copies of the complaint that spawned the Section 18 inquiry; Ext.P7 was passed despite his reply (Ext.P6). He argues that the proceedings under Section 18 require an enquiry and hearing, and that the notice and opportunity of hearing are essential, particularly where civil consequences follow. The respondents defend that Ext.P4 can be issued without notice, that a prima facie case justifies action under Section 18 and 20, and that information relates to human rights concerns with a shortened timeline. The High Court ultimately sets aside Exts.P4 and P7, treats Ext.P4 as due notice, and directs a fresh hearing with copies of the complaint, within four months, without expressing on merits.
This criminal miscellaneous case challenges the Gram Nyayalaya's proceedings in S.T. No. 435/2019 arising from Crime No. 21/2018 at Sannidhanam Police Station, Pathanamthitta. Petitioners Suresh Kumar T.M. and Rajesh R. are accused in offences under Sections 143, 144, 147, 353 and 188 read with Section 149 IPC, for participating in an unlawful assembly and for alleged disobedience of prohibitory orders during a protest near Sabarimala Sannidhanam on 18 November 2018, in response to the Supreme Court’s judgment permitting entry of women to the temple. Annexure-A FIR and Annexure-B final report were filed by the police, and the Crl.M.C. seeks to quash all further proceedings pursuant to the final report. The petitioners contend that cognizance under Section 188 IPC cannot be taken on a police report under 173(2) Cr.P.C., and that cognizance under 188 IPC requires a complaint by a public servant or subordinate the orders of whom were allegedly violated. They further argue that peaceful protest, protected by Article 19(1)(a) (freedom of speech) and Article 19(1)(b) (right to assemble peaceably), cannot amount to an offence. The State responds that the protest violated prohibitory orders and formed an unlawful assembly, disclosing offences including 143/144/147/149 and 188/353. On close scrutiny, the High Court finds no material showing ‘criminal force’ or assault under 350/351 IPC, and notes that peaceful protest is protected by constitutional rights. Citing Narayanan and Hariprasad and Prakash karat, the court applies the de minimis principle under Section 95 IPC, and concludes that the proceedings are an abuse of process. The Crl.M.C is allowed, and all further proceedings including S.T.435/2019 are quashed.
This is a Kerala High Court review petition (R.P. No. 271 of 2022) arising from W.P.(Crl.) 502/2021. The petitioner, Krishnakumar M.S., contends that he had pledged his Innova car KL-29-N-4554 to respondents 3 and 4 for his daughter's education. He asserts that when he sought redemption, the vehicle was not returned and alleges misappropriation or sale by the respondents. He approached the police for action, but no cognizable offense was registered; consequently he sought relief in this Court through writs directing the police to trace the vehicle and recover documents. The High Court, after hearing counsel for both sides, dismissed the writ petition in limine, noting disputed questions of fact and pointing out that alternate efficacious remedies under the Cr.P.C. were available. The petitioner challenges this order via review, arguing that Annexure-4 statements, obtained under the RTI Act, were not properly considered and that there was misrepresentation by the second respondent before the Court. The Court, however, reiterates that review is unfounded where facts are in dispute and where no error on the face of the records is shown; it emphasizes that police inaction in registering a crime is to be addressed under Cr.P.C. (Sections 190, 200, 202 and 156(3)) rather than by writ. Citing Aleque Padamsee, the Court holds there is no basis to review the order, and the petition is dismissed with no costs.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case under Section 482 Cr.P.C. filed by SIMI.C.N., the accused and Village Officer of Puthur Village, challenging the proceedings arising from Crime No. 1539/2020 registered at Ollur Police Station and the related final report in C.C. No. 1783/2020 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate’s Court-III, Thrissur. The incident occurred on 10.08.2020 when defacto complainant Mini Unnikrishnan (panchayat president) and associates demanded issue of Life Mission income certificates in manual mode despite a server defect and online filing, prompting a tense confrontation in the village office. The accused allegedly faced harassment, intimidation and public ridicule, and, under severe mental strain, cut her left arm, leading to a charge under IPC Section 309 and related sections. The petitioner contends that Section 115 of the Mental Health Care Act, 2017 creates a presumption of severe stress and exempts punishment, arguing that her act was not intentional and should be quashed as an abuse of process. The High Court examines historical debates on decriminalization of suicide, cites related decisions, and ultimately holds that Section 115 saves the act from penal consequences, quashes the proceedings, and exonerates the petitioner as an abuse of process.
The petitioner, Fathima C. @ Pathummu, challenges the acquisition of land on which a building stands, taken for the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI), and asserts that she has not received eligible compensation. She contends that Section 94 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 prohibits acquisition in cases where part of a building is taken, and seeks relief under that statutory framework. The counsel for the petitioner concedes that a Final Award under Section 3G(1) of the National Highways Act (NH Act) has already been issued by the Competent Authority for Land Acquisition (CALA) and that Ext.P7 has been filed under Section 3G(5) of the NH Act against the same. The petitioner asks the Court to direct the competent Arbitrator to consider Ext.P7 under Section 3G(5). The respondents counter that Ext.P7 is not a valid 3G(5) application and that the petitioner must file a proper one in the statutory format for consideration by the Arbitrator. The judge notes that CALA, once issuing a 3G(1) award, is functus officio, and that the remedy lies before the District Collector/Arbitrator. The Court grants limited relief, directing the petitioner to file a proper 3G(5) application before the District Collector within two weeks; the District Collector shall hear both sides and pass an appropriate order expeditiously, ideally within eight months. The merits of Section 94 RFCTLARR Act are left for the proper proceedings, with an option to approach the Court if the eight-month period is not met. The judgment also states the District Collector should consider Ext.P6 (Central Government directives) and binding precedents in the process.
This is a petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C. filed by the State of Kerala, represented by the Addl. Director General of Prosecution and senior prosecutors, challenging earlier orders that denied voice-sample collection in Crime 1229/2017 (Chalakudy). The investigation, arising from the murder of Rajeev and alleged monetary conspiracy involving five to seven accused, relied heavily on call-detail records and the need to match voices with recorded communications. The State sought a direction under Article 142 of the Constitution to allow voice-sample collection from accused persons for comparison with disputed voices, arguing a lacuna in the Cr.P.C. and identification acts, and relying on evolving jurisprudence culminating in the Supreme Court’s Ritesh Sinha decision (2019) and earlier Pratap A.K. v. CBI. The respondents opposed, contending Annexure-C order is final, that Article 142 cannot override normal procedure, and that res judicata applies to preclude review, among other objections. The court surveys a string of authorities, including Roopesh @ Praveen, Daisy M.P., and Raman Gopi, and ultimately holds that, given the changing legal landscape and the Supreme Court’s guidance, the petitioner is entitled to collect voice samples. The order directs the JFCM Chalakudy to obtain samples and have them tested by an appropriate examiner, with proper safeguards for privacy and statutory compliance. The Criminal M.C. is allowed accordingly.
This is a bail petition (BA No.4409 of 2024) before the Kerala High Court arising from Crime No.196/2024 of Mananthavady Police Station, Wayanad, for alleged dacoity under Section 395 IPC. The petitioners, Praveesh C., Vipinlal C., and Vineesh M., were arrested on 13.3.2024 in connection with an incident on 27.2.2024 when they are said to have intercepted a car carrying a de facto complainant and his friend, looting a mobile phone, Rs.23,00,000 and the car key. The prosecution asserts the petitioners are history-sheeters with multiple prior offences and that the investigation is ongoing, with the third petitioner having eight crimes including a 2024 Sec.302 IPC case. The petitioners contend innocence, asserting false implication, lack of incriminating material linking them to the alleged offence, and noting the complainant did not identify them at the time of the incident; they have been in judicial custody for about 83 days, and investigation is largely complete with recoveries made. The Public Prosecutor counters with the petitioners’ criminal history and the risk of tampering with evidence or intimidating witnesses if released. The Court emphasizes the presumption of innocence and the principle that bail is the rule, not jail, under Article 21, citing Sanjay Chandra v. CBI. After detailed consideration, the court partly allows the bail: petitioners 1 and 2 are granted bail on a Rs.50,000 bond with two solvent sureties, subject to conditions including periodic appearance, non-tampering, surrender of passports if any, and a provision for cancellation of bail for violations; the application for the third petitioner is dismissed. The order also acknowledges the ongoing investigations and permits recoveries to be effected, in line with Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and another, as cited. The decision reflects a balanced approach: bail for two petitioners with safeguards, while keeping the third petitioner’s bail application dismissed.
This is a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution challenging Ext.P1 detention order dated 03-03-2024 issued by the District Magistrate (2nd respondent) under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAAPA) and the subsequent government order confirming the detention on 30-04-2024, after the Advisory Board’s recommendation on 22-04-2024. The petitioner, previously declared a “known goonda,” had a six-month preventive detention that expired on 15-09-2023. Within a month, he was allegedly involved in an NDPS case (MDMA, 5.20 g) and released on 11-01-2024. On 12-02-2024, a report recommended KAAPA proceedings, leading to the Detention Order (Ext.P1) on 03-03-2024, executed on 07-03-2024 with government confirmation on 21-03-2024 and advisory-board recommendation on 22-04-2024; government confirmed on 30-04-2024. The respondent list includes the State of Kerala, the District Magistrate Malappuram, the District Police Chief Malappuram, and the Perinthalmanna SHO. The petitioner argues non-application of mind by the detaining authority, citing Rema Vijayalal v. State of Kerala to press for consideration of the maximum detention period. The State relies on a prior decision (WP(Crl) No. 711 of 2024) and cites SC/Constitutional precedents (Pangarkar; A.K. Roy) that the maximum detention period is decided by the government, not the Advisory Board. The High Court ultimately dismisses the petition, holding that the detenu’s challenge to the government’s mind-set fails, upholding the detention order and its maximum-period framing in light of the cited authorities.
This is a batch Review Petition filed by 100 petitioners challenging a government-imposed qualification for a particular post, arising from a Writ Petition WP(C) 11196/2024 that culminated in a judgment dated 19 March 2024. The Petitioners contend that their challenge is restricted to the prescribed qualification and does not attack the entire recruitment process, and they rely on the decision in Fayaskhan H.K. v. Director of Medical and Health Services, Kavarathy (2024 (2) KHC 230) to justify maintainability before this Court. The respondents—State of Kerala and related government bodies—submit that the interim prayer seeking deferral of Ext.P5 proceedings could not be pressed before this Court and that any relief of deferment would lie before the Administrative Tribunal; however, they also concede that if the Court proceeds with the main prayer concerning Ext.P3 representation, they would not oppose such disposal. The learned Judge recognizes that the central issue is the qualification prescribed, yet notes, based on submissions, that the petition is tenable to the extent of directing disposal of Ext.P3 representation by the Government. Consequently, the Court allows the Review Petition and recalls the judgment of 19 March 2024 with the consent of both sides, clarifying that the main prayer remains subject to government action on Ext.P3.
The petitioner Sahalap.P, wife of Sri Firdose, challenges Ext.P1 detention order issued under Section 3(1) KAAPA (Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007) against her husband. The detention proposal, dated 15.4.2024, rests on his alleged involvement in six cases over four years, classifying him as a 'Known Rowdy' under Section 2(p)(iii) KAAPA. An externment order under Section 15(1) KAAPA had already been passed on 9.10.2023. The detaining authority proceeded on the assertion that, despite externment, the detenu engaged in new acts, including Crime No. 456/2024 on 10.4.2024, and that there was a likelihood of recurrence if released on bail. The petition contends fault lines: crucial records for Crime No. 456/2024 were not placed before the detaining authority; the wound certificate is not produced; the date of crime is incorrectly mentioned; several offences are minor and lack the requisite gravity to justify detention; there was a delay of about one month in passing Ext.P1; and the detenu submitted a representation on 18.6.2024 which was not considered. The respondents submit that the detaining authority had substantial material–six cases, final reports in five, and grave nature of acts; awareness of custodian status and bail risk supports the order. The High Court, applying the proximity/live-link doctrine and relying on Stenny Aleyamma Saju and Senthamilselvi, upholds the detention, finds no grounds to intervene, and dismisses the petition.
The Kerala High Court hears an Original Petition filed by Defendants 2, 10 and 12 in O.S. No.368/2014 (Chittur Munsiff’s Court), challenging an order and seeking guidance on court fees and valuation for two prayers added to the partition suit, namely AA and AB. The suit originally sought partition by metes and bounds; upon amendments, AA and AB were introduced, each valued at Rs. 1,000 with court fees of Rs. 40 each under Section 25(d) of the Kerala Court Fees and Suits Valuation Act. The Munsiff concluded that the valuation and court fee were correct. The petitioners argued that since the subject matter is valuationally capable and the plaint valued the property at Rs. 5,40,000 based on annual income, court fees should be assessed on that market value rather than the fixed Rs. 40. They relied on Satheedevi v. Prasanna and Suhrid Singh to differentiate cancellation/declaration and the corresponding court-fee framework. The petition also analyzed Section 25(d)(ii), Section 7 market-value determinations, and Usman Kurikkal on non-executants’ fee. Respondents contended the current valuation and fee were proper. The High Court distinguished between cancellation/declaration and declarations with consequential relief, applying Sankaran Velukkutty for AB relief and holding AA relief payable under Section 25(d)(i). The petition was allowed; the impugned order was set aside, with directions to the Munsiff to pass a fresh order consistent with the discussed law.
Aggrieved by Ext.P6 order passed in I.A.2/2022 in O.S. 424/2019 of the Munsiff Court, Kodungallur, the petitioner NANDHINI has challenged the order directing police assistance to enforce an injunction restraining trespass. The background traces to a long sequence of family litigation: a divorce decree between the respondents in 2011, followed by execution proceedings under which the first respondent purchased the petitioner’s property and possession was handed over after protracted litigation. The suit originally yielded Ext.P2, an order of temporary injunction restraining the petitioner and her husband from trespass. During the pendency of the suit, Exts.P3 and P4 under Order 39 Rule 2A were moved to initiate action for disobedience or breach of the injunction and to attach the property or detain violators. The petitioner opposed Ext.P3, asserting that the court below ought to have held a proper enquiry before taking punitive action under the Rule. The first respondent contends there is a long history justifying enforcement and that occupancy by the petitioner is admitted, negating the need for an enquiry. The learned judge, C.S. Dias, J., holds Ext.P6 premature and unsustainable for bypassing due process. The court directs the trial court to decide Ext.P3 in accordance with Order 39 Rule 2A after hearing both sides, and to complete the proceedings by 23.12.2022, while preserving rights and cautioning against unilateral coercive measures.
This writ petition challenges a Kerala Lok Ayukta inquiry’s findings regarding recovery of a retirement-related amount from a retired headmaster. The respondent retired on 30.06.2001. After Pay Revision Orders, his pay was refixed at Rs. 8,475, and Rs. 78,957 was recovered from his Death-Cum-Retirement Gratuity on 25.09.2004. Complaint No.1042 of 2017 before the Kerala Lok Ayukta led to an order noting that Ext. P5 (dated 16.07.2014) could not retroactively revoke rights vested by Ext. P1 and that Ext. P9 pay fixation had already accorded benefits; the Lok Ayukta directed the authorities to remedy the injustice by releasing Rs.78,957 with 7% simple interest from 25.09.2004 and to file an action report within three months. The petitioners contended that recovery after retirement, and without giving the employee an opportunity to explain pay fixation, violated Rule 3 of Part III of the Kerala Service Rules and the principle of natural justice; they also invoked State of Punjab & Others v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) to urge that recoveries should not occur after a long delay. The High Court, while not disturbing the Lok Ayukta’s findings on merits, held that recovery was illegal due to lack of opportunity and the long lapse, but dismissed the writ petition and directed that the Lok Ayukta relief be implemented where appropriate. The court thus upheld the illegality of the recovery, dismissed the petition, and left the Lok Ayukta’s remedy in place.
TR.P(C) Nos. 728/2021 & 730/2021 This is a common order by the Kerala High Court in twoTransfer Petitions (Civil) filed under S.24 CPC by Reshma R (wife) and her parents Rajan S. and Ushakumari seeking transfer of matrimonial proceedings from the Family Court, Chavara, to the Family Court, Kottarakara. The respondent is Sanal P S. The petitions arise out of a strained marriage; the wife has already filed OP 417/2020 for divorce in Kottarakara, while the husband has pending OPs 740/2020 (restitution of conjugal rights) and 741/2020 (money/ancillary relief) in Chavara. The petitions were heard with no appearance by the respondent. The court invoked established Supreme Court jurisprudence on transfer in matrimonial disputes, citing Sumitha Singh v. Kumar Sanjay; Mona Aresh Goel v. Aresh Satya Goel; Vaishali Shridhar Jagtap v. Shridhar Vishwanath Jagtap; Santhini V. Vijaya Venkatesh; and N.C.V. Aishwarya v. A.S. Saravana Karthik Sha, which emphasize the convenience of the wife and children and the avoidance of conflicting judgments. Observing that the wife already has proceedings in Kottarakara, the court exercised its discretion under Sec. 24 CPC to transfer OPs 740/2020 and 741/2020 from Chavara to Kottarakara for consolidation and efficient adjudication. The registry is to transmit records to Kottarakara, which should hear all related matters together, including OP 417/2020.