Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 593 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 26363 of 2021

Jiya George v. Central Board of Secondary Education

The petitioner, a student of Mahakavi Kumaranasan Central School, Kayamkulam, seeks to quash Ext.P12 (2nd respondent) rejection and to direct the 2nd respondent to consider her representation to correct her Class X Certificate from Giya George to Jiya George. Her actual name is Jiya, as recorded in birth, passport, Aadhaar and other public documents; however, the Class X Certificate bears the misspelled name Giya George, creating a discrepancy that has caused the University of Kerala to withhold her Degree Certificate. She submitted a representation on 04.10.2019 seeking to correct/change the name, accompanied by documents demanded in Ext.P10; she complied with the requirements. The 2nd respondent issued Ext.P12 rejecting the request, stating that the correction did not qualify under Rule 69 of the Examination Bye-Laws. The respondents contend that the request was processed but ultimately rejected for non-fulfilment of Rule 69 criteria. The court notes that corrections of date of birth and name are now governed by the Apex Court’s Jigya Yadav v. Central Board of Secondary Education decision until amended bye-laws are notified, and that the petitioner’s application must be considered in light of that judgment. The writ petition is disposed of by permitting the petitioner to file a fresh application before the 4th respondent (the School), who shall forward it to the 2nd respondent for an appropriate decision in light of Jigya Yadav within six weeks. The court’s aim is to align official records with the true name, ensuring the degree and related credentials can be issued.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.24833 of 2015

Dr. T.R. Chandramohan v. Commissioner of Police Kollam, Sub Inspector of Police Kilikolloor, Environmental Engineer, Kerala State Pollution Control Board, Kuzhikantom Sree Krishna Swamy Temple represented by its owner Savithri, and Assistant Commissioner of Police (Special Branch), Kollam

Dr. T.R. Chandramohan, a pediatrician running a clinic from his residence, filed WP(C) No. 24833 of 2015 alleging persistent noise pollution from Kuzhikantom Sree Krishna Swamy Temple adjacent to his home. He contends that the temple’s loudspeakers, beating of drums, bells, conches, and occasional firecrackers violate the Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000, particularly in a densely populated area identified as a silent zone. Despite prior court directions in WP(C) No. 1569 of 2014 directing the first respondent to consider his representations, and subsequent contempt proceedings, the temple continued disruptive activities, prompting the petitioner to seek relief. The petitioner invokes fundamental rights under Article 21 (right to life with dignity), supported by Article 48A (environmental protection) and Article 51A(g) (duty to preserve the environment), and relies on statutes and precedents such as the Rules, the Environment (Protection) Act, and Supreme Court decisions emphasizing that religious practices must comply with pollution-control norms. The temple authorities allegedly undertook undertakings in Exhibit P3 but appeared to have deviated when large loudspeakers and other noise-generating activities resumed. The respondent authorities failed to enforce the statutory limits, leading the High Court to exercise its supervisory and mandamus-like remit. The judge ultimately disposes the petition with concrete directions to ensure compliance, inspection, and due process, aiming to restore peaceful living and protect the clinic’s functioning.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 18591 of 2017

Gracy Varghese and Dr. Jacob Abraham v State of Kerala and others

Gracy Varghese and Dr. Jacob Abraham, absolute owners of parcels in Kumbalam Village, challenge erroneous classification of their land as nilam in the draft data bank and the 2013 data bank. Their properties (95.25 cents in Re Sy.No.78/5 and 22.350 cents in Re-Sy.No.78/6) were converted land per LLMC proceedings (Ext.P3), but the data bank registers continued to misdescribe them. They approached the Local Level Monitoring Committee (LLMC) seeking correction under the Kerala Land Utilisation Order, 1967 (KLU Order) and, on 20.04.2017, filed Ext.P4 for permission to use the land for purposes other than cultivation. The District Collector was informed that Ext.P4 should be considered in light of LLMC’s findings, yet Ext.P5 forwarded the matter again to LLMC, causing delay. The petition, once disposed of with other petitions in 2017, was revived by a review petition (R.P.49/2018) which noted the petitioners’ land was not part of the data bank, prompting this petition’s reconsideration. The court underscores that amendments to the Kerala Conservation of Paddy and Wetland Act, 2008 (Act 28 of 2008) took effect on 30.12.2017; hence Ext.P4 must be examined under the KLU Order as it stood then. Relying on a Division Bench decision (District Collector v. Fr.Jose Uppani), the court disposes the petition by setting aside Ext.P5 and directing the District Collector to reconsider Ext.P4 in accordance with law, considering Ext.P3 LLMC proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
RCREV. NO. 163 OF 2021

Noufal v. A.P. Asharaf

Noufal v. Asharaf concerns a Rent Control revision filed by tenant Noufal under Section 20 of the Kerala Building (Lease and Rent Control) Act, challenging a 2021 order on eviction. The Rent Control Court, Thalassery, had found no evidence to support eviction under Section 11(2)(b) but had allowed the petition on other grounds; the Rent Control Appellate Authority (RCAA) reversed and granted eviction under Section 11(4)(ii) on the ground that the tenant had altered and removed part of the petition schedule building, thereby reducing its value and utility. The revision petition argues that the pleadings did not establish a ground under Section 11(4)(ii), that Exts.C1 and C2 did not prove removal of the wall, and that the Advocate Commissioner’s reports did not support the landlord’s case. The High Court notes that while pleadings may be liberally construed, there must be some basis to determine the eviction grounds, and the burden lies with the petitioner to demonstrate alteration; it finds no evidence of a wall removal and that the RCC’s findings were correct. Citing Nalakath Sainuddin v. Koorikadan Sulaiman and Simon v. Rappai, the court explains the broad revisional power of Section 20 and cautions against pedantic pleading. Consequently, the revision is allowed, the RCAA’s order is set aside, and the RCC’s order is restored; interlocutory applications are closed.

High Court of Kerala
W.A. No. 1555/2022

Kerala Books and Publication Society & The Chairman & Managing Director v. Sakthi Traders

This writ appeal challenges the order of a learned Single Judge in WP(C) 19825/2022, whereby Sakthi Traders (the writ petitioner) succeeded and the Kerala Books and Publication Society (KBPS) was directed to finalise the tender for sale of paper waste to the highest bidder, subject to its terms. The tender related to tearing and damaged reels, usable cut bits, and white folded forms and printed waste. KBPS contends that the tender process had not been finalised and that even though it was the highest bidder (Exhibits P5 and P6 dated 14.03.2022), agreements had been executed with other bidders. It further asserts that a government communication dated 12.04.2022, noting KPPL’s revival and need for white cuttings to meet KPPL’s pulp requirements, improperly influenced the process by directing supply to KPPL, rendering final award premature or unlawful. The respondents urge that there is no concluded contract and that mere participation in a tender does not confer a right to award. The Division Bench ultimately held that there is no concluded contract and that government direction cannot mandate award to a bidder; it allowed the appeal and set aside the Single Judge’s direction to confer the tender in Sakthi Traders’ favour. It remanded with directions to decide in accordance with law within a short timeframe.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 748 of 2021

Lali v. Rajeena

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a dispute over easement by grant regarding a private pathway (plaint item No.3) between the properties of Lali (plaintiff/applicant) and Rajeena (defendant/respondent). The suit sought a declaration of easement and a permanent injunction restraining obstruction to the path’s use. The trial court held that the plaintiff had an easement by grant over a 3.60-meter-wide pathway (17 meters in length) along the northern boundary of plaint item No.2, which was subsequently affirmed by the first appellate court. The defendant contends Ext.A4 (a consent letter dated 05.07.2007) did not specify width and that there was an existing 1.8-meter-wide access; she argues the width of 5 meters claimed by the plaintiff was never agreed, and any larger width would be onerous and unrealistic. The High Court, on second appeal, examines the width by applying the principle that easements must be exercised in the mode least onerous to the servient owner, and considers the building rules and space constraints around the defendant’s property. Citing precedents on easement by grant and the need for a just and reasonable width, the court ultimately holds that the width should be fixed at 2.50 meters and modifies the injunction accordingly. The judgment underscores that easements are precarious rights to be balanced with servient land interests and statutory regulations, and it remits costs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 29274 OF 2021

M/S. Kinalur Rock Sand, Mankayam v. Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change and others

The petitioner, M/S. Kinalur Rock Sand Mankayam, holds a quarrying permit for 4.0558 hectares in Re-Sy.No.109, Kinalur Village, Kozhikode District, and seeks to operate the quarry consistent with Ext.P10 Environmental Clearance (EC). The SEIAA Kerala issued EC with Condition No.3 mandating clearance from the Standing Committee for Wildlife under the Office Memorandum dated 08.08.2019, noting that the site lies within 10 km of Malabar Wildlife Sanctuary. The petitioner challenges this condition as an overreach beyond the EC’s scope. The petitioner’s counsel cites the Supreme Court’s directions in T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India, contending that the EC cannot impose a general wildlife clearance condition; instead, ESZ considerations should be site-specific. The Government Pleader states that ESZ norms and the 10 km buffer are applicable and that no mining within sanctuaries is permitted, with distances to be verified. On 21.06.2022 the Court ordered an inspection to determine the site’s distance to the sanctuary, which revealed the distance to be more than three kilometres. The judgment then discusses the Supreme Court directions from Godavarman and the 2011 ESZ Guidelines, which prescribe ESZ widths and compliance responsibilities. References are also made to related W.P.(C) Nos.12829/2022 and 14883/2022. In the end, the Court quashes Condition No.3 of Ext.P10 EC, allowing the writ petition to the extent of quashing this condition while directing compliance with ESZ norms in future actions.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) Nos. 2111, 2112, 2113, 2114 and 2116 of 2021

Common Order in OP(C) Nos. 2111, 2112, 2113, 2114 and 2116 of 2021, High Court of Kerala

These Original Petitions challenge a common order of the Co-Operative Arbitration Court (Northern), Kozhikode, which, in ARC Nos. 29 of 2017, 28 of 2017, 27 of 2017, 26 of 2017 and 25 of 2017, directed eviction of members of The Chandranagar Co-operative House Building Society Ltd. The petitions—OP(C) Nos. 2111, 2112, 2113, 2114 and 2116 of 2021—argue that the Arbitration Court had no jurisdiction to entertain eviction proceedings because the occupancy was under a license arrangement, not a lease. The petitioners contend that the documents are license agreements and that occupant status should be treated as licensees; therefore, eviction should be adjudicated by a Civil Court, not the Arbitration Court. The Society counters that the nomenclature of the instrument cannot decisively determine the issue; the essential question is the true nature of the occupancy, and Section 69 of the Co-operative Societies Act provides that disputes between a member and the Society shall be resolved by the Co-operative Arbitration Court. The court observes that the petitioners are admittedly members who occupied Society premises, and that Section 69 empowers the Arbitration Court to adjudicate such disputes, including eviction. While distinguishing the earlier decision in Chandranagar Co-operative House Building Society Ltd v KK Ali (2020(1) KHC 112), the common order is ultimately upheld. The petitions are dismissed, and the Arbitration Court’s jurisdiction is maintained across all five OP(C) Nos. 2021 filings.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.25642 of 2021

R. Karthik v. State of Kerala and others

This writ petition challenges Exts.P13 and P14, i.e., the orders denying issuance of a community certificate designating the petitioner as Hindu-Pallan. The petitioner’s father belonged to Hindu-Pallan and his mother to Hindu-Ezhava; school records and several certificates over the years consistently record him as Hindu-Pallan. After the family moved to Kollam, the Tahsildar, Kollam (third respondent) rejected the application for a community certificate on the ground that the petitioner was born to an inter-caste marriage and his mother belongs to the Ezhava community, while the petitioner himself follows Hindu-Ezhava rituals. The appeal against Ext.P13 was dismissed by Ext.P14. The petitioner contends that lifelong identity as Hindu-Pallan cannot be altered merely due to marriage or change of residence; he relies on Jyothsna A v. Kerala PSC (2022) 1 KHC 401 and a Babasaheb Ambedkar quote distinguishing Varna and Caste by birth. The respondents submit that Tahsildars are not equipped to decide caste status and that KIRTADS must conduct enquiries in prescribed circumstances, as per the Kerala Act. The court found Exts.P13 and P14 illegal for lack of proper enquiry, noting that the petitioner’s life-long certificates (Exts.P3–P11) support Hindu-Pallan status. It directed reconsideration by the Tahsildar Kollam and issuance of a certificate based on Exts.P3–P11, with any KIRTADS enquiry to be performed only if warranted under the Act. The petitioner’s immediate employment prospects were a consideration in directing timely reconsideration.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P Nos. 863 & 864 of 2022

Grace Davis v. State of Kerala and Johny Thomas

This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition (CRL.R.P. Nos. 863 & 864 of 2022) arising from two NI Act proceedings under Section 138. Grace Davis, aged 74, challenges concurrent convictions and sentences recorded by the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Pala (S.T. Nos. 44/2017 and 60/2017) and affirmed by the Sessions Court, Kottayam, in relation to two dishonored cheques for Rs. 20,00,000 each issued in 2015. The trial court relied on documentary Exts. P1, P7 and Ext. P13, along with oral evidence, to hold that two distinct transactions occurred and that the cheques were issued in discharge of a debt. The High Court, in exercising revisional jurisdiction under Cr.P.C. 397/401, reiterises that revision is supervisory and not a second appellate remedy; it cannot reappreciate evidence unless there is a gross miscarriage of justice or non-consideration of material. Relying on Supreme Court precedents such as State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri, Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan v. Dattatray Phalke, Rangappa v. Sri Mohan, Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar, and Kalamani Tex, the Court upholds the concurrent findings and the legality of the presumption under S.139 NI Act in favour of the complainant, while emphasizing the burden on the accused to rebut. The revision petitions are dismissed, but the Court grants two months for payment of the fine and directs the accused to surrender by 07.02.2023, with execution deferred till 06.02.2023.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 9802 OF 2021

Niyas v. State of Kerala

This is a regular bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 9802 OF 2021) by the second accused, NIYAS, in Crime No. 13/2020 of the Excise Enforcement and Anti-Narcotic Special Squad, Thiruvananthapuram. The prosecution case alleges offences under the NDPS Act (sections 8(c) and 20(b)(ii)(c) r/w 29). On 07.10.2020, information led officers to intercept two vehicles on the Alamkode-Kilimanoor road; 101 kg of ganja and 3 kg of hashish oil were recovered from the vehicles. The petitioner challenges the legality of the search and seizure, arguing non‑compliance with Section 42(1) and (2) of the NDPS Act, lack of a warrant for the private vehicle, no conspiracy under Section 29, and the unreliability of statements under Section 67; reference is made to Tofan Singh v. State of T.N., Boota Singh v. State of Haryana, and Karnail Singh v. State of Haryana. The Public Prosecutor contends there was substantial compliance with Section 42(1)/(2), that information was reduced to writing and communicated to the superior, and that Sections 50, 57 and the procedure under Section 37 (commercial quantity) are applicable. The court, after examining the facts, holds that Section 42 was complied with, Section 50 does not apply since recovery was from a vehicle, and Section 37 applies, but the twin conditions are not satisfied. Consequently, the bail application is dismissed. The judgment underscores that the contraband was in commercial quantity and that bail is not a matter of right under NDPS for such offences.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.5614 of 2024

Bibin Thomas v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application (B.A. No. 5614 of 2024) under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, filed by Bibin Thomas (3rd accused) in Crime No. 670/2023 of Pothanikkadu Police Station, Ernakulam, in the NDPS matter relating to ganja alleged under NDPS Act, 1985 (initially under Section 20(b)(ii)(C) and later incorporating Sections 27A and 29). The contraband—about 20.144 kg of ganja—was seized on 13.11.2023 from the residence of the 1st accused; the petitioner contends he was falsely implicated, relying on the confession of the 1st accused, which he argues is inadmissible per Tofan Singh v. State of Tamil Nadu. The 2nd accused was enlarged on bail earlier by an order dated 05.07.2024. The prosecution maintains incriminating materials, including the commercial quantity nature of the contraband, financial transactions, and the petitioner’s presence in the same vehicle as the 1st accused. The court notes the investigation is complete and final report laid on 30.03.2024, and that the petitioner has no criminal antecedents. On balance, the court dilutes the rigour under Section 37 NDPS, allows bail, and imposes bond of Rs. 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, plus conditions including regular appearances, non-tampering with witnesses, no new offences, passport surrender, and possible cancellation on violation, with observations limited to bail considerations and not merits.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases

WP(C) Nos. 10612/2024 & connected cases, Kerala High Court

The Kerala High Court, sitting in a batch of writ petitions (WP(C)) concerning freezing of bank accounts in cyber-crime investigations, consolidates petitions from petitioners including individuals, banks, and service/co-operative banks. The petitions challenge orders freezing bank accounts issued by police or authorities under the Cyber Crime/National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal framework. The court notes a recurring pattern of indiscriminate freezes that hamper legitimate banking transactions and business, and directs that freezing be confined to the amount specified in the police requisition or intimation. The judgment draws on prior judicial guidance, especially from Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC OnLine 661), and references earlier Kerala decisions, including WP(C) 28155/2023 and related matters, to justify proportional, targeted freezing and timely de-freezing where appropriate. It emphasizes the need for banks to comply with police intimations but also safeguards petitioners’ ability to operate funds beyond the freeze limit. The court disposes of the connected petitions with directions: banks shall confine freezing to the exact amount mentioned in police notice; police authorities must furnish precise information; and petitioners may approach the court again for further relief if required. The decision centralizes a proportionality standard in freezing assets in cyber-crime investigations and attempts to harmonize investigative needs with the day-to-day functioning of financial accounts across multiple jurisdictions (Kerala, Gujarat, Rajasthan, Delhi, Maharashtra, Karnataka, etc.).

High Court of Kerala
BA No. 4003 of 2024

Praveen Prasad v. State of Kerala and Station House Officer, Mavelikkara Police Station

Praveen Prasad, the first accused in Crime No. 267/2024 of Mavelikkara Police Station, approaches this Court under Section 439 CrPC for bail. The charges—under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 294(b), 323, 324, 427, 325 and 308 read with Section 149, along with Section 92(b) of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016—arise from an incident on 12 March 2024, in which the accused allegedly formed an unlawful assembly, restrained the complainant and battered him with an iron rod and a stick, resulting in grievous injuries. The petitioner was arrested on 26 March 2024. Counsel for the petitioner submitted that he is innocent and that the investigation is practically complete with recoveries already effected; the prosecution allegedly included Section 308 to deny bail. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail, arguing ongoing investigation and the danger of tampering with evidence and intimidating witnesses if released. The court, citing Sanjay Chandra, Dataram Singh, State of Kerala v. Raneef and Hussainara Khatoon, reaffirmed the presumption of innocence and that bail is the rule. Observing that the petitioner has been in custody for about 55 days and that the investigation is complete, the judge allowed bail. The order requires the petitioner to furnish Rs 50,000 bond with two solvent sureties and imposes conditions—regular appearance before the IO on Saturdays, non-interference with witnesses, no new offenses, passport surrender, and the possibility of cancellation on breach. The Division acknowledges Sushila Aggarwal’s guidance on continuing investigations while on bail.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.9423/2022

Theresa Jose v. Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB)

The petitioner, Theresa Jose, proprietor of Cochin Granites, seeks to shift the electricity connection from consumer No.1157522012050 serving the older building IX/339B to the newly constructed building No.9/305B, Ward No.9, in Madakkathanam, Manjalloor. A civil dispute with the landlord is pending (O.S.344 of 2021), and a parcel of construction expenditure exceeding Rs.1 crore has been incurred under a lease and licence, supported by building permit Ext.P1 (26.07.2017) and sanitation certificate Ext.P2 (18.12.2020). After a 12.01.2022 inspection, the Board issued a provisional assessment for overload (Rs.52,424) and a notice on 30.01.2022; attempts to increase load via Ext.P5 were rejected (Ext.P7). The petitioner contends that Regulation 45 of the Kerala Electricity Supply Code, 2014 requires no separate no-objection from the landlord in the context of a pending dispute, and that several unreported Kerala High Court decisions have dispensed with such NOC requirements in similar landlord–tenant disputes (citing Hindustan Petroleum Corp. Ltd. v. KSEB; Shalif Mohammed Nahas v. KSEB). The Board argues dues must be cleared and that shifting is not provided; at best a new connection could be issued. The Court, after analysing Regulation 45 and prior judgments, allows the writ petition and directs the Board to consider Ext.P5 manually for shifting and for increasing load to the new building, without insisting on the disputed dues, within one month, subject to appellate orders and a safeguard that the amount may be paid if the appellate court rules against the petitioner.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).No.6633 OF 2022

M/S. K. G. P. GRANITES RAVANANKUNNUPURA v. STATE OF KERALA & ORS

The petitioner, M/S. K. G. P. Granites Ravankunnuppura, challenges the Environmental Clearance (EC) granted for quarrying on approximately 4.2627 hectares. The EC (Exhibit P1) was issued on 03.03.2017 for five years, while the quarry lease runs from 18.05.2017 to 17.05.2029 (about 12 years). The petitioner argues that the EC should be valid for the life of the project, i.e., the entire mine life estimated by the Expert Appraisal Committee, as per Clause 9(i) of the EIA Notification, 2006, and cites the court’s prior reasoning that limiting EC duration for mining projects clashes with the notification’s spirit. The respondents contend that SEIAA’s term has expired and reconstitution is pending; they urge invoking Clause 8 procedures if needed and re-evaluating the project life to harmonize EC validity with the mine life. The court recalls the decision in T. Mathew Abraham v. State Level Environment Impact Assessment Authority (2020) 6 KLT 302, affirming that mining ECs should be granted for the life of the project and that a limited five-year validity violates the notification. The petition is disposed with directions to revalidate the EC after reassessing the project life, seeking additional information if required, and to comply within four months after SEIAA reconstitution.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.10020/22

Ratheesh P.K. and Ratheesh K.M. v. Cochin International Airport Limited and Circle Inspector of Police, Nedumbassery, and Addl. CIAL Taxi Beneficiaries Organization MeKKEL Post

This writ petition challenges the restrictions imposed by Cochin International Airport Limited on auto-rickshaws plying for passenger pickup at Nedumbassery airport. Petitioners Rathesh P.K. and Rathesh K.M., auto-rickshaw operators with contract carriage permits, contend their rights to operate on all fit roads in Ernakulam District and to pick up passengers at the airport premises have been unreasonably curtailed. They assert a fundamental freedom to ply their autos and a passenger’s right to travel by any means, seeking a writ of mandamus and police protection to prevent obstruction. They invoke Article 226 of the Constitution and rely on Binny Ltd. v. Sadasivan to argue that the scope of a writ is determined by the duty to be enforced rather than the identity of the respondent, including private bodies performing public functions. The respondents counter that the petition is not maintainable because the airport authority is not a State under Article 12, and that airport premises are restricted areas governed by the Airports Authority of India Act, 1994, and related regulations; Ext. R1 judgments are cited to show that while dropping passengers may be permitted, parking or waiting inside the airport is prohibited. The court ultimately held that entry to airport premises is subject to reasonable restrictions in public interest and security, and dismissed the petition as infructuous.

High Court of Kerala
CUS.Appeal Nos.11/2018, 28/2018, 30/2018, 32/2018, 33/2018, 34/2018, 41/2018

Commissioner of Customs, Cochin v. KIMS Health Care Management Ltd.

This batch of Customs Appeals before the Kerala High Court arises from seven Cus. Appeals (Nos. 11/2018, 28/2018, 30/2018, 32/2018, 33/2018, 34/2018, 41/2018) challenging a Bangalore Tribunal order (21.08.2017) allowing exemptions claimed under the Served from India Scheme (SFIS) for an MRI scanner imported by KIMS Health Care Management Ltd. The MRI scanner, Bill of Entry 1001 dated 22.05.2006, had an assessable value of Rs. 3,59,37,288; the Revenue contends the importer’s exemption claim is improper as SFIS credit of Rs. 18,96,214 leaves an unpaid duty of Rs. 33,43,605. The Tribunal allowed the appeal of the importer, relying on exemptions under Notification Nos. 92/2004 (for BCD) and 20/2006 (for SAD), and held that Education Cess and additional duties could be excluded from the computation. The Revenue’s substantial questions of law centered on whether the Appellate Tribunal erred in permitting the exemption and in applying Notification No. 20/2006 to the SAD and other duties. The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench judgment, held that there is no substantial question of law arising; the Tribunal’s findings on the duty payable and exemption are tenable in law, and the appeals are dismissed. The decision effectively sustains the Tribunal’s favorable order to the importer and dismisses the Revenue’s challenge.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO.2435 OF 2008

KANIYARATHIL PURUSHU PERINTATHOOR AMSOM, ANIYARAM v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (Criminal Appeal No. 2435 of 2008) challenging a 2008 conviction under Section 58 of the Abkari Act. The appellant, KANIYARATHIL PURUSHU PERINTATHOOR AMSOM, ANIYARAM, was found on 20 February 2002 at Perigalam Panchayath with 40 bottles of Indian Made Foreign Liquor (180 ml each). He was initially charged under Section 58 Abkari Act; the prosecution later submitted a final report under Section 55(a) Abkari Act and Rule 9 of the Foreign Liquor Rules; The trial court convicted and sentenced him to one year rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1 lakh. On appeal, the counsel urged that the arrest was doubtful and that the prosecution failed to prove the link between the contraband and its analysis; reliance was placed on Santhosh v. State of Kerala to challenge the arrest and seizure. The State contends the prosecution evidence is adequate. The High Court scrutinized chain-of-custody: Ext.P3 seizure mahazar; absence of seal description; lack of specimen; failure to prove the sample was forwarded to the laboratory; and non-examination of transit officials. Citing Bhaskaran and Rajamma, the court held that the evidence failed to establish that the contraband was subjected to laboratory analysis or that the sample remained untampered. Consequently, the accused is acquitted, and the appeal is allowed, with disposal of interim deposits.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C).483 of 2022

Jayachandran v. Shibu T Varghese

This Original Petition (Civil) under Article 227 of the Constitution of India arises from execution proceedings in which the judgment debtor, Jayachandran, seeks exemption from attachment and sale of his house and the land immediately appurtenant thereto under Section 60(1)(c) CPC, on the ground that he is a labourer (coolie) and the property is exempt for a labourer. The Decree Holder, Shibu T Varghese, obtained a decree in OS No.95/2016, with EP No.52/2019 in the Principal Sub Court, Kottayam. After objections and pre-sale steps, an order denying exemption was passed; subsequently, E.A.2/2022 filed in February 2022 seeking exemption also failed. The petition argues that the house and immediate land are used for the laborer’s enjoyment and thus exempt from attachment, and that the preliminary objection and the Gahan record showing employment as a company employee should not defeat his claim. The court, however, frames the critical issue as whether failure to raise the Section 60(1)(c) exemption at the initial stage of execution proceedings can operate as res judicata when raised later. Relying on Mohanlal Goenka and subsequent Kerala authorities, the court finds constructive res judicata applicable to execution proceedings, holding that a belated plea cannot be allowed. Consequently, the petition is dismissed, upholding the sale proceedings and rejecting interference under Article 227.