Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 589 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 29662 of 2021

Block Development Officer, Block Development Office-Palakkad Rural Development Department, Kalakkad, Palakkad-678015 v. Income Tax Officer (TDS), Aaykar Bhavan, English Church Road, Palakkad-678014; Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, TDS CPC, Vaishali, Ghaziabad, Uttar Pradesh-201010; Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), National Faceless Appeal Centre, New Delhi-110003; Central Board of Direct Taxes, North Block, New Delhi-110002; Union of India, Ministry of Finance, Direct Taxes Department, New Delhi-110001

The writ petition (WP(C) No. 29662 of 2021) by Block Development Officer, Palakkad, challenged intimations issued under Section 234E of the Income Tax Act, demanding late filing fees for TDS statements (Form 24Q) for the financial years 2012-13 to 2014-15. The petitioner argued that 234E was introduced by the Finance Act, 2012 and became effective from 1 July 2012, but Section 200A, which governs computation of late fee, was amended to include new sub-clauses only from 01.06.2015; thus, there could be no liability for late fees for statements prior to that date. The respondents argued that the petitioner, having invoked statutory remedies and heard appeals, could not challenge the intimations under Article 226. The court relied on M/s. Sarala Memorial Hospital v. Union of India and Another (W.P.(C) No. 37775 of 2018), which held that the Section 234E amendment takes effect from 01.06.2015 since Section 200A was made effective from that date. Consequently, the court held that the demands for 2012-13 to 2014-15 were without authority and quashed Ext.P1 to Ext.P7 to that extent. The writ petition was allowed in part. The judgment emphasizes that pre-01.06.2015 demands cannot be sustained, and there was no necessity to remand to the Tribunal.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C).No.2510 of 2021

Anto vs. Sathyanandan, Sunil, Haridas, Rajamani and Binoy

This is an Original Petition (Article 227) challenging an order dated 02.12.2021 in IA No.4/2021 in OS No.415/2010 before the Principal Sub Court, Irinjalakuda. The plaintiff, Anto, claimed easement by prescription over B schedule (a pathway) and sought interim/ permanent relief to restrain obstructive acts and to remove a ginger plantation. After trial, with multiple adjournments and unsuccessful mediation, the plaintiff moved to amend the plaint (IA 4/2021) to alter the B schedule’s description and ownership scope, arguing that a prior misdescription by counsel necessitated correction. The defendants objected, cautioning that the proposed amendment would change the basic structure of the suit, require new pleadings and evidence, and prejudice them, especially since the amendment would alter who owns the servient and dominant properties and even treat the B schedule as a public road. The Trial Court/ Munsiff upheld the objection and denied the amendment. The petitioner challenged this denial under Article 227, arguing inadvertent pleading mistakes should be corrected. The High Court noted that amendments after completion of evidence are only permissible if they advance the real dispute and do not prejudice the other side, and that wrong legal advice cannot justify a drastic post-trial change. Ultimately, the court declined to revisit the Sub Court’s order, upholding the amendment denial and dismissing the petition.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C NO. 7331 OF 2022

Amalsha @ Faizi v. State of Kerala

Amalsha @ Faizi filed CRL.M.C. No. 7331 of 2022 challenging the cancellation of bail in Crime No. 304/2021 of Sakthikulangara Police Station under Sections 22(b) and 29 of the NDPS Act, by the Special Judge (Additional Sessions Court‑ IV), Kollam, which had cancelled bail granted under CrPC 439(2). The petition was argued after the court below found that the petitioner, while on bail, committed two more offences (Crime Nos. 7/2022 and 63/2022) and was also detained under the KAAPA Act. The petitioner urged that cancellation of bail is a harsh and exceptional measure, to be exercised only on supervening circumstances; she relied on Apex Court and Kerala High Court authorities emphasizing that cancellation requires cogent reasons, and that misapplication of bail cannot be inferred merely from subsequent criminal activity. The Public Prosecutor contended that the accused flagrantly violated bail conditions, involved in serious offences, and was booked under KAAPA, justifying cancellation and custody. The High Court, after reviewing the authorities—Dolat Ram, Dataram Singh, Ash Mohammad, Ram Lakhan, Administration v. Sanjay Gandhi, Mithun, X1, Deepak Yadav, Godson, and especially the three‑bench ruling in P. v. State of Madhya Pradesh—held that misuse of liberty by committing similar/other criminal activity constitutes a supervening circumstance warranting cancellation of bail. Because the accused committed further crimes and was detained, the petition was dismissed and the bail cancellation affirmed. The registry was to transmit a copy of the order to the trial court within seven days.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 8408 OF 2022

Edwin Thomas v. State of Kerala

Edwin Thomas, the fifth accused in Crime No.883/2021 of Kasaragod Police Station, challenged a Sessions Court order (CRL.M.P. No.2223/2022) cancelling his bail in the related crime for offences under Sections 365 and 395 IPC. The bail had been granted on 05.03.2022 with a condition not to involve himself in another crime. Subsequently, Edwin Thomas was implicated in a separate offence (Crime No.487/2022, Koratti PS) on 19.05.2022, under Sections 452, 341, 324, 506, and 395 read with 34 IPC, and under Section 27 of the Arms Act. The Station House Officer sought cancellation of bail on grounds that the accused violated the bail condition by committing another crime. The Sessions Court, after hearing, cancelled the bail. The petitioner contends that cancellation is unsustainable, arguing that the subsequent crime is possibly a false implication and is not connected to the original case; there was no proper inquiry into the likelihood of involvement in the new offence, and the cancelation would affect the accused’s fair trial. The State counters that the accused has several antecedents (including other Chalakudy and Thrissur cases under various IPC sections) and that the mere fact of a later crime with grave allegations demonstrates breach of conditions and endangers the fair trial. The High Court ultimately upholds the cancellation, emphasizing the proximity in time between the initial bail and the later offence, the grave nature of the later allegations, and repeated offences, while clarifying that surrender and renewal bail may be sought on merits.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 814 OF 2022

Madhu Kottayil Kalarikkal v. Firoz Ali Thazhath Veetil House, Kuttaloor, Oorakam, Keezhmuri Post, Malappuram District; State of Kerala

This is a criminal revision petition under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. filed by the revision petitioner Madhu Kottayil Kalarikkal challenging concurrent convictions for an offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (NI Act). The complainant alleged that the accused issued a cheque (Ext. P1) dated 25.05.2017 to repay Rs. 8,00,000 for the purchase of a bus, but the cheque bounced for want of funds. The trial court, after examining PW1 (the complainant) and PW2 and marking Exts. P1–P5, convicted the accused under NI Act Sec. 138 and imposed a fine of Rs. 8,00,000, directing that the amount be paid as compensation under Cr.P.C. Sec. 357(1)(b); in default, the accused would suffer six months of simple imprisonment. The Sessions Court, in Cr. Appeal No. 02/2022 dated 12.10.2022, confirmed the conviction and sentence. The revision petition challenges the existence of a legally enforceable debt, arguing that the complainant’s capacity to lend has not been proved; the accused asserts the bus belonged to the complainant’s wife and that the cheque was misused from security issued as collateral (25 blank cheques and a stamp paper). The High Court reaffirms the principle that revision cannot be a vehicle for re‑appreciation of evidence, upholds the concurrent verdicts, but grants three months to pay the compensation and defers execution to 22.02.2023, with a direction to appear on 23.02.2023 for compliance.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.37313 of 2022

K. Krishnankutty Nair, K. Raveendran Pillai, V. Sujatha, D. Ambujakumari and M. Sulaimankunju v. Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Office of the Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies, Civil Station, Kollam; Assistant Registrar of Co-operative Societies (General), Patharam Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. No. 721, Patharam, Kollam; Administrator, Patharam Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. No. 721, Patharam, Kollam

The petitioners, five members comprising the managing committee of Patharam Service Co-operative Bank Ltd., challenge Ext.P6, an order dated 19.11.2022 removing the committee and appointing an Administrator under Section 33(1) of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969. They contend that the Registrar can appoint an Administrator only after notice and opportunity to show there is a quorum; Ext.P6 was issued without such notice, and the resignation dynamics between 12.09.2022 and 12.11.2022 left the committee with insufficient members to constitute a quorum. They further dispute the validity of the nomination of Sri Sulaimankunju as a member, arguing that the resignation of Thajudeen on 12.09.2022 and subsequent resignations reduce the body below quorum. The respondents contend that, notwithstanding resignations, five members remained capable of constituting a quorum, and rely on Section 33(1) and Rule 38(4) to justify Ext.P6, backed by precedents including Pavithran, Divakaran and Nataraj Gownder. The Government Pleader cites statutory interpretations and case law to justify the order and the non-necessity of notice publication per the Division Bench WA 500/2022. The Court ultimately holds that Thajudeen’s resignation took effect on 12.09.2022, the 20.09.2022 meeting was inconsequential, and with subsequent resignations the remaining members could not form a valid quorum, leading to the writ petition being dismissed per the court’s analysis of authorities and the proscriptions in Section 33(1).

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 28781 OF 2018

M. Nazimudeen v. Venjaramoodu Co-operative Rubber Marketing Society & Others

This writ petition challenges Ext.P11, a notice issued by the 1st respondent stating that the Society is not liable to remit provident fund contributions to the Kerala State Cooperative Employees Pension Board and directing the petitioner to remit pension contributions. The petitioner had previously approached this Court in W.P.(C) No.38668 of 2010 alleging inaction by the 1st respondent in remitting contributions, and the Court’s Ext.P9 judgment (dated 01.08.2017) directed that if the petitioner paid any deficient amount to the Pension Board, the Board would consider granting full pension under the Employees' Provident Fund Pension Scheme, 1994. The petitioner contends Ext.P9’s observations were not reflected in Exts.P10 and P11. He relies on Thulasi Devi B. v. Kerala State Coop. Employees Pension Board and Others (2008 (4) KHC 498) to argue that non-payment by an employer cannot delay pension, and on Sambasivan Nair T.R. v. Kerala State Co-operative Employees Pension Board and Another (2012 (3) KHC 518) to urge that, in default, the Pension Board should not pursue revenue recovery. The respondents claim the Society remitted contributions on time and the denial is not their fault. The court, after hearing, directed the addition of the State/5th respondent to consider Ext.P14 in light of Ext.P9 and the cited decisions, to be heard within a month, and disposed of the petition with these directions, ensuring the petitioner copies the judgment and Ext.P14 before the 1st respondent.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 35060/2018

The Principal Secretary, Finance Department, Government of Kerala v. Kerala Lok Ayukta and Mohanakumar s/o Madhavan Pillai

This is a writ petition under WP(C) No. 35060/2018 before the Kerala High Court, challenging Ext. P4 interim order dated 06.06.2018 issued by the Kerala Lok Ayukta in Complaint No. 850/2013. The interim order directed the Additional Chief Secretary, Finance Department, Government of Kerala, to ensure the payment of Rs. 12,61,824, the commuted value of pension of the 2nd respondent Mohanakumar, forthwith. The petitioner contends that Ext. P4 violates the proviso to Rule 3 of Appendix-X, Part III KSR (Pension Commutation Rules), which prohibits commuting any portion of pension during pendency of judicial or departmental proceedings against an officer or pensioner. The 2nd respondent had a vigilance case (VC 12/08/IDK) dating from 2005, with trial in CC No. 35/2016 progressing slowly; pension commutation was argued to be improper while proceedings were pending. The petition traces prior orders, including a Division Bench order (29.10.2018) citing Rule 3A of Part III KSR and decisions such as State of Kerala v. V.R. Muraleedharan Nair, and cites Supreme Court guidance in Chandran (2022) that pensionary benefits should not be released during criminal proceedings. The Court ultimately sets aside Ext. P4, holding the Lok Ayukta order contrary to statutory provisions and directs expeditious trial of the pending proceedings. The petition is allowed, and the interim order is quashed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 37224 of 2022

K.K. George v. Regional LPG Manager (South), Bharat Petroleum Corporation Limited and Ors.

The petitioner, K.K. George, engages in the transportation of LPG cylinders and challenged Ext.P1 tender terms issued by BPCL, which require bidders with existing contracts to produce a No Objection Certificate (NOC). Clause 8(i) of Ext.P1 appears to mandate an NOC, yet the petitioner contends BPCL has accepted conditional NOC in Ext.P2 and Ext.P5, undermining the objective of ensuring vehicle availability. He argues that unconditional NOC is necessary to guarantee that vehicles will be available on demand and that replacing trucks already under contract would be impracticable within tight timeframes, potentially affecting BPCL’s operations. In response, respondents contended the matter is contractual and not public-law, challenged maintainability for lack of impleading all tenderers with conditional NOCs, and pointed to Clause 20(d) allowing disputes to be raised with an Independent External Monitor. On merits, it was argued that the term 'unconditional NOC' is not used in Ext.P1 except in Annexure I, and that Annexure I’s declaration cannot modify tender terms. The court, invoking the Supreme Court’s Montecarlo line of authority on limited intervention in contract matters, held that interference in contractual affairs should be narrow, and that the unconditional NOC cannot be read into Ext.P1. The petition was accordingly dismissed as lacking a public-law element and inappropriate for writ relief.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.34564/2017, 34782/2015 & WP(C) No.13902/2018

Sadhana Gilbert and Salomi Abraham v. State of Kerala and Ors (W.P.(C) Nos.34564/2017, 34782/2015 & 13902/2018)

These are connected writ petitions challenging warrants issued by the Ernakulam Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum under Section 27 of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, in execution proceedings arising from a complaint. The petitions relate to orders wherein the Forum held the petitioners liable for offences under the CP Act and directed imprisonment and fines. The proceedings center on whether the warrants of arrest can be sustained, particularly in light of earlier judicial dicta on arrest of women in execution. The court notes Mary Chacko v. Jancy Joseph (which prohibited arrest of a woman) and the Full Bench decision in Veena Madhukant v. State Bank of India and Others (which held Mary Chacko per incuriam) and discusses how these authorities bear on the present proceedings. The complainant contends that the later Full Bench decision supersedes Mary Chacko, while the petitioners contend for staying or quashing the warrants and adherence to due process. The judgment ultimately disposes of the petitions by declining to quash the orders but grants an opportunity for the petitioners to appear before the Forum and seek appropriate orders, with further action to be taken in accordance with law if compliance is not forthcoming. The disposition also directs action in the 13902/2018 matter to be taken promptly by the Forum if the accused does not appear.

High Court of Kerala
BA.No.4368/2024

Sunil N.S. v. State of Kerala

Sunil N.S., the first accused in Crime No. 297/2017 of Nedumbassery Police Station, Ernakulam, faces trial in SC No.118/2018 before the Principal Sessions Court, Ernakulam. The gruesome allegations involve a conspiracy allegedly led by a movie star, abducting and sexually assaulting the victim in a moving car, with offences under IPC sections 120B, 109, 342, 366, 354, 354B, 357, 376D, 201 and 212 r/w 34, and IT Act sections 66E, 66A. The case has attracted public attention and is supervised by the Supreme Court for timely disposal. The petitioner moved Bail Application BA 4368/2024 under Section 439 Cr.P.C. on 23.05.2024, three days after dismissal of an earlier bail petition in BA 3403/2024; this is the 10th such application. Prior orders and the Apex Court's directions had held that the petitioner must face trial in custody given the gravity and seriousness. The present court proceedings saw the Amicus Curiae urging that costs may be imposed in bail petitions to deter frivolous filings, relying on Vinod Seth v. Devinder Bajaj and Another; Vineeth v. State of Kerala provides the standard for entertainability of a second application. The Public Prosecutor opposed bail. The High Court ultimately dismissed the application, finding no change of circumstances and imposing costs of Rs. 25,000 to be paid to the Kerala Legal Services Authority.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.22622/12

Poornam Info Vision Pvt. Ltd. and George M.J. v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ petition challenges the authority of an Inspector under the Kerala Industrial Establishments (National and Festival Holidays) Act, 1958 to adjudicate and quantify wages payable as compensation for employees working on holidays. Following an inspection in 2010 at Poornam Info Vision Pvt. Ltd. (Cochin SEZ), several violations were noted, including non-payment of double wages and lack of compensatory off. A show-cause notice Ext.P9 was issued directing payment of Rs. 48,72,678 and initiating revenue recovery proceedings. Petitioners contended Ext.P9 was not a final order and that the Inspector has no adjudicatory power to determine the quantum due; they argued the Act may not be applicable to their establishment and that even if applicable, employees should pursue remedies under the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 or civil courts. Respondents argued the Inspector’s powers extend to carrying out the Act’s objectives, including quantifying amounts due, with revenue recovery available for non-payment. The High Court examined the statutory scheme, held that the Inspector is not empowered to adjudicate or fix the quantum, and rejected the doctrine of implied powers as a basis for such adjudication. It quashed Ext.P9 and the related revenue recovery actions, while leaving open the question of applicability of the Act to the unit. The petition is allowed to that extent. It also notes that employees may pursue remedies under IDA or civil law for wage claims.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 33401 of 2017

Elizabeth Abraham v. State of Kerala & Others

Elizabeth Abraham, a lecturer in the Department of Pharmaceutical Sciences at Mahatma Gandhi University, has worked since July 1996, initially on a contract basis. She seeks regularisation of her service as a Lecturer, relying on Exts. P15, P16 and P17 judgments of this Court, which have been upheld by a Division Bench through Ext. P18 and whose outcomes were not reversed by the Supreme Court SLP. She asserts that she is identically situated to the beneficiaries in those decisions and that the university’s transfer of the department to the 4th respondent should not defeat her claim. The petitioner submits that several others have benefited from regularisation on the strength of those orders, and that non-consideration of her claim, despite representations, violates principles of equal protection under Article 14. The university counters that placement is not identical because she obtained a PG degree only in 2012, and that the law in State of Uttarakhand v. Sudhir Budakoti supports classification based on reasonable grounds, so differential treatment can be permissible. The court records that Ext P23 merely notes transfer of the department and does not address tenure. It directs the University to hear the petitioner, decide her claim under Exts P15–P17 within three months, and to grant relief if she is similarly situated, while considering any delay or acquiescence.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 7089 OF 2022

ABOOBACKER v. STATE OF KERALA

This Criminal Misc. Case (CRL.MC No. 7089 of 2022) arises from Crime No. 75/2013 of Kasaragod Police Station. The petitioner, ABOOBACKER, challenges proceedings in LP No.33/2019 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Kasaragod, on the ground that the substratum of the prosecution has collapsed following the acquittal of several co-accused (Accused Nos. 1–6, 8 and 9) in CC No.66/2017 and the refiled CC No.222/2019. The original case involved 12 accused and offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 323, 324, 354, 326, and 153A r/w 149, arising from a 2013 riot at Shanthi Nagar, where injuries to multiple witnesses and a harassment of a female intervenor were alleged. Annexure A3 shows the acquittals of most co-accused. PW1 and PW2 did not support the prosecution, and the prosecution examined no further witnesses. The petitioner invoked section 482 Cr.P.C., relying on Sahadevan v. State of Tamil Nadu and Moosa v. Sub Inspector of Police, to assert that the fallen substratum warrants quashing of proceedings. The High Court, relying on these precedents, held that the proceedings against the petitioner should be quashed. The Crl.M.C is allowed and all further proceedings against the petitioner are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No.58 of 2022

Omana v. Christudas

Omana v. Christudas concerns a dishonored cheque suit arising from a loan of Rs. 1,75,000 allegedly advanced by the plaintiff to the defendant on 15.10.2009, evidenced by a cheque drawn on the State Bank of Travancore. The cheque bounced for “funds insufficient.” The defendant contends the loan relationship was with her brother Sudan, not with her, and that she issued a signed blank cheque as security; she further claims repayment through a Rs. 1,00,000 loan from HDFC Bank and denial of the asserted Rs. 65,000 borrowal. The brother (DW2) and the daughter (DW3) were examined, but the trial court and the first appellate court accepted the plaintiff’s version and did not accept the daughter’s evidence. Ext.A1 (cheque), Ext.A6 (dishonor memo), Ext.A2 (cheque return memo), Ext.A3–A5 (notice documents) were relied upon to show execution and demand for payment, while the defendant failed to rebut the presumption under Section 118 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. The High Court upheld the concurrent findings that the plaintiff is entitled to Rs.1,83,750, but modified the rate of future interest, reducing it from 12% p.a. to 6% p.a. from the date of suit till realization, following relevant precedents including Lillykutty v. Lawrance.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 649 of 2022

Nasar and Others v. Moideen and Abu Tahir

This Regular Second Appeal (RSA No. 649 of 2022) before the Kerala High Court arises out of a dispute over possession and title, with the appellants claiming rights as legal representatives of the deceased defendant in the original suit. The factual matrix traces to O.S. No.231/1997 before the Munsiff, Ottapalam (dated 07.04.1999) and its appellate progression in A.S. No.83/1999 before the Sub Court, Ottapalam (dated 29.09.2018), which culminated in a decree in favor of the plaintiff-respondent. The appellants (11 in number) are legal representatives of the deceased defendant Beevi Umma and were not parties to the original suit or first appeal; during the pendency of the appeal, supplemental appellants 2 and 3 were impleaded following instigation of execution proceedings. They seek condonation of a 683-day delay in filing the appeal (CM Appln. No.1/2022). The respondents oppose the delay, arguing lack of bonafides and obstructive conduct, with the title already found against the appellants’ predecessor in interest. The court references liberal, justice-oriented notions of “sufficient cause” from precedents such as John K.P. v. Mani Varkey and Lipok AO v. State of Nagaland, ultimately concluding that there is no justifiable reason to condone such a long delay. The result is that the CM Appln. and RSA are dismissed with no order as to costs, affirming the lower decrees against the appellants."

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 30265 of 2013

SUJA JACOB v. SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE (AGRICULTURE PRODUCTION COMMISSIONER), GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM & OTHERS

The petitioner, Suja Jacob, seeks relief under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, challenging a District Level Authorized Committee (DLAC) order that permitted reclaiming a 10-cent parcel of paddy land at Sy.No. 446/2A, Ranny Village, Pathanamthitta, for constructing a residential house. After LLMC approval, Ext.P3, the subsequent Ext.P4 order allowed reclaiming the land; respondents 5–7 challenged this via Ext.P5 revision, and the 1st respondent, by Ext.P9, set aside Ext.P4. The petitioner contends that under Section 9(6) of the Act, an aggrieved person can appeal to the Collector within 30 days, whose decision is final, and there is no revisional jurisdiction vested in the Government or the 1st respondent. The Government Pleader supports Ext.P9, arguing the revision is justifiable, but the petitioner argues otherwise, citing Bhasi T.B. v. State of Kerala, which holds that the Government cannot revise the DLAC’s decision and the remedy is a writ petition. The High Court agrees that Ext.P9 is unsustainable and allows the petition in part. It directs the petitioner to file a representation before the 3rd respondent for extending the six-month time limit in Ext.P4, to be considered expeditiously after notice to respondents 5–7.”

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 37952 of 2010

M/S P.K. RAMACHANDRAN v Union of India

The petition challenges the forfeiture of the Earnest Money Deposit and the debarment of the petitioner from retendering for constructing the Boys Hostel CIFNET, Kochi, under CPWD e-tendering. The petitioner, an A-class registered contractor, submitted a tender with an estimated cost of Rs 2,81,16,940 and Earnest Money of Rs 5,62,339. Tenders were opened on 20.10.2010; the petitioner later discovered that the electronic transmission had omitted rates for almost all items, except a few, suggesting a technical error in uploading. On 20.10.2010 the petitioner emailed Ext.P3 explaining the anomaly and requesting that the respondents allow contractors to view their rates post-submission and to release the EMD. The respondents acknowledged receipt and subsequently accepted the petitioner’s tender at Rs 12,28,610, which was 95.63% below the estimate. The petitioner then argued that this was due to a system error and that the tender could not be treated as a complete bid. Despite Ext.P7, Ext.P8 replies, Ext.P10 forfeited EMD and debarment followed. The court noted that there was no concluded contract and that the bid had been submitted promptly; invoking West Bengal Electricity Board’s equitable-relief doctrine, it allowed the petition, set aside Ext.P10, and directed the respondents to reconsider after a hearing within three months, permitting additional representations. The decision emphasizes fairness, transparency, and the sanctity of process while recognizing the petitioner’s prompt notice of a technical error.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 26118 of 2021 and 26631 of 2021

Safeer Muhammed HaneeFa P.T. v District Education Officer, Tirurangady; Manager, M.H.S.S Moonniyur; Headmaster, M.H.S.S Moonniyur; Ali Akbar P.V v District Education Officer, Tirurangadi; District Educational Officer, Tirur; Manager, M.H.S.S Moonniyur; Headmaster, M.H.S.S Moonniyur

These twin writ petitions challenge the non-approval of appointments of HSTs (Arabic) and HSTs (English) at Moonniyoor Higher Secondary School, an aided institution managed by the Moonniyur management. The petitioners contend that the vacancies arose on 26.11.2011 (HST Arabic) due to the promotion of a predecessor and on 07.07.2009/08.07.2009 (HST English) due to resignation; both vacancies were regular in nature and could not be filled only on a daily wage basis under Exhibit P1. They relied on Chapter XIV A, Rule 49 of the Kerala Education Act and Rules (KER) and on the Supreme Court’s decision in State of Kerala v. Sneha Cherian and Others, 2013 (1) KLT 755, which held that when regular vacancies exist, appointments require continuous approval from the date of appointment. They also cite government orders and clarifications (Exts P3–P5, P4) that permanent vacancies in aided schools entitle teachers to vacation salary, irrespective of service length, and that Rule 49 applies to such vacancies only when not permanent. The respondents, represented by government pleaders, contend that the Manager appointed petitioners on daily wage basis and regularisation cannot be granted. After hearing, the court found the vacancies to be regular and established, quashed the daily-wage approvals, and directed that approvals be granted from the dates of appointment with attendant benefits, including vacation salary, in accordance with the governing rules and Sneha Cherian principle.

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos.7913, 7981, 8006, 8059, 8203, 8239, 8606, 8754 & 8763 of 2022

Bail Applications in BA Nos. 7913, 7981, 8006, 8059, 8203, 8239, 8606, 8754 & 8763 of 2022, In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This is a consolidated High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam bench disposition on a batch of regular bail applications filed by Sri Lankan nationals/refugees (various petitioners accused in two sets of Crime Nos. 529/2022 (Pallithottam) and 868/2022 (East) Kollam) under sections including IPC 511, 370 read with 34, and defences under the Foreigners Act (sections 14A, 14C), Emigration Act (section 10) and Passport Act (section 12(1)(a)). The petitions, necessitated by detention concerns of foreign nationals and refugees, were heard after interim orders in October–November 2022. The court noted the state of detention centers and transit arrangements and observed that petitioners (foreign nationals/refugees) could not be indefinitely detained while instructions from the respective governments were being sought. Citing health concerns of children and pregnancy, the court directed interim bail with conditions, including personal bond, non-interference with investigations, and compliance with movement restrictions. It ordered that foreign nationals stay at a transit home (Gandhi Bhavan International Trust, Pathanapuram) or Open Prison/Centre, Kollam, and ensured medical and educational facilities for children, subject to the investigation and future orders. The court also directed authorities to secure the necessary instructions from Kerala, the Central Government, and Tamil Nadu Government and to file concrete instructions by the next posting date, disposing of the bail applications with interim directions.