WP(C) Nos. 31414/2016 & 28038/2016 Two writ petitions, WP(C) Nos. 31414 of 2016 and 28038 of 2016, were heard together by Justice Amit Rawal in the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam. The petitions challenge an order of the Kerala State Human Rights Commission dated 25 July 2016, which held that the petitioner Velayudhan Chettiar’s conduct and the Pettah Sree Mutharamman Coil Committee constituted an ex-communication from the Vanika Vaisya community, restricting his participation in community functions. The first petition is by the Pettah Sree Mutharamman Coil Committee; the second by K. Chandrakumar and V. Vijayakumar, members of the same coil committee, seeking relief against the HR Commission’s order. The facts describe the committee’s bye-laws, the 2011 censure of Velayudhan Chettiar for an out-of-community marriage, and the 2014 civil court decree in OS 1935/2011, which held there was no excommunication but noted the consequences for participation. The HR Commission’s 2016 order was based on a misreading of the civil decree, treating informing about virtues and vices as ostracism beyond the decree, and purportedly purporting ex-communication. The court held that the HR Commission exceeded its jurisdiction by rewriting the civil decree and by applying bye-laws in a manner inconsistent with the decree and practice; the HR Commission order was set aside and the writ petitions allowed. The decision underscores the need to respect civil-decree finality and the limits of interlocutory human-rights remedies within this community context.
This Kerala High Court revision arises from eviction petitions filed under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The tenant, Thankamma, challenged eviction orders under Section 11(3) (and the related 11(2)(b)) issued by the Rent Control Court (Kolenchery) and confirmed on appeal by the Appellate Authority in RCA No.37 of 2020. The Respondent Landlords sought the tenant’s eviction to shift their grocery business to the petition schedule room, arguing bonafide need. Thankamma contended, inter alia, that there was no arrears and that the landlords possessed other vacant rooms to accommodate the business; she also sought the benefit of the 1st and 2nd provisos to Section 11(3). The Rent Control Court dismissed the 11(2)(b) challenge and granted eviction under Section 11(3); the Appellate Authority affirmed. The High Court, reviewing under Section 20, examined whether the findings were legal, regular, and proper, following precedents that revising courts cannot reappreciate evidence as a second appeal. It held that the landlords had not shown availability of other suitable premises; accordingly, the revision petition was dismissed. However, to ease relocation, the Court granted six months to surrender possession on conditions including affidavit, arrears deposit, and continued payment of rent. The decision reaffirms the narrow scope of revisional interference and the two provisos to Section 11(3).
The core issue in this writ petition is whether IMG Enterprises Pvt Ltd can be held liable under Ext.P1 for using a goods vehicle in Kerala after the expiry of its national permit Ext.P3, whose validity was extended by Ext.P4 to 31 October 2021. The petitioner argues that the vehicle operates under a national permit issued under Section 88(12) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, with an authorization that permits operation across India. Ext.P4 extended the validity of all authorizations including Ext.P3 till 31.10.2021. Thus, based on the clearance and the consolidated tax paid under Rule 87 and the forms, there could be no tax liability or offence. The petitioner relies on the provisions of Section 88(12), Explanation to that section, and on Central Motor Vehicles Rules 1989 including Rules 86–90; he cites P.K. Balan v. State of Kerala and Hamad Transport to argue non-imposition of tax on vehicles with national permits. The respondents contend that Ext.P3 expired on 11 May 2021, and that the vehicle was used in Kerala on 16 October 2021, which is beyond the authorized period, justifying Ext.P1 demands and refund denial. The court analyzes the statutory framework, including the 1988 Act, CMVR Rules and the 2021 notification regime. Ultimately, the court holds that Ext.P4 effectively extended the authorization, the petitioner’s use falls within the extended period, and no offence or tax under the Kerala Act is warranted. Consequently, Ext.P1 demands are quashed and Ext.P2 refunds are ordered within one month of a certified copy of the judgment.
This writ petition filed by Gracy George, a High School Assistant in Social Science, challenges Ext.P13, the suspension order issued during departmental proceedings, and seeks to treat the suspension period as on duty with full salary from 11-10-2010 to 27-02-2011, along with eligibility for other service benefits. The petitioner, who joined service in 1988 and was declared protected in 2007–2008, faced deployment and later suspension after filing for Leave Without Allowance to attend to her ailing husband. The matter traces various steps: the leave applications (2007 onward), deployment to Nedumpuram, the suspension order dated 11-10-2010 issued by the DDE, a stay by this Court, and subsequent developments. Following a Division Bench intervention, the Government issued Ext.P7 and, after scrutiny, Ext.P17 explaining that the suspension occurred while her leave was under consideration and that the period should be treated as duty, but without monetary benefits. The petitioner insists on salary and benefits for the suspension period, while the respondents maintain that Ext.P17 correctly regularised the period as duty without monetary remuneration. The Court, after examining the materials and the government’s action, found no basis to interfere with Ext.P17 and dismissed the petition, noting that the petitioner did not work during the suspension and that monetary salary could not be restored retroactively.
This Arbitration Request (AR 102/2021) before the Kerala High Court concerns CKK Catering Services, a partnership firm that operated a Vegetarian Refreshment Room (VRR) at Ernakulam Junction railway station under a license originally granted by Southern Railway and subsequently assigned to IRCTC under a catering policy. CKK paid security and license fees for 2018-19 and operated until 04.05.2019, after which IRCTC invoked CKK’s bank guarantee in September 2019. CKK invoked arbitration as per Annexures A and B; IRCTC appointed a sole arbitrator. CKK challenged that appointment in court, arguing that disputes must be referred to a sole arbitrator under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 and that the appointment by IRCTC’s CMD violated the Act’s provisions, particularly Section 12(5) and Seventh Schedule, since the appointing authority or nominated arbitrator was ineligible. IRCTC contends the tripartite agreements require arbitration under the Act, with Article 19.2 of Annexure A and clause 8.9 of Annexure B limiting the dispute-resolution mechanism to a gazetted railway officer or a properly appointed arbitrator. The court ultimately held that the CMD’s appointment was void ab initio under Section 12(5) read with the Seventh Schedule and, following the decisions in TRF Ltd. and Bharat Broadband Network, appointed a new sole arbitrator, Justice NK Balakrishnan, and directed disclosure, fees, and scheduling, allowing the arbitration to proceed. The decision underscores that ineligible appointment cannot stand and reconstitutes the arbitration with a valid arbitrator.
CRL.M.C. No. 5748 of 2021 Saleesh (45) and Balan (76), petitioners/accused in SC 6/2016 before the Additional Assistant Sessions Court, Irinjalakuda, challenge orders allowing the production of additional documents and witnesses under Sections 91 and 311 Cr.P.C. The factual backdrop is a catastrophic explosion at the petitioners’ smithy on 17.03.2014, resulting in eight deaths and multiple severe burn injuries; the trial remains pending with about 20 witnesses examined and numerous Exhibits. The Public Prosecutor sought leave to produce official reports and to examine witnesses from Fire Station, Divisional Magistrate, Tahsildar, Inspector of Factories and Boilers, Panchayat and private individuals. The Sessions Court had, by orders dated 22.11.2019 and 24.02.2020, allowed these applications; a prior challenge in Crl.M.C.8781/2019 led to remand for fresh consideration. The High Court notes that Section 311 Cr.P.C. empowers broad, discretionary action to uncover truth while safeguarding fair trial rights. It rejects the argument that such additions are mere corrections of lacunae, endorsing the trial’s need for comprehensive evidence given the gravity of the offence. While distinguishing K.V. Vijayadas and Mannan S.K. on facts, the court finds no basis to interfere with Annexure-A9. The petition is dismissed, and the trial may proceed with the summoned witnesses and documents under judicial supervision.
Sneha Jyothi, a proprietor challenging enforcement actions by Canara Bank for recovery of dues under a loan reportedly covered by the CGTMSE scheme, approaches the Kerala High Court under Article 226 seeking mandamus to extend CGTMSE benefits. The petitioner asserts that CGTMSE has already released 75% of the guaranteed amount to the bank, and therefore further recovery would breach the scheme. She relies on Sai Sree Ganesh Industries v. Union of India (2018 Hyd 126) to contend that debt recovery should align with the scheme provisions and that the bank cannot press for full recovery when benefits have been disbursed. The bank counters by pointing to Ext.R1(a) of the CGTMSE scheme, arguing that while 75% is payable to lenders on default, the bank bears the duty to recover the entire amount, with an adjustment later made with the trust managing the CGTMSE scheme. The Kerala High Court agrees that the CGTMSE framework governs such recoveries but emphasizes the bank’s primary duty to recover the full debt; it disagrees with the Andhra Pradesh high court’s broader ruling that recovery could be paused or that notices under the SARFAESI Act must explicitly state CGTMSE coverage. Ultimately, the court finds merit in the bank’s position, and the writ petition is dismissed, clarifying that the petition fails and costs are not awarded.
This is a Criminal Misc. Case under Section 482 Cr.P.C. before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, challenging an order dated 23-06-2022 in CMP 49/2022 in CC Nos. 2661/2015, 2662/2015 and 2663/2015 pending before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Tripunithura. The complainant is a Dubai-based doctor who entered into a construction agreement with the first accused company for constructing a 4 BHK villa on 12.98 cents of land; Rs. 30 lakh was paid as the first installment, but the project was later abandoned. Cheques issued by the accused (2-4) towards refunds were dishonoured for insufficient funds, giving rise to offences under Section 138 NI Act against the company and its officers. The petitioners contend that since the corporate debtor is under moratorium under Section 14 IBC (as per NCLT Kochi order of 03-11-2021), further proceedings against the corporate debtor must be stayed and that the moratorium should extend to bar continuation of proceedings against the officers under Section 141 NI Act. The trial court relied on the three-judge Apex Court decision in P. Mohanraj & Ors. v. Shah Brothers Ispat Pvt. Ltd. (2021) 6 SCC 258 to stay proceedings against the corporate debtor while permitting action against the accused persons. The High Court analyzes decisions including Aneeta Hada, Ahuja K.K., Srikanth Singh and Dilip Hariramani, clarifying that the moratorium under Section 14 IBC applies only to the corporate debtor, while the natural persons named in Section 141 NI Act remain liable. Ultimately, it holds that the petition is untenable; the order of the Magistrate to dismiss the petition against accused 2-4 is not infirm, and the matter is disposed of by dismissing the petition.
BAIL APPL.NO.5133 OF 2024 Abdul Rafi M.A and Riyas P.M., petitioners in Bail Appl. No. 5133 of 2024, approached this Court under Section 438 CrPC seeking pre-arrest bail in Crime No. 154/2024 of Cheruthuruthy Police Station, Thrissur, for offences under Section 379 r/w Section 34 IPC and Sections 20 and 23 of the Kerala Protection of River Banks and Regulation of Removal of Sand Act, 2001. The prosecution alleges that on 09.03.2024 at about 16:30 hours, the Investigating Officer and party found the accused removing sand from the Ooroly kadavu in Bharathapuzha; on seeing the police, the accused fled, and the contraband article was recovered. The petitioners contend their total innocence and submit there is no material substantiating the charges; they point out that Section 379 IPC is not attracted in cases of this nature and custodial interrogation is unnecessary since the contraband has already been recovered. The learned Public Prosecutor opposed the application, noting criminal antecedents and the likelihood of reoffending if granted bail. After considering the rival submissions and noting the court’s precedent that Section 379 IPC may not be attracted in similar cases, and that custodial interrogation is not essential where recovery has occurred, the court allowed pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC. The order imposes conditions including surrender within two weeks, bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, appearance for interrogation, no inducement, passport surrender, no other offenses, and potential cancellation for violation, while clarifying that observations do not reflect merits of the case.
WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & con.cases This is a consolidated judgment of the Kerala High Court dealing with multiple WP(C) petitions filed under WP(C) Nos. 10612 of 2024 and connected cases, where bank customers petitioned against freezing of their bank accounts following police/intimation in cybercrime investigations across various states. The Court notes that the petitioners’ accounts were frozen on the basis of police notices from different jurisdictions, and, at the admission stage, issued interim directions to confine the freezing to the amount in dispute as notified by the police. Banks reportedly implemented these directions accordingly. The court cites and extracts Paragraph 12 of the directions in Dr. Sajeer v. Reserve Bank of India (2023 KHC Online 661) to justify its approach, and ultimately disposes of the petitions with directions that the freezing of accounts should be restricted to the disputed amounts, with banks required to act in accordance with police information about continuation and duration. The decision emphasizes safeguarding the petitioner’s right to operate accounts while ensuring proceeds of crime are preserved, and it applies uniform guidance across the multitude of connected petitions. The petitions are disposed with the stated directions, and all contentions remain open for potential renewal if required in the future.
The Kerala High Court, in Bail Application No. 4514 of 2024, considers the bail plea of Ajas, who stands accused in Crime No. 309/2024 of Anthikad Police Station, Thrissur, for offences under Sections 341, 323, 324, 506 and 307 read with Section 34 IPC. Arrested on 17.3.2024, the petitioner submits innocence and contends that the 307 charge has been added without materials to substantiate it, with the aim of denying bail. The prosecution maintains that the investigation is ongoing and notes the petitioner’s prior involvement in a 2020 case under Sec. 294(b), alleging grievous injuries and asserting risks of tampering with evidence and witness intimidation if released. The court invokes the presumption of innocence and the constitutional right to liberty, reiterating the principle that bail is the rule and jail the exception. Relying on Sanjay Chandra v. CBI, State of Kerala v. Raneef, and Hussainara Khatoon, it emphasizes that pre‑conviction detention should not be punitive and should be proportionate to the investigation’s status. After careful consideration, the court grants bail with stringent conditions: bond of Rs.50,000 with two solvent sureties, regular appearance before the IO, no tampering or intimidating witnesses, no new offences, surrender of passport, and the court’s power to cancel bail for violations, citing Sushila Aggarwal for the conditional framework.
Chekkotty, a 74-year-old resident of Kozhikode district, filed WP(C) No. 27881 of 2016 challenging an order of the Tribunal for Local Self Government Institutions (TLGI), Thiruvananthapuram, in Appeal No. 401/2014 dated 11 July 2016. The Tribunal had allowed the third respondent Kunhikannan’s appeal and set aside the Perambra Grama Panchayat Secretary’s order under Section 235W(3) of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act, 1994 directing demolition of a thatched hut/shade constructed by the third respondent in front of the petitioner’s commercial building. The lower orders adjudicated the legality of erecting a hut and whether a permit was required under 235P read with Section 220(b) and relevant building rules. The petitioner argued he was not a party to the Tribunal proceedings, that the hut was constructed around 2005, and that the hut obstructed entry and light, contrary to municipal building rules. He submitted that the Secretary’s show-cause and the Deputy Director’s directions were duly recorded but not properly confirmed in the Tribunal’s order, and that the hut may fall under exemptions listed in Rule 10(xii) and Section 235Y. The respondents contended the hut was in private land, pre-dated certain rules, and did not violate building norms; the Panchayat had previously taken no further action. The High Court ultimately held that the Tribunal’s interference was not arbitrary and that no demonstrable illegality or denial of natural justice was shown; accordingly, the writ petition was dismissed. The decision underscores judicial restraint in revisiting Tribunal determinations and emphasizes statutory interpretation around huts, permits, and road-adjacent construction.
Charles, the petitioner in OP(C) 1984 of 2022, challenges Ext.P4 order of the Subordinate Judge, Nedumangad in I.A. No.14/2022 in O.S. No.26/2013, which postponed ruling on the admissibility of documents produced by the plaintiff. The suit, filed by the 1st respondent for damages based on an agreement against the petitioner and respondents 2 and 3, centers on documents alleged to be insufficiently stamped and therefore inadmissible. The petitioner argues that under Order 13 Rule 3 and 4 CPC, admissibility of documents must be decided before trial or marking of documents in evidence. He relies on Santhakumari v. Raghavan Unni and another (2014 KHC 715) to support the proposition that the court has power to weed out inadmissible documents and must record the grounds for rejection. The court below, however, postponed the admissibility question until after evidence. The learned counsel contends that this contravenes statutory procedure and established jurisprudence. The court cites several authorities, including Chaganti Ventaka Bhaskar v. C. Chandresekhar Reddy, Sanjay Shrikishanji Somani v. Vishnupant Shankarrao Shahane, S. Kaladevi v. V.R. Somasundaram, Ranajit Kanungo v. Ibcon Pvt. Ltd., Mt. Sumitra Kuer v. Ram Khair Chowbey, and Dwijesh Chandra Roy v. Naresh Chandra Gupta, to emphasize that a court may reject or exclude inadmissible or irrelevant documents at any stage if they are not valid, and should not admit them. Following this analysis, the High Court holds that the Sub Court must decide the admissibility of the disputed documents first and dispose of the petition accordingly, directing that the admissibility issue be resolved before further proceedings. The petition is, therefore, disposed of in terms of this direction.
Geetha Pai, mother of Surekha Pai, seeks correction of the date of birth in the Births and Deaths Register under the Registration of Births and Deaths Act, 1969. Surekha Pai was born on 10.3.1981, but the register incorrectly records 21.6.1981. The petitioner submitted Ext.P1 under Rule 11 of the Kerala Registration of Births and Deaths Rules, 1999, with Exts.P2–P9 proving the correct DOB via hospital certificates, school records, a consular birth record, a PAN card, voters ID, and affidavits by family members. Ext.P10—the Registrar’s order—rejects the correction, citing reliance on hospital records and procedural requirements. The petitioner challenged Ext.P10, relying on this Court’s Division Bench in Secretary, Registrar of Births and Deaths v. Thomas Jacob and others (2011 (3) KHC 389) and Chalakudy Municipality v. Malavika (2009 (4) KHC 713), which held that the Births and Deaths Act permits corrections and that the procedure is designed to enable corrections, not defeat them, and that hospital reports may be impractical if the hospital no longer exists. This Court held that the rule and statutory framework permit correction upon credible declarations and supporting documents, quashed Ext.P10, and directed the Registrar to correct the DOB within two weeks, based on Ext.P1 and the supporting materials.
Shivendu Sivadas, a resident of Kerala, filed WP(C) No.15713 of 2024 seeking correction of her date of birth and name in the CBSE records. She states that although born on 15 November 1995, the Secondary School Certificate shows 15 November 1996 and the surname is spelt Sivendu Sivadas. She submitted Ext P1 Birth Certificate, Ext P6 Passport, Ext P14 Aadhaar Card, among other documents, to support a DOB of 15.11.1995. The CBSE rejected the correction, relying on amended Rule 69.1(ii) of the CBSE Examination Bye-laws that allow corrections only within one year of result declaration. The respondents argued that the application was rightly rejected under the amended rule. The court highlighted that a misrecorded DOB would affect the petitioner’s future career and noted that correction of CBSE certificates is governed by the Supreme Court scheme in Jigya Yadav (SC). Accordingly, the court directed the 2nd respondent to consider Exts P15 and P16 for correction in light of the Jigya Yadav scheme, and to decide within two weeks, upon receipt of the application with all supporting documents; the communication dated 01.04.2017 is set aside to enable independent decision. The court emphasized prompt action so that the petitioner can obtain corrected SSC and university certificates for internship in Kerala. The writ petition is disposed of with the above directions.
The Kerala High Court, in a Criminal Miscellaneous Case, considers cancellation of bail under Section 439(2) Cr.P.C. The sole accused, Abhilash, faced offences under IPC Sections 363, 354, and 354A(1)(i) and POCSO Act Sections 8 read with 7 and 12 read with 11(i)(iv)(vi) in Chalakudy Police Station Crime No.460/2021. He was granted bail by the 1st Additional Sessions Court, Thrissur on 17.08.2021, with a condition prohibiting involvement in other offences. The prosecution moved to cancel bail after a new case, Crime No.500/2022, under IPC Section 324, was registered against him for an alleged assault, and the court below cancelled the bail as per Annexure-1. The petitioner seeks to quash that cancellation. The court noted that the subsequent crime is a baillable offence under investigation and not yet finalised, and that the victim in Crime No.500/2022 is not the same as in the original case. It relied on decisions including Godson v. State of Kerala and Rajasthan v. Mubin to emphasize that mere registration of a subsequent crime cannot alone justify bail cancellation, unless it interferes with a fair trial. The High Court ultimately set aside the impugned order, allowing the Crl.M.C., with a caveat that observations regarding the subsequent crime will not affect the ongoing investigation in Crime No.500/2022.
This arbitration petition, filed under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, seeks appointment of a sole arbitrator to adjudicate disputes arising from the reconstitution of the partnership firm M/s Srinivas Rangan & Co., which operated under Bharat Petroleum's licensed dealership. The original partners—K.A. Paul, K.A. Francis, K.A. Raphael and K.A. Joseph—were to govern through Annexure A1; clause 22 provides that any partner disputes should be referred to the Senior Divisional Manager of the petroleum company, and the arbitrator's decision would be final. After the death of K.A. Paul (2011) and K.A. Raphael (2016), the heirs sought reconstitution; Annexure A2 (executed in 2013) was signed with the concurrence of heirs, but its authenticity is disputed by the second respondent, who was not signatory; a criminal complaint (Crime No.2141/2021) was filed. Despite the alleged forgery, the applicants pressed for arbitration citing clause 22 and the need to resolve intra-partner disputes. The respondents conceded to arbitration but contested Annexure A2's validity. The court relied on Vidya Drolia v. Durga Trading Corporation (2021) 2 SCC 1 to hold that a sole arbitrator can decide even fraud allegations, and proceeded to appoint Justice K.T. Shankaran as the sole arbitrator, with Ernakulam as the seat, and with directions on disclosure and fees under the Fourth Schedule.
BAIL APPL. NO. 8835 OF 2021 FIJO, the 3rd accused in Crime No. 705 of 2021 under the NDPS Act, seeks bail under Section 439 CrPC. The prosecution alleges a large quantity of ganja (20.845 kgs) was transported by accused Nos. 1 and 2 in a Mahindra Bolero near Muringoor Chackola Marys Tile Works and that accused Nos. 3 and 4 assisted in financing and coordinating the procurement and transport. Accused Nos. 3 and 4 are said to have stayed in a lodge in Udupi to facilitate the contraband’s procurement, with call details suggesting involvement; however, no contraband is recovered from the petitioner. The applicant contends false implication, claiming innocence and maintaining that the Rs. 5,000 transferred to accused No. 2 was for a joint diary farm business, not the narcotics transaction; he asserts no direct possession or control of the contraband. The State opposes bail, noting the commercial quantity and the petitioner’s alleged participation, alongside a background of 20 other criminal cases and ongoing investigation. Given the commercial quantity under NDPS Act, the court invokes Section 37 and the standard of “reasonable grounds.” It references Union of India v. Shiv Shanker Kesari for the meaning of “reasonable,” Kamla Mills Ltd for interpretation of “reasonable,” and State of Kerala v. Rajesh. The court concludes there are insufficient grounds to grant bail, noting the unsettled investigation and the petitioner’s history, and dismisses the application.
This is an OP (FC) petition challenging whether the Family Court can proceed with guardianship and custody of minor children when interim custody has already been granted by a Magistrate under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (DV Act). The petitioner, Cesil Jesudas, a father, contends that the DV Act interim order (Ext.P1) restraining him from custody should not bar the Family Court from considering his Ext.P3 petition for guardianship/custody. Respondent Sandhya J S opposes, arguing that without challenging Ext.P1, custody before the Family Court cannot be pursued. The court clarifies the distinct, remedial, and supplementary nature of the DV Act, noting that Sections 21–23 empower protective orders and temporary custody while the main adjudication of guardianship/custody lies in the Family Court under the Guardians & Wards Act and the Family Courts Act. The judgment emphasizes that DV proceedings are not a substitute for matrimonial or civil adjudication, and pendency or interim DV orders do not embargo civil or Family Court proceedings. Relying on prior Kerala and Supreme Court decisions, including Narayana Elayathu and Satish Chander Ahuja, the bench holds that Ext.P1 will not bar Ext.P3 and that the Family Court retains jurisdiction over guardianship and custody matters, to be decided in accordance with law. The petition is allowed with directions to proceed with Ext.P3 in the Family Court.
This is a writ appeal (W.A. No. 1588 of 2022) challenging the order in W.P.(C) No. 33526 of 2022 dated 21 October 2022 by which a learned Single Judge of the Kerala High Court declined the reliefs sought by Muhammed Kupparayil, a NEET (UG) 2022 aspirant who sought to be treated as an OBC (Mappila) candidate for counselling under the Medical Counseling Committee. The petitioner scored 110 marks in NEET UG-2022 (out of 720) and applied to correct his communal category after his score card was issued; he contends that he mistakenly filled General category and that he belongs to OBC-Mappila. He highlights that the National Testing Agency issued Public Notice on 24 May 2022 offering a limited correction window (24–27 May 2022) and asserts belated correction would not adversely affect the counselling process, given the rural/background factors and the need for reservation. The respondents argue that sufficient opportunities to correct were provided, the correction window has closed, and altering the list at this stage would disrupt counselling. The Kerala High Court in Karthik B. v. Principal Secretary (W.A. No. 1427 of 2020) was invoked to emphasize strict adherence to the time schedule and that prospectus/notifications bind all. The appeal was dismissed with no costs, upholding the necessity of time-bound corrections and the integrity of the counselling process while noting the Madras High Court’s indulgent stance was not binding.