Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 570 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.A No. 2189 of 2008

Athikka Babu v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal appeal (CRL.A No. 2189 of 2008) preferred by Athikka Babu against a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act, arising from a seizure of 5 litres of illicit arrack on 29.04.2002 at 6:00 p.m. at Kavinmoola, Sivapuram. The accused was initially tried for the offence punishable under Section 55(a) of the Abkari Act and was convicted and sentenced to six months' Rigorous Imprisonment plus a fine of Rs. 1 Lakh by the Additional Sessions Court (Adhoc-III), Thalassery, in Sessions Case No. 677/2003. The High Court’s scrutiny focused on (i) unexplained delay in producing seized properties and samples before the court, (ii) the prosecution’s failure to establish the arrest at the place of occurrence, and (iii) whether the contraband sample reliably linked to the substance tested in the Chemical Examiner’s laboratory. Relying on Ravi v. State of Kerala and Santhosh v. State of Kerala, the court found serious deficiencies in the chain of custody, the seal description and its specimen, and the absence of a satisfactory explanation for delays, casting doubt on the prosecution’s theory. Observing that the sample might not be the same as tested and that a lab report alone cannot be conclusive, the court acquitted the accused. The appeal is thus allowed and the judgment of conviction reversed, with the accused set at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
CRP(WAKF) NO. 8 OF 2016

CRP(WAKF) No. 8 of 2016

CRP(WAKF) No.8 of 2016 arises from a challenge to a decision of the Wakf Tribunal, Kozhikode, in O.S. No.20/2013 concerning a family wakf property. The petitioner, Rukhiya, seeks a declaration that the assignment deed No.1208/07, executed by the first respondent mutawalli, does not bind the plaint schedule property and requests permanent injunction to restrain further dealing on the property. The Wakf Tribunal, after evaluating oral and documentary evidence, held that the plaint schedule property is not a wakf property and dismissed the suit. The revision petition contends that the O.S.41/2009 brought by respondents was filed fraudulently and in collusion, with the petitioner and other heirs not impleaded; hence the judgment in O.S.41/2009 is void ab initio and not binding on them. The respondents maintain that O.S.41/2009 concluded the property was wakf and that its findings have attained finality; they rely on a prior Supreme Court citation, Mayadevi v. Lalta Prasad (AIR 2014 SC 1356), to emphasize due process and binding effect. The High Court, after examining the record, notes that the petitioner and her heirs were parties to the earlier suit, and that its findings cannot automatically bind them. Therefore, the matter must be remitted for fresh disposal to the Wakf Tribunal in accordance with law, with directions to afford both sides full opportunity to adduce evidence and to dispose within six months.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C).No.6435 of 2021

W.P.(C).No.6435 of 2021, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

This is a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution by P. P. Mathai, an occupant of Room No.6 on the first floor of Sumangali Auditorium within the Kavil Bhagavathi Temple premises managed by the Travancore Devaswom Board. The petitioner had been paying a fixed rent of Rs.275 per month and a security deposit of Rs.26,500 since 1997, with the Board annually increasing rent by 10% until 2020. In 2014 the 3rd respondent issued a demand notice for arrears after an alleged retroactive rent revision; Ext.P2 and Ext.P3 reflect representations and notices, and Ext.P4’s 2019 judgment in W.P.(C) No.21665 of 2019 directed consideration of the representation by the Devaswom Commissioner. On 11.12.2020 the Sub Group Officer issued Ext.P5 demanding revised rent of Rs.3,015 per month and a security deposit of Rs.50,000 from 30.09.2020, based on Delhi Schedule of Rates (DSR). The petitioner seeks quashing Ext.P5 and mandamus to fix rent at 10% of the existing rent and to reconsider the security deposit. The respondents contend the Travancore-Cochin Hindu Religious Institutions Act, 1950 requires the Board to protect and augment Devaswom revenue and that redetermination is appropriate using market-based rates, relying on several precedents. The court examined extensive statutory provisions (Parts I–III) of the Act, related sections (3, 4, 15, 15A, 16, 24, 27, 31) and Trusts Act provisions (49, 51, 52), plus dicta on fiduciary duties and parens patriae. Following decisions such as Abu K.S., T. Krishnakumar, Suneesh K.S., H.N. Vijayan, and V. Muraleedharan Nair, the court directed refixation of rent at market value with due process and board approval. The petition was disposed with no costs.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.1118 of 2022

Manager, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Company Limited v Reji Thomas and Others

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA No.1118 of 2022) from Kerala High Court, challenging an award of Rs.31,70,000 plus interest and costs by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal-I, Pathanamthitta in OP(MV) 186/2019, arising out of a fatal road accident on 9 January 2019 involving a motorcycle KL-03/AA 7619 and a lorry TN82/Y 3607. The petitioners (respondents in the MACA) claimed compensation for the death of 21-year-old Robin Reji, alleged to be a mechanical engineer by profession with a notional income of Rs.20,000 per month. The insurer (applicant) contested liability, arguing contributory negligence, disputed the decedent’s income and age, and challenged the Tribunal’s findings. The Tribunal held the driver negligent (Ext A6) and conducted evidence-based assessment, fixing the decedent’s notional income at Rs.20,000 per month and awarding Rs.31,70,000 with interest and costs. On appeal, the insurer challenged (i) contributory negligence, (ii) the notional income, and (iii) the interest rate of 8%. The High Court, after examining Ext A6 and applicable precedents (including Basanti Devi, Zuhara Razak, and other SC/High Court decisions), affirmed the Tribunal’s approach, rejected the insurer’s grounds, and dismissed the appeal. The court emphasized the doctrine of reasonable, discretionary assessment in compensation and that charge-sheets can constitute evidence of negligence in the absence of contrary evidence.

High Court of Kerala
WA NO. 448 OF 2022

Muhammed Iqbal Layina Kilillath v Union of India and The Passport Officer, Sub Regional Passport Office Kannur

This writ appeal arises from WP(C) 3931 of 2021, challenging the Regional Passport Office’s decision regarding correction of the appellant’s personal particulars in Passport No. Z 2365772. The petitioner, Muhammed Iqbal Layina Kilillath, an NRI, claims the passport erroneously records his name as Mohamed Iqbal Shahad Ali, with a date of birth of 01.01.1962 and his father’s name as Machairy Shahad Ali, whereas Exts P2–P5 (birth certificate, school certificate, Aadhaar, PAN) establish the correct identity: Muhammed Iqbal Layina Kilillath, DOB 24.01.1968, father’s name Machery Shaduli. The petitioner contends that correcting these details is essential for his employment abroad, where service terms hinge on accurate DOB, and that Ext P6 represents a pending request for re-issuance. The High Court’s writ court had dismissed the petition on the grounds that corrections are multifarious and require a decree or cogent proof, urging the petitioner to pursue civil remedies. The appellant contests this, arguing the Passport Authority should decide the pending Ext P6 application in accordance with statutory provisions. Respondents rely on prior precedents (Vasu Sasi and Jayakumar) to contend that passport details cannot be lightly interfered with and corrections after a long delay require strict justification. The High Court ultimately sets aside the dismissal and directs the Passport Officer to consider Ext P6 within two weeks, clarifying that the civil-court route is not essential and that the decision will be governed by statutory provisions and applicable circulars.

High Court of Kerala
RCRev. No.135 of 2024

Soopi Kutty v. V.M Hameed

This is a Rent Control Revision under Section 20 of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, challenging the eviction orders in a shop premises case in Kasaragod. The revision petitioner, Soopi Kutty, claimed tenancy of shop No. M.G.P. X-454 from 2008 and contended that rent arrears were not proven or were paid up to February 2019; he argued that the landlord’s claim of bona fide need was not genuine and that the landlord’s daughter’s supposed dependency did not justify eviction. The respondent-landlord, V.M. Hameed, asserted arrears from February 2017 and sought eviction under Section 11(2)(b). He also claimed a bona fide need in view of his daughter returning from abroad and requiring a plywood showroom for her and her husband who presently lack employment. The Principal Munsiff’s Court, Kasaragod, by order dated 19.02.2021, held eviction warranted under both sections and rejected the tenant’s evidence. The Rent Control Appellate Authority confirmed the eviction in its 29.11.2023 order. The High Court, in revision, cautioned against re‑appreciation of evidence under Section 20 and relied on established principles from appellate precedents. While upholding eviction on merits, the Court dismissed the revision petition and granted the tenant seven months to vacate, with conditions including an undertaking, arrears deposit, and continued rent payment; failure to comply would revert to eviction enforcement.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev Nos. 84/2018; 75/2018; 78/2018; 77/2018; 79/2018; 80/2018; 82/2018; 81/2018; 86/2018; 91/2018; 92/2018; 94/2018

State of Kerala v Raphel T. Joseph

These OT Revision petitions arise from a common order of the Kerala Value Added Tax Appellate Tribunal dated 5 March 2018 in T.A.(VAT) No. 564 of 2014 and Cross Objection Nos. 2 of 2016, challenging the scope of reassessment under Section 25 KVAT Act, 2003. The petitions involve the State (Revenue) challenging the Tribunal’s interpretation of reassessment powers in cases of escape assessment, under‑assessment, or misapplication of the compounding scheme. The High Court, after reference from a Division Bench due to conflicting opinions in C.C. Sebastian v State of Kerala and State of Kerala v Muhammed Ali A.M. (2017) 25 KTR 73, referred the matter to a Full Bench. The Full Bench held that Section 25 provides for several independent contingencies allowing reassessment, including cases where a dealer accepts a compounding rate of tax under Section 8 but where misrepresentation or erroneous facts exist, and that such reassessments can be initiated even while a compounding arrangement exists. It overruled the proposition laid down in A.M. Muhammed Ali as incorrect, and held that the powers under Sections 25, 56 and 66 are separate and independently conferred to prevent revenue loss. The Court remitted the matter to the Tribunal to decide on merits, preferably within four months, and the revision petitions were allowed to set aside the Tribunal’s order. The decision reaffirms Revenue’s power to reopen assessments under Section 25 in appropriate circumstances.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) 74 of 2022

State of Kerala represented by the Secretary, General Education Department, Government Secretariat, Thiruvananthapuram v A.O Jayakumar

This High Court of Kerala (Division Bench) heard an original petition (OP(KAT) 74 of 2022) filed by the State challenging a Kerala Administrative Tribunal (KAT) order dated 4 February 2021 in OA No. 963 of 2017. The Tribunal had directed the Government to declare the probation of a retired Education Department Accounts Officer who had, during service, been promoted to Administrative Assistant, with effect from 18 May 2010, and to finalize any disciplinary proceedings and grant revised pay and pensionary benefits. The applicant retired on 30 September 2015. The key chronology involves the promotion and probation period ending in 2010, a recommendation for probation sent on 3 March 2012, but DPI forwarding only in 2015, and five disciplinary proceedings against the officer in 2013. The Government, by order dated 12 November 2015, refused to declare probation. The Tribunal held that the delay by the DPI and the Government’s inaction justified consideration only in 2015 and directed fresh orders declaring probation from 18 May 2010, with disciplinary actions concluded within two months and consequential pay adjustments. The State argued that delay cannot create a right to probation and relied on T. Thankachan v. State of Kerala. The High Court upheld the Tribunal’s order, dismissed the petition, and directed the Government to issue a formal order declaring probation from 18 May 2010 with all consequential steps to follow.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No.334 of 2021

Aralam Grama Panchayat represented by its Secretary v. Raju Joseph and Others

The Aralam Grama Panchayat, as petitioner, challenged the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s Ext.P4 order in OA EK(M) 221/2021, which held that regularisation of temporary daily-wage drivers across local bodies could not be granted since they were engaged against no sanctioned posts. The Tribunal directed that transparent, objective guidelines be framed for appointment of temporary drivers to prevent complaints about the selection process, including minimum qualifications, age, notification publication, a structured selection process with driving proficiency assessment, interview weight, selection-board composition, minimum tenure, re-notification, disengagement procedures, and eligibility of long-serving drivers. Aralam Panchayat contended that such stringent norms would hinder short-term engagements and urge continuation of the current interim arrangement while the selection process is set in motion. The High Court, while acknowledging the need for transparent norms in recurring appointments, found some Tribunal directives untenable and proceeded to modify them. It directed the Director of Panchayats to frame a scheme within a defined period (four months) and to ensure that the skill test for drivers is conducted by the Motor Vehicle Inspector, with a limited interview component and a board-based assessment. It also permitted continued service of the present daily-wage driver until the new process is completed and disposed the petition accordingly, thereby balancing administrative practicality with merit-based selection.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 6040 OF 2016

Sabu M. Jacob v. State of Kerala and The Inspector of Factories and Boilers, Perumbavoor

This criminal miscellaneous petition, filed by the Managing Director of Kitex Garments Limited, seeks to quash a complaint pending before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kolenchery, arising from an accident at the factory on 24 May 2014 that resulted in the death of an employee. The prosecution alleges contraventions of the Factories Act, 1948 (sections 7A(1); 7A(2)(b); 7A(2)(d); and section 92) and related Kerala Factories Rules (Rule 81D; Rule 123(1)). The core issue is whether the petitioner, as Managing Director, can be treated as the occupier under the deeming provision in section 2(n) of the Act, thereby making him liable under section 92. The petitioner contends that vicarious liability cannot be imported into criminal prosecution and that there is no specific nomination showing him as occupier; Annexure A3 (Form 18) naming another person as occupier is a post-accident document and cannot determine the occupier as on the accident date. The State counters that any director may be deemed occupier under section 2(n), and the sanction for prosecution was rightly issued. The court ultimately dismisses the criminal‑miscellaneous case, leaving open the question of occupier status to be determined during trial, due to evidentiary questions and the statutory deeming provision.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 10612 OF 2024 & con.cases

In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam - WP(C) No. 10612 of 2024 & connected cases

The judgment addresses a batch of writ petitions (WP(C) 10612 of 2024 and connected matters) wherein account-holders challenged freezing of their bank accounts following police intimation in cybercrime investigations. The Kerala High Court, presided by Justice T.R. Ravi, notes that accounts had been frozen by banks on police directions from various regions, causing substantial hardship to petitioners. The Court invokes and extrapolates the directions from the decision in Dr. Sajeer v RBI (2023 KHC Online 661), directing banks to confine freezes strictly to the amount mentioned in the police requisition and to permit normal transactions beyond that limit. It also requires police authorities to inform banks about the continuation and duration of the freeze (up to eight months as per the cited precedent) and leaves open the petitioners’ rights to approach the Court if information is not provided. The Court thereby disposes of the petitions with directions to balance investigative needs with the petitioners’ financial operations, emphasizing that freezes must be proportionate and time-bound. The order consolidates the approach for all connected petitions and closes the batch with a directive to banks and police to comply with these constraints, while preserving rights to contest further if required.

High Court of Kerala
2072/2021; 15244/2021; 16281/2021; 17686/2021; 18260/2021

WP(C) Nos. 2072/2021, 15244/2021, 16281/2021, 17686/2021 & 18260/2021

These batch writ petitions originate from petitions challenging the mode of solemnisation of marriages under the Special Marriage Act, 1954, and whether it can be effected via video conferencing. The High Court of Kerala, in a reference from a learned Single Judge, examines whether online solemnisation is permissible in light of Sections 11–13 of the Act, which ordinarily require declaration before the Marriage Officer, a designated place, and the presence of three witnesses, with a formal certificate upon completion. Earlier Kerala decisions (Dioncey Augustine and Shitha V.K.) held that physical presence was mandatory; but the court reconsiders these views in the context of evolving technology and statutory interpretation. The court surveys Section 12(2) (form/place of solemnisation) and the proviso mandating an exchange of words in the presence of the Marriage Officer and witnesses, and reasoned that solemnisation can be effected by exchange of words, potentially through videoconferencing, particularly when supported by modern communication tech and electronic records under the Information Technology Act, 2000 (Section 10A, Section 6). Relying on Mathew T.K. and other authorities, and invoking the doctrine of updating construction for ongoing statutes, the court holds that online solemnisation is permissible, subject to safeguards. Consequently, the court makes its interim order absolute and directs the State to follow these directions.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5321 OF 2024

Deb Prasad Mukhergee v. State of Kerala

This is a bail petition filed under section 439 CrPC by Deb Prasad Mukhergee, the sole accused in Crime No. 295/2024 of Rajakkad Police Station, Idukki, for alleged rape of the victim on 18.04.2024, offences under IPC sections 376(1) and 376(2)(f). The accused, relative of the victim’s husband, was arrested on 12.05.2024 and has since been in judicial custody for over two months. The investigation reportedly is complete, the medical examinations have been conducted, and the final report was laid on 03.07.2024. The petitioner contends innocence and lack of material tying him to the acts, urging that continued detention is unnecessary given absence of criminal antecedents. The State/Prosecutor opposes bail, arguing the offences are heinous and there is a real risk of intimidation, witness tampering, and interference with evidence if released. The court anchors its decision in established bail principles from Dataram Singh and State of Kerala v. Raneef, Hussainara Khatoon I, and the Article 21 framework, emphasizing that bail is the rule and jail is the exception, and that rights of the accused must be balanced with public interest. Considering the two months’ custody, completed investigation, final report, and lack of prior convictions, the judge allows bail subject to conditions including a Rs.1,00,000 bond with two solvent sureties, regular appearances, non-inducement of witnesses, travel restrictions, passport surrender, reporting requirements, and potential for cancellation on breach. The order clarifies that these observations pertain to the bail petition only and do not decide merits of the case.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No. 2855/2023 (Batch including Nos. 2867/2023 and 3910/2023)

W.P.(C) No. 2855/2023 & batch (including WP(C) Nos. 2867/2023 and 3910/2023)

This batch of connected writ petitions arises from Mahatma Gandhi University’s Kalolsavam selection processes for the intercollegiate Youth Festival scheduled from 08.02.2023 to 12.02.2023. Petitioners B. Malavika Namboothiri (2855/2023), Athulya Sunil (2867/2023), and Michael Joe Francis (3910/2023) allege that intra-college performances at Sacred Hearts College, Thevara, were unfairly evaluated and that time allotted for performances contravened guidelines. They contend that Kerala Natanam and related events entailed longer durations (15 minutes per participant per university guidelines; college rules prescribe 10 minutes) but participants were accorded only about 4 minutes, hampering their ability to perform and be assessed fairly for selection to the intercollegiate festival and potential Kalathilakam designation. They assert grievances regarding the evaluation process and seek relief, including re-evaluation or admission to higher levels. The respondents—Mahatma Gandhi University (MGU), the Kalolsavam Organising Committee, and the Grievance Redressal Committee of Sacred Hearts College—contest that time limits in intra-college events are not binding on colleges and that the judges’ evaluations are final. The Court ultimately held there was no mala fides or arbitrariness warranting interference under Article 226, dismissed the petitions, and urged measures to prevent mishaps in future Kalolsavams while emphasizing the festival’s spirit of healthy competition.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4760 OF 2008 & CRL.MC NO. 4869 OF 2008

Crl.M.C. No. 4760 of 2008 & Crl.M.C. No. 4869 of 2008

Two criminal miscellaneous petitions under Section 482 CrPC to quash FIR No. 534/2008 of Kollengode Police Station, and the related proceedings arising from alleged forged documents of title to 430 acres of land vested with the Government under the Ecologically Fragile Land (EFL) regime. The petitioners include accused 1–5 (the prior owners who held 550 acres of cardamom plantation) and accused 6 (the later purchaser). The litigation traverses decades: a Forest Tribunal found 530 acres not private forest but cardamom plantations; the Supreme Court affirmed restoration of possession to the prior owners; subsequently, the State enacted the Ecologically Fragile Land Ordinance, 2000 vesting land with the Government, later codified in the EFL Act, 2003. A notification vesting 430 acres was challenged, but WA/2012 (Division Bench) declared the notification void and restoration of the property to the owners; the Court held the vesting notifications could not stand and title as on the date of notification remained with the owners. The petitioners contend the FIR is an abuse of process in light of those decisions and vesting illegality; the State argues the crime was registered when land lay with the Government and that forging titles is criminal. The Kerala High Court quashes the FIR as abuse of process, relies on Bhajan Lal and binding precedents, and follows the Division Bench decision. The petitions are allowed; the FIR is quashed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 295 OF 2023

Sulochanan V.S. v. Rahul Raj R. and Beena R.C.

This High Court of Kerala, in OP(C) No. 295 of 2023, questions Ext.P7, the order passed in RP No.16/2023 in IA No.11/2022 in OP(Election) No.1/2021, by the Principal Munsiff, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioner, Sulochanan V.S., a returned candidate from Ambalathara Ward 67 in the Thiruvananthapuram Corporation election held on 8 December 2020, challenges the election petition outcome on grounds of alleged violations of the Kerala Municipalities Act, 1994. The 1st respondent, a local voter, filed OP(Election) No.1/2021 seeking to declare the petitioner’s election void; the 2nd respondent sought impleadment as an additional respondent (IA 11/2022) and sought correction (IA 12/2023). The court below allowed IA 11/2022 (Ext.P5). The petitioner moved for review (RP 16/2023; Ext.P6), which was dismissed by Ext.P7. The High Court found that Section 166 of the Kerala Municipalities Act requires only the petitioner and the contesting candidate (and related statutory parties) to be joined; the 1st respondent is a voter, not a contesting candidate, and the 2nd respondent cannot seek relief via impleadment after not challenging the election herself, contrary to the statute. Relying on Sudhamayee Pattnaik v. Bibhu Prasad Sahoo and Jyoti Basu v. Debi Ghosal, the court held that election disputes are statutory rights. Consequently, Ext.P5 and Ext.P7 were set aside, Ext.P4 was dismissed, and the trial court was directed to dispose OP(Election) No.1/2021 expeditiously in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 5662 OF 2021

CRL.MC NO. 5662 OF 2021

In CRL.MC 5662/2021, the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, presided over by a Single Judge, considers a criminal miscellaneous case filed to quash proceedings arising from Crime No.1913/2019 of the Museum Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, which is pending as CP No.24/2021 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court III, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners are accused Nos. 1 and 2; the 2nd respondent is the victim. The offences alleged against the 1st petitioner include Sections 376, 313 and 506 read with 34 IPC. The prosecution contends that, after a false promise of marriage, the petitioner had sexual intercourse with the victim on several occasions and later reneged; the victim allegedly became pregnant and aborted the pregnancy. The petitioners’ counsel submits that even on face value of the FIR and investigation, there is no offence under Section 376 IPC, as the relationship appears consensual and the 1st petitioner was a married man known to the 2nd respondent. The Public Prosecutor argues that the statements are sufficient to attract 376, 313 and 506 IPC and that Section 482 Cr.P.C cannot be invoked if a prima facie case exists. After a detailed scrutiny, the Court finds no basis to attract 376, 313, 312 or 506 IPC. It notes the live-in relationship, lack of force, and that the promise of marriage to a married woman is not enforceable under law; it relies on Renjith v. State of Kerala and XXX v. State of Kerala. The petition is allowed and all further proceedings are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 27594/2021; 27569/2021; 27529/2021

W.P.(C) Nos. 27594/2021, 27569/2021 and 27529/2021, High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These connected writ petitions challenge notices issued under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act. The petitioners contend that after the Finance Act, 2021, which amended Section 148 and introduced Section 148A, the Department must follow the new procedure before initiating reassessment proceedings. The petitions were aligned with the Supreme Court’s decision in Union of India v. Ashish Agarwal (2022) 444 ITR 1 (SC), wherein the Court held that reassessment notices issued under the unamended Section 148 are to be treated as show-cause notices under Section 148A(b), with the assessing officer required to furnish the information relied upon and give the assessees a short response window. The Supreme Court also held that a one-time enquiry with prior approval under Section 148A(a) is not mandatory for all such notices, though a department may conduct enquiry if necessary. The Kerala High Court, noting the Department’s concession that the Ashish Agarwal decision covers these matters, disposed of the petitions by directing that Section 148 notices shall be treated as show-cause notices under Section 148A, with proceedings to be completed in accordance with the Supreme Court’s directions. Exhibits and Bombay High Court references are appended and illustrate the notices and interim orders involved. The decision harmonizes post-2021 reassessment procedures with existing rights under the Finance Act 2021.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 27738 of 2009

Lalan P.R. and Aysha v. Chief Registrar General of Marriages (Common) and Local Registrar of Marriages (Common) (Secretary, Corporation of Cochin)

The petitioners, Lalan P.R. (Hindu by birth) and Aysha (whose mother is Muslim) married in 2001 according to Hindu rites and sought registration under the Kerala Registration of Marriages (Common) Rules, 2008. The Local Registrar of Marriages (Common) refused registration, saying registration under the Rules requires solemnization under personal laws or statutory provisions, effectively excluding marriages where one party’s religion differs. The petition challenged Ext. P4, arguing that Rule 6 mandates compulsory registration of all marriages solemnized in the State irrespective of religion, and that mere non-conformity with a listed personal law should not bar registration when solemnization has occurred. The Court examined Rule 6, its provisos, and the purpose of the Rules, emphasizing that solemnization means celebration with proper ceremonies and due form, and that registration under the Rules is not proof of a valid marriage but has evidentiary value for issues like custody and age. Relying on Seema v. Ashwani Kumar and subsequent judgments (including Bhaurao Lokhande, Rajeeve, Deepu Dev, and Sabu K. Eliyas), the Court held that marriages solemnized per Hindu rites can be registered under Rules 2008 irrespective of religion if proof of solemnization is provided (Form I/II). Ext. P4 was set aside and directions issued to register within a short time upon proper declarations; a circular to reflect the ruling was to be issued.

High Court of Kerala
CRP No. 71 of 2018

M.A. Abdul Rahiman and others v. Hassanathul Juma Masjid and others

This civil revision petition arises from proceedings where a Wakf landowner sued to recover possession of a 3-cent plot in Kasaragod, claiming the building thereon was let on ground rent. The defendants claimed kudikidappu rights (tenancy) and produced a Land Tribunal purchase certificate. The Munsiff dismissed the suit; on appeal, the Sub Court held that the certificate not binding on the Wakf; the High Court in RSA proceedings left open the question and directed fixation of value in the execution proceedings. The Land Tribunal later found that the defendants had no kudikidappu right in RS 51/19 Kasaba, Kasaragod; it valued the building at Rs. 51,285, later enhanced to Rs. 1,97,250, with the decree directing surrender of vacant possession for that amount. The revision petition contends that the Land Tribunal committed illegality by denying kudikidappu, relying on Section 125(3) of the Land Reforms Act and the definitions of kudikidappu in Section 2(25). The court observed that the essential difference between hut and homestead under Section 2(25) governs kudikidappu; the hut threshold of Rs. 750 construction cost and Rs. 5 monthly rent is relevant only to huts; homesteads have no such restriction. The court found the petitioners were not in possession and relied on inconsistencies in their pleadings; thus the revision petition was dismissed, upholding the Land Tribunal and executing court orders.