Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 558 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 435 OF 2017

Sherifa Cherukunhi Beevi v. Sherifa Sainaba Beevi, Syed Liyakkathali Pookoya Thangal and State of Kerala (CRL.REV.PET NO. 435 OF 2017)

This is a criminal revision petition filed under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, challenging the dismissal of an appeal by the Sessions Court in Crl.Appeal No.418 of 2016 arising from MC No.38 of 2009 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kozhikode. The first respondent (wife) had sought protections and a right to reside in a shared household against her husband (the second respondent) and the mother-in-law (the revision petitioner). The Magistrate found that the Pallipuram residence, where the wife and her daughter resided, was owned by the revision petitioner, not the husband, and directed the husband to secure alternate accommodation with facilities matching those available at Pallipuram within three months. The Sessions Court dismissed the appeal for delay, with delay of 1068 days. During settlement discussions, the husband indicated willingness to provide alternate accommodation; a new two-storey building was constructed about 650 metres away and found to have road access, electricity, water, and other facilities per a Commissioner’s report. The High Court allowed the revision petition, quashing the Sessions Court’s dismissal, and directed the first respondent to vacate Pallipuram and occupy the new dwelling by 28.02.2022.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 2979 of 2023

Varkey Mathew v. Oriental Insurance Co., Ltd.

The Kerala High Court, in MACA No. 2979 of 2023, reviews an appeal by the claimant seeking enhanced compensation from an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Muvattupuzha, dated 10 March 2023 in O.P.(M.V.) No.600/2020. The appellant, Var key Mathew, represented by his wife as next friend and legal guardian, sustained serious injuries in a motor accident on 21 February 2020 when car KL-17-Q-1631 hit an autorickshaw KL-36-C-3360 at Peringazhakkavala. The Tribunal found the accident occurred due to rash driving by the car driver and awarded ₹12,65,200 with 8% interest from the date of petition and proportionate costs. The 1st respondent driver-owner did not contest (ex parte); the 2nd respondent insurer admitted coverage but challenged the claimed age, occupation, income and injuries, deeming the amount exorbitant. On appeal, the High Court reexamined evidence: Ext.A12 (driving licence) supports occupation as a driver, leading to a higher monthly income of ₹15,000; Ext.C1 shows 77% permanent disability, but the Tribunal treated 100% occupational disability for compensation purposes. The Court follows Kajal v. Jagdish Chand for bystander expenses, recalculating and awarding an additional ₹2,90,000 with 7.5% interest from filing till realization, payable within two months. The appeal is allowed, and the Tribunal’s award is enhanced accordingly, with MACA so ordered.

High Court of Kerala
TR.P(C) NO. 174 OF 2021

Kala Nasarudheen v. Fashana P, Haroon Al Rasheed and Abdul Jaleel

Kala Nasarudheen filed TR.P(C) 174 of 2021 under Section 24 CPC seeking to transfer OP 689/2019 from the Family Court, Malappuram, to the Family Court, Palakkad. She is the mother of respondents 2 and 3; the first respondent is the wife of the second respondent. The marital relationship between respondents 1 and 2 is strained, and Annexure A1 has been filed against the petitioner and respondents 2 and 3 seeking return of gold ornaments, along with money, movable property and past maintenance. The petitioner asserts that her health is poor and that she cannot travel the long distance from Palakkad to Malappuram to contest Annexure A1, making transfer desirable for her comfort and expedition. The first respondent counters that Annexure A1 seeks relief beyond ornaments—money, movable articles and past maintenance—and that personal appearance of the petitioner is not strictly necessary, especially since the dispute is primarily between respondents 1 and 2; travel distance would be over 100 km, and there is an earlier Family Court proceeding (MC 359/2019). The court cites Supreme Court precedents emphasizing that, in matrimonial transfers, the convenience of the woman and children governs the decision, and the law in this area is settled. After considering pleadings, the judge finds the petitioner’s hardship can be alleviated without requiring personal appearance and, therefore, refuses to transfer. The order directs expeditious disposal by the Malappuram FC and limits compulsory appearance to necessity.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 907 of 2015

Henry and Annie v. K.L. Thomas

Henry and Annie, the appellants/defendants, challenge a judgment arising from a suit by K. L. Thomas, who claimed absolute ownership of plaint A schedule property containing two buildings. The dispute centers on a concrete road connected to the plaint A schedule property via plaint B schedule, used by residents on both sides for ingress and egress. In 2001, the 1st defendant executed Ext. A6, a consent letter in favour of the plaintiff authorising use of a portion of his property as a passage, specifying a width of 30 cm from the south-east boundary and 80 cm from the south-west boundary of building 65/70. The plaintiff contends Ext. A6 creates an easement by grant and seeks protection of vehicular access to the plaint A schedule through plaint B. The defendants maintain that the consent letter is not registered and that the plaintiff is entitled to use only the widths stated, and that no easement by grant exists. A Commission report (Exts. C1/C2) was filed; the trial court dismissed the suit and counter claim; on appeal, the first appellate court partly decreed the relief, restraining interference with vehicular access through the B schedule area and prohibiting certain constructions, while excluding portions overlapped by the defendants’ building. In the second appeal, the Kerala High Court held Ext. A6 does not amount to relinquishment requiring registration and affirmed the appellate decree; the appeal was dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 35151 OF 2011

Janatha Tile Works Ltd. v. Employees' Provident Fund Organisation & Ors.

This writ petition challenges the orders imposing damages under Sections 7Q and 14B of the Employees Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, for default in remittance of employees’ provident fund contributions. The petitioner, a tile-manufacturing unit, contends it was declared a sick unit and put through industrial revival measures; subsequent activity suggested the company survived post-land sale but was run by workers, yet the authorities did not consider pleadings for relief under sick-unit provisions. Exts.P2, P2(a) (Assessing Officer) and Ext.P4 (Appellate Tribunal) are attacked as unsustainable in law, and similar grounds were raised in a prior writ petition (W.P. No. 21617 of 2007). The respondents maintain that the second proviso to Section 14B contemplates relief only for sick industrial companies registered with BIFR and where a rehabilitation scheme is sanctioned; they argue that, after admission of liability following land sale, damages under 7Q and 14B are inevitable, supported by jurisprudence including the Supreme Court’s Horticulture Experiment Station decision (LiveLaw 2022). The High Court found no illegality in the orders and dismissed the petition, while noting the absence of documentary evidence of BIFR rehabilitation and the lack of a registered scheme. Interim relief granted by this Court was vacated.

High Court of Kerala
OT.Rev Nos. 63/2021 and 74/2021

M/S P.M.KELUKUTTY AND BROTHERS ENGINEERING CONTRACTORS v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court hearing two connected Tax Revision petitions (OT.Rev Nos. 63/2021 and 74/2021) challenging the Kerala VAT Appellate Tribunal’s orders in TA (VAT) Nos. 238/2017 and 239/2017. The petitioner, M/S P.M. Kelukutty and Brothers Engineering Contractors, is engaged in civil and electrical works in a Special Economic Zone (SEZ) developed by ULCCS under a subcontracting arrangement, and seeks exemption under Section 6(7)(b) of the KVAT Act on sale of building materials and related inputs to the SEZ developer. The Tribunal denied the exemption, prompting the revision petitions. The revision petitions raise whether the proviso inserted by the Kerala Finance Act, 2014 to Section 6(7)(b) is curative and retrospective, extending the exemption to works contracts performed through sub-contractors. The arguments invoke statutory interpretation principles regarding provisos, including traditional rules that a proviso both qualifies and can alter the main enactment, and whether certain amendments can be declaratory or curative. The court surveys Union of India v VKC Footsteps India Pvt. Ltd, Allied Motors, Vatika Township, and Sundaram Pillai among others, concluding that the 2014 proviso is curative in nature and retroactive. Consequently, the revisions are allowed, the Tribunal’s orders are set aside, and the matters are remitted to the Tribunal for fresh merits.

High Court of Kerala
OP (FC) Nos. 173/2022, 180/2022, 181/2022, 182/2022

Neethu I.S. v. Sajesh Babu B.

Four connected Original Petitions (OP (FC) Nos. 173/2022, 180/2022, 181/2022, 182/2022) are before the Kerala High Court at Ernakulam from the Nedumangad Family Court. The petitions, filed by Neethu I.S. and, in 180/2022, Indira, challenge orders of the Family Court Nedumangad and seek early disposal of their matrimonial matters pending before the Family Court. The matter was admitted on 27 May 2022 along with connected cases, and the High Court requested remarks from the Presiding Officer. The Presiding Officer reported that a joint trial was allowed on 20 April 2022; however, there is no explicit record on whether the early hearing petition has been allowed or rejected. The High Court, noting the absence of a conclusive finding on early disposal, disposed of the petitions by leaving the issue to the Family Court and directed that the Family Court decide the early disposal petition in accordance with the Division Bench judgment of this Court in Shiju Joy v. Nisha (2021 (2) KLT 607). The judgments emphasize timely resolution and direct the Family Court Nedumangad to proceed in conformity with the cited precedent. The order also records that the joint trial has been permissible and that the Family Court should pass appropriate orders on the early hearing petition in line with the cited Division Bench ruling, thereby ensuring acceleration of the proceedings while preserving due process for the parties.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev. No.336 of 2019

POOMANGALORAKATH KAPPALLI SUBAIR and POOMANGALORAKATH KAPPALLI MUJIB RAHMAN v. MEETHALE PURAYIL SUHARA

This Kerala High Court revision challenges an eviction order under Sections 11(2)(b), 11(4)(i), and 11(8) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, in a matter concerning a ground-floor shop in a double-storey building. The Rent Control Court dismissed eviction on all three grounds, while the Appellate Authority reversed, ordering eviction under all heads. The tenants contended that rent was paid since August 2003 and receipts were not consistently given by the landlady; they argued absence of receipts should not automatically lead to arrears and that they had not sub-let the premises. They also submitted that the business conducted by the tenants was not clearly shown to be sub-letting, and that licensing evidence was lacking. The landlady argued that rent remained unpaid since August 2003, that the tenants had effectively sub-let to Nazar, and that there was a bona fide need for additional space for her adjoining business, supported by an Advocate Commissioner’s report and documentary material, including a certificate from a local traders’ body. The High Court, after analyzing the evidence and relying on established authorities, held that arrears may include time-barred amounts for eviction, that sub-letting was established, and that the landlady’s need was bona fide, ultimately dismissing the revision petition and upholding the Appellate Authority’s order.

High Court of Kerala
WA NO. 1356 OF 2021

HaneeFa v. M. Vijayan and The Secretary, Regional Transport Authority cum Regional Transport Officer, Malappuram & Kozhikode

The Writ Appeal (WA No.1356 of 2021) challenges a 22 September 2020 order in WP(C) No.19439/2020 issued by the Kerala High Court. HaneeFa, a 3rd party/appealant, is an existing stage carriage permit holder on route Alinchuvadu–Kozhikode (KL-55/M-5816). The petition sought mandamus to dispose of a representation for revision of timings within a month, proposing a timing conference and hearing. The original WP(C) directed provisional timing revisions after obtaining a report from the AMVI so as not to clash with other services, while reserving the final settlement of timings for a formal conference. The grounds of the WA argue that provisional revision of timings when a settled timetable exists violates Rule 212 of the Kerala Motor Vehicles Rules and older Kerala High Court precedents (1968 KLT 73; 1973 KLT 266), Krishnankutty v. John (1992 KLT 883) and Joji Edattel v. Secretary, KTA (2004 KLT 493). They also rely on prior W.A. decisions (W.A.No.936/2021) to press for compliance with rules and fair hearing for all operators. The respondents’ counsel contends that revision is necessary to avoid clashes and ensure public convenience, and that provisional adjustments may be permissible pending final settlement, with due notice and hearing.

High Court of Kerala
RP No. 869 of 2022 in RFA No. 40 of 2012

Chembukandy Saffiya v. C. Abdul Aziz and others (RP No. 869 of 2022 in RFA No. 40 of 2012)

This Review Petition, filed by Chembukandy Saffiya, challenges the Kerala High Court’s 5 July 2022 judgment in RFA No. 40 of 2012, which disposed of an appeal concerning partition and release deeds relating to the property involved. The impugned judgment held that by executing Ext. P1 release deed along with her children, the petitioner and her children had ratified Ext. P2 partition deed and, relying on authorities cited in paragraph 42, that they were estopped from challenging the validity of Ext. B2 partition deed. The petitioner contends that the court erred in applying estoppel to minors and that Ext. B2 is void ab initio, rendering any ratification invalid. The petition also invokes Order XLVII, Rule 1 CPC and relies on classic formulations on the scope of judicial review, including Moran Mar Baselios Catholicos v. Most Rev. Mar Poulose Athanasius (AIR 1954 SC 526), Lily Thomas v. Union of India (AIR 2000 SC 1650), Parsion Devi v. Sumitri Devi (SC), and Aribam Tuleshwar Sharma v. Aribam Pishak Sharma (AIR 1979 SC 1047), to argue that review is limited to correcting errors apparent on the face of the record or discovering new matter, not as a substitute for an appeal. The Court ultimately dismissed the review petition, holding no merit, and closed any pending interlocutory applications.

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.1119/2023

Debati Majhi v. State of Kerala

Debati Majhi, the 6th accused in Crime No.3/2022 of Railway Police Palakkad, seeks regular bail under Section 439 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The contraband seized at Palakkad Railway Station on 10 February 2022 was 46.686 kg of ganja, alleged to be in possession of the applicant and other accused, leading to offences under Sections 22(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the NDPS Act. The State contends that the offence involves a commercial quantity and thus Section 37 of the NDPS Act applies, requiring the court to be satisfied of ‘reasonable grounds’ to believe the accused is not guilty and that he will not commit any offence while on bail. The applicant argues humanitarian considerations, highlighting that his daughter is a person with disability, supported by Annexure-1 (Unique Disability ID). He has remained in custody since 10.02.2022, and the matter is pending in Sessions Court, Palakkad, with the charge sheet filed. The Public Prosecutor submits that bail cannot be granted in a commercial quantity case. The High Court reiterates that in NDPS cases involving commercial quantity, Section 37 should be read with two conjunctive conditions, and the rider cannot be diluted for humanitarian grounds. Citing Union of India v. Shiv Shankar Kesari and subsequent authorities, the court concludes there are no reasonable grounds to grant bail and dismisses the petition. The order underscores that bail is not a pronouncement of guilt and requires careful appraisal of grounds.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2367 OF 2007

A.P. Krishnan v. State of Kerala

This criminal appeal challenges the conviction and sentence recorded by the Additional Sessions Court, Fast Track-III, Palakkad, in SC No.299/2005, under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act, which imposed three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs.1,00,000 on the appellant. The prosecution case, based on seizure of about 4 litres of illicit arrack on 25.02.2002 at Ottappalam, was supported by PWs 1–5 and Exhibits P1–P7 and MO1. After trial, the appellant was convicted, while the defense offered denial under Section 313 Cr.P.C. The principal issues raised in the appeal concern the integrity of the evidentiary chain: whether Exhibit P2 (seizure mahazar) described the seal, whether Exhibit P5 (forwarding note) recorded the official’s name and forward date, and whether officials handling the sample during transit were examined. Citing Bhaskaran K. v. State of Kerala and Kumaran v. State of Kerala, the court scrutinized gaps in the chain of custody, and held that the sample’s link to the laboratory analysis (Ex.P7) was not established, with delays in analysis remaining unexplained. Relying on Krishnadas, Vijay Pandey and related authorities, the court concluded the prosecution failed to prove that the analysed sample was the same as seized contraband, culminating in acquittal. The appeal is thus allowed and the accused is set at liberty.

High Court of Kerala
FAO Nos.98/2022, 100/2022

FAO Nos.98/2022 and 100/2022, In the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam

These two appeals arise from a challenge to an interim injunction issued by the trial court in OS 14/2022, seeking to restrain the defendant Nutricreams Private Limited from using the trademarks MERIIBOY and MERRICREM. The plaintiff, a partnership firm, is the registrant of MERIIBOY and had entered into Ext.A3, styled as a Memorandum of Understanding, granting permission to the defendant to use the mark up to 31 March 2023, subject to a supplementary agreement detailing terms. No supplementary agreement was executed. The defendant contends that a consent letter by four other partners permitted the use, and that the absence of a final supplementary agreement should not bar such use. The plaintiff countered that Ext.A3 is a concluded contract governing the lease of the trademark; without final terms, it cannot be binding. The court discusses partnership principles, including that a partnership is a compendious enterprise with mutual liability and that the implied authority of a partner as an agent is governed by Section 19 of the Indian Partnership Act, with reference to Section 22, and defines an “act of a firm” under Section 2(a). It cites Structee Mecha India v. Bharatkumar Pahlajrai to illustrate the doctrine that one partner’s act may bind the firm where circumstances warrant. On balance, the High Court held that, to prevent breach of contract, the injunction can be maintained until disposal of the suit, directing expeditious disposal within three months, and disposed of both appeals with no costs, effectively upholding the injunction.

High Court of Kerala
Cont.Case (C) No.1926 of 2022

Deepesh K.R. v. P.D. Shobhana, Secretary, Cochin Devaswom Board

This contempt of court case challenges non-compliance with the directions contained in Annexure A1 of this Court’s order dated 2 November 2021 in DBP No.48 of 2020 and connected matters. The petitioner, Deepesh K.R., contends that the Cochin Devaswom Board has not complied with the directions, including considerations for appointment claims as Kazhakom in Parakkottukavu Devaswom and related temples under Karayma rights, as outlined in the 2021 order. On 17 October 2022, admission of the contempt petition referenced an application for extension of time in DBP No.48/2020. On 8 February 2023, the Court allowed condonation of a 104-day delay in filing I.A.1 of 2022 and granted a two-month extension to comply with the directions. The Court clarified that the merits of the underlying issue need not be considered in these contempt proceedings; the sole issue is extension of time. On 7 June 2023, the Court noted that the Board had passed an order dated 12 April 2023 contrary to the provisional extension, but observed service issues and closed the contempt case, preserving the petitioner’s right to challenge the order in appropriate proceedings. The Court also cites State of U.P. v. Harish Chandra for the principle that mandamus cannot compel action contrary to law.

High Court of Kerala
OP (CAT) Nos.188/2014, 95/2015, 189/2014 and 124/2015

Union of India and Others v. P. Sethumadhavan and Others (OP(CAT) Nos.188/2014, 95/2015, 189/2014 and 124/2015)

The batch of OA petitions before the Kerala High Court, challenging orders of the Central Administrative Tribunal (Ernakulam Bench), concerns financial upgradation of Grade Pay in the next promotion hierarchy for non-gazetted personnel serving in naval armament depots and similar wings under various Union of India ministries. The petitioners (Union of India and certain ministries/agencies) contended that the CAT orders granting financial upgradation were contrary to statutory pay rules and the binding precedent of the Supreme Court. The respondents (the individual government employees named in OA 1111/2013, OA 1112/2013, OA 180/00182/2014 and related petitions) argued for upgradation as per the Circulars and previous CAT orders. The matter hinges on interpretation of the Central Civil Service (Revised Pay) Rules, 2008 and DoPT/O.M. No. 35034/3/2008-ESTT(D) (2009), with reliance on the Supreme Court decision in Union of India v. M. V. Mohanan Nair (2020), which clarified the eligibility for such upgradation. The Kerala High Court, noting the Mohanan Nair judgment, holds that the batch of petitions is covered in favor of the petitioners and against the respondents, and allowed the Original Petitions, thus quashing the CAT orders granting upgradation and aligning with the Union's position.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) Nos. 2004/2018 and 1755/2019

OP(C) Nos. 2004/2018 & 1755/2019: BINOY KURIAN v. VARKEY JOSEPH & UNION BANK OF INDIA

Two Original Petitions before the Kerala High Court challenge orders of the Munsiff Court Vaikom in EP 76/2016 in OS 6/2016 arising from a sale of property to satisfy a money decree. The core issue is whether the exemption under Section 60(1)(c) CPC can apply when a statutory charge exists under Section 55(6)(b) of the Transfer of Property Act, and whether a decree with a statutory charge constitutes a charge decree for purposes of Section 60(1)(c). The court references Ammini v. K.V. Vibeesh & Ors. to hold that exemption cannot apply where there is a charge or statutory charge; finds Ext.P4 (3 January 2018) illegal and sets it aside, while Ext.P11 (20 June 2018) directing sale of part of the property is upheld; the court directs sale of the portion necessary to satisfy the decree, with power to include more if required. The petitions discuss res judicata, estoppel and the rule against approbating and reprobating, but the court determines these do not alter the core legal position. The final disposition is that O.P(C).2004/2018 is dismissed and O.P(C).1755/2019 is allowed as indicated, with expedited execution within six weeks.

High Court of Kerala
CON.CASE(C) NO.1925 OF 2020

Travancore Titanium Products Limited and others v. Employees Provident Fund Organisation (Contempt Case C) No.1925 of 2020, High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam

This Contempt Case arises from petitions filed by the petitioners (employees of Travancore Titanium Products Limited and others) in W.P.(C) No.15602 of 2015, alleging willful disobedience of directions in the judgment dated 12.10.2018 in W.P.(C) Nos.13120/2015 and connected matters. The petitioners challenged the implementation of pension rules under the Employees Provident Fund scheme, referencing the amendments effected by G.S.R. 609(E) (2014) and the interpretation of paragraph 11(3) and 11(4) of the pension scheme. The Supreme Court’s 2022 judgment in Employees Provident Fund Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B. and connected matters clarified the validity of the 2014 amendment, read down certain provisions, and directed the authorities to extend options and adjust contributions and pension calculations. In the Kerala High Court, the Bench comprising Anil K. Narendran, J., and Sophy Thomas, J., held that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension must be reconsidered by the EPFO in light of the 2022 Supreme Court decision. The court closed the contempt petition, while preserving EPFO’s right to recompute entitlements in accordance with law and the Supreme Court’s directions. The matter ultimately hinges on ensuring compliance with the post-2014 scheme and the extended time/option framework for eligible employees.

High Court of Kerala
MACA Nos. 1326/2018 and 1431/2018

Jyothis S. and others v. Somasekharan Pillai and Sooraj Somasekharan Pillai and The Divisional Officer, New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

The common judgment in MACA Nos. 1326/2018 and 1431/2018 deals with two connected Motor Accidents Claims appeals arising from the death of a husband and wife who were a headmaster and a teacher. The appellants challenge the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal’s award on several fronts: (i) the Tribunal’s use of a “split multiplier” for computing future earnings—advocating instead for using the actual income of the deceased plus future prospects, with multipliers 11 (husband, age 53 at death) and 13 (wife, age 48), after deducting income tax; (ii) the allowance for loss of consortium, arguing for Rs.40,000 per claimant for the wife’s side (three legal heirs) and for the husband’s side (two legal heirs), with 1/3 deduction for personal expenses and the head of loss of love and affection to be obliterated; (iii) whether pay revision and retirement benefits, retroactive to 2014, should be counted in determining compensation; and (iv) whether conventional heads require 10% enhancement. The Court extensively reviews jurisprudence (Jayasree N., Ushakumari, Pranay Sethi, Reshma Kumari, Sarala Verma, Valsamma Baiju, Jashuben, Shyno M. Aykara) and concludes that the split multiplier is unsustainable and that consortium calculations must reflect the specified heirs, with updated multipliers and deduction. It also holds that pay revision benefits should not be reckoned, but grants 10% enhancement on conventional heads and clarifies tax treatment of future prospects. The final orders re-calculate compensation and direct payment with interest and NEFT/RTGS transfer.

High Court of Kerala
DBA NO. 14 OF 2021

Travancore Devaswom Board v. Deputy Examiner for Local Fund Audit, Kerala State Audit Department, Travancore Devaswom Board Audit

This Division Bench of the High Court of Kerala adjudicated an application by the Travancore Devaswom Board seeking extension of the term of appointment of Sri Nidheesh Sundar as Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) at the Appam Aravana Preparation Plant, Sabarimala, for a further period of one year from 17.09.2021 on the existing terms and conditions. The matter has a procedural history: an interim order on 09.11.2021 granted four months extension; the Respondent filed a statement dated 25.03.2022 highlighting the indispensability of the employee for supervision of machineries and noting the contract’s expiry on 16.04.2021. The Board justified extending the contract period citing recommendations and the Chief Engineer’s report; it noted that there has been no regular recruitment since 2017 and that the workforce has relied on contract appointments. The Deputy Examiner for Local Fund Audit contended that there is no necessity to create a permanent post, supported by ROC No.3507/16/Est-I dated 27.06.2022. The bench referred to State of Haryana v. Piara Singh to illustrate that ad hoc or temporary appointments may be permissible in exigencies of administration but must be replaced by regular appointments as soon as possible, with fair recruitment processes. On 27.06.2022, the Board decided there was no need to create permanent posts, and this DBA was closed in light of that decision.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 2145 OF 2008

Martin Thomas Valummel v. Sebastian, Siby Varghese and The National Insurance Co. Ltd., Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd.

Martin Thomas Valummel, the appellant, challenged an award of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Pala, in OP(MV) 798/2006, arising from a motor vehicle accident on 11 March 2006 involving a van owned by the 2nd respondent and insured by the 3rd respondent. The petitioner claimed Rs. 6,00,000 as compensation for injuries sustained, after inpatient treatment spanning 17 days in three hospitals. The tribunal partially allowed the petition, directing the 3rd respondent to pay Rs. 1,60,070 with Rs. 3,200 costs. The respondents 1 and 2 did not contest; the 3rd respondent contested the age, income and occupation of the appellant and denied policy violations. The appellant contends that the Tribunal erred in quantifying compensation, particularly due to a low notional income (Rs. 2,000/month) and limited head-amounts despite a 7% functional disability. Relying on Ramachandrappa, the High Court fixed a higher notional income of Rs. 5,500/month and recalculated losses: loss of earnings Rs. 33,000; loss due to disability Rs. 73,920; pain and suffering Rs. 10,000; loss of amenities Rs. 40,000, with other heads deemed reasonable. The court held the Tribunal’s award inadequate and enhanced total compensation to Rs. 2,68,670, with interest at 6% per annum and costs. The appeal was allowed in part, with distribution ordered through the Tribunal.