This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenges recovery notice Exhibit P-2 dated 05.09.2023 and adjudication order Exhibit P-4 dated 01.02.2022, denying input tax credit (ITC) for the financial year 2017-18. The petitioner, a registered dealer under the CGST and SGST Acts, had claimed ITC for a supply from M/s. T. V. Sundaram Iyengar & Sons Private Limited, which did not reflect in Form GSTR-2A due to the supplier’s incorrect GSTIN in GSTR-1. The supplier’s error necessitated instructions under Circular Exhibit P-6 (No. 183/15/2022-GST, 27-12-2022) clarifying the reconciliation process for initial-year ITC, including verification under CGST Section 16 and potential relaxations for bonafide errors. Petitioner relied on the Diya Agencies judgment (WP(C) 29769/2023, dated 12-09-2023) which directed remand to examine the petitioner's ITC claim with evidence. The court, noting initial-year difficulties and the clarifications in Exhibit P-6, allowed the petition, set aside the recovery order and the adjudication, and remanded to the Assessing Officer to reconsider ITC for 2017-18, with a 10% deposit and opportunity to submit evidence. The decision underscores remedial measures in the GST regime’s infancy and emphasizes bonafide ITC evidence over mere non-reflection in GSTR-2A.
This is a Criminal Appeal under Section 374 CrPC (Crl.A No.1250 of 2018) arising from conviction under Section 20(b)(ii)(B) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act) by the Special Court for NDPS Act, Vatakara, in S.C.No.20 of 2015. The appellant was intercepted on 20.12.2013 while riding a motorcycle near Amarambalam bridge; 3.5 kg of ganja was found in a bag carried by him. The trial court relied on PW2 and PW3 (detecting officers) and Exts.P2 and P3 (arrest memo and mahazar) along with Ext.P6 (confession) to convict, while one co-accused was acquitted. The appellant challenges the legality of the seizure, arguing non-compliance with Section 50 of the NDPS Act since the contraband was on his person, and that the polythene bag in which it was enclosed was not produced in court. He also points to hostile independent witnesses and contends that Ext.P6 is inadmissible under Section 25 of the Indian Evidence Act. The State counters that the recovery was proven beyond reasonable doubt, that the bag was on the appellant’s lap, and that Section 50 may not apply where recovery is from a bag carried by the accused. The High Court discusses the doctrine and case law on Section 50, citing Baldev Singh, Pawan Kumar, and Dayalu Kashyap, and holds that the evidence suffices to convict, though Ext.P6 is inadmissible under the Evidence Act. The sentence is reduced on appeal and the conviction is upheld in part.
BAIL APPL. Nos. 4671/2024; 4816/2024; 4686/2024; 5153/2024 This is a common High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, order dated 24 July 2024 delivering a consolidated decision on four bail applications arising from Crime No. 481/2024 registered at Irinjalakuda Police Station, Thrissur. Accused persons (5th, 13th, 17th, 18th and 19th) faced charges under IPC Sections 143, 147, 148, 506(ii), 341, 323, 324, 307 and 302 read with 149, alleging formation of an unlawful assembly, restraint, and grievous injuries culminating in two deaths. The petitioners argue innocence, claiming no specific overt act linking them to the predicate crime; they emphasize the final report’s filing and the absence of antecedents, urging release on bail after substantial pre-trial detention (65–113 days). The State counters with concerns of habitual offending, risk of witness intimidation, and a potential impact on society, invoking the law laid down in Kalyan Chandra Sarkar and the need to protect the ongoing investigation. The Court, applying the presumption of innocence, bail jurisprudence, and Article 21, finds no specific overt act against petitioners to attract the predicate, and despite the final report, grants bail with stringent conditions (bond Rs.50,000 with two sureties; periodic appearances; no tampering; territorial restrictions; passport surrender; and potential cancellation on breach). The order clarifies it does not decide merits of the case.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5693 OF 2024 The petitioners—accused 1 to 3 in Crime No. 475/2024 of Peramangalam Police Station, Thrissur—seek pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC. The offences relate to alleged mental and physical harassment of the de facto complainant, wife of the first petitioner, under Section 498-A IPC, spanning from 12.09.2021 to 20.05.2024, with the FIR lodged only on 28.06.2024. The petitioners contend their innocence, asserting the defacto complainant filed Annexure-1 FIR to wreck vengeance and that the allegations are omnibus with no material linking them to any recoveries or coercive acts; custodial interrogation is unnecessary, and no recovery is shown. The prosecution argues the investigation is ongoing and that grant of pre-arrest bail could hamper it. The court notes the marital relationship is strained and observes the delay between the alleged conduct and the FIR, which may indicate differences rather than malice. Relying on Bhadresh Bipinbhal Sheth v. State of Gujarat and another (2015 KHC 4579), the court emphasizes cautious handling of pre-arrest bail in family-dispute contexts, and that a special case is not a prerequisite for Section 438 bail in such scenarios. After balancing submissions, the court grants pre-arrest bail subject to conditions including surrender within 10 days, a Rs.50,000 bond with two solvent sureties of equal amount, cooperation with investigation, no witness tampering, passport surrender, no other offences, and a provision for cancellation if conditions are breached; the order preserves the investigation and states the remarks are for the bail inquiry only.
The petitioner, K.P. Umasankar, stands as guarantor for a loan availed by a proprietary concern, PBT Spices, from Punjab National Bank in 2006. The loan became a non-performing asset, prompting SARFAESI proceedings; those proceedings led to S.A. No.799/2010 before the Debts Recovery Tribunal and OA No.292/2012, both of which remained pending. In the interim, the bank offered an One Time Settlement (OTS) on 30.03.2019 for Rs.7,02,116, of which Rs.4,50,000 was paid on that date; the balance of Rs.2,52,116 was to be paid by 15.05.2019. The original borrower died on 08.05.2019, after which the guarantor sought extension of the balance payment, which Ext.R1(b) refused. The petitioner approached the High Court under Article 226, contending that the bank’s refusal to extend the time was arbitrary and illegal. Counsel for the petitioner argued that, in exceptional circumstances, the terms of an OTS can be extended under Article 226, citing Bind u Vijayakumar (2022(1) KHC 394) and Vijayakumari (AIR 2018 SC 759), among others, to justify leniency. The bank countered that an OTS is a binding contract that cannot be varied by writ petition and relied on decisions such as Bijnoor Urban Cooperative Bank and Tamil Nadu Industrial Investment Corporation, which hold that modification requires mutual consent and writs should not compel extension. The court ultimately held that, given the borrower’s death and the significant prepayment, there are exceptional circumstances to direct the bank to accept the balance with interest, extinguishing the guarantor’s liability upon payment.
Sudheesh K.C., a daily wage worker engaged by the Kerala State Civil Supplies Corporation Limited since 2017, was terminated on 01 February 2023 following a preliminary enquiry into alleged irregularities at the Chalakudy SupplyCo Depot. He contends that the termination is not a mere discharge but a finding of departmental offence, which would entail prior notice and an opportunity to be heard, and that such a stigmatic consequence cannot flow from an unenforced enquiry. The respondents submit that as a daily wage employee, termination can occur without notice, and that although a preliminary enquiry was conducted, no guilt was established and no stigma attaches to the termination. The court surveys the jurisprudence on punitive versus non-punitive terminations, citing Wainganga Bahuddeshiya Vikas v. Ku. Jaya and Rahey Shyam Gupta, as well as older decisions such as Ram Narayan Das, Champaklal, Sukh Raj Bahadur, and Benjamin, to delineate the law. It clarifies that preliminary enquiries aim to uncover prima facie material to initiate a proper departmental enquiry, not to determine guilt. Noting the absence of notice, the court finds a violation of natural justice and directs reinstatement/re-engagement of the petitioner as a Daily Wage Worker if work is available, while reserving the right to issue notice and proceed as per law.
WP(C) 15128/2023 & 2220/2023 This case concerns two writ petitions filed by Reg h Unandanan V. Menon, then General Manager (P&A) (Oushadhi) of Pharmaceutical Corporation (IM) Kerala Ltd, challenging a memo of charges dated 28.02.2023 and the accompanying statement of allegations, together with a suspension order dated 11.01.2023. The Board of Directors, acting on information from two informants, initiated an enquiry, leading to the memo and suspension. The petitioner argues that the charges are vague, lacking particulars, and that the Board acted with bias and preconceived notions, and that the Statement of Allegations contains no concrete allegations, merely a conclusion of misconduct. The Corporation maintains that the informants presented grave information and that the Board properly evaluated the allegations, calling for an enquiry and suspension to safeguard the corporation’s interests, and that due process was followed. The High Court, after detailed scrutiny, held that the core issue is whether the charges are specific and the Statement of Allegations provides a meaningful opportunity to respond. Relying on Supreme Court precedents (A. V. Rayidu, Kulkarni, Khanna, Vijay Shankar Pandey, Kunisetty Sathyanarayana), the court finds the memo of charges and the suspension order to be invalid due to vagueness and lack of proper particulars. It quashes both petitions, sets aside the orders and proceedings, and clarifies that fresh action may be initiated with due procedure.
This is a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court deciding a Review Petition (R.P. No.954 of 2022) filed by The South Indian Bank Ltd. against a judgment in C.E. Appeal No.3 of 2020, concerning Service Tax liability and the invocation of the extended period of limitation under proviso to Section 73 of the Finance Act, 1994. The original order and the Tribunal’s findings turned on whether extended time could be invoked where there was short levy and whether penalties should be imposed or waived for reasonable cause. The bank argued that there was no wilful suppression or evasion, citing Rajasthan Renewable Energy (GSTL 2018 Raj) to urge that wilful misstatement or suppression is required for the extended period; and the Supreme Court’s Northern Operating Systems decision to support a constrained interpretation of wilfulness. The department contended that suppression was unearthed by an intelligence report and that the bank’s failure to disclose the true value of taxable services amounted to suppression. The High Court analyzed these authorities, noted that there was evidence of suppression and that the remittances occurred after the intelligence report, while the show cause notice was issued later, and ultimately concluded there was no error on the face of the record. The review petition was disposed of with the original judgment standing, i.e., the petition was dismissed.
This High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, hears MACA No.513 of 2012, an appeal arising from the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Irinjalakuda, which awarded Rs.56,000 with 7.5% interest to the appellant on 15.11.2011 in OP(MV) No.744/2007. The appellant Baby, a pillion rider in a two-wheeler, sustained serious injuries in a collision on 06.04.2007 at about 6:50 p.m. on the Thrissur–Kodungallur road, allegedly caused by negligent conduct of two riders. The Tribunal found some liability and assessed quantum; the insurer contested negligence and the amount, while other respondents also disputed. On appeal, the appellant’s counsel urged higher monthly income than the Tribunal fixed (Rs.4,000 instead of Rs.2,000), supported by the standard laid down in Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. (2011) 13 SCC 236, and sought enhancement for loss of earnings, disability, pain and suffering, and loss of amenities. The Respondents countered with disputes over negligence, policy validity, and quantum. The High Court re-evaluated evidence (Exts A1–A11 for the appellant; B1–B3 for the insurer), increased monthly income to Rs.4,000 for five months, fixed 8% disability (overruling the Tribunal’s reasoning on Ext.A11), and added Rs.7,000 each for pain and suffering and loss of amenities. The appeal was allowed in part, directing enhanced compensation of Rs.53,240 with interest, and ordering the insurer (R2) to deposit within two months.
N. Nandakumar filed WP(C) 27076/2022 seeking a licence to start quarrying on private Patta land in Kizhakkencheri-II Village, Palakkad. He had obtained an LOI from the Director of Mining and Geology, EC from SEIAA, Consent to Operate from the Pollution Control Board, and an Explosives Licence; however, the Secretary of the Kizhakkencheri Grama Panchayat insisted that the D&O licence could not be processed without clearance from the Standing Committee of the National Board for Wildlife (SCNBWL) and a District Disaster Management Authority (DDMA) NOC, based on Exts.P7, P8 and P18. The petitioner challenged these requirements as illegal and arbitrary, contending SEIAA cannot alter EC conditions without hearing, and that the MoEF&CC memo (Ext.P10) cannot create sweeping restrictions. The quarry site lies near Eco Sensitive Zones (Peechi-Vazhani and Chimmony Sanctuaries). The court examined whether ESZ restrictions could compel SCNBWL clearance and whether DDMA consent is required under Kerala Panchayat Raj Act. Relying on Apex Court directions in Re: T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad and Goa Foundation, and Malayoram Rock Products, the court found Exts.P7, P8 and P18 arbitrary and unsustainable, partially setting them aside. It directed the 3rd respondent to consider Ext.P16 for a D&O licence without SCNBWL clearance and DDMA NOC within one month.
RP 936 of 2021 in MAT.Appeal No.89 of 2020 This Kerala High Court review petitions concerns the correctness of a 2020 judgment in MAT.Appeal No.89 of 2020 that recognized the right of a Muslim wife to terminate her marriage unilaterally by khula under Quranic law and the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act, 1939. The review challenges the scope and procedure of khula, contending that the Supreme Court’s and other authorities’ discussion on khula cannot override the statutory framework under Indian law. The petition asserts that Muslim Personal Law, Article 25 of the Constitution, and the Shariat Act, 1937 govern questions of marriage and dissolution, and that Quranic verses (notably 2:229) provide a unilateral right to end the marriage, with any ritual or court procedure being a matter of statutory or judicial design rather than a religious imperative. The court is urged to treat khula as a no-fault, unilateral remedy, not contingent on the husband’s consent, and to resist treating such a remedy as faskh or dependent on third-party rulings. The judgment discusses the distinction between Fiqh and Shariah, the role of Sunnah, and the potential use of istihsan (juristic discretion) and maqasid (goals) of Shariah to resolve equity concerns, but ultimately holds that the situational practice cannot be read as general law. The petition is dismissed, leaving the prior judgment intact while acknowledging the desirability of amicable settlements.
CRL.M.C No. 8050 of 2022; CC 1244/2016 This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 Cr.P.C. heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court. The petitioners, accused Nos.1 and 3, are M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. and its authorised signatory, Sheeja Sunny, who sought to quash Annexure-A2, the complaint in CC No.1244/2016 pending before the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-XII, Thiruvananthapuram. The complainant, Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd., alleged that the first accused, in discharge of a contractual obligation under a channel carriage arrangement (entered into on 20.07.2015), issued a cheque for Rs. 3,42,000 which bounced. The petitioners argued that the second petitioner (an authorised signatory) was merely an employee without control over day-to-day affairs and that, even if a legally enforceable debt existed, the liability and loss had since been discharged by payments reflected in Annexure A-3, thus rendering the substrate of the case non-existent. They contended that continuing the prosecution would be an abuse of process. The respondent-counter statement disputed the claimed discharge, asserting that the payments were not in respect of the cheques involved in the present 138 NI Act cases and that many other cases remain pending. The court examined the complaint under Nagawwa principles, observed that substantial factual disputes require trial, and held that the petition to quash was meritless, dismissing the Crl.M.C. petition. The complainant’s case, including S.138 proceedings, may proceed to trial.
Fazil N.P., holder of a regular permit to operate on the Nilambur (Starting point) – Mavoor (Termini) route using Stage Carriage KL-51A-7384 (later replaced by KL-11S-5949), seeks relief challenging changes to timings prescribed for his trip. The third respondent, Mohammed Aslam, owner of a stage carriage (Reg. No. KL-14H-1116) sought a revision of timings before the second respondent. Following directions issued by this Court in Ext.P5, a timing conference was held where objections were filed by the petitioner and seven other operators; the Secretary, RTA, Kozhikode, rejected the revision of timings by Ext.P7, observing that several operators objected and noting concerns of unhealthy competition. The third respondent challenged Ext.P7 before the State Transport Appellate Tribunal (STAT) without impleading objectors. The STAT quashed Ext.P7 and remanded for fresh consideration, directing notice to all concerned. RTA subsequently issued Ext.P10 proposing a timing conference as per Ext.P9. The petitioner contends that the 3rd respondent should have impleaded objectors and that Ext.P9 violated natural justice since affected parties were not heard. The respondents argue the 2nd respondent’s order was proper, and the remand was open to hearing all concerned. The High Court disposed of the petition, directing the 2nd respondent to expedite matters in terms of the STAT’s Ext.P9 directions and to proceed accordingly, citing principles from Subhash Chandra v. State of UP to justify the approach.
BAIL APPL. NO. 5289 OF 2024 This is a bail petition under Section 439 CrPC filed by Muhasin, the second accused, in Crime No. 941/2024 of Malappuram Police Station arising from alleged NDPS Act offences (Sections 22(b) and 29) involving 2.12 grams of MDMA claimed to be for sale. The first accused was found in conscious possession of the contraband and arrested; during investigation it is alleged that the second accused supplied the contraband, who was also arrested. The petitioner contends total innocence and false implication, arguing there is no material linking him to the supply, and highlights that he has been in judicial custody for over 60 days with the final report not yet laid. He seeks statutory bail under Section 167(2) CrPC read with Section 36A(4) of the NDPS Act. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, noting ongoing investigation and labeling the petitioner a habitual offender based on five other crimes, while conceding that the contraband is of an intermediate quantity and the final report is not filed. The court discusses extended investigation timelines under 36A(4) NDPS and 167(2) CrPC and relies on Supreme Court authorities (Sanjay Dutt; Uday Mohanlal Acharya) to emphasize the indefeasible right to bail on default in filing the charge sheet. Finding the petitioner in custody for more than 60 days with no final report, the court grants statutory bail subject to stringent conditions: bond of Rs 1 lakh with two solvent sureties, appearance before IO, no tampering with evidence, surrender of passport, and possible cancellation/modification of bail, with authority to investigate and recover as needed under Sushila Aggarwal.
MSA Nos. 04/2021 & 05/2021 The Kerala High Court, in a common judgment dated 14 July 2022 by Justice M.R. Anitha Thursday, hears M.S.A. Nos. 04/2021 and 05/2021, challenging a Kerala Real Estate Appellate Tribunal order that disposed of complaints under the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016. The appellant booked an apartment in Tritvam, Kochi, paying Rs.16 lakh in July 2019 before a sale agreement was executed. In October 2019 he sought cancellation and demanded refund; the promoter claimed forfeiture of Rs.15,16,667 with a Rs.83,333 refund. The appellant approached K-RERA (Complaint No.185/2020) seeking return of the advance with interest and Rs.5 lakh compensation, and also sought penalties for alleged Section 13 violations. The Adjudicating Officer dismissed the CCP 110/2020 claim, finding that refunds and interest fall within K-RERA’s purview while compensation demands fall under the Adjudicating Officer’s exclusive jurisdiction under Section 71 read with 72. The Tribunal disposed of the matters by summarizing jurisdictional boundaries and ordering remittance for registration issues. The High Court, relying on M/s. Newtech Promoters and Developers Pvt. Ltd. (SC), held the Act retroactive to ongoing projects and directed K-RERA to reconsider the complaint for the return of the advance with interest, while leaving compensation claims to the Adjudicating Officer. The judgment modifies the Tribunal’s order and directs fresh proceedings within two months, with costs to be borne by the parties.
This criminal appeal challenges the conviction of the appellant for rape and related offences committed against his daughter (the victim), a juvenile, as well as assault. The trial court convicted him under IPC sections 323, 324, 376(2)(f), 376(2)(n) and Section 23 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000, based on the testimony of the victim (PW1) and corroborating evidence from medical and other witnesses. The prosecution examined 12 witnesses and relied on Exts P1–P16, including medical certificates and Forensic Science Laboratory reports (Exts C1, P4, P7). The defence contended that the victim, aged about 25 at the time of evidence, disclosed the acts belatedly and that lack of corroboration (e.g., Molly the relative) undermined reliability; they relied on several judgments (Sakim Ali; Dharm Sai; Kishore Bahadur; Partap Singh) to argue the evidence should be scrutinized with doubt. The Kerala High Court reviewed the core of the victim’s testimony under the sterling witness framework (Rai Sandeep) and found the core version natural, consistent, and aligned with the medical evidence, thereby upholding the conviction. The Court, however, modified the sentence under 376(2)(f) from life imprisonment to 20 years of rigorous imprisonment, while keeping other sentences intact. The appeal is allowed in part.
This is a common judgment of the High Court of Kerala rendered on 30 September 2022 by Justice K. Babu in multiple criminal appeals (CRL.A Nos. 854/2022, 57/2012, 58/2012, 2209/2011, 2212/2011, 49/2012 and connected cases) arising from Abkari Act offences concerning spirit smuggling. The appellants challenged their convictions for offences under Sections 55(a), 55(b), 55(i) and 8(2) read with 8(1) of the Abkari Act and Section 120B IPC, as well as the manner of investigation and the chain of custody of contraband samples used for chemical analysis. The trial court had convicted the common accused No.1 in S.C. Nos.194/2003 and 195/2003 and common accused Nos.2 and 9; the High Court examined the prosecution’s case critically for compliance with statutory safeguards, particularly the link between seizure and laboratory analysis, the tamper-proof handling of samples, and the competence of Abkari officers to investigate under SRO 321/96. Citing a series of precedents (Bhaskaran, Rajamma, Ramachandran, Viswanadhan, Jil, Baburaj, Ramankutty, Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram, Sasidharan, Sujith, Vijay Pandey), the court found due process and strict link-evidence requirements unmet. Consequently, the appeals were allowed and the accused acquitted, with fines if any to be disbursed.
Jaisal seeks bail in Crime No.14/2024 of the Cyber Crime Police Station, Thrissur, for alleged offences under IPC Section 420 and IT Act Section 66(D). The petition, filed under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, states that the accused was arrested on 15.06.2024 and has remained in judicial custody for 52 days; the investigation is practically complete and recovery has been effected. The prosecution contends that the accused, along with other suspects, induced the de facto complainant to invest Rs 4,73,400 through six bank transfers between 04.02.2024 and 07.02.2024, promising an online job and profits, but paid only Rs 3,850 as profit and failed to return the capital. The petitioner claims innocence and asserts there is no material showing receipt of money. The Sessions judge cites the Supreme Court's decisions in Sanjay Chandra v. CBI and Dataram Singh v. State of UP to reaffirm the presumption of innocence and the general rule that bail is the norm, with detention before conviction being an exception. After careful consideration, the court grants bail under stringent conditions, including a Rs 50,000 bond with two solvent sureties, appearance before IO on Saturdays, non-inducement, non-tampering, surrender of passport, and the possibility of cancellation for violation, while allowing the IO to continue investigation and recoveries.
This matter is an arbitration request under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, filed by Tech-Sharp Engineers Pvt. Ltd. (the applicant) seeking the appointment of a sole arbitrator to resolve disputes arising from a tendered mechanical works contract for Offsites-IREP Area under Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. (BPCL). The applicant, selected by BPCL, alleges delays and inaction by BPCL, culminating in the return of its final bill and a demand for a No-Claim Certificate; disputes regarding payment and claims are said to have triggered the arbitration clause (Annexure A1). The 2015 amendment to the Act and jurisprudence, including TRF Limited v. Energo Engineering Projects Ltd and related decisions, are invoked to argue that BPCL’s right to nominate an arbitrator has forfeit. BPCL contends that a Madras High Court order restraining payments to a sub-contractor complicates adjudication and argues for a technical expert if required. The Court, noting that Clause 91 of Annexure A1 obliges arbitration and that the appointing authority’s right has been forfeited post-amendments, proceeds to appoint Mr. Justice K. Abraham Mathew as the sole arbitrator, with conditions on jurisdiction, disclosure, fees, and venue. The order leaves contentions open for later arbitration, with the seat at Ernakulam and procedural directions to be followed by the Arbitrator.
This is a revision petition under Sec. 19(4) of the Family Courts Act, 1984, challenging the Family Court, Nedumangad, MC No.464/2011, under Sec.125 CrPC which directed S.V. Hari to pay maintenance to his wife Ansy and their minor daughter Shreya. The Family Court fixed a total monthly maintenance of Rs. 7,000 (Rs. 3,000 for the minor and Rs. 4,000 for the wife) after scrutinising the pleadings and evidence, including the petitioner’s salary certificate showing a gross salary of Rs.18,000 and net Rs.6,137 after deductions. Hari contends subsequent developments—his wife’s remarriage and employment elsewhere, plus a letter indicating she does not want maintenance—entitle modification or cancellation under Sec. 127 CrPC. The respondents argue that Sec.125 is a social-justice provision to prevent destitution and to ensure a reasonable standard of living for wife and child, regardless of remarriage, and that the petitioner’s earnings justify ongoing support. The High Court notes courts may estimate notional income for fixation of maintenance. It relies on authorities like Rajnesh v. Neha, Captain Ramesh Chander Kaushal, and Bhuwan Mohan Singh to uphold social-justice rationale. The petition is dismissed, with liberty to seek modification against the second respondent under Sec.127; the order is to be complied with by the Family Court.