Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 559 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.30616 of 2022

PAPPINSSERYVEETIL MEENAKSHI VARASIAR and PAPPINISSERYVEETTIL BHARATHI VARASIAR v. SRI V.V. UNNIKRISHNAVARIYAR, SREE KALARIVATHUKKAL BHAGAVATHI TEMPLE (Chirakkal Kovilakam Devaswom Group) and others

This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution challenges Ext.P6 (Deputy Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, OA No.4 of 2019 dated 11.06.2020) and Ext.P7 (Devaswom Commissioner, AP No.4 of 2020 dated 13.07.2022), seeking certiorari to quash those orders. The petition seeks a declaration that the 2nd petitioner is the hereditary pookazhakam of the Sreekalarivathukkal Bhagavathi Kshethram under Chirakkal Kovilakam Devaswom Group, Kannur District; a writ of mandamus to correct internal documents and reinstate the 2nd petitioner as pookazhakam; and to pay back wages and other benefits for the period she was kept out of service pursuant to Ext.P7. On 27.09.2022, the Respondents urged maintainability via Section 62 of the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951. The petition discusses whether a writ under Article 226 should bypass a statutory remedy when available. The court surveys precedents such as Chhabil Das Agarwal, Mathew K.C., Thansingh Nathmal, Titaghur, Pavithran, and others, emphasising that ordinarily, an efficacious statutory remedy should be pursued and that Article 226 is discretionary. The petition is ultimately dismissed as not maintainable without prejudice to invoking Section 62; the court leaves open the right to pursue the statutory remedy through the appropriate forum. The decision reiterates the principle that statutory remedies, not writs, govern redress in these statutory schemes, absent exceptional circumstances.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No.3123 of 2009

MACA No.3123 of 2009 vs. IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal from the Kerala High Court (MACA No. 3123 of 2009) under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, arising from an injury claim in Palakkad. The original petition filed by Shamsudeen A. for injuries suffered on 1 February 1998 against a lorry KLW/2691, driven by the first respondent, alleged negligence; the driver and owner faced contest; the insurer contested liability and the amount. The Tribunal held negligence proved and awarded Rs.1,10,873 plus costs. The appellants contended the quantum was inadequate and urged higher compensation, relying on Chameli Devi & Ors v. Jivrail Mian and Ors (2019 KHC 5352) to fix notional income at a realistic level; the court, noting the accident occurred in 1998, re-fixes the notional monthly income at Rs.2,500. It confirmed four months of incapacity but, taking the revised income into account, added Rs.4,000 for loss of earnings and Rs.7,000 each for pain and sufferings and loss of amenities, totaling Rs.18,000 additional compensation with 6% interest from the filing, after deducting 134 days’ delay ordered by the court. The third respondent insurer remains liable; deposit of enhanced compensation with interest and costs before the Tribunal within sixty days is ordered, and the Tribunal shall disburse the enhanced amount in the ratio 50:50. The appeal is allowed in part.

High Court of Kerala
Tr.P.(C) No. 505/2022

LIYA SARAH GEORGE v. MANU POIKAYIL ALEXANDER

This is a transfer petition (Tr.P.(C) No.505/2022) under section 24 CPC filed in the Kerala High Court, seeking transfer of OP (Guardian) No.406/2022 from the Family Court, Pathanamthitta, to the Family Court, Thrissur. The petitioner(s) comprising Liya Sarah George (wife), and her parents George K P and Marry George, contend that the marital relationship with Manu Poikayil Alexander has deteriorated and that several related proceedings (OP (Divorce) No.2632/2021 and OP (Guardian) No.2613/2021) are already pending before the Thrissur Family Court, with another DV Act proceeding (M.C. No.32/2021) filed in Thrissur. The respondent is contesting Exts P1 and P2 before the Thrissur Family Court. The petition argues that transferring Ext P4 to Thrissur would consolidate all cases and avoid conflicting decisions, thereby saving judicial time and protecting the interests of the wife and child. The court relied on established Supreme Court jurisprudence, including Sumitha Sing and related decisions, to emphasize that the convenience of the woman and child should guide transfer orders in matrimonial disputes. Ultimately, the judge exercises discretionary power under section 24 CPC and grants the transfer, with directions for consolidation, transmission of records, and joint trial in Thrissur.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5033 OF 2024

Ragesh.T v. State of Kerala

Ragesh.T, the sole accused in Crime No.178/2024 of Payyanadi Police Station, Kannur, seeks regular bail in Bail Application No.5033/2024 before the Kerala High Court. The prosecution alleges rape under Section 376(2)(n) IPC along with offences under Sections 420, 341, and 323 IPC, arising from a relationship formed online from December 2021. The specific allegations state that the accused subjected the defacto complainant to sexual intercourse on 23.11.2022 and on subsequent dates, after promising to marry her, and that Rs.75,000 was obtained from her with an assurance of return. It is further alleged that on 06.12.2023 the complainant, upon visiting the accused’s residence, was wrongfully restrained and manhandled. The defense argues innocence and contends that any sexual intercourse occurred with consent; it is alleged the complainant misrepresented her age as 27, whereas medical records show ages around 32, and the accused was not willing to marry an older woman. The petitioner was arrested on 10.06.2024 after the dismissal of B.A.2333/2024 (anticipatory bail). The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, noting the ongoing unmarried relationship and that release could impede the investigation as it is in an early stage. The court observed prima facie offences but, given progress in investigation and lack of custodial necessity, granted regular bail on conditions including bond, sureties, reporting, travel restrictions, passport surrender, and no further offences during bail.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(RC) NO. 80 OF 2022

Chithra K. Ajith v. L. Subramonian and Others

Chithra K. Ajith, a landlord, filed R.C.P. No. 31 of 2021 before the Rent Control Court, Thiruvananthapuram, seeking eviction of the respondent-tenant L. Subramonian and the alleged sub-tenants (Sparks Mantra and partners) under Sections 11(2)(b), 11(3) and 11(4)(1) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. Alongside, the petitioner moved I.A. No. 1 of 2021 under Section 12 of the Act to direct the tenant to remit admitted arrears and to continue paying rent during the pendency of the eviction proceedings. The original petition was invoked through Article 227 of the Constitution of India for time-bound consideration. On 30.03.2022, the Court issued admission notice and sought a status report from the Rent Control Court. The Rent Control Court’s report shows ex parte notice on the 1st, 3rd, and 5th respondents; 2nd and 3rd respondents appeared; 4th respondent’s service was dispensed with due to the nature of relief sought. The 5th respondent moved I.A. 3 of 2022 seeking to set aside the ex parte order, which was allowed on 31.03.2022. Relying on K.V. Shiraz v. Binny Emmatty (O.P.(RC) No. 72 of 2022), the High Court held that once a tenant is ex parte, the Rent Control Court cannot proceed with the Section 12 application, and directed the Rent Control Court to finally dispose of R.C.P. No. 31 of 2021 within three months. The petition is thus disposed of to ensure expeditious resolution of the eviction petition, with service on the 4th respondent dispensed with and the matter to proceed for objections and hearing as appropriate within the stipulated period.

High Court of Kerala
R.C.Rev.No.45 of 2022

SIVARAJAN v. KUNJAMMA

This revision arises from eviction proceedings under Section 11(2) and 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The Rent Control Court at Chavakkad ordered eviction under Section 11(3) on a bonafide need claimed by the landlady, a mother aged around eighty, to accommodate her dependent son’s business and to reside with her. The Rent Control Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal, and the revision petitioner tenant challenged the order under Section 20. The landlady contends that her son requires five rooms in the petition schedule premises for shifting his steel business from Kannur to Kunnamkulam, where she currently resides with him and where her family depends on her. The tenant challenges the legitimacy of the landlady’s claimed need, arguing she has resided in Kannur with her son for long and that the need to start a new business in Kunnamkulam is a pretext to evict at a higher rent. Evidence included the testimony of the landlady’s daughter PW1 and PW2, the landlady’s son, plus documents Exts. A1–A5. Sections 11(3) and its provisos frame the injunction on eviction, with the first proviso hinging on another building in possession and the second proviso requiring the tenant to prove livelihood dependence. On review of the record, the High Court affirmed the concurrent findings that the need is bonafide, and dismissed the revision, while granting the tenant six months to surrender possession on strict conditions.

High Court of Kerala
OP(KAT) No. 43 of 2023

K. Gopalan v. State of Kerala & District Collector, Malappuram

This Original Petition (OP) challenges a pension-reduction order issued after retirement under Rule 59(b) of Part III KSR. The petitioner, K. Gopalan, a retired Deputy Collector (HG), faced a show-cause notice alleging an act during his tenure as Revenue Divisional Officer Tirur: directing acceptance of basic tax on land possession without adequate verification. Following retirement in 2014, the government issued Annexure-A5 (G.O. 14.06.2017) reducing his pension by ₹500 per month, and Annexure-A7 (11.12.2017) denying review. The Kerala Administrative Tribunal dismissed OA No. 301/2018, holding that Rule 59(b) could be invoked in the circumstances. The petitioner argues that there was no disciplinary action or guilt established during service, that the alleged misconduct concerns a single instance, and that his long, unblemished career and a 2011 letter of appreciation negate a finding that his service was not thoroughly satisfactory. He further contends that amendments to Rule 59(b) came into force in 2018, after the incident, and cannot validate the action. The respondents maintain the action was proper, noting that the Tahsildar's report requested guidance and that the entailing tax matter and escheats considerations supported pension reduction. The High Court ultimately relies on precedents emphasizing that pension reduction should reflect the service record as a whole, not a solitary lapse, and quashes the challenged orders, restoring full pension with refunds due within three months.

High Court of Kerala
DBP No. 52 of 2024

Travancore Devaswom Board - Report No.15 of 2024 in Complaint No.130 of 2023, Sabarimala - Purchase of tins and lids and increase in price - Suo Motu Proceedings Initiated

This High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, hears a suo motu petition (DBP No.52 of 2024) initiated by the Travancore Devaswom Board in response to Ombudsman Report No.15 of 2024 arising from Complaint No.130 of 2023 concerning the purchase of composite cans and lids for Aravana Prasadam at Sabarimala Sannidhanam and related price increases. The Ombudsman's report recommended verification of files and accounts by the Kerala State Audit Department. Additional respondents were suo motu impleaded: the State of Kerala (represented by the Principal Secretary, Revenue Devaswom Department) and the Deputy Director, Kerala State Audit, to oversee the audit. The Court places emphasis on prior SSCR No.24 of 2022 orders concerning supply during Mandala-Makaravilakku, including tenders and contract obligations, and directs that there be no shortage of Aravana Prasadam and that tendering, supply, and production considerations be examined strictly in accordance with law. It clarifies that any alleged tender violations would fall within contract terms and be subject to audit. The final disposition disposes of the DBP with directions to audit and to consider the Annexure O1 complaint in the process.

High Court of Kerala
EX.SA NO. 15 OF 2008

Thankappan Nair Sunil Kumar Kunchukonam Varuna Bhavan, Kottukal Desom, Village (Appellant) v. Lekshmi Pillai Parvathy Pillai Thittachal Veedu, Venpakal Desom, Athiyannoor, Pakuthy (died) and his legal heirs (1) Raman Pillai Raveendran Nair; (2) Parvathy Pillai Indira Devi Sree Nilayam; (3) India Devi Yamuna Devi; (4) Gopalakrishnan Nair Praveen Kumar; (5) Gopalakrishnan Nair Prathapan; (6) Lakshmy Pillai Karthiyayni Pilllai; (7) Velayudhan Pillai Jyothishkumar; (8) Karthiyayani Pillai Saleela Kumari; (9) Velayudhan Pillai Asaleesh Kumar (Respondents)

This Execution Second Appeal arises from the execution proceedings of O.S. No. 595/1986 and E.A. No. 110/2001 before the II Additional Munsiff Court, Neyyattinkara, challenging a decree-scheduled property. The appellant, son of the 16th judgment debtor, sought to challenge the delivery and ownership of a petition schedule property under Order 21 Rule 99 CPC, claiming independent rights in the petition schedule property based on documents noted in the record (Exts A1, A4) and a settlement deed (document No.596/2000) along with a 1997 sale deed to the father. The trial court found that the executor’s title was not proven and that the petition schedule property did not correspond to the decree schedule property; consequently the petition was dismissed. The first appellate court upheld the dismissal. The High Court, while admitting the appeal, held that objections to execution under Order 21 Rule 97/99 CPC must relate to the subject matter of the execution and not to other properties. It rejected the petition on multiple grounds: the petition schedule and decree schedule properties are not identical; the relied documents were created during the proceedings and are hit by lis pendens; the petitioner failed to establish title of the executor to execute Ext A1. Observing contradictions in Exts A1 and A4 and the lack of valid title in the mother to grant Ext A1, the court affirmed dismissal, noting that the petitioner is the son of the 16th defendant and that the remedy lies in appropriate legal proceedings. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) NO. 948 OF 2021

Jose De Almeida & Others v Union of Anglo Indian Associations & Others

This is an OP(C) under Article 227 of the Constitution of India challenging orders in a civil suit concerning the Union of Anglo Indian Associations. The petitioners, life members of the Union registered under the Travancore-Cochin Act, claim they have a right to participate in general body meetings and elections, asserting that the term of office for the governing committee expired on 07.07.2020 and that the present office-bearers (defendants 2 and 3) cannot continue. They allege irregularities in the General Body Meeting held on 13.12.2020 arranged to manipulate elections and seek a temporary injunction restraining further action by the defendants pursuant to that meeting. The respondents contend that the AGM was conducted with proper quorum and that some petitioners did not sign attendance; Covid-19 restrictions and Section 144 CrPC prevented timely elections; a Returning Officer finalised the voters’ list including petitioners, and the election process was accelerated with a deadline of 28.12.2020. The Trial Court dismissed the injunction, the District Court affirmed. The High Court upheld the discretionary approach, noting the need to balance rights and the risk of injustice, citing Wander Limited and Seema Arshad Zaheer for the non-interference principle. The matter is directed to proceed with trial and dispose of the original suit within six months.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 805 of 2012

Subramanian M.R. v. Sunil A.R., V.K. Anandarajan, and The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

This is a Motor Accident Claims Appeal (MACA No. 805 of 2012) from a 2003 accident governed by Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, decided by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Thrissur. The appellant, Subramanian M.R., sustained injuries when a bus (owner 2nd respondent) insured by the 3rd respondent allegedly negligent- ly struck his motorcycle on 04.10.2003 on Thriprayar Road. The Tribunal held the respondents liable and awarded Rs. 42,400 with 8% interest, finding the bus owner and insurer liable while the appellant’s own evidence about income was contested. The insurer disputed the age, income and occupation of the claimant and argued that the compensation claimed was excessive. On appeal, the court undertook a reassessment of income and damages, noting the Tribunal’s notional income of Rs. 2,500 per month and citing Ramachandrappa v. Manager, Royal Sundaram Alliance Insurance Co. Ltd. to fix notional income in the context of a 2003 accident. The judge re-fixated the appellant’s monthly income at Rs. 3,500, treated disability as 2%, and recalculated past earnings loss, loss of earning capacity, pain and sufferings, and loss of amenities. The result is an enhanced compensation and a deposit/cost order, with directions to deposit the enhanced amount before the Tribunal within 60 days for disbursement on deposit."

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A NO. 2926 OF 2008

Jayan @ Kuzhiyana Jayan v. State of Kerala

Jayan @ Kuzhiyana Jayan, the appellant, challenges a conviction under Section 8(2) of the Abkari Act for possessing 35 litres of arrack found at Mulavana, Thiruvananthapuram, on 04.08.2004. The Fast Track Sessions Court convicted him and imposed three years' rigorous imprisonment and a Rs. 1 lakh fine. The Kerala High Court, in a criminal appeal, examines the evidentiary chain—seizure details, sampling, sealing, and the chemical report (Ext. P8). The appellant argues the contraband's genuineness is not established; the sampling from bulk quantity was done by a court official without statutory sanction; no specimen seal was produced; the sample did not reach the chemical examiner in tamper-proof form. The court cites Bhaskaran, Baburaj, Smithesh, Baby, and Rajamma to emphasize that sampling by magistrates or court staff without proper procedures renders Ext. P8 ineffective. On these grounds the court acquits the accused, sets aside the conviction and sentence, and orders his release; any depositions under interim orders are to be disbursed to him. This decision reinforces the importance of proper chain-of-custody and seal verification in narcotics or intoxicant seizures.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C). No.3028 of 2023

Dr.KRISHNASETHULAXMY v. State of Kerala and Others

Dr. Krishnasethulaxmy, a 27-year-old Ayurvedic doctor with 40% permanent disability (cerebral palsy) belonging to the Vishwakarma community, seeks reallocation to PG Ayurveda courses under the Persons with Disabilities quota in clinical subjects Salakyathanthram (Salakyathanthram) at Govt Ayurveda College, Kannur, or Kayachikilsa at Govt Ayurveda College, Thiruvananthapuram. She ranked eighth among physically disabled candidates in the All India Ayush PG Entrance Examination and achieved second position in disability verification during medical board counselling. The petition argues that the candidate portal offered eight options per the prospectus, but she was constrained to select only three options, all non-clinical and unrelated to disability needs, on priority due to alleged omissions. She allegedly met the Commissioner of Entrance Examinations in person on 23/01/2023, submitting representations requesting admission to earmarked clinical subjects. The petitioner contends the 2nd respondent failed to redress grievances and that non-clinical options were chosen to keep vacancies within the general category. She asserts eligibility for PwD quota and fitness for Kaya Chikilsa and Roga Nidanam, supported by certificates. The 2nd respondent counters that admissions follow the AYUSH prospectus (GO RT 617/2022/AYUSH) and that a State Medical Board and a State Level Committee found the petitioner eligible for PwD quota but only for non-clinical subjects. The court affirmed deference to expert committees and dismissed the petition, citing Nimmy Alphonsa Joseph and Albin Joseph. Ultimately, the writ petition is dismissed for lack of arbitrariness or illegality.

High Court of Kerala
CRP Nos. 461, 462 & 464 of 2014 and 147 & 148 of 2015

Common Order in CRP Nos. 461, 462 & 464 of 2014 and 147 & 148 of 2015, High Court of Kerala

These civil revision petitions arise from the same project dispute over compensation for trees cut along the Mysore-Kozhikode 400 kV electric line. Petitioners in OP Nos. 64/2011, 174/2010, 220/2012, 341/2012 and 337/2012 of the Court of the First Additional District Judge, Kozhikode challenge orders awarding compensation under Section 51 of the Indian Electricity Act, 2003 read with Sections 10 and 16 of the Indian Telegraph Act, 1885. The High Court, noting all cases are similar, refers to a common order in CRP No. 144/2013 and connected matters, and endorses the remand principle based on the Supreme Court's decision in Kerala State Electricity Board v. Livisha. The petitioners' counsel urged remand to fix compensation by considering the yield from each tree and the diminution in land value after ascertaining market value, following Livisha. The respondent did not seriously oppose. The court agrees that the batch is similarly situated and remands all petitions to determine yield from each tree and the land's diminishing value following Livisha, with liberty to adduce additional evidence, and directs the parties to appear on 17.10.2022. The orders under challenge are to be set aside, and the original petitions disposed of in light of the Livisha yardstick, with expeditious disposal given the period 2010–2012.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5272 OF 2024

Fahad Shamsudheen v. State of Kerala

Fahad Shamsudheen, the sole accused in Crime No.1285/2024 of Angamaly Police Station, Ernakulam, seeks pre-arrest bail under section 438 CrPC before the Kerala High Court. The case arises from an allegation that the petitioner compelled the de facto complainant to terminate her pregnancy at a private clinic, resulting in abortion, under section 313 IPC. The prosecution maintains there are materials showing the accused signed the required abortion form and that custodial interrogation is necessary to advance the investigation, arguing that granting bail would hamper the process. The petitioner, through counsel, contests the allegations, asserting a consensual relationship with the complainant since 2022, with a mutual decision to terminate the pregnancy. He contends the complainant later pursued a relationship with another person, leading to malice and a false FIR; hence, he is innocent, and there is no justification for custodial custody or for recovery. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, claiming incriminating materials and the need for interrogation. After hearing, the court finds that custodial interrogation is not necessary for proper investigation and that the circumstances justify pre-arrest bail, subject to conditions. The order enumerates conditions including surrender before the IO within 10 days, a bond of Rs.50,000 with two solvent sureties, appearance for interrogation, restraint from tampering with evidence or inducing witnesses, surrender of passport, and prohibition from involvement in other offences. The court clarifies the observations pertain to the bail application and not merits, and cites Sushila Aggarwal for continuing investigation while on bail.

High Court of Kerala
BA No. 4093 of 2024

Deepu PadmaraJan and Sreechand R S v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed by two accused in Crime No.539/2024 of Attingal Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners, Deepu PadmaraJan (accused no. 1) and Sreechand R S (accused no. 2), are charged with offences including 294(b), 323, 324 and 326 r/w 34 IPC. The prosecution alleges that on 10.04.2024 the first accused assaulted the defacto complainant over delay in serving fried chicken, causing a fracture to the facial bones; allegedly, the other accused aided in the act. The defence contends that 326 is not attracted and that there is no need for custodial interrogation, arguing that the FIR itself does not establish a prima facie case for 326 and that the prosecution has included 326 to deny bail. The Public Prosecutor presents treatment records showing the injury and asserts material implicating the petitioners, while acknowledging that the specific overt act for 326 is attributed to the first accused. The court cites several Supreme Court judgments to reiterate that anticipatory bail is an extraordinary remedy and should be granted only in exceptional circumstances. After weighing submissions and the available material, the court dismisses the first petitioner’s bail plea, but allows pre-arrest bail to the second petitioner with conditions, emphasizing safeguards to prevent tampering and ensuring appearance and no further offences.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P.No.1527 of 2016

Dinesh Kumar v. Sajeevan and State of Kerala

This Kerala High Court criminal revision challenges the conviction of Dinesh Kumar under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, recorded by the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Perumbavoor, and affirmed on appeal by the Sessions Court. The complainant alleged that the accused issued a cheque for Rs 3,00,000 in discharge of a loan; the trial court found guilt and imposed imprisonment till rising of the court, along with a fine of Rs 3 lakh and compensation under Section 357(3) Cr.P.C. The revision contends that the demand notice did not disclose transaction particulars and seeks to re-examine these aspects as part of the prosecution’s case. The High Court reiterates the limited scope of revision under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C.: it is supervisory and not an appeal, and cannot re‑appreciate evidence unless there is gross miscarriage or perverse findings. Citing State of Kerala v. Puttumana Illath Jathavedan Namboodiri and Sanjaysinh Ramrao Chavan, the judge clarifies that the revisional court should not substitute its view for that of the trial court. The court discusses the presumption under Sections 118 and 139 of the NI Act, noting that once the complainant proves the transaction, the reverse onus shifts to the accused who must rebut by preponderance of probabilities, with Bir Singh and Kalamani Tex cited in support. It observes that Divakaran K.K. v. State of Kerala was overruled by Basheer v. C.K. Usmankoya, and ultimately dismisses the revision, directing execution of the sentence by 3 November 2022.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 12998 of 2022

Vishraam Builders Navodhrutham and Prabhakaran v. Revenue Divisional Officer, Tahsildar (Chavakkad) and Village Officer, Guruvayur

The petitioners, Vishraam Builders Navodhrutham and Prabhakaran, challenge a Building Tax Act, 1975 assessment relating to a 26-unit apartment complex. The assessing authority treated the entire complex as a single building, levying Rs. 4,52,400 as building tax and Rs. 39,000 as luxury tax. Petitioners contend that each apartment, about 700 sq ft, should be assessed independently under the statute since multiple owners funded the construction and the complex comprises separate units. They characterize Ext.P14 (the assessment order) as perverse, arbitrary, and non-speaking, arguing that it fails to address material contentions and violates natural justice; they rely on Abraham Thomas and Others v. State of Kerala and Others (2012 (2) KHC 792) regarding speaking orders. The Government Pleader argues that since the petitioners invoked statutory remedies, they should pursue revision under Section 13 rather than approach Article 226. The court acknowledges that normally a revision would be appropriate but, given the nature of the assessment order and to avoid delaying tax collection, proceeds to review. It finds Ext.P14 non-speaking and violative of natural justice, sets aside Ext.P14, Ext.P15, Ext.P16, and Ext.P20, and grants petitioners six weeks to file objections with a hearing, directing fresh assessment within three months; cooperation of petitioners is required, otherwise the authority may proceed under law.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 7863 of 2022

JAYASREE P.R. v. COUNCIL OF SCIENTIFIC & INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH, HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT GROUP (EXAMINATION UNIT), CSIR, NEW DELHI & UNIVERSITY GRANTS COMMISSION

Jayasree P.R., a petitioner with M.Sc in Physics and B.Ed in Physical Science, challenged the final answer key of the CSIR-UGC NET examination (JRF/NET) conducted on 18.12.2016. The dispute centers on Question 75 in Part C of Code 5C, involving the energy required to split an alpha particle into tritium and proton. The provisional key listed 19.3 MeV as correct; the petitioner chose option 3 (19.3 MeV) as the nearest correct answer. In Ext.P5, the provisional key kept 19.3 MeV, but the final key altered to option 1 (32.2 MeV), yielding a marks deficit that kept the petitioner below the cutoff of 34.09%. She contends the wrong key or the deletion of the question would have changed the outcome in her favor, and along with two others, had approached this Court in W.P.(C) No.11673 of 2017 seeking rectification. The respondents argued that the petition is barred by res judicata, and on merits, that option 1 was the correct answer and that academic decisions are best left to experts. The Kerala High Court, relying on prior judgments and expert opinions, ultimately held that the matter concerns an academic evaluation, and that the relief sought cannot be granted in this fresh petition. The petition is dismissed. The decision reflects deference to academic judgments and limits on judicial intervention in examination minutiae.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 1662 OF 2021

Themiz Mohammed Ayapally v. State of Kerala

In CRL.MC No.1662 of 2021 before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, the petitioner Themiz Mohammed Ayapally, accused No.5 in Crime No.7/2003 of Vazhakkad Police Station, seeks to quash further proceedings in LP 17/2019 in CP 54/2007 on the ground that acquittal of the remaining accused undermines the substratum of the prosecution. The crime involved kidnapping and alleged gang rape of the victim (PW1) by five accused under IPC sections 366 and 376(2)(g) r/w 34. The Sessions Court acquitted four co-accused after trial; the petitioner contends that, with the substratum of the case dislodged, continuing proceedings against him would be futile. The prosecution’s case, as per final report, largely rested on the testimony of PW1 and her parents, who, during trial, contradicted the original version, failed to identify the accused, and revealed inconsistencies about who kidnapped and raped PW1. The court references Sahadevan v. State of Tamil Nadu, Moosa v. Sub Inspector of Police, and Ajith v. State of Kerala to emphasize that where the entire prosecution is unreliable and cannot be proved beyond reasonable doubt, the benefit should accrue to all accused, not just those who faced trial. On this basis, the High Court exercises its inherent power under Cr.P.C. Section 482 and quashes LP 17/2019/CP 54/2007. The CRL.M.C is allowed.