Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 553 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No. 2274/2021

Sreedharan Paraprath v. Sahadevan P. and others

The original petition (OP(C) No. 2274/2021) filed in the Kerala High Court challenges Ext.P12, an order dated 20.10.2021 in I.A.4/2021 in O.S.412/2016 of the Munsiff Court, Kuthuparamba. The petitioner (plaintiff in O.S.412/2016) seeks to set aside the order and restore the process for identifying the plaint-scheduled property via remission of the commission report. There are consolidated suits (O.S.412/2016 and O.S.353/2016) for permanent prohibitory injunctions against the respondents who contend non-possession/identity issues regarding the property. An Advocate Commissioner was appointed and a commission report (Ext.P4) exists; Ext.P12 dismissed Ext.P10 on delay, though the petitioner argues there was no sitting in court for long periods (as per Ext.P13 B-diary). The High Court observes that property identification is mandatory in injunction suits and cites Pattathari Kuttiraman v. Puthukkudi Narayanan to support this position. The Court sets aside Ext.P12, allows Ext.P10, directs appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to identify the properties in both plaints, permits work memos and objections to the commission report, and orders expeditious disposal of the suits by 31.03.2023. The decision underscores supervisory relief under Article 227 of the Constitution to correct a misappreciation of pleadings and material.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO.3398 OF 2023

M/S B & B GRANITES v. Union of India and others

This writ petition filed by M/S B & B GRANITES challenges the condition imposed in the Environmental Clearance (Ext.P3) requiring clearance from the Standing Committee of the National Board for Wildlife (SCNBWL) before commencing quarrying activities near Peechi-Vazhani Wildlife Sanctuary. The petitioner alleges that the site is situated beyond the Eco-Sensitive Zone (ESZ) boundaries and that the Office Memorandum of 08.08.2019 mandating SCNBWL clearance, and the 10 km radius concept, are misapplied. The petitioner also notes the 6.7 km (to buffer zone) and 9.5 km (to core area) distances from the sanctuary and relies on a Supreme Court order in Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India (2022) stating that restrictions should be limited to ESZ boundaries. An interim inspection by the Chief Wildlife Warden reported distances from the sanctuary boundary and revised ESZ measurements, indicating the quarry lies at a substantial distance from the core/ESZ. The petitioner contends that since the quarry lies outside ESZ and beyond its boundaries, SCNBWL clearance is unnecessary and restrictive. The Court, after considering the evidence and the Supreme Court’s guidance, allowed the petition, quashed Ext.P3’s condition 3(3), and directed the 4th respondent to issue the quarry lease in accordance with law without insisting on SCNBWL clearance. The order underscores a reliance on ESZ-based restrictions and statutory provisions of the Environment Protection Act, 1986.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) No.100 of 2023

Archana Santhosh & Sachin K. Vaikan v. Nil (O.P.(FC) No.100 of 2023)

Archana Santhosh and Sachin K. Vaikan, petitioners in O.P.(FC) No.100 of 2023, challenge Ext.P3 order of the Family Court, Ernakulam, which refused leave under the proviso to Section 14(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act to permit filing a divorce petition before the one-year period from marriage. The petition was filed under Article 227 challenging the interlocutory application I.A. No.7576 of 2022 in an unnumbered original petition of 2022. The Family Court had followed the principles in Amardeep Singh v. Harveen Kaur and Vishnudas H and held that while the six-month cooling period under Section 13B can be waived, the one-year bar under Section 14(1) cannot be relaxed. The petitioners argued that the proviso empowers the court to grant leave for presentation before expiry of one year if there exist sufficient reasons, citing exceptional hardship or depravity; they described circumstances: marriage on 07.09.2022; separation from 13.09.2022; non‑consummation of the marriage; and potential hardship to their careers and mental well-being if forced to wait. The Kerala High Court, applying the Amardeep Singh principle and Vishnudas H, held that the proviso creates two instances where leave may be granted: exceptional hardship or exceptional depravity. It reversed Ext.P3 and allowed I.A.7576/2022, granting leave for presentation of a divorce petition on mutual consent. Consequently, the original petition is allowed and the petitioners may proceed with a mutual-consent divorce petition within the permissible framework.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C)No.2310 of 2023

Arun Mohan; Sanal Kumar T.C; Sandeep P.V v. State of Kerala; Travancore Devaswom Board; Devaswom Commissioner; Special Tahsildar (Land Conservation); Parakkadavu Grama Panchayat; Secretary Parakkadavu Grama Panchayat; and others

The petitioners, devotees of Chirakkal Sree Mahadeva Temple and members of the Temple Advisory Committee, filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking mandamus to reclaim approximately 10 acres of temple land from third parties and to require the Devaswom authorities to act on a complaint to reclaim temple property. They alleged that vast temple property had been diverted through false tenancy and patta arrangements, reducing temple land to about 64 cents, and sought protection of temple assets and prevention of waste into the temple pond due to a nearby manufacturing unit. The petition relies on judicial pronouncements emphasizing trustees’ duty to safeguard temple properties (A.A. Gopalakrishnan v. Cochin Devaswom Board; Travancore Devaswom Board v. Mohanan Nair) and the guardianship role of courts under parens patriae. The court recounted Exts. P1–P9 and related correspondence showing historic attempts to retrieve land, including an Ombudsman order and purchase certificates. It noted that the dispute involves title to multiple parcels, including an 8th respondent’s purchase certificate, and discussed the Kerala and Madras HRCE Acts, the Kerala Land Reforms Act, and associated rules and provisions. Ultimately, the court disposed of the petition by directing appropriate proceedings under the Kerala Land Conservancy Act to evict encroachers and to conclude within six months, while maintaining status quo on certain properties pending determination.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C.No. 7307/2019

Crl.M.C.No. 7307 of 2019 (Sajith N.K v. Jishabai and State of Kerala)

This criminal miscellaneous case challenges the order of the Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Payyoli, in C.C. No. 380/2018, by which the petitioner Sajith N.K. was summoned under sections 196, 199, 200 and 209 IPC on a private complaint filed by respondent Jishabai. The respondent alleged that the petitioner, while denying marriage, submitted false affidavits in judicial proceedings, including an affidavit asserting a marriage on 22/03/2009 at a temple under Hindu Nambiar custom, and that similar false affidavits were filed in other proceedings (Family Court OP 259/14 and CMP 2893/15). The earlier criminal case against the petitioner for rape under Section 376(2)(n) IPC was closed with acquittal. During these proceedings, the Magistrate conducted inquiry under Cr.P.C. Section 202 and took cognizance. The petitioner contends that for offences enumerated in clause (b) of sub-section (1) of Section 195 Cr.P.C., a private complaint under Section 200 Cr.P.C. is impermissible, and that the remedy lies under Section 340 Cr.P.C. The High Court agrees, holding that Sections 195 and 340 must be read together; the bar under 195 and the remedy under 340 are within the exclusive province of the court. Consequently, Annexure 2 (cognizance) is set aside and the respondent is directed to file a Section 340(1) Cr.P.C. application in the Family Court; if such an application is filed, the Family Court shall decide according to law. The Crl.M.C. is allowed with these directions, directing that the proper recourse be pursued in the Family Court under 340(1).

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5842 OF 2024

Muhammed Riyas O.A. v. State of Kerala

On 25 July 2024, in Bail Application No. 5842 of 2024, this Court considered Muhammed Riyas O.A., accused No.3 in Crime No. 562/2024 of Parappanangadi Police Station, Malappuram. The prosecution alleges a conspiracy in which the accused, with others, intercepted the defacto complainant’s vehicle, smashed its windscreen, threatened with a gun, and assaulted a companion with a sword, abducting a friend. The offences charged include Sections 363 and 307 read with 34 IPC, and Sections 27(1) and 25(3) of the Arms Act; Section 120B IPC was later added. The petitioner was in judicial custody since 26 May 2024. The prosecution contends that he is the kingpin and that grant of bail would lead to witness intimidation and tampering with evidence; they seek continued custody. The counsel for the petitioner submits innocence, points to the absence of any prior criminal record, the near-completion of investigation, and the absence of meaningful reasons to keep him detained. The learned judge cites the presumption of innocence, the general principle that bail is the rule and jail the exception, and Article 21’s protection of liberty, citing Sanjay Chandra and Dataram Singh. After weighing the materials, the court finds no compelling grounds to deny bail and, in the interest of justice, grants it subject to conditions: Rs. 50,000 bond with two sureties, appearance, no intimidation, no new offences, passport surrender, and standard supervisory conditions as per Sushila Aggarwal, with continued IO oversight where appropriate.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 10871 OF 2022

ANOOP P PAULOSE v. STATE MISSION DIRECTOR NATIONAL HEALTH MISSION, GENERAL HOSPITAL JUNCTION, THIRUVANANTHURAM; DISTRICT MEDICAL OFFICER (HEALTH) CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICE OF DISTRICT HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE SOCIETY, AROGYAKERALAM, THRISSUR; DISTRICT PROGRAMME MANAGER, NATIONAL HEALTH MISSION, AROGYAKERALAM, OLD DISTRICT HOSPITAL COMPOUND, ROUND EAST, THRISSUR; CHAIRMAN AND DISTRICT COLLECTOR, THRISSUR, DISTRICT HEALTH AND FAMILY WELFARE SOCIETY, THRISSUR

The petitioner, Anoop P Paulose, was employed in a health administration role under the 1st respondent and was terminated from service by Ext. P17 following a departmental inquiry conducted by the 3rd respondent. He asserts that the termination is stigmatic and violates due process since the charge details were not made available prior to the hearing, he was not allowed to peruse witness statements or cross-examine witnesses, and the hearing was conducted without adequate notice or opportunity. The respondents contend that the Executive Committee of the District Health and Family Welfare Society examined the matter and recommended termination following a review of the petitioner’s responses to memos. The court emphasizes that even for temporary/contract employees, stigmatic dismissals require a fair opportunity to defend. Citing Pavanendra Narayan Verma, K.C. Joshi, and Vijayakumaran C.P., the court finds merit in the petitioner’s claim of lack of due process and directs the 1st respondent to consider Ext. P16 and to pass orders after affording a reasonable opportunity to be heard, within six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of the judgment, with the interim order remaining in force. The petition is disposed with these directions, leaving other issues open for consideration.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 7482 OF 2022

IREL (India) Limited v The Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act and The Appellate Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act

This writ petition challenges orders of the Controlling Authority under the Payment of Gratuity Act (2002-2021) granting gratuity to the first respondent for the period 01.06.1991 to 31.05.1993, counted as part of service. The petitioner, a unit of IREL (India) Limited (Rare Earths Division), contends that the two-year training period cannot be treated as regular employment and must be excluded from gratuity calculation, arguing that the trainee is an apprentice and not an employee under Section 2(e) of the Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The petitioner relies on Indian Rare Earths Ltd. v. K.S. John (2013 KHC 673) to support the view that training post-appointment falls outside Section 2(e). The first respondent asserts that the training period involved actual work in the plant, with duties akin to regular staff, and that the period was counted in the employee’s service, yielding gratuity. The court, after examining the text and authorities, holds that a trainee under a contract of employment may be covered by the Act unless strictly an “apprentice,” and that the nature of duties and overall object of the Act must guide interpretation. It concludes there was no illegality in the challenged orders and dismisses the petition, upholding the gratuity entitlement for the disputed period.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.APPEAL NO.455 OF 2021

Suresh Kannan v. State of Kerala and The SHO, Kannur Railway Police Station

This Kerala High Court criminal appeal concerns the conviction of the appellant, Suresh Kannan, for murder under IPC Section 302 and an offence under Section 151 of the Railways Act, 1989, as recorded in the Special Court for Trial of Offences Against Women and Children, Thalassery (SC No.241/2015). The trial court found the appellant guilty after a trial that encompassed eyewitness accounts, the victim’s dying declaration, post‑mortem findings, and chemical analysis identifying petrol as the accelerant. The incident occurred early on 20 October 2014 at Kannur Railway Station when Pathu @ Pathumma was set on fire inside a train carriage after a dispute over accompanying him to Mangalore; she succumbed to burn injuries. The prosecution’s case rested on testimonies of railway staff and other witnesses who observed the victim in distress, the circumstances at the railway platform, and the appellant’s flight from the scene. The High Court’s analysis delves into the legality and weight of Ext.P35 (a confession) under CrPC Section 164, while also considering the dying declaration (court’s reliance on PW24’s account) and identification parade evidence (Ext.P33). The court ultimately upholds the conviction, rejects the defense challenge to Ext.P35, and affirms the trial court’s sentence, concluding that the prosecution proved murder beyond reasonable doubt and the related railway loss.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.21678 of 2021

K.A Jacob v Union of India and Marine Products Export Development Authority (MPEDA) and others

This writ petition challenges a long disciplinary process initiated against K.A. Jacob, a former Senior Accountant at MPEDA. He was suspended in 2015 after allegations of fraudulent medical reimbursements, including tampered bills and certificates purportedly issued by Dr. Maya, an authorised medical attendant. The charges were framed under the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965, with proceedings conducted through an inquiry officer. The petitioner replied, but sought 14 additional documents and several witnesses; the inquiry officer partly granted requests and rejected others, and the proceedings proceeded despite the petitioner’s non-cooperation, including an ex parte finding in the latter stage. The petitioner challenged the inquiry in prior petitions; eventually, in 2016 the inquiry report held the charges proven, and the disciplinary authority (the Chairman) dismissed him from service. The appellate order confirmed, and subsequent petitions sought to quash orders Ext.P1, P21 and P24, or reinstate him provisionally. The Kerala High Court’s judgment analyzes MPEDA’s Act and the authority structure, including whether the Chairman can act as appointing and disciplinary authority. It emphasizes the Chairman as the authority’s alter ego, supported by statutory provisions and standing instructions. It notes that the petitioner, by not cooperating and by participating in some proceedings, is estopped from challenging the process. The court ultimately dismisses the petition, upholding the disciplinary action while acknowledging the outline of natural justice challenges and proportionality arguments, but finding no grounds to interfere with the inquiry or the penalty.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No.3931 of 2023

Dr. Aravind Madanan v. State of Kerala and Another

Dr. Aravind Madanan, an orthopedic surgeon, is before the Kerala High Court in a criminal miscellaneous case seeking to quash FIR No.124/2023 of Thoppumpady Police Station (Ernakulam district) alleging offences under IPC sections 376, 376(2)(n), 354, 451 and 323, and the corresponding proceedings under Cr.P.C. The alleged offences relate to sexual acts alleged to have occurred in November 2021 at Emerald Hotel, Kadavanthra, and in October 2022 at Belvether Hotel, Thoppumpady. The victim, a divorcee and patient, appeared to file an affidavit stating that she is the petitioner’s friend and that the dispute has been settled; she has no objection to quashing the proceedings. The Public Prosecutor stated that the matter was inquired by the I.O., who found the dispute amicably settled. The High Court invoked its inherent power under Section 482 Cr.P.C, guided by Gian Singh, Narinder Singh and Laxmi Narayan, to consider whether quashing is appropriate where the offences are not compoundable but the dispute is private and settled. It emphasized that heinous offences such as rape generally resist quashing, but private disputes with settlement may be terminated if continuation would cause injustice or abuse of process. Noting the timing of settlement and unexplained delay, the Court concluded that continued prosecution would be oppressive and did not meet ends of justice, thereby allowing the petition and quashing the FIR and proceedings.

High Court of Kerala
WA NO. 858 OF 2022

S. Afsar Ahmed v. State of Kerala and Others

This writ appeal challenges a 2019–2021 sequence involving the amendment to the bye-laws of the Kerala Hockey Society, a body registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860. The appellant, formerly Secretary General of the society, contends that the bye-law amendment carried out at the AGM on 2 October 2016 was effected surreptitiously by members 5–7 without following the bye-laws’ procedure, and that the District Registrar (2nd respondent) and the Registrar of Societies acted on the amended bye-laws without proper verification. Ext. P10 records the amendment; Ext. P17 is the District Registrar’s order upholding it, while Ext. P17’s reasons were sought to be reviewed. The petitioner approached this Court under Article 226, arguing improper registration and challenging the legality of the amendment. The learned Single Judge dismissed the petition, holding that internal disputes within a private society are not amenable to writ jurisdiction, since the society is not a “State” under Article 226. On appeal, the court acknowledges that Zee Telefilms and BCCI v. CODA were distinguishable and not applicable on the facts, but partly allows the appeal by vacating a finding that prevented civil redress, thereby enabling the petitioner to pursue civil remedies while leaving the Registrar’s order intact. The overall outcome is a limited relief to pursue due process in a civil forum rather than direct writ intervention.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 616 of 2022

Vallikkadan Ayamu Haji v Vallikkadan Pathummakutty and Others

This Regular Second Appeal challenges the final decree for partition in O.S. No.293/2012 (I.A. No.305/2015) filed in the Sub Court, Manjeri, and affirmed by the Additional District Judge, Manjeri, in A.S. No.105/2018. The suit sought partition of plaint A and B schedule properties. After trial, a preliminary decree was passed finding the properties partitionable; a final decree was framed by metes and bounds, with Ext. C2 and Ext. C2(a) forming part of the Commission report. The appellant, the 1st defendant, challenged Ext. C2 in relation to plaint A schedule, arguing that Plot No.5 creates a way to plaint A schedule via a mud road and that Plot No.4, allotted to him and acquired from others, is rocky and less cultivable, while plots for others are more favorable. He further contends that the right of way issues should have been decided in the final decree proceedings, not in separate litigation. Respondents countered that a mud road exists on the northern side of plaint A schedule and that there is no public road; the Commissioner’s report and the plans show a continuous access path, including Plot 5. The trial court and appellate court upheld the final decree. The High Court held no substantial question of law and dismissed the appeal, upholding the decree. The matter engages the statutory framework governing second appeals and the mandatory requirement of substantial questions of law.

High Court of Kerala
BA Nos.976 & 979 of 2023

IRSHAD v. STATE OF KERALA

This is a sexual bail petition decision by the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam concerning IRSHAD, the 1st accused in Crime Nos. 15/2023 and 16/2023 registered at Ettumanoor Police Station, Kottayam. The petitions, filed under Section 439 CrPC, sought regular bail pending trial. The court heard on 15 February 2023, with counsel for the petitioner and the Public Prosecutor presenting arguments. The prosecution alleges that on 02 January 2023, the 1st accused slapped the defacto complainant and, along with accused Nos. 2 and 3, beat him and robbed Rs.5,500 from Prem Prasad; in Crime No.15/2023 the charges include 324, 323, 294(b), 308 read with 34 IPC. In Crime No.16/2023, offences under 323 and 394 read with 34 IPC are stated. The defense submits that two crimes arose from the same occurrence and that the accused is innocent; it notes the accused was arrested on 05 January 2023 and has been in custody since then. The Public Prosecutor highlights the accused’s criminal antecedents and states the investigation is progressing. The court, after perusing the case diary and IO report, finds no serious injuries in medical records but emphasizes stringent bail conditions due to antecedents. It ultimately allows bail on Rs.50,000 bonds with two sureties per crime, imposes conditions to prevent witness intimidation, ensure cooperation, and requires attendance before the IO on Tuesdays for two months or until final report. The order closes with the judge’s endorsement granting bail with specified conditions.

High Court of Kerala
CON.CASE(C) NO. 2091 OF 2019

Cont.Case (C) No. 2091 of 2019

Cont.Case (C) No. 2091 of 2019 is a contempt petition filed by a large group of petitioners (former petitioners in W.P.(C) No. 31850 of 2016) alleging willful disobedience of the directions contained in Annexure I to the Kerala High Court’s judgment dated 12 October 2018 in W.P.(C) 31850/2016 and connected matters. The petitioners’ challenge centers on the implementation of pension reforms under the Employees' Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) scheme, particularly following the 2014 amendment notified as G.S.R. 609(E). The Supreme Court’s detailed decision dated 04 November 2022 in Civil Appeals Nos. 8143-44 of 2022 (and connected matters) held that the 2014 notification is legal and valid, read down certain provisions of the pension scheme, and extended options under the amended scheme with time adjustments, while relying on earlier precedents such as RC Gupta (2018) 14 SCC 809. The Kerala High Court, after considering the Apex Court’s directions, held that the petitioners’ entitlement for higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO in accordance with law. The court directed EPFO to undertake the exercise in line with the 2022 judgment and closed the contempt case, reserving the petitioners’ rights under the Supreme Court’s directions. The order underscores the judiciary’s insistence on lawful recalibration of pension entitlements within the statutory framework while ensuring remedy to affected employees.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC No.2533 of 2021

Renjith @ Munna v. State of Kerala

Renjith @ Munna, the petitioner, challenged six calendar cases decided by the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Chengannur, arising from CC Nos. 1683/2018, 1684/2018, 1685/2018, 1686/2018, 1687/2018 and 2096/2018. In all except CC 1687/2018 the offences were under section 379 IPC, while CC 1687/2018 involved section 511 IPC. The judgments were passed on 25.06.2018 after the petitioner pleaded guilty; sentences ranged from three years’ simple imprisonment (for five cases) to one year (for CC 1687/2018), with judicial custody commencing 18.01.2018. The petitioner contends that the annexed judgments do not specify whether the sentences should run concurrently or consecutively, and that under section 427(1) CrPC, the failure to direct concurrency would require consecutive imprisonment, potentially totaling 16 years, which would violate Article 21 of the Constitution given the maximum sentence for 379 IPC is three years. The State opposes automatic concurrency, but the court recognises that section 427(1) empowers courts to order concurrent sentences and that High Courts may intervene for miscarriage of justice under Article 226/482 CrPC. Relying on Benson v. State of Kerala, Iqram v. State of Uttar Pradesh, and Mohd Zahid v. State, the High Court ultimately exercises its discretion to grant concurrency. The court orders that sentences in CC 1685/2018, 1686/2018, 1687/2018 and 2096/2018 run concurrently with CC 1684/2018, with CC 1683/2018 already served, and directs release on 12.08.2023, subject to no other pending penal actions. It leaves CC 609/2018 and CC 293/2018 untouched.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.4742 OF 2023

Athulshaji, Ramaswami and Vinod v. State of Kerala

This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC 4742 of 2023) arises from CC 769/2017 pending in the Judicial Magistrate of First Class–I, Punalur, involving accused Athulshaji, Ramaswami and Vinod charged with offences under Sections 451, 323 and 324 read with Section 34 IPC. The petition under Section 482 CrPC seeks quashing of the criminal proceedings in light of an amicable settlement between the parties, supported by affidavits and a recorded statement by the de facto complainant that he bears no lasting grievance. The State opposes quashing, maintaining that the exercise of inherent jurisdiction cannot be invoked merely on a civil convenience, and that serious or public interest offences should not be brushed aside. The Kerala High Court, relying on State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and the line of Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, lays down the principle that quashing may be permissible where the dispute is private, the offences are non-compoundable but of private character, and there is an entire settlement between parties. It weighs the gravity of the alleged offences, injuries, and antecedents, and finds that quashing would promote peace and ends of justice. The petition is allowed; the final report and all further proceedings are quashed, with Annexure-A2 Final Report in Crime No. 487/2017 and related proceedings in CC 769/2017 quashed. The Court emphasises that serious offences would not be quashed and explains the balance between private settlement and public interest.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C. No. 4879/2021

Bijo Alexander v. State of Kerala

This is a Cr.L.M.C. under section 482 of the Cr.P.C filed by Bijo Alexander, the sole accused in CC No.21/2020 (Crime VC 14/2016/SCE) pending before the Court of Enquiry Commissioner & Special Judge, Muvattupuzha. The accused, a police officer in the Kerala Police, is charged under section 13(1)(e) r/w 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, with amassing wealth of ₹33,38,126 during 2011–2015 disproportionate to his known income. He seeks to quash Annexure A5 final report by VACB on the ground that the investigating officer did not consider several assets and income disclosed in Annexure A3 (property statements Form Nos. I–VI), including agricultural income of ₹20,93,800; ₹3,50,000 received from his brother‑in‑law; and ₹6,00,000 from sale of gold ornaments, which would reduce the apparent disproportionate assets. He had earlier approached WP(C) No.18664/2020 seeking to compel consideration of these statements. VACB contends that the final report was prepared after scrutiny of Annexure A3, and the petitioner was given opportunities to present his case; the matter involves disputed facts and evidence, not a matter for 482. The High Court, citing Kurukshetra University; Bhajan Lal; Rashmi Kumar; Neeharika Infrastructure; and Thommandru Hannah, reiterates that 482 Cr.P.C. powers are exceptional, not routine, and should not be used to conduct mini‑trials or weigh merits. Accordingly, the petition is dismissed, though discharge relief may be sought before the trial court.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 31348 OF 2022

M/s. Mangalodayam Private Limited v. The Superintendent, Central Tax & Central Excise, I Circle, Thrissur Range; The Joint Commissioner (Appeals), Office of the Commissioner (Appeals), Central Tax, Central Excise and Customs; Union of India; Central Board of Indirect Taxes & Customs

Mangalodayam Private Limited challenges an order cancelling its GST registration under the CGST/SGST regime. The petitioner contends that the cancellation was improperly triggered by a show-cause notice issued in Form GST REG-31 (used for suspension) rather than a proper cancellation notice under Rule 21 and Form GST REG-17, and that the notice lacked crucial details such as the period of non-filing returns. The High Court notes the notice (Ext. P2) was vague about the specific grounds and period; it also recalls its own decision in W.P. (C) No. 28783/2022 emphasizing that a REG-31 show-cause cannot substitute a Rule 21-based cancellation notice. Relying on Babu Verghese and Gujarat/Madhya Pradesh High Court authorities, the court holds that the action to cancel registration must be grounded in the prescribed form and procedure. The court further discusses the scope of interpretation in fiscal statutes, citing Government of Kerala v Mother Superior Adoration Convent to reject over-broad revenue-favouring readings. Consequently, Ext. P2 is quashed, though not absolving the petitioner of fiscal liabilities; returns with tax, late fee, interest and penalties must be filed within two weeks of restoration. The petition is allowed, with the registration to be restored subject to compliance.

High Court of Kerala
RP No. 338 of 2022

SURESHKUMAR.K vs STATE OF KERALA, THE LABOUR COMMISSIONER, AND THE KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION

This is a review petition (RP No. 338 of 2022) challenging the Kerala High Court’s 3 August 2021 judgment dismissing OA (KAT) No.114 of 2021, which had challenged the order in OA (KAT) No.896 of 2017 before the Kerala Administrative Tribunal. The original applicant, Sureshkumar K., contended that the State PSC’s selection process for a post under KS&SSR Part II allowed an adverse party to rely on documents and qualifications submitted after the deadline, and that the PSC had irregularly finalized rank lists in 2014 and 2017 while the applicant failed to produce the requisite experience certificates in time. The Tribunal and later this Court emphasized that Rule 17(c) of KS&SSR Part II required certificates to be produced when requested and well before finalization of the rank list, and that the applicant’s belated submission of an Annexure A-23 experience certificate in 2017 could not rescue the candidature which had been rejected in 2010. The court also noted the PSC’s reliance on Jyoti K.K. v. Kerala PSC to treat a higher qualification as satisfying the lower prescribed qualification and cited Soni P.M. (DB) to underscore deadline discipline. The petition was dismissed, with the bench indicating that review cannot revisit merits or substitute appellate review for the original judgment.