Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 554 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
WA 1612 of 2023

Gowrikutty.G.S and others v State of Kerala and others

This intra-court appeal (W.A. No.1612 of 2023) arises from a Writ Petition filed by contract-based Library Assistants of the University of Kerala alleging denial of regularisation after ten years of service. The learned Single Judge dismissed WP(C) No.19991 of 2023 on the ground that the petitioners were engaged on contractual terms, not through a statutory selection process, and that regular appointments to non-teaching posts are to be made by a select process under Kerala University First Statutes and KPSC rules, with mutual waivers of regularisation in their agreements. The appellants argued that they were recruited through a process known to law, performed duties akin to regular posts, and that double standards denied them equal treatment with others who were regularised. The respondents maintained that contract employment is permissible but does not confer a right to permanent absorption, citing Umadevi (3) and other precedents to insist that regular recruitment must be through due process before regularisation can be considered. The Kerala High Court, per a Division Bench, reaffirmed that irregular contract appointments without due process cannot entitle personnel to regularisation; it relied on constitutional principles of equality (Art.14) and the due process framework (Art.16) and the Umadevi doctrine to uphold the decision and dismissed the appeal. The effect is that the contractors’ demand for regularisation without compliant recruitment remains unaccepted.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 4337 OF 2006

R. Rajan Pillai v. Ibrahim Kutty (deceased) and State of Kerala and Addl.R3 Subaida Beevi and Sri Sangeetha Raj-PP

The revision petition arises from a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act for issuing a cheque in discharge of a debt. The accused, R. Rajan Pillai, was convicted by the Judicial First Class Magistrate-II, Pathanamthitta, for issuing Ext.P1 cheque which the complainant alleged to have been issued in discharge of a debt arising from the sale of wooden logs. The trial court sentenced him to simple imprisonment for six months and to pay Rs. 32,000 under Section 357(3) Cr.P.C. The Sessions Court, in appeal, confirmed the conviction but modified the sentence to imprisonment till rising of the court and to pay Rs. 32,000. In the revision petition before the Kerala High Court, the petitioner contends that the transaction and the cheque’s execution were not proven, and that Ext.P1 allegedly bears material alterations; he also argues that the presumption under Sections 118(a) and 139 NI Act cannot be invoked. The court, relying on established NI Act presumptions, held that the signature and execution were proved and there was no material alteration. It noted that revisional jurisdiction cannot re-appreciate the evidence. Consequently, the revision petition is dismissed, with no interference in the impugned judgments. The matter cites several authorities to discuss presumptions and onus in NI Act cases.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 4552 OF 2023

Sreejith and others v. State of Kerala

This is a petition under Section 482 CrPC filed by five accused—Sreejith, Kamaldev, Ganesh, Kiran and Mekhan—seeking quashing of CC No.1108/2017 on the file of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Irinjalakuda. The offences alleged are under Sections 341, 323, 294(b) read with 34 IPC, arising from an incident on 3 April 2017 in which the petitioners, in furtherance of a common intent, allegedly assaulted respondents 3 to 5. The petitioners’ counsel submits that the dispute has been amicably settled and both sides do not wish to pursue prosecution; affidavits from the respondents support the settlement. The Public Prosecutor expresses reservations about quashing merely on the basis of a settlement, noting that the offences are non-compoundable and that the case involves acts with serious impact on society; however, she concedes that there are no other crimes against the petitioners. The High Court, applying the framework from State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan, Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, holds that Section 482 power can be exercised to quash non-compoundable offences where the disputes are civil/private in nature and the settlement is genuine, while not applying to heinous offences or certain statutory offences. Having considered the circumstances—including the gravity of the offence, injuries, antecedents, and the consistence with the amicable settlement—the court allows the petition and quashes the proceedings and final report.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC 3965/2023 (and connected cases)

Crl.M.C Nos.3965 of 2023 & connected cases

These Criminal Miscellaneous Cases challenge an order dated 27 April 2023 of the Sub Divisional Magistrate, Fort Kochi, invoking Section 111 CrPC read with Section 107 CrPC, directing the petitioners to attend and show cause why they should not be ordered to execute a cash bond of Rs 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties for keeping the peace for a period of one year. The petitioners contend that before invoking Section 107, the Magistrate must apply his mind to the material before him and must be satisfied that there are sufficient grounds for proceeding; the order, which is identically worded across MC Nos. 139/23 to 145/23, merely states that Crime No 82/23 and information from the North Paravur Police Station exist, without detailing the nature of the alleged breach or the credible threat. Relying on Moidu v. State of Kerala, Peethambaran, Santhosh M.V., and Bejoy K.V., the petitioners urge that the remedy cannot be invoked on vague hunches or routine police reports. The State contends that the 107 CrPC provision is preventive, not punitive, and that the Magistrate's satisfaction was based on credible information. After examination, the Court agrees with the petitioners: the order lacks grounding materials and fails to satisfy Section 111's requisites; consequently, the Annexure A orders are quashed, and all further proceedings are set aside.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 584 of 2019

Ammini v. Subramanian (dead) LRs impleaded and Others

Ammini filed RSA 584 of 2019 challenging the judgment in AS 101 of 2016 arising from O.S. 430 of 2011, a partition suit concerning property originally belonging to the plaintiff’s father. The trial court dismissed the suit on the ground of estoppel and the plaintiff’s alleged receipt of her due share (Ext. B1) in 1999. The first appellate court dismissed the condonation of delay (564 days) in filing the appeal, leading to dismissal of the appeal. Aggrieved, Ammini approached the Kerala High Court in a second appeal, arguing that the delay was caused by the advocate’s misplacement of the case file and late contact, and urging liberal, justice-oriented condonation principles. The respondents counter that the delay is inordinate and unexplained, relying on the advocate’s affidavit and noting Ext. B1 and the 2011 Ext. A1 settlement deed to undermine the claim. They contend there is no substantial question of law to merit a second appeal under Section 100 CPC. The High Court reiterates the settled requirement that a second appeal lies only if a substantial question of law is involved, and ultimately holds that no such question arises, dismissing the appeal with no cost. The order relies on established jurisprudence on condonation of delay and the interpretation of substantial questions of law.

High Court of Kerala
CON.CASE(C) NO. 2140 OF 2022

Andandan T v. KSRTC and Prithwiraj S (Contempt of Court)

This Contempt of Court case concerns the alleged non-implementation by KSRTC of the High Court's directions contained in Annexure I, the 16 January 2018 judgment in W.P(C) No. 38303 of 2017. The petitioner, Andandan T., a KSRTC pensioner, alleges willful disobedience by KSRTC’s Chairman and Managing Director in applying the pension scheme and arrears as interpreted by this Court. The background traces to a Larger Bench decision in K.L. Francis v. KSRTC (2015) which, in the context of pending SLPs before the Supreme Court, held that provisional service followed by regular service should be counted for pension. The 2018 judgment noted pendency of SLPs and directed pension reckoning in line with that authority, subject to the Supreme Court proceedings. The Supreme Court disposed of the appeals in 2022 (CA Nos. 3161-3165/2019), clarifying ex-gratia payments, arrears, and installments. The petitioner seeks to enforce Annexure I’s directions and the benefits of the Supreme Court framing; KSRTC contends the petitioner is excluded from Annexure V’s 2021 pension scheme. After hearing, the Court closed the contempt case, with a caveat that the petitioner may challenge the 07 October 2022 order in appropriate proceedings, and it imposed costs of Rs 5,000 on KSRTC for wasting judicial time. The judgment underscores tensions between pension schemes, court directives, and evolving Supreme Court guidance.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 15874/2013

Corporation of Thiruvananthapuram v. Ajayachandran Nair Meena T.C. and The Town Planning Officer, Corporation of Thiruvananthapuram

This writ petition (WP(C) No. 15874/2013) filed by the Corporation of Thiruvananthapuram challenges Ext.P6, the Tribunal for Local Self Government Institutions’ order in Appeal No. 493/2012 (dated 27.08.2012), which allowed revival of a building permit issued to the first respondent for a multi-storey residential building. The core issue is whether a building permit can be extended when the land is proposed to be acquired under a Town Planning Scheme and whether reliance on an obsolete development plan can ground rejection of a construction permit. The Tribunal held that a mere proposal to acquire land and reliance on an obsolete scheme cannot bar registration of a permit and directed the Secretary of the Municipality to renew the permit, highlighting that the ultimate public purpose and compensation lie with the Land Acquisition Act, and that no notification under S. 4(1) was issued at the relevant times. The petitioner contends that the stop memo was issued by an unauthorized officer, that the development plan is obsolete, and that extension under S. 394 and Rule 15A(2) of the Kerala Municipality Act and Rules is required to be properly followed. The High Court, applying settled law (Raju S. Jethmalani; Padmini; Nazar; Shivaprasad) holds that there are no legal infirmities and dismisses the petition, while directing compliance with the Tribunal’s directions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.23186 of 2022 & connected cases

The Manager, Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools (Plus One admissions) v The State of Kerala and Others (W.P.(C) Nos.23186 of 2022 & connected cases)

These batch writ petitions challenge Government Order G.O.(M.S.) No.121/2022/G.Edn. dated 7 July 2022, and the accompanying Plus One admission prospectus, which together reduce the management quota for private aided higher secondary schools to 20% and reserve 10% of seats for students of the community to which the management belongs, with a mechanism requiring the management to declare its community. Petitioners argue this policy infringes Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution by impermissibly discriminating on religion/community and by reserving seats for the management’s own community. They further contend that such reservations undermine merit, violate prior court directions (OP No.18658/2000 etc.), and infringe Kerala Education Rules (Chapter VI, Rule 11) and various Government Orders (MS nos. 18/91, 29/91, 156/2003, 206/2005). Respondents defend the policy as a lawful executive decision to rectify anomalies in the admission process, ensure merit-based CAP admissions, increase transparency, and safeguard meritorious students in the context of government funding. The court undertakes a constitutional and policy analysis, distinguishing between the 20% management quota (upheld) and the 10% community quota (held unconstitutional), and directs that 10% seats be treated as open merit in CAP.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No.22634/2021

K. Viswanathan v Union of India & Others

This writ petition challenges two CBSE communications (Exts P10 and P11) issued to address the alleged wrong computation and tabulation of marks for the petitioner’s daughter, a Class X student at Christ Nagar Senior Secondary School, during the COVID-19 disrupted 2020-21 board examinations. CBSE, following the school’s participation, formulated a scheme byelaw dated 01.05.2021 for awarding marks out of 100 (20 internal, 80 board-based) and a dispute-resolution policy requiring schools to maintain student-wise internal records and documentation (Clause 8). The petitioner contends that the final marks awarded in Hindi and Science, derived from three Pre-Board/Model examinations, were inconsistent with the student’s demonstrated performance in prior years and with the school’s own records; he asserts misapplication of the policy and that the school’s and CBSE’s responses did not adequately justify the marks, nor was there a proper reclarification by the Result Committee or the CBSE Regional Office as per the policy. The respondents contend the representations fell within dispute types 1-3, and that the issue has been resolved through the CBSE’s decision. The High Court analyses the policy, circulars and Supreme Court directions (Mamta Sharma v. CBSE; Akshpreet Kaur v. CBSE), and ultimately dismisses the petition, holding interference is unwarranted and the resolution process was properly followed. The judgment underscores standardisation and moderation of marks to ensure fairness across schools.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.23186 of 2022 & connected cases

W.P.(C) Nos.23186 of 2022 & connected cases

This consolidated High Court of Kerala judgment deals with a set of writ petitions filed by managers of Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools challenging Government Order GO(MS) No.121/2022/G.Edn. dated 07.07.2022 and the accompanying Plus One admission prospectus for 2022-23. The core issue is the State’s policy to reduce the management quota in Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools to 20% and to reserve 10% of seats for students from the community to which the school’s management belongs, with a mechanism obliging the management to declare its community for admission under the 10% quota to be filled on merit. Petitioners contend this constitutes unconstitutional reservation and violates Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution, as well as earlier Court directions quashing community-based quotas, and would undermine merit and fairness. The State defends the policy as a rational administrative reform aimed at transparency and curbing malpractices in CAP admissions, arguing it is a policy decision within executive powers and need not be justified by detailed reasons. The judgment holds that GO. MS. 121/2022 to the extent it creates a 20% management quota is permissible, but the 10% community quota and the rider that failure to declare a community reverts to merit are unconstitutional. The Court directs that the 10% community quota seats be treated as open merit seats to be allotted strictly through the Centralized Allotment Process (CAP) on merit, and disposes of the petitions accordingly, while noting that admissions already carried out under declarations shall stand. The decision reaffirms the Government’s policy shift but strikes down the community-based subquotas as violative of constitutional principles, and directs uniform application through CAP for the removed seats.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 22276 OF 2021

XXX v. State of Kerala and others

Kerala High Court hears WP(C) 22276/2021 filed by XXX seeking protection and empowerment for victims of sexual assault, amid complaints of police indifference and trauma-induced distress. Justice Devan Ramachandran underscores the enduring pain of sexual violence, including humiliation, fear of stigma, memory-related trauma, and the need for comprehensive care that covers medical, psychological, and legal support. He notes that victims face a complex constellation of emotions and cites neurological impacts of trauma that can disrupt memory and decision-making. While acknowledging DNA analysis and interim orders already granted, the court emphasizes that victims must encounter a trauma-informed system from the moment a report is made. Following wide consultations with Bar, NGOs, and state agencies, he lays out a protective framework—integrating the Central and State schemes of One Stop Centres and Victim Rights Centres (VRC), and the role of a Victim Liaison Officer (VLO). The protocol calls for 112 and 100 emergency access, facility of lodging FIR/statement at a place of the victim’s choice, prompt notification to the jurisdictional police, and continuous, 24/7 support through the One Stop Centre, VRC, and ERSS-based helplines. It also requires police sensitization, privacy safeguards, and ongoing guidance under Cr.P.C. provisions until trial completion, while clarifying that these directions supplement, not replace, Supreme Court trial directives. The State is directed to circulate the directives.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 17787 of 2022

The Principal, Chinmaya Vidyalaya v. Kerala State Commission for Protection of Child Rights and Others

Chinmaya Vidyalaya, a CBSE-affiliated private unaided higher secondary school at Thazhathangadi, challenged an order of the Kerala State Commission for Protection of Child Rights directing the school to constitute a School Management Committee (SMC) with parental representation and to report within the 2022-23 academic year. The petitioner's grievance centers on paragraph 6(c) of Exhibit P7 and the consequential Exhibits P7(a) and P10, which required creation of a parallel SMC and threatened coercive action for non-compliance. The school argues that CBSE bye-laws govern SMC formation (Ext.P8) and that state or RTE provisions do not apply to unaided institutions not receiving government aid, under Section 21 of Act 35 of 2009. It contends that the SMC, if any, must strictly conform to CBSE bye-laws and that the Commission has no power to impose a CBSE-parallel body. The CBSE and Government Pleader counters emphasize that CBSE-affiliated schools must adhere to their bye-laws and any applicable state regulations, and that where RTE or state rules are not in force, Rule 8.2.2 of the CBSE bye-laws applies. The High Court relies on Jigya Yadav v. CBSE to hold that CBSE bye-laws have the force of law and that unaided schools fall outside Section 21’s coverage, thus exceeding the Commission’s powers. The court quashes the contested paragraphs and directs adherence to CBSE bye-laws, with CBSE ensuring compliance. The writ petition is disposed of in favour of the petitioner.

High Court of Kerala
O.P.(FC) No.575 of 2022

Uthaman T.G. v. Sreelatha K.S. and Anil Kumar P. (O.P.(FC) No. 575 of 2022)

Uthaman T.G. filed O.P.(HMA) No.1054 of 2017 before the Family Court, Pathanamthitta, seeking dissolution of his marriage to Sreelatha K.S., married on 28.04.2002. He also sought production of records from M.C.No.220 of 2016 on the file of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pathanamthitta, to substantiate alleged cruelty and an extra-marital relationship. The Family Court dismissed Ext.P9 (I.A.1/2020) on 13.07.2022, prompting the petitioner to challenge the order under Article 227 of the Constitution before the Kerala High Court. The petition was heard with the 1st respondent appearing, while the 2nd respondent did not appear. The central issue is whether the Family Court may call for records from another court to aid a matrimonial petition, particularly when a related criminal appeal is pending before a Sessions Court. The petitioner relied on Lakshmi and another v. ChinnammaL @ Rayyammal and others (2009) 13 SCC 25 to contend that essential documents should not be refused merely on procedural grounds and that truth-seeking must prevail; the respondent argued privacy and credibility concerns, alleging manipulation of data and that such records are not relevant while the appeal is pending. The High Court held that the Family Court erred in dismissing Ext.P9. Relying on Lakshmi, the court held that documents essential to prove the case may be called for, duplicating/authenticating copies if necessary, and that pendency of the appeal does not bar production. The order dated 13.07.2022 (Ext.P11) was reversed; Ext.P9 was allowed; I.A. 1/2020 in O.P.(HMA) No.1054 of 2017 was allowed.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 985 OF 2023

Aju v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application filed by the 3rd accused, Aju, in Crime No. 866/2022 of Kilikolloor Police Station, seeking regular bail in connection with alleged NDPS offences under Sections 22(c), 22(b)(ii) and 29. The police reportedly seized MDMA and ganja from accused Nos. 1–4 on 25 August 2022 at Jeena Lodge, Karikode. The prosecution claims the seizure included 18.740 g MDMA and Rs. 79,050 from the 1st accused, 36 g and 650 mg ganja with Rs. 42,310 from the 2nd accused, 4.37 g MDMA and Rs. 9,290 from the 3rd accused, and 0.520 g MDMA from the 4th accused, with a chemical analysis dated 31.01.2023. The defense contends the material is Methamphetamine, not MDMA, and that the total MDMA quantity is below 50 g of Methamphetamine, rendering the offence as an intermediate quantity under Section 22(b) rather than a commercial quantity under Section 22(c). The Public Prosecutor initially doubted the quantity but, accepting the chemical analysis, agrees on the intermediate-quantity position. The 3rd accused has criminal antecedents, but given custody since 25.08.2022 and the ongoing final report, the court grants regular bail with stringent conditions: bond Rs.50,000 with two sureties, no witness tampering, cooperation with trial, no new offences, and surrender of passport. The order reflects cautious supervision to ensure trial readiness.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 3187 of 2022

Veerankutty T. M. v. The Secretary to Government, represented by the Secretary, Department of Co-operative Societies, Secretariat, Thiruvananthapuram, and others

Veerankutty T. M. v. The Secretary to Government, represented by the Secretary, Department of Co-operative Societies, Secretariat, Thiruvananthapuram, and others, is a Kerala High Court writ petition challenging actions by a bank under the SARFAESI Act, 2002. The petitioner alleges that the loan transaction was tainted by fraud and that the sixth respondent acted in collusion with bank officials to mortgage the petitioner’s property without his knowledge or consent. He seeks two remedies: (i) a writ of certiorari quashing the records up to Exhibit P‑16, and (ii) a mandamus preventing recovery of a 0.0728 hectare property in Sy. No. 1155/2 in Pazhayannur Village, pending consideration of Exhibit P‑15 by the 2nd respondent. The petitioner relies on Mardia Chemicals Ltd. v. Union of India and others to argue that where fraud is alleged the protections of the SARFAESI scheme should not shield the underlying transaction from challenge; he also cites a connected writ petition (W.P(C) No. 24960/2020). The bank counters that Section 14 proceedings before the Chief Judicial Magistrate are ministerial and do not adjudicate rights, and the proper remedy is under Section 17 of SARFAESI. The court accepts that the first prayer cannot be granted, finding that civil courts’ jurisdiction is barred for matters within the Tribunal’s domain, except in limited fraud circumstances. Consequently, the writ petition is dismissed; the second prayer is not maintainable, and the petitioner is directed to pursue remedies under SARFAESI.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5091 OF 2024

Faizal v. State

This is a bail application (BAIL APPL. NO. 5091 OF 2024) filed by Faizal, the 8th accused in Crime No.232/2024 of Nooranadu Police Station, Alappuzha, under Section 439 CrPC. The offences alleged against him include IPC sections 341, 365, 342, 323, 324, 395 and 506(ii) and Section 27 of the Arms Act. The prosecution contends that on 18.02.2024, at about 22:30 hours, the accused intercepted the victim’s motorcycle; the first accused placed a sword on the victim’s neck and threatened murder; the first accused along with others abducted the victim into a car, and the others assaulted, confined, or robbed him, while Faizal is alleged to have travelled in the car with accused 3–7. The petitioner’s counsel argues that Faizal had no overt act attributed to him, merely being present in the vehicle, and that after 70 days in custody with investigation now complete and recoveries effected, continued detention is unnecessary. The State counters that the petitioner is an inveterate offender with prior crimes, and that his release would risk intimidation of witnesses and tampering with evidence. The court relies on Hussainara Khatoon, Sanjay Chandra, and State of Kerala v. Raneef to underscore the presumption of innocence, the right to bail, and protections for undertrial prisoners, while balancing public order concerns. The judge ultimately allows the application, imposing stringent bail conditions, including a Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, periodic appearances before the IO, non-tampering with witnesses, travel restrictions, passport surrender, and potential cancellation if violated, citing Sushila Aggarwal for recoveries during bail.

High Court of Kerala
OP(FT) No.4 of 2021

OP(FT) No.4 of 2021 (Forest Tribunal, Kozhikode) State of Kerala v. SulaiKha (d/o Abdullakutty Haji) and others

This Original Petition (OP(FT) No.4 of 2021) challenges an order of the Forest Tribunal, Kozhikode, dated 16.10.2020 in IA No.246/2020 in OA No.89/2016, which allowed the petitioners to amend their original plaint. The amendment expands the scope of the case by asserting that the disputed land—out of a total 69 acres—was also cultivated with rubber beyond the 28.50 acres originally claimed, bringing the planted extent to 38.52 acres and providing details about the cultivation and related transactions (permissions, mortgage, auction). The respondents contend that such amendments alter the very nature of the relief (shifting from exemptions under Section 3(2)/(3) to exclusion under Section 2(f)(1)B) and prejudice their defence, especially since the original pleadings admitted nil planting. The applicants argue that the amendment merely elaborates and supplements the existing pleadings, supported by decades-old documents, and does not change the relief sought, but rather clarifies facts essential to the dispute under the Kerala Private Forest Vesting and Assignment Act, 1971. The High Court, citing liberal amendment standards and a Supreme Court pronouncement in Life Insurance Corp. v. Sanjeev Builders, upholds the Forest Tribunal’s order allowing the amendment, finds no irreparable prejudice, and determines the amendment is necessary to adjudicate the central issues. Consequently, the petition is dismissed, and the Tribunal’s order is sustained.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.M.C No. 8056 of 2022

M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. and Sheeja Sunny v. State of Kerala and Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd.

This Kerala High Court case, titled Crl.M.C. No.8056 of 2022, concerns a challenge under Section 482 CrPC to quash Annexure-A2 to the complaint in CC 749/2016 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Thiruvananthapuram. The petitioners, accused 1 and 3, are M/S Jeevan Telecasting Corporation Ltd. and its authorised signatory Sheeja Sunny. The complainant, Asianet Satellite Communications Ltd., alleges that an amount of Rs. 3,42,000 was due under a channel carriage arrangement and that a cheque for that sum issued by the first accused (drawn on State Bank of Travancore) was dishonoured. The petition contends that the second petitioner was only an employee/authorised signatory with no control over day-to-day operations and that the liability, if any, had been discharged by subsequent payments reflected in Annexure A3; thus the substrate of the case no longer exists and continuing the prosecution would amount to abuse of process. The counter affidavit disputes Annexure-A3, asserting that payments were not in discharge of the specific cheque and that substantial dues remain, with numerous S.138 cases pending. The learned judge applies Nagawwa v. Veeranna Shivalingappa Konjalgi and subsequent SC precedents, explaining that quashing is warranted only where the allegations do not prima facie constitute an offence or amount to abuse of process, among other narrow grounds. Ultimately, the court dismisses the petition for quashing, allowing the criminal proceedings to continue in the trial court.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 27151 OF 2010

IBS Software Services Pvt. Ltd. v. The State of Kerala and Others (WP(C) No. 27151 of 2010)

IBS Software Services Pvt. Ltd., a private limited company, leased multiple spaces within Technopark, Trivandrum, under several lease deeds. In renewal discussions, the third respondent, Technopark, demanded payment of property tax as part of the renewed terms. The leases uniformly required the lessee to pay statutory taxes and other charges; the petitioner contends that property tax liability is anchored in the owner under the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994, and that the occupier’s liability is limited to recoveries permitted by the Act (Sections 237 and 526) or to rent adjustments under Section 374 of the CPC, with no express liability on the lessee to pay property tax in renewal. The petitioner relied on earlier decisions (Azeez v. Vaikom Municipality; Jayarajan v. Vadakara Nagarasabha) to argue that liability for property tax cannot be fastened on lessees in the renewal context, especially under amended provisions. The respondents argued that lease clauses explicitly bind the lessee to statutory taxes and that Section 237 provides a first-charge mechanism for property tax, while Section 526 permits the occupier to recover amounts from the owner or deduct from rent. The High Court distinguished prior authorities as inapplicable to the facts and the amended framework, discussed transitional issues, and ultimately dismissed the petition, indicating ongoing disputes require separate proceedings or remedies.

High Court of Kerala
WP(Crl.) No.124 of 2023

Shanid K T v. State of Kerala & Ors.

The petitioner challenges Ext. P1 show cause notice and Ext. P2 externment order issued under the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAAPA). The externment order restrained the petitioner from entering the territorial limits of Kozhikode City for one year, later reduced to eight months by the Advisory Board under Section 15(2). The writ petition raises two main grounds: (i) non-application of mind by the detaining authority in passing Ext. P2, and (ii) a long delay between the last prejudicial activity (29/05/2022) and Ext. P2. The petitioner relies on decisions including Sreeja Jayaprakash v. District Collector/District Magistrate (2019 KHC 2814), Shyam Kumar @ Unni v. State of Kerala (2020 KHC 599), and Jasid A.S. v. State of Kerala (2022(7) KHC 453). Respondents contend there was proper application of mind and that the delay is not inordinate. The Court notes that Ext. P2 refers to a bail order in a different case (Crl.M.C.No.1117/2022) but held this to be a typographical error; the detaining authority had considered bail conditions and found them insufficient, justifying externment. The Court discusses the difference between S.3 and S.15 proceedings (Stalin C.V. v. State of Kerala) and the permissible reverse-looking inquiries under KAAPA, while emphasizing the preventive, rather than punitive, nature of S.15. Ultimately, the petition is dismissed, upholding Exts. P1 and P2 and denying relief to the petitioner.