CRL.REV.PET NO. 1437 OF 2010 This is a Criminal Revision Petition (CRL.Rev.Pet. No. 1437 of 2010) filed before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam by six accused persons challenging their conviction and sentence for offences under sections 143, 147, and 323 r/w 149 IPC in CC No.22/2006 of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Androth, and the subsequent affirmation by the District Court in CRA No.4/2008. The trial court convicted the petitioners for forming an unlawful assembly and assaulting PW1 near a mosque on 23.02.2006, with sentences of one month (Sec.143 IPC), six months (Sec.147 IPC), and two months (Sec.323 IPC) for the first accused, and two months for others under Sec.323 r/w 149 IPC. The appellate court upheld these convictions. In the revision petition, counsel for the petitioners argued that there was no proper dock identification of accused Nos.2–6; Ext.P1 listed all accused, but PW1’s chief examination named only the first accused, and PW2–PW3 identified several accused without precise correlation, rendering the evidence unreliable. Relying on decisions like Vayalali Girishan, Manu G. Rajan, and Thadiyantevida Nazeer, they urged acquittal for lack of proper identification. The State contended that the identity could still be proven through scrutiny of PW1’s testimony and corroboration. Ultimately, the High Court set aside the conviction, acquitting all accused, and allowed the revision petition on the ground of improper dock identification.
MACA Nos. 1508 of 2017 and 587 of 2021 These two Motor Accident Claims Appeals (MACAs) arise from the same accident and were heard together by Justice Devan Ramachandran. The claimant in MACA587/2021 was injured in an accident caused by a vehicle driven by the 1st appellant in MACA1508/2017 (owner of the vehicle, 2nd appellant) and insured by Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Taliparamba (OPMV 322/2016) awarded Rs. 2,07,900 as compensation, but exonerated the Insurance Company on the ground that there was no valid policy in force at the time of the accident. The claimant filed MACA587/2021 seeking enhanced compensation, while the owner and driver challenged the quantum in MACA1508/2017 as being too high. The High Court decided the two appeals together, and critically addressed: (i) quantum of compensation, applying Ramachandrappa’s standard notional income; (ii) the insurance cover issue by examining the policy chronology and relevant case law (Sobina Iakai, Kamalamma, and General Assurance Society). The Court concluded that the Tribunal’s Rs.5,000 monthly notional income should be revisited to Rs.9,000 in light of Ramachandrappa, while confirming Rs.90,000 for pain and sufferings. On insurance, the Court directed fresh evidence on the actual time of premium receipt and whether cover could start from a future date, remitting the insurance coverage issue to the Tribunal within three months. It also held the claimant entitled to Rs.25,500 for loss of earnings (MACA587/2021).
The State of Kerala and the Director of Medical Education challenge Ext.P4 order of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal (KAT) dated 24.05.2022 in OA No.1322/2016, which had held that the applicant, Lathiamma P.R., should have her seniority in Staff Nurse Grade-II reckoned from the date of the Public Service Commission’s advice (17.02.2003) on her inter-district transfer to Kottayam under the Jawan quota. The petitioners contend that inter-district transfers are governed by a long line of Government Orders (GOs) and statutory rules; post-enactment of KS&SSR, seniority is determined by the date of joining the new unit (with provisos), not the date of PSC advice. They argue that Annexure A10 (G.O. 36/91/P&ARD, 02.12.1991) and other orders either superseded earlier relaxations or restricted seniority protection to specific categories; the five-year rule under KS&SSR and its exceptions require ministerial approval. The respondent sought to preserve original seniority under the Jawan quota, invoking Annexure A9 (GO 12/04/P&ARD). The High Court reviews the matter, cites KP Sudhakaran and Ramachandran v. Madhu to emphasize statutory rules prevail over executive orders and 5-year rule restrictions, and ultimately holds that the respondent is not entitled to seniority from 17.02.2003 and that the Tribunal’s Ext.P4 order is unjustified. The petition is allowed, and the Tribunal order is set aside.
This High Court of Kerala writ appeal arises from an interim order of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Kochi, in CP/17/KOB/2020, which directed an interim administrator to manage Union Christian College and required maintenance of status quo in the college’s administration. The Union Christian College (W.P. No. 13114 of 2020) challenged the NCLT order by filing a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, seeking quashment of the NCLT order and declaration that the NCLT had no jurisdiction to entertain CP/17/KOB/2020. The matter has a background where the college petition sought radical corporate governance changes, including alterations to the Memorandum and Articles of Association (to align with Companies Act, 2013), appointing an administrator, removal of a manager, and forensic audit, with the NCLT interim order appointing an administrator. In 2021–2022, a Division Bench disposed of related writ appeals (WA Nos. 34 of 2021 and 1365 of 2020) and directed the writ court to decide maintainability under Article 226. The present court, while noting the need to decide maintainability, declined to modify the interim status quo and ultimately dismissed the writ appeal, holding that status quo as on 01.07.2020 must continue and the writ court should address maintainability in due course.
This writ petition challenges how compensation for properties acquired for the National Highway has been computed, specifically regarding amounts for electrification and plumbing. The petitioners allege that although the competent Authority for Land Acquisition (CALA) has computed compensation under Section 3G(1) of the NH Act, the amounts due for electrification and plumbing were not offered, contrary to the position declared by this Court in Ext. P6. They petition the court to require CALA to apply Ext. P6 and include these items in the awarded compensation before the Awards under Section 3G(1) are finalized. In response, the State and NHAI argue that CALA has already completed the determination of compensation under 3G(1), and that petitioners have not produced documents to substantiate their claims; they submit that the petitioners should pursue the remedy in the statutory arbitration under Section 3G(5) after CALA issues Awards, with the Arbitration Authority empowered to hear the concerned official of the NHAI if needed. The court notes the principle laid down in Usman Arif v. Project Director (2022) 1 KLT 35 that once CALA settles an Award, the CALA becomes functus officio, and claimants must invoke arbitration under 3G(5). Consequently, the court disposes the writ by directing CALA to provide copies of Awards within two weeks and permits the petitioners to approach the statutory Arbitrator under 3G(5) after obtaining the Awards, who will consider Ext. P6 after hearing both sides; the court also grants liberty to return after eight months if needed.
This High Court bail application concerns Nithin, the sole accused in Crime No. 788/2022 of Kannamali Police Station, charged under Sections 22(b) and 8(C) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act for allegedly possessing 0.9 gram of MDMA with intent to sell on 17 December 2022. The Prosecution asserts a prior criminal record, including several NDPS offences, and contends the petitioner is a habitual offender who could reoffend if released on bail. The defense contends that Section 50 of the NDPS Act requires that the person to be searched be taken before a gazetted officer or a Magistrate, and that the search was conducted by a police CI who, though gazetted, is not an independent officer and thus not competent under Section 50. The petitioner also argues that rights under Section 50 were not properly conveyed, and that failure to conduct the search before a gazetted officer could vitiate the recovery and conviction. The court examines Sections 50(1)-(6) and jurisprudence, including State of Rajasthan v. Premanand and State of Punjab v. Balbir Singh. It holds that a gazetted officer must be present at the search, but an officer who is part of the detecting/investigating team may, in limited circumstances, not be competent. In the present case, the recovery was 0.9 g of MDMA, an intermediate quantity; bail is granted with conditions to ensure cooperation and prevent recurrence.
This is a criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC before the Kerala High Court, decided by a single judge, Justice Raja Vijayaraghavan V. Accused Nos. 1 and 2 (Selvant X and Jobish John) faced charges in CC No.1402/2020 before the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class-II, Ernakulam, for offences under Sections 341, 323, 294(b) and 506 read with Section 34 IPC. The petition seeks quashing of the proceedings on the basis of a settlement between the parties, evidenced by Annexure-3 (affidavit) and the parties’ statements, arguing that continuation serves no purpose and would hinder peace. The court directed investigation to verify the settlement and to report on any criminal antecedents or impediments to quashing. The Public Prosecutor expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement, but conceded no other grievances or transgressions by the petitioners. The court then canvassed the law governing the exercise of the power under Section 482 CrPC to quash non‑compoundable offences where the disputes are private and the parties have settled, citing decisions starting with State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan and others, including Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, among others, and summarised at paras 15.1–15.5. The court concluded that the offences are private in nature and not of a serious/public-danger dimension, and that quashing would uphold the ends of justice while not undermining societal interest. Accordingly, the petition is allowed and Final Report in Crime No.1391/2019 and all further proceedings in CC No.1402/2020 are quashed.
Petitioners Shaju C. Chacko and Leena Ignatious challenge Ext.P3, the Revenue Divisional Officer dated 13.06.2022 order, which rejected Form-5 and kept their land in the data bank. They contend the 21.65 acres in Survey No. 329/0-16, Puthur Village, Thrissur, was converted to non-paddy use prior to the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008, and that it was erroneously included in the data bank when the data bank was prepared under Section 5(4)(i) of the Act. Their Form-5 application sought removal from the data bank to allow alternative uses. The impugned order relies on an Agricultural Officer’s report dated 04.06.2022 without any independent assessment, site inspection, or reasoning, rendering it not a speaking order. The petition is supported by the KSREC report (Ext.P4) and by submissions that surrounding areas are developed and that the land’s suitability for paddy cultivation and irrigation facilities were not adequately analyzed. The court recalls decisions in Arthasasthra Ventures (India) LLP v. State of Kerala, Muraleedharan Nair R. v. RDO, and Aparna Sasi Menon v. RDO, holding that an authority must independently assess land status and consider whether removal will affect paddy cultivation and nearby fields. The judgment quashes the order and directs fresh consideration, emphasizing independent mind under Rule 4(4f) and a comprehensive appraisal, within three months, with a speaking order.
Crl.R.P. No. 1552 of 2007 Kunhan, the revision petitioner, challenges a conviction under the Abkari Act (Section 55(a), with Sections 8(1) and (2) of the Abkari (Amendment) Act, 1997) recorded by the Ottapalam Additional Sessions Court in SC 311/2002 and upheld by the Fast Track Court. The Kerala High Court hears Crl.R.P. No. 1552 of 2007 on 10 October 2023. The prosecution alleged possession of two litres of arrack in a five-litre can; PWs 1-4 testified and Exts P1–P6 were produced. The revision argues grave procedural lapses in the chain of custody and documentation: Ext P1 seizure mahazar lacks a specimen seal and its description of the seal; Ext P5 forwarding note shows a specimen seal different from PW1’s description; Ext P6 references a different item number than Ext P5; forwarding note not produced; chemical examiner not examined; and discrepancies in lab forwarding/analysis. Relying on a line of Kerala and Supreme Court precedents emphasizing strict compliance with Abkari Act formalities, the petitioner contends the link between seizure and lab analysis is not established beyond reasonable doubt. The court cites Baburaj, Sathi, Vijayan, Nadarajan, Moothedath Sivadasan, Sasidharan, State of Rajasthan v. Daulat Ram, and Vijay Pandey to underscore chain-of-custody and correlation requirements. Ultimately, the High Court allowing the revision petitions, acquits the accused, and orders cancellation of bail; any deposited amounts are to be refunded as law requires.
Thomas C.J, holder of a regular permit for stage carriage KL-08-AC-8384, files WP(C) No. 3762 of 2023 seeking renewal of Exhibit P1 permit with validity till 06.08.2021 and replacement of the old vehicle with a newer model after procuring KL-05-Z-1690. Exhibit P2 for renewal was filed on 12.07.2021 and Exhibit P4 for replacement on 07.11.2022; both are pending before the 1st respondent. The petitioner contends that after the interdiction under Rule 260A of the Kerala Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989, and given the old vehicle’s age, he obtained a newer vehicle and submitted the replacement request, arguing that insisting on current records of the old vehicle as a condition for renewal or replacement is illegal and unjustified since the vehicle has been made roadworthy. He notes that in Ext. P6 judgment, the court held that the Motor Vehicle Tax, welfare fund contributions, and any dues must be cleared, and there is no provision requiring current records for renewal. He has also filed Ex. P7 for a temporary permit, which has not been acted upon. The learned Government Pleader cites Usman v. Regional Transport Authority, Malappuram (2015 (4) KHC 779) to contend that holding a permit is a sine qua non for replacement. The court examines Rule 172 (renewal) and holds that production of current records is not a prerequisite for renewal, directing the 1st respondent to decide P2 and P4 in light of Usman within six weeks and, if a temporary permit is filed, to decide it within three weeks. The petition is disposed of.
CRL.M.C. No. 8844 of 2023 Baiju, the accused in a case under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, was convicted by the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court II, Pala and sentenced to simple imprisonment till rising of the court and to pay Rs. 3,27,000 as compensation, with further conditions. On appeal, the Sessions Court at Kottayam suspended the sentence with a condition to deposit 20% of the compensation within 60 days, under CMP 44/2023 in Crl.A. 109/2023. The petitioner challenged this order in CRL.M.C., arguing that as per the Supreme Court’s decision in Jamboo Bhandari v. MP State ID Corp (2023) (6 KHC 80), a speaking order is necessary when imposing a deposit under Section 148 NI Act. The High Court examined the issue and held that while Section 148 allows deposit, it cannot be a blanket order; the court must give reasons for imposing 20% and record exceptional circumstances if such deposit is ordered. Annexure 3, the suspension order, was found to be unsustainable for lacking such reasoning. Accordingly, the High Court set aside the 20% deposit, directed the AD&SJ Pala to reconsider CMP 44/2023 in Crl.A. 109/2023 after hearings, and stayed coercive steps until fresh orders. The decision endorses purposive interpretation of Section 148 and the right to meaningful appellate process.
CON.CASE(C) NO. 1954 OF 2019 This Contempt Case arises from alleged willful disobedience of the directions contained in Annexure 1 judgment dated 12.10.2018 in WP(C) No.13249/2015 and connected matters. The petitioners, a large group listed in WP(C) 13249/15, filed under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, contending that the Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO) did not implement the directions in the 2018 judgment regarding pension disbursement. The Supreme Court’s later judgment dated 04.11.2022 in Civil Appeals Nos. 8143-8144 of 2022 (Sunil Kumar B. v. EPFO) and connected matters held the 2014 notification (G.S.R. 609(E)) legal and valid, and directed read-down and implementation of amendments to the pension scheme (including paragraph 11(4)) with certain transitional directions. The Kerala High Court notes these developments and acknowledges that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by EPFO in light of the 2022 Supreme Court judgment. The respondents submit that the required exercise should be undertaken in accordance with law, and the Contempt Case is thus closed, without prejudice to EPFO’s right to reconsider entitlement in view of the apex court’s decision. The Appendix records Annexure 1 (the 2018 judgment) and the joint application dated 23.02.2019.
This Motor Accidents Claims Appeal arises from O.P.(M.V.) No.887/2014 filed in the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Perumbavoor, seeking compensation for the death of Sasidharan Nair after a motor vehicle accident on 02.05.2013. The Tribunal held the driver of the mini tipper lorry negligent, with the National Insurance Company Ltd. liable for compensation, amounting to Rs.19,86,037 with 8% interest. The insurer (appellant) challenges both the Tribunal’s finding of negligence and the quantum of compensation, arguing that the deceased was riding after consuming alcohol and that the driver’s license was not valid, and that Ext.X1 (wound certificate) and oral evidence do not conclusively prove negligence. The respondents/claimants (wife and two daughters) support the Tribunal’s decision, arguing the driver opened the door, causing the scooter to crash. The High Court, while reappraising the evidence, upheld negligence on the part of the 2nd respondent for opening the door and confirmed liability on the insurer, but reassessed the compensation. It recalculated monthly income from Rs.11,844 to Rs.11,544 after deducting Rs.300 medical allowance, applied a 15% future prospect addition, and reduced the loss of love and affection in light of Satinder Kaur’s principle, preserving the loss of consortium head. The result is a revised compensation of Rs.19,41,197, with the appellant directed to deposit within three months.
This is a criminal miscellaneous petition under Section 482 CrPC before the Kerala High Court by the accused Nos. 1 and 2 in CC No.1283 of 2020, challenging the continuation of prosecution for offences under IPC sections 294(b), 323, 324, 341, 506 and 34. The petition seeks quashing the proceedings in light of an amicable settlement between the accused and the defacto complainant, supported by affidavits. The investigating officer was directed to verify the settlement and report on any impediment to terminating the proceedings, and the Public Prosecutor indicated reservations but acknowledged absence of other serious crimes against the petitioners. The Court relied on a line of Supreme Court decisions starting with State of MP v. Laxmi Narayan and Gian Singh v. State of Punjab, Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, and others, which hold that the power under 482 CrPC can quash non‑compoundable offences where disputes have been settled privately, subject to exceptions for heinous or public‑interest offences. The Court underscored that offences like 307 IPC and the Arms Act would not be quashed, while private offences with settled disputes may be. After considering gravity, antecedents, and the amicable settlement, the Court held that quashing would not adversely affect society and allowed the petition, quashing Annexure‑2 Final Report and all further proceedings in CC No.1283/2020.
Dr. P. Madhavankutty Varier, the Managing Trustee of Arya Vaidya Sala Kottakkal, challenged a Government decision denying exemption from building tax under the Kerala Building Tax Act, 1975 for a hospital building constructed to house an Ayurvedic Hospital and Research Centre at Thrikkakkara, Ernakulam. The trust argued the building is principally used for charitable purposes and funded by the trust, satisfying Section 3(1)(b) and its Explanation 1, which includes relief of the poor and free medical relief. The Government, after hearing the parties, rejected the exemption in Ext.P11. The High Court traced the evolving case law on what constitutes a "charitable purpose" for exemption: S.H. Medical Centre Hospital v. State of Kerala (2014) held that buildings must provide free medical relief for exemption; St. Alphonsa Hospital followed that approach. Lisie Medical Institutions (2017) questioned that reading, clarifying that "charitable" includes but is not limited to the relief of the poor and free medical relief. The three-judge bench in Lisie (2023) held that exemption is available only where a hospital's use is principally for charitable purposes and that the Explanation clarifies the scope of 'charitable' but does not widen the exemption to all hospital buildings. On facts, while the Will and poverty relief elements exist, the Government's finding that the hospital does not predominantly provide free medical relief and that substantial charges are levied prevailed. Consequently, the writ petition is dismissed.
This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC filed by twelve accused (petitioners) in Crime No.1938/2021 of Mangalapuram Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, challenging the continuation of prosecution for offences under IPC Sections 143, 147, 149, 341, 324 and 308. The prosecution case alleges that the accused formed an unlawful assembly and attacked the victim, resulting in criminal proceedings. The petitioners contend that the parties have resolved their dispute amicably and seek quashing of proceedings, supported by an affidavit from the victim indicating no objection. The Public Prosecutor conveyed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement, but admitted that the matter is settled. The court examined the arguments, the records, and relevant precedent. It relied on Madhya Pradesh v. Laxmi Narayan and Others (2019) 5 SCC 688, which summarizes the conditions under which non‑compoundable offences may be quashed under S.482 CrPC, particularly when the dispute is private, civil in nature, and the parties have settled. The decision also cites Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Narinder Singh v. State of Punjab, reinforcing the cautious approach toward quashing offences of a serious or public nature. After careful consideration, the court found the dispute private, accepted the settlement, and quashed all further proceedings against the petitioners in Crime No.1938/2021. The order reflects a single‑judge bench exercising power under CrPC 482 in light of a settled, non‑public dispute.
This writ petition challenges Ext.P12, a penalty order under Section 67(1) KVAT Act, 2003, imposing Rs. 6,06,16,380 for the 2013-14 year on a dealer accused of turnover suppression and tax evasion. The petitioner had already paid compounding tax (3% under Section 8) and the maximum compounding fee (Rs. 8 lakhs) and had remitted Rs. 80,09,183 towards tax; these payments were adjusted against the penalty demand. The Intelligence Officer had found large-scale suppressed turnover after inspection, computed tax evasion and issued a notice under Section 67(1), ultimately culminating in Ext.P12. The petitioner argued that compounding under Section 74 was already granted (Ext.P1) and that, since the compounding process exists under Section 8, further penalty proceedings were unwarranted and ultra vires; they also asserted lack of hearing and that AS-7-style timing differences were misapplied to levy penalties. The Respondents contended that KVAT’s self-assessment regime obligates truthful disclosures, and that the penalty is warranted for suppression and non-disclosure, especially given a pattern across quarters and failure to file Form No.49 under Rule 24B. The learned judge held that the petition should be dismissed with the appellate authority directed to decide the merits of the pending appeal within 15 days, without commenting on limitation, and that the observations here are to be treated as limited to disposal of the petition.
The case concerns the procedure to be followed after issuing a purchase notice under Section 67(2) of the Kerala Town and Country Planning Act, 2016, in the context of a Master Plan or Detailed Town Planning Scheme. The Special Government (LSGD) contends that once a landowner issues a purchase notice, acquisition action must wait for variation proceedings to be completed, making variation mandatory. The writ petitioners (respondents in the WA) argue that landowners cannot be indefinitely deprived of their property and that variation proceedings are administrative formalities rather than essential prerequisites for implementing the Master Plan or DTP Scheme. The court analyzes Sections 67(1)–(7), including the proviso to Section 67(7), clarifying timelines: sixty days for local authorities to decide acquisition after a purchase notice; six months for Government action; and the obligation to initiate variation if the authority chooses not to acquire. The judge concludes that once a purchase notice is issued and the authority fails to act within the statutory window, the landowner’s right crystallizes to use the land in accordance with law, and remaining steps are procedural. The WA is disposed of with directions that permit building permits to be pursued without awaiting final variation approval, while requiring due consultation with the Chief Town Planner.
R.C.Rev.Nos.326, 327, 329, 330, 332 & 340 of 2019 The six rent-control revision petitions arise from eviction proceedings under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, initiated by landlords against tenants in a building at Koorkanchery, Thrissur. The Rent Control Court allowed eviction on the ground of bona fide need to construct a hotel by the landlords’ son, and the Rent Control Appellate Authority affirmed. The tenants challenged these orders in six revisions, contending that the need was not bona fide, that the 5th respondent lacked qualification or a genuine plan, that other suitable premises existed, and that the second proviso to Section 11(3) should protect their livelihood. The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench, examined evidence including PW1’s testimony and Exts. A33–A34 (qualification) and Ext. X1 (planning permission). It concluded the need was bona fide, that the 5th respondent demonstrated ability to construct and operate a hotel, and that the tenants failed to prove the second proviso. Relying on leading precedents on bona fide need and revisional scope, the Court dismissed all six revisions but granted seven months’ time to surrender possession with conditions. The decision underscores that the High Court’s revisional power is not an appellate re‑weighing of evidence, but a legality-focused review.
This is an original petition under OP(Crl.) No.390/2020 before the Kerala High Court (Ernakulam) challenging an order of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kalamassery, in MC 38/2018 under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 (DV Act). The respondent had filed under Section 12 DV Act seeking reliefs under Sections 18, 19, 20 and 22. The Magistrate referred the dispute to mediation, resulting in Ext.P1 (6 February 2019) mediation settlement which mutually agreed to divorce and sale of the shared household; proceeds to be shared. When the household could not be sold, a second mediation yielded Ext.P2 (22 January 2020), under which the petitioner agreed to pay Rs 25,00,000 within six months to settle all disputes. The petitioner later claimed he was compelled to sign Ext.P2 without understanding the consequences and sought permission to withdraw. The court below passed Ext.P3 directing payment as per Ext.P2 and corrected the date of Ext.P2 in Ext.R1(b). The petitioner contends that the DV Act proceedings cannot be referred to mediation; the terms are unconscionable; and the order does not meet CPC requirements. The respondent maintains that parties are bound by mediation once concluded. The High Court holds that DV Act proceedings are civil in nature and that a magistrate may refer to mediation under CPC 89 and Order XXIII Rule 3, enforce the compromise, and that unilateral withdrawal is not permitted. The petition is dismissed; Ext.P3/Ext.R1(b) is upheld and the payment directive stands.