This is a petition under OP(C) challenging Ext.P7, an order transferring O.S. No.33/2019 before the Sub Court, Alappuzha, to the Commercial Court, Alappuzha. The respondent had leased the petitioner’s property to operate a resort and paid a Rs 20,00,000 security deposit. After expiry of the lease, possession was handed over and the respondent sought refund of the deposit; the suit claimed Rs 18,87,000. The respondent moved I.A. No.2/2021 for transfer to the Commercial Court, which the Sub Court allowed (Ext.P7). The petitioner contends there was no commercial transaction and that the dispute falls under Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965, citing Blue Sea Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. Polytech Engineering and Consultants (2021 KHC 3483). The respondent argues the lease and deposit reflect a commercial transaction with immovable property used exclusively in trade, bringing the dispute within the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The High Court analyses Section 2(1)(c)(vii) and Explanation (a) of the CC Act, and relies on Jagmohan Behl v. State Bank of Indore and Ambalal Sarabhai Enterprises Ltd v. K.S Infraspace LLP to uphold a broad interpretation. The Court agrees with Ext.P7, holds the dispute is a commercial dispute, and dismisses the petition; Ext.P7 is confirmed and no interference under Article 227.
The petitioners—three Indian nationals who earned foreign medical degrees from Bangladesh and completed their internships abroad—challenged the Kerala State Medical Council’s insistence on compulsory Rotatory Residential Internship (CRRI) in India as a condition for permanent registration under Section 13 of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956. They argued that advisories and regulations issued by the National Medical Commission (NMC) and related regulations permit foreign graduates who studied abroad and whose primary qualification is recognized for enrollment in the country of origin to be granted permanent registration without Indian CRRI, provided they meet prescribed criteria, including those in Exts. P4–P5. They relied on Exts. P2–P3 advisories showing acceptance of foreign training, the Sadhiya Siyad decision (KHC 2021) which held CRRI requirements could be inconsistent with IMC Act and regulations, and post-2021 NMC regulations, which include exemptions for pre-18.11.2021 qualifications. The respondents argued that Ext.R1(a) resolution mandating CRRI was adopted in public interest and previously upheld; they invoked Sundarjas Kanyalal Bhathija to urge referral to a larger bench. However, the court found that the National Medical Commission’s Foreign Medical Graduates Licentiate and Compulsory Rotating Medical Internship Regulations, 2021, along with Regulation 5 exempting pre-18.11.2021 graduates, render the CRRI requirement non-mandatory for petitioners who meet criteria (Ext. P7). The writ petition is disposed of by directing the first respondent to allow these petitioners to apply for permanent registration and, if otherwise in order, to grant permanent registration without CRRI.
This Kerala High Court decision arises from OP(KAT) No. 130 of 2022, challenging the Kerala Administrative Tribunal’s OA 1842/2020, which dismissed the petition challenging an internal departmental enquiry culminating in a penalty of the barring of three increments with cumulative effect against Jayachandran, a police inspector. The petitioner contends that the enquiry was tainted by bias, and more critically that a copy of the enquiry report (Annexure-A8) and related materials were not furnished to him before the disciplinary authority accepted the findings and decided the punishment. He argues the Enquiry Officer and the disciplinary authority were not the same person, violating natural justice. The Government defended the non-furnishing timing and relied on Rule 17(i)(b) of the Kerala Police Departmental Inquiries, Punishment and Appeal Rules (KPDIP & A Rules). The court emphasizes the constitutional principle that the delinquent must receive the copy of the enquiry report and have an opportunity to explain and challenge the findings, citing the Constitution Bench decisions in ECIL v. Karunakar (Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar) to underscore fair procedure. The High Court set aside the Tribunal’s order, holding that the enquiry must restart from the stage of drawing up the enquiry report, with a copy provided to the delinquent and a chance to show cause, to be completed within six months, following Karunakar’s dictum on natural justice.
The petitioner, Nassar MTP, seeks release of his vehicle KL-60D-3815 and a declaration that the Village Assistant in charge of Madikkai Village did not have authority under the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1967 (KMMC Rules) or under the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (MMDR Act) to seize the vehicle. The seizure occurred on 26 December 2013 and is challenged on the basis that Government Order G.O. (MS) No.20/14/1D dated 12 February 2014 restricts the seizure power to officers notified as competent authorities; the Government Pleader contends that the competent adjudicating authority is the District Geologist, Ernakulam District, though this officer is impleaded suo motu rather than as a party. The court previously granted interim custody on 18 March 2014 upon the petitioner’s deposit of Rs.25,000, to be adjusted as a compounding fee. Referencing Jayarajan v. Deputy Tahasildar and Digil v. Sub Inspector of Police, the court acknowledges that even where seizure is improper, the competent authority may initiate proceedings and that if an offence is involved it must be investigated by a Magistrate. The court concludes that seizure must be reported to the competent authority within two weeks and, if the petitioner wishes to compound the offence, it shall be permitted by paying Rs.25,000; upon compounding, no prosecution will lie, otherwise proceedings will continue under law. The petition is disposed of accordingly.
Mat.Appeal No.171 of 2022 This matrimonial appeal arises from the dismissal of O.P. No.200 of 2014 by the Family Court, Kasaragod, on 07 January 2016, which sought a decree of divorce. The appellant, Nivya V.M., challenges the order before the Kerala High Court in Mat.Appeal No.171 of 2022, filed after a substantial delay. The appellant seeks condonation of a 2152-day delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, arguing that severe despair arising from marital discord and protracted litigation impacted her ability to pursue relief. She alleges depression, psychiatric counselling, and attempts to migrate to the United States, along with other personal difficulties. The respondent counters that the reasons are false or pretextual, noting the appellant’s active participation in other legal proceedings, her travel to the U.S. for Ph.D. studies in 2018–19, and the existence of criminal cases against her, as well as the absence of material substantiating the delay. The court relies on Katiji and Esha Bhattacharjee to emphasize a liberal approach to condonation of delay, but reiterates that such liberalism has to be tempered by reason, substantial justice, and prevention of injustice. Ultimately, the Division Bench finds the delay inordinate and fails to find a sufficient cause, dismissing the condonation petition and, consequently, the appeal itself.
This is a Kerala High Court case (O.P.(FC) No.481 of 2021) filed under Article 227 of the Constitution challenging a Family Court interim custody order in a guardians & welfare petition. The petitioners, Anu Joseph, PV Joseph, and Mini Joseph, sought relief from an order passed by the Family Court, Alappuzha, in I.A. No.868 of 2019 in O.P.(G&W) No.468/2019, which granted interim custody of the couple’s minor son Jerome Jijo James to the father, Jijo James, on certain weekends. The High Court reviewed the matter after notices were issued and stayed the impugned portion of the order, permitting limited interaction between the father and child. On 02.12.2021, the court further modified the interim arrangement to give the father custody on Sundays from 10:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., with handover at the Family Court premises and daily contact via video/voice calls. The judge observed the child’s reluctance to interact with the father and noted concerns about possible tutoring by grandparents, while emphasizing the welfare of the child as the paramount consideration. Relying on Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan (2020) 3 SCC 67, the court reaffirmed the need to safeguard the child’s best interests while preserving both parents’ rights to contact. It ultimately retained the ongoing arrangement with a revised schedule, and directed a review after three months.
Cont.Case (C) No.2319 of 2019 This Contempt Case (Civil) No.2319 of 2019 before the Kerala High Court arises from a petition by petitioners 1–11 in W.P.(C) No.2044 of 2017, alleging willful disobedience of the directions contained in Annexure A judgment dated 25.02.2019 in that writ petition, which followed Annexure B judgment dated 12.10.2018 in W.P.(C) No.13120 of 2015 and connected matters. The apex court’s detailed judgment dated 04.11.2022 in Civil Appeal Nos.8143–8144 of 2022 and connected matters (reported as AIR 2022 SC 5634) in Employees Provident Fund Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B. upheld the legality of Notification No.G.S.R.609(E) (22.08.2014) and set out directives to apportion and compute pension benefits, extend options under the scheme, and read down certain provisions. The petitioners claim compliance with these directions to secure higher pension, while the EPFO contends that reconsideration is required under law. The court acknowledges the apex court’s directives and, after hearing counsel for the petitioners and the EPFO, holds that the contempt petition is to be closed, with a liberty to reconsider petitioners’ entitlement for higher pension in view of the 04.11.2022 judgment. The order is passed by a Division Bench of two judges.
Joy Mathew filed WP(C) No. 12931 of 2022 challenging Ext.P14, an order of the Tahsildar refusing to reassess and reclassify 60 cents of land in Survey No.270/4-1, Eramalloor, from Purayidom/Dry land to be reclassified in the Basic Tax Register and related revenue records. The petitioner, who holds 55.74 acres in the same survey, had earlier obtained permission under the Kerala Land Utilization Order (Clause 6(2)) in 1995 to convert 60 cents; after the conversion, portions of the land were partially or fully converted and building activity ensued, with LLMC and KSREC involvement. The petitioner argued that Ext.P14 violated the Kerala Land Tax Rules 1971 (Rule 8(iii) and Rule 10(iii)), and was issued without notice or hearing and thus violated natural justice. The respondents argued Ext.P14 was proper, reflecting consideration of all relevant materials and evidence, and that there was no requirement to interfere. The court appointed an Advocate Commissioner to inspect the land and examine the building on the property and considered prior judgments, including Kaipadath Property Development Company (Pvt.) Ltd. v. State of Kerala and Others, which held that lands covered by Land Utilization Order cannot be included in the data bank under the Paddy Land Act. The High Court ultimately allowed the petition, set aside Ext.P14, and directed the first respondent to reconsider Ext.P8 taking into account this judgment and the law, with a hearing to be provided to the petitioner within one month.
CRL.M.C. NO. 8182 OF 2023 This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (Crl.M.C. No. 8182 of 2023) before the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam, presided by a Single Judge, Justice P.V. Kunhikrishnan. Filed under Section 482 CrPC, the petition seeks to quash proceedings against the petitioner, accused No.8 in Crime No.1301/2023 of Kodungalloor Police Station, Thrissur, for offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 341, 342, 323, 324, 326, and 308 with Section 149. The prosecution alleges an unlawful assembly and assault on the victim. The petitioner and the victim have settled the dispute; the victim filed an affidavit supporting the settlement. The State/Public Prosecutor initially expressed reservations about quashing solely on the basis of settlement, noting the petitioner’s involvement in another case (Section 307 IPC), though no other case is registered against him. The court examined submissions and records, including the Supreme Court’s decisions in Laxmi Narayan (2019) and related Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, to lay down the governing principle for quashing non-compoundable offences under 482 CrPC. The court held the dispute private, the settlement acceptable, and allowed the Crl.M.C., quashing all further proceedings against the petitioner alone in Crime No.1301/2023. This decision relies on the balancing of private settlement against public interest in certain non-compoundable offences.
Cont.Case (C) No.2233 of 2019 This Contempt of Court case arises from alleged willful disobedience by the respondents of the directions contained in Annexure A1 judgment dated 25.02.2019 in W.P.(C) No.38296/2017, which followed the judgment dated 12.10.2018 in W.P.(C) No.13120/2015 and connected matters. The petitioners, a batch of 15 individual employees, filed under Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, contend that the EPFO failed to implement the directions of the High Court and the Supreme Court regarding pension scheme amendments, the extension of options, and the disbursement of higher pension as contemplated in the amended regime. The apex court’s later judgment dated 04.11.2022 in Civil Appeal Nos. 8143-8144 of 2022 (and connected matters) held that the notification G.S.R.609(E) of 22.08.2014 is legal and valid, read down certain provisions, and directed time-bound actions including extending the window to exercise options. The Kerala High Court, noting these directions, observed that the entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by the EPFO in light of the 2022 Supreme Court judgment. Accordingly, the court closed the Contempt Case, while reserving the right of EPFO to reexamine entitlements under the law and the appellate judgments. The matter now stands resolved, subject to compliance with the Supreme Court’s directions."
The petitioner, J. Suresh, owner of 34.96 ares of land in Cheppadu village, moves this writ petition challenging Ext.P17, an order by the Revenue Divisional Officer (RDO) refusing to remove land from the data bank under the Kerala Conservation of Paddy Land and Wetland Act, 2008. He contends the land is a 'dry land' converted before enactment of the Act and should be excluded; the data bank entry was made erroneously under Section 5(4)(i) of the Act, and the Form-5 application under Rule 4(4d) of the Rules should have been considered with independent appraisal. The impugned order is argued to be non-speaking, as it relies solely on the Agricultural Officer’s report without site inspection or independent assessment, and fails to discuss paddy cultivation suitability or nearby lands. The Court references earlier decisions emphasizing that the RDO cannot merely follow officer reports and must independently assess the land’s status and impact on paddy cultivation. It also notes that decisions must consider whether extraction would affect irrigation and cultivation, and that KSREC data and Rule 4(4f) factors should guide the decision. The petition is allowed; Ext.P17 is quashed and the matter is remitted for fresh consideration, with directions to obtain KSREC reports and issue a new order within three months.
OT.Rev Nos. 29/2022, 30/2022, 31/2022, 32/2022, 33/2022, 34/2022, 35/2022, 36/2022, 37/2022, 38/2022, 39/2022, 40/2022, 41/2022, 42/2022, 43/2022, 44/2022 These are batch of Other Tax Revision (VAT) petitions under the KVAT/CST framework issued by the Kerala State to challenge exemption regimes pertaining to inter-State sale and intra-State sale of rubber and rubber products. The Kerala High Court, in a Division Bench of Justice S. V. Bhatti and Justice Basant Balaji, heard OT.Rev Nos. 29/2022 through 44/2022 on 12 October 2022. The core issues relate to three notifications issued under Section 8 of the CST Act 1956 and corresponding provisions of the KVAT Act 2003: (i) the initial exemption notification under Section 8(1)/(2) for inter-State sale of natural rubber and tread rubber against tax paid under KVAT, (ii) a second notification restricting the exemption to sub-section (1) of Section 8, and (iii) a third notification introducing an option to pay the tax rather than continuing with exemption. The matter traces to orders of the Commercial Tax Department and the Tribunal remanding the case for disposal with due regard to the second notification. The State contends that the second notification supersedes the first and that the dealer’s “choice” principle is illegal, whereas the dealer argues the first notification remains in effect and the option to pay is valid under the third notification. The bench holds that the second notification rectified the illegality of the first, follows the Hi-Tek Traders ratio, and dismisses the revisions with no costs.
This Kerala High Court writ appeal arises from a 2021 order of a learned single judge who set aside an Insurance Ombudsman Exhibit-P10 award directing Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited (insurer) to settle a claim for damage to a rice mill chimney. The appellant-insurer challenges the finding on maintainability of the Ombudsman’s proceedings, arguing that under Rule 13 of the Redressal of Public Grievances Rules, 1998, complaints before the Ombudsman can be lodged only by an individual “any person,” not by a partnership firm; hence a firm like Puthen Modern Rice Mill cannot initiate such a consumer dispute. The insurer also contends that the Ombudsman acts within a limited statutory framework and that the writ court cannot reappraise facts, with Article 226 review being limited unless there is jurisdictional error. The writ petition relied on evidence including survey reports and newspaper clippings to dispute that a storm damaged the chimney, asserting wind/storm as insured peril under the policy. The Division Bench ultimately held that the core issue is maintainability of a complaint by a firm, relying on National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Indus Motors Co. Pvt. Ltd. and Another (2005) to hold that partnership firms are not within the ambit of Rule 13, and dismissed the appeal. The court also noted that the Ombudsman’s award should be reasoned (citing Star Health) and retained the requirement of a proper evidentiary basis. The interim Rs.2,00,000 order was recalled.
This is a revision petition under Section 125 CrPC filed by Binukumar.J challenging a Family Court Nedumangad order in MC 490/2015 directing maintenance to Linshimol and Athulya L.B. The Family Court, after considering pleadings and evidence (including PW1 and CPW1), ordered the petitioner to pay monthly maintenance of Rs.7,000 to the first respondent and Rs.2,000 to the second, from 14.12.2015. The petitioner contends that the first respondent is living in adultery, has independent means, and that he is physically incapacitated due to ailments, thus arguing the quantum is excessive and maintenance should be denied. The respondents, who are unable to maintain themselves, assert their entitlement to support. The Court below held that the petitioner is an able-bodied person with income reportedly around Rs.25,000, and that the defense of adultery was not proven with evidence to disentitle maintenance and that the claimed quantum was reasonable. Citing jurisprudence including Sheela v. Albert Hemson Alias James, Rajnesh v. Neha and Anr., Captain Ramesh Chander Kaushal v. Veena Kaushal, and Bhuwan Mohan Singh v. Meena, the High Court affirmed the necessity of maintenance as social justice under Sec.125 CrPC and rejected the plea that adultery alone defeats a wife’s claim. The revision petition was dismissed, upholding the family court’s maintenance order, with directions to adjust any deposited amounts.
Confronted with Ext P5 order passed in IA 4/2022 in Commercial Suit No.86/2022 by the Commercial Court, Ernakulam, the defendants (petitioners) challenge the order rejecting Ext P3 (amendment application) to the written statement. The plaint, filed by the first respondent, seeks a decree for recovery of money against the petitioners and others; the petitioners had resisted and later sought leave to amend to deny that an agreement for sale dated 09.07.2009 existed, contending that the underlying document (Document No.1) is forged. The trial court held that the proposed amendments would be inconsistent with the defence and would prejudice the plaintiff, since the pleadings already admit the execution of the disputed agreements. It found that the amendments would withdraw admissions by introducing a new version of events inconsistent with Ext P2. The petition relied on the Supreme Court's Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Sanjeev Builders Private Ltd decision, arguing that amendments should be liberally considered and guided by the principle of avoiding injustice; the court disagreed, noting that amendments cannot be used to wriggle out of admitted facts. The High Court affirmed the trial court's reasoning under Article 227, clarifying that the supervisory jurisdiction cannot act as an appellate forum, and that the amendments would prejudice the plaintiff. The result is a dismissal of the original petition with no costs, and a directive that the suit proceed free from the observations in Ext P5 or this judgment.
This writ petition challenges orders issued by the Ombudsman for Local Self Government Institutions in Complaint No.486/2019, seeking dismissal of the complaint and a declaration that the Ombudsman had no jurisdiction to entertain or issue the impugned orders. The petitioner claims ownership of a one-cent property with a house and alleges that his predecessor discharged wastewater onto the adjoining property of the second respondent, causing nuisance. Although the Panchayat Secretary admitted that earlier the petitioner’s father discharged waste, the Ombudsman issued Ext.P4 directing inspection and installation of a sewage treatment facility to abate the nuisance. After the petitioner’s father’s death, the petitioner was impleaded; the Ombudsman later informed that a notice had been issued against the petitioner to abate nuisance, but concluded that issuing a notice alone is not enough and that the waste treatment facility must be installed. The Ombudsman repeatedly issued various orders (Ext.P4-P9) to address the nuisance, including threats to withhold the Secretary’s salary if needed. The petitioner’s counsel argued that the Ombudsman’s jurisdiction under Section 271J of the Kerala Panchayat Raj Act is limited, and that the Ombudsman cannot issue positive orders or adjudicate private disputes, or compel acts by third parties. The respondent’s counsel contended that discharging faecal waste affected the second respondent, and that the Ombudsman’s powers were invoked to redress this grievance.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.M.C. No.8808 of 2023) under Section 482 CrPC concerns the accused Muhammed Rassal, who was charged in C.C. No.115/2022 arising from Pudukkad Police Station Crime No.661/2021, Thrissur, for offences under Sections 406, 420 read with Section 34 IPC. The prosecution initially opposed quashing solely on the basis of settlement, while Charge Witness No.2 filed an affidavit stating no objection to quashing. The victim’s affidavit, and the accused’s counsel, indicate that the parties have resolved their dispute and do not wish to continue the prosecution. The Public Prosecutor, though skeptical about relying only on the settlement, concedes the matter is settled. The court, after evaluating the submissions and records, invokes the legal principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Laxmi Narayan and others v. State of MP, along with Gian Singh and Narinder Singh, to assess whether quashing is appropriate where the offence is non‑compoundable but private in nature and resolved by the parties. The court holds the dispute to be private in nature and finds the settlement acceptable, allowing the quashing of proceedings only as against the petitioner. Overall, the court allows CRL.M.C. 8808/2023 and quashes CC 115/2022 against the petitioner Muhammed Rassal.
This writ appeal, filed by the Employees Provident Fund Organisation (EPFO), challenges a learned Single Judge’s order in WP(C) 20551/2015 directing re-determination of pension payable to respondents 1–50. The appeal references directions from judgments including P. Sasikumar and others v. Union of India and others (ILR 2019 (1) Ker. 614) and ultimately relies on a Supreme Court decision in Employees Provident Fund Organisation v. Sunil Kumar B. and Others (2022 (6) KLT 234 (SC)). The appellants contend that the 22.08.2014 notification remains legal and valid and that the Supreme Court has laid down directions regarding options to be submitted by employees. They submit the issue should be resolved strictly in light of those apex Court directions, with consideration of any employee options, and with the question of circular dated 25.01.2023 left open. The respondents’ counsel, while highlighting relevant precedents, emphasize adherence to settled framework for pension calculation under the EPF scheme. The Division Bench ultimately allows the appeal, sets aside the Single Judge’s order, and directs consideration strictly in accordance with the Supreme Court’s directions, including taking note of employee-submitted options, while leaving open the applicability of circular 25.01.2023.
Cont.Case (C) No.2008 of 2019 Cont.Case (C) No.2008 of 2019 is a contempt petition filed by petitioners 13, 14, 24, 26, 32, 36, 40, 43, 46, 47, 48, 52, 57, 58, 62, 63, 65, 66, 68, 69, 70, 73, 78, 83, 85, 89, 93, 95, 96, 101, 103, 105, 107, 112, 116, 118, 120, 121, 122 and 124 in WP(C) No.19899 of 2015, alleging willful disobedience of directions in Annexure A1 judgment dated 12.10.2018 in that writ petition and connected matters. The underlying dispute centers on entitlement to higher pension under the Employees Provident Fund regime, following the 2014 amendment (G.S.R.609(E)) and the pre-amendment 1995 scheme. The Supreme Court’s detailed judgment dated 04.11.2022 in Civil Appeals Nos.8143-44 of 2022 and connected matters (AIR 2022 SC 5634) is invoked to examine the validity and application of the amended pension scheme. The Kerala High Court recalls earlier directives, including a read-down approach to certain provisions and the extension of option exercise under paragraph 11(4) of the amended scheme, while noting that some members may still be governed by the pre-amendment regime. The court ultimately directs that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension be reconsidered by the EPFO in light of the Supreme Court’s 2022 decision, and closes the contempt case, without prejudice to such reconsideration. The order emphasizes adherence to law and the apex court’s binding guidance.
ITA Nos. 34 of 2018; 35 of 2018; 25 of 2019; 27 of 2019 This is a consolidated Kerala High Court judgment disposing of four appeals (ITA Nos. 34/2018, 35/2018, 25/2019, 27/2019) involving two co‑operative banks—Kottayam Co-operative Agricultural & Rural Development Bank Ltd. and Meenachil Co-operative Agricultural & Rural Development Bank Ltd.—and their claim for deduction under section 80P(4) of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The primary issue is whether these PCARDBs with areas of operation spanning more than one taluk can be eligible for the deduction, in light of the amended Explanation (b) to section 80P(4) which defines PCARDB as a society confined to a taluk with the object to provide long-term credit for agricultural and rural development. The High Court, by a two-judge Division Bench, examines the literal meaning of “a taluk,” examines Section 13(2) of the General Clauses Act, and relies on precedents to hold that the term cannot be expanded to cover multiple taluks without producing absurd results. It rejects the assessee’s interpretation and upholds the revenue’s view, concluding that the appeals fail and are dismissed, thereby sustaining the ITAT orders denying the deduction.