BAIL APPL. NO. 3574 OF 2022 This batch of bail petitions arises from RC No.034/2022 (CBI, SCB, Thiruvananthapuram), involving allegations of large-scale misappropriation and fraudulent accounting within the Kerala Advocates’ Welfare Fund Trustee Committee. Audit reports (2018) flagged a misappropriation of Rs. 3,56,68,450 and missing stamps valued at Rs. 3,15,82,800, with total unaccounted losses reaching several crores. The statutory auditor later computed a loss of Rs. 7,61,24,725, largely due to unaccounted stamp sales, understated bank interest, inflated accounts, and fictitious entries. Accused Nos. 3 to 9 are alleged to have links to the diverted funds, with Accused No.1 Chandran and his wife accused No.3 (Sreekala) implicated, along with others including Chandran’s associates A4–A9. The CBI investigation subsequently took over pursuant to court directions in a previous Writ petition. The petitioners argued lack of nexus and urged anticipatory bail, contending no custodial necessity and no obstruction to investigation. Counsel for the prosecution, however, contended that investigation is at a preliminary stage, several benami transactions exist, and custodial interrogation is necessary to unearth the full scope of the scheme, including other co-conspirators. The court enumerated standard anticipatory bail criteria and, after analyzing the materials, held that the petitioners failed to make a prima facie case for Sec. 438 Cr.P.C. relief and that bail would impede the investigation; the applications were dismissed, keeping the investigation intact over a decade-long fraud involving multiple accounts and entities.
This victim-appeal challenges the judgment of the Additional Sessions Court No.I (Special Court under POCSO) Pathanamthitta, which acquitted the accused—father of the victim and his friend—of offences under IPC Section 376 read with Section 34 and POCSO Sections 4 read with 3, 6, and 5. The prosecution examined 11 witnesses; Exts. P1–P15 were marked, but the trial court disbelieved PW1, and found the medical certificate Ext. P3 inconsistent with the allegations, noting hymen intact and no penetration. The trial court also found that PW1 and her twin sister DW2 were possibly influenced by the victim’s mother to lodge a false case. The victim’s appeal argues that the court erred in discounting the Section 29 presumption under POCSO and in treating the sole testimony of a minor as inadequate, arguing that the medical evidence is not determinative and that the prosecution had established the foundational facts. The respondents contend that PW1’s version is internally inconsistent, not corroborated, and that the medical evidence fails to support the charges. The High Court re-evaluates the evidence, citing principles on interference with acquittals (perverse findings standard) and endorses the acquittal, while partially allowing the appeal by quashing a Sessions Court direction to register a Section 22 POCSO complaint against the victim’s mother, and directing quashing of any related F.I.R. under 482 Cr.P.C. The final disposition upholds acquittals and shifts the focus to the questioned propriety of the Section 22 direction.
This criminal revision petition arises from concurrent convictions of three petitioners for offences under Sections 323 and 325 IPC read with Section 34 IPC, arising from an incident on 27 May 2001 near the residence of PW1, where the petitioners allegedly inflicted voluntary hurt on PW1 and PW2 by beating with a granite stone and other forms of assault. The trial before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pathanamthitta, culminated in conviction under Sections 323 and 325 IPC with sentences of fine and simple imprisonment. The Additional Sessions Judge (Adhoc) Fast Track-II, Pathanamthitta, on appeal, refused to interfere, sustaining the conviction and sentence. In the present revision, the petitioners challenge these concurrent findings. The court notes the prosecution’s case that there was a common intention among the petitioners, though the weapon alleged for Section 326 IPC was not produced. The defence relied on DW2, the District Police Surgeon, who suggested that injuries noted in medical records were not necessarily caused by granite stones, a point the courts below rejected. The High Court highlights the limited scope of revisional interference, citing established authorities that revisional courts are not to reweigh evidence as in an appeal, and that interference is warranted only for perverse, untenable, or grossly erroneous findings. Ultimately, the court partially allows the revision: it upholds the convictions under 323 and 325 IPC, but modifies the sentence for 325 IPC to imprisonment till rising of the court with a fine of Rs.10,000 per petitioner, directs that the fines be paid as compensation under 357(1)(b) CrPC, and requires the petitioners to appear before the trial court by 15.02.2024 for enforcement. The conviction under 323 IPC remains intact, with the existing fine. The order emphasizes that compensation to PW1 and PW2 be paid to their legal heirs as applicable.
This writ petition challenges the termination of the petitioner from service by the Travancore Devaswom Board following an enquiry conducted under the Kerala Civil Services (CC&A) Rules. The petitioner contends that the penalty is vitiated for violation of natural justice and non-compliance with the prescribed disciplinary procedure, highlighting a suspension order (Exhibit P1) and a memo of charges (Exhibit P2) that allegedly contain contradictions. The petitioner also points to a criminal case arising from misappropriation during the Sabarimala counting on 15.1.2015, which he argues should have deferred disciplinary proceedings in light of prior authorities. He asserts that he was not allowed to participate in the enquiry and was not given an opportunity to cross-examine witnesses, and that a copy of the enquiry report was not served before the final order (Exhibit P5). The respondents submit that all necessary opportunities were provided; the Enquiry Officer, being a lawyer, ensured representation and that the petitioner had ample opportunity to present evidence and contradict the prosecution evidence. They contend that the standard of proof in disciplinary proceedings is preponderance of probabilities, not criminal beyond reasonable doubt. The Court ultimately holds that the enquiry complied with due process and dismisses the writ petition, noting the petitioner’s representation and opportunity to defend.
This is an original petition under Article 227 challenging Ext.P6 order of the Munsiff Court, Pathanamthitta, in OS 396/2004. The respondents/plaintiffs had sued for fixation of the western boundary of plaint schedule items 1 and 2 and for consequential reliefs; the trial court dismissed the suit in 2007. The respondents’ appeal resulted in Ext.P3 judgment remanding the case to the trial court for fresh disposal after allowing both sides to lead evidence. Subsequently, the petitioners moved Ext.P4 seeking leave to amend the written statement (Order 6 Rule 17 CPC) to amplify the pleadings under Ext.P2. Ext.P5 objected, and Ext.P6 rejected the amendment as barred by the proviso to Rule 17. The petition contends the amendment merely amplifies the written statement and does not introduce a new defence; it argues the remand did not restrict amendments and that liberal amendment is permissible under the cited Supreme Court decisions. The High Court, citing State of Bihar v. Modern Tent House, Pradeep Singhvi v. Heero Dhankani, and Life Insurance Corp. v. Sanjeev Builders, holds that amendments necessary to determine the real questions should be allowed unless prejudice is shown. It sets aside Ext.P6, allows Ext.P4, directs timely amendment and rejoinder, and orders expeditious trial, aiming for disposal by 13.04.2023, under Article 227.
CON.CASE(C) NO. 2206 OF 2021 Radha Warassiar, an 80-year-old senior citizen petitioner, filed this Contempt of Court Case (Civil) under sections 11 and 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, seeking contempt against the respondent, the Assistant Devaswom Commissioner, Cochin Devaswom Board, Thripunithura, for wilful disobedience of Annexure A1 order dated 11 February 2019 in DBP No.1 of 2019. The court’s 2019 order directed disbursement for expenses incurred by the petitioner for deploying additional hands during the temple festival of 2018. On 28 March 2019 the petitioner submitted Annexure A2 seeking disbursement for the festival of 2019, arguing her grievances persisted. The court noted that Annexure A1’s scope was confined to the 2018 festival and the order did not cover 2019 expenditures. During proceedings, the respondents argued that Annexure A2 falls outside the A1 order’s scope and that the board had already sanctioned Rs. 1,400 on 15 March 2019, which the petitioner did not accept, leading to the present petition. The court cited A.A. Gopalakrishnan v Cochin Devaswom Board and Travancore Devaswom Board v Mohanan Nair to emphasize the protective duties towards temple properties and the guardian role of the judiciary. Ultimately, the court found no basis to proceed with contempt, and the petition was dismissed; the files were to be returned to the Cochin Devaswom Board.
WP(C) Nos. 15579 & 25005 of 2023 This is a consolidated Kerala High Court writ petition challenging the KEAM sports-quota provisions, specifically Annexure XVIII(ii) (Ext.P7) and related prioritization for admission to professional courses (MBBS) in 2023. The petitioner in WP(C) No.15579/2023, Brijit Joseph, a student from Kerala who represented the State in volleyball and was selected for a sports-hostel at SAI, sought reservation benefits under the sports quota based on his national-level participation, contending that the State and SAI distinctions in the quota categorization were discriminatory. The accompanying WP(C) No.25005/2023 challenges the inclusion of certain co-petitioners (and respondents in 15579) in the final category lists, arguing that the norm requires separate grace-marks lists for individual and team events and that some candidates (including those with SAI representation) should not be prioritized over Kerala-based athletes. The State of Kerala and the Kerala State Sports Council defended the criterion under Section 31(1A)(ix) of the Kerala Sports Act, 2000, asserting a stringent, Kerala-centric selection framework; they argued that recognition of national events conducted by SAI bypasses the district-to-state process and that policy decisions in Annex XVIII(ii) are non-justiciable. The court examined the governing prospectus, interim orders, and prior jurisprudence on Article 14 (reasonable classification) and intelligible differential to evaluate whether the priority scheme irrationally discriminates against Kerala students. The judgment partially allows WP(C)15579 (upholding provisional admission) and dismisses WP(C)25005, directing that admissions be finalized in light of the provisional order.
CON.CASE(C) NO. 2336 OF 2019 This Contempt of Court Case (Civil) No. 2336 of 2019 before the Kerala High Court arises from a petition by KSCSC Ltd (petitioners in WP(C) No. 27459/2016) alleging willful disobedience of directions contained in Annexure A1 judgment dated 25.02.2019, in turn rendered after Annexure A2 judgment dated 12.10.2018 in WP(C) No. 32532/2016 and connected matters. The petition references the Supreme Court’s detailed judgment dated 04.11.2022 in Civil Appeals Nos. 8143-8144 of 2022 and connected matters (AIR 2022 SC 5634), which upheld the legality of Notification No. G.S.R. 609(E) (22.08.2014) and laid down directions for applying the amended pension scheme to exempted establishments, extending the right to exercise options under the pension scheme, and clarifying rights of employees who did not exercise options before 1.9.2014. The Apex Court’s directions include read-down of certain provisions, the extension of option exercise periods, and guidance on pension computation and contributions. The Kerala High Court, after considering the 2022 Supreme Court judgment, held that the petitioners’ entitlement to higher pension requires reconsideration by the EPFO and that the contempt petition should be closed. The order directs EPFO to undertake the reconsideration in accordance with law, while reserving the petitioners’ rights to pursue remedies in light of the 2022 judgment. The court ultimately closes the contempt case, with EPFO empowered to reassess entitlements under the applicable legal framework.
This Regular Second Appeal under Section 100 r/w Order XLII CPC challenges the judgments in A.S. No. 66/2018 of the Additional District Court-VII, Ernakulam, and O.S. No. 844/2009 of the II Sub Court, Ernakulam, arising from sale deed No. 1399/2004 of Thrikkakara SRO and the plaint schedule property. The suit sought a declaration that the sale deed is not binding on the plaintiffs’ right, title and possession over 1.85 acres and for recovery of possession. The trial court decreed in favor of the plaintiffs; the appellate court also upheld. The 7th defendant (appellant) contends that Ext. A5 contains two schedules (14.40 acres and 1.85 acres) and, by virtue of Order II Rule 2 CPC, the suit is barred for not having raised a claim to Item No.2 in Ext. A5 without leave; plaintiffs counter that pleadings and proof are required for such bar, relying on Dalip Singh. The High Court examines whether the bar is properly pleaded, and whether the alleged binding effect of Ext. A5 and the 2016 RS/189/2016 decree affects the rights of the plaintiffs. It ultimately holds that no substantial question of law arises and the appeal is meritless, dismissing the appeal and all pending interlocutory applications.
Sudha P., a former Peon of Ambalapara Service Co-Operative Bank, challenged the order of termination and the subsequent awards and undertakings through a sequence of proceedings beginning with ARC No.106 of 2011. The Co-operative Arbitration Court (ARC) in its 6 March 2018 award set aside the dismissal and directed reinstatement with immediate effect, but without back wages or service benefits. The Co-operative Tribunal, in Appeal No.24 of 2018 and Revision No.57 of 2018, upheld the freedom of the award to the extent of reinstatement and ordered restoration of service and monetary benefits, while the writ petition W.P.(C) No.19899 of 2018 sought enforcement. This Court stayed the operation of the award/judgment in 2018 and observed that the Supreme Court, while not entertaining the Special Leave Petition, urged early disposal of the writ petition. The petitioner contends that Ambika v. Kottappadi Service Co-operative Bank Ltd. (2018 (3) KLT 779), which relied on Maharashtra State Co-operative Housing Finance Corp. v. Prabhakar Sitaram Bhaba nge (2017) 5 SCC 623, misapplies Kerala Act provisions. The Division Bench examines maintainability of the review, relying on Kunhayammed and Khoday Distilleries, and ultimately dismisses the review petition as not falling within proper review, while directing the writ petition to be listed before a Single Judge for early consideration.
TR.P(C) Nos. 548/2021 & 549/2021 The Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, heard two transfer petitions filed by Sulfath V.H (wife) and, in the second petition, her minor child Laiba, challenging the Family Court, Irinjalakuda’s orders in O.P. No.857/2021 (divorce by Mubaarath) and G.O.P. No.858/2021 (custody). The petitions seek to transfer the divorce and custody proceedings from Irinjalakuda to the Family Court, Ernakulam, so that the cases can be consolidated and jointly tried. The Court notes the wife’s residence in Ernakulam with the child, the husband’s employment abroad, and the lack of a chaperone to transport between Ernakulam and Irinjalakuda, making ongoing proceedings inconvenient and burdensome for the wife and the child. Relying on a line of Supreme Court decisions emphasizing the welfare and convenience of women and children in family-law transfers, the Court exercised its discretionary power under Section 24 CPC to transfer the cases to Ernakulam to achieve consolidation and avoid multiplicity of proceedings, thereby saving judicial time. The order directs the Family Court, Ernakulam to receive the records, issue notices, and proceed with consolidated hearing. The petitions are disposed of by a common order, with a direction to effect the transfer immediately.
This writ appeal challenges the 8 April 2021 judgment in WP(C) No. 33186 of 2019, whereby Ext. P10, a Government order, was set aside and the matter was directed to be reconsidered. The appellant, Leeja Napoleon, fifth respondent in the writ petition, had been appointed to a sanctioned Higher Secondary School Teacher (Junior) post in Physics under the Corporate Management of the Diocese of Alappuzha, initially on a leave vacancy from 2010 and later in 2013 the Government created new HSST posts. The writ petitioner, Joseph K.G. and others, contested her claim, arguing that Rule 51A of the Kerala Education Rules, 1959 requires a claimant to be relieved from service and in an approved post to be eligible. Ext. P10 purportedly granted relief under Rule 51A to the fifth respondent; however, the learned Single Judge found Ext. P10 to be arbitrary, illegal and unsustainable, because it relied on a mistaken premise that the fifth respondent had a valid Rule 51A claim while she continued in the post without relief. The court directed the Government to reconsider afresh the entire matter after hearing rival contentions. On appeal, the Fifth Respondent contended that Rule 51A supports her claim, but the Division Bench held the appeal lacks merit and dismissed it, leaving the government to reassess the issue afresh, particularly whether relief from service was obtained.
This Kerala High Court Criminal Appeal (CRL.A No. 409 of 2007) challenges a Special Court (NDPS Act) Vadakara judgment of 28 February 2007 convicting the two accused under Section 21(b) NDPS Act for possession of 100 grams of brown sugar each, intended for sale, seized near the Ambalakulangara Durga Bhagavathi temple in Tirur on 30 August 2004. The prosecution relied on PW3 (Circle Inspector), PW1 (Probation Circle Inspector) and PW4 (eyewitness) who testified to the detection, arrest and seizure; MO packets and P3 mahazar were produced; Ext. P15 confirmed the material as narcotic drug. The defense argued illegal search and seizure, non-compliance with Sections 42, 50 and 57 NDPS Act, lack of authority of the investigating officer, and excessive sentencing. The court below held the prosecution proved possession beyond reasonable doubt; the chemical analysis supported the narcotic character. On appeal, the High Court held that Section 42(2) compliance is not mandatory and that substantial compliance with Sections 42 and 57 is established via Exts. P16–P17 and the conduct of officers; it also found evidence of waiver of Section 50 rights by the accused, supported by Exts. P1–P2. The court confirmed the conviction, but reduced the substantive sentence from six to three years of rigorous imprisonment, with the fine and default sentence unchanged. The appeal is partly allowed on sentence.
W.P.(C).Nos.14016/2010 & 14040/2010 These are two connected writ petitions (W.P.(C).Nos.14016/2010 and 14040/2010) challenging orders of the Employees Provident Fund Organization (EPFO) demanding provident fund contributions from nurses undergoing bond or training programmes. The petitioners contend that such trainees are not “employees” under the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952, particularly under Section 2(f), as they are apprentices paid stipends during training and have no right or obligation to be employed. They rely on the decision in Sivagiri Sree Narayana Medical Mission Hospital v. Regional Provident Fund Commissioner (2018 (4) KLT 352) and on Apex Court Appeal (Civil) No.978/2000, which held that apprentices engaged under the Apprentices Act or Standing Orders fall outside the definition of employee. The EPFO and its authorities oppose this interpretation, noting pending Division Bench appeals against Sivagiri’s view and citing earlier judgments of this Court (e.g., 2011 and 2017 rulings) supporting the contrary. After considering these authorities, the learned judge, P. V. Kunhikrishnan, J., reasons that the earlier supportive authorities do not bind this case and ultimately quashes the impugned orders (Exts. P8, P9 in 14016/2010 and Ext. P3 in 14040/2010), allowing the petitions. The decision aligns with the broader theory that trainees on stipend are not employees under the EPF Act.
This Writ Petition (Criminal) by Amal Mary.R challenges detention under the Kerala Anti-social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 (KAA(P)A). The petitioner, wife of Libin Laurance, contends that order of detention (Exhibit P1 dated 16.5.2023; Exhibit P2 dated 9.8.2023) is invalid due to improper subjective satisfaction and misapplication of mind. She points out that four crimes were forwarded to the detaining authorities, but the sponsoring authority and detaining authority only considered three, with the third alleged offence occurring within the Kochi Infopark jurisdiction. She submits that the 4th respondent District Police Chief Kollam could rely only on crimes within his district and that, absent a report from the Kochi City Commissioner, the 3rd respondent could not validly detain the detenue. She highlights a clerical error in the sponsoring report, where the detainee’s name was written as “Leo Placid” instead of “Libin Laurance,” arguing this demonstrates lack of proper application of mind. The State submits that the procedure under Section 3(1) and 3(2) permits detention by the District Magistrate with appropriate reporting, and relies on Sameena Beevi v. State of Kerala to contend that 3(2) notifications authorize detention by district authorities. The court ultimately holds that the detaining authority considered relevant materials, the provisions of Section 3 have been satisfied, and the detention order is legally sound, dismissing the petition.
This writ petition (W.P.(C). No. 11767 of 2011) was filed by Fr. Mathew Thekkekkulam Infant Jesus Church, Daisy Mani, Thomas Thottathil, Michael Thomas, and Shaju K. Jose seeking protection of a region in Kannur district allegedly affected by indiscriminate mining. The petition prayed for mandamus or similar relief to implement the recommendations in Ext. P1 and to direct the subordinate officers accordingly to protect the area; to direct the District Collector to take immediate action on Exts. P3 and P4 after hearing the petitioners; to restrain the 7th respondent from granting or renewing quarry licenses in the Ext. P1 area; and to compel respondents 2–5 to file a report showing actions taken on Ext. P1 and the reasons for issuing quarry permits post-2007. The respondents include the State of Kerala and several statutory authorities, along with private quarry operators. During proceedings, it was stated that the unit of the 10th respondent is not functioning presently, leading the court to note that if any grievance remains, the petitioners may approach the competent authority in accordance with law. Based on these developments, the court disposed of the writ petition, closing the matter with a direction that petitioners may pursue redressal through appropriate authorities if required.
The appellants, Mithun Babu P.S. and Geetha Gopinadhan, approached the Kerala High Court under Article 226 challenging SARFAESI recovery proceedings initiated by City Union Bank Ltd. against their Thrissur branch facilities, including three loans totaling over Rs. 37 lakh and a gold loan. They contended that the bank should permit settlement of the outstanding liability in instalments and that release of 111.95 grams of gold ornaments (approximately 13.9 sovereigns) would enable payment of a substantial sum, with the balance recoverable through instalments. The writ petition noted that during the Covid period their business suffered losses, the bank issued a sale notice for 29.03.2022, and that a previous writ order in W.P.(C) No.8735 of 2022 directed repayment in instalments. The bank argued that the writ petition is not maintainable against SARFAESI proceedings and that no instalment had been paid despite indulgence, leading to a fresh sale notice on 22.07.2022. The High Court considered authorities reaffirming that writ petitions against SARFAESI matters are normally not entertained where a statutory remedy exists under Section 17, albeit recognizing the prior 18‑installment order. Ultimately, it held no interference was warranted with the impugned judgment and dismissed the writ appeal, framing the matter in terms of following settled law and the available statutory remedy.
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenges Ext.P5, the notification dated 14.07.2022 issued by the Commissioner, Malabar Devaswom Board, inviting applications for the post of non-hereditary trustees in Pisharikavu Devaswom. The petitioner, one of eight hereditary trustees, contends that the selection process for non-hereditary trustees is not permissible under the Madras Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act, 1951, specifically Section 39(2), and that Ext.P1 Scheme vests the administration of Pisharikavu Temple in eight hereditary trustees with non-hereditary trustees appointed by the Commissioner. The petitioner seeks quashing of Ext.P5, a declaration that no non-hereditary trustees can be appointed unless the contingency under Section 39(2) arises, and a writ of mandamus to compel the 1st respondent to finalize a new scheme in OA No.7 of 2018 in accordance with the Act. During proceedings, the Court referred to the decision in K. Chathu Achan v. State of Kerala (ILR 2022 (4) Kerala 199), which holds that active politicians or those engaged in political activities cannot be non-hereditary trustees, and that regular worshippers who are prepared to work for the temple should be eligible. The court directed the 1st respondent to proceed strictly in light of that ruling, consider Ext.P4 and the petitioner’s representations, and dispose the matter with a reasoned order within two months. The petition is thus disposed of with directions to the 1st respondent to consider representations, and to issue a reasoned order after hearing both sides; Ext.P5 proceedings and Ext.P4 complaint shall be decided in accordance with law.
Mayankutty, the Additional 3rd Respondent in Ex.F.A. No.43 of 2014, challenges the High Court of Kerala’s February 18, 2021 judgment disposing of Ex.F.A. No.43/2014 by a compromise recorded under Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC in O.S. No.48/2001. The original suit, for specific performance of an agreement to sell 1.65 acres, culminated in an ex parte decree against Moideen; after his death his legal heirs were brought on record as additional respondents. During the pendency, the parties arrived at a settlement dated 01/2021 under Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC, which the court recorded and disposed of Ex.F.A.43/2014 in terms of the compromise, with a direction that half of the court fee be refunded to the appellant. The review petition contends the compromise is invalid since Moideen’s heirs (additional respondents 3–5) were not signatories, and their rights remained adjudicated elsewhere; it argues that additional respondents were unnecessary and their interests not resolved, so the compromise cannot bind them. The High Court examined the scope of Order XXIII Rule 3 CPC and whether the compromise was properly recorded and binding on the parties who signed; it held that the essential parties to the compromise were the appellant and respondent 1, and that the non‑signatures of 3–5 did not invalidate the arrangement. Consequently, the petition is dismissed. The final order: review petition fails and is dismissed.
WP(C).7203/21; WP(C).8566/2021; WP(C).13904/2021; WP(C).15689/2021; WP(C).19915/2021; WP(C).21493/2021; WP(C).22624/2021; WP(C).24451/2021; WP(C).24545/2021 (connected) The batch of writ petitions before the Kerala High Court, consisting of WP(C) Nos. 7203/2021, 8566/2021, 13904/2021, 15689/2021, 19915/2021, 21493/2021, 22624/2021, 24451/2021 and 24545/2021, involves retired employees of the Kerala State Financial Enterprises Ltd (KSFE) challenging the non-disbursal of terminal benefits such as gratuity, earned leave surrender, dearness allowance arrears, salary revision arrears, festival incentives and other reliefs. The petitioners allege that approvals and recoveries were implemented via circulars or loans/“chits” and, because of alleged defaults, the company withheld their terminal benefits. They contend retirement benefits constitute earned property and must be disbursed promptly; withholding them without a disciplinary process violates mutual trust and Article 300-A rights, and employees are entitled to interest for delayed payment. The KSFE defends its practice of quantifying liabilities before retirement disbursement and adjusting recoveries against terminal benefits, arguing that liabilities due to sanctioned loans in the petitioners’ service periods justify deductions. The court emphasizes that no disciplinary action had been initiated and stresses that retirement benefits are constitutional rights; it relies on precedents recognizing pension/retiral benefits as property rights. Ultimately, the petitions are allowed with directions to disburse terminal benefits within three months, payment of 6% interest on gratuity from the retirement date, and 9% interest if payments remain unpaid beyond three months.”