BAIL APPL. NO. 4226 OF 2024 This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC filed by the third accused in Crime No.506/2024 of the Chadayamangalam Police Station, Kollam. The FIR alleges that on 27.04.2024, in furtherance of a common intention, the accused and others restrained the defacto complainant and his companions; the 1st accused abused the complainant and struck him on the head, while the 2nd accused inflicted a blow with an iron rod causing head injuries, and the 3rd accused punched the complainant in the right eye; during the altercation, a gold chain was allegedly stolen. The petitioner contends innocence and argues that Annexure A1 shows Section 308 IPC is not attracted, asserting that including 308 is a tactic to deny bail; he has been in judicial custody for about a month, the investigation is practically complete, and recovery has been effected; there are no criminal antecedents. The Public Prosecutor submits that the investigation is ongoing and that releasing the petitioner could enable tampering with evidence or intimidation of witnesses, especially since accused 1 and 2 are still in custody. The court notes that the overt acts lie primarily with the 1st and 2nd accused, while the petitioner’s act is comparatively minor. Relying on Sanjay Chandra v. CBI and Dataram Singh v. State of U.P., and on Article 21 (touchstone of bail), the court concludes that bail is the rule and imprisonment is the exception, and grants bail with conditions including a Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, weekly IO appearances, non-tampering obligations, surrender of passport, and standard safeguards, while cautioning that violations permit cancellation of bail.
Dr. Laila T. Abraham, a University Librarian at Mahatma Gandhi University, petitions for extension of service till the age of 60, contending that superannuation for University teachers should apply to Librarians as well, in line with UGC Regulations. She relies on Ext.P9(a) directing the Government to consider her claim in light of UGC Regulations 2010, and criticizes Ext.P11 for stating that Librarians’ retirement age cannot be enhanced to 60, arguing Ext.P11 amounts to contempt of court. The respondents contend that retirement age for MG University staff is governed by Kerala University First Ordinances, 1978, and the MG University Act (Section 99), and that no MG University Ordinances exist to alter Librarian retirement. They rely on Harikumar S. & Others v. State of Kerala (W.A.1283 of 2016) and Mathai M.M. v. Elizabeth Xavier (2011) to contend that UGC Regulations are only recommendatory and do not mandate parity between Librarians and Teachers. The court acknowledges that retirement age for Librarians is dictated by university regulations, not UGC, and that the petitioner has not challenged those regulations. Nevertheless, it directs a reconsideration by Government after hearing, within four months, to assess amendments to MG University Regulations and the potential role of UGC Regulations in the decision-making process.
This public interest litigation challenges ongoing protests and assemblies in public spaces around the Raj Bhavan and State Secretariat in Thiruvananthapuram, arguing that footpaths and public ways are being encroached for political protests and campaigns. The petitioners, led by the Trivandrum Chamber of Commerce and Industry and its President Raghu Chandran Nair, seek a mandamus directing state authorities and police to (i) earmark designated public spaces for mass assemblies and protests, and (ii) remove assemblies around the Secretariat and Raj Bhavan including adjoining footpaths. They urge constitutional and statutory safeguards, citing the Kerala Public Ways (Restriction of Assemblies and Processions) Act, 2011, as well as IRC pedestrian facility guidelines, and highlight instances where footpaths have been consolidated into makeshift shelters, obstructing pedestrian movement and affecting the general public and businesses. The petition also references Basil Attipetti v. State of Kerala (2012) to emphasize limitations on certain provisions of the Act. The respondents contend that enforcement is ongoing and sufficient, citing High Court orders and a 16 August 2021 circular, and argue that no fresh guidelines are necessary. The High Court, after considering statutory provisions, precedents, and executive measures, disposes of the petition with directions to comply with apex court orders and the 16 August 2021 circular, emphasizing enforcement over new earmarking guidelines.
This is an appeal under MACA No.3965 of 2019 from a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal award in O.P. (MV) No.683/2015, Perumbavoor, arising from injuries sustained on 15 December 2014 when the petitioner (a teacher) was injured in a scooter accident on the Angamaly–Kalady MC Road. The petitioner claimed compensation under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, alleging that the offending scooter, owned by the first respondent and insured by the second respondent, was driven rashly and negligently by the appellant. The Tribunal partly allowed the petition and directed the second respondent insurer to pay the compensation amount and recover it from the first respondent, on the ground that the first respondent violated insurance policy conditions by producing a fake driving licence. The petitioner’s evidence included Exts A1–A16; the insurer examined RW1 and produced Exts B1–B4; disability was assessed at 15% (Ext C1) and loss of earnings at Rs. 1,31,952, totaling Rs. 4,01,172 with interest and costs. The appellant contends lack of involvement in the accident, challenge to reliance on the charge-sheet (Ext A5), and disputes about licence validity and quantum. The High Court, citing Pazhaniammal and Kolavan, held that a charge-sheet can constitute prima facie evidence of negligence under Section 166, and that absence of a valid licence corroborates the insurer’s liability.
The court dismissed the appeal, upholding the impugned award, with each party bearing its own costs.
This writ petition challenges environmental clearance (Exhibit P6) and subsequent mining permissions granted to the 11th respondent for operations in Re Sy No. 10/114, 10/115 of Tholambra village, Thalassery Taluk, Kannur. The petitioner alleges the Environmental Clearance was issued by the District Environment Impact Assessment Authority (DEIAA) after a National Green Tribunal (NGT) judgment (Exhibit P12) and that the procedure contravenes the Supreme Court’s directions in Deepak Kumar v. State of Haryana, warranting invalidation. The site lies close to Poovatharkundu river, a biodiversity-rich area, within a moderate landslide hazard zone; the petitioner contends the project threatens water, ecology and local residents, and argues that the clearance should have been issued by SEIAA in light of cluster concerns and siting criteria under the Kerala Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2015. The petitioner relies on Exhibit P16 to urge reconsideration and seeks quashings of Exhibits P4, P6, P7, and P14; he also seeks mandamus to prevent mining without prior approval from the 8th respondent (District Level Crisis Management Group) and to take action against the mining plan holder. The respondents counter that the remedy lies with the NGT, that there is no demonstrated cluster or watercourse, and that EC procedures were proper. The court ultimately declines to decide merits, directing SEIAA to re-examine the issues after hearing both sides, with interim orders within three weeks and final orders within six weeks."
The petitioner, Kerala State Financial Enterprises Limited, challenges Ext.P11, an order of the 2nd respondent (Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) Unit-3) directing the petitioner to deposit 50% of the demand as a pre-condition to entertain its appeal under Section 250 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (Ext.P3). The assessment order (Ext.P1) and the demand notice (Ext.P2) were issued by the 3rd respondent, prompting the filing of Ext.P3 and a stay petition (Ext.P8). The court finds Ext.P11 to be patently wrong and in gross violation of settled law, notably Archana Agencies v. Commercial Tax Officer (2014 (2) KLT 715), which mandates that stay orders in taxation matters must be reasoned and must reflect a balance between the rights of the taxpayer and the State. The judgment emphasizes the duty to provide reasons for decisions and the necessity of fairness in quasi-judicial action, particularly under taxation statutes and Article 265 of the Constitution (no levy without law). Consequently, Ext.P11 is set aside, and the 2nd respondent is directed to reconsider Ext.P8 after due consideration of Archana and related decisions, with an opportunity of hearing, including issuing a fresh notice. Until a decision on Ext.P8 is rendered, all coercive measures arising from Exts.P1 and P2 are stayed. The court’s stance reinforces the obligation to reason and fairness in tax-adjudication processes.
This is a regular bail application by Nishad, the 8th accused in Nilambur Police Station Crime No. 280/2022. The prosecution case is that, in August 2019, accused Nos. 1 to 7 abducted Shaba Shareef, restrained him at the residence of the 1st accused, subjected him to beating to extract information about an ancestral treatment method, and, in October 2020, accused Nos. 1, 2, 8 and 9 allegedly killed Shareef, chopped his body, and threw the pieces into the river from the Seethi Haji Bridge at Edavanna. The petitioner, who was the driver of the 1st accused in 2019, contends he was falsely implicated by mistaken identity and had no knowledge of the crime. He asserts no direct or indirect evidence links him to the offence, no materials are recovered from his possession, and there is no confession implicating him. In custody since 10-05-2022, he has a family to support and no antecedents. His earlier bail applications were rejected by the Magistrate and this Court noted abroad involvement in a separate crime (Crime No. 422/2022) based on passport details. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, detailing the brutal, planned nature of the crime, involvement with others, and risk of absconding and witness tampering, including that the vehicle used was seized. Relying on Supreme Court bail principles (Prasanta Kumar Sarkar; Amarmani Tripathi; Prahlad Bhati; Ram Govind Upadhyay) and subsequent decisions (Deepak Yadav; Mamta; P…… v. MP; Kalyan Chandra Sarkar), the Court concludes the case warrants denial of bail. The application is dismissed with a direction to expedite the trial.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.MC No. 8858 of 2023) before the Kerala High Court arises from Crime No. 1491/2018 of Mundakayam Police Station, and CC No. 134/2019 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kanjirappally. The petitioner, Mahesh, faced charges under IPC sections 294(b) (filthy language), 457 (lurking house trespass), 324 (voluntarily causing hurt by dangerous weapon), 506(ii) (criminal intimidation), and 427 (mischief). The core issue is whether the prosecution can be quashed under Section 482 CrPC in light of a settlement between the accused and the complainant, despite the offences being non-compoundable. The petitioner’s counsel argued that the parties have settled, supported by the victim’s affidavit, and there is no objection to quashing. The Public Prosecutor acknowledged the settlement though he expressed reservations about quashing proceedings in non-compoundable cases. The High Court, applying the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in Laxmi Narayan (2019) and the earlier Gian Singh and Narinder Singh decisions, held that the dispute is private in nature and may be resolved via amicable settlement, making it appropriate to exercise the power under Section 482 CrPC to quash the case. The court ultimately allowed the petition and quashed proceedings against the petitioner in CC No. 134/2019.
Sumith V Kumar and Sandra Sanjith, both Scheduled Caste students, participated in NEET 2021 for admission to medical courses in Kerala. They challenge Clause 4.1.5 of Ext. P2 Prospectus, which prescribes that seats for SC/ST candidates shall be allotted after excluding the seats set apart for All India quota, Government of India nominees, special reservations, Persons with Disabilities, and other supernumerary or management quota. Clause 4.1.3 provides that Persons with Disabilities shall be given 5% of seats only after leaving seats under Clauses 4.1.1 and 4.1.2. Thus, two reservation frames are applied, allegedly marginalising SC/ST candidates and violating Article 14. The petition argued that such differential treatment is arbitrary and unconstitutional, eroding the constitutional safeguards for SC/ST. The State contends that the Constitution empowers the State to provide reservations and that Persons with Disabilities constitute a homogeneous class; their reservation is valid and based on enabling provisions of Article 15(5). It argues that the state can identify distinct classes and allocate seats through separate channels of entry, citing K. Duraisamy v. State of Tamil Nadu to support two-channel admissions and that such classification must rest on intelligible differentiation. The court, holding that PWD is a distinct class and that reserved seats are permissible, concludes that the petition lacks merit. The writ petition is dismissed, upholding the Prospectus provisions. The decision underscores the state's discretion in applying reservations within the constitutional framework.
OP(MAC) No.652/2011 & W.P.(C) No.31473/2009 Two related petitions before the Kerala High Court challenge MACT awards and related orders on tax deduction at source (TDS) from interest components of compensation. OP(MAC) 652/2011, filed by the Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation (Kumbakonam Division II), challenges Ext. P5 directing refund of Rs. 38,191 deducted as TDS from a MACT decree (Rs. 3,02,000 with 9% interest from 06.10.1998) and asserts that the compensation sum is not subject to TDS. WP(C) 31473/2009, filed by the Managing Director of the Tamil Nadu Road Transport Corporation, seeks to quash Ext. P3, which ordered deposit of sums and, following an attachment warrant, led to the attachment and later release of a vehicle after an affidavit. The petitioners contend that deduction of income tax at source is not warranted when the interest component on MACT awards is below Rs. 50,000, relying on statutory exemptions under the Income Tax Act and on Abdulla P.M. v. National Insurance Co. The respondents argue TDS is a statutory obligation under Sec. 194A(1) with exemptions only where the interest is under the threshold, and that breach of undertaking can justify attachment. The High Court ultimately holds that TDS deduction is not warranted where the interest is below the threshold, sustains the challenge to Ext. P5, and declines to interfere with Ext. P4’s attachment order, dismissing the petitions.
This Original Petition (OP(C)) arises from Ext.P6, an order in I.A.5/2020 in O.S.180/2013 before the Munsiff Court, Peermade. The respondents-plaintiffs had filed suits for possession of 2.667 cents of land after purchasing the property at a 2009 auction conducted by the Provident Fund Authority. The petitioners (Tamilians) were not conversant with Malayalam and faced language barriers, leading them to seek leave to amend the written statement (Ext.P4) and to amend the plaint in the related suit (Ext.P3) in consolidated proceedings. The trial court dismissed both amendments, holding they were barred by the proviso to Rule 17 of Order 6 CPC, since amendments would alter pleadings after trial commenced. The petitioners challenged Ext.P6 in this Court, arguing illiteracy and lack of awareness of pleadings; they rely on Supreme Court authority that amendments to pleadings follow a liberal yardstick, unlike amendments to plaint. The High Court, applying the principles in Sushil Kumar Jain v. Manoj Kumar (2009) 14 SCC 38, held that, in these circumstances, a liberal approach should apply and set aside Ext.P6 with directions to allow amendements in writing statement and to complete the process within a short timeframe. The decision underscores Article 227 supervisory jurisdiction to ensure expeditious disposal of the suits.
The present WA 906/2023 is a writ appeal from a learned Single Judge’s dismissal of W.P.(Crl.) No.754/2022 dated 04-04-2023. The appellant, M. R. Ajayan, editor of Green Kerala News, challenged the sale of a damaged Leonardo Helicopter MSN22394 owned by Yusuf Ali (Lulu Group) by The New India Assurance Company Ltd. through a sealed tender process, alleging fraud and violation of mandatory procedures. Exhibit-P1 notice described the sale on an “as is where is” basis, while the owner allegedly received the full insurance amount (about Rs. 62 crores) without two mandatory expert reports. The petitioner claimed that due diligence requirements had not been followed and sought investigation by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) into Exhibit-P2 dated 16.07.2022. Respondents countered that the sale complied with Insurance Act provisions and IRDA guidelines, a surveyor was appointed, and the claim settled after professional assessments, making the writ petition bald and baseless. The High Court declined to issue directions for CBI inquiry, emphasizing that Article 226 power should not be used to order criminal investigations into routine commercial transactions absent a lack of diligence. The court relied on the ratio from K. V. Rajendran to permit CBI only where FIR exists and the investigation is lackadaisical, ultimately dismissing the writ appeal. The bench comprised Chief Justice S. V. N. Bhatti and Justice Basant Balaji.
The Kerala High Court, hearing a Criminal Miscellaneous Case (CRL.M.C. No. 3789 of 2023) filed by Baby Varghese, examines whether inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC can quash criminal proceedings in SC No. 269 of 2021, pending before the District and Sessions Court, Ernakulam. The petitioner is accused of offences under IPC sections 294(b) (obscene acts), 509 (insult to modesty), and 354A(i)(iii) (outraging modesty) read with Section 3(1)(s) and 3(2)(va) of the SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. The prosecution alleges that on June 3, 2019, the accused, with others, hurled stones at the de facto complainant’s courtyard, abused the second respondent with caste-slurs, and exposed himself, causing indignity to women present. The petitioner’s counsel contends there is an amicable settlement; affidavits from respondents indicate resolution, and the investigation has been reviewed for impediments to terminating proceedings. The Public Prosecutor, while reserving opinion, acknowledges no remarkable prior antecedents and that respondents express no enduring grievances. The court surveys binding authority (Gian Singh, Narinder Singh, Laxmi Narayan, and other decisions) on the use of 482 CrPC to quash non‑compoundable offences where the dispute is private and resolved, while cautioning against quashing for heinous or public-interest offences. After weighing gravity, antecedents, and the settlement, the court holds that quashing is warranted and allows the petition, quashing the final report (Crime No. 538/2019) and all further proceedings (SC No. 269 of 2021).
This Original Petition challenges Ext.P8 order in IA No.637 of 2018 in O.S. No.452 of 2012 before the Sub Court, Kottayam. The petitioner, P.K. KuriaKose, was the defendant in the suit and had been ex parte; an ex parte decree was passed. He moved IA 1341 of 2017 to set aside the ex parte decree; the application was dismissed for default. Subsequently, he filed IA 637 of 2018 to restore IA 1341/2017. The trial court dismissed IA 637/2018 via Ext. P8, holding that there was lack of bonafides and that entertaining the petition would amount to abuse of process, citing the principles discussed in Parimal v. Veena (2011 KHC 4117) and considering past conduct to cast doubt on the petitioner's motives. The petitioner approached this Court under Article 227 of the Constitution. The Kerala High Court held that the trial court’s approach was hyper-technical and improper and overstepped its jurisdiction; it emphasized that substantial justice overrides technicalities and that matters must be decided on merits rather than default. It set aside Ext.P8, allowed Ext.P4, and restored IA 1341/2017 to the file, directing the Sub Court to hear both sides and dispose of IA 1341/2017 within three months, with execution of the ex parte decree deferred until disposal. This relief ensures a fair opportunity to contest the merits and avoid undue prejudice to the petitioner.
This is a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court hearing WA No. 781 of 2021 arising from WP(C) No. 4078 of 2021 challenging a show cause notice issued by the Customs Preventive Division, Thrissur, under the Customs Act, 1962, seeking confiscation of gold weighing 2599.08 grams and imposition of penalties under the Act. The petitioner claims possession of legally imported gold supplied by M/s Srikumaran Thangamaligal and produced Ext. P3 to substantiate procurement; however, the authorities contend the gold is smuggled or not proven to be legally procured. A previous application for release of the seized gold was rejected while the investigation proceeded. The learned Single Judge held the writ petition premature, noting the petitioner could raise all objections before the competent authority and left the matter open for due process. The appellant contends lack of jurisdiction in the initiating authority and seeks Article 226 relief, arguing the burden of proof on legal procurement rests on the State under Section 123 and that no smuggling occurred. The respondents rely on extant judgments that show cause notices are prima facie, require response, and that writ review at this stage is inappropriate, including Kunisetty Sathyanarayana and Haldia Wax. The Division Bench agrees that the jurisdiction lies with the statutory authority and dismisses the writ appeal, while directing expeditious completion of the enquiry, preferably within four weeks. The decision underscores deference to statutory show-cause processes and limits judicial interference at the show-cause stage.
This writ appeal challenges an interim order of the Kerala High Court (Single Judge) concerning a grant by Mannarkkad Municipality Council for starting a private fish market, conditioned by various infrastructure and public health requirements under the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994. The appellants, namely Mannarkkad Municipality, its Secretary, and the Municipal Council, challenged Ext. P19 (Council resolution) and Ext. P20 (Secretary’s notice) which denied licensure on the ground that basic infrastructure and regulatory conditions were not satisfied. The writ petitioner, Abdul Gafoor, contends that the Council exercised uncanalised and arbitrary power under Sections 460(3) and 463 to impose onerous prerequisites and that this power is not properly regulated due to lack of by-laws or government rules (Section 567). The learned Single Judge had issued an interim order directing that a license be issued to the petitioner if the application is otherwise in order, dehors Ext. P19’s stated reasons, to avoid further delay in a citizen’s litigation. The appellants argue that the issue is primarily about the legality of the Council’s uncanalised power under the Act and that interim relief should not amount to granting a final remedy without merits. The respondents emphasize public health and environmental concerns and argue for upholding the interim measures. The Division Bench ultimately held that the interim order was not appropriate and set it aside, leaving the matter to early merits hearing.
R.C.Rev.No.58 of 2022 before the Kerala High Court challenges eviction orders under Section 11(3) of the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The Rent Control Court (Additional Munsiff-I), Kozhikode, by order dated 28.11.2019, directed eviction on the ground of bona fide need, since the landlady Shineeja proposed to start a textile business and tailoring unit using the rooms. The matter was carried in appeal as R.C.A. No. 68 of 2020 before the Rent Control Appellate Authority, Kozhikode, which dismissed the appeal on 22.01.2022. The revision petitioner contends the need is not bona fide and points to the landlady’s wealth and multiple incomes as indicating a pretext. The record includes PW1, RW1, RW2 and Exts. A1–A18, B1. The Courts below held the need bona fide, and the Appellate Authority’s findings were not interfered with. The High Court, after hearing, reaffirmed that bona fide need must be real, sincere, and manifestly honest rather than a mere pretext, citing Adil Jamshed Frenchman, Shiv Samp Gupta, Deena Nath, Ammu v. Nafeesa, and other authorities. It held that the second proviso to Section 11(3) places burden on the tenant, and that the evidence supports the landlady’s plan. The revision petition was dismissed, and six months’ time to surrender was granted with conditions, including an affidavit, arrears deposit, rent, and license compliance.
Sukanya A.S., an Executive Assistant in the CGST and Central Excise department, challenged an Annexure-A1 order dated 22.04.2024 that sought to repatriate her from the Cochin Zone to her parent Chennai Zone in compliance with directions of the Board. The Central Administrative Tribunal had granted an interim stay on 24.04.2024. By Ext.P6 dated 21.05.2024, the Tribunal vacated that interim order. The petitioner contends that the order causes hardship, especially as she cares for her blind father, and seeks to restore the status quo ante by continuing in Cochin Zone and treating Annexure-A1 as ineffective. The respondents counter that transfer is an incidence of service and that the Recruitment Rules (2015/2016) do not provide for inter-Commissionerate transfer; they rely on policy, and the Apex Court’s guidance that policy can be revisited to accommodate compassionate grounds, along with the Tribunal’s decision to vacate the interim order. The Kerala High Court, while declining to issue notice and dismissing the petition, clarifies that the Tribunal is free to decide the Original Application on merits and that any repatriation must follow the Recruitment Rules and policy framework. The decision references S.K. Nausad Rahaman and related CAT jurisprudence for context, and indicates that the matter requires expeditious disposal by the Tribunal without commenting on merits of the Original Application."
BAIL APPL. NO. 5692 OF 2024 This bail application concerns Kanha Charan Bisoy, the first accused in Crime No. 324/2024 of the Ambalamedu Police Station, Ernakulam, charged with offences punishable under sections 461 and 394 read with section 34 IPC. The petitioner, aged 24, was arrested and remanded to judicial custody on 03.06.2024. The application, filed under section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, seeks bail. The prosecution asserts that the accused, in concert with another, trespassed into the de‑facto complainant’s hotel and robbed Rs.700, with the first accused slapping and the second kicking the victim. The petitioner contends total innocence, alleging false implication, with no material connecting him to the crime, and points out that 50 days have passed in custody, the investigation is virtually complete, and recovery has been effected; he also asserts no prior criminal record. The Public Prosecutor counters that the investigation is ongoing and that the accused, being Odisha native, may flee justice if released on bail. The judge, applying well settled principles, notes that bail is the rule and detention is the exception under Article 21, and relies on Hussainara Khatoon, Sanjay Chandra, and State of Kerala v. Raneef to emphasize the presumption of innocence and the rights of undertrial detainees. After balancing the rival submissions and the circumstances, the court allows the bail application subject to stringent conditions, aiming to safeguard the investigation while preserving the accused’s liberty.
Jiji Elamanna, judgment debtor, challenges Ext P4 of E.A. No. 2080/2022 in E.P. No. 159/2020 before the Subordinate Judge, Kozhikode, contending that the order is illegal and unsustainable since it precludes proper fixation of the reserve price for the auction arising from an ex parte award. The award, dated 31-01-2017 in ARC 1234/2016 of the Joint Registrar of Co-operative Societies (Arbitrator), awarded Rs. 45,32,483 with future interest. Execution proceedings were initiated, and an auction was conducted but attracted no bidders. The decree holder sought leave under Order 21 Rule 72A CPC to participate in the auction; leave was granted. The petitioner then moved EA 2080/2022 seeking appointment of an Advocate Commissioner to assist in fixing the reserve price. The court below rejected Ext P3 and Ext P4; the petitioner argues that Ext P4 permits evasion of due process and fails to ensure proper price fixation. The High Court references Anto Nitto v. South Indian Bank (1997 KHC 563) and Ammini v. K.V. Vibeesh (2019(3) KHC 646) to reconcile precedents. It holds that reserve price fixation with an Advocate Commissioner is appropriate when the decree holder participates in the auction, and that, if the decree holder does not participate, Ammini’s principle applies. The petition is allowed in part: the petitioner may file an Order 26 Rule 9 application within 10 days for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner, and EP 159/2020 shall remain in abeyance until further orders; the lower court is to decide expeditiously.