Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 527 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 4596 OF 2024

Firoz Hossain v. State of Kerala

This bail application under Section 439 CrPC is heard by a Single Judge of the Kerala High Court in respect of Crime No. 48/2024 of Changanacherry Excise Range Office, alleging possession of 31.116 grams of brown sugar, an NDPS Act offence. The sole accused, Firoz Hossain, was arrested on 10.04.2024 and has remained in judicial custody for about two months. He contends innocence, false implication, and lack of material linking him to the contraband; he points to the completed investigation and recovery, and highlights his clean criminal record and lack of antecedents. The prosecution argues ongoing investigation and flight risk, noting the petitioner’s origin in West Bengal and absence of Kerala roots. The court, applying well-settled jurisprudence on bail, including the Hussainara Khatoon principle that absence of local roots cannot be a sole ground to deny bail, finds that continued detention is unnecessary given the intermediate quantity of contraband, near-complete investigation, and absence of antecedents. Consequently, the court allows the bail application, directing the accused to furnish a bond of Rs. 1,00,000 with two solvent sureties, and prescribing conditions for appearance, non-tampering with witnesses, non-commission of offences, passport surrender, restrictions on leaving the jurisdiction, provision of addresses and mobile number, and possible cancellation of bail for non-compliance. The ruling also references Sushila Aggarwal for the proper calibration of bail conditions.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos. 23186 of 2022 & connected cases

Writ petitions by Managers of Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools challenging Government Order GO(MS) No.121/2022/G.Edn. dated 7.7.2022 and the prospectus for Plus One admissions 2022-23 (consolidated).

These batch writ petitions, heard by a single judge of the Kerala High Court, challenge Government Order GO(MS) No.121/2022/G.Edn. and the Plus One admission prospectus for 2022-23 insofar as they pertain to Private Aided Higher Secondary Schools. The core controversy centers on the allocation of 20% management quota in PAHS, the merger of a 10% community quota into management quota, and the Centralized Admission Process (CAP). The petitioners—managers of PAHS—argue the GO interferes with established rights, breaches Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution, and contravenes precedents that prohibit community or management-based quotas. The State defends the policy as a corrective measure to eliminate corruption and ensure merit, transparency, and uniform application of reservation norms, aided by CAP. The court undertakes a constitutional-review, distinguishing between permissible policy decisions and illegal classifications, and ultimately strikes down the 10% community quota in the impugned GO as unconstitutional while upholding the 20% management quota and directing that the 10% seats be treated as open-merit seats to be filled via CAP. Admissions already made under declarations by management are not disturbed. The decision underscores the court’s restraint in reviewing government policy unless constitutional rights are violated.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL.NO.5298 OF 2024

Justine Baby v. State of Kerala

Justine Baby, aged 31, stands accused in Crime No.765/2024 of Kattappana Police Station, Idukki, of offences under Sections 294(b), 326 and 307 IPC. The petitioner applies under Section 439 CrPC for bail after surrendering on 28.05.2024. The prosecution alleges that on 26.05.2024, at around 23:00 hrs, the accused, out of prior animosity toward the injured Christo, rammed his car into the motorcycle, causing the rider to fall and suffer grievous injuries, and then attempted to run over the victim. The defence contends innocence, arguing the injuries resulted from a road accident and that the IO has inappropriately included sections 326 and 307 to ensure detention. The applicant has been in judicial custody for 55 days, the investigation is practically complete, and no prior criminal record exists. The court cites Sanjay Chandra v. CBI and Dataram Singh v. State of U.P. to reaffirm the presumption of innocence and that bail is the rule, with detention only as an exception. After balancing the rival submissions and the material on record, the court holds that continued detention is unnecessary and grants bail subject to bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, and conditions including regular appearance, no tampering with witnesses, surrender of passport, and the possibility of cancellation on breach; recoveries may be effected on bail under Sushila Aggarwal principles.

High Court of Kerala
RCREV. NO. 38 OF 2024; RCREV. NO. 104 OF 2024

P. M. Hussain v. Binu G and B. Nirmala Devi (Rent Control Revisions, Kerala High Court)

Two Rent Control Revision petitions, RCRev.38/2024 filed by the tenant P. M. Hussain and RCRev.104/2024 filed by the landlords against the same appellate judgment arising from RCA No.17 of 2022, relate to eviction on the ground of personal necessity and determination of arrears of rent under the Kerala Buildings (Lease and Rent Control) Act, 1965. The Rent Controller dismissed the petition under the proviso to Section 11(3) on the ground of lack of bona fide need, and directed determination of arrears. The Lower Appellate Authority reversed the Rent Controller’s findings and ordered eviction, but did not determine the arrears, prompting the landlords to file RCRev.104/2024. The revision petitions were heard on 12.06.2024, and the High Court, in a Division Bench led by Hon’ble Justice Amit Rawal and Hon’ble Justice Easwaran S., allowed RCRev.38/2024 and dismissed RCRev.104/2024, setting aside the appellate order and upholding the rent controller’s disposition. The court relied on the consent letter dated 13.02.2019 and other materials indicating malafide intent, and emphasized that a landlord must approach the court with clean hands. It held that the evidence supported the Bona Fide Need issue; while granting relief, it directed that arrears be settled in accordance with law and, as an interim measure, to pay arrears after deducting amounts already paid. The order underscores the clean hands doctrine and the need to evaluate bona fide need against full factual context, including concealment of related tenancy arrangements.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5531 OF 2024 & 5554 OF 2024

Akshay K. Shal v. State of Kerala

This is a common order in two bail applications under Section 438 CrPC filed by Akshay K. Shal, accused in Crime Nos. 829/2023 and 836/2023 of the North Paravur Police Station, Ernakulam. The petitioner is charged with offences punishable under Sections 406, 420, 465, 468 and 471 of the Indian Penal Code, relating to allegedly forging building permits and fabricating the digital signature of the municipality to obtain money from de facto complainants. The applications seek pre-arrest bail; the defense contends innocence, false implication, and lack of material to substantiate the charges, arguing custodial interrogation is unnecessary and no recovery is effected. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, noting the petitioner has criminal antecedents and involvement in four other similar crimes at the same police station, and warns that bail could lead to witness intimidation or tampering with evidence. The judge cites Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra (2011) 1 SCC 694, outlining anticipatory bail parameters such as gravity of the accusation, prior antecedents, flight risk, likelihood of repetition, impact on the investigation, and the need to guard against misuse of arrest. After considering the material and the fact that the petitioner has prior antecedents and that custodial interrogation is necessary, the court finds no satisfactory grounds to grant protection under Sec. 438. Consequently, the bail petitions are dismissed, and the judge notes a prior order (Annexure A4) dismissing a similar application.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 21624 OF 2020

Anulal O. v. AL Airport Services Limited and Others

Anulal O., a contractual Junior Customer Agent engaged by Air India Air Transport Services Limited (AIATSL) on Ext. P3, challenges the non-renewal of his contract and seeks renewal and deployment as a Junior Customer Agent at Kochi International Airport, besides a correction in ESI registration. Ext. P3, dated 17.04.2017, envisaged a fixed term of three years from 17.04.2017 to 16.04.2020, with a possibility of extension due to contractual needs and pandemic; it may automatically expire on 16.04.2020 or on attaining the age of 58, whichever is earlier. During its subsistence, the petitioner was de-rostered on 01.02.2019, a matter addressed in W.P.(C) No. 9421/2019, with a 27.05.2019 judgment directing the 4th respondent to decide on wages from that date. The petitioner argues that renewal is due and non-renewal violates natural justice, affecting livelihood as the family relies on his income. The respondents contend the petition is not maintainable under Article 226 for a contractual post and that no statutory right to renewal exists; the remedy would be damages under the Specific Relief Act, 1963. The court dismisses the writ, holding that fixed-term contracts do not guarantee renewal, and Article 226 cannot compel renewal; damages under Section 40 may be pursued if breach is proved. It also relies on authorities on victimisation pleading (Bharat Iron Works) and the no-renewal principle (Yoghesh Mahajan).

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5145 OF 2024

Ambareesh P D and Sumesh Thathuppara alias Sumesh T B v. State of Kerala and others

This is a bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed by Ambareesh P D and Sumesh Thathuppara alias Sumesh T B, accused in Crime No.292/2024 of Kelakom Police Station, Kannur, along with eight co-accused, for offences under IPC sections 143, 147, 148, 452, 341, 324, 326 and 427 read with 149. The prosecution alleges that on 05.05.2024, around 9 PM, the accused, in common intention, trespassed into the de facto complainant’s house, dragged him out and assaulted him with wooden sticks, resulting in grievous injuries. The petition seeks pre-arrest bail under Sec.438 CrPC. The petitioners claim innocence and challenge the addition of Section 326 without substantial material, asserting no custodial interrogation is necessary, and that the dispute with respondents 2 and 3 has been amicably settled (Annexure A4). Respondents 2 and 3 state the dispute has been resolved, statements have been recorded, and custodial interrogation is unnecessary for proper investigation. The court notes the settlement and the lack of subsisting grievance, and, after considering the submissions, allows the application, directing surrender within 10 days, bond of Rs.50,000 with two sureties, and other standard bail conditions, citing Sushila Aggarwal for post-bail recoveries.

High Court of Kerala
B.A. No. 5378 of 2024

Adarsh v. State of Kerala

The petitioner, Adarsh, the fourth accused, moved B.A. No. 5378 of 2024 before the Kerala High Court under Section 439 CrPC seeking bail in Crime No. 46/2023 registered at Agali Excise Range Office, Palakkad. The case involves narcotics allegedly seized from two vehicles on 13.11.2023: 91 kg of ganja from the first vehicle and 25.75 kg from the second, with the fourth accused driving the latter vehicle. The prosecution contends a conspiracy among accused 1–3 to transport contraband from Andhra Pradesh and sell it in Kerala, and that the fourth accused knowingly drove the second vehicle with contraband. The offence, under Sections 20(b)(ii)(c), 25 and 29 of the NDPS Act, involves a commercial quantity, invoking the stringent bail regime under Section 37 of the NDPS Act. The petitioner argues lack of material tying him to the transport, innocence, and has been in judicial custody for over eight months, with investigation complete and final report filed. The Public Prosecutor opposing emphasizes the accused’s role in driving the vehicle with knowledge of contraband and the contraband’s commercial quantity, calling for denial of bail under Section 37. The Court notes the NDPS bail framework, considers judicial precedents on the subject, and ultimately finds no reasonable grounds to believe the petitioner is not guilty or unlikely to re-offend, dismissing the bail application and upholding the rigour under the Act.”

High Court of Kerala
B.A.No.5121 of 2024

Narayana v. State of Kerala

Narayana, the sole accused, is arraigned in Crime No.4/2022 of Ernakulam South Police Station for the murder of his wife and two children by administering a large quantity of sleeping tablets mixed in ice cream, followed by strangulation. He was arrested on 06-01-2022 and has remained in judicial custody for more than two and a half years as the trial (S.C. No.658/2022) has not yet commenced, pending receipt of the Forensic Science Laboratory report. The prosecution alleges a motive of heavy financial liabilities; the accused allegedly attempted suicide after the killings. The petitioner argues innocence, false implication, and infringement of Article 21 due to delayed trial. The Public Prosecutor counters with the gravity of the crime, risk of flight since the accused hails from Tamil Nadu, and potential danger to others, including a possible suicide attempt if enlarged on bail. The Trial Court has indicated that the FSL report has not been received despite repeated reminders, and would require about three months after receipt to conclude the trial. The Kerala High Court cites Ankur Chaudhary and Shince Babu to hold that prolonged pre-trial detention infringing Article 21 mandates consideration of bail. Considering the long custody, pendency of trial, and the fact that recoveries may be pursued during bail, the court allows bail on stringent conditions: Rs 50,000 bond with two sureties, residence, regular appearances, travel restrictions, no tampering, passport surrender, and potential bail cancellation for violation. The Forensic Lab report is to be submitted, enabling the trial to proceed.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) 27434 of 2022

Manju Jose and Others v. State of Kerala and Others

This is a writ petition (WP(C)) filed by four aided school teachers working in schools under the Corporate Educational Agency, Diocese of Kothamangalam, challenging the non-approval of their appointments made against additional division vacancies from 1 June 2010. The petitioners seek a declaration that their appointments be deemed approved from the date of appointment, treating that the manager had executed a bond as per Government Order G.O.(P) No.10/10/G.Edn. The background includes a ban on appointments in such vacancies under G.O.(P) No.317/2005/G.Edn. (2005) and its lifting with conditions by G.O.(P) No.10/10/G.Edn. (2010), which required managers to execute a consent/undertaking that vacancies would be filled from protected teachers in proportion to appointments made during 2006-07 to 2009-10. The Government later included petitioners in the comprehensive teacher’s package via G.O.(P) No.199/2011/G.Edn (2011), with regularisation from 01.06.2011. The petitioners rely on precedents, including a Division Bench decision in Suma Devi (supra) that non‑execution of bond should be deemed executed, obliging equal appointments from protected teachers. The respondents contend 1:1 apportionment and that bonds must be executed; some matters are before the Supreme Court. The court disposes of the petition by directing reconsideration of revision petitions (Exhs P6-P9) within four months, allowing deeming of bonds, and noting orders remain subject to final Apex Court orders.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO. 2182 OF 2022

Samgi Mathew v. State of Kerala & Others

This petition, CRL.MC 2182/2022, challenges the final report in Crime No.236/2017 and CC 596/2017 at Pathanamthitta, where the petitioner Samgi Mathew faces offences under sections 279 and 427 IPC for allegedly driving a car that struck a KSEB A-type pole, causing damages of Rs. 35,625. The Kerala High Court, in an order dated 11 January 2023, allowed the Criminal Misc. Case in part and quashed the 427 IPC charge while leaving the 279 IPC charge intact. The court scrutinized Annexure A2 (the Final Report) and emphasized that the core allegation is rash and negligent driving, not intentional mischief. It found that the material does not establish an offence under Section 425 IPC (mischief), which requires intention to cause loss or knowledge that damage is likely, a mental element absent in the record. The court relied on Rajesh R. v. State of Kerala (2014) and Basdev v. State of Pepsu to explain the distinction between intent and knowledge and to hold that mischief cannot be subsumed within rash driving. While quashing 427, the court directed that prosecution may proceed under 279 IPC and urged expeditious disposal of the long-pending case. Annexures A1 and A2 were considered for record-keeping and to define the scope of the quashable charges.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C) No.21117/2021

Rajeevan E. v State of Kerala and Others

Rajeevan E., a junior assistant (under suspension) with Supplyco at Kozhikode, was placed under suspension on 6 September 2021 following an inspection that revealed shortages of boiled rice and an excess of wheat at the NFSA godown in Vellayil, Kozhikode. He had taken charge on 11 March 2019, when the godown served as a joint stock repository for five other godowns under three ration offices. The petitioner claims that no stock verification was conducted at the time of taking charge, there was no formal authorization naming him as custodian, and the godown was poorly maintained with stock belonging to multiple offices, making liability attribution to a single custodian problematic. He requests quashing Ext.P9 and an audit covering June 2019 to March 2021. Supplyco contends that the petitioner acknowledged taking charge and that stock verifications were conducted twice under head office direction; the 31 March 2021 inspection showed a shortage in rice and excess stock in wheat, justifying suspension pending enquiry. The court noted that suspension is not a penalty but a pre-enquiry precaution, and found that material to support liability was lacking at this stage. The writ petition was disposed of with directions to review the suspension and expedite the enquiry, directing completion within three months, given transfer and tampering concerns."

High Court of Kerala
BA No. 2748 of 2022

Sakkir Hussain v. State of Kerala

This is a bail application under Section 439 CrPC by Sakkir Hussain, accused No.3 in Crime No. 22/2020 of Parappanangadi Excise Range Office, Malappuram, under NDPS Act Sections 22(b)(ii)B, 22(c) and 29. The prosecution alleges that on 22.11.2020, 1st and 2nd accused were found in possession of contraband—88.120 g MDMA, 1.150 kg Ganja, 0.930 g LSD stamp and 325.580 g Hashish—in a rented house, and that the contraband was supplied by the petitioner, who was arrested on 14.07.2021 and has remained in custody. The defense contends there is no material linking him to the offences; the MDMA initially identified was later found to be Methamphetamine; the 1st and 2nd accused have already been granted statutory bail; the petitioner is said to be implicated largely on the confession statements of others. The prosecution counters with call data records (about 356 calls) and regular monetary transactions totaling around Rs. 5.49 lakh, suggesting involvement and a pattern of courier-based delivery via DTDC from Goa. The court finds materials indicating prima facie complicity and a modus operandi, noting the petitioner’s involvement in related cases. While Mohd. Muslim v. State (NCT of Delhi) is cited to explain Section 37 NDPS bail standards, the judge emphasizes case-by-case satisfaction rather than a rigid rule and, while acknowledging Fasil v. State of Kerala’s dilution remark, limits that observation. Ultimately, bail is denied; the court records a report that trial can be completed within eight months and directs expeditious prosecution.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) Nos.23679/2021; 26212/2021; 26762/2021

W.P.(C) Nos.23679/2021, 26212/2021 and 26762/2021 (K.V. Jacob & Sons, Engineers & Contractors; SkIlled Constructions Company Ltd.; Deens Group v Cochin Smart Mission Ltd and Others)

The Kerala High Court heard three related writ petitions challenging government relaxations reducing performance security in Smart City Mission contracts in Kochi. Petitions W.P.(C) Nos.23679/2021, 26212/2021 and 26762/2021 involve works awarded to three contractors: K.V. Jacob & Sons (roads under Division I & II), Skilled Constructions Company Ltd. (minor/foot over bridges), and Deens Group (roads and smart roads). The core grievance is that, under Atmanirbhar Bharat Package, the Union government issued OM dated 12.11.2020 reducing performance security from 5–10% to 3% for existing contracts, with retention money to be released proportionally. Kerala Government issued GO(P) No.7/2021/Fin dated 7.1.2021 relaxing security/earnest money requirements for public works, applicable to new tenders and to works where agreements had not yet been signed; petitioners argue discrimination as those with signed agreements before 7.1.2021 are excluded, violating Article 14 (equality) per the test in State of West Bengal v Anwar Ali Sarkar. Respondents contend the central OM applies to contracts under GFR 2017 while GO(P) 7/2021 only covers new tenders or works without signed agreements; contracts already signed fall outside its scope. The court ultimately held that GO 7/2021 does not apply to pre-signed contracts and dismissed the petitions on contract-law grounds, noting no fundamental rights violation and that petitioners cannot compel contractual concessions via writs.

High Court of Kerala
MACA No. 932 of 2018

IFFCO TOKIO GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED v GOPIDAS & OTHERS

The Kerala High Court, in MACA No. 932 of 2018, disposed of an appeal by IFFCO Tokio General Insurance Company Limited challenging a Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (Alappuzha) award concerning the death of Vishnu in a road accident that occurred on 07.02.2011. The petitioners (Respondents 1–3) had sought compensation for Vishnu’s death after he was struck by KSRTC buses while riding a motorcycle; the petition involving two KSRTC buses and a vehicle in transit from Ashok Leyland (the 8th respondent). The Tribunal held both KSRTC drivers negligent and directed the insurers (including the appellant) and the vehicle’s manufacturer to pay the compensation in equal proportion, the quantum being Rs. 11,62,500 along with interest and costs. The appellant argued that there was no valid coverage for the KSRTC vehicle on the accident date, contending that the policy issued was only a cover note for transit and not a policy in force for the KSRTC; the policy reportedly ran 01.04.2010 to 31.03.2011 and named Ashok Leyland as the insured. The respondent KSRTC maintained coverage existed. The High Court examined Ext.B1 (policy certificate) and, relying on Section 157 MV Act and precedents on just compensation, held coverage existed during transit and sustained the Tribunal’s conclusion. The court also addressed quantum, noting that the monthly income should be adjusted upward in light of Ramachandrappa, Syed Sadik, and Minu Rout to ensure just compensation. The appeal was dismissed and the Tribunal’s award confirmed.

High Court of Kerala
OP(DRT) Nos. 95 & 272 of 2023

OP (DRT) Nos. 95 of 2023 and 272 of 2023 (Common Judgment)

This is a common judgment of the High Court of Kerala, Ernakulam, delivered by Justice C. S. Dias on 27 July 2023, arising from OP (DRT) Nos. 95 and 272 of 2023, challenging OA 258/2013 filed before the Debt Recovery Tribunal, Ernakulam. The petitions involve a bank’s recovery suit (Federal Bank) and sundry counter claims by the respondents in OA 258/2013. OP 272/2023 is filed by the Federal Bank as petitioner seeking expeditious consideration of OA 258/2013 and the counter claim, while OP 95/2023 is filed by VK Abdul Rahim seeking expeditious disposal and a directive to consider IA Nos. 2310/2015 and 2311/2015, which were filed in the OA. A central issue is whether a counter claim in OA 258/2013 is maintainable, with the bank citing Nahar Industrial Enterprises Limited v. Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (2009) 8 SCC 646 to argue against maintainability, and the respondents contending that no Supreme Court declaration bars the counter claim. The Court, invoking Article 227 of the Constitution, determines that a “quietus” can be achieved by directing the Tribunal to decide maintainability first, then dispose of OA 258/2013 expeditiously. It directs DRT-I to decide IA Nos. 2310/2015 and 2311/2015 within one month of certified copy, thereafter enabling disposition of OA 258/2013 in accordance with law.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P No.129 of 2011

Sugatha, D/o Subhashini v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition arising from CC 479/1997 (Judicial First Class Magistrate, Attingal) and the affirmation in CRL Appeal No. 299/1999 by the Fast Track Court, Thiruvananthapuram, upholding a conviction under Sections 55(a) and 55(g) of the Abkari Act against the revision petitioner, Sugatha. The prosecution alleged possession of illicit arrack (5 litres) and wash for brewing arrack (20 litres) on 16.04.1996. The trial court sentenced two years’ simple imprisonment and Rs.25,000 fine, with default imprisonment. The appellate court did not interfere. In the revision petition, the accused attacked the prosecution evidence on multiple grounds: absence of a search memo, lack of a property list, and a questionable link between seized contraband and the chemical analysis due to defects in seals, forwarding notes, and specimen impressions. Independent witnesses turned hostile, leaving only official witnesses. The court noted that the detection and investigation were performed by PW1, the Excise Inspector, and highlighted serious doubts about the chain of custody, including the seal, forwarding note, and tamper-proof dispatch. Relying on several precedents (Moothedath Sivadasan, Bhaskaran, Rajamma, Sasidharan, Ajayakumar), it held that the prosecution failed to prove link evidence beyond reasonable doubt. The revision petition was allowed, acquitting Sugatha and cancelling her bail bond.

High Court of Kerala
RP 765/2022; RP 827/2022 in OP(C) No. 377/2022

Nanminda High School Society v. District Educational Officer, Thamarassery; OP(C) 377/2022; RP Nos. 765/2022 & 827/2022

This judgment from the Kerala High Court (K. Babu, J.) deals with two review petitions (RP Nos. 765 of 2022 and 827 of 2022) challenging the judgment dated 12.7.2022 in OP(C) No. 377 of 2022 concerning Nanminda High School Society. The original suit sought a declaration that the society’s general body meeting held on 21.1.2021 was invalid for want of prescribed quorum, and that there was no validly elected governing body. Plaintiffs prayed for a temporary injunction restraining the current management from functioning as office-bearers pending disposal of the suit. The trial court dismissed the injunction; the District Court affirmed; this Court had dismissed the Original Petition earlier, leaving the court to dispose of the suit. The review petitions challenge the direction in the OP(C) judgment restraining appointments in Nanminda High School, arguing that it violates Section 33 of the Kerala Education Act, 1958. The court recalls statutory provisions and Supreme Court precedents that injunctions should not be granted in such educational-act proceedings and that a court should not direct authorities to contravene statutory provisions. The Pawing issue is whether the restraining order should stand. The court vacates the restraining directive to the extent it binds appointments, but directs that all appointments be subject to the outcome of OS No.173/2021 and that the trial court dispose of it within two months. The petitions are disposed of accordingly.

High Court of Kerala
W.A.NO.1596 OF 2021

Divyamol.R.S v. Union of India and Others

Divyamol.R.S., an Assistant Sub-Inspector/Clerk in the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), challenged a 2021 transfer from Cochin to the CISF unit at Narsapur, Andhra Pradesh, arguing that compassionate-ground appointment guidelines shielded her from out-of-state postings and that the transfer was a mid-term punitive action following a sexual harassment complaint against a superior officer. Her career began after a compassionate appointment in 2007, with postings in Cochin and subsequent transfers including an order moving her to Vishakhapatnam in 2015 and later to Kudigi (Karnataka) in 2017. The writ petitions and subsequent writ appeal, heard by a Division Bench of the Kerala High Court, scrutinized whether the guideline-based protection from transfer and the spouse-posting clause created a right to stay within Kerala or in the same station as her husband. The respondents asserted that transfers in a disciplined force are in the exigencies of service, governed by statutory provisions and internal guidelines, and not subject to routine interference by courts; the transfer to Narsapur was justified to maintain discipline and administrative efficiency. The court analyzed the law on transfer in service, the nature of disciplinary proceedings, and the lack of formal harassment complaints, ultimately holding that the impugned transfer was valid. The appeal was dismissed, interim orders vacated, and the petitioner was to be relieved to report at Narsapur, after joining time.

High Court of Kerala
W.P.(C). Nos. 2543 & 15384 of 2021

W.P.(C). Nos. 2543 & 15384 of 2021 (Kerala High Court)

Captioned writ petitions challenge the validity and application of the Kerala Preservation of Trees Act, 1986 (KPT Act) and the Kerala Promotion of Tree Growth in Non-Forest Areas Act, 2005 (Act, 2005), in relation to trees standing on private land restored from vesting under the Kerala Private Forest (Vesting and Assignment) Act, 1971. The petitioners claim ownership of 7.8890 hectares in Mangalam Dam village, traced to a 1965 sale and a 1993 judicial order that restored 107 acres of land and rescinded certain KPT Act restrictions; they sought to cut teak and rubber trees to replant rubber, arguing the rubber crop is mature and diseased, and that teak trees threaten the replanting. They rely on Exhibit P4 notification being rescinded (by Exhibit P5 in 1993), on the Supreme Court’s decision in State of Kerala v Abdul Ali (2013) and on Ouseph Kuriakose v Divisional Forest Officer (2020) to contend that the Act, 2005 relaxes restrictions on non-forest land and that Section 6(1) of Act, 2005 permits cutting of non-sandalwood trees, subject to exceptions. The respondents counter that Section 5 of KPT Act remains in force for the notified area; that P9 and P10 orders were properly issued; and that a strict compliance with both statutes is necessary. The court, after hearing, disposed of the petitions by dismissing WP2543 and allowing WP15384 to the limited extent stated in judgment.