Tenetowl LogoTenetowl

Indian Court Judgements Archive

Public, crawlable legal index containing extracted Indian judgments, bench details, statutory citations, and full case text.

Total Records: 93,163•Page 525 of 4659
High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C No.2530 of 2023

Vishnusathyan and others v. State of Kerala

This is a Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC concerning seven accused (Vishnusathyan, Vishnusukanaran, Abhijithca, Nishanth Hari, VivekSathyan, Akhilka, Akhilappu) charged along with others in CC No. 438/2022 before the Judicial Magistrate of the First Class, Chottanikkara. The petition seeks to quash the proceedings on the ground of amicable settlement between the parties who allege no lasting grievance and wish to end the prosecution to restore peace. The offences include sections 143, 147, 294(b), 323, 324, 506(1) read with 149 IPC. The Respondents/police oppose quashing solely on the basis of settlement, noting the seriousness of the offences and seeking a balanced approach; however, they acknowledge no further crimes against the petitioners. The High Court relies on established Supreme Court principles that the inherent power under Section 482 CrPC to quash non-compoundable offences can be exercised in private, civil-like disputes where the entire dispute is resolved, except for heinous, serious, or public-service-offence categories. After considering gravity, antecedents, and the amicable settlement, the Court holds that quashing would not harm public interest or the ends of justice. Consequently, the petition is allowed and the final report (Annexure-A2) and all further proceedings in CC 438/2022 are quashed.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 636 OF 2011

Reji Mathew v. Ramachandran and State of Kerala

Reji Mathew v. Ramachandran and State of Kerala is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition challenging a conviction under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The trial court in CC 630/2002, Ranni, held that the revision petitioner issued Ext. P1, a cheque dated 09.07.2002, in discharge of a debt of Rs. 3,00,000 to the complainant; the cheque bounced for insufficiency of funds. The complainant issued four lawyer notices (two signed by mistake) and the case proceeded to trial. Exts. P1 to P14 were marked; the petitioner examined DW1 and marked Exts. D1–D8; the petitioner did not respond to Section 313 questions. The trial court convicted under Sec. 138 NI Act and sentenced three months’ imprisonment with Rs. 3,50,000 by way of compensation under CrPC 357(3), and a further three months on default. On appeal, the Appellate Court confirmed the conviction but reduced the sentence to imprisonment till the rising of the Court, preserving the compensation. The High Court confirmed the conviction, rejecting the claim that Ext. P1 was given only as security and observing that Ext. P1 relates to a legally enforceable debt. It relied on presumptions under Sections 118 and 139, and on the reverse onus doctrine; it cited Kumar Exports, Rangappa, Kalamani Tex, Shree Daneshwari Traders and other authorities. The revision petition is dismissed; the conviction and sentence are affirmed; two months’ time to deposit the fine is granted; appearance before the Trial Court by 13.11.2023; execution stayed until that date; copy to be sent to the Trial Court for compliance.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C).21391/21

Sudeep K.T. v. Malabar Cancer Centre and others

The petitioner, Sudeep K.T., was the Head of the Department (Engineering & Maintenance) at Malabar Cancer Centre and was subjected to a memo of charges (Exhibit P1) dated 18 March 2020, to which he responded (Exhibit P2). Subsequently, he was placed under suspension by Exhibit P3 on 28 March 2020, with the period of suspension extended on several occasions. One extension is Exhibit P3(A) dated 15 June 2021, and another extension is Exhibit P5 dated 25 September 2021, extending the suspension from 27 September 2021 to 26 December 2021. The petitioner contends that once the suspension period has elapsed, further extensions are impermissible and that the respondents are obliged to reinstate him; he asserts that indefinite suspension is untenable, and that the extension must be justified by contemporaneous reasons. He relies on the Supreme Court’s Ajay Kumar Choudhary v. Union of India (2015) 7 SCC 291 to argue that suspension pending a disciplinary inquiry should be temporary and not protracted or punitive in nature, and that repeated renewals without a prompt resolution undermine due process. The respondents contend that Exhibit P5 was pre-dated and issued after the period of suspension had elapsed, and that the extension was contemplated after considering the file on 23 September 2021, with delays arising from administrative issues, RTI queries, and COVID-related disruptions. In a dispositive mode, the Court disposed of the petition directing that the inquiry initiated with Exhibit P1 be completed within three months.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.MC NO.3072 OF 2021

Sunilkumar v. State of Kerala

This petition, CRL.MC 3072/2021, arises from the order in SC No.838/2019 of the Fast Track Special Court, Haripad, and challenges the discharge of the sole accused in a case involving offences under IPC Sections 451, 354 and 354D, POCSO Act, and SC/ST Act, in relation to a minor defacto complainant. The petitioner alleges long-standing enmity between families and false involvement in a case rooted in personal disputes over land and local grievances, asserting that the initial investigation culminated in a final report under Section 173(2) CrPC and was later followed by a further investigation under Section 173(8). The subsequent 173(8) report, which found no offence, was superseded by an Annexure-9 discharge order by the Fast Track Court, which the petitioner contends is illegal and results in miscarriage of justice. The State contends that sections 173(2) and 173(8) permit continued investigation or discharge depending on the evidence, and that a supplementary (further) investigation does not erase the earlier report. The High Court discusses Vinay Tyagi, Joseph, and Amit Kapoor to explain the permissible interplay between 173(2) and 173(8), clarifying that a 173(8) report does not automatically nullify a 173(2) report and that a court may discharge, proceed, or order further investigation. Ultimately, the Court modifies the discharge order, holding that the 173(8) report cannot erase the 173(2) report and directing that the proceedings continue in accordance with law, including consideration of framing a charge or allowing further investigation.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5104 OF 2024

Moidu and others v. State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court bail application under Sec. 438 CrPC before Judge C.S. Dias concerning four accused in Crime No. 202/2024 of Vellamunda Police Station, Wayanad. The petition seeks pre-arrest bail for the petitioners, who face charges under IPC sections 341, 294(b), 354B, 324, and 506 r/w 34. The prosecution contends that on 01.05.2024, in furtherance of their common intention and due to animosity toward the defacto complainant, they restrained her husband, abused them, tore the defacto complainant’s purdah, and outraged her modesty. The petitioners contend they are related to the former husband, maintained cordial relations, and that the present complaint arises from a dispute over compensation intended for the late husband’s employer, with misappropriation alleged by the defacto complainant’s present husband. They deny tearing the purdah and argue custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The court, after considering the materials, notes family-dispute dynamics and pending Mahal Committee proceedings, and privileges pre-arrest bail with conditions. It cites the Supreme Court in Bhadresh Bipinbhal Sheth v. State of Gujarat for guiding principles in family-dispute bail and emphasizes that the investigation need not be hindered. The order cautions that the observations are for the bail application only and not merits, citing Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) for such caution, and imposes standard bail conditions including surrender, bond, cooperation, and passport surrender.

High Court of Kerala
RSA No. 750 of 2022

Thankam @ Parvathy v. K.P.SANKARANKUTTY GUPTHAN and Others

This Regular Second Appeal arises from a partition suit filed by Ammalukutti Amma for partition of 15 items of property, challenged up to the Kerala High Court. The Sub Court, Ottappalam, and later the Additional District Judge held that Items 1–14 were already settled by compromise decrees in two earlier suits (O.S. Nos. 13/1988 and 16/1988), leaving only Item 15 as partitionable. The appellant, Thankam @ Parvathy, contends that she is misnamed in the earlier suits (listed as Parvathy in those records) and that the compromise decrees were not validly binding on her due to lack of her signature; hence, Exts. B22 and B31 should not bind her. The case traverses the proper remedy for challenging compromise decrees under the CPC—Order XXIII, Rule 3;Order XLIII, Rule 1A; and related sections—framing the question of whether a second appeal is maintainable when compromises are involved. The court cites Ashiya Ummal v. S.N. Sathy and other authorities (Banwari Lal’s case, H.S. Goutham, Rajanna, Nazir Mohamed, Government of Kerala v. Joseph, Santosh Hazari, Kondiba Kadam) to delineate the evolving law on challenging compromises and the requirement of substantial questions of law for a Section 100 appeal. Ultimately, the court finds no substantial question of law, dismisses the appeal (without admitting it), and dismisses all pending interlocutory applications, directing transmission of the order to the trial and appellate courts.

High Court of Kerala
5036/2024

Umesh v. State of Kerala

Umesh, aged 35, petitioner, sought pre-arrest bail under Section 438 CrPC in connection with Crime No. 285/2024 of Valiyamala Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, alleging offences under Sections 294(b), 447, 324 and 308 IPC. The prosecution claims that on 15 April 2024, around 22:30 hours, the petitioner trespassed into the de facto complainant’s house, attacked him with a chopper and attempted to murder him, causing grievous injuries; the FIR was registered the next day. The petitioner contends he is innocent, that there is no material to substantiate the 308 IPC charge, and that arrest is unnecessary; he asserts the investigator has already recovered the weapon. The police opposition argues there are incriminating materials, and that the petitioner’s custodial interrogation is necessary to effect recovery; the session court had already dismissed a similar application finding custodial interrogation necessary. The court notes the treatment records of the injured show serious injuries and acknowledges the prosecution contention of incriminating material; however, it stresses that anticipatory bail under Section 438 CrPC is an extraordinary remedy to be granted only in exceptional circumstances, citing Supreme Court judgments including Srikant Upadhyay v. State of Bihar and Jai Prakash Singh v. State of Bihar and HDFC Bank Ltd. v. J.J. Mannan. After careful consideration of facts and the gravity of the accusation, the court rejects the application, holding that the petitioner has not established a case for pre-arrest bail. The bail petition is therefore dismissed by C.S. Dias, J.

High Court of Kerala
CRL. M.C. NO.8165 OF 2023

CRL.M.C. No. 8165 of 2023 (Petitioners/Accused Nos.1 to 10 v. State of Kerala and Others)

This Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous case arises under Section 482 CrPC to quash proceedings in CC No.178/2019 arising from Crime No.47/2019 at Anchalummoodu Police Station, Kollam. Accused Nos.1 to 10 were charged under Sections 341, 294(B), 323, 324, 325 read with Section 34 IPC for allegedly confining the victims and assaulting them with abusive language. The petitioners submitted that the dispute is private and has been settled; affidavits from the victims support the settlement and express no objection to quashing. The Public Prosecutor, while acknowledging the settlement, expressed reservations about quashing merely on the basis of compromise. The Court examined the matter in light of the Supreme Court’s framework—Laxmi Narayan v. State of Madhya Pradesh (and others), and the related Gian Singh and Narinder Singh line of authorities—holding that the power under S.482 CrPC to quash may be exercised in non-compoundable offences where the dispute is private and settled, with certain caveats (no involvement of heinous or public-interest offences). After analysis, the court found the dispute private in nature and accepted the settlement, quashing all proceedings against the petitioners. The decision emphasizes the private nature of the dispute, the victims’ assent, and the balance with public interest.

High Court of Kerala
MACA 4653/2019; MACA 199/2023

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. GOPINATHAN K.K. and others

This Kerala High Court decision, heard by a single judge, arises from two Motor Accidents Claims Appeals challenging a Pathanamthitta tribunal award in OP(MV) 1663/2017. The deceased, aged 94, was a timber broker-real estate businessman who died after a road accident. The Tribunal had awarded Rs. 5,35,260 in compensation to the claimants (the deceased’s children) under the head of dependency; the insurer challenged the award as excessive, while the claimants sought enhancement. The core issues were (i) the notional income to be attributed to an elderly decedent with unclear earnings, (ii) whether the claimants were entitled to compensation for Loss of Parental Consortium (referred to as Loss of Love and Affection in the award), given the claimants’ and decedent’s ages, and (iii) whether any amount under Pain and Suffering was warranted. The court adopts the Ramachandrappa standard to determine notional income, concluding Rs. 11,000 per month (with no future prospects) for a 94-year-old, and upholds a 50% deduction for personal expenses. It reviews the Loss of Consortium issue, determining that compensation for such loss can be payable to the claimants despite age, and while the tribunal’s Pain and Suffering award is scrutinized, the court ultimately deletes it. The appeals are disposed with a revised Loss of Dependency, recharacterized Loss of Consortium payments, and an enhanced overall package payable with interest at 9%.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.R.P No. 39 of 2016

P. I. Moideen Kutty S/o Ali Kutty Haji vs Abdul Rasheed V and State of Kerala

This is a Kerala High Court Criminal Revision Petition filed under Sections 397 and 401 Cr.P.C. by P.I. Moideen Kutty, challenging the concurrent conviction and sentence for an offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (N.I. Act). The accused was convicted by the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Malappuram, and affirmed by the Special Court for SC/ST (POA) Act Cases, Manjeri. The cheque for Rs. 5,00,000 issued by the accused in favour of the complainant was dishonoured for want of funds. The central issue is whether the prosecution under Section 138 could proceed without arraigning the firm “Thennala Enterprise,” a partnership firm that issued the cheque, since Section 141 provides for vicarious liability when a company commits an offence. The petitioner contends that the firm and the persons in charge must be arraigned and that non-arraignment vitiates the prosecution; he relies on Babu v. State of Kerala and Aneeta Hada and Others v. Godfather Travels and Tours Pvt. Ltd., among others, to assert that arraigning the firm is imperative. The court analyzes Sections 141, 138, and 313 Cr.P.C., and examines case law including the cited authorities. Ultimately, the High Court finds the entire prosecution vitiated due to non-arraignment of the firm and acquits the petitioner, with concurrent verdicts set aside. The revision petition is allowed; the accused is acquitted and set at liberty, with bail, if any, cancelled.

High Court of Kerala
OP(C) No.2507 of 2021

Asha A. v. Manjusha Santosh and others

The petitioner, Asha A., challenged the election of Manjusha Santosh as the councillor for Kollam Municipal Corporation in the Alattukavu Division, alleging a margin of four votes in her favour. The election petition (OP/Election) 3/2021 was challenged at the threshold in OP(C) 2507/2021 on two grounds: (i) lack of verification under Section 167(1)(c) of the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994, and (ii) absence of an affidavit as mandated in the proviso to Section 167(1)(c). The Additional Munsiff’s Court, Kollam, had held the petition properly verified and the accompanying Rule 62 affidavit as substantial compliance, dismissing the petition. On appeal, the High Court scrutinized whether verification must be in the CPC fashion and whether an affidavit under CPC Order VI Rule 15(4) is mandatory. It held that Section 167(1)(c) requires signature and verification but does not mandate a separate CPC-style affidavit; and that the petition’s schedule can be considered part of the petition and verified accordingly. Citing M.T. Lissy, Geetha Shetty, G.M. Siddeshwar, and other authorities, the court reiterated that election petitions are not plaints and defects in verification or affidavits are curable and to be resolved during trial. The court found no grounds to dismiss at threshold under sections 165, 166, or 191, and concluded the petition lacks merit, ultimately dismissing it on merits. The petition is dismissed.

High Court of Kerala
MACA NO. 1095 OF 2012

Ajikumar v. Geetha Devi and Bajaj Allianz Insurance Co. Ltd.

Ajikumar, the appellant, challenged the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Kollam award in O.P.(M.V.) No.1675/2007 arising from a motor vehicle accident on 08 December 2006 involving a Maruti car KL 2 V 699. The Tribunal held the insurer liable and directed the insurer to pay Rs.1,16,000 with 7.5% interest and costs, while permitting recovery against the vehicle owner due to the driver lacking a valid driving license. The appellant sought enhancement of compensation, arguing for higher income and damages. The insurer contended that the pleaded income of Rs.2,500 per month should govern and raised objections to higher figures. On appeal, the Kerala High Court allowed the appeal, relying on Supreme Court authorities Ramachandrappa v. Manager (2011) 13 SCC 236, Syed Sadiq v. Divisional Manager (2014) 2 SCC 735, and Minu Rout v. Satya Pradyumna Mohapatra (2013) 10 SCC 695 to fix the monthly income at Rs.5,500 for an ordinary worker in 2006. The court held 10% permanent disability, recalculated disability, loss of earnings, and loss of amenities, and awarded an additional Rs.1,15,500. The appeal is allowed; the enhanced amount must be deposited within three months, and the court clarifies that the recovery right against the owner is set aside, with 182 days’ delay excluded from interest.

High Court of Kerala
CO 52 of 2023 (also MACA 2569 of 2016)

ABOOBACKER v. NATIONAL INSURANCE CO. LTD. (CO No. 52 of 2023; MACA No. 2569 of 2016)

This judgment from the Kerala High Court (Deván Ramachandran, J.) addresses appeals arising from the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Kozhikode, in OP(MV) No.1607/2014, involving a scooter accident on 26.07.2014. The Cross Objector, ABOOBACKER, seeks enhanced compensation after the Tribunal awarded Rs. 10,47,120 on a finding of negligence against the offending car. The National Insurance Company Ltd. contends the Tribunal’s quantum is excessive. The core dispute concerns the quantum of compensation, especially the notional income, future prospects, and heads of damages for pain and suffering, loss of income due to disability, loss of earnings, and future treatment. The Court upholds negligence findings but scrutinizes the quantum. Relying on Ramachandrappa, it fixes notional income at Rs.10,000 per month (despite the Cross Objector’s FIR statements suggesting higher income, the evidence does not substantiate a higher avocation). It adopts a robust view on income with a presumption the cross objector had a better avocation (Rajani). Disability is kept at 25%, future prospects are fixed at 25% (not 50%), and future treatment is deleted. Pain and suffering is enhanced to Rs.40,000, while other heads adjust to yield a modified compensation payable with interest at 8.5%. The order ultimately allows the appeal and cross objection in part, directing enhanced compensation with costs.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.REV.PET NO. 164 OF 2016

Abdul Saleem v. State of Kerala

This is a criminal revision petition filed by Abdul Saleem, the sole accused in C.C.No.1380/2006 (Judicial First Class Magistrate Court, Chavakkad), challenging judgments rendered in the trial and appellate courts. The prosecution alleged that on 3.6.2006, the accused drove a car in a rash and negligent manner, endangering life, which struck Vinod as he pedaled a bicycle, resulting in his death. The Magistrate convicted the petitioner under sections 279 and 304A IPC and sentenced him to three months and one year respectively. The Sessions Court affirmed these convictions and sentences. In the Kerala High Court revision petition, the counsel for Abdul Saleem urged that contradictions exist in the occurrence witnesses’ evidence, and there is no convincing basis to hold rash and negligent driving; he stressed that high speed by itself does not prove negligence and that the prosecution must establish rashness with the totality of circumstances. The Public Prosecutor contended that the scope of revision under section 401 Cr.P.C. is not wide enough to re-appreciate evidence. The court reviewed the evidence, including PW1 and PW3’s testimonies, the scene mahazar, postmortem findings, and lighting conditions, applying principles from State of Karnataka v. Satish and other precedents to determine whether rashness and negligence were established. Ultimately, the High Court allowed the revision petition in part: conviction was sustained, but the sentence was reduced to 1 month for 279 IPC and 6 months for 304A IPC, to run concurrently, with surrender within two weeks and cancellation of bail.

High Court of Kerala
BAIL APPL. NO. 5626 OF 2024

Muneer v. State of Kerala

The petitioner, Muneer, challenges a pending crime registered at Kuthuparamba Police Station (Crime No. 475/2024) for offences punishable under sections 498A, 323, 324 and 294(b) IPC. The matter before the Kerala High Court is an application for pre-arrest bail under Section 482 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). The relationship between the parties began with their marriage in 2006 and produced four children; the prosecution alleges sustained mental and physical harassment culminating in an assault on the complainant on 26 May 2024, causing simple hurt. The petitioner asserts his innocence, contends that the complaint is frivolous, and emphasizes that the marital discord has endured for years, yet he is the family’s sole breadwinner and custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The Public Prosecutor opposes bail, citing four other crimes at the same police station and warning that release could lead to intimidation or tampering with witnesses. The court notes the 18-year marriage, the lack of allegations for nearly two decades, and that the conduct would be best tested at trial. Relying on Bhadres Bipinbhai Sheth v. State of Gujarat (2015 KHC 4579) and Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and another (2020 (1) KHC 663), the court finds valid grounds to exercise its inherent BNSS power and grants pre-arrest bail with conditions, including surrender and bond requirements, cooperation, and non-interference with witnesses.

High Court of Kerala
FAO No.351 of 2010

Jayakumar v. State Bank of Travancore & Aby C Kuruvilla

This appeal by the 6th judgment debtor in EP No.332 of 1999 in OS No.1048 of 1992 before the Additional Sub Court, Kottayam, challenges an auction sale of 26.5 cents of land (survey No.284/21) at Aymanam, conducted on 06.01.2007 under the decree in favour of the State Bank of Travancore for Rs.6,06,003.39 plus interest. The sale was to the decree holder as purchaser for Rs.6,00,000, and the 6th judgment debtor moved EA 79/2007 under Order XXI Rule 90 CPC to set aside the sale, alleging irregularities in publishing and conducting the sale, including a lack of essential details in the proclamation (time and place), and an undervaluation, with a private valuer’s certificate used to fix the upset price. The executing court dismissed the application after a contested hearing, finding no bonafides and upholding the sale as conducted in accordance with Rules. On appeal, the Kerala High Court held that the sale was vitiated by illegality in the proclamation and sale process: the court failed to ensure that only a portion meeting the decree was sold, relied on ipse dixit of the decree holder, and did not conduct independent enquiry. The court cited Desh Bandhu Gupta, Janak Raj, Chinnammal, Ambati Narasayya and Kayjay to emphasize that improper publication and lack of jurisdiction can render a sale illegal. The appeal is allowed, the order in EA 79/2007 is set aside, EP restored, and sale proceeds to be refunded with interest, with further directions for compliance and remand.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) No. 27197 of 2022

MAVIS DAVIS vs THRISSUR MUNICIPAL CORPORATION; BHARAT PETROLEUM CORPORATION LTD. & ORS

Petitioner Mavis Davis challenges the Thrissur Municipal Corporation's refusal to issue a Trade Licence to operate a Fuel Station at Ollur, Thrissur District. The land in question already hosted a functioning Retail Petroleum Outlet, formerly run by a franchisee Mr. Kuttappan K.I., who held a Trade Licence from the Corporation. Subsequently, Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. (BPCL) entered into a franchise arrangement with a Partnership Firm of which the petitioner is the Managing Partner and a co-owner of the land. When the petitioner's firm applied for a D&O Licence, the Corporation demanded consent of all co-owners of the property. The petitioner contends that a co-owner must be treated as the owner of the property for all practical purposes until partition, and thus consent from every co-owner is not necessary. Respondents 1 and 2 argued that because multiple persons own the land, obtaining consent from all co-owners is essential to avoid future civil litigation if disputes arise. BPCL officers urged that the partnership is not a co-owner, so consent from all co-owners should not be made mandatory. Counsel for the petitioner maintained that insisting on every co-owner’s consent would unjustly stall the dealership arrangement already agreed with BPCL. The court recalls a prior decision in Jayaprakash v. Kozhikode Corporation, stating co-owners share ownership of all parts of the property until partition. It distinguishes Jayaprakash on the facts since a partnership firm is involved rather than a single co-owner. The court ultimately disposes the petition by directing the Corporation to consider the trade licence application without insisting on consent from all co-owners, balancing property rights with practical business needs.

High Court of Kerala
WP(C) NO. 8721 OF 2022

V.K. Vasudevan Namboodiri v. Assistant Educational Officer, Talipparamba North and others

V.K. Vasudevan Namboodiri, the manager of Poomangalam AUP School, challenges Ext. P2 notice for approval of appointment of a Manager and seeks that the hearing be conducted by any AEO other than the AEO, Thaliparamba North, with a direction to the 3rd respondent to conduct the hearing. He states that since 2015 he served as the approved Manager and his term ended in 2021; after applying for approval, the AEO issued an order appointing the 4th respondent. This Court quashed the impugned order in Ext. P1 (31.01.2022) for lack of hearing and directed a fresh hearing with opportunity to be heard and to pass fresh orders. On remand, the petitioner alleges bias by the 1st respondent, pointing out that rival claimants were summoned on two different dates and that certain documents submitted by the 4th respondent were not furnished to him; he contends he was not allowed to file objections, cross-examine, or produce materials. The respondents contend that the petitioner has not established membership in the Malanad Education and Charitable Trust; a supplementary Trust Deed (Ext. R4(3)) was allegedly created without approval. The Government Pleader urges fresh notice with exchange of documents; the court ultimately holds bias claims require substantial material, disposes by directing both sides to appear before the 1st respondent on 18.08.2022, with documents exchanged, and directs a reasoned order within a short timeframe.

High Court of Kerala
CRL.A.No.963 of 2018

Ravi Prasad Kochuvila Veedu v. Chithra P. Nair and State (CRL.A. No. 963 of 2018)

This is a criminal appeal under Section 378(4) Cr.P.C. arising from an acquittal of the first respondent for an offence punishable under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. The complainant, Ravi Prasad Kochuvila Veedu, alleged that two cheques drawn on State Bank of India were issued to discharge a debt but were dishonoured on presentation for want of funds. The trial court acquitted the accused after evaluating the evidence. The High Court re-examines the matter, noting the complainant’s evidence (PW1-PW3) and documentary Exts. P1-P12, the notice of dishonour, and the defence evidence (DW1-DW4). It considers whether the initial burden was discharged and whether the presumptions in Sections 118 and 139 NI Act apply, including the possibility of rebutting them by the accused. Relying on Rangappa v. Sri Mohan and later Supreme Court decisions (Bir Singh, Kalamani Tex, Oriental Bank of Commerce), the court held that the complainant did discharge the initial burden and that the presumption operates as a reverse onus to be rebutted by the accused by preponderance of probabilities. Consequently, the appeal is allowed, the acquittal set aside, and the accused convicted under Section 138 NI Act with sentence, compensation, and surrender directions.

High Court of Kerala
Crl.M.C.No.2178 of 2022

M.T.P. Ashraf and others v. State of Kerala and Others

This petition under section 482 Cr.P.C. challenges the continuance of criminal proceedings arising from Payyanur Police Station Crime No.1109/2020, now CC 307/2021 before the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Payyanur. The seven petitioners are accused in a dispute between rival factions, alleged to have restrained respondents and attacked them with deadly weapons, with resulting property damage to motorcycles amounting to Rs. 71,500. The FIR (Annexure-A1) and the final report (Annexure-A2) are before the Court, and Annexures A3–A8 comprise affidavits by respondents 2–7 acknowledging the settlement and seeking quashing. The Station House Officer has verified the settlement as genuine, and the State Public Prosecutor along with counsel for respondents 2–7 confirm the private nature of the dispute and the genuineness of the settlement. Relying on Gian Singh v. State of Punjab and Another (2012) 10 SCC 303, the petition argues that the inherent powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C. permit quashing where continued prosecution would serve no fruitful purpose in a private dispute. The High Court, after considering the affidavits and verified settlement, holds that the dispute is private, there is no public interest to be served, and accordingly allows the Crl.M.C. and quashes the final report and all further proceedings in CC 307/2021 against the petitioners.