St. Mary’s Orthodox Syrian Church Mangalam Dam Post, a constituent church of the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Church, sought police protection and directions from the Kerala High Court to ensure that its 1934 Constitution-appointed clergy could conduct services in the church, cemetery, and kurishadies without obstruction by the Jacobite faction and its supporters. The petitioners alleged that since 1995 they have faced entry bans and hindrances from respondents 10–13, despite a framework of binding orders clarifying who could perform duties under the 1934 Constitution. A civil suit under Section 92 CPC had been filed and later revoking leave ordered; Ext.P7 (Common Supreme Court order in KS Varghese v. St. Peter's & Paul's) held that decrees affecting all constituent churches must be enforced and that police protection could be ordered to ensure compliance. The petition contends that the authorities have failed to execute the Apex Court's directions; respondents counter that the writ is misconceived, there is no breach of peace, and police cannot resolve civil disputes or enforce civil judgments; there is doubt about the church’s status. The High Court held that the Apex Court’s binding directions apply to all constituent Malankara churches, and that police must ensure compliance. The petition is allowed with directions to take steps within one month to grant adequate protection to the petitioners so they may enter the church and perform services unhindered.
CRL.M.C Nos. 5336 of 2021 & 3767 of 2023 This Kerala High Court Criminal Miscellaneous Case involves two petitions under Section 482 CrPC seeking quashing of criminal proceedings arising from Tirurangadi Police Station Crime No. 688/2020. Petitioners, accused Nos. 1-4, challenged the ongoing process under sections 143, 147, 148 and 506(ii) r/w 34 IPC, arguing for termination of proceedings in the wake of an amicable settlement with the de facto complainant. The State, represented by the Public Prosecutor, initially voiced reservations but acknowledged no material transgressions against the petitioners beyond the settled disputes. The court directed an inquiry via the investigating officer to verify the genuineness of the settlement and assess any impediments to quashing. The judge then canvassed a line of Supreme Court precedents—State of M.P. v. Laxmi Narayan; Gian Singh; Narinder Singh; State of Rajasthan v. Shambhu Kewat; State of M.P. v. Deepak; State of M.P. v. Manish; J. Ramesh Kamath; State of M.P. v. Rajveer Singh; Parbatbhai Aahir; State of M.P. v. Kalyan Singh; and State of M.P. v. Dhruv Gurjar—summarising the law on exercise of inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC to quash non-compoundable offences where disputes are resolved. The court concluded that the circumstances render quashing appropriate, emphasizing the civil character of the dispute and the ends of justice. Consequently, the petitions were allowed and FIR 688/2020 and CC 82/2021 were quashed, bringing peaceful closure for the parties.
CRL.REV.PET NO. 3498 OF 2005 This is a Kerala High Court criminal revision petition filed by the accused, Gopalan C. S/o Keeran, challenging his conviction under section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (NI Act) in C.C. No. 23 of 2004 of the Special Judicial First Class Magistrate Court (Marad Cases), Kozhikode, and the subsequent conviction-affirming, sentence-modifying order of the Additional Sessions Judge, Kozhikode. The trial court held him guilty for issuing a dishonoured cheque for Rs. 95,000 to the complainant, who alleged non-payment of a loan advanced in April 2001. The Sessions Court upheld the conviction but reduced the sentence to imprisonment till rising of the court and imposed Rs. 95,000 as compensation with a default sentence. The revision petition contends that the alleged debt was only Rs. 25,000 and that the cheque(s) were given as security; repayment, if any, was not properly proven, and the cheque(s) were misused to lodge a false case. The High Court examines legal principles on security cheques and the presumption under sections 118 and 139 NI Act, citing Bir Singh v. Mukesh Kumar and Sripati Singh v. State of Jharkhand, reaffirmed by Dashrathbhai Patel v. Hitesh Patel. The court finds no reason to interfere with the conviction and sentence, dismisses the revision, and clarifies that the imprisonment will abate on death, while the Rs. 95,000 compensation must be recovered from the revisionist’s assets through his legal representatives. The records are to be transmitted to execute the compensation.
Shijas Shaji v. State of Kerala challenges Ext.P1, an externment order under Section 15(1)(a) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007, restraining him from entering Kottayam Revenue District for one year. The petitioner contends the basis for externment—punctual record of the last prejudicial activity in Thrissur (Crime No. 955/2022, 13 May 2022)—cannot justify restricting entry into another district, especially since the most proximate local act in Kottayam occurred on 14 November 2021. Citing the nine-month gap between that act and the order, the petitioner argues there is no live link and no adequate application of mind, rendering the order arbitrary and vitiated. The State counters that externment can be grounded on out-of-district activities where exigent circumstances demand action and that the live link is preserved by recent offences. The court accepts that there is no rigid rule preventing cross-district externment but emphasizes that externment is an extraordinary power requiring direct application of mind and explicit justification for the duration. It relies on Deepak v. State of Maharashtra to insist that an order must disclose subjective satisfaction, and that the maximum one-year period be reasoned. On the facts, the court finds the Ext.P1 order defective for lack of explained live-link and reasons, and accordingly quashes the order, allowing the petition.
WP(C) Nos. 2696 of 2023 and 2705 of 2023 These two writ petitions challenge Ext.P2, a communication issued by the 2nd respondent, rejecting the petitioners’ applications for building permits on the ground that land development permit under Rule 31 of the Panchayat Building Rules, 2019 is not obtained. The petitioners bought modest plots in Nalleppilly Village, Palakkad District, for the purpose of constructing houses. They argue that the land is dry, not yet subjected to large‑scale development, and that subdivision and development were not carried out as envisaged under the Building Rules; hence there is no obligation to secure a separate land development permit for a small plot and a single dwelling. They rely on precedents including Nafeesa v. Chavakkad Municipality & Anr. (2018 KHC (3) 473) and Panjal Grama Panchayat v. Aneesh P (2022 (2) KLT 653) to contend that building permits can be considered without a land development permit for such circumstances. The respondents contend that the developer divided plots without development permission and Ext.R1(d) notice has been issued. After hearing, the court held that since the petitioners purchased only small plots for construction and no development as defined has occurred, the Panchayat cannot refuse to consider the building permit applications. Ext.P2 is set aside and directions are issued to consider the building permit applications under the Kerala Panchayat Building Rules, without insisting on a land development permit, and to pass orders within three weeks, with the right to proceed against the developer left open.
BA No. 10499/22 & 2408/2023 These bail petitions arise from Crime No. 1989/2021 of Palakkad Town South Police Station, concerning the murder of Sanjith, an RSS worker, alleged to be part of a broader political feud between RSS and the Popular Front of India (PFI). Bail Applications 10499/2022 (accused nos. 6 and 7) and 2408/2023 (accused no. 11) are heard together. The prosecution contends a premeditated, well-planned conspiracy in which the accused, connected to the PFI/SDPI, participated with active roles in the militant campaign that culminated in Sanjith’s death on 15.11.2021. The investigation cites seven conspiracies in different dates, with supporting materials including case diary entries, call data records, tower location data, and CW statements; a police confession by the 6th accused is noted but inadmissible under Section 25 of the Indian Evidence Act. The court undertakes a petitioner-wise examination, emphasizing the seriousness of the offences, the organized nature of the crime, the risk of further violence on release, and the potential societal impact of allowing bail. Though circumstantial evidence links the petitioners to the conspiracy and murder, the court concludes that bail cannot be granted at this stage. Accordingly, both bail applications are dismissed, underscoring the need to prevent further political violence and maintain public order.
This is a Kerala High Court criminal miscellaneous petition (CRL.MC No. 8195 of 2017) filed by Union of India, Income Tax Department, challenging a common order of the Judicial First Class Magistrate Court-II, Mananthavady, dated 9 October 2017, in Crl.M.P. Nos. 384/2017 and 704/2017. The factual matrix arises from a cash seizure of Rs. 50 lakhs at the Tholpetty check post on 12 March 2017 during vehicle inspection. The money was deposited with the trial court and subsequently IT authorities issued a notice under Section 132A(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act to explain the source of the funds. The IT Department sought possession and release of the assets under Section 451 Cr.P.C., arguing that the assets were held in custody by the court pending investigation and that the Department, under Sections 132-A, 132-B and 153A of the IT Act, has a statutory framework to pursue tax liabilities. The Magistrate’s order partially allowed the 2nd respondent’s claim (Abdul Razak P.) and retained 30% for IT Department, releasing 70% to the 2nd respondent on a bank guarantee. The High Court held that the balance of convenience and the statutory framework favor the IT Department, set aside the Magistrate’s order, and directed release of the funds to IT Department for completing proceedings under 132-B, 153A or other IT Act provisions, with a six-month bond condition and a fallback deposit if not completed.
The petitioners, two private limited companies, approached Kerala High Court under Article 226 seeking protection from obstruction alleged to be caused by the 3rd respondent and his associates while constructing a boundary wall on private property in Kollam East Village. The 2nd petitioner had acquired land spanning 33.88 ares for a textile/hypermarket showroom, with all permits in place. An existing boundary wall along the northern edge was proposed to be replaced by a taller wall; however, individuals presenting themselves as Sankar Nagar Residents obstructed the work, claiming ownership over the disputed strip. The police reportedly intervened and cleared obstructions, enabling the work to proceed until the 3rd respondent, claiming to be president of the Sankar Nagar Residents Association, filed O.S. No. 13 of 2024 seeking an injunction in the Principal Munsiff Court. The Munsiff granted an interim injunction restraining the petitioners’ persons from proceeding with the wall. The petition contends misrepresentation by the 3rd respondent and seeks mandamus directing Respondents 1 and 2 to provide adequate protection to life and property during construction. The High Court notes that the interim civil order governs the matter and that police protection cannot be ordered in civil disputes where civil courts already have jurisdiction. It relies on established authorities that police protection is not a remedy to adjudicate civil rights and should not substitute for civil litigation. The petition is dismissed as the writ petition cannot override the civil process or bind police to act contrary to a court order.
O.T.Rev.No.87/2018 & O.T.Rev.No.93/2018 This Kerala High Court judgment consolidates two tax-revision petitions filed by Sri Jose Thomas, a property developer who opted for compounded tax under Section 8 of the Kerala Value Added Tax Act (KVAT). The petitions challenged the Kerala Value Added Tax Appellate Tribunal’s orders upholding differential VAT demands for the assessment years 2008-09 and 2010-11. Central issues include: whether the “whole contract amount” for composite works should include amounts paid to subcontractors, service tax, one-time building tax, and maintenance/sinking funds, and whether deductions claimed under Form 20H were properly allowed. The petitioner argued that amounts paid as pure agent on behalf of customers, such as service and building taxes, should not form part of the contract receipts liable to KVAT, and that deductions should reflect Form 20H details year-specific. He invoked Larsen & Toubro Ltd. v. State of Karnataka to argue that only the value added after entering into the contract should be taxed, and that the “whole contract amount” must be interpreted in line with the scheme of the KVAT Act. The State contended that the whole contract amount encompasses all receipts connected with the contract. The court, after analysis, held that pure-agent amounts cannot be included in “whole contract amount” and remanded matters for factual verification regarding deductions and tax credits. It, however, answered the primary issue against the assessee, holding that the entire contract value can be taxed under the compounded rate framework, and not merely the post-agreement value. The petitions were disposed in part: Q1 in favour of Revenue; other issues remanded; some questions not pressed.
MACA 514/2011 & connected cases (MACA 542/2011, MACA 1539/2011, MACA 1543/2011) These consolidated Motor Accidents Claims Appeals arise from four original petitions (OP/MV 1335/2003, 1338/2003, 1333/2003, 1342/2003) before the MACT, Ernakulam, concerning a fatal accident on 5.4.2003 involving a Maruti van in which Martin died and his family members and other passengers claimed compensation. The MACT awarded a composite sum across petitions; the appellants challenged heads including loss of dependency, funeral and transportation expenses, loss of estate, and loss of love and affection, arguing for higher income and the application of Pranay Sethi principles (40% future prospects, multiplier 15) with 3/4 deduction for personal expenses, age of the deceased at 39, and a salary of Rs.7,173 per month. The insurer argued the Ext. A7 salary certificate was not definitively proven and that Rs.6,000 per month was appropriate; it emphasized policy conditions and vehicle capacity violations (exceeding the permitted 4 passengers) affecting liability. The Kerala High Court, applying Pranay Sethi, Ramachandrappa, and related precedents, enhanced the awards across the MACAs: loss of dependency, funeral, transport, loss of estate, and especially loss of consortium; it rejected loss of love and affection in one head; it ordered 7.5% interest on enhanced amounts and left other Tribunal findings intact, with insurer liable to pay and recover from the insured where appropriate. The court issued a unified order for all four MACAs, confirming the Tribunal’s core findings while granting substantial enhancements.
Mithra Chandran seeks relief under Article 227 of the Constitution of India against Ext. P10, an order of the Family Court, Pathanamthitta in I.A. No. 21 of 2022 in O.P. (G&W) No. 38 of 2020, which handed custody of two minor daughters to the respondent. The Family Court's Ext. P10 was issued to enforce the order in Ext. P4 (19.07.2022) declaring the respondent guardian and altering custody. The petitioner contends Ext. P10 is illegal since it enforces an ex parte judgment and violates Ext. P4; she argues she was not promptly heard in O.P. (G&W) No. 38 of 2020. The respondent maintains that Ext. P4 remains in force and that the review petition is pending; Ext. P10 was issued to implement Ext. P4’s directions due to non-compliance. The High Court, applying Article 227 with caution, relies on established jurisprudence (Shalini Shyam Shetty, Jai Singh, K.V.S. Ram, Sobhana Nair, Yashita Sahu) to hold there is no patent illegality in Ext. P10 and no reason to interfere with custody pending final welfare considerations. Noting the welfare of the two girls (11 and 8) and the mother’s need to interact with them, the Court grants interim custody to the petitioner from 01.01.2023 to 02.01.2023, directing custody to be returned to the respondent thereafter. The petition is dismissed with these directions and the Court reiterates the primacy of the child’s welfare in such disputes.
This Criminal Miscellaneous Case under Section 482 CrPC concerns quashing of S.C. No. 2214/2022 pending in the Addl. District & Sessions Court‑IV, Kollam, arising from Pallithottam Police Station Crime No. 192/2022. Petitioners Nos. 1–4 are Maxwell @ Tinu, Alocious Ramesh, DiJu and Midhun Leons, accused of offences under IPC Sections 341, 323, 324, 452 and 307 read with Section 34. The Respondents include the State (Public Prosecutor), Pallithottam Sub‑Inspector, and Mercilin Muthaya, the de facto complainant. The petition argues that the disputes have been amicably settled (as supported by Annexure 2 filed by the 3rd Respondent) and that continuing the criminal proceedings would distort public peace and obstruct the parties’ future lives. The Court had earlier directed the Investigating Officer to verify the settlement’s genuineness and to report on any antecedents. The Public Prosecutor reserved his position, cautioning against quashing purely on the basis of settlement, given the serious nature of Section 307 IPC and the possibility of broader societal harm. The High Court relies on precedents (Laxmi Narayan; Gian Singh; Narinder Singh, among others) to hold that Section 482 can quash non‑compoundable offences in private disputes where the settlement is genuine, while not disturbing cases involving heinous offences. On the facts—minor injuries, settled relationship, lack of antecedents—the Court quashes the proceedings, noting it would serve ends of justice and public peace. The petition is allowed; the Final Report and further proceedings are quashed.
Crl. Appeal No. 446 of 2018 This criminal appeal by Krishnan Kutty challenges the conviction for rape of his minor daughter, basing it on two episodes: September 2011 and December 2013, alleged during vacations when the children were with him. The Sessions Court convicted him under Section 376 IPC and Section 4 of the POCSO Act, sentencing life imprisonment under the latter with no separate IPC sentence. The Kerala High Court, while upholding guilt on the December 2013 episode, addresses a host of defense objections: whether charging two distinct episodes together violates Section 218 CrPC, given post-enactment of the POCSO Act; whether the victim PW1 can be deemed a sterling witness; and whether there was corroboration, medical evidence, or missing witnesses that would undermine credibility. The court relies on established propositions that a prosecutrix’s testimony can sustain a conviction in rape cases and adopts the sterling-witness framework from Rai Sandeep v. State (NCT of Delhi) to test truthfulness and consistency. It concludes that PW1, though a minor, spoke coherently and consistently, with corroboration from PW2, PW3, PW4, PW7 and the medical evidence (Exts. P9 and P11). The court rejects the defense’s claims of non-disclosure, inconsistencies, lack of medical corroboration, and the non-examination of relatives. Ultimately, the appeal is dismissed and the sentence affirmed, with no jeopardy to the ratio of the trial court’s findings.
This is a consolidated revision petition under Section 125 CrPC filed in the Kerala High Court, Ernakulam, challenging a Family Court order in MC Nos. 183/2018 and 183/2019. The petitioners, wife Dheera N.G. and her minor son Soorya Narayanan, represented by their mother, sought maintenance at Rs. 20,000 and Rs. 7,500 respectively from the respondent husband Simesh S. The Family Court awarded Rs. 4,000 per month to the wife and Rs. 2,000 to the child. The revision petitions contest the quantum and the respondent contests his liability. The essential facts describe the wife’s long-term illness — Acute Disseminated Encephalomyelitis (ADEM) resulting in paralysis and prolonged hospitalization, with substantial medical bills and ongoing treatment costs including medicines, physiotherapy, diapers, and everyday care. The husband contends he has insufficient means, noting his wages around Rs. 11,681 and additional overtime income, and points to family generosity during hospitalization. The petitioners argue maintenance is required under Section 125 to relieve destitution and to allow the wife and child to live with dignity, citing cases that interpret “means” broadly and emphasize earning capacity. The High Court, applying these principles, holds the respondent to be able-bodied with earned income, and, considering medical expenses and the child’s needs, increases maintenance to Rs. 8,000 for the wife and Rs. 4,000 for the child, with arrears payable within two months. RP71/2023 is dismissed.
This writ petition challenges Exhibit P8 order dated 10.11.2021 and Exhibit P9 No Objection Certificate (NOC) dated 10.11.2021 issued by the Additional District Magistrate, Kannur under Rule 144 of the Petroleum Rules, 2002, permitting the establishment of a retail petroleum outlet by M/s. Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited at a site within Kathirur Grama Panchayat. The petitioners—residents of Kathirur—allege potential safety hazards and non-compliance with the statutory framework, pointing to pending O.S. No. 408/2019 before the Munsiff’s Court, Thalassery and contending that the District Collector did not properly consider objections raised in P1 to P5. The Petroleum Company counters that all requisite statutory clearances have been obtained (Pollution Control Board, PESO, Fire and Rescue, etc.), that the outlet was commissioned on 15.03.2022, and that neighbours have no statutory right to object once approvals are secured, citing Rule 144 and the need for NOC from the district authority. The court reviews relevant authorities including Reliance Industries Ltd. v. Commissioner of Land Revenue, Muhamed C v. District Collector, C. Albert Morris v. K. Chandrasekaran, and Vijaya Oil Company v. Vijayawada Guntur Tenali Urban Development Authority, to hold that objections require a statutory right and that, on this record, there is no arbitrariness or illegality justifying interference. The petition is dismissed, affirming the legality of the NOC process and the accompanying conditions.
BAIL APPL. NO. 6097 OF 2024 This bail petition under Section 439 CrPC concerns PREMLAL K in Crime No. 96/2024 registered at the Changanassery Excise Range Office, Kottayam, for alleged possession of two litres of Indian Made Foreign Liquor intended for sale, an offence punishable under Section 55(i) of the Kerala Abkari Act. The Kerala High Court, in a single-judge module led by Justice C. S. Dias, heard the matter on 01 August 2024. The petitioner contends innocence and false implication, noting that he has no prior criminal antecedents and has remained in judicial custody since 15 July 2024. He argues that the investigation is largely complete and recovery has already been effected, making continued detention unnecessary. The State, represented by the Senior Public Prosecutor, opposes bail, arguing that the investigation remains in progress and that, if released, the petitioner may commit a similar offence. After careful consideration of the facts — including the short duration of custody, the small quantity involved, lack of antecedents, and the progress of investigation — the court concludes that further detention is unwarranted. The court thus grants bail on conditions: bond for Rs. 50,000 with two solvent sureties; appearance before the Investigating Officer every Saturday for two months or until the final report; a prohibition on inducing or tampering with witnesses; risk of non-commission of offences; surrender of passport if any; and a provision that breach may lead to cancellation of bail. The order also cites Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) and another to support the police’s permissible action while bail is in effect. The bail application is allowed.
The petitioner, Surabhi C.V., a lower grade Urdu teacher appointed on a part-time basis with full-time benefits at Karannoor AUP School, Eranhikkal, challenges Ext P17 issued by the District Educational Officer and the consequential Ext P18. She was initially appointed in 2015; for teachers appointed before 31.03.2019 the time to acquire KTET qualification was extended up to 31.05.2021. The schools reopened physically only from 01.11.2021. The petitioner cleared KTET on 03.09.2021 (Ext P11). Government Order Ext P21 dated 17.02.2023 extended the time to acquire KTET. Ext P17, dated 23.01.2023, and Ext P18, issued by the Headmistress based on Ext P17, were challenged as they purportedly denied the petitioner pay revision arrears and full-time benefits and hampered her resignation from one school to join another. The petitioner contends that her KTET qualification, the later government order extending eligibility (Ext P21), and the interim actions justify entitlement to the pay revision arrears and benefits, and the resignation should be accepted. The judgment ultimately quashes Exts P17 and P18, directs the 5th respondent to pass a consequential order in line with Ext P21 and to accept the petitioner’s resignation, and orders immediate disbursal of 2019 pay revision arrears and full-time benefits.”
This bail application BA.9589/2021 is filed by the fourth accused in Crime No.1654/2020 of Kodungallur Police Station, Thrissur, under sections 20(b)(ii)(c), 27(A), and 8(A) read with section 27(B) of the NDPS Act. The accused has been in custody since 12 June 2020. The prosecution alleges a conspiracy to procure ganja for illegal sale, with the first and second accused traveling to Andhra Pradesh in a vehicle to collect the contraband, which was later transferred to a different lorry and intercepted near Pulloott Bridge, resulting in the seizure of 75.625 kg of ganja, and a separate seizure of 2 kg from the petitioner at Irinjalakuda. The defense contends that the petitioner had no role in the commercial quantity seized and that he is falsely implicated; there is no direct link tying him to procurement or transportation, and the trial has already commenced with numerous witnesses. The court considers the standard under Section 37 of the NDPS Act, requiring “reasonable grounds” for believing the accused not guilty. Relying on Union of India v. Shiv Shanker Kesari (2007) 7 SCC 798 and Municipal Corpn of Greater Mumbai v. Kamla Mills Ltd, the court notes that “reasonable grounds” must be substantial and probable, not mere prima facie evidence, and that the court is not to pronounce an acquittal. After evaluating the facts, the court finds material indicating the petitioner’s active involvement in collecting and transporting contraband and that releasing him on bail would disrupt the trial and reflect adversely on justice; thus bail is refused. The court also highlights the need for a speedy trial and acknowledges the petitioner’s antecedents. Consequently, the bail application is dismissed.
BAIL APPL. NO. 4307 OF 2024 This is a Kerala High Court bail application under Section 438 CrPC filed in respect of Crime No. 438/2024 registered at Pangode Police Station, Thiruvananthapuram, involving two petitioners as accused 2 and 3 and the State as respondent along with Ullas Chandran, who sought pre-arrest bail. The prosecution alleges that on 17.10.2023, in furtherance of their common intention, the accused restrained the defacto complainant; accused 1 struck the complainant with a metal block causing a fracture and injuries to the nose and forehead, accused 2 assaulted with a key causing grievous injuries, and accused 3 assisted in the commission of the offences under IPC sections 323, 324, 326 read with 34. The first petitioner/2nd accused is contended as infructuous since he has already been arrested, while the 2nd petitioner/3rd accused submitted that there is no specific overt act attributed to him and custodial interrogation is unnecessary. The State and the defacto complainant opposed bail, arguing ongoing investigation and likelihood of hampering it if released. After careful consideration of Annexure FIR and materials, the court found no specific overt act against the 2nd petitioner and held custodial interrogation unnecessary, thus allowing pre-arrest bail to the 2nd petitioner/3rd accused with conditions: surrender within 10 days, Rs.50,000 bond with two sureties, appearance as directed, no inducement or tampering, surrender of passport within a week, and prohibition from committing other offences; observed that these conditions comply with Supreme Court guidance (Sushila Aggarwal) but are restricted to the application, not merits.
The petitioner is the registered owner of a goods carriage vehicle KL-34-E-6547, financed by Hinduja Leyland Finance Ltd (5th respondent). The vehicle defaulted on monthly hire charges, and while seeking renewal of the goods carriage permit via the online portal, the respondents demanded a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the financier. The petitioner contends that renewal can be considered under Section 51(9) of the Motor Vehicles Act, and urges that the court apply principles from Shabu Sukumaran v. RTO, TVM and Ors. (2018 (2) KLT 219). The core issue is whether the registering authority can renew a permit despite a financier’s objection, provided the applicant furnishes the declaration under Section 51(8) and the authority affords an opportunity of hearing. Section 51 deals with special provisions regarding motor vehicles under hire-purchase agreements; Sub-sections (6)–(9) outline the obligation to obtain an NOC, the financier’s seven-day response window, and the authority’s discretion to renew or refuse after hearing. The petitioner seeks a writ of mandamus to permit renewal without the financier’s NOC. After considering the matter, the court holds that the registering authority possesses discretion to renew, notwithstanding financier objections, subject to due process. The petition is disposed of with directions to furnish the declaration under Section 51(8), with orders under Section 51(9)(a) to be issued within one month with notice to the financier.